{ "attempt": "0cc3128f59c81c0cdfa05b4ab6017339", "comparison": { "reports_success_shape": [], "strong_hits_after_setter": [ 1854, 1882, 1895, 1904, 1907, 1919, 1979, 2018, 2024 ] }, "corpus": { "fresh_rows": 4, "max_created_at_ids_le_prev": "2026-09-28T07:39:06.520Z", "n": 189, "n_after_prev_check": 3, "n_after_step_setter": 185, "reused_rows": 185, "reused_sha256": "563068ceaada6dbca6555907f52dcabf808765ceb6a938257e35936015371833", "sha256": "2a619af89fd6ad0840bfe08a14c21797eb8293aac7bd327e7eedb709f97acc80" }, "job": 4540, "post_prev_check": [ { "created_at": "2026-09-28T08:43:27.216Z", "id": 2025, "locator_hits": [], "object_hits": [ "attain", "drop" ], "quotes_step": false, "route": 174, "status": "recorded", "success_hits": {} }, { "created_at": "2026-09-28T08:56:11.136Z", "id": 2026, "locator_hits": [ "#2024", "route 100" ], "object_hits": [], "quotes_step": false, "route": 148, "status": "recorded", "success_hits": {} }, { "created_at": "2026-09-28T09:10:45.704Z", "id": 2027, "locator_hits": [], "object_hits": [], "quotes_step": false, "route": 76, "status": "recorded", "success_hits": {} } ], "prev_check": { "created_at": "2026-09-28T07:53:35.263Z", "id": 2024 }, "price": { "assignment_cpu_hours": 8.0, "band_2e9_lt_Mp_le_1e10": { "P=2": { "rows": 6530, "sum_Mp": 29026687045172 }, "P=6": { "rows": 7468, "sum_Mp": 35816755546836 } }, "band_rows": 13998, "band_slots": 64843442592008, "hours": { "merge_classification_recorded_rows": 0.038449918256944444, "p2_p6_band_four_thread": 18.01206738666889, "p2_p6_band_single_thread": 82.24688304415018, "p30_branch_pool43_M_le_2e8_at_2.4e8": 0.3660905158333333, "p30_branch_pool43_at_2.4e8": 1.6710547495833334, "p30_branch_pool43_single_thread": 1.8312928762557077, "p30_branch_pool47_at_2.4e8": 3.4873869306944445, "p30_branch_pool60_at_2.4e8": 10.285198623888888, "recorded_sweep_total": 2714914077706 }, "p30_branch": { "43": { "max_Mp": 9937554990, "pool": 11, "rows": 1255, "sets": 893, "sum_M": 106997475150, "sum_Mp": 1336793828490 }, "43_M_le_2e8": { "max_Mp": 2164698690, "pool": 11, "rows": 986, "sets": 718, "sum_M": 26522192160, "sum_Mp": 289780013520 }, "43_M_le_5e8": { "max_Mp": 5449626930, "pool": 11, "rows": 1173, "sets": 840, "sum_M": 64658681640, "sum_Mp": 812498086530 }, "47": { "max_Mp": 9986850930, "pool": 12, "rows": 1972, "sets": 1394, "sum_M": 228761404920, "sum_Mp": 2784340903200 }, "60": { "max_Mp": 9986850930, "pool": 14, "rows": 4112, "sets": 2924, "sum_M": 734737117440, "sum_Mp": 8151674493600 } }, "rate_provenance": "return #2024 (job #4528) timing of the served kfork.c on three rows already on the #1833 record; NOT re-measured here (no C compiler on PATH in this workspace)", "rate_slots_per_sec": { "conservative": 240000000.0, "four_thread": 1000000000.0, "measured_single_thread_hi": 267000000.0, "measured_single_thread_lo": 219000000.0 }, "step_budget_hours": 2.0 }, "route": 100, "served_1804_census": { "A_max": 16, "A_max_at_p11": 13, "A_max_at_p7": 8, "H1_holds": false, "H2_counterexample_count": 1585, "H2_holds": false, "P": 30, "hard_rows": 1904, "max_drop": 2, "n_drop_eq_D_ge3": 0, "n_p11_rows": 531, "n_p7_rows": 572, "n_rows": 1904, "sets": 2228, "step_target_cells": { "p11_A_ge_19": 0, "p7_A_ge_14": 0 }, "sum_Mp": 127613768940 }, "served_1833_dbound": { "D_equals_floor_at_targets_P30": false, "D_floor_case_count_P30_p_le_19": 80, "Lmax": 60, "min_L_for_D_ge3_at_P30": { "7": 14, "11": 19, "13": 21, "17": 27, "19": 33 }, "n_strict": 2300, "pmax": 97, "rows": 4036 }, "served_1833_sweep": { "D_ge3_fraction": 0.6375973475210116, "attained_drop_eq_D_counts": { "2/3/4/2": 45 }, "max_attained_D": 2, "max_drop": 17, "n_drop_ge_D_minus_2": 1327, "n_rows": 12969, "per_P": { "2": { "n": 11017, "nD_ge3": 7234, "n_drop_eq_D": 45, "n_drop_ge3": 1350, "n_drop_gt_D": 0, "sum_M": 238461787838, "sum_Mp": 1901324672806 }, "6": { "n": 1952, "nD_ge3": 1035, "n_drop_eq_D": 0, "n_drop_ge3": 0, "n_drop_gt_D": 0, "sum_M": 117398167356, "sum_Mp": 813589404900 } }, "sum_Mp_drop_ge_D_minus_2": 33220729374 }, "step": { "budget_hours": 2, "compute": { "cpu_hours": 0, "disk_gb": 1, "ram_gb": 2 }, "failure": "No drop = D row for D >= 3 through Mp 1e10 and no merge-gain invariant: record the observed max drop per (P,p,D) and stop.", "method": "Reuse sweep2612.jsonl (rows with D >= 3 at P=2 and P=6, all with drop < D) and kfork.c: for each row with drop >= D-2, list every maximal A-run and translate at min fork count and the merged A_{Pp}-run that beats A - d*, and classify the merge (end-extension through a removed unkilled slot vs a different window). Then scan P=2 and P=6 with Mp up to 1e10 for drop = D at D >= 3, lowest Mp first, and P=30 rows with p=7, A >= 14 or p=11, A >= 19 (the smallest A where D(30,p,A) >= 3).", "question": "Is the phase bound D(P,p,A) attained when D >= 3, or is the exact maximal drop D minus a merge gain that is always positive once D >= 3?", "required_sources": [ "return-1267", "return-1804" ], "required_tools": [ "python3", "cc" ], "success": "A row with drop = D >= 3 (cross-checked by kfork.c), or a proven lower bound on the merge gain for D >= 3 that matches the observed maximal drops." }, "step_copies_sha256": { "brief": "5a7520c706fac0165c7eeed352c72f37fa9e7b7a082a6cf9164a100d9287d274", "return-1833.next_step": "5a7520c706fac0165c7eeed352c72f37fa9e7b7a082a6cf9164a100d9287d274", "return-2018.next_step": "5a7520c706fac0165c7eeed352c72f37fa9e7b7a082a6cf9164a100d9287d274", "return-2024.next_step": "5a7520c706fac0165c7eeed352c72f37fa9e7b7a082a6cf9164a100d9287d274", "route-100.next_step": "5a7520c706fac0165c7eeed352c72f37fa9e7b7a082a6cf9164a100d9287d274" }, "step_setter": { "created_at": "2026-09-26T14:25:52.196Z", "id": 1833 }, "step_sha256": "5a7520c706fac0165c7eeed352c72f37fa9e7b7a082a6cf9164a100d9287d274", "verdict": { "outcome": "progress", "q1_candidates": [ 2025, 2026, 2027 ], "q1_newer_return_answers_step": false, "q2_queue_looping": true, "q3_covered_range_negative": true, "q3_p26_band_affordable": false, "q3_p30_branch_affordable": true }, "vocabulary": { "locators": [ "sweep2612", "kfork", "dbound2612", "dbound", "A_{Pp}", "A - d*", "D(P,p,A)", "phase bound", "base extension", "base-extension", "Pp,R", "return-1267", "return-1804", "#1267", "#1804", "#1833", "#2018", "#2024", "route 100", "route 127", "4176", "boundary-transfer" ], "object_words": [ "drop", "merge gain", "merge-gain", "attain", "K*(P", "K*(30", "A - B", "A - B", "maximal A-run", "fork count" ], "success_patterns": { "drop_eq_D": "drop\\s*=\\s*D\\b", "drop_eq_D_ge3": "drop\\s*=\\s*D\\s*>=\\s*3", "drop_ge_3": "drop\\s*>=\\s*3", "merge_gain": "merge[\\s\\-_]?gain" } } }