# Pre-registration — the kill shadow as a band-averaged pair-Buchstab integral **Written 2026-08-19, TODO item 5, BEFORE any measurement was run and before any comparison to a measured depth.** The candidate numbers below come from `research/shadow-buchstab-01-candidate.js` (embedded output, pure computation, no data in it). The instrument that will score them, `research/shadow-buchstab-02-instrument.js`, did not exist when this file was written. ## What is being tested `research/anchored-windows.md` §5 records the **kill shadow**: the window just past a level's crystallization edge holds ≈ 0.85 of the tile's fair twin-slot share, at every level it measured. `attack2-05-07-integral-ladder.js` reading A5-2 asserts — without computing it — that this 0.85 **is** the average of the Unification-Law survival curve over that window: rho(u) = e^{2gamma}/u^2 on 1 <= u <= 2 (exact under HL) rho(u) = (e^{gamma} omega(u))^2 on 2 <= u <= 3 (independence conjecture) with `u = ln x / ln y`, `omega` Buchstab's function, and the band `[y^2, 2y^2]` equal to `u ∈ [2, 2 + ln2/ln y]`. The claim under test is that the measured shadow depth equals the x-weighted average `B_x(y)` of `rho` over that band. ## The candidate values (computed, then frozen) Band anchored at the level's own square, `[y², 2y²]`, x-weighted: | y | w = ln2/ln y | **B_x(y)** | B_u (flat in u) | |---|---|---|---| | 23 | 0.221065 | **0.873491** | 0.865981 | | 97 | 0.151517 | **0.851659** | 0.846009 | | 401 | 0.115641 | **0.839217** | 0.834695 | | 997 | 0.100387 | **0.833670** | 0.829665 | | 2999 | 0.086578 | **0.828512** | 0.824994 | | 10007 | 0.075252 | **0.824182** | 0.821079 | | y → ∞ | 0 | **0.793055** | 0.793055 | Band anchored at the *next* prime's square (the configuration `anchored-windows.md` §5 actually used — sieve level `p`, window `[p'², 2p'²]`): 0.943056 (p=23), 0.862697 (97), 0.843619 (401), 0.836045 (997), 0.828629 (2999), 0.824213 (10007). Predicted octile profile inside the band, normalised to the band mean (this divides out any level-wide finite-size factor): rise from first to last octile = **1.0769 at y = 997** and **1.0596 at y = 10007**. ## Scoring rules, fixed in advance The scoring target is a **fresh measurement**, not the §5 table: that table's producer (`scratchpad/anchored-check.js`) no longer exists, and `anchored-windows.md`'s own header forbids quoting §5 without recomputation. The §5 numbers (0.834 @ p=23, 0.850 @ 97, 0.853 @ 401, 0.856 @ 997) are used here for one purpose only — to set the tolerance — and are declared read before this file was written. **Tolerance.** `tol = 0.011` absolute, on the ratio-to-fair-share scale. Reason: half the spread of the four recorded depths (0.856 − 0.834 = 0.022). A candidate that cannot resolve the levels better than the levels differ from each other has not explained the levels; half the spread is the coarsest tolerance under which "derived" still means something. **Counting-noise floor, declared in advance.** Each band holds `N ≈ delta(y)·y²` slots; the Poisson-scale relative error `1/sqrt(N)` is ≈ 17% at y = 23, ≈ 8% at y = 97, ≈ 3.5% at y = 401, ≈ 1.1% at y = 997, ≈ 0.15% at y = 10007. **Levels with `1/sqrt(N)` above the tolerance (y = 23, 97, 401) cannot decide anything and are scored as INFORMATIVE ONLY.** The verdict rests on y ≥ 997. **D1 (magnitude).** `|B_x(y) − measured(y)| ≤ 0.011` at every deciding level. **D2 (level trend).** The candidate is strictly decreasing in y (the band narrows like `1/ln y`, so any average over it falls toward 0.793055). D2 holds iff the measured band ratio also falls with y, by more than the noise floor. This is a sign test the candidate cannot avoid: it does not depend on the value of any constant. **D3 (band shape).** Measured last-octile/first-octile ratio within `±0.020` of 1.0769 at y = 997 and of 1.0596 at y = 10007. D3 is the sharp test: it is insensitive to every level-wide normalisation, including whatever finite-size factor separates measured `rho(2)` from 0.793055. **Verdicts.** - **DERIVED** — D1 and D2 and D3 all hold. The shadow is the band average and the object is closed. - **SHAPE-ONLY** — D3 holds, D1 or D2 fails. The Buchstab curve governs the band's interior but not the shadow's level-dependence or its level; the residual is then a normalisation, not a mechanism. - **MISS** — D3 fails. The shadow carries structure the band average does not know, and the residual's shape names it. No other statistic will be promoted to a verdict after the fact.