# Pre-registration: the blind @29 test of the joint-deficit closed form *Written 2026-08-19 and committed alone, before any producer script for this run existed. Everything below is fixed in advance: the predictions, the acceptance bands, the validation gate the instrument must clear before any @29 number is reported, and what each verdict does to `TODO.md` item X. No @29 census exists at the time of writing; `xchannel-triples.md` §7 names @29 as the level that would decide R3 and prices it out of reach in memory.* ## 1. The statistic, stated so the new instrument is provably the same one `research/natal-cap-39-triple-census.js` defines, for a level `x` with `W = ∏_{p≤x} p`, natal set `N = {r ∈ [0,W) : r ≡ 11,17 (mod 30), p ∤ r, p ∤ r+2 for 7 ≤ p ≤ x}`, and scour primes `qs = {q prime : x < q, q² ≤ W}`: - for a triple `Q = {q₁ W, mixed} c(Q,ε)) / (6·N̄·Σ_{∏Q > W} 1/∏Q)`.** The in-memory instrument reaches the super-`W` part by the bridge `mixed super-W obs = Σ_{r∈N}[C(a,2)b + a·C(b,2)] − (sub-W mixed obs)` with `a(r) = #{q ∈ qs : q | r}` and `b(r) = #{q ∈ qs : q | r+2}`, and it materialises three arrays of width `W` (`A`, `a`, `b`, 5 bytes per slot). At @29, `W = 6,469,693,230`, so that is 32 GB for this instrument and 162 GB for `natal-cap-35`'s 25-byte slot. That price, not the arithmetic, is what stopped the series at @23. **The identity the segmented instrument will use instead**, exact and with no estimator, obtained by exchanging the order of summation in the bridge: > `mixed super-W obs = Σ_{r∈N} #{(q₁ W}` > ` + Σ_{r∈N} #{(q₁ ∈ D_a(r), q₂ W}` with `D_a(r) = {q ∈ qs : q | r}`, `D_b(r) = {q ∈ qs : q | r+2}`. Each `r` contributes only through its own two divisor lists, `|D_a| ≤ 6` and `|D_b| ≤ 6` at @29, so the sum is computable one segment of `[0,W)` at a time in memory bounded by the segment. The denominator's second factor, `Σ_{∏Q>W} 1/∏Q`, is a tail sum over the prime list alone and is computed directly as a tail (not as `e₃` minus the sub-`W` sum), so no cancellation enters it. Aligned super-`W` obs must be exactly 0 at every level (P1, a theorem). It is carried as an instrument check, not as a result. ## 2. The predictions, adopted verbatim from the record `research/history/staging/import-stein.md` §3.2, "Forward prediction, on the record before the level exists", gives the zero-parameter closed form `1 − J = 4S₂`, `S₂ = Σ_{x 6` Test 1 is primary because it is exactly the test that produced the +2.87, −0.29 and +0.60 already on the record, and changing yardsticks between the fitted levels and the blind one is how a candidate gets promoted by its scorer rather than by the data. **TEST 2 (SECONDARY — scale accuracy, which is what a MARGINAL result means).** `d = (1−J)_meas/0.028943 − 1`. - **TIGHT**: `|d| ≤ 1.25%` — at @29 the closed form is at least as accurate as it was at @23 (+1.25%). - **CONSISTENT**: `1.25% < |d| ≤ 2.5%` — at least as accurate as at @19 (−2.49%), the worse of the two scored levels. - **DRIFTING**: `2.5% < |d| ≤ 5%` — worse at @29 than at either scored level, by up to a factor of two. - **REFUTED AS THE CONSTANT**: `|d| > 5%`. **COMBINED VERDICT, fixed now.** | Test 1 | Test 2 | verdict written in the report | |---|---|---| | HIT | any | **HIT** — the closed form survives its first blind level | | MARGINAL | TIGHT or CONSISTENT | **SURVIVES WITH A MEASURED OFFSET** — right to `d`, not right | | MARGINAL | DRIFTING | **WEAK** — the scale law holds, the closed form is not the constant | | MISS | DRIFTING or worse | **MISS** | | MISS | TIGHT or CONSISTENT | impossible by construction; if it occurs the instrument is at fault | **A fourth band on `J` itself, to catch the case where the object changes rather than the constant.** If `J(29) < 0.94` or `J(29) > 1.00`, the report leads with that and not with the score: the deficit would then have left the track it has held since @19 (`J` = 0.9599, 0.9659), and the closed form's failure would be a symptom rather than the finding. ## 4. What this test cannot do, registered before it runs The candidate is **not separable at @29 from its two nearest rivals**, and the numbers saying so are computed here, before the run: | law | prediction for `1 − J` at @29 | distance from the candidate | |---|---|---| | **N1, the candidate** `4S₂` | **0.028943** | — | | N2, constant multiple of `F`, `c` = @23's measured 3.8667 | 0.029145 | +0.70%, **1.6σ_J** | | N3, `1 − J ∝ 1/lnW` anchored at @23 (lnW: 19.223 → 22.590) | 0.028990 | +0.16%, **0.4σ_J** | **So a HIT at @29 confirms that the ~3.8 law continues past the in-memory ceiling and fixes its scale to about half a percent. It does not single out `4S₂`, and no claim that it does may be written.** Any of the three laws passing means all three pass. **@31 is where they separate, and that is registered too.** At @31 the candidate predicts 0.024784, N2 predicts 0.024818 (+0.14%) and N3 predicts **0.025165** (+1.54%), against `σ_J ≈ 2.3·10⁻⁵` ≈ 0.09%. N3 is therefore **≈ 16σ** from the candidate at @31 while being 0.4σ from it at @29. If @31 is affordable it is run and scored by the same two tests against 0.024784, with the added clause: `(1−J)_meas` inside `0.024784 ± 3σ_J` **refutes N3**; inside `0.025165 ± 3σ_J` refutes N1. N2 stays inseparable at @31 and is not tested. ## 5. The validation gate, which comes before any @29 number The segmented instrument is a new instrument. Before @29 is computed it must reproduce, **exactly and to the unit**, the embedded output of `research/natal-cap-39-triple-census.js` at @17, @19 and @23 on every one of: | quantity | @17 | @19 | @23 | |---|---|---|---| | `W` | 510510 | 9699690 | 223092870 | | `N̄` | 14850 | 252450 | 5301450 | | `K` | — | 435 | 1739 | | `B₃` split (3,0)/(2,1)/(1,2)/(0,3) | 848/2729/2713/847 | 27377/85713/85449/27391 | 879225/2779604/2779107/879385 | | sub-`W` triples `∏Q < W` | 5246 | 162982 | 4517592 | | sub-`W` mixed obs | 2243 | 97097 | 3751046 | | `Σ_{∏Q>W} 1/∏Q` | 0.039784 | 0.050943 | 0.058834 | | **mixed super-`W` obs** | **3199** | **74065** | **1807665** | | by orientation (2,1)/(1,2) | 1622/1577 | 37139/36926 | 904409/903256 | | CRT denominator | 3544.79 | 77162.70 | 1871421.20 | | **`J`** | **0.9025** | **0.9599** | **0.9659** | | aligned super-`W` obs (P1) | 0 | 0 | 0 | **If any integer-valued row differs by one unit at any of the three levels, no @29 value is reported at all**, and the run is written up as an instrument failure. This is the gate `natal-cap-39` itself used when a `Uint8Array` wrap moved `X̄` by 13.33, and it is the reason that defect was caught. At @29 the instrument's own internal identities are also checked and must hold: `Σ_{r∈N} 1 = N̄ = 2∏_{7≤p≤29}(p−2) = 143,139,150`; `B₃` from the `(a,b)` counts equals sub-`W` plus super-`W` from the divisor lists, class by class; aligned super-`W` obs `= 0`; and the two orientations `(2,1)` and `(1,2)` agree to within their own Poisson scale. ## 6. What each verdict does to TODO item X Item X currently reads, on this point: *"the ~3.8 constant now has a ZERO-PARAMETER closed-form candidate ... landing at −0.29σ (@19) and +0.60σ (@23) with asymptote exactly 4 ..., and blind values pre-computed at @29 ... and @31 .... It is a candidate, NOT a derivation ... so the derivation stays the item's open analytic target, now with a target formula and two blind tests waiting."* Its Named gaps carry *"@23 is the in-memory instrument's last level (@29 needs 162 GB)"*, and its first move defers *"any segmented @29 rewrite"*. - **HIT.** The first of the two waiting blind tests is spent and passed. Item X gains a fourth scored level and its first out-of-sample one; the phrase "two blind tests waiting" becomes "one blind test waiting, @31". The closed form stays a **candidate, not a derivation** — §4 forbids any promotion on @29 alone, since N2 and N3 pass with it. The Named gap "@23 is the in-memory instrument's last level (@29 needs 162 GB)" is **closed by the instrument**: the level is reachable in bounded memory, and the item's deferral of "any segmented @29 rewrite" is spent. The item's open analytic target (derive the constant) is unchanged and is worth more, because the thing to be derived is now confirmed at a level the fit never saw. - **SURVIVES WITH A MEASURED OFFSET.** Same as HIT on the instrument and the Named gap, but the item must carry the offset `d` in print beside the closed form, and "landing at −0.29σ and +0.60σ" must be extended with the @29 z. A closed form claimed to have asymptote exactly 4 that drifts at the level where the test is sharpest is a weaker object than the record currently describes, and the item says so. - **WEAK or MISS.** `4S₂` is struck from item X as the constant's closed form. What survives is only what the measured ratio series says: the item's ~3.8 reverts to a measured multiple with a fourth point, and the sentence "its asymptote is exactly 4, which is AGG's neighbourhood count" loses its support and must be marked as an @11–@23 reading that the first blind level refused. The `import-stein.md` §3.2 prediction block is annotated in place, not deleted. The Named gap on the in-memory ceiling still closes: a MISS is a measurement, and it needed the same instrument. - **The `J`-band clause fires (`J < 0.94` or `J > 1.00`).** The headline is the joint deficit's own trend, not the closed form. `xchannel-triples.md` R1's band classifier is re-applied to `J(29)` and the pre-registered bands there (DEEPENING / FLAT / DECAYING ON THE FORCED TRACK / DECAYING FASTER THAN FORCED / GONE OR REVERSED) decide what item X's "monotone DECAY" clause becomes. - **The validation gate fails.** Nothing is reported about @29, item X is untouched, and the note records which row failed. ## 7. Scope Producers: `research/xchan-at29-*.js`, embedded with `node research/qc/embed.js`. Report: `research/history/staging/xchan-at29.md`. This file. No live document is edited by this run; `TODO.md`, `IMPORT-MAP.md` and the changelog are out of scope, and the item X update is **proposed in the report, not applied**.