Connected-cumulant grouping for twin-slot growing moments without prime factorization

Investment state: known. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.

Contribution to the goal

A specific arithmetic input for route143's exact count-object moment dial: group connected CRT correlations before absolute values, permitting cross-prime dependence. If |kappa_j| <= (j!/2) mu (A x^a)^(j-1) uniformly through j~x/log x at h=ceil(x^beta), beta>1+a, the finite-degree derivation in the report gives G2<=ceil(x^beta). a<3.266450284 permits a below-DHR exponent; a<1 is TPC-strength. Neither inequality is established. The new fourth-order small screen supplies a reason to examine signed grouping, not an exponent estimate. It preserves route181/return2247's recorded rank1 obstruction and does not transfer its band-minorant observations to the count object.

Prior work and proposed difference

prior_art_md — route 190's held step (job #8471)

No online search: the step check is answered entirely from the project's own served record, as the brief asks ("decide whether the returns already on record answer it"). Comparison set = the brief's research_context (40 returns) plus route 190, job #8471, held-pursuit job #5035, the adversarial state document and the docs index — 52 records, fetched by content hash into served_bj/.

Route 190's own returns

Returns after #2334 that bear on the step

Adjacent records not bearing on the step

#2247/#2358/#2364/#2559/#3642/#4013 mention Euler products for other objects and #3548/#3609 check other routes; a marker scan of all 52 records (C10) finds the step's three named keys nowhere but in #2334's step text.

Exact remaining gap

The step would screen three named prime-local / block-collision keys for sign mixing at q in {30,210,2310,30030} × h in {7,10,12} against a 300-trial size-matched label-shuffle baseline. The record already holds the baseline method and its outputs at those rungs (#2334, #2370), the exact kappa4/B_abs at the new rungs (#2344, #3044), a same-class candidate screened at the same 12 rungs with 0/12 excess over random (#2344, #2370), the exact sign boundary constraining any such key (#2340, #2344), and two exact lemmas making any key finer than the difference multiset value-constant (#2334, #2370). The unsettled fragment is the three keys as literally written: a re-screen of a closed family at the step's rungs, not a new contribution. The record's own revisit condition is a genuinely sign-mixing partition (strictly below a size-matched control at &gt;= 2 of these rungs) or a direct bound on |kappa4|/B_abs. Hence known, no next_step, no obstacle.

Central uncertainty

H(a,A) is OPEN: uniform bounds on cumulants j=2..2k, k=ceil(4x/((beta-1-a)log x)), h=ceil(x^beta), all sufficiently large prime x and every fixed beta>1+a. Variance is included; repeated offsets/local saturation are retained. Fourth-order small cancellation cannot prove it, fixed-order O_k bounds do not give usable growing-order constants, and cumulants need not factor over primes. The proposed first child only checks a grouping and states its uniform fourth-order remainder target; the parent stays conditional until growing-order bounds are established. No negative association or independence is assumed.

Required evidence

Unaccepted premises remain conditional.

Evidence behind continued investment

These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.

Investigation history

Comparison only. No experiment, no new rung, no producer import, no contributor code run; stdlib, one process. Every fact is re-derived by check_bj.py from this run's own served snapshots in served_bj/ (52 records, HTTP 200, sha256 manifest index_bj.json). check_bj.py 14/14 PASS, exit 0; --corrupt 1..14 each exits 1 with exactly 1 FAIL line naming its own check (check_bj.out.json, check_bj.corrupt_exit.txt; full detail in the uploaded evidence_bj.md).

The record already answers the step

  1. Rungs recorded. #2344 (r192, job #5041) has exact kappa4/B_abs at all 5 new rungs (q=30030 h=7,10,12; q=2310 h=10,12), e.g. q=30030 h=7 -37128321/691176200 / 1746535691079/1659514056200 and h=12 -17427841632/207439257025 / 778902122088/207439257025. #3044 (r209, job #6419) reproduces the q=30030 h=7 and h=12 pairs exactly by an independent path (direct enumeration of n mod 30030, survival masks, superset sums, cumulant of C(n)).
  2. The step's own grid has already been run.#2370 (r192, job #5077) pre-registered 5 translation/ permutation-invariant analytic partitions and ran them at x in {5,7,11,13} × h in {7,10,12} — exactly the step's 12 rungs — with 300 seeded size-matched shuffles: 0/12 sign-mixing, 12/12 sign-separating; observed G in [0.134,1.000] vs shuffle mean [0.015,0.268]. #2344's explicit mod-6-mixing candidate beats its control at 0/12 (mix_beats_rungs=0). #2334's parity/mod 2/3/5/6 and multiplicity-shape groupings are at or above the size-matched mean at every rung. At &gt;= 2 of the step's 4 rungs (at all 12 tested) the step's failure clause fires, and only that clause.
  3. Why the success clause cannot fire. #2370: a shuffle cancels at random while any partition correlated with |K| is coherent, so "beat a label shuffle" is not attainable by an analytic partition and is stricter than a cancellation bound needs.
  4. Predictability. #2340: at x=5 sign(K_x(d)) is exactly a function of d mod 6 (126 classes, 0 mixed, G_6/B_abs=1.0000); 10 mixed classes at q=210/2310 (6.79%/5.70% of B_abs). #2344 extends 0-mixed to h in {10,12}; mixed mass at h=7 is 6.79/5.70/4.81% for q=210/2310/30030, and 4.81/21.23/32.38% at q=30030 for h=7/10/12.
  5. Exact lemmas. K_x depends only on the offset multiset (#2334) and only on the difference multiset (K_x(d+s·1)=K_x(d), proven #2370, 1600/1600 shifts), so finer keys are value-constant; and G is class-relabelling invariant, so the step's "group by the COMPLEMENT of the predicted sign" only exchanges the two classes — a no-op under its natural reading (C12).
  6. Failure branch registered. #2344: obstacle.kind=scoped_obstruction, revisit_when names route 190's open step (this one) or a direct exact bound on |kappa4|/B_abs.

Boundary

The step's three named keys as written — complement-of-predicted-sign grouping; the p=2-only connected term sign; the Euler-product/inclusion-exclusion block-collision decomposition — and per-statistic purity occur in no served record (marker scan: those phrases appear only inside #2334's own step text). They are keys of the class already screened at the step's rungs; hence known, no next_step, no obstacle.

Defect flagged (not repaired)

#2344's printed |kappa4|/B_abs is wrong in 4 of its 5 rows (its fractions are right); the corrected values are in the uploaded evidence_bj.md and report_bj.md, and #2344's "oracle reaches 0.0085–0.0177 at q=30030" is unsupported (true: 0.022375/0.033747/0.051041).

Controls

14 controls: step identity, route state, rung coverage, independent reproduction, the 4/5 defect, the corrections, the already-run grid, the registered failure branch, sign boundary, marker scan, published controls, relabelling invariance of G, oracle range, snapshot integrity.

Result: the child is defeated at finite scale, by its own pre-registered failure clause and by a size-matched control; the route stays open with a changed child.

Evidence (exact Fractions; q=x#, h=7, ordered 4-tuples, convention of return #2324):

What changes: the proposed grouping direction is anti-productive; the object is multiset-symmetric. A useful grouping must be coarser than the multiset and sign-mixing, or |kappa4| must be bounded directly. H(a,A), G2, and exponents remain open and untouched. Rung: finite screening + exact lemma; no asymptotic claim. depends_on: [2324].