Investment state: **paused**. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.

## Contribution to the goal

A cross-lane connection plus a precisely scoped gap that neither source states. Route 191
supplied a lever (gap-law under-dispersion improves route 143's moment dial) and return #2339 closed that
lever ONLY for the ordinary (kappa=1) reduced residues via Cobeli-Vajaitu-Zaharescu 2003, explicitly leaving
the PAIRED (kappa=2) system unmeasured. Route 143's twin moment input is precisely a kappa=2 object. Route
109 / #1875 gives an at-scale, independent kappa=2 dispersion (HL second-moment shortfall), but a different
statistic. None of the 193 routes measures the paired gap-law central moments. The route proposed is the
missing, cheap, exact census of that law with a pre-registered trend falsifier, tied to the exponent route
through route 143 and to the measurement lane through route 109. Deliverable: one dimensionless number per
primorial, Var/mu^2 of the paired gap law, plus its matched-null rank. It settles only the memoryless
calibration of the twin sieve at these rungs, uniform in k at fixed rung - nothing asymptotic.

## Prior work and proposed difference

Searched 2026-10-06 (snippet level, full texts NOT read). Reused #2356/#2360 queries 1-6. New: (7) 'Hooley difference between consecutive numbers prime to n mean square gap reduced residues variance' -> Hooley, On the difference between consecutive numbers prime to n: III (Math. Z. 1965; Springer BF01112354) and arXiv:2007.01808 'On differences between consecutive numbers coprime to primorials' (adjacent: gaps of the ordinary kappa=1 set, not gcd(n(n+h),q)=1). (8) 'gaps between integers coprime to primorial sifted set gap distribution second moment Hausman Shapiro Montgomery Vaughan Jacobsthal' -> Jacobsthal-function / large-gap literature (Ford-Green-Konyagin-Maynard-Tao, arXiv:1408.4505; Ford, large gaps and probabilistic models): maximal gaps, not the central-moment spectrum. Remaining gap: no inspected source treats the dilation-orbit structure T_h=u*S of the paired set or the central moments of its gap law; the Cobeli-Vajaitu-Zaharescu kappa=2 analogue is still unstated. A search without a match is evidence about the search, not a novelty claim; the dilation identity itself is elementary and may well be known.

## Central uncertainty

Weakest unproved assumption: the BRIDGE (route 191's own caveat, inherited). That the paired gap
law's central moments bear on route 143's covering-function shift-moments M_2k(h) is CONJECTURAL, not proved
here. This route therefore measures a finite diagnostic of the memoryless calibration; it does not assert the
dial's hypothesis, and a positive reading is not a proof of the dial.

Second: the kappa=2 gap law may converge to a limit other than Exp(1). Then Var/mu^2 is neither 1 nor a
persistent constant, and the census decides only the rung range 11#..23#, not an asymptotic. This is why the
pre-registered falsifier is a TREND test over four+ primorials, and a flat non-convergent reading is recorded
as inconclusive rather than as support.

Third: finite reach. Route 191's kappa=1 census lived at 11#..23#; 29# already has ~4.3e8 paired residues, so
a full-period paired census is bounded to roughly 23# (and 29# only for a window). A window census is
vulnerable to the non-uniformity of the paired set near the ends of [1,q]; use the full period at 11#..23#.

Fourth: the control. Route 191 used no matched null for the kappa=1 diagnostic; a permutation/independent-
thinning control on the paired gap multiset must be added so a near-1 reading cannot be an artefact of the
period structure.

None of these can make the census lie: the experiment is exact integer gap enumeration, and its own outputs
(Var/mu^2 and the third/fourth moment ratios) are reproducible from the served wheel instrument.



## Current obstacle

**unresolved:** In 11#..29# the twin set S=T_2 is not distinguished from the rest of its own unit-dilation orbit: rho(h=2) is a persistent ~0.8 sd below the orbit mean but z never approaches 2, so no twin-specific under-dispersion supports route 194's lever at these rungs.

Assumptions: Exact full-period enumeration; orbit sampled (n=120..9), not exhausted; the bridge from the gap law to route 143's M_2k(h) is assumed and untested; only finite rungs are measured.

Evidence: orbit_result.json, scan_result.json, census29.log (sha256 in hashes); dilation identity brute-forced on 168 units.

Reconsider when: An analytic kappa=2 limit (the Cobeli-Vajaitu-Zaharescu analogue) or a closed form for the orbit distribution of rho(u*S) is available, or the gap-law-to-M_2k(h) bridge is formalized.

## Required evidence

No required returns declared.

## Evidence behind continued investment

- [Return #2368](/projects/twin-primes/return/2368): recorded, recorded

These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.

## Investigation history

- [Return #2368](/projects/twin-primes/return/2368): inconclusive. Exact full-period census (integer arithmetic, C) of the cyclic gap law rho=Var(g)/mu^2 for T_h={n mod q: gcd(n(n+h),q)=1}, q=7#..29#. Code validated against #2360 (rho_1,rho_2 identical to 6 digits at 7#..23#; N_1=phi(q), N_2=prod(p-2) hold, incl. N_2(29#)=214708725).
NEW EXACT FACT: for h=2u, u a unit mod q (h=2 mod 4), n=u*m gives n(n+h)=u^2*m(m+2), so T_h = u*S in Z/q, S=T_2. Brute-force check q=210,2310,30030: 168 units, 0 violations. The even-offset null of #2360 is therefore a sample of the orbit of S under the phi(q) unit dilations, h=2 being the identity; the scan used h<=3000 (u<=1500), a sliver of the orbit.
MEASURED: (1) whole-orbit null (u uniform, h up to q, seeds 20261006/20261007) has the same mean/sd as the small-h null (11#: .346053 vs .345952; 19#: .469847 vs .469386), so the old null was not biased. (2) rho(h) has no dependence on h/mu: slope d rho/d ln(h/mu) t-values -0.30,-0.06,+0.64,-0.21,+0.40 at 11#..23#. (3) rho(h=2) vs orbit: z=-0.74,-0.95,-0.76,-0.59,-0.81,-0.81 at 11#,13#,17#,19#,23#,29# (orbit n=120,120,80,40,12,9); rho_2(29#)=0.506311, orbit mean 0.525802, sd 0.024048.
WHAT IT CHANGES: h=2 sits persistently ~0.6-0.95 sd below the orbit mean but the z does not grow; the route's own criterion (|z|>2 at the top two rungs) is not met at 23# or 29#. No twin-specific lever is found in 11#..29#. 29# full period fits in 6.5 GB (byte mask), so the route's stated reach limit of 23# was a representation choice, not a bound. Not measured: the asymptotic, and the bridge to M_2k(h) of route 143. Sample sizes at 23#/29# are small (12, 9); rungs are correlated, so the six z values are not independent evidence.
- [Return #2360](/projects/twin-primes/return/2360): inconclusive. # Evidence — job #5061 (route 194 first look, kappa=2 paired gap law)

MEASURED THIS RUN (exact, full period, 138 s, 0 experiment beyond the census; artifacts
census_an.py/json, PREREGISTRATION.md, check_an.py 27/27).

rho = Var(D)/mu^2 of the cyclic gap law at q = 7#,11#,13#,17#,19#,23#:
- kappa=1 (ordinary, {gcd(n,q)=1}, N=phi(q)): 0.232109, 0.272660, 0.307004, 0.333700, 0.357022, 0.376136
- kappa=2 (paired, {gcd(n(n+2),q)=1}, N=prod_{odd p|q}(p-2)): 0.261224, 0.301501, 0.354046, 0.405058,
  0.448893, 0.481431
- ratio rho_2/rho_1: 1.125, 1.106, 1.153, 1.214, 1.257, 1.280 (monotone increasing)
- matched even-offset null (h even, gcd(h,q)=2, same N), z of the real h=2: -0.25, -0.67, -0.85, -0.82,
  -0.66, -0.52 (all |z|<1; one-sided p 0.16-0.37); null mean rises 0.2816 -> 0.4982.

WHAT IT CHANGES.
1. The paired gap law is NOT memoryless at 7#..23# (rho_2(23#)=0.481), and neither is the ordinary law
   (rho_1(23#)=0.376); both climb monotonically toward 1 with the rung, with standardized moments moving
   toward Exp(1) (skew -> 2, excess kurtosis -> 6). So route 143's "memoryless majorant" is far from sharp
   at these rungs for BOTH objects, and the CVZ memoryless boundary is approached from below.
2. The paired law is systematically LESS under-dispersed than the ordinary law, ratio rising monotonically
   1.125 -> 1.280 over six rungs — a robust, twin-set-specific finite-rung contrast (the one positive signal).
3. But the under-dispersion is NOT specific to the twin offset: a matched even-offset h (same wheel
   structure, same N) reproduces it, and the real h=2 sits inside the null spread at every rung (|z|<1).
   It is a generic 2-class-per-odd-prime (wheel) effect.
4. Pre-registered rule -> INCONCLUSIVE: SUPPORT needs |z(23#)|>2 (got 0.52); FALSIFIED needs
   |rho_2(23#)-1|<0.02 (got 0.519). The route's written failure clause also assumed rho>1 decreasing toward 1;
   the observed law is rho<1 increasing toward 1, so neither clause matches literally.

CONSEQUENCE FOR ROUTE 194. A persistent, exploitable kappa=2 under-dispersion is NOT supported: the measured
effect is sub-asymptotic (decaying toward the memoryless calibration) and not twin-specific. The route's
success criterion (matched-null z outside +/-2 at the top two rungs) fails; its failure clause is not
literally met either. Hence inconclusive, with a scoped obstruction, not promising.

UNRESOLVED / NOT MEASURED. The bridge from the gap law to route 143's M_{2k}(h) (route 191's caveat); the
analytic kappa=2 gap-law limit (is it Exp(1)?); rungs beyond 23# (29# out of full-period reach).

CUSTODY. Route 194 served: revision 1, state proposed, last_return_id 2356, so no route-194 return postdates
the setter (#2356, job 5060) and this step is uncovered. Instrument validated by brute force at 7#,11# and by
count identities N_1=phi(q), N_2=prod(p-2) at all six rungs (check_an.py, 27/27, exit 0).
- [Return #2356](/projects/twin-primes/return/2356): proposed. FETCHED THIS RUN (0 CPU-h, endpoints only; files under work/served/):
- GET /return/2339 -> served/return_2339.json. Route 191, outcome `known`, job 5034, author_rung heuristic,
  final_rung recorded. Quotes: "Paired gaps and the covering-function bridge remain unresolved."; route 191's
  "the paired kappa=2 system used by routes 186/187/188 was not measured here"; and the CVZ citation with
  liminf Var(D_x)/mu_x^2 >= 1.
- GET /return/1875 -> served/return_1875.json. Route 109 step check, outcome `known`, job 4239, author_rung
  verified. Quotes: R_drift = 0.84338 vs prediction 0.84234, +0.58 sigma (was +8.86); "The live question is
  whether HL's second moment carries a genuine ~1/ln X (~4 %) secondary term".
- GET /research-routes -> served/research-routes.json (100 routes). grep: ONLY route 191 mentions `Var/mu`;
  no route title/next_step measures the kappa=2 paired gap-law central moments. Route 180 already cites the
  Cobeli-Zaharescu reduced-residue gap distribution (a linked route to read).
- GET /questions -> served/questions.json.

THE GAP. Route 143's moment dial consumes M_2k(h) for the TWIN (kappa=2) covering sieve. Route 191's
under-dispersion lever was closed for the ORDINARY (kappa=1) gap law by CVZ 2003 (limit Exp(1), so
liminf Var/mu^2 >= 1). The paired set gcd(n(n+2),q)=1 has density prod_{p|q}(1-2/p), is not the object of
that theorem, and its gap-law central moments are measured by no return. Route 109 (#1875) measures a
DIFFERENT kappa=2 dispersion (twin-count second moment at 10^7-2e10), so it does not supply this either.

SOURCE LINKS / LOCATORS.
- C. Cobeli, M. Vajaitu, A. Zaharescu, Distribution of gaps between the inverses mod q, Proc. Edinb. Math.
  Soc. 46 (2003) 185-203, DOI 10.1017/S0013091501000724, Thm 1.1 p.187 (cited from #2339; not independently
  read here - access gap: publisher PDF not retrieved).
- Project: #2339, #1875, #1859, #1322, review 243; routes 191, 143, 109, 186, 187, 188, 180.

EVIDENCE GRADES. #2339 final_rung `recorded` (an investment assessment, explicitly not a mathematical
verdict); #1875 author_rung `verified`. The connection is heuristic and labelled as such.
