{ "route_id": 27, "outcome": "progress", "evidence_md": "T29's SAMPLED COLUMN REPRODUCES #161's PLATEAU START AND REFUTES MY OWN SIX-POINT RATIO TREND.\n\nMEASURED (period_check.c unchanged, full period = phase-max; 414 s wall = 0.115 CPU-h under bounded exec, exit 0, timed_out false):\np: 31 37 41 61 101 109 113 127 131\nK*({p}): 4 3 2 2 2 2 2 1 1\n* The FINAL 1-PLATEAU STARTS AT p = 127 at level 29 -- #161's published T29 transition (\"reads 1 from p = 127\") reproduced on this run at the sampled points, alongside the diagonal 4 at p = 31 and 3 at p = 37 (already reproduced in #614/#616).\n* NO RECOVERY among the nine samples: 4 -> 3 -> 2 -> ... -> 1 is monotone non-increasing. Sampling cannot rule out a dip BETWEEN samples (stated, not glossed); what it establishes is that the column does not RISE at any sampled prime, so the rare non-monotonicity of #618 does not appear at level 29 where the samples look.\n* THE SIX-POINT RATIO TREND IS REFUTED. Plateau/level = 127/29 = 4.38, BELOW T23's 4.65 (a monotone ratio >= 4.65 would have needed p >= 135). So the plateau-start ladder 11, 23, 37, 59, 71, 107 whose ratios rose 2.2, 2.09, 2.85, 3.47, 3.74, 4.65 over levels 5-23 does NOT extend: the trend REVERSES at the largest reachable level. Corrected statement to quote: the ratio is ~2-4.7 across levels 5-23 and 4.38 at level 29, with no monotone law -- this is the \"failure\" branch the #618 next step named, obtained with the seventh point it asked for.\n\nCOST AND SCOPE, STATED. A full column to p = 131 at level 29 costs ~18 min (each invocation re-sieves the 6.47e9-position tile, ~12 s, plus p x 0.4 s of block scan), more than the 0.25 CPU-h offered, so the column was SAMPLED at nine primes bracketing its structure, and the run used 0.115 CPU-h. Per-prime wall times 25-67 s, sieve-dominated. A TWO-CLASS column at level 29 was not attempted: prod(Q) = 31 x 37 = 1147 blocks x 214.7M slots is ~500 s for a SINGLE prime, i.e. several CPU-hours for even a short column. NOT CLAIMED: no law for the plateau starts, no monotonicity claim between samples, nothing about |Q| >= 2, nothing on route 26's blocked phase fork, no asymptotics.", "prior_art_md": "Reuses the search record of #610/#611 under the rule that assigned validation reuses the search record, plus the confirming searches of #616 (\"adjacent-kill run table ... column reads 1 from transition prime\" -- no results; the object is project-internal) and #617 (\"... phase translation maximum versus fixed anchor ...\" -- nothing on the anchored-vs-phase-max distinction). Unchanged verdict: the span/fusion mechanism is owned by Holt, arXiv:2502.20470v3 sec 3 Lemma 2 (p. 5) with Holt-Rudd arXiv:1408.6002 p. 11 and arXiv:2605.19165 sec 3 (p. 11); the longest-run law by Flajolet-Sedgewick Prop. V.2; no source bounds a MAXIMUM adjacent-kill run on a sieved two-class set. EXACT REMAINING GAP: (i) no published statement about a covering ladder's increment or transition at a step changing both lattice and killer set; (ii) no two-class order-m profile object and no uniform bound on m*(s); (iii) no published treatment of a single-killer covering column as a function of the killer's size -- neither the rare non-monotonicity of #618, nor the plateau-start ladder 11/23/37/59/71/107, nor its non-extensibility to level 29 (4.38) appears in print. Scope of the negative: arXiv, OEIS and the open web plus this project's corpus.", "depends_on": [ 161, 616, 614 ], "next_step": { "question": "Is the plateau-start ratio's behaviour at level 29 (4.38, below level 23's 4.65) a reversal or a single outlying point -- and where does the one-class column finally reach its 1-plateau at the largest reachable level, between the sampled 113 (=2) and 127 (=1)?", "method": "Complete the level-29 column in the two gaps the samples left: the primes 43, 47, 53, 59, 67, 71, 73, 79, 83, 89, 97, 103, 107 (between 41 and 113, where 2 is expected but unmeasured) and the interval 113 < p < 127 (empty -- the next prime is 127), so the transition is already bracketed. Then repeat the sampled sweep at level 23 with the SAME nine primes to check that the ratio comparison is not an artifact of unequal sampling density. Cost at level 29 is sieve-dominated: 496 s of block scan for the 13 primes plus 13 x 12 s of tile re-sieve = ~11 min = 0.18 CPU-h.", "success": "The gap primes all read 2, so the level-29 column is exactly 4,3,2*,1 and the ratio reversal stands as a measured counterexample to the six-point trend -- a seventh and eighth point that turn a six-point observation into a refuted conjecture with the counterexample named.", "failure": "A gap prime reads 3 (a recovery at level 29) or 1 before 127. Either would be the first departure from #161's published T29 transition and would put the claim's convention under question again.", "budget_hours": 0.5, "compute": { "cpu_hours": 0.25, "ram_gb": 2, "disk_gb": 1 }, "required_tools": [], "required_sources": [] } }