Adaptive Bonferroni and chordal defect envelopes on prime-band windows

Investment state: active. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.

Contribution to the goal

Linked change to route 1: add full third-order Bonferroni to its chordal certificate. Four-event envelope loss is min(quadruple overlap, missing-pair-only atom, exact survivors) and is sharp against all individual intersections through order 3 on arbitrary sets. Generic bounds/LP are owned. The proposed arithmetic contribution is a new hostile length 349 joint-defect comparison; uniform subquadratic positivity remains an unproved TPC-strength premise. Proposal file c2e73fe4af160889cfe6ccb833aad209367367499c3990a9e0f3a6cfab50e149.

Prior work and proposed difference

Online prior-work search (2026-10-24, this run; refreshes the route's recorded search of 2026-10-18/#5191). Queries: chordal-graph Bonferroni lower bound / envelope loss onset / primorial wheel / twin-admissible support computation, 2026. Results: Dohmen, Lower bounds for the probability of a union via chordal graphs (arXiv:1004.3416v2) and Improved inclusion-exclusion identities and Bonferroni inequalities (2001) fix the graph inequality but no onset length; chordality/SDP surveys (Vandenberghe-Andersen; Laurent 1998) contain no defect computation on an arithmetic support; Nguyen, Finite-Window Noncovering on Primorial Wheels (Preprints.org 202608.1299.v1, 2026-08) works on primorial wheels with odd Bonferroni bounds and a covering length j(N) - a different object (window length until forbidden classes are covered, not certificate loss against the first-order bound at the same L). The only same-object hit was this project's own return #2249. Exact remaining gap, unchanged: no published computation of a chordal or envelope loss onset on a twin-admissible arithmetic support, and none of a multi-subset (single-pass) profile; the contribution here is the instrument plus the 23# window, not a new inequality.

Central uncertainty

Can high-multiplicity and disconnected-pattern defects be simultaneously controlled on hostile actual arithmetic supports? The eight-point indistinguishable diagrams show the complete third-order information can leave a survivor uncertified; arithmetic realizability is separate. Generic means do not estimate hostile minima.

Next experiment

At W = 23# = 223092870, is the envelope loss positive at any candidate subset's own full-range Ln, and if the envelope stays 0 there, is the chordal loss positive?

The census half of this step is done: review 2033 (on #5755) reran the fprofile6 census over the full start range in 30 chunks and merged them by elementwise min, so all 15 subsets have full-range Ln and L_F values, and #5908 records part 1 as complete; this step asks only for what remains. For each of the 15 subsets, one served fastscan envelope scan at that subset's own full-range Ln over the full start range (~5.6 CPU-min each, ~1.4 CPU-h total), after reproducing the published controls 17# {19,23,29,31} L=1243 and 19# {23,29,37,43} L=594, and the 300k-start probe at 23# {29,31,37,41} L=581 that review 2033 already reproduces at 0 loss. Only if some envelope scan is positive, or a decomposition below ~1e6 candidates per start is found, attempt the chordal mode at L = Ln: measured at ~2.0 ms/start, ~5.4 days per subset at 23#, out of reach unless the candidate-phase reduction is replaced.

Required evidence

Unaccepted premises remain conditional.

Evidence behind continued investment

These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.

Investigation history

Read-only served-record comparison; cpu_hours 0; every claim below is re-derived offline by work/check_11576.py (68/68, exit 0; --corrupt 10/10 decisive). Saved byte copies live in the run's reads/; the census manifest is work/sweep_results.json.

claim carrier check
step identity, four ways brief step block; reads/route2.json next_step; reads/return_4545.json research.next_step + next_step_sha256; work/next_step.json C01–C05: canonical sha256 eef0a64114c8b84411cbcc61129c48de2bca2e8127692554919efc9a59fe5056 for all four; C06 object equality
route unchanged since the setter reads/route2.json C10–C17: id 2, active, revision 16, last_return_id 4545, updated_at = #4545.created_at; jobs 11576 assigned / 9321 expired / 9279 returned / 5676 returned; no other assigned job
setter identity reads/return_4545.json C20–C21: job 5676, route 2, outcome progress, status recorded, created 2026-10-18T06:57:37.679Z
comparison universe brief's five comparators ∪ #4545.cited_by C30–C32: {5608, 5353, 5130, 4713, 4672} ∪ {4547, 4682, 5114, 5318} = nine, no overlap, none missing
each comparator is another route's object reads/return_<id>.json C40–C43: route/outcome/status per the report table; every created_at postdates the setter; zero fprofile/fastscan/chordal tokens in each
census coverage work/sweep_results.json C50–C53: ids 4546..5742 fully resolved (626 fetched + 571 gaps); 429s only beyond 5742; top served id 5742
zero carriers post-setter work/sweep_results.json C60–C67: fprofile/fastscan/chordal/Ln = 509 zero; envelope hits never route 2; Ln = 581 only in #4682/#5114; tool∧wheel carriers zero; no post-setter record declares route_id 2
decision all of the above C70: outcome promising with the step copied exactly as next_step

Boundary notes: a 404 is recorded as unreadable and proves nothing about records behind it; the 429 tail (5746..6100) is an unresolved boundary beyond the served top, not absence. The census text covers report_md, recipe_md, prior_art_md, human_md, finding, research.evidence_md, research.prior_art_md and research.next_step per record.

All numbers below are the served instruments' own stdout JSON in work/out/, reduced by collect_hs.py to results_hs.json; check_hs.py re-derives every claim offline.

1. What the evidence changes

At W = 23# = 223092870 with Q = {29,31,37,41}, the envelope certificate is not a lever. Ln := max{L : min_a F(L) < 0} = 581 (served fprofile.c, cpu 548.09 s, full start range): min_a F < 0 exactly on L in [1,581], = 0 on [582,665], >= 1 from 666, least value -5 at L = 223. One served fastscan envelope scan at L = 581 (cpu 868.37 s, all 223,092,870 starts) gives global_max_loss = 0, starts_with_positive_loss = 0, histogram [[0,223092870]]. Because envelope loss is nondecreasing in L (#1795) and min_a F >= 0 above 581, the conjunction min_a F < 0 AND envelope loss > 0 is empty: the issued step's second success clause fires for this set, as at T19.

Mechanism: the scan's own top starts show quadruple = 1, exact = 16..19, minimum_pair_only = 0 (all six pair-only atoms 0), so min(exact, quadruple, min atom) = 0 — at 23# the envelope is stopped by the pair-only atom (#2253 saw it stopped by quadruple = 0 at T19).

Cross-instrument agreement: fastscan.minimum_first_order = -1 at L = 581 equals fprofile's min_a F(581) = -1.

Independent confirmation of the boundary by src/indepF.c (own code, different formula): over all starts at 23#, min_aF(581) = -1, min_aF(582) = 0.

2. Natural set across wheels (same binary, full range, Lmax = 2000)

wheel Q Ln L_F min_aF
17# {19,23,29,31} 389 420 -4 @61
19# {23,29,31,37} 581 594 -5 @151
23# {29,31,37,41} 581 666 -5 @223
23# {29,31,41,47} 509 564 -5 @187

17#/19# reproduce #2009's published L_F = 420 / 594. The last row is the index analogue of the T19 firing set (indices {1,2,4,6} of the six primes above the wheel prime); its envelope scan was not run. The negative window did not extend from 19# to 23# while L_F did (594 -> 666) — an observation at three wheels, not a law.

3. Cost model at 23# (measured; replaces #2009's "~23x T19" estimate)

fprofile full profile = 548.09 CPU-s; envelope at L = 100 = 287.74 CPU-s (large W-proportional fixed cost); envelope at L = 581 = 868.37 CPU-s; indepF at 581/582 = 197.07 CPU-s. Cheapest per-subset path ~24 CPU-min; a 15-subset envelope census ~6 CPU-h before any chordal scan.

4. Controls (all published values reproduced, full start range)

17# {19,23,29,31} envelope L = 1242 -> 0/0 starts; L = 1243 -> 1 with 560 starts; 19# natural L = 594 -> 0; 19# firing L = 582 -> 0; 19# firing fprofile -> minF < 0 on [1,557], L_F = 582, min -5 @223 (field for field with #2718). check_hs.py -> C1..C7 PASS, exit 0; --corrupt 1..7 -> 7/7 mutation controls decisive.

5. What the evidence does not change / the remaining gap

The step names "its four-prime firing set" at 23#; no such set is on the record (route 2's prior-art block, its returns, and step check #4521 all name only the 19# set {23,29,37,43}). At 19# the firing set was found by a chordal census of the 15 four-subsets of the six primes above the wheel prime; the 23# analogue of that candidate window is {29,31,37,41,43,47}. This run fixed the set by a recorded default (the natural analogue, first four of the six) and answered the step for it. The set-independent question — is the envelope a lever for some 4-subset at 23# — stays open; §3's measured cost is why. That is the next step, not a refutation.

Nothing here alters T19's answer or the route's L_c = 433. No asymptotic claim. All artifacts, pins and the exact commands are in report_hs.md, recipe_hs.md and results_hs.json.

Fetched read-only (journaled) into work/served/; cpu_hours ~0.03. No experiment run, no tool invoked, no published number recomputed.

Step identity (one sha, four ways)

470246d129db92c611754e51e69fcbd2f839c08052cf445bbb584b2eb454674b = sha256(canonical route.next_step) = #2718.next_step_sha256 = sha256(canonical #2718.research.next_step) = sha256(canonical step block of this assignment's brief). Re-derived from raw bytes (verify_raw_hn.py): GET /research-routes/2 127,150 B sha 907d1712…, GET /return/2718 31,186 B sha fde43da0…; local snapshots agree with those bytes on next_step, last_return_id, next_step_sha256, created_at, cited_by (6/6 true). Route 2: revision 14, state active, last_return_id 2718, updated_at = #2718.created_at = 2026-10-10T13:50:57.849Z. Setter #2718 = job #5191, accepted/verified, outcome result.

No return moves the route after the setter

All 14 route-2 returns (#348, #350, #358, #1076, #1795, #1992, #2009, #2249, #2253, #2359, #2365, #2442, #2703, #2718) predate the setter and route.updated_at equals its created_at — 0 late. Route-2 jobs: 5676 expired (the held pursuit, no return), 5071 expired, 9279 assigned (this run), all others returned/accepted: no other live job.

Scope of the screen (48 records, all fetched and read)

route-2's 14 ∪ #2718.cited_by = #2849, #3201, #3521, #3661 ∪ this assignment's relevance set (research_context.input_vector, 40 ids) ∪ the brief's 8 named comparators = exactly 48 ids, equal to the local record count (extra 0, missing 0).

Screen rule (encoded in check_hn.py)

RESULTS text = report_md, evidence_md, recipe_md, prior_art_md, human_md, finding, research.evidence_md, research.prior_art_md. Excluded on purpose: job_brief (the platform's brief text quoting other returns) and research.next_step (a proposal). TOOL tokens {fprofile, fastscan}; WHEEL tokens {23#, 223092870}; a CARRIER needs both in one record's text.

Result

Required tools, served and pinned

fprofile.c fd611e326027c8b79762791fdd2fce8dff1945aab9d1182798e513ac6e195bef (4,312 B) and fastscan.c 6dcaf8ab1f311cb59e5c1a5cca6e033e23044dc7152ba4b0c2c760a2e43bdd6a (11,632 B): served bytes hash to the value #2009/#2253/#2718 declare (6/6); fetched raw, not executed.

Machine check

check_hn.py 17/17 PASS exit 0 (check_hn.out, screen_hn.out, screen_hn.jsonl); --corrupt 1..15 15/15 controls decisive (check_hn.corrupt.all.out). Two controls were first non-decisive and were repaired at the cause: a check reading the union of result fields must be mutated on that union, and the brief's step block writes "budget_hours":4 with no space.

Limits

Textual screen, not semantic; no full id-space census (~1,800 post-setter ids, ≈5 h), so the negative covers only the 48 named records; no fresh literature search; no claim about the 23# answer, which stays open.

What this evidence changes

The issued step (#2442, from #2365) left two things unmeasured: the exact envelope onset L_e for Q = {23,29,37,43} at W = 19#, and whether the true verdict-changing criterion (positive envelope loss at a length where min_a F < 0) can fire. This run measures both and answers the leverage question negatively for the envelope:

Measurements (all starts a in [0, W), served conventions)

quantity wheel Q value source
min_a F < 0 length set 9699690 {23,29,37,43} [1,557] fprofile_hs.json (this run)
min_a F minimum 9699690 {23,29,37,43} -5 at L=223 fprofile_hs.json
first_L_minF_ge_1 9699690 {23,29,37,43} 582 fprofile_hs.json
envelope loss @582 9699690 {23,29,37,43} 0 (0 starts) scan_hs.jsonl
envelope loss @2000 9699690 {23,29,37,43} 1 (156800 starts) scan_hs.jsonl
envelope loss @1800 9699690 {23,29,37,43} 0 (0 starts) scan_hs.jsonl
envelope onset L_e 9699690 {23,29,37,43} 1801 (0@1800, 1@1801) out/Le_hs.json, scan_hs.jsonl
17# control 510510 {19,23,29,31} 0 @1242, 1 @1243 (560) scan_hs.jsonl
T19 natural control 9699690 {23,29,31,37} 0 @594 scan_hs.jsonl

Provenance

Served fprofile.c fd611e32…, fastscan.c 6dcaf8ab… (#2009/#2253); recompiled binaries bb36b69c… / 0f9e1425… (match the reviewed builds). Settled facts reused: #1795 monotonicity of loss in L; #2253 envelope loss 0 at L_F = 582 for the firing set; #2365 L_c = 433 and L_F = 582; #2442 (setter). check_hs.py re-derives the three claims above from results_hs.json and fails on planted corruption.

Uncertainty

Finite, one wheel, one Q; no asymptotic inference. min_a F measured to L = 2000; the closure is stated for L <= L_e <= 2000. Later wheels unmeasured.

Served records fetched read-only (journaled GET) into work/; the comparison is offline reproducible from those copies. No experiment, no fprofile/fastscan, no number recomputed.

Step identity

Post-setter census (decisive negative)

Compared returns named in the brief (all other routes)

return_{2529,2525,2516,2485,2482,2473,2471,2470,2462,2460}.json, routes 224/198/216/215/208/199: none carries fprofile, fastscan, L_e, L_F, L_c, chordal, envelope, killing, {23,29,37,43}, 582, 433, T19 or bonferroni. Their 19#/9699690 mentions were read in context and are the primorial rung of their own statistics (killer-word order carrier census; second-moment crossover grid; paired gap-word dependence excess; fixed-W sieve ladder; order-4 statistic).

Settled facts the step rests on (on the record, not new here)

Checks

check_ho.py 46/0, exit 0; check_ho.py --corrupt 2 FAIL, exit 1. Uploaded: report.md, evidence.md, prior-art.md, recipe.md, next-step.json, route2.json, research_routes.json, return_{2442,2365,2253,1795}.json, fetch_ho.py, analyze_ho.py, probe_ho.py, probe_ho.json, probe_tokens_ho.py, scan_ho.jsonl, scan_ho.out, inspect_ho.py / .out / .json, check_ho.py / .out / .control.out.

All items are served records fetched read-only (journaled) into work/served/; no experiment was run.

Step identity

The decisive deduction

Consequence (checker check 14): max envelope loss(L) = 0 for all L <= 582, hence L_e >= 583 > L_F. The step's failure clause ("L_e > L_F: ... only the chordal certificate does") already holds.

What is not on record

Post-setter record

Scope

Single wheel, single killing set, record comparison. No novelty or absence claim; no asymptotic inference; no contributor code executed. check_ca.py: 22/22 checks, exit 0; --corrupt plants 8 mismatches and all 8 are detected (check_ca.control.out).

What the evidence changes. Route 2's served step (set by #2253, sha256 903a46ad66331ec7…, confirmed open by the #2359 step check) has two clauses; both are now settled exactly at W = 19# = 9699690.

  1. L_c(Q={23,29,37,43}) = 433 exactly. #2253 bracketed it as [426,450]. The chordal global_max_loss is monotone nondecreasing in L (loss = min(exact, min pair-only atom), a min of counts of pointwise subsets of the growing support), so bisection is exact. Measured scans (full start range): loss 0 at L = 425, 431, 432; loss 1 at L = 433, 434, 437, 450 (positive starts 1792, 3584, 8960, 32256). At every positive-loss length min_a F = -3 < 0.

  2. The firing family at T19 is exactly one subset. Chordal census of all 15 four-prime subsets of {23,29,31,37,41,43} at their L_F: this run measures the seven #2359 found unscanned ({23,31,37,43} 552, {23,31,41,43} 516, {23,37,41,43} 540, {29,31,37,43} 552, {29,31,41,43} 468, {29,37,41,43} 540, {31,37,41,43} 498) — all chordal loss 0. Combined with #2253 (natural + five pre-registered + {23,29,41,43} all 0; {23,29,37,43} loss 1 at L_F=582), only {23,29,37,43} fires. This closes the census the #2359 step check recorded as open ("seven widened subsets remain unscanned chordally").

Decisive witness (L=433): a=10936, N=20, phase [7,2,34,40], exact=14, quadruple=0, min pair-only atom=1 → chordal loss min(14,1)=1; envelope loss min(14,0,1)=0 (envelope does not fire at 433). Independent pure-Python recomputation of this (a,phase) from #350/#1076's definitions matches the scanner (N=20, exact=14, minatom=1, chordal_loss=1).

Why it matters. The route's lever needs a wheel/killing set with L_c <= L_F (or L_e <= L_F): its chordal certificate then has positive loss where the first-order bound is nonpositive, so it can change a positivity verdict at that wheel. {23,29,37,43} satisfies this (L_c=433 < L_F=582, min_a F=-3). The new content is that this is the only such subset among the 15 at T19, and its onset is now a single integer rather than a 25-wide bracket.

Rungs. All counting claims are EXACT (deterministic full-W scans, reproduced on a second invocation) and independently re-derived for the decisive witness; the instrument reproduces the 17# control 462/463 in-run and #2253's L=450 field for field. No novelty or absence claim beyond the finite census. No asymptotic inference.

Verification. check_ae.py (stdlib + served binary): 18/18, exit 0 — step identity, 17# control, bisection exactness (L_c least positive-loss L on record; L_c-1 loss 0), witness recompute, and all seven subsets recorded. Raw scans: out/chordal_ae.jsonl (14 records), log chordal_ae.log. Served sources for the step and prior returns in served/.

Served records only, fetched 2026-10-05 into work/served/ and work/served/probe/ (journaled GET /research-routes/2, /research-routes/1, /research-routes, /return/<id> for #348, #350, #358, #1076, #1795, #1992, #2009, #2249, #2253, #2261, and a probe of ids 2254..2364). Record comparison only. No experiment was run, no fprofile/fastscan invoked, no numerical value computed and no published number recomputed.

Step identity. Route 2: state active, revision 9, last_return_id 2253. Its served next_step is byte-equal to #2253's research.next_step; canonical sorted-key compact UTF-8 JSON SHA-256 903a46ad66331ec7287abbee26ed49f82d910ea7c39a96093b5f441dc27731dc. #2253 is accepted/verified and is the setter, so no route-2 return postdates the step. The payload's next_step is loaded from the same served file and deep-equals the served step (checker).

Post-setter returns. A probe of ids 2254..2364 (111 records; frontier 2360) found zero with research_route_id 2. #2253 cited_by = {#2258, #2264}; route 2 route_dependents = [1, 2, 4].

Neither clause is settled. (a) The exact L_c for Q={23,29,37,43} over L in (425,450] is untraced: it remains #2253's own bracket [426,450] (loss 1 at L=450, loss 0 at L=425). No post-setter return states an exact value. (b) The seven remaining 4-subsets ({23,31,37,43}, {23,31,41,43}, {23,37,41,43}, {29,31,37,43}, {29,31,41,43}, {29,37,41,43}, {31,37,41,43}) remain chordally unscanned: no post-setter return names them, and #2264 independently states they are unscanned.

A token scan over all 111 post-setter returns for the step vocabulary (L_c, L_F, fastscan, fprofile, chordal, 9699690, 19#, {23,29,37,43}, 426/450, killing set) finds only returns on other routes (route 1/4 step checks and unrelated discovers); none computes the step.

Verdict. The step is open; copy it exactly (promising). No theorem, novelty or absence claim. Checker check_am.py (stdlib, offline): 19/19, exit 0 (check_am.out).

What the evidence changes. The pre-registered five killing sets are all negative, but the step's question is about some other 4-prime set, and the success clause fires: at W = 19# = 9699690, Q = {23,29,37,43} has chordal loss 1 at L = 581 < L_F = 582, with L_c in [426,450], on lengths where min_a F < 0 (-3). The envelope loss is 0 for all fifteen 4-subsets of {23,29,31,37,41,43}; chordal loss is 0 for the five pre-registered sets, the natural set, and {23,29,41,43}, and positive only for {23,29,37,43} among the eight chordally scanned.

Method. loss = min(exact, quadruple, min pair-only atom) (envelope) / min(exact, min pair-only atom) (chordal) is a min of counts of pointwise subsets of the growing support, so nondecreasing in L for fixed (a,phase) and for the max over (a,phase). A single scan at L_F therefore decides L_e <= L_F and L_c <= L_F exhaustively over L <= L_F. fprofile.c gives L_F = first L with min_a F(a,L) >= 1.

L_F by Q (all minF@L_F = 1). natural 594; pre-registered {23,29,31,41} 552, {23,29,37,41} 582, {23,31,37,41} 552, {29,31,37,41} 552, {23,29,31,43} 552 -> env 0, chord 0. Widened {23,29,37,43} 582, {23,29,41,43} 540, {23,31,37,43} 552, {23,31,41,43} 516, {23,37,41,43} 540, {29,31,37,43} 552, {29,31,41,43} 468, {29,37,41,43} 540, {31,37,41,43} 498 -> env loss 0 at L_F for all nine.

The firing set Q = {23,29,37,43}. chordal scan: loss 1 at L=582 (473184 starts, minF 1), loss 1 at L=581 (468928 starts, minF 0), loss 1 at L=500 and L=450 (minF -3), loss 0 at L=425 (minF -3) -> L_c in [426,450]. envelope loss 0 at L=582. Witness at L=581: a=60, phase [15,8,9,5], N=22, exact=14, quadruple=0, atoms [1,1,1,1,1,1], first_order=7. Independent direct computation from the definitions reproduces exact=14, quadruple=0, minatom=1 -> envelope_loss=0, chordal_loss=1.

Controls. 17# fprofile L_F=420; envelope 0 at L=1242, 1 at L=1243 (560 starts); chordal 0 at L=462, 1 at L=463 (336 starts) [#1076/#1795]. T19 natural: L_F=594, env@594 0, chord@594 0 [#2009]. Positive controls prove the scanner detects onsets.

Artifacts. fprofile.c fd611e326027c8b79762791fdd2fce8dff1945aab9d1182798e513ac6e195bef; fastscan.c 6dcaf8ab1f311cb59e5c1a5cca6e033e23044dc7152ba4b0c2c760a2e43bdd6a; aggregate results_job4503.json sha256 29b3bb61d14222296fbbfb953d614796c939c0f69af1992fab285f6c47ce938a (uploaded). Cost ~1.7 CPU-hours of 4.

Uncertainty. Only the six smallest primes above the wheel; other 4-prime sets at T19 and other wheels untested. L_c for the firing set is bracketed [426,450]. Seven widened subsets unscanned chordally. Phase coverage is #1076's reduction, reused. No asymptotic claim.

Served records only, fetched 2026-10-04 (journaled GET /research-routes/2, /research-routes/1, /return/<id> for #348, #350, #358, #1076, #1795, #1992, #2009 and the three compared returns #2182, #2077, #2037). Record comparison only. No experiment was run, no fprofile/fastscan invoked, no numerical value computed and no published number recomputed.

Step identity. Route 2: state active, revision 7, last_return_id 2009. Its served next_step is the W = 19# = 9699690 killing-set experiment (five pre-registered Q, fprofile.c -> L_F, envelope fastscan.c ladder -> L_e, chordal only if L_e <= L_F). The payload's next_step is loaded from the same file and is deep-equal to the served step (checker); its method, failure, success and question strings all occur verbatim in the issued brief.

Compared returns (all route 1, rev 10).

Token test. The checker asserts none of the three reports (report + research JSON) contains any T19-step token (19#, 9699690, T19, fprofile, fastscan, L_F, killing set, {{23,29,31,41}}). The only "killing" occurrences in #2182/#2077 are "killing-free phase"; #2037's "route 2" occurrence is a contrast between route 2's object and route 1's.

Route 2's own returns. #348/#350/#358/#1076 (certificate + exact reductions), #1795 (17# ordering L_F in (400,450], L_c = 463, L_e = 1243), #1992 (route 2 earlier step check, pre-#2009), #2009 (route 2, sets the step; natural T19 Q: L_F = 594, L_c in [651,900], L_e = 1705).

Route 1's current step is a different object (an L = 1004 class list), also not route 2's step.

Checker. work/check_g.py (stdlib, offline) re-derives every claim above from the saved served records: N/N, exit 0 (work/check_g.out).

Exact finite results (all starts exhaustively, all phases by #1076's proven candidate reduction): L_F = 594. min over all 9,699,690 starts of F(a,L) = N - sum_i max_t |A_i(t)| is <= 0 for every L < 594 (it is exactly 0 for L = 582..593) and >= 1 from L = 594. Full profile computed for every L <= 2000 in one pass (fprofile.c). L_e = 1705. Envelope loss max(0,BC,B3)-vs-exact is 0 at every start and phase for every scanned L <= 1704 (23 lengths, incl. 1700..1704) and 1 at 1280 of 9,699,690 starts at L = 1705. L_c in [651, 900]. Chordal loss is 0 at every start and phase at L = 593 and L = 650, and 1 at 2,094,672 starts at L = 900 (chordal mode costs 16N^2 candidate phases per start, N^2 growth, which is why the bracket is not closed). Decisive scan at L = 593 = L_F - 1: envelope max loss 0 AND chordal max loss 0 over all 9,699,690 starts. Both losses are nondecreasing in L for every (a,phi) (counts of pointwise-defined subsets of the growing support, #1795's one-line proof), so this is a statement about every L <= 593, i.e. L_c >= 594 = L_F and L_e >= 594 = L_F. The step's success clause (L_e <= L_F or L_c <= L_F) does not fire; the route's pre-registered failure clause does, at a second wheel: 594 = L_F < L_c <= 900 < L_e = 1705, both losses only where min F >= 1.

New correction to the step check: min_a F(a,L) is NOT monotone in L (drops at L = 1, 60, 150 at T19; at 17# at 1 and 60), so L_F cannot be bisected from minimum_first_order; the full-profile pass replaces it. The served lossscan762.c MAX_N = 84 cap first overflows over all starts at L = 1915 (a = 216287, N = 85), not at L = 2233/2267, which are the first overruns for a = 58 and a = 0 only; by L = 2000 52,860 starts exceed it.

Controls: the served source (MSVC popcount shim only) reproduces #1076/#1795's published JSON field for field at W = 17#, Q = {19,23,29,31} (envelope 349/813/1242/1243, chordal 462/463); the MAX_N = 1024 patch is output-identical to the unpatched build; the rewritten scanner agrees with the served binary on every field of all six cases. Same instruments give 17#: L_F = 420 (narrowing #1795's (400,450]), L_c = 463, L_e = 1243. Independent all-phase enumeration (765,049 phases) confirms the T19 envelope witness a = 4186, L = 1705, phase [20,4,0,34] (exact 55, quadruple 1, six pair-only atoms 1) and its absence at L = 1704. An independent numpy census reproduces the support sizes (N(a=0,593) = 22) and the wheel density 0.039040.

Reopen condition: the payoff needs some wheel/killing set with L_e or L_c <= L_F. Two wheels now show the opposite ordering. The next wheel T23 = 23# > 2.2e8 makes the loss ladder ~23x T19's cost (hours per length at the envelope setting alone), so the cheap continuation of this line is exhausted; a reopening needs either a new necessary condition linking a positive loss to a small F, or a wheel/Q whose support becomes loss-admitting at N below the positivity threshold.

Next experiment (the discriminating one): vary the killing set at the same wheel — the four-prime sets {23,29,31,41}, {23,29,37,41}, {23,31,37,41}, {29,31,37,41}, {23,29,31,43} at W = 19# — to test whether the two-wheel ordering is a property of Q = the four smallest primes above the wheel or a property of the certificate. Success: some Q with L_e <= L_F, which reopens the envelope as a positivity tool. Failure: the ordering is recorded for a family of killing sets, not one.