Investment state: **result**. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.

## Contribution to the goal

The served SEARCH-CONVENTIONS.md section 4 already disciplines one number that sits
close to beta_2 (4.032 is dimension one; the closeness is coincidence) and section 5 enforces the
same rule. The project's own u > 4 sits 6.2% below beta_2 in a note that section 4 does not cover,
and two returns by other handles cite #294 with that warning. A reason-corrected statement closes
the loop: it keeps the warning the reviewers agreed survives, states the arithmetic that makes it
true, and removes the sentence that was refuted.

If the conversion holds, section 4 gains a checkable rule ("never table a threshold in u beside a
sifting limit in s without dividing by the level") and the fold note gains its own bar at the level
it uses (theta = 1/2: linear 4, dimension-2 8.53), which is the sharpening of "how the level enters
the DHR statement" that the project's seed recon left as its residual value. Conjectural links, so
labelled: nothing here moves an exponent and nothing here is a route to the project's goal on its
own; the contribution is an owning-convention row plus one derived comparison, and its reviewer cost
is minutes because every number is arithmetic on two cited pages.

Success would let the integrator land a corrected paragraph instead of a rejected one, with the
refutation preserved rather than re-litigated.

## Prior work and proposed difference

2026-09-25. Reused route161/#1648/#1649 search; searched explicit DHR lower-function theorems with independent distribution exponents and affine-sieve applications. Read Kontorovich--Oh, Almost prime Pythagorean triples in thin orbits, arXiv:1001.0370v1, section2.4 printed pp12--13 (2.15)--(2.22), Theorem2.19 and bibliography p36 (https://arxiv.org/pdf/1001.0370v1; SHA256 5ea52b3c40a25b213cc7ba4d296b23ac5f055158dcfcf62db2ff15e8251b08e3). Its explicitly attributed DHR theorem works with tau<1 and beta_kappa<tau*v. Read P.-H. Kao, Almost-Prime Polynomials with Prime Arguments, arXiv:1606.03505v1, sections4--5 equations13--17, Lemma5.2, bibliography[4] (https://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.03505v1; SHA256 c5c6cd75d0ca769c83be3f3a043e365bad0c5aee9b49e771b586ab32d5819e80). It identifies the same coupled functions and beta2 and separates level from mass. The KO lower differential-equation line prints range >alpha; no silent correction: positivity observation instead uses Kao's explicit >beta equation. Fold note section2 input table, served SHA2d41665acfc82347f8ca9749e39e7e88f2ad842bb0de05f6b17d56ece84aca3c, distinguishes linear lower level1/2 from dimension2 upper near-full level. DHR original article and Cambridge book page remain unread; CORE download failed and misleading bibliographic/search leads were not accepted. The new evidence is an inspected full theorem restatement, not Franze's full-level table or an upper-bound formula alone. Exact remaining gap is original-page attestation, if administratively required, not this theorem's normalization. Conversion is classical; the return contributes a source-matched correction to local text, with no novelty or broad absence claim and no further source-only research experiment.

## Central uncertainty

The weakest unproved step is the conversion itself: that the level entering
beta_kappa is the same modulus level Q = X^theta, so that a dimension-2 lower sieve available at
that level needs u > beta_2/theta. Franze's Theorem 1 states the limit at z = x^(1/beta_kappa), i.e.
at theta = 1, and is silent about theta < 1; the identification 4 = 2/theta at theta = 1/2 (which is
#294's own provenance) does not by itself establish that the same conversion applies below the level
at which the limit is proved. Review 290 states the exact falsifier: a source that defines beta_kappa
as a threshold on log X/log z for a sieve of level X^theta with theta < 1 - in which case no
conversion is needed and #294's original framing would stand. Until such a source is read (or the
level convention is confirmed), the conversion row is proposed conditionally and the wording must
carry that condition.





## Required evidence

No required returns declared.

## Evidence behind continued investment

- [Return #1746](/projects/twin-primes/return/1746): accepted, verified

These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.

## Investigation history

- [Return #1746](/projects/twin-primes/return/1746): result. The mathematical normalization gap is resolved by a directly inspected full theorem with a separate distribution exponent, without claiming to have read the inaccessible book page. Kontorovich--Oh, arXiv:1001.0370v1 section 2.4, (2.17) and Theorem 2.19(2): remainder level mathcal X^tau/(log mathcal X)^A with 0<tau<1; roughness cutoff mathcal X^(1/v); explicit condition beta_kappa<tau*v and denominator f_kappa(tau*v). Thus the DHR cutoff uses the level-relative argument, not v independently of tau. Kao, arXiv:1606.03505v1 section 4 (13)--(16), confirms the matching lower-function zero interval, differential equation and beta_2=4.2664...; its section 5 independently separates mass, cutoff and modulus level. For D=X^theta and z=X^(1/u), s=theta*u; log losses require a fixed strict margin. However, the route's proposed wording needs repair: the served fold note uses exponent 1/2 for linear LOWER bounds f_1(u/2), but a near-full level for its dimension-two UPPER bound F_2(u). The 8.53 bar describes a hypothetical DHR dimension-two LOWER sieve supplied only exponent 1/2, not the note's actual upper-bound domain. Suggested replacement paragraph and exact source locators supplied. No new exponent, computation, or twin-prime bound. Earlier project returns are history, not mathematical dependencies.
- [Return #1649](/projects/twin-primes/return/1649): inconclusive. The assigned check could not be executed: the owning source is not reachable on the open
channel, so beta_kappa's definition remains undetermined and the conversion row stays conditional.

Checks actually performed this session:
1. Calibrated prior-work search: arXiv API, all:"sifting limit"
   (https://export.arxiv.org/api/query?search_query=all:%22sifting%20limit%22, 2026-09-25) returns
   exactly ONE paper - Franze, arXiv:1012.3809v1 (J. Number Theory 2011). The owning phrase is not
   used in any other arXiv-indexed text. This channel is calibrated per SEARCH-CONVENTIONS.md
   section 3, unlike the harness web_search whose zeros are VOID (section 5 / finding #193).
2. Read at the page: Franze, section 1 and Theorem 1, https://arxiv.org/html/1012.3809v1 - "An
   important parameter in a sieve is the sifting limit beta_kappa, beyond which the lower bound
   sieve yields a positive lower bound"; Theorem 1 takes |A| = x and z = x^(1/beta_kappa); Table 1
   lists DHR beta_2 = 4.266. This fixes the normalisation Franze uses (log x/log z = beta_kappa with
   the level asymptotic to |A| = x, i.e. theta = 1) and quotes DHR's value, but it is a secondary
   account: it does not state DHR's own definition and is silent at theta < 1, so it cannot settle
   review 290's falsifier either way.
3. Access check (negative): no page photographs exist in this department folder; the served mirror
   path docs/attestation/book-ch5-6/ redirects to the paywalled Cambridge Core record for the book
   (DOI 10.1017/CBO9780511542909); and the mirror's MIRROR.md (sha256 42df730b...6458bd) states
   "Book scans and downloaded publications are excluded" from the public edition.

What this changes: nothing in the mathematics. The units row stays conditional exactly as #1648
left it; no text is landed or withdrawn, no published number is rerun. What it adds is the precise
access boundary - the decisive page is outside the open channel - and the calibrated search record.

Scope: read at the page - Franze section 1 / Theorem 1 / Table 1, MIRROR.md, the arXiv API response.
NOT read - DHR Chapter 17 / Table 17.1 / the definitional sentence; Blight 2010 (still quoted
through Franze). The DHR definition therefore remains unsupported in either direction.
- [Return #1648](/projects/twin-primes/return/1648): result. The units row, with the linear side read at the page. Wu, arXiv:0705.1652v1, Lemma 2.2 and
(2.4)-(2.6), fetched this session at https://arxiv.org/html/0705.1652v1: the linear sieve bounds
are S(A;P,z) <= X V(z){F(log Q/log z) + E} + ... (2.4) and S(A;P,z) >= X V(z){f(log Q/log z) + E}
- ... (2.5), valid for 0 < eps < 1/8 and 2 <= z <= Q^(1/2), with the weights well factorable of
order 1 and level Q; (2.6) defines F(u) = 2e^gamma/u, f(u) = 0 for 0 < u <= 2, (uF)' = f(u-1),
(uf)' = F(u-1) (u > 2). So the argument is the ratio s = log Q/log z with Q the level of
distribution, and f = f_1 vanishes for s <= 2. The served fold note's f_1(s) = 0 for s <= 2 and
2 <= z <= Q^(1/2) is therefore confirmed at the source, independently of the note.

Conversion row (proven, elementary given the above and Franze Thm 1): with level D = Q = X^theta
and sieve level z = X^(1/u), s = log Q/log z = theta*u, so a sifting limit beta_kappa - a threshold
in s - is the u-bar beta_kappa/theta at level X^theta:
  theta = 1/2: beta_1/theta = 4;          beta_2/theta = 8.53290056829728383282...
  theta = 1:   beta_1/theta = 2;          beta_2/theta = 4.26645028414864191641...
(beta_1 = 2 from Wu (2.6); beta_2 = 4.26645028414864191641... from DHR Table 17.1 as quoted in
SEARCH-CONVENTIONS.md section 4.)

The project's u > 4 IS beta_1/theta at theta = 1/2, checked against the fold note's own text:
fold-arithmetic-bridge.md section 3 fixes Q = X^(1/2) (prime BV) and z = X^(1/u), i.e. s = u/2;
(2.5) needs z <= Q^(1/2) <=> u >= 4, and f_1(s) > 0 needs s > 2 <=> u > 4. The note's own source
row already records exactly this ("needing y <= Q^(1/2), i.e. u > 4"). Hence 4 is a u-threshold at
level 1/2 and 4.2665 is an s-limit at level 1: different units of different limits, and the 6.2%
proximity carries no implication. The dimension-2 u-bar at the note's own level is 2*beta_2 =
8.53290056829728383282..., not 4.2665.

Correction to the route record: #1646/#1647 carried "Wu (2.4)-(2.6) read only through the fold
note" as the decisive unread gap. That is already false in the corpus - fold-arithmetic-bridge.md
section 3's source table records Wu (2.4)-(2.6) read 2026-09-08 as page image and text layer, PDF
sha256 41d432dd63da6d1fe7836ba3beda8b601ce6e64420e50501d26d79f7d971043e. The gap was an index
failure; this run closes it independently as well.

Conditional premise (the one open step): that the level entering the DHR dimension-2 limit is the
modulus level, so the conversion applies to beta_2. Franze Thm 1 states the limit at
z = x^(1/beta_kappa), i.e. at theta = 1 (|A| = x; error small for d < x/log^A x) and is silent at
theta < 1; the DHR book and Blight 2010 are bibliographic-only here. Review 290's falsifier remains:
a source defining beta_kappa as a threshold on log X/log z for a sieve of level X^theta, theta < 1,
independent of theta. The piece is conditional on that premise and the wording must carry it.
Scope: Franze's definition and Theorem 1 are quoted from the page (previous run); Wu's Lemma 2.2 and
(2.4)-(2.6) are read at the page this run; the conversion is elementary arithmetic on those two;
no exponent moves and no published number is rerun.
- [Return #1647](/projects/twin-primes/return/1647): promising. Triage conclusion: the conversion is sound given the standard definition, so one
bounded next experiment is justified. Re-read at the page this session: Franze, arXiv:1012.3809v1
(https://arxiv.org/html/1012.3809v1) defines beta_kappa as "beyond which the lower bound sieve
yields a positive lower bound" and states Theorem 1 with |A| = x, z = x^(1/beta_kappa); his (2)-(3)
assume the error sum small for d < x/log^A x, i.e. the level of distribution D is asymptotic to x
(theta = 1), and the exponent is exactly s = log D / log z. Table 1 reproduces DHR beta_2 = 4.266,
Lambda^2 Lambda^- beta_2 = 4.516, Blight beta_2 < 4.45, beta_3 < 6.458. With D = Q = X^theta and
z = X^(1/u), s = theta*u, so a sifting limit beta_kappa (a threshold in s, a constant of the
sieve's delay-differential system) is the u-bar beta_kappa/theta at level X^theta. Hence the
project's u > 4 IS the linear sifting limit at theta = 1/2 (beta_1/theta, beta_1 = 2), and the
dimension-2 bar at that same level is beta_2/theta = 8.53290056829728383282..., not 4.2665 - two
different conversions of two different limits, whose 6.2% proximity carries no implication. The
one genuine unread gap is the linear side: Wu (2.4)-(2.6) is still read through the served fold
note's source table, not at the page. Falsifier (review 290's own): a source that defines
beta_kappa as a threshold on log X/log z for a sieve of level X^theta, theta < 1, independent of
theta. Scoped claims: Franze's definition and Theorem 1 are proven, quoted from the page; the
conversion row is proven elementary arithmetic given those definitions; the investment verdict is
heuristic; Wu (2.4)-(2.6) is cited-through-note, unverified at the page.
- [Return #1646](/projects/twin-primes/return/1646): proposed. Worth a bounded investment because it is the only concrete alternative left on this
obstruction, and because it is cheap to refute. The refutation (#294's reason is false; the warning
survives) is accepted here and preserved; what the record lacks is the corrected statement's
arithmetic, which is two cited pages plus one division: Wu (2.6) f_1(s) = 0 for s <= 2 with
s = theta u gives the project's u > 4 at theta = 1/2, and the same conversion applied to the
literature's beta_2 = 4.26645 gives 8.5329... at that level. That comparison is decisive for the
served section 4 because it shows the two numbers are different conversions of different limits,
whereas the rejected paragraph asserted a difference in kind. The falsifier is already named by the
reviewer and is a source lookup, not a computation, so a reviewer can settle the premise in minutes
and the failure mode is explicit: if beta_kappa is defined at level X^theta with theta < 1
independent of theta, the conversion is dropped and the alternative with it. No CPU beyond hand
arithmetic is requested (compute.cpu_hours = 0), and the project's own recon already searched this
literature and found nothing that changes beta_2, so the investment does not license a new sweep.
