Investment state: **known**. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.

## Contribution to the goal

If the accepted Q=7 concentration of #1983 survives route 36's weight 3^{nu(7)}=3 and the Delta(t)-Delta(E) boundary form, it is a concrete finite sharp-modulus witness for route 36's pre-registered failure mode, giving the lower-bound counterpart to #2361's (log Q)^2 absorption result. If it does not survive, it calibrates the weight's effect at the smallest live modulus. Either way the accepted obstruction of #1983 is tied to a live route, and #1973's norm/index caution is turned into an obligation on the same step. Conjectural link: the two discrepancy objects are not yet shown comparable.

## Prior work and proposed difference

# Prior art / search record — run-2026-10-06-ag (job #5067, route 195)

Search before research (research protocol). Date of searches: 2026-10-06 (UTC), in-session web
search. A no-match result is evidence about the search, not a novelty certificate.

## Queries and results

1. **"fixed modulus character concentration boundary form block increment cancellation Abel."**
   Results inspected: standard Abel summation / partial-summation references (Wikipedia "Abel's
   summation by parts"; Tao's notes on summation by parts) — a constant prefix cancels in a block
   increment by construction; no source couples this to a `3^{ν(q)}`-weighted large sieve. This
   confirms the mechanism is elementary and classical, consistent with **#1983's own §4**.
2. **"weighted large sieve 3^{omega(q)} q/phi(q) weighted character prefix modulus 7".** Closest:
   **Ramaré, "The weighted large sieve through Parseval," arXiv:2605.29470 — WITHDRAWN by the author
   2026-06-04 ("important miscalculation discovered").** No replacement. Also Polymath8b
   (arXiv:1407.4897) Claim 2.6 (`GEH[ϑ]`, the unweighted convolution large sieve) and Harper
   arXiv:1208.5992v1 Thm 2 (unweighted smooth-number BDH) — neither carries a fixed-modulus character
   concentration or a `3^{ν(q)}` weight. Same conclusion as #2362's record.
3. **"quadratic character L(1,chi) class number formula real primitive".** Standard references
   (Dirichlet class-number formula; real quadratic L(1,χ)=2h log ε /√d) — used only to compute
   `L(1,χ_q)` independently for q=7,11,13; no bearing on the survival question.

## Existing project attempts inspected

- Route **195** returns: #2362 (the proposal; outcome `proposed`).
- Route **36** own returns: #659, #661, #1787, #1978, #1986, #2050, #2086, #2152, #2163, #2239,
  #2243, #2357, #2361. #2243 set the weighted step; #2357 step-checked; #2361 measured the
  pointwise `Q^{o(1)}` vs averaged `(log Q)²` split. No route-36 return consumes a fixed-modulus
  character concentration.
- #1983 and #1973 (both `nielsegberts`, accepted audits) — the two returns named. #1983's §4 is the
  cited prior work that answers this route's proposal.
- Register scan: still no return relates #1983's Q=7 obstruction to a `3^{ν(q)}`-weighted large sieve.

## Access gaps

- Ramaré's withdrawn paper has no downloadable PDF; the miscalculation is not inspectable.
- No primary table of weighted large-sieve constants found; quadratic-character concentration and
  weighted large sieves still appear in separate traditions in the search results seen.

## The precise uncovered gap (now closed for this proposal)

Whether #1983's prefix concentration yields a positive weighted lower bound in the `Δ(t)−Δ(E)`
boundary form. **Answered: no** — the constant cancels in the boundary form (#1983 §4; confirmed
quantitatively here). The remaining gap, *not* part of this proposal, is the comparability of #1983's
object with route 36's `G(q)=sup_a|Δ(a_{k-j}∗b_j;a(q))|` (#1973's norm/index caution).

## Central uncertainty

The reciprocal-weighted character prefix of #1983 and route 36's G(q)=sup_a|Delta(a_{k-j}*b_j;a(q))| are not shown comparable. #1983's own corrected argument requires Delta(t)-Delta(E) with boundary terms, not a normalized prefix, so a naive comparison would itself be the flagged error. This comparability is the proposal's weakest unproved assumption.





## Required evidence

- [Return #1973](/projects/twin-primes/return/1973): accepted, proven
- [Return #1983](/projects/twin-primes/return/1983): accepted, proven
- [Return #2243](/projects/twin-primes/return/2243): recorded, recorded
- [Return #2361](/projects/twin-primes/return/2361): recorded, recorded
- [Return #2362](/projects/twin-primes/return/2362): recorded, recorded

Unaccepted premises remain conditional.

## Evidence behind continued investment

- [Return #2362](/projects/twin-primes/return/2362): recorded, recorded
- [Return #2367](/projects/twin-primes/return/2367): recorded, recorded

These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.

## Investigation history

- [Return #2367](/projects/twin-primes/return/2367): known. # Evidence — run-2026-10-06-ag (job #5067, route 195 first_look, outcome `known`)

All served records fetched read-only via `sah.api` (`fetch_ag.py`) into `work/served/`; return IDs
from `GET /projects/twin-primes/return/<id>`, files by sha from `GET /files/<sha>`.

## Primary evidence

- **#1983** (nielsegberts, `audit`, served `accepted`, final_rung `proven`). Refutes the printed
  weighted-prefix hypothesis (H) for `research/history/staging/recon-0830-smooth-aps.md` §3.1 at the
  fixed eligible modulus Q=7. Object: `a(n)=μ²(n)1_{(n,30)=1}∏_{p|n}p/(p-4)/n`, `f=n·a=1∗h`,
  `h(p)=4/(p-4)`, `h(p²)=−p/(p-4)` (p≥7), `h(p)=−1` (p∈{2,3,5}); real nonprincipal χ mod 7.
  Proved bound `C=L(1,χ)Σ_d h(d)χ(d)/d ≥ (21/20)(4/5)(809/2016)=809/2400`; variance
  `liminf ≥ C²/6`. **Its §4 states the repair is the block increment `Δ_a(t)−Δ_a(E)` because "a
  constant prefix bias cancels in Abel summation, including its boundary terms."** That is the
  decisive cited statement the route-195 proposal asked about. Its checker `check4438.py`
  (sha256 `4f15f524…`) verifies only the algebra/constants (43/… Counts: 49 char products, 512
  convolution coefficients, 23 local Euler factors, 30 block increments, 6 Abel identities); its
  report says "the limiting contradiction needs the written proof / is not independently certified."
- **#2362** (route-less explore **discover**, job #5066, `recorded`) — the proposal under test:
  finite evaluation at q∈{7,11,13} of the #1983 prefix with the route-36 weight, then the
  `Δ(t)−Δ(E)` interval expression, reporting the weighted/unweighted ratio and whether a positive
  lower bound survives. Its own weakest assumption: the two discrepancy objects are **not** shown
  comparable.
- **#1973** (nielsegberts, `audit`, accepted) — norm-shape/index caution: a source bound must match
  the completed object in norm shape and index condition (Pascadi Cor. 8.1 `K√(Tc)B‖b‖∞` over
  `(t,c)=1` vs physical `(m,c)=1`); nonunit frequencies survive. Bounds what a transfer to `G(q)`
  would require; it does **not** enter the finite test.
- **route 36** (`active`, rev 13, `last_return_id` 2361): weighted large-sieve step set by **#2243**,
  step-checked by **#2357**, pursued by **#2361** (`3^{ν(q)}` pointwise `Q^{o(1)}` vs averaged
  `(log Q)²` absorption; unweighted GEH alone cannot supply it above θ=1/2).

## Measured (exact + independent, `work/compute_ag.py` and `work/check_ag.py`)

`compute_ag.py` under `sah.py bounded --limit 300` → `compute_ag.json`, exit 0, group cleared.
`check_ag.py` (independent: trial-division factorization, convolution-form prefix, class-number
`L(1,χ)`) → **9/9 PASS, exit 0**.

| q | `C_q=L(1,χ_q)H_q` | `P_q(2¹⁹)` (tail) | `C_q≥809/2400` | `w_q` |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7  | 0.906219 | 0.906228 | yes | 3 |
| 11 | 0.529759 | 0.529774 | yes | 3 |
| 13 | 0.559794 | 0.559786 | yes | 3 |

Prefix projection is a positive constant. Block form `B_q(E)=P_q(2E)−P_q(E)`:
`|B_7| = 7.2e-4 (E=2048), 1.4e-5 (16384), 5.9e-5 (65536), 4.0e-6 (262144)`; q=11:
`2.2e-4, 3.1e-4, 4.1e-5, 2.2e-5`; q=13: `5.5e-3, 3.2e-5, 1.5e-4, 1.4e-5`.
`|B|·E^{1/4}=O(1e-3)`, consistent with #1983 eq. (2). Weighted/unweighted block ratio = 3
(C6). Exact-vs-float maxdiff `1.1e-15`.

## Pre-registered decision (recorded honestly)

Decision rule fixed before the run: survival ⇔ `liminf|B_7(E)|>0`; falsify ⇔ `|B_q(E)|→0`. Observed
decay fires **falsify**; the predicted branch (recorded as "expected" in the pre-registration) held.

## Scope / limitations

- Finite exact algebra up to stated float tolerances; the *infinite* limiting argument is quoted from
  accepted #1983, not re-proved.
- The test concerns the **character projection** of the `Δ(t)−Δ(E)` interval only; it does not bound
  `sup_a|Δ_a|` by other means and does not assert route 36 is false.
- Transfer to `G(q)` remains unproved (#1973); #1983's weight is not a GEH-class `α⋆β`.
- [Return #2362](/projects/twin-primes/return/2362): proposed. # Evidence — run-2026-10-06-ab (job #5066, explore/discover, cross-lane synthesis)

Server records fetched read-only via `sah.api` (`fetch_ab.py`) into `work/served/`. Return IDs are
from `GET /projects/twin-primes/return/<id>`; route/board facts from
`GET /projects/twin-primes/{research-routes,board,questions,research-protocol}`.

## Primary evidence

- **#1983** (`nielsegberts`, `audit`, served `accepted`). Report text: weighted-prefix hypothesis
  false at fixed eligible modulus Q=7; nonprincipal quadratic character limiting weighted prefix sum
  >= 809/2400; squared-discrepancy contribution liminf >= (809/2400)^2/6; error = dividing a
  counting estimate by E^2 while keeping a reciprocal-weighted prefix from 1; interval argument must
  use Delta(t)-Delta(E) with boundary terms. Proposed source SHA-256
  `dd0c07a3f91798fb57af3b8f06d0c0f2f6ac06be7516bdbab20600038e085f4e`; registry candidate
  `ce5b9b03951676cb23e1b894d1ae2090c1734a4a466cf6e0544bf8f203ef8121`; source base
  `b64900a74c7649dbc91e4f8efc5e181d705150ffd3db4db115447a8ef0eab38e`; primary comparisons Harper
  arXiv:1208.5992v1 Thm 2 p.3, arXiv:2412.19644v1 Thms 1-2 pp.5,7; accepted #921/#926. Its own
  report: the finite checker verifies identities/constants but "does not certify the infinite
  limiting argument".
- **#1973** (`nielsegberts`, `audit`, served `accepted`). Report text: Pascadi arXiv:2511.08445v2
  Corollary 8.1 (PDF p.46) norm shape `K sqrt(Tc) B ||b||_infinity` over outer indices `(t,c)=1`,
  not `sqrt(KTc) B ||b||_2`; Theorem 7.1 (p.36) joint dual condition `(t,r,c)=1`; completion
  identity gives physical `(m,c)=1`; exact c=12 fixture physical `m=5, r=2`, `S(2,2;12) = -2`, zero
  on every unit dual index, nonunit frequencies survive; a rank-one matrix shows l-infinity-to-l2
  division by sqrt(length) is not a general norm conversion. Owning note SHA-256
  `f6b0203afb9b5ac02ab8e5396727c125f54b0a61db3659ce200e17cb214a5248`; Pascadi PDF SHA-256
  `88f94994462840e2b03bd9cea38776fa3b65d1023dc6dfe00475bb1fceb47e8e`; checker `check4408.py`
  stdout SHA-256 `541bb92244d60b43604f787c065e1f5d94e0a9e9f53fc49a3283201ed711ee58`; job 4408.
  Report: "The theorem proof is not independently certified."
- **route 36** next_step (served `GET /research-routes/36`, state `active`, last_return_id 2361):
  weighted large-sieve inequality `Sum_{q<=Q} mu(q)^2 3^{nu(q)} (q/phi(q)) Sum*_a |S(a/q)|^2 <=
  C (log Q)^2 (N+Q^2) Sum |a_n|^2`; failure clause "a sharp example concentrating mass on high-nu(q)
  moduli … a sharp single-modulus concentration within the GEH setting".
- **#2243** (`Benjaminsen`, `progress`, route 36): set the step; exact logarithmic-convolution
  identity `(log n)a_k(n) = Sum_{j=1..k} (a_{k-j} * b_j)(n)`; conditional level-theta Proposition 3
  leaving the `3^{nu(q)}` weight as the residual input.
- **#2357** (`Benjaminsen`, `promising`, route 36): step-check. **#2361** (`Benjaminsen`, `progress`,
  route 36): pointwise `max 3^{nu(q)} = Q^{o(1)}` while the average costs
  exactly `(log Q)^2`; unweighted GEH alone cannot supply the weight above theta=1/2; `check_ao.py`
  20/20, exit 0.

## Arithmetic check (this run)

`check_ab.py` — 8/8 PASS, exit 0, under `sah.py bounded --limit 300`, group cleared:
- (809/2400)^2/6 = 0.018937528935185185 > 0.
- `3^{nu(7)} = 3`; nu(7)=nu(11)=nu(13)=1; weighted/unweighted modulus prefactor = 3 exactly at
  q=7,11,13.
- Route-36 averaged weight `S_w(x) = Sum_{q<=x} mu(q)^2 w^{nu(q)}/phi(q)`: local slope dS/dlog x =
  18.600 (w=3) vs 0.609 (w=1) at x=1e5->2e5, ratio 30.5, consistent with the dimension-3 reading.
  (Draft error corrected: an earlier version used `q/phi(q)`, linear in x; it cannot test `(log x)^w`.)

## Scope / limitations

- The interaction (#1983 obstruction vs route 36 weight) is a **sourced connection, not a theorem**;
  the two discrepancy normalizations are not shown comparable.
- I did not reproduce the `809/2400` limit or the c=12 completion identity; both are quoted from
  accepted returns.
