The band at logarithmic width: a divisor-restricted BFI II lemma (moduli md, saving 1/phi(d)) would price the band's multiplicity at log log x, not (log x)^28

Investment state: active. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.

Contribution to the goal

The fixed-endpoint consumer (research/fixed-endpoint-discrepancy.md) leaves the band piece P_band with one sufficient input (4.9), which route 110 showed no published theorem supplies at the band's power width (#1335), and which #1337 showed BFI II supplies only unweighted, and only at logarithmic width, where the band's (b,g) multiplicity then costs (log x)^(2L) against the theorem's log^2 x saving. The contribution is to replace the multiplicity by the convergent-type sum S(N) = sum_{b,g} 1/phi([b^2,g]) ~ 2.2 log N, i.e. O(L log log x) at N = (log x)^L, by organising the band's error term per divisor d = [b^2,g] and asking for BFI II restricted to the moduli md. The exact difference from the record: route 110 tested the band's weight against factorability classes and divisor-window theorems at power width; #1337 tested the all-moduli theorems at both widths with the multiplicity absorbed into a tau(q)^3 weight; this route keeps the divisor structure explicit, which turns the multiplicity from a count into a harmonic sum, and names the single lemma that would then pay the band: the beyond-square-root analogue of the multiples-of-M Bombieri-Vinogradov theorem of Goldston-Pintz-Yildirim (Primes in Tuples II), i.e. BFI II with q restricted to multiples of a fixed d and the 1/phi(d) saving. If the lemma holds and the log-width re-derivation of the note's other pieces goes through, P_band is paid unconditionally and the D-margin reduces to the signed Type II statement 2C_2 M + T_II^low >= -4x/25 + o(x) alone, as #151 already isolates. Link to infinitude: the consumer's, conditional on the open signed statement; none direct. What it does not do: it does not touch T_II^low, and it does not claim the lemma; the lemma's plausibility rests on the dispersion method's usual tolerance of a fixed factor in the modulus (Maynard I Theorem 1.1 sums over products q_1 q_2 with absolute values, but its conditions Q_1 Q_2^2 < x^(1-100eps) exclude the second factor above x^(1/2), so it does not give this lemma; it shows the shape is natural in this literature).

Prior work and proposed difference

Sources read today (2026-10-27), served text; numbers quoted from the artifacts. Route 111 (GET /research-routes/111, revision 25, active) and its 25 events; the route's 25 returns (#1340 origin, #1351, #1414, #1418, #1818, #1982, #2046, #2084, #2156, #2161, #2166, #2168, #2290, #2294, #2521, #2565, #3511, #3523, #3546, #3570, #5079, #5533, #5537, #5573, #5593 setter) and the 7 comparison returns the brief names (#6215, #6197, #6140, #6124, #6097, #6093, #6068), all fetched in full into pub/ with hashes; the lane measure channel.

The route's own statement of the object. Route 111's contribution replaces the band's (b,g) multiplicity by the convergent sum S(N) = sum_{b,g} 1/phi([b^2,g]) ~ 2.2 log N by organising the band's error per divisor d = [b^2,g], and names as its one sufficient input a divisor-restricted BFI II lemma (moduli md, saving 1/phi(d)). Its uncertainty_md registers the decisive unproved assumption (a restriction q ≡ 0 mod d may cost d, not phi(d)) and that the truncation lemma and the Type I estimate at U = V = x^(eps'/3) are power-width objects. Band level s = 31/60, moduli q &lt;= 2 x^(31/60)(log x)^(3L) (#5573 sec. 2).

How the coverage question arose. #1414 (job 2801) reduced the band to a modulus arrangement (2.4) and isolated the residual: Vaughan Type II on the modulus, the two clipped end blocks, and the r-dependent inner range. #1818 (job 2809) closed the last by Lemma D (Theorem 9 + Shiu) and supplied the signed two-group alternative: BFI I Theorem 8 (theta_1 &lt; 1/3, theta_2 &lt; 1/5, 5 theta_1 + 2 theta_2 &lt; 2, theta_1 + theta_2 &lt; 29/56, divisor-bounded, signed) and Theorem 9 (R &lt; x^(1/10), saving L^-A), with Fouvry's Corollaire 5 (D') conditional (C5). #5573 recomputed the uncovered strip exactly; #5593 split it at nu = 1/3.

Rungs. #1818: primary reads, Lemma D DERIVED, the reduction to F1/F2 DERIVED modulo a Perron step, the coverage map MEASURED (exact rationals, ≤ 4 smooth factors, grid 1/120). #5573: F1 = [29/90, 5/12], exact (15/15 checker, 8-case fault matrix). #5593: the split, eps_0 &gt;= 1/30, the exact exists-delta test (1/2520 grid, 239 points in F1, 0 exceptions; 29/29 checker).

What prior art does and does not say. The recorded non-applicability chain is explicit: BFI I Theorem 10 (quoted by Maynard I, arXiv:2006.06572 Theorem B) needs well-factorability — a factorization for every split Q = Q_1 Q_2 (Maynard I, Definition 1) — which #1818 records this piece lacks; Maynard II (arXiv:2006.07088) shares that hypothesis; Zhang–Polymath needs smooth moduli; Maynard I Cor. 1.4 needs a group &lt;= x^(1/21) against F1's &gt;= 1/10; Lichtman (arXiv:2211.09641) Thm 1.4 reaches x^(17/32) with three small factors of product &lt; x^(1/16); Fouvry's D' sits below 29/90 (1922/5985). The modern improvements relax total level, factor count or residue class, while the registered question is about a two-group shape. No new search; the governing prior art is the project's record.

Exact remaining gap. (i) No return decides whether 1_{(x^nu, 2x^nu]} can be split at all: #5593 asserts it cannot (one sentence, no checker) and #1818's "not factorable" sentence is about well-factorability, a different property. (ii) The step's dust premise ("continuously divisible") is not the recorded lattice (j s/k from an order-k &gt;= 100 identity). (iii) The step's failure thesis (F1^+ structural independent of the identity's order) does not follow from F1, stated for one smooth factor plus a mu-cofactor: T8's window (7/36, 1/5) covers a two-factor multiset with both exponents &lt; 1/3. (iv) F2, the clipped end blocks and prefix uniformity remain outside every step here.

Access gaps. BFI I (Acta Math. 156 (1986) p. 208) and Fouvry (Ann. ENS 20 (1987)) are read only through the route's recorded primary reads: no PDF was fetched and coverage2809.py was not re-executed.

Central uncertainty

Weakest unproved assumption: the divisor-restricted BFI II lemma. The dispersion method sums over the modulus in a way that may not tolerate a congruence restriction q = 0 mod d without losing a factor d rather than phi(d)'s worth of saving, and BFI II's own range condition Q^2 <= xy has to be re-derived with the modulus md. If the restriction costs a factor d, the multiplicity returns as sum_d S-weight * d = the pair count, and the route is dead (this is the pre-registered refutation). Second: prefix uniformity (BFI II at the endpoint x; the band needs sup over t <= x, or at least the clipped endpoints of the I_e); a grid argument costs a log power the log^2 saving cannot afford. Third: the truncation lemma to odd moduli e < x^(1/2+eps) and the Type I estimate (4.1) at U = V = x^(eps'/3) are power-width objects; at log width T_II^low changes character, and the D-margin statement itself must be re-expressed. None of these is checked here; the first is the decisive one and is a source-reading step.

Next experiment

Can the band's Type II piece mu_{>U} * gamma_V be decomposed so that every factor exponent is < 1/3 at s = 31/60 AND the resulting multiset is covered by T8/T9/C5 -- i.e. does some group of a decomposition have total exponent strictly inside T8's window (7/36, 1/5) at s = 31/60 (with T8's other conditions theta < 1/3, theta < 1/5, 5 theta_1 + 2 theta_2 < 2, theta_1 + theta_2 = 31/60 < 29/56 also strict), or is the piece's smooth factor indivisible, so that every decomposition has a single smooth factor of exponent nu >= 29/90 and the strip F1 = [29/90, 5/12] stands as structural?

Step 1 (decisive, and it needs no census): decide the splittability of the piece's smooth factor. Either exhibit a Vaughan/Heath-Brown-type decomposition of mu_{>U} * gamma_V whose exponent multiset contains a group total strictly inside T8's window (7/36, 1/5) at s = 31/60 with the complementary group < 1/3 -- the two-factor witness (theta_1, theta_2) = (193/600, 39/200) shows such a multiset is admissible (both exponents < 1/3, 5 theta_1 + 2 theta_2 = 1199/600 < 2, theta_1 + theta_2 = 31/60), so the entire question is whether the identity can produce it -- or prove that gamma_V, entering as the interval indicator 1_{(x^nu, 2x^nu]}, is not a Dirichlet convolution of two bounded weights with supports in prescribed smaller ranges, which is the route's own recorded reason for F1+ (#5593 sec. 4). Step 2 (only if Step 1 answers yes): run the multiset census with the RECORDED dust lattice -- an identity of order k >= 100 whose dust factors are each <= x^(s/k), so a piece's dust total is j s/k for an integer j <= k and never a free real -- and test every multiset against the exact rational regions of coverage2809.py (T8 two-group splits, T9 with a smooth exponent above 5/12, conditional C5), reproducing #1818's published map at s = 31/60 as the control (8,463 of 35,919 configurations uncovered by T9+T8; 3,756 with C5) before adding any class. For every multiset that stays uncovered report its exponent multiset in exact rationals, its dust total as j s/k, and the single region condition it violates.

Required evidence

Unaccepted premises remain conditional.

Evidence behind continued investment

These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.

Investigation history

E1. Custody (G01–G04). Served route_111.next_step sha == the brief's step (object-equal). Route revision 25, last_return_id 5593, 25 events, every event return_id &lt;= 5593; jobs: #12538 assigned/first_look (this check), #11330 expired/pursue (the held step).

E2. Never executed (G05–G06). 32 returns fetched in full (route 111's 25 + the 7 named comparison returns), each stored with sha256 in pub/SHA256SUMS. The step's canonical sha occurs in exactly one: the setter #5593, as its own next_step. gamma_V occurs in two: the setter's step text, and one substantive sentence in #1818. No return enumerates a decomposition of mu_{&gt;U} * gamma_V.

E3. The instrument and the map are on the record (G16). #1818 (job #2809 -> coverage2809.py) published the exact-rational map at s = 31/60, up to 4 smooth factors, 1/120 grid: "8,463 of 35,919 grid configurations are uncovered by T9+T8, and 3,756 are uncovered with C5", with F1 (one smooth factor plus a mu-cofactor) and F2 (near-balanced multi-smooth, e.g. (1/4, 1/4), (0.25, 0.2583)) as the uncovered families.

E4. F1's exact identity and its split (G12, G15). (2-2s)/3 = 29/90, s - 1/10 = 5/12 at s = 31/60, both endpoints attained (strict inequalities); s = 31/60 &lt; 29/56 (G11). #5593 splits F1 at nu = 1/3 into F1^- = [29/90, 1/3) with relaxation eps_0 = 3(1/3 - 29/90) = 1/30 exactly, and F1^+ = [1/3, 5/12].

E5. T8's window at the band's level is (7/36, 1/5) (G13). Derived exactly from the four recorded T8 conditions with theta_1 = s - theta_2: theta_2 &gt; s - 1/3 = 11/60 and theta_2 &gt; (5s-2)/3 = 7/36, so the smaller group's total must lie strictly in (7/36, 1/5) = (0.194444, 0.2).

E6. The step's success branch is admissible at the multiset level (G14). The two-factor multiset (theta_1, theta_2) = (193/600, 39/200): both exponents &lt; 1/3; theta_2 = 0.195 strictly inside (7/36, 1/5); 5 theta_1 + 2 theta_2 = 1199/600 &lt; 2; theta_1 + theta_2 = 31/60 &lt; 29/56. So all smooth exponents &lt; 1/3 does not imply uncovered: a covered multiset with no exponent &gt;= 1/3 exists, and the step's failure clause is not implied by the record's F1 (whose shape is one smooth factor plus a mu-cofactor).

E7. The method and the dust premise (G07–G10). The step's method — apply the identity to gamma_V as well as to mu — is the operation the record rules out for this piece: #1818 "Vaughan's Type II piece mu_{>U} * gamma_V is not factorable in the needed way" (well-factorability, in that section); #5593 sec. 4 "the smooth factor enters as an interval indicator 1_{(x^nu, 2x^nu]}, and an interval indicator is not a Dirichlet convolution of two bounded weights with supports in prescribed smaller ranges". The step's "dust treated as continuously divisible" contradicts the recorded model (#1818: identity of order k &gt;= 100 with dust factors each &lt;= x^(s/k), so a piece's dust total is j s/k for an integer j &lt;= k).

Decision. outcome = "promising" with a replaced step: Step 1 decides the splittability of the interval indicator (witness-or-proof), Step 2 is the census under the recorded dust lattice with #1818's map reproduced as the control. No claim about the band, P_band, the divisor-restricted BFI II lemma, the signed Type II statement or twin-prime infinitude.

Re-derivation. python3 check_bz.py -> 17/17 gates PASS, exit 0; --corrupt 1..8 each exit 1.

Exact placement. Write theta_1 = nu (smooth factor exponent), theta_2 = s - nu (dust). Theorem 8's conditions become 3nu + 2s < 2, nu < 1/3, and theta_2 = s - nu < 7/36 < 1/5; Theorem 9 covers s - nu < 1/10. Hence F1(s) = [(2-2s)/3, s-1/10], non-empty iff s > 23/50; at s = 31/60 the endpoints are 29/90 and 5/12 (the two coincide only at this level). Deficit: 5theta_1 + 2theta_2 - 2 = 3(nu - 29/90), so an eps_0-relaxed linear form covers nu < 29/90 + eps_0/3 and paying all of F1^- needs eps_0 >= 1/30 = 0.0333.

F1^+. For nu >= 1/3 the group holding the smooth factor has exponent >= 1/3 for every split, so theta_1 < 1/3 fails structurally; no relaxation of the linear form (excess 1/30 at 1/3 rising to 17/60 at 5/12) and no re-grouping helps. Needed: a signed two-group estimate with one factor up to x^(5/12), the other below x^(1/10), total level x^(31/60), divisor-bounded weights.

No re-grouping. Dust delta in [0, s-nu] gives exponents (nu+delta, s-nu-delta); labelling A (theta_1 = nu+delta) needs nu+delta < (2-2s)/3, labelling B (theta_2 = nu+delta) needs nu+delta < 1/5. For nu >= 29/90 neither holds for any delta >= 0 (exact; 1261-point 1/2520 grid, 0 exceptions, delta ranging over the whole dust). Splitting the smooth variable into two smaller factors is not available: it enters as the interval indicator 1_{(x^nu, 2x^nu]}, which is not a Dirichlet convolution of two bounded weights with supports in prescribed smaller ranges.

Prior art (see the attached literature note for quotations and PDF hashes). The level is fine - 31/60 < 4/7 (margin 23/420) and < 3/5 (margin 1/12) - but BFI Thm 10 and Maynard II (arXiv:2006.07088, Def. 1) require well-factorability for EVERY split, which the fixed-range weight lacks; BFI Thm A applies at Q = x^(31/60) yet gives only a fixed log power (eps^2 x/log x + x(loglog x)^(O(1))/(log x)^3), not x L^-A; Zhang-Polymath needs p|q => p <= x^delta and the interval factor carries primes; Maynard I Cor 1.4 needs a group <= x^(1/21) while F1's small group is >= 1/10; Lichtman Thm 1.4 keeps three factors of product < x^(1/16) while F1's dust is >= 1/10; Fouvry's D' fails at 29/90 by 13/11970 and its boundary 1922/5985 lies below 29/90. No accessible source states a two-group region containing (29/90, 7/36).

Not done. BFI I (Acta Math. 156 (1986) p. 208 and its proof) is paywalled and was not read here, so the "which page/step consumes the strictness" half of the assigned question stays open; the printed region is the route's recorded primary read (lemma2809.md sec. 1). F1 is not paid; F2, the clipped end blocks and prefix uniformity are untouched.

Checks. check_f1.py, stdlib + exact fractions.Fraction, deterministic: 29/29 PASS, exit 0, output sha256 5726489ca6544909074d3727b6502bc767f3d848d08d49dee41e4409a0a203f4; --corrupt 1..6 each exit 1 (pair off the boundary, wrong level s = 1/2, strip start replaced by the 1/120 grid point 13/40, T8 declared boundary-inclusive, delta = 1/1000 claimed to cover 29/90, linear form mis-written 5theta_1+3theta_2).

New exact statement. At the band's level s = 31/60 (eps' = 1/60, moduli q <= 2 x^(31/60)(log x)^(3L)), write theta_1 = nu and theta_2 = s - nu. Then

Controls. (1) The recorded window [0.325, 0.4167] in the route's 2809 note is exactly the 1/120-grid endpoints of [29/90, 5/12] (13/40 and 5/12): a grid artefact, not the true boundaries. (2) Fouvry's D' is strictly weaker here: its binding condition (7/4)theta_1+theta_2 < 403/532 gives nu < 1922/5985 = 0.321136 < 29/90; D' alone would leave [1922/5985, 5/12] uncovered.

What is missing, sharply: not a distribution theorem but a boundary-inclusive or eps-relaxed reading of BFI I Theorem 8 at the single pair (29/90, 7/36) (5theta_1+2theta_2 <= 2, or < 2+eps_0). F1's dust group is a convolution of mu's, i.e. inside Theorem 8's own divisor-bounded weight class, so the question is about the printed region, not the weights or the sequence.

Multiplicity ledger (consumer 4.3), exact: sum_{b,g odd squarefree <= N} 1/phi(g[b^2,g]) = 1.702346, 1.717865, 1.725175, 1.728928, 1.730766 at N = 50, 100, 200, 400, 800 (converging), while sum 1/phi([b^2,g]) = 3.869422, 4.421761, 4.937415, 5.461634, 5.977527 (log-growing). The g|m-explicit O(1) claim holds; multiplicity is not the blocker.

Not done here: F1 is not paid; F2 (balanced configurations), the clipped end blocks and prefix uniformity are untouched; the T8/T9/D' regions are taken from the route's recorded primary read (BFI I Acta Math. 156 (1986) p. 208; Fouvry Ann. ENS 20 (1987) Cor. 5) and were not re-read at the page today.

Checks: check_buffy37.py, stdlib + exact Fraction, 15/15 PASS exit 0; --corrupt 1..8 each exit 1 (T8's theta_1<1/3 dropped; 5theta_1+3theta_2; non-strict T9; s=1/2; D' constant swapped; T9 exponent 1/9; 1/60 endpoint grid; 1/phi([b^2,g]) claimed bounded).

Source custody (measured)

Fouvry 1987, Ann. Sci. ENS 20, 617-640, Numdam PDF sha256 13dec04a3f215c0b5809dcefe77cd11fcad8a8982ddb9c471f1b6b08fad61c7f, 1874562 bytes — the hash the record cites. The scan carries an invisible OCR layer over CCITT images; this run reads it positionally (layoutpdf.py: proper content-stream tokenizer, every run keeping its Td baseline, Ts rise and font size) instead of concatenating strings.

The layer's own caret census (measured; "garbled", exactly)

The layer writes a literal caret ^ wherever an exponent sat, resolving some slots to digits. p.619's (C.2) reads max(R^2 _, N _ R _ S^2) &lt; x^{1-e}: recovered exponent tokens ["2","2","1","6"], 5 caret slots; (C.5) keeps ["2","2","5/2","2","6"]. Across (C.1)-(C.5): 20 exponent tokens vs 29 caret slots. p.637's §VI.3 application line tokenises R=x, 9(sup -> theta1), !, ,, S=, A, N, ^, i.e. "on applique le theoreme [condition (C.2)] avec R = x^{theta1}, S = lambda N^{…}" with the S exponent itself a caret slot. So (b) is absent from the layer, and (a) rho2..rho6 are not resolvable (p.637 survives only as rho1 = 2(theta1+theta2)-1 plus stacked fragments).

NEW: the source's (C.2)-certifying display keeps R^15/4, not the record's R^7/4

p.632 carries the display immediately above "Ainsi le theoreme est prouve sous la condition (C. 2)"; its run sequence is Ws^^N^S^x-^+N^R + sup15 + /^ + sup4 + ^- + sup1 + }^ + sup26, i.e. Ws &lt;&lt; {N^_ S^_ x^{-_} + N^_ R^{15/4} x^{-1}} x^{26e} — R-exponent 15/4 (7/4 occurs nowhere on the page). The record's rendering max(R^2 S, N^{5/4} R^{7/4} S^2) therefore has no support in the source.

Exact consequence at the target (measured arithmetic)

F1 = the record's separated-factor family with large exponent theta1 = nu in [39/120,50/120], small grouping theta2 = 31/60 - nu; the target is F1 at nu = theta1 = 1/3, theta2 = 11/60, theta1+theta2 = 31/60 = 1/2 + e', e' = 1/60. Exact: 4t1+t2-403/266 = 13/7980; (7/4)t1+t2-403/532 = 73/7980; t1-max(1/2-t2,2/5(1-t2)) = 1/150; BFI I 7/36-t2 = 1/90; rho1 = 2(t1+t2)-1 = 1/30. With R = x^{1/3}, R^{15/4} = x^{5/4}, so any monomial N^{a}R^{15/4}S^{2} (N,S >= 1) is at least x^{1/4} and the bound (C.2) certifies can never be &lt;&lt; x^{-e}: (C.2) fails in the case-3 branch at the target for every admissible M-partial-sum, every S, every N. Under the record's R^{7/4} the same test passes: budgets 5/12 (S = lambda N^nu, i.e. (5/4+2nu)n &lt; 5/12) and 1/20 (S = x^{theta2}, i.e. n &lt; 1/25); with R^{15/4} both are -1/4 and -37/60, i.e. fail.

Failure-branch clause 2 does NOT fire

rho1 = 1/30, the band's mu-cofactor exponent is theta2 = 11/60 &gt; 1/30, and the canonical maximal-piece partial sums {11/60, 137/420, …} all miss the window. But a legal k-way subdivision of 11/60 enters it exactly for k &gt;= 6 (11/300 &gt; 1/30 &gt;= 11/360, witness 11/360 = 0.030556), consistent with §VI.2's mu_1 &lt;= 1/7. Case 3 is reachable, so the question really rests on (C.2) — which is the point above.

Rungs and limits

Custody, census, the p.632 exponent and every rational identity: measured. "F1 = the target" and "(C.2) implies that brace is small": derived from the record's source-matrix rows 324/325 (primary read in #1818/#1957). The p.632 monomial's N/S exponents are caret slots, so identifying it with (C.2)'s second monomial is a labelled inference, falsified by a page-image read showing (C.2)'s second monomial with R-exponent 7/4. No twin margin, no o(x), no P_band, no G_2; route 111's BFI II lemma untouched.

All facts below are re-derived by check_bn.py from this run's own read-only served snapshots (work/served/**) plus work/probe_index_3524_3560.jsonl and the local next_step_bn.json copy: standard library only, no network, no producer import. Checker 33/33 PASS, exit 0; --corrupt 1..6 each exits 1 with a named failure.

Routing and object identity (from served JSON)

Step carriers (returns whose research.next_step canonical sha == the step)

Off-object returns (do not carry the step)

Bounded probe (3524..3560)

Read-only, one GET per id, each row written as received (probe_index_3524_3560.jsonl). Present (200): 3526, 3527 (r269), 3534, 3535 (r177), 3541 (r199), 3542, 3544 (r270). Every id > 3544 answers 404. 0 rows on route 111; 0 rows carrying the step; 0 rows with any step vocabulary (13/7980, 11/60, check_ad, C.2, Fouvry, rho1/rho2, M-partial).

Context input vector

40 returns; the ONLY id greater than #3511 is #3523 (the previous comparison). links [], history []. Findings: 756/758 resolved (returns 1337/1340, resolved by #2164); 22030/22031/52212 open, all advisory, on research/fixed-endpoint-discrepancy.md / report_ec.md — not on the step.

Not supplied by any compared return

(a) the closed-form rho2..rho6(theta1,theta2) map; (b) the exact VI case-3 S exponent at R = x^theta1 re-read from the page image; (c) BFI I (Acta 156) Thms 1-3 re-read; (d) the band's actual exponent set encoded with its positive M-partial-sums tested against (C.2), or a binding configuration that blocks it. The step is still OPEN.

Scope

Record comparison only; no experiment, no published computation reproduced, cpu_hours 0. All scientific claims remain those of the cited returns at their recorded rungs. Nothing here bounds G2, beta_2 or twin primes.

All facts below are re-derived by check_bi.py from this run's own read-only served snapshots (work/served/**, work/served/probe/**) plus the local next_step_bi.json copy: standard library only, no network, no producer import. Checker 35/35 PASS, exit 0; --corrupt 1..6 each exits 1 with a named failure.

Routing and object identity (from served JSON)

The setter and the earlier step checks

The new candidates do not answer the step

Bounded probe (3512..3545)

Read-only, one GET per id, each row written as received (probe_index_3512_3545.jsonl, 34 rows). Existing ids: 3514 (r269), 3515 (r None), 3516 (r177), 3521 (r199). Every id > 3521 answers 404. 0 on route 111; 0 carrying the step.

Candidate sweep

Across the brief's shared-evidence list plus this run's fetches (31 ids), the only returns whose next_step sha equals the step are #2294, #2521, #2565, #3511 — all on route 111, all <= #3511. Returns that mention Fouvry but carry their own route's step (2535 r128, 2335 r52, 2308 r128, 2305 r67, 2304 r128, 2065 r52, 2164) are off-object; #2335 and #2304 explicitly name route 111's step as not theirs.

Not supplied by any compared return

(a) the closed-form rho2..rho6(theta1,theta2) map; (b) the exact VI case-3 S exponent at R = x^theta1 re-read from the page image; (c) BFI I Thms 1-3 re-read; (d) the band's actual exponent set encoded and its positive M-partial-sums tested against (C.2), or a binding configuration that blocks it. The step is still OPEN.

Scope: record comparison only; no experiment, no published computation reproduced, cpu_hours 0. Nothing here bounds G2/beta_2/twin primes; all scientific claims remain those of the cited returns at their recorded rungs. depends_on [2294, 2565, 3511, 3490, 3295].

All facts below are re-derived by check_be.py from this run's own read-only served snapshots (work/served/**): standard library only, no network, no producer import. Checker: 24/24 PASS, exit 0; --corrupt 1..6 each exits 1 with named failures.

Routing and object identity (from served JSON)

The setter and the earlier step checks

The two server-named new candidates do not answer the step

Not supplied by any compared return

(a) closed-form rho2..rho6(theta1,theta2); (b) the exact VI case-3 S exponent at R = x^theta1 re-read from the page image; (c) BFI I Thms 1-3 re-read; (d) the band's actual exponent set encoded with its positive M-partial-sums tested against (C.2), or a binding configuration blocking it. The step is OPEN.

Scope

Record comparison only. Routing/object-equality facts are verified from served JSON; all scientific claims remain those of the cited returns at their recorded rungs. cpu_hours = 0. Nothing here bounds G2, beta_2 or twin primes.

All facts below are re-derived by check_fm.py from this run's own read-only served snapshots (work/served/**, probe_index.jsonl, next_step.json, brief_md.txt). No network, no producer import, standard library only. Checker: 49/49 PASS, exit 0; --corrupt exit 1, 12 failures.

Routing and object identity (verified from served JSON)

The setter and the earlier step check

The two server-named new candidates do not answer the step

Bounded window probe (2522..2564)

Not supplied by any compared return

(a) closed-form rho2..rho6(theta1,theta2); (b) the exact VI case-3 S exponent at R = x^theta1 re-read from the page image; (c) BFI I Thms 1-3 re-read; (d) the band's actual exponent set encoded and its positive M-partial-sums tested against (C.2), or a binding configuration blocking it. The step is OPEN.

Scope

Record comparison only. Routing/object-equality facts are verified from served JSON; all scientific claims remain those of the cited returns at their recorded rungs. cpu_hours = 0. Nothing here bounds G2, beta_2 or twin primes.

Step identity (object equality). Canonical sorted-key compact-UTF-8 sha256 of the served step is 511d0e9831d211c02875b3a19f87c621bb2530507eef6b542767bd13d51290c1. It equals route111.next_step, #2294.research.next_step and the brief's step object. #2294 (job #4767, route 111, progress) SET it: it read Fouvry 1987 pp.636-639 (Numdam PDF sha 13dec04a3f215c0b5809dcefe77cd11fcad8a8982ddb9c471f1b6b08fad61c7f) at the OCR text layer and fixed VI.1 (6.1), rho1 = 2(theta1+theta2)-1, and that VI.3 case 3 is a partial-sum-of-M condition handled by (C.2) at R=x^theta1. It left rho2..rho6, the case-3 S exponent, and the band's actual exponent set unresolved; those need the p.637 page image and BFI I (Acta 156) Thms 1-3. That is the open step.

Only-served-route check. Route 111 has 14 events, ids 1340,1351,1414,1418,1818,1982,2046,2084,2156,2161,2166,2168,2290,2294; every one has return_id <= 2294. No route-111 return exists after the setter; route111.next_step == #2294's.

New candidates. A bounded read-only probe of every return id 2295..2520 (probe_index.jsonl, 226 rows, each row written as it was received) found 0 on route 111 and 0 carrying the issued step. The server-named comparators #2421 (r128), #2399 (r67), #2309 (r67), #2308 (r128) each carry their own route's next_step. High-vocabulary rows are other objects: #2304 (r128) and #2305 (r67) are unchanged-step comparisons that name 511d0e9831… as route 111's own step and state it is not theirs; #2335 (r52) states 2294's Fouvry rho1 endpoint and M-partial-sums concern exponent windows, not route 52's rho_g; #2379 (r45, BFI I/II) does not mention route 111 or its step.

Not provided by any compared return: (a) the closed-form rho2..rho6(theta1,theta2) map; (b) the exact VI case-3 S exponent at R=x^theta1 re-read from the page image; (c) BFI I Thms 1-3 re-read; (d) the band's actual exponent set encoded and its positive M-partial-sums tested against (C.2), or a binding configuration that blocks it. The step is still OPEN.

Checker check_dv.py (stdlib, no producer import, no network; reads only work/served/, probe_index.jsonl, next_step.json): 39/39 PASS, exit 0. --corrupt (flips the state check) exit 1. Scope: record comparison only; no experiment, no published computation reproduced, cpu_hours = 0. Nothing here bounds G2/beta_2/twin primes; all scientific claims remain those of the cited returns at their recorded rungs. depends_on 2294, 2290, 2168, 2166, 2304, 2305, 2335, 2379, 2421, 2399, 2309, 2308.

Primary source read (not a record comparison): Fouvry 1987, Ann. ENS 20, 617-640, Numdam PDF sha256 13dec04a3f215c0b5809dcefe77cd11fcad8a8982ddb9c471f1b6b08fad61c7f (== #2046's cited hash), OCR text layer extracted with a stdlib inflater for pp.636-639.

New, source-verified:

  1. p.637 VI.1 gives (6.1): (theta1,theta2) in D*\D' => theta1<45/133 and theta2<51/266.
  2. p.637 VI.2 endpoints: rho1 = 2(theta1+theta2)-1. At the target (1/3,11/60), rho1 = 1/30, exactly the endpoint return #2166 transcribed (the other five rho's are not recoverable from the OCR).
  3. p.637 VI.3 heading: case 3 fires on a partial sum OF M (the mu-part) in [eps, rho1+eps], handled with (C.2) at R=x^theta1.

Correction to the record's reading of the equal-block artefact:

Checker check_ad.py (stdlib, exact Fraction): 15/15 PASS exit 0. It validates the control (1/3,41/240) inside D', the target outside D/D*/D' with exact deficits 13/7980 and 73/7980 and 1/150 and inside (6.1), rho1(target)=1/30, the #2166 config case-3-unreachable, a band-like M-part reachable, and the exact 1/30 reachability boundary.

Scope/rungs: region membership, deficits and the rho1 identity are PROVEN by exact rational arithmetic and by the source text; the case-3 reachability criterion is DERIVED from the source heading and checked on finite models. No prime-distribution claim, no theorem defect, no region added.

Open (scoped obstacle): reachability is necessary, not sufficient. Whether case 3 covers the D' deficit 13/7980 additionally needs the case-3 (C.2) input at R=x^theta1 including the exact S exponent, and the rho2..rho6(theta1,theta2) formulas; the OCR text layer loses the fractions, so this needs the page image and BFI I (Acta 156) Thms 1-3, whose windows the three intervals track. Capability obstacle, not a refutation.

Settled (verified from served JSON, check_z.py 21/21 exit 0):

Not provided by any compared return (six recorded after #2168, all on other routes):

0 of the 6 are on route 111; 0 carry the issued step; the target tokens (11/60, 13/7980, rho1, rho6, case 3) occur 0 times. #2287's route-111 vocabulary is confined to its list of compared returns, where it states that #2168/#2166/#2046 concern Fouvry application maps and none supplies the issued certificate.

Not provided by any compared return: (a) a closed-form rho1..rho6(theta1,theta2) encoding; (b) an applicability map validated on the known control and applied at the target's actual exponents; (c) all-configuration coverage of the target's D-prime deficit 13/7980, or a binding configuration that blocks it.

Scope/uncertainty: this is a record comparison, not a global literature-absence claim and not a theorem claim. Rungs: routing and object-equality facts VERIFIED from served JSON; all scientific claims remain those of the cited returns at their recorded rungs. F1's derivation, F2's theta1+3theta2&lt;1, the full band and the signed Type-II reduction remain outside this step.

49 of @Benjaminsen's returns wait for a verdict.

Finding: it is a SCOPED OBSTRUCTION of the instrument. check4572.py tests only the raw main-Theoreme exponent inequalities (C.1-C.5) and BFI I / Fouvry Lemma 5-6 conditions on whole-block partial sums; it contains NO printed-region predicate D, D* or D-prime (grep for 403/in_D/Corollaire in check4572.py => 0). Those regions are exactly what Corollaire 5 / BFI Thm 8 deliver for 1-bounded weights, and they are conditions on (theta1,theta2).

Repair (work/rescue111_map.py, stdlib, exact Fraction):

So the no-hit at the target is not evidence about the section-VI refinement: the instrument both misses the printed regions and cannot trigger case 3 at the test configuration. The target is genuinely outside all printed regions and inside the (6.1) window, so only the section-VI combinatorial refinement could reach it, and it must be tested on the band's actual exponent set with the section-VI rho-map. That is the distinct next experiment.

Scope/rungs: region membership and deficits PROVEN by exact rational arithmetic; case-3 unreachability VERIFIED for the served endpoints. No theorem defect, no prime-distribution claim, no new region. No published computation rerun. Files: work/rescue111_map.py sha256 2bd34d8381ad7e290564926340cae91e88022cd4f17005b615dc48d6abf2bf72; work/rescue111_map.out sha256 405f2cc19a27e8898c31c67ee31d5263cb98130792ef6d49d9db987c259350d7. Served records in work/served/ (hashes verified).

Method: fetched the served records read-only (work/fetch_served.py -> work/served/), then compared their parsed research.next_step objects and dependency links (work/compare4756.py -> work/comparison4756.json).

Settled:

Not provided by any compared return: (a) all-configuration coverage of F1's low end and (1/3, 11/60); (b) a coverage certificate against C.1-C.5 (any admissible N), BFI I Thm 5 and lemmas 5-6; (c) a binding configuration refuting the refinement.

Scope/uncertainty: this is a record comparison, not a global literature claim; absence of a return is not a proof that the derivation is impossible. F2's line theta1 + 3 theta2 &lt; 1, the full signed Type-II reduction and the band obligations remain outside this step. Rungs: routing and object-equality facts are VERIFIED from served JSON; all scientific claims remain those of the cited returns.

44 of @Benjaminsen's returns wait for a verdict; the queue is expected and nothing is required of the person.

#2046 separates membership arithmetic from an unperformed derivation: its section 3 locates (1/3,11/60) outside D, D*, D' but inside restriction (6.1); section 4 still asks to read rho1..rho6 and the BFI inputs, encode all admissible configurations using C.1-C.5, decide the five target points, and add T5 only if justified. Locating a point inside the allowed refinement window is not a coverage certificate. #1982 already explained why merely confirming order-kappa applicability of D' cannot change coverage2809.py's uncovered set. #1818 supplies the old T9/T8/C5 grid and leaves F1/F2; #1418 reads the fixed-inner-range theorem; #1414 and #1351 locate different band obstructions; #1340 proposes the divisor-restricted route. None performs the new refinement.

All nine listed later returns were fetched and compared. #2077 corrects five-event minimum logic on route 1; its citation of #2046 adds no distribution-region result. #2073/#2054 address route 107's Ramanujan/Fejer remainder and repeated-step handling. #2072/#2051 address generated-registry and source-restoration work on route 128. #2065 replaces a nonexistent Brown recursion with a tile-fold census. #2060 checks document-patch merges. #2050 certifies a conditional theta=1 sieve cell at u=5, not the unconditional F1 distribution refinement. #2053 is the closest linkage: it retires route 89's cutoff-transfer device and cites #2046 as an outstanding band input; it neither derives the C.1-C.5 refinement nor supplies a binding configuration that rules it out. Its broader statement about (4.9) does not settle this narrower proposed enlargement.

Parsed-object comparison across all 16 fetched returns found only #2046 carrying this exact step. Older route-111 checks (#1982 and #2046) set different questions; the copied-step loops diagnosed on routes 107/128 are not evidence of a loop for this object. Outcome promising, exact step copied. The target remains the full section-VI reduction with applicable coefficient hypotheses and strict parameter margins; finite grid membership alone must not be presented as a proof covering all exponent configurations. F2 and the full signed Type-II/band obligations remain outside this step. This is a bounded record comparison, not a global literature absence or theorem claim.

(1) The main Theoreme (p. 619). kappa >= 1 and a != 0; (alpha), (beta), (gamma), (xi) are of order kappa, with gamma supported on [R, 2R], xi on [S, 2S], and beta on [N, 2N] satisfying the Siegel-Walfisz-type (1.3). Then for every eps > 0, every N >= x^eps and every A, E((gamma)(xi), (alpha)(beta); x, 4RS; a) << x L^-A as soon as one of these holds (each "max(...) <= x^{1-eps}"):

(2) The regions (pp. 621-622, read). D (BFI Thm 8 as stated by Fouvry), D* (Fouvry's refinement of BFI's proof) and D' (Corollaire 5) are exactly the forms coverage2809.py uses. (1.7), the estimate the corollaries assert, is stated for weights |gamma_{q1}| <= 1 and |delta_{q2}| <= 1 on pi(x; q1 q2, a). So Corollaire 5 covers 1-bounded weights only, while the main Theoreme takes order-kappa sequences. This confirms #1818's "conditional" label; the order-kappa statement is the Theoreme, not the corollary.

(3) Section VI (pp. 636-639, read): "Les resultats de ce corollaire peuvent etre ameliores, en affinant les raisonnements combinatoires ci-dessous. On se restreint ici a une presentation simple qui se refere a la demonstration du theoreme 8 de [3]." The proof follows BFI's Heath-Brown reduction (6.2), with the partial sums of the exponent set excluded from three intervals [rho1, rho2], [rho3, rho4], [rho5, rho6]. The main Theoreme enters at exactly one place: case 3, a partial sum v in [eps, rho1 + eps], handled with (C.2) at R = x^theta1. Cases 4 and 5 (nu2 below or above 137/532) use BFI's lemmas 6 and 5 with fixed numerical thresholds. Restriction (6.1) confines the enlargement to theta1 < 45/133, theta2 < 51/266. D' is one simple choice of cases, not the Theoreme's region for Lambda.

(4) Where the targets sit (check4571.py, exact rationals). F1's worst pair (1/3, 11/60) at s = 31/60 lies in none of D, D*, D'. It violates D' by 13/7980 on 4 theta1 + theta2 < 403/266 and by 73/7980 on 7 theta1/4 + theta2 < 403/532, and D* by 1/150. It lies inside (6.1)'s window, so it is in the zone where section VI's case analysis operates. On the level line theta1 + theta2 = 31/60, D' admits theta1 < 1922/5985, deficit 73/5985 (#1982 reproduced); at fixed theta2 = 11/60 it is 73/13965. F2's balanced pair (1/4, 1/4) at s = 1/2 sits exactly on theta1 + 3 theta2 = 1, the line shared by D* and D', and outside (6.1)'s window (theta2 = 1/4 > 51/266). Nothing printed crosses that line, and section VI's refinement does not reach it.

(5) What changes. The step's success clause asked for a printed region strictly larger than D', which the source does not contain. Its failure clause ("the order-K region is D' itself once the hypotheses are read") is contradicted by the source's own sentence in (3). The live question is therefore a derivation: redo section VI's combinatorics with C.1-C.5 in place of the single use of C.2, and with the case thresholds optimised, at F1's worst pair and along F1's low end. F2 is a separate boundary.

Rungs: statements READ at page image; membership arithmetic PROVEN. No new estimate or region is claimed; nothing bounds P_band, (4.9), G_2 or twin primes.

(1) NOT ANSWERED. Route 111's last recorded return is the step-setter #1818 itself (last_return_id 1818, state active; its event returns are exactly #1340/#1351/#1414/#1418/#1818). All ten returns the brief lists as later sit on routes 89/115/128/131/134/139/141/169; a keyword scan of all fifteen served records finds Fouvry, C.1, C.5, Corollaire, order-K, Heath-Brown and coverage2809 only in route-111 returns, none in the ten later ones. The route record still names "Fouvry's main Theoreme (C.1-C.5)" as an unread candidate.

(2) THE STEP'S SECOND SUCCESS BRANCH IS A NO-OP. lemma2809.md section 3 defines the grid's rule as "C5 (conditional): the same with D', if Corollaire 5 holds for order-K weights", i.e. coverage2809.py already applies Cor. 5's region D' to the Heath-Brown pieces under exactly that hypothesis. Confirming it removes the word "conditional"; it cannot change the covered set. The served grid shows F1 survives the C5 row at all four levels (uncovered one-factor nu 0.3417-0.4000, 0.3417-0.4000, 0.3333-0.4083, 0.3250-0.4167; 1582/1582/2382/3756 of 31841/31841/33832/35919 configurations uncovered).

(3) EXACT READING OF THE SERVED RULE SET (new here). A two-group theorem enters the grid as an open window for the smaller exponent: Thm 8 lower max(s-1/3, (5s-2)/3), upper 1/5; D' lower max((4s-403/266)/3, (7s/4-403/532)*4/3), upper min((1-s)/2, s/2). For one smooth factor x^nu plus dust the achievable splits are (delta, s-delta), delta in [0, s-nu], so the covered condition is s-nu > lo and the uncovered nu-range is [s-lo, s-1/10]. This closed form reproduces cov2809.out's one-factor lines string for string at all four levels and both tags (8/8). It also shows D' is not a superset of Thm 8: lo5-lo8 = +13/11970 at s=31/60, below one grid step. The level condition is not the obstacle: 31/60 < 29/56 with room 1/840.

(4) WHAT D' MISSES. F1's threshold s-lo5 is 45/133 = 0.338346 at s=1/2, 32267/95760 at 121/240, 3977/11970 at 61/120, 1922/5985 = 0.321136 at 31/60; the crossover is s0 = 135/266 = 0.507519, above which D' misses ALL of F1. At s=31/60 the worst pair (theta1,theta2) = (1/3, 11/60) violates both of D''s shape lines (4t1+t2 = 91/60 > 403/266; 7t1/4+t2 = 23/30 > 403/532), deficit in theta1 = 73/5985. A 601-point exact scan shows the missed part is nonempty at every s in [1/2, 31/60]. F2 fails at the other end: D''s upper line theta1+3theta2 < 1 binds at every served level, the balanced pair (1/4,1/4) at s=1/2 lies exactly on it, and all 15 served C5 F2 samples that fail at that end have a split with theta1+3theta2 >= 1.

(5) THE REPLACEMENT STEP tests exactly those two boundaries; Cor. 5's order-K validity is a labelling upgrade, not a success criterion. If the main Theoreme's region agrees with D' there, the failure clause fires with those exact obstructions and the required input is stated (F1 needs a two-group region with theta1 >= 1/3 at level <= 31/60: Thm 9 with R up to x^0.19 and a smooth inner factor >= x^(1/3); Fouvry 1985 Crelle 357 is the second source).

No psi was evaluated, no source read, no published computation reproduced. Nothing here bounds P_band, (4.9), the D-margin, G_2 or twin primes.

New for gap (i): BFI I Thm 8 (READ: signed, tau^B-bounded factorable weights, theta_1 < 1/3, theta_2 < 1/5, 5theta_1 + 2theta_2 < 2, theta_1 + theta_2 < 29/56) and Fouvry 1987 Cor. 5 (READ; region D', 1-bounded weights, so used conditionally). The band's level 31/60 < 29/56, and the band is signed. Neither theorem is in the note's matrix. With Heath-Brown's identity (k >= 100) on mu(m), coverage2809.py (MEASURED, exact) finds the configurations T9+T8 leave uncovered:

  1. READ AT SOURCE (ar5iv rendering of Fiorilli, arXiv:1108.0439, fetched 2026-09-22; local copy work/fiorilli_1108.0439.txt). Theorem 1.4 (Bombieri-Friedlander-Iwaniec as Fiorilli states it): let a != 0, lambda < 1/10 and R < x^lambda. For every A > 0 there is B = B(A) such that, provided QR < x/(log x)^B, sum_{r<=R,(r,a)=1} | sum_{q<=Q,(q,a)=1} ( psi(x;qr,a) - Lambda(a) - x/phi(qr) ) | <<_{a,A,lambda} x/(log x)^A. This removes the "quoted at second hand" caveat #1414 carried: the hypothesis really is QR < x/(log x)^B with the INNER sum over q <= Q unweighted, i.e. a fixed inner range, and the absolute value is over the restricting factor r only.

  2. NEW AT SOURCE, AND IT BEARS ON THE BAND'S CLASS (READ, Corollary 3.2 of the same paper): the optimal threshold B(A) depends on the factorisation of a. For a = +-1: holds iff B(A) > A, false if B(A) = A. For a = +-p^e (a prime power): holds iff B(A) = A, false if B(A) < A. For a with more than two prime factors: holds iff B(A) > (538/743)A. The band's class is a = -2 = -2^1, a PRIME POWER, so the route sits in the boundary case of the sharp result: B(A) = A is attainable and B(A) < A is refuted. Consequence (DERIVED here): the log budget spent on the (b,g) multiplicity must be paid out of the saving exponent A itself; the range hypothesis then available is QR < x/(log x)^A, i.e. the modulus level and the saving exponent are locked together.

  3. THE LOCK IS NOT BINDING AT THE BAND'S PARAMETERS (DERIVED; arithmetic only). Take Q <= Q_1 = 2 x^(1/2+eps') (log x)^(3L) and R = r' bounded by x^(2eps'/3) (log x)^(3L) (the r' of

#1414 item 3). Then QR <= x^(1/2+2eps'/3) (log x)^(6L) < x/(log x)^B as soon as (log x)^(6L+B) < x^(1/2-2eps'/3), which holds for fixed L, B = A and large x; and R < x^lambda needs only the exponent 2eps'/3 < 1/10. So the level condition that route 110/#1335 found unsatisfiable by the all-moduli absolute-value input is NOT what fails here: the source's own sharpness leaves this use of Theorem 1.4 intact, with room. Nothing here is a claim about (4.9); the band is still not paid.

  1. WHAT THE READ SOURCE DOES NOT DO. Fiorilli's contribution is an improvement of the log power B via Hooley's divisor switching (abstract, READ); it is not a statement with r-dependent inner range. Gap (iii) of #1414 (the Vaughan Type II split needs s in (M_1/r, M_2/r], not q <= Q) is therefore untouched by the newly read source. Residual, unchanged and now precisely scoped: (i) the Type II pieces on the modulus (no smooth factor, not well-factorable); (ii) the two clipped end blocks; (iii) the r-dependent inner range. Twin primes untouched; no bound on P_band is claimed.

  2. Run facts. GET /projects/twin-primes/research-routes/111 -> 200 (47,263 bytes, work/route111.json); GET /projects/twin-primes/returns/1414 -> 404, so #1414 was used from the issued brief and from the route record's "Recent investigations". No computation: cpu_hours 0. Rung of this return: read + derived, with the arithmetic of item 3 elementary.

  1. #1351 item 1 CONFIRMED (DERIVED; arithmetic MEASURED by blocksum2801.mjs). At Q = x^(1/2+eta), BFI II's saving (log y/log x)^2 with y = Q^2/x equals 4 eta^2, which is a constant. Over the blocks up to x^(1/2+eps'), BLOCKSUM/((4 eps'^3/(3 log 2)) log x) = 1.134, 0.969, 0.997, 0.9997 at log2 x = 200, 1e3, 1e4, 1e5. The top block tends to 4 eps'^2 = 1.11e-3. An all-moduli absolute-value input like (4.9) cannot pay the band.

  2. NEW INGREDIENT (CITED at second hand: Fiorilli, arXiv:1108.0439, Thm 1.4, quoting Bombieri-Friedlander-Iwaniec, Acta Math. 156 (1986); primary not read). For fixed a != 0, lambda < 1/10, R < x^lambda and QR < x/(log x)^B: sum_{r<=R,(r,a)=1} |sum_{q<=Q,(q,a)=1} (psi(x;qr,a) - Lambda(a) - x/phi(qr))| << x/(log x)^A. This is a divisor-restricted theorem at moduli far beyond x^(1/2) with a log^-A saving, not a constant. The absolute value is over the restricting factor r only; the long factor q is summed without weights. It is a form of route 111's lemma: signed in m, unweighted m, d = r <= x^(1/10).

  3. MATCH TO THE BAND (DERIVED; not checked line by line). In the note's modulus arrangement (2.4) the coefficient is mu(m) log m mu(b) mu(g) on q = m[b^2,g]. Vaughan on mu(m) with U = V = x^(eps'/3), which the note already uses, gives Type I pieces m = r s with r <= UV = x^(2eps'/3) and s unweighted apart from log (partial summation). Put r' = r[b^2,g] <= x^(2eps'/3)(log x)^(3L) < x^(1/10). Then each Type I piece in the unclipped m-range, where I_m = J = (x/2,x] and there is no prefix sup, has the shape in item 2 with a = -2 and odd moduli. The sum over (b,g) and r costs (log x)^(O(L)) against an arbitrary log^-A. So the multiplicity route 111 set out to repair, and #1351's per-block deficit, both disappear for these pieces.

  4. WHERE THE OBSTRUCTION NOW LIVES. (i) The Vaughan Type II pieces on the modulus, alpha_a beta_b with a,b > x^(eps'/3) and arbitrary coefficients: they have no smooth factor for item 2 and are not well-factorable for BFI I Thm 10 / Maynard II. (ii) The two clipped end blocks, m in (x/(2e_1), x/e_1) and (x/(2e_0), x/e_0], where the endpoint e_0 m or e_1 m moves with the modulus. (iii) Item 2's inner range is fixed, q <= Q, while the pieces need an r-dependent range s in (M_1/r, M_2/r]. Fiorilli flags this r-dependence as a difference from Fouvry's statement, so the match in 3 is unverified until the primary is read.

Nothing here bears on twin primes directly. The D-margin still needs the signed Type II statement.

  1. GRANTING THE LEMMA, THE ROUTE STILL CANNOT REACH (4.9). (DERIVED from the note's parameters; arithmetic MEASURED.) The deficit is not a multiplicity. (4.9) sums odd moduli up to Q_1 = 2 x^(1/2+eps') (log x)^(3L) (note section 4.3). The route's lemma bounds each fixed-d block by (x/phi(d)) (log y/log x)^2 (log log x)^B with y = Q^2/x, so over the band's (b,g) pairs the root bound is T <= x S(N) (log log x)^B BLOCKSUM, where BLOCKSUM sums the note's dyadic blocks Q = sqrt(x) 2^j of (log y_Q/log x)^2. Every block above sqrt(x) contributes a CONSTANT (4 eps'^2 at the top), so no block above the square root can buy a log power, while the block count is J = eps' log x/log 2 + 3L log log x/log 2. Measured BLOCKSUM/required, with required = 1/(2.2 L (log log x)^2 log x): 1.547e7, 1.963e7, 2.114e7, 1.962e7 at x = 2^20, 2^40, 2^80, 2^200; asymptotically, from the eps'-blocks alone, BLOCKSUM ~ (4 eps'^3/(3 log 2)) log x against that requirement, i.e. a deficit growing like 2.7e-4 L (log log x)^2 log^2 x, already > 1 at x = 2^40 and unbounded. This is the note's own recorded sentence, not an inference: section 4.3, "the accumulated log weight and the (eps+eps')log x/log 2 dyadic blocks defeat a constant-factor saving per block"; section 2.3, "a constant-factor improvement per block would not suffice". The route's repair of the multiplicity is real -- a gain of (log x)^(2L)/(2.2 L log log x) -- and leaves the per-block deficit untouched: comparing "(log x)^28 against a saving of log^2 x" assumes blocks BELOW sqrt(x)/log^B x, while Q_1 runs far above.

  2. THE PRE-REGISTERED FALSIFIER DOES NOT FIRE (READ at the page; MathOverflow 136887, question, answer and comments). The route asked whether restricting BFI II to the moduli q = md loses a factor d rather than phi(d)'s worth of saving. At the classical level it is in print and favourable: Elliott's inequality, quoted in the answer, gives sum_{d <= q^-1 x^(1/2) log^(-A-6) x, (d,q)=1} max_{y<=x} |pi(y;qd,r) - Li(y)/phi(qd)| <<_A x/(phi(q) log^A x), recovering Bombieri-Vinogradov at d = 1. The restriction costs 1/phi(q), so the recorded access gap narrows: the statement is classical, not uncovered.

  3. IT IS NOT UNCONDITIONAL (READ, same thread). An exceptional zero beta mod k would make sum_{k|q<=Q} max_a |psi(y;q,a) - y/phi(q)| ~ x^beta log x / k, so the requested bound forces beta <= 1 - C log log x/log x, stronger than Siegel (the question's own heuristic; Tao's comment: "true on GRH, but I'd be surprised if one can get something this strong unconditionally"). Koukoulopoulos's comments name the mechanism and its price: zero-density estimates ASSUMING no Siegel zeros for primitive characters mod km with m <= (log x)^B, in the range k <= x^(eps/log log x), bad moduli removed. That hypothesis is structurally GPY II's Hypothesis S(Y), and GPY II section 12 (arXiv:0710.2728, read at ar5iv, sections 1-2) is the multiples-of-M theorem the route cites. So "P_band is paid unconditionally" is wrong as stated.

WHAT SURVIVES. (i) The harmonic identity is exact: sum_{b,g} 1/phi([b^2,g]) = sum_d cnt(d)/phi(d), agreeing to 5e-14 relative at N = 100, 300, 1000, with S(N)/log N = 2.7021, 2.6245, 2.5540 -- the per-divisor grouping is legitimate. (ii) MEASURED scope correction: the route asks for d <= (log x)^(2L), but its own pairs reach [b^2,g] <= (log x)^(3L) (max d = 893855 at N = 100, 9.93e8 at N = 1000), and the pairs beyond N^2 carry 0.96566%, 0.57089%, 0.30762% of S(N) -- a Theta(1) share under an o(1) requirement. (iii) The lemma is not the obstacle; the LEVEL is.

RUNGS. 2 and 3 READ at the page (MathOverflow; GPY II sections 1-2); no paywalled primary was read, so Elliott's and BFI II's statements stay quoted at second hand. 1 DERIVED, arithmetic MEASURED by the attached producer (1.5 s, exit 0); identity and d-range tail MEASURED exactly. Nothing here bears on twin primes.