{ "basis": 1400, "docs": [ { "normalized_only_served": 2, "normalized_only_thrown": 2, "ledger_changed": 4, "headings_changed": 0, "verdict": "substantive", "sample_ledger_changed": [ "| 5 (retired) | `Q-shadow-prereg` Is the kill shadow's 0.85 the band-average of the Unification-Law survival curve over the post-crystallization window? | OPEN | Pre-registration only, written before ", "| `Q-shadow-prereg` | OPEN | Is the kill shadow's 0.85 the band-average of the Unification-Law survival curve over the post-crystallization window? | Pre-registration only, written before any measurem", "| 5 (retired) | `Q-shadow-prereg` Is the kill shadow's 0.85 the band-average of the Unification-Law survival curve over the post-crystallization window? | ANSWERED | Scored in shadow-buchstab.md: SHAP", "| `Q-shadow-prereg` | ANSWERED | Is the kill shadow's 0.85 the band-average of the Unification-Law survival curve over the post-crystallization window? | Scored in shadow-buchstab.md: SHAPE-ONLY under" ], "document": "research/QUESTIONS.md", "versions": 3, "repeated_sha": true, "changed_lines": 4, "substantive_lines": 4, "class": "substantive", "controls_named_by_review": true, "sample_substantive": [ "-| 5 (retired) | `Q-shadow-prereg` Is the kill shadow's 0.85 the band-average of the Unification-Law survival curve over the post-crystallization window? | ANSW", "+| 5 (retired) | `Q-shadow-prereg` Is the kill shadow's 0.85 the band-average of the Unification-Law survival curve over the post-crystallization window? | OPEN", "-| `Q-shadow-prereg` | ANSWERED | Is the kill shadow's 0.85 the band-average of the Unification-Law survival curve over the post-crystallization window? | Score", "+| `Q-shadow-prereg` | OPEN | Is the kill shadow's 0.85 the band-average of the Unification-Law survival curve over the post-crystallization window? | Pre-regis" ], "sample_removed": [ "-| 5 (retired) | `Q-shadow-prereg` Is the kill shadow's 0.85 the band-average of the Unification-Law survival curve over the post-crystallization window? | ANSW", "-| `Q-shadow-prereg` | ANSWERED | Is the kill shadow's 0.85 the band-average of the Unification-Law survival curve over the post-crystallization window? | Score" ], "note": null, "served_sha": "07cadf7fb13fccddd1e2482badee60280ae55218f47213e54427c91d61e81b92", "thrown_sha": "e2ddcfc55f89be535041515a26fbc5068db832a7db548d35765b75f5360ff60e" }, { "normalized_only_served": 3, "normalized_only_thrown": 3, "ledger_changed": 6, "headings_changed": 0, "verdict": "substantive", "sample_ledger_changed": [ "parity: Exact divisor algebra retains Lambda(n-2)mu(n), centering, odd moduli and moving endpoints. The top-range repair uses ordinary prime Bombieri-Vinogradov (Tao Notes 3 Theorem 17, prefix form by", "status: PARTIAL", "verdict: Equations (3)-(4), the exact split and flip, survive review and finite controls. A repair of the top-range bound T^top=O_(A,eps)(x/log^A x) is DERIVED in section 3a (2026-09-08) with the endp", "parity: Exact divisor algebra retains Lambda(n-2)mu(n), centering, odd moduli and moving endpoints. The top-range repair uses ordinary prime Bombieri-Vinogradov (Tao Notes 3 Theorem 17, prefix form by" ], "document": "research/centered-discrepancy-estimate.md", "versions": 3, "repeated_sha": true, "changed_lines": 6, "substantive_lines": 6, "class": "substantive", "controls_named_by_review": false, "sample_substantive": [ "-status: ANSWERED", "+status: PARTIAL", "-parity: Exact divisor algebra retains Lambda(n-2)mu(n), centering, odd moduli and moving endpoints. The top-range repair uses ordinary prime Bombieri-Vinogrado", "+parity: Exact divisor algebra retains Lambda(n-2)mu(n), centering, odd moduli and moving endpoints. The top-range repair uses ordinary prime Bombieri-Vinogrado" ], "sample_removed": [ "-status: ANSWERED", "-parity: Exact divisor algebra retains Lambda(n-2)mu(n), centering, odd moduli and moving endpoints. The top-range repair uses ordinary prime Bombieri-Vinogrado", "-verdict: Yes, at the stated scope. Equations (3)-(4), the exact split and flip, survive review and finite controls. The top-range bound T^top=O_(A,eps)(x/log^A" ], "note": null, "served_sha": "0e472838611a569c06491fe539ad5c557a45805840bdb9091b324d7aedd1a175", "thrown_sha": "dd6e1a4c892f4b085400ba36ea81e41d62449563145e9add8ef8c65227c16a90" }, { "normalized_only_served": 3, "normalized_only_thrown": 18, "ledger_changed": 0, "headings_changed": 0, "verdict": "reflow/filtering", "sample_ledger_changed": [], "document": "research/corner-correlation.md", "versions": 3, "repeated_sha": true, "changed_lines": 22, "substantive_lines": 0, "class": "filtering", "controls_named_by_review": false, "sample_substantive": [], "sample_removed": [ "-s,s'>1 or all non-squarefree n. See [independent review F5](history/reviews-0906/20-independent-handoff-review.md).", "-negligible class. Here, in (5) and wherever (5) is cited, that sub-family", "-is the s=s'=1 piece of the prime-r sum (1): k=r and t=r' are primes, and", "-proper prime powers have already been moved into the O_H error of (1).", "-Then k=r prime and r|d forces r^2|n, costing O(x^(19/25+epsilon));", "-likewise r'^2|(n-2) costs O(x^(19/20+epsilon)). Hence, exactly," ], "note": null, "served_sha": "75558308dbc44e07b5fb4014b5d6ebb0504e7f142a51b7a55a69e0285318463a", "thrown_sha": "e1f5941060c8e1fcbf62afd90883d35f22ccca504f9d0bed4e5835242b19c4c2" }, { "normalized_only_served": 7, "normalized_only_thrown": 10, "ledger_changed": 4, "headings_changed": 0, "verdict": "substantive", "sample_ledger_changed": [ "Independent reviewer / disposition: the 2026-09-09 integration review reconstructs the repaired tails, density, multiplicity and uniform-mean application; accepts (4.1) with the bookkeeping correction", "verdict: Reviewed 2026-09-09 after the coprimality repair: T_I^low=O_(A,eps')(x/log^A x), hence S=C_2x+B+O_A(x/log^A x), with B the exact Type II plus band sum (2.9). The untruncated modulus bound was", "Independent reviewer / disposition: the 2026-09-09 integration review reconstructs the repaired tails, density, multiplicity and uniform-mean application; accepts (4.1) with the bookkeeping correction", "verdict: Reviewed 2026-09-09 after the coprimality repair: T_I^low=O_(A,eps')(x/log^A x), hence S=C_2x+B+O_A(x/log^A x), with B the exact Type II plus band sum (2.9). The untruncated modulus bound was" ], "document": "research/fixed-endpoint-discrepancy.md", "versions": 3, "repeated_sha": true, "changed_lines": 17, "substantive_lines": 4, "class": "substantive", "controls_named_by_review": true, "sample_substantive": [ "-verdict: Reviewed 2026-09-09 after the coprimality repair: T_I^low=O_(A,eps')(x/log^A x), hence S=C_2x+B+O_A(x/log^A x), with B the exact Type II plus band sum", "+verdict: Reviewed 2026-09-09 after the coprimality repair: T_I^low=O_(A,eps')(x/log^A x), hence S=C_2x+B+O_A(x/log^A x), with B the exact Type II plus band sum", "- Independent reviewer / disposition: the 2026-09-09 integration review reconstructs the repaired tails, density, multiplicity and uniform-mean application; ", "+ Independent reviewer / disposition: the 2026-09-09 integration review reconstructs the repaired tails, density, multiplicity and uniform-mean application; " ], "sample_removed": [ "-verdict: Reviewed 2026-09-09 after the coprimality repair: T_I^low=O_(A,eps')(x/log^A x), hence S=C_2x+B+O_A(x/log^A x), with B the exact Type II plus band sum", "- Independent reviewer / disposition: the 2026-09-09 integration review reconstructs the repaired tails, density, multiplicity and uniform-mean application; ", "-(4.9) would pay the band piece P_band, but no inspected source states it, and it does not touch", "-the below-level Type II piece T_II^low of (2.7): with (4.9) the D-margin still requires", "-2C_2M+T_II^low>=-4x/25+o(x). A bound for the actual signed weights of B could suffice without (4.9);", "-(4.9) cannot replace a signed bound for T_II^low. The exact sum is (2.9) and the required" ], "note": null, "served_sha": "19b6b12c228ec9decd4bd5328cf28b84c63e257ed04dbf55938ea687397f801d", "thrown_sha": "21dce4f3b3bc36d3fd662a616cc2b6a149ddf67ff79bc71a85f4f7b3c82e46c0" }, { "normalized_only_served": 5, "normalized_only_thrown": 41, "ledger_changed": 3, "headings_changed": 1, "verdict": "substantive", "sample_ledger_changed": [ "the stronger sub-2 observation remains measured, not proved.", "It proves neither a twin lower bound nor either open parity hypothesis.", "The closed-form f_1 is increasing on [2,4]: its derivative has the sign of s/(s-1)-log(s-1), which decreases and is positive at s=4. D_3 is increasing. The integrand k(v)=log(v-1)/v has derivative wit" ], "document": "research/fold-arithmetic-bridge.md", "versions": 3, "repeated_sha": true, "changed_lines": 69, "substantive_lines": 3, "class": "substantive", "controls_named_by_review": false, "sample_substantive": [ "+the stronger sub-2 observation remains measured, not proved.", "-The closed-form f_1 is increasing on [2,4]: its derivative has the sign of s/(s-1)-log(s-1), which decreases and is positive at s=4. D_3 is increasing. The int", "-It proves neither a twin lower bound nor either open parity hypothesis." ], "sample_removed": [ "-At that calibration date, the rigorous sub-2 ranges were (4,4.8] and", "-(8,infinity); the intervening interval remained measured. Proposition 6", "-below supplies a later directed certificate for the missing interval.", "-## 4b. All-depth sub-2 certificate (2026-09-11)", "-", "-**Proposition 6.** Under the definitions and standard sieve inputs above," ], "note": null, "served_sha": "2d41665acfc82347f8ca9749e39e7e88f2ad842bb0de05f6b17d56ece84aca3c", "thrown_sha": "d248928b9cddf5802e64a38f03c77e015a2e6cce7c1eb977820d4213d4514149" }, { "normalized_only_served": 2, "normalized_only_thrown": 2, "ledger_changed": 4, "headings_changed": 0, "verdict": "substantive", "sample_ledger_changed": [ "status: PARTIAL", "verdict: Derived: G_i(n)=Lambda_(>W_i)(n)-F_i(s_i(n))*log t_i(n)-E_i(n), with all small-prime factors in s_i and all primes of t_i exceeding W_i. The correction is supported on a small-prime power exc", "status: ANSWERED", "verdict: All three parts are answered at their stated scope. Derived: G_i(n)=Lambda_(>W_i)(n)-F_i(s_i(n))*log t_i(n)-E_i(n), with all small-prime factors in s_i and all primes of t_i exceeding W_i; on" ], "document": "research/global-factor-signs.md", "versions": 3, "repeated_sha": true, "changed_lines": 4, "substantive_lines": 4, "class": "substantive", "controls_named_by_review": true, "sample_substantive": [ "-status: ANSWERED", "+status: PARTIAL", "-verdict: All three parts are answered at their stated scope. Derived: G_i(n)=Lambda_(>W_i)(n)-F_i(s_i(n))*log t_i(n)-E_i(n), with all small-prime factors in s_", "+verdict: Derived: G_i(n)=Lambda_(>W_i)(n)-F_i(s_i(n))*log t_i(n)-E_i(n), with all small-prime factors in s_i and all primes of t_i exceeding W_i. The correctio" ], "sample_removed": [ "-status: ANSWERED", "-verdict: All three parts are answered at their stated scope. Derived: G_i(n)=Lambda_(>W_i)(n)-F_i(s_i(n))*log t_i(n)-E_i(n), with all small-prime factors in s_" ], "note": null, "served_sha": "0509638b58b7458b0eeddc0525745cafef5bd508d01ad65e74cc88b583ba72bb", "thrown_sha": "0a4f04bf5337a649add37617cc3189ebeb0327bb4dcd5bc7e0050f7c7c6b678d" } ], "controls": { "single_version_doc": { "document": "AGENT-START.md", "versions": 0, "repeated": false }, "review154_all_fire": true }, "summary": { "flagged": 6, "substantive": 5, "filtering": 1, "identical": 0, "raw_class_substantive": 5, "uninspected_in_route": [ "research/centered-discrepancy-estimate.md", "research/corner-correlation.md", "research/fold-arithmetic-bridge.md" ] } }