--- a/research/corner-measurement.md 2026-09-15 15:08:36 +++ b/research/corner-measurement.md 2026-09-15 15:08:36 @@ -293,7 +293,17 @@ - **Cutoffs use floating-point powers of 2.** V, Z, D_1, E_1 are `Math.floor(Math.pow(2, j*alpha))`. At an alpha where 2^(j*alpha) lands within 1e-8 of an integer the floor could move by one. No j in the run - is near such a point, but the code does not check it. + is near such a point. *Checked since (job #1336), by recomputing every + cutoff as an exact integer root of a power of two: over j=20..300 the + float and exact right prime bands are identical at every j, so no + reported number is affected. The floor does move, but only where + 100 | j, and only on Tmax: there 93j/100 is an integer, E_1 = 2^(93j/100) + is an exact power of two, and the float division returns 2^(7j/100) + where the exact value is 2^(7j/100) - 1. The spurious extra integer is + a power of two, hence composite, so it can never add a prime to the + band. Z and E_1 themselves agree with their exact values for all + j <= 53; the first E_1 disagreement is at j=54, where E_1 passes 2^53 + and the double mantissa runs out. This limitation is now closed.* - **Nothing here is an input to any estimate.** No step of any argument in the corpus may cite a number from this note. @@ -304,12 +314,36 @@ - A run reaching x with at least a few primes in the *actual* band (Z, Z x^(2eta_0)] would make the actual-parameter rows a measurement of the corner rather than of a one-prime shadow. For eta_0=1/100 and - v=1/20 the band is (x^(1/20), x^(7/100)], whose prime count by the prime - number theorem is about x^(7/100)/(0.07 log x) - x^(1/20)/(0.05 log x): - roughly 4 primes at x=2^70 and roughly 17 at x=2^100. Neither is + v=1/20 the band is (x^(1/20), x^(7/100)]. The band endpoints are small + integers, so its contents are decidable exactly rather than estimated: + the band holds **5** primes at x=2^70, namely (11,29] = {13,17,19,23,29}, + and **20** at x=2^100, namely (32,127]. (An earlier version of this + note gave "roughly 4" and "roughly 17" from the prime number theorem + estimate x^(7/100)/(0.07 log x) - x^(1/20)/(0.05 log x), which evaluates + to 4.13 and 17.15; x/log x understates pi at arguments of size 29 and + 127. Corrected by exact integer recomputation, job #1336.) Neither is reachable by a sieve over (x/2,x], now or ever. The degeneracy is structural, not a compute budget problem, and it is the reason the actual corner cannot be measured directly at all. +- The exact form of that structural claim is a joint condition on eta_0 + and j (x=2^j), not a threshold in x alone. The band is (Z, Tmax] with + Tmax/Z ~ x^(2 eta_0) = 2^(2 eta_0 j), so by Bertrand's postulate the + band is non-empty as soon as **2 eta_0 j >= 1**. Checked exactly: for + eta_0 = 1/100, 1/40, 1/20, 1/8 the largest empty j is 33, 10, 6, 3, + every one strictly below the threshold 1/(2 eta_0) = 50, 20, 10, 4. Since + v is fixed by the decomposition, eta_0 is the only knob, and populating + the band at a reachable j costs eta_0 of order 1/j: at j=36, the largest + measured, >=2 primes needs eta_0 >= 1/71 and >=5 needs eta_0 >= 1/31. + The corner is the eta_0 -> 0 region, so a populated band and a genuine + corner are in direct opposition at every reachable scale. This prices + the obstruction; it is not a recipe for evading it. +- The population is **not monotonic in j**. Exactly: the band first holds + 1 prime at j=23 but is empty again at j=32,33; first holds 2 at j=41 but + falls back to 1 at j=47,48,49; first holds 3 at j=53 and 5 at j=65, and + only from k=5 does ">= k for all larger j" hold over the range checked. + Z = floor(2^(j/20)) steps over the band's smallest prime at j a multiple + of 20, before Tmax ~ 2^(0.07 j) has gained a new one. Any future claim + of the form "the band is populated from x=2^J on" must name its k. - A |K|/mass decay measurably faster than the matched control's, sustained over more than a factor of two in log x, would be the first finite evidence of arithmetic cancellation in this object. It would still be a