{ "object": "route 44's [CONJECTURAL] mechanism clause: is the deciding window at theta = G2(T_q) the fold's own record kill run?", "why_this_check": "route 44 names it itself as a minutes-long comparison against #159's part 4.3 'K spent' column; no return has run it; #159 published only SUM_L Q_L at that theta, never the per-L split", "theta": "G2(T_new), where N(theta) = 0 identically, so the transport is decided by the window term alone", "gates_reproduced_from_159": { "D_Tx": [ 1485, 22275, 378675, 7952175 ], "G2_Tx": [ 66, 108, 150, 204 ], "certificate_loose": [ 108, 150, 204, 270, 270, 240 ], "certificate_alt": [ 108, 150, 204, 258, 258, 240 ], "note": "every published figure touched was used as a gate, never recomputed for its own sake" }, "F1_deciding_index_per_L": [ { "fold": "13->17", "ladder_L_free_697": 2, "record_kill_run_r": 1, "deciding_L_loose": 2, "deciding_L_alt": 2, "sum_Q_loose": 20 }, { "fold": "17->19", "ladder_L_free_697": 2, "record_kill_run_r": 1, "deciding_L_loose": 2, "deciding_L_alt": 2, "sum_Q_loose": 16 }, { "fold": "19->23", "ladder_L_free_697": 3, "record_kill_run_r": 2, "deciding_L_loose": 3, "deciding_L_alt": 3, "sum_Q_loose": 4 }, { "fold": "23->29", "ladder_L_free_697": 2, "record_kill_run_r": 2, "deciding_L_loose": 3, "deciding_L_alt": 2, "sum_Q_loose": 4 }, { "fold": "23->31", "ladder_L_free_697": 3, "record_kill_run_r": 2, "deciding_L_loose": 3, "deciding_L_alt": 2, "sum_Q_loose": 4 }, { "fold": "23->37", "ladder_L_free_697": 2, "record_kill_run_r": 2, "deciding_L_loose": 3, "deciding_L_alt": 2, "sum_Q_loose": 14 } ], "F1_verdict": "deciding index = record kill run + 1 at 6/6 folds; in the loose Q_L this sits one ABOVE #697's ladder at 23->29/31/37, and the alternation refinement is exactly what removes the extra index (3->2, no other change anywhere)", "F2_identity_test": { "identity": "N_new(G2_new) = SUM_L Q_L(G2_new), the reason #159's ratio at theta = 546 is exactly 0.5000", "folds": [ { "fold": "13->17", "N_new": 20, "sum_Q": 20, "holds": true }, { "fold": "17->19", "N_new": 20, "sum_Q": 16, "holds": false, "true_ratio": 0.625 }, { "fold": "19->23", "N_new": 4, "sum_Q": 4, "holds": true }, { "fold": "31->37", "source": "return #159 log", "N_new": 2, "sum_Q": 2, "holds": true }, { "fold": "37->41", "source": "return #159 log", "N_new": 4, "sum_Q": 4, "holds": true } ], "verdict": "NOT an identity: fails at 17->19. The inequality survives; the 0.5000 equality that made the fold-41 figure look like a law is a coincidence of that fold." }, "scope": "finite, reachable levels only; G2 <= certificate everywhere tested; the transport's PROVEN grade untouched; folds 31->37 (6.2e9 slots) and 37->41 (2.2e11) not enumerable in this budget, so the L=3->2 collapse is unverified there", "compute": "4 exact enumerations, largest word 7952175 gaps (63 MB), < 0.05 CPU-h, no published computation rerun" }