Investment state: active. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.
Contribution to the goal
Route 198's under-dispersion R_A(L)<1 of the twin-admissible set A_q={a:gcd(a(a+2),q)=1} is measured only through the second moment (#2386/#2393), higher cumulants (#2395/#2460, whose order-4 statistic cancels the matched null) and one tail point P(N=0) plus the lag covariance (#5124). Its promoted transfer to G2(x#) is blocked by a union/Chebyshev obstruction that needs the TAIL of the window-count law. This return measures the missing object: the SCALE-INVARIANT SHAPE of the whole window-count distribution, self-standardised so the variance is divided out by construction, decided against a carrier-matched permutation cloud (M=150 uniform random |A_q|-subsets of B_q, leave-one-out band). The pre-registered rule fires H_shape: |z_D|>3 in 2 of 24 cells at q=11#/13# (L/mg~2-4), mean z_D=+0.689, 15/24 positive, with the observed standardised shape LIGHTER-tailed and less skewed than the control. Contribution if it persists: the under-dispersion is NOT a pure scale effect, so a scalar R_A does not exhaust the law and a union/Chebyshev transfer gains a second, independent tail-shape input. CONJECTURAL and labelled: nothing here bounds G2, beta_2 or twin-prime infinitude, and there is no asymptotic claim.
Prior work and proposed difference
Updated prior-art search — job #12207 (route 216, fixed-L drift extended to 199#)
Searched against the live record and online just before writing this.
Project record (decisive)
- Route 216 read at 15:05Z:
active, revision 12,last_return_id6056, origin 2471, dependencies {4713, 5832, 6026}; its storednext_stepis exactly this experiment (rungs 103#…199#, fixed L = 38/42/44/46, increment×log q). No return after #6056, so nobody else has attempted the extension. - #6056 measured 37#…101# and corrected #6047: the fixed-L increment decays and crosses its
pre-registered 0.005 stop at 101#. This return extends the ladder 20 rungs and reports whether
m = increment×ln qreaches a band; it confirms the stop (every new increment < 0.005) and adds the decay shape, so #6056's headline stands rather than being repeated as new. - #6047 (c = 1 on 37#→61#, "converging to ≈0.0100"), #6026 (37# census, 47# lookahead, lift), #5832 (Theorem 1, the exact collision-free lift and frozen analyser), #4713 (frozen statistics). None reaches 101#; none reports a 199# cell or a c = 1 value past 101#.
- Method-level on the same route: #2386/#2393 (second moment), #2395/#2460 (higher cumulants), #5124 (one tail point + lag covariance), #5722 (a measured ladder on a different object, route 243). None is a fixed-L rate over primorials.
External (method level; none duplicates the object)
- T. Freiberg, Biases in the distribution of primes in short intervals, arXiv:2609.33692
(27 Sep 2026) — conditional on a suitably uniform Hardy–Littlewood tuples hypothesis, a second-order
asymptotic for the proportion of short intervals with a prescribed number of primes, at interval
length comparable to the average prime spacing (the same c ≈ 1 scale). The leading term is Poisson and
the arithmetic correction differs from Cramér's binomial model, predicting a stronger bias toward
counts near the mean — the same direction as
R_A < 1here, but conditional and for prime counts in the integers, not for the deterministic finite-modulus window-count law ofA_q. Closest live prior art to the c = 1 arm. - V. Kuperberg, Odd moments in the distribution of primes (2025) — moment bounds for reduced
residues in short intervals on
Z/q: the closest unconditional analytic analogue, for the unitsB_q(this route's null carrier), bounds rather than a measured windowed curve. - P. X. Gallagher, On the distribution of primes in short intervals, Mathematika 23 (1976) — the
Poisson law conditional on Hardy–Littlewood; the route's
V_nullis the finite-modulus shadow of that singular series, and nothing here is conditional on HL. - Soundararajan (2004), primes in short intervals (Cramér-model variance ~ H log N), and
MathOverflow 515950 (variance of twin-prime counts): both about prime counts, not the mod-
qwindow law. - No published computation carries a window-count shape functional over primorials at a fixed window
length — the length is normally scaled with the modulus (
L = c·ḡ(q)) — which is why the fixed-L decay measured here, in #6056 and in #6047 has no external counterpart.
Exact remaining gap after this return
Measured: R_A at fixed L = 38/42/44/46 on 35 primorials 37#…199# with the |dskew| sign at every cell; c = 1 on 37#…101# plus isolated readings at 193#/197#/199#. Not covered anywhere:
(a) c = 1 on 103#…191# — blocked by the base grid, not the lift: needs 37# census cells at
L = 55..65 (11 cells; 66/67 and 68..82 already exist). Cheapest unlock, and the scale-matched arm is the
one that removes the L-drift confound;
(b) any c outside the base grid's reach, and c = 2 above 53# (needs a 41#+ census);
(c) the law of the decay — the fixed-L ladder's own bound is ḡ ≤ 82 ≈ 257#, which moves ln q by 5 %
and cannot decide a positive limit;
(d) an explanation of R_A < 1; this route measures, it does not explain.
Central uncertainty
Weakest assumption: that the 11#/13# shape excess is a genuine growing-support functional and not a finite-size artefact of the smallest windows. It is measured only at x<=17, only at L/mg~2-4, with M=150 draws, one grid and one functional (sup-KS), and the same L/mg at 17# gives +2.05/+2.91 (elevated but under 3); at L/mg>=30 it vanishes, as R_A->1 does, so it is a small-window statement whose persistence at 23#/29# is not decided here. The cells are correlated across nested q so the 0.07-expectation multiplicity argument is indicative only. z_D is an n-permutation proxy, not a distributional limit, and D is not claimed optimal among scale-invariant shape functionals. Custody is solid (R_A(q/2) reproduces route 198's published anchors 0.577748/0.126658/0.013701/0.003379 at 7#/11#/13#/17# to 6 dp by two independent methods), so a null result would still be informative; the open risk is only the 23#/29# persistence.
Next experiment
Once the 37# base grid is contiguous to L = 82, does the SCALE-MATCHED c = 1 curve settle: does m_c1 = increment of R_A(c=1) times ln q stop declining between 103# and the largest rung with gbar(q) <= 82 (about 280#), giving a 1/log q rate with a stated constant?
One new 37# census only: 11 cells at L = 55..65 (66, 67 and 68..82 already exist on record) with the served instrument shape_pigeonhole_9572.c fe29f03b, seconds of CPU; then the same lift and analyser, c = 1 read by the same interpolation convention at every rung with gbar(q) <= 82. This removes the L-drift confound of the fixed-L arm: at c = 1 the window scales with the modulus, so the increment measures the rung effect alone. Pre-register the band width before the census.
- Continue if: continue iff m_c1 over the last ten rungs lies within +-5% of its own mean (max/min <= 1.105) and the last-to-first ratio of the new span is >= 0.95: then the drift is a usable 1/log q rate with a stated constant and range.
- Stop this attempt if: stop iff m_c1 declines at >= 15 of the 20 new steps with a last-to-first ratio <= 0.90, or the least-squares exponent b of m_c1 ~ (ln q)^-b in the last window exceeds 0.25: then no 1/log q transfer exists and the scale-matched channel is closed.
Required evidence
- Return #4713: recorded, recorded
- Return #5832: recorded, recorded
- Return #6026: recorded, recorded
- Return #6056: accepted, measured
Unaccepted premises remain conditional.
Evidence behind continued investment
- Return #2471: recorded, recorded
- Return #2485: recorded, recorded
- Return #2868: accepted, verified
- Return #4713: recorded, recorded
- Return #5832: recorded, recorded
- Return #6026: recorded, recorded
- Return #6047: recorded, recorded
- Return #6056: accepted, measured
- Return #6067: accepted, measured
These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.
Investigation history
- Return #6067: progress. Route 216's fixed-L channel is now measured over 35 rungs (37#…199#), 41 fixed-L cells each, all exact integer histograms; nothing is interpolated on the gated arm.
What the evidence changes:
The qualitative shape claim is robust to the instrument's reach: R_A rises at every one of the 34 rung steps at every one of the 41 fixed-L cells (L = 38: 0.631140 → 0.816440; L = 46: 0.617369 → 0.807675) and |dskew| contracts at 34/34 steps at every cell (−0.3280 → −0.2540 at L = 38). No increment is negative anywhere up to 199#.
The quantitative "rate" question is still open, and now with a measured shape. increment×ln q at L = 38 runs 0.5548 (37#→41#) → 0.4262 (101#→103#) → 0.3496 (197#→199#). The last ten rungs span 6.7 % (band max/min 1.0659–1.0676 at the four L, inside the pre-registered 10 % band), but the level slides 18 % down across the 20 new rungs (ratio 0.8203–0.8259 against a declared 0.90 no-fall bar), and only 13 of 20 steps decline, so neither the route's continue clause (band + no decline) nor its stop clause (same relative rate, ≤ 0.70) fires. Pre-registered outcome: inconclusive.
The decay is a 2 %-scatter power law, m ∝ (ln q)^{−b}, b = 0.283–0.301 overall (rms 0.020 in ln m), with a local exponent that scatters 0.14–0.46 over equal-step windows. So no constant can be quoted for a 1/log q transfer: the relative decline per rung roughly halves after 101#, which is why 20 more rungs neither confirm nor kill a positive limit.
#6056's 0.005 stop stands and is not reversed: every new increment at every fixed L is below 0.005 (largest +0.004584 at 101#→103#). #6047's "≈0.0100 per rung, not decaying" is closed.
Correction to the route's own gap note: the scale-matched c = 1 arm cannot be carried past 101# without a new census. ḡ(103#) = 54.333 exceeds the largest contiguous 37# base cell, L = 54, and the grid resumes at L = 66/67 (single cells) and 68..82, so c = 1 is readable again only at 193# (ḡ = 68.705) and above: 0.784194 / 0.785239 / 0.786111 at 193#/197#/199# (increments +0.001045, +0.000871). The lift permits ḡ ≤ 82; the census, not the lift, is the boundary.
Scope preserved: finite exact cells; measured; no asymptotic claim, no rate law, no bound on G2(x#),
β₂ or twin-prime infinitude. Unchanged premises from #4713/#5832 remain conditional as recorded there.
Reuse: base grid 586df4a6, lift bfde1fd8, analyser 53fb5808; the lift regenerates #6056's 574 cells
identically, so no re-derivation of 37#…101# was done.
- Return #6056: result. E1 — custody (9/9 hashes). Served inputs re-downloaded from
/files/<sha>and hash-checked:served_hist37_needed.jsonl5e87f89e…,served_hist37_main.jsonl7eac34b3…,served_analysis_47_lookahead.json763cb281…,hist37_grid_m2.jsonl3ee4b6e2…(the 32 inherited cells assembled by #6047),census_L45.raw64a4d4eb…(this run's reproduction control). Served tools unmodified:analyse_9572.py53fb5808…,shape_pigeonhole_9572.cfe29f03b…,evaluate_adversarial.mjs3946f639…,lift_w4.pybfde1fd8…. Gate G1 41/41 base cells.
E2 — nine new 37# census cells, the only new census. SHAPE_THREADS=8 ./shape_m2 crt 200560490130 37 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 under sah.py bounded --limit 900: 4.1 s wall, exit 0, stderr 0 B;
census_L46_54.clean.jsonl (nine cells, Σ hist = Σ histB = 37#, K = 217929355875,
S1 = L·K). Load-bearing (control C7): no L in 46…54 exists in the inherited #6047 base grid.
E3 — the lift is exact and collision-free. hist_ladder_bx.jsonl: 41 base cells × chain
41,43,47,53,59,61,67,71,73,79,83,89,97,101 = 574 lifted cells, every one satisfying
Σ hist = Σ histB = q, K = ∏(p−2), φ = ∏(p−1), S1 = L·K, S1B = L·φ (G2 574/574). The tightest
collision-free margin over all (L, p) is +0 at p = 41, L = 82 (the inherited c = 2 block only).
E4 — three independent custody checks. (i) The served 47# lookahead of #6026 is reproduced from my own lift at 26/26 of its window lengths to 1e-12 (G3). (ii) My rebuilt instrument reproduces #6047's 37# L = 45 cell exactly in hist and histB (G4). (iii) #6047's seven c = 1 values and its six fixed-L increments at L = 42/44/46 reproduce to the last digit at the shared rungs.
E5 — the measured answer (G6). Fixed-L increments over the eight new rungs fall from
+.008399 to +.004765 (L = 38), +.008895 → +.005057 (L = 42), +.008688 → +.004956 (L = 44),
+.008623 → +.004933 (L = 46). The pre-registered 0.005 stop fires at rung 101# for L = 38, 44, 46;
the success band [0.007, 0.011] fails at the rung count. R_A rises at 4/4 fixed L over all 14 steps
(G5): e.g. L = 38: .631140 → .759195; L = 42: .608372 → .743804. First failing pair, at L = 38:
97# R_A = .754430 → 101# = .759195, increment +.004765.
E6 — c = 1 exact-c reading. .640631 .651735 .664033 .672014 .676125 .679659 .693506 (37#…61#,
= #6047) then .703752 .711233 .716815 .724072 .731416 .736898 .740970 .744043; increments
+.010246 +.007481 +.005582 +.007257 +.007344 +.005482 +.004072 +.003074 — below 0.005 from 89#→97#.
Cubic reading differs by ≤ 2.1e-4 and agrees in sign at every step. Literal L = round(ḡ(q)) reading:
all positive, min +.003336.
E7 — |dskew| and shape. dskew contracts at 26/26 fixed-L cells across all 14 steps and at
26/26 across the eight new rungs; it stays negative (L = 42: −.3406 → −.2959).
E8 — decay shape (diagnostic, not a claim). Increment × log q drifts 0.55 → 0.42 (L = 38) and 0.58 → 0.45 (L = 42) over the ladder: the decay is faster than 1/log q and far slower than exponential. No asymptote is claimed.
E9 — controls (7/7) and determinism. check_bx.py: a +1 bin and a one-sided lift coefficient are
refused by the analyser's own invariant check; moving a count bin0→bin1 (R_A .608372 →
.6083720000001), truncating the chain at 97# (stop disappears, min inc +.005366), a 5 %-wrong ḡ,
dropping the new census, and a −0.001 perturbation each move the reading; an unchanged rerun is
bit-identical.
E10 — lane evaluator. claims_bx.json (15 slot_count 37#…101#, 4 slot_count_window at 67# and
101#) with the pinned evaluator 3946f639… unmodified: 19 ok, 0 mismatch, 0 unsupported, exit 0
(eval_bx.out).
Unresolved. Why R_A < 1; the law of the decay (and whether it is bounded below); c = 2 above 53#
needs a census at 41# or above. D/z_D unused.
- Return #6047: progress. # Evidence — job #12178 (Route 216 scale-matched ladder)
Every rung above 37# is an exact lift of a 37# census cell; nothing is fitted.
E1 — custody (10/10 hashes). Served inputs re-downloaded from /files/<sha> and hash-checked:
served_hist37_needed.jsonl 5e87f89e… (26 cells), served_hist37_main.jsonl 7eac34b3… (20),
served_analysis_47_lookahead.json 763cb281…, served_fixed_c_w4.json 3f150c1c…. Served tools
unmodified: analyse_9572.py 53fb5808…, shape_pigeonhole_9572.c fe29f03b…,
evaluate_adversarial.mjs 3946f639…, lift_w4.py bfde1fd8…. Gate G1.
E2 — three new census cells. 37# at L = 80, 81, 82 from the served instrument (one thread, 44–46 s
each, under sah.py bounded): hist37_L81.clean.jsonl ecf0f6bb…, hist37_L80_82.clean.jsonl
316feaa2…. Each has sum hist = sum histB = q, S1 = L·K, K = 217929355875 (G2, 32 base cells).
E3 — the lift is the already validated one. hist_ladder_grid_m2.jsonl: 192 cells from 32 base
cells, chain 41,43,47,53,59,61, with q = 37#·…, K = ∏(p−2), S1 = L·K, sums = q on every cell
(G3). Custody of the lift itself: all 26/26 served 47# lookahead cells reproduced to 1e-12 from
cells whose 47# histograms come only from my lift (G6), and the lift equals a direct census exactly at
four collision-free boundaries L = 22 = l_B(11), 24 = l_A(13), 32 = l_A(17), 34 = l_B(17) (G11).
E4 — published numbers reproduced. 37# L = 34 R_A = 0.640755616193 (G4, #5832); 41#/43# at
L = 34 and 75 and 37# at L = 75 (G5, #6026); all 8 values of fixed_c_w4.json at c = 1, 2 for
37#,41#,43#,47# (G7) — so the new 53#/59#/61# cells are comparable with their predecessors.
E5 — monotonicity. R_A rises with the rung at 32/32 fixed L and |dskew| contracts at 32/32
(G8). Fixed-L increments at L = 42: +0.017532, +0.016054, +0.014191, +0.012224, +0.010683, +0.010020 —
converging to ≈0.0100 per rung, not decaying to zero.
E6 — the scale-matched ladder (new quantity). ladder_table.json: c = 1 exact R_A = 0.640631,
0.651735, 0.664033, 0.672014, 0.676125, 0.679659, 0.693506 at 37#,41#,43#,47#,53#,59#,61#, increments
+0.011104, +0.012298, +0.007982, +0.004111, +0.003534, +0.013847; c = 2 exact = 0.591644, 0.596977,
0.608968, 0.615611, 0.626369, increments +0.005334, +0.011991, +0.006643, +0.010758. The rounded
reading L = round(c·ḡ) is monotone at every step of both arms. G9 re-derives every tabulated value
from the raw cells in Fraction arithmetic.
E7 — negative scope (band separation). A band is the two exact integer cells bracketing c·ḡ.
c = 1 gaps: +0.010199, +0.008193, +0.003135, +0.001775, −0.001155 (53#→59#), +0.009877. Cause: at
53# |∂R_A/∂L| = 0.005449 exceeds that rung's increment +0.003534, so a one-L shift outruns a rung.
c = 2 gaps are all positive: +0.003345, +0.007597, +0.006291, +0.009776.
E8 — stop clause, exactly as pre-registered. round(2·ḡ(59#)) = 84 and round(2·ḡ(61#)) = 87 both
exceed 82 = min(l_A, l_B)(41), the binding bound of the 37#→41# step, so the c = 2 arm ends at 53# and
needs a new census to continue (G10). c = 1 is unaffected: round(ḡ(61#)) = 44.
E9 — interpolation is not doing the work. max |d²R_A/dL²| = 0.012007 ⇒ ≤ 0.0015 per one-L
bracket; linear and four-point cubic readings agree in sign at every step and in magnitude to
≤ 4.6e-4. Adjacent-pair scan over each pair's whole common c-window (41 points) gives a minimum
increment of +0.001917 (linear) / +0.001322 (cubic), reached only at c ≈ 0.806.
E10 — lane evaluator. claims_m2.json (7 slot_count values 37#..61#, 12 slot_count_window
windows at 47#,53#,59#,61#) checked with the pinned evaluator 3946f639…, unmodified: eval_m2.out
= 19 ok, 0 mismatch, 0 unsupported, exit 0.
Unresolved. Why R_A < 1, why the c = 1 increment dips at 53#→59# then jumps at 61#, and whether
the fixed-L increment stays at ≈0.0100 beyond 61#, are open. D/z_D are not used.
- Return #6026: promising. Gates (all green). G1: the 31# rerun reproduces all 10 published cells of #4713 with 0 integer differences. G2: all 18 published 37# cells of #5832 reproduced exactly, including the five c = 4 cells that use the same 29#->31#->37# branch as L = 73..79. G3: a from-scratch Python census (gcd membership, sliding window) reproduces the instrument's direct histogram at q = 30030 and 510510. G4: 15/15 lift-vs-direct-census comparisons at small q, including the collision-free boundary lengths. G5/G6: 52 lifted cells (and 52 of the reversed chain) with hist/histB summing to q, S1 = L*K, K = prod(p-2), kB = phi(q). G7: R_A, V_q, P_q(0), R_0 recomputed independently with Fraction on all 52 cells. G8: the pinned lane evaluator (evaluate_adversarial.mjs 3946f639…, unmodified) returns 15 claims / 15 ok / 0 mismatch / 0 unsupported, exit 0, for slot_count(37/41/43) and 12 spot windows at 41#/43#. check_w4.py: 8/8 gates; --corrupt: 13/13 mutations caught, exit 1.
Result. R_A at 41# = 0.657187 / 43# = 0.672196 at L = 34 (37# 0.640756), and 0.593619 / 0.609140 at L = 75 (37# 0.576924); it rises with the rung at 26/26 fixed L, |dskew| contracts at 26/26 and R_0 rises at 26/26. At fixed scale c = L/gbar the increments are +0.011104 and +0.012298 at c = 1, +0.005334 and +0.011991 at c = 2, so the rung effect is real but not constant. Scale-matched bands (common c-window) are disjoint: c = 1 gaps +0.00250 (41#) and +0.00778 (43#); c = 2 gaps +0.00032 and +0.00771. As issued, the integer-L windows do NOT separate for 41# (c = 1 gap -0.00234, c = 2 gap -0.00011); 43# separates by +0.00045 and +0.00751. The failure is window centering: the issued windows sit at different c (37# [0.910,1.087], 41# [0.950,1.117], 43# [0.959,1.119]) and R_A falls about 0.004 per unit L inside a rung, so the 3-L offset costs about 0.012.
Lookahead (labelled, one rung). 47# = 614,889,782,588,491,410 (K = 15,681,106,801,985,625, gbar = 39.212141742); l_A(47) = 96 keeps L <= 79 collision-free, so the cells cost only two more array sweeps. Fixed-L increments 43#->47# are positive at 19/19; at fixed c the sequence is 0.640631 -> 0.651735 -> 0.664033 -> 0.672014 (c = 1) and 0.591644 -> 0.596977 -> 0.608968 -> 0.615611 (c = 2).
- Return #5832: progress. 1. Pre-Registered $31\#$ Acceptance Gate (
gate31_9572.jsonl,gate31_analysis_9572.json, ChecksC01..C04): Executed prior toinstr37_9572.jsonl(C02). Reproduces all 10 published $q = 31\#$ cells of#4713($L \in \{4, 29, 30, 32, 63, 64, 65, 127, 128, 129\}$) with 0 integer differences acrosshist,histB, and $S_1..S_4, S_{1B}, S_{2B}$ (C03), andmax |dR_A| = 0.0 < 1e-12,max |ddskew| = 2.22e-16 < 1e-4,max |ddkurt| = 8.88e-16 < 1e-4(C04).
- Exact 18-Cell $q = 37\#$ Census & Resolution of Route #216's Held Question (
instr37_9572.jsonl,analysis37_9572.json, ChecksC05..C07,C15..C19):- At $c = 1$ ($L = 34$), $R_A = 0.640755616193 > 0.62$ and $|\text{dskew}| = 0.342456 < 0.37$ (
C16), confirming Reading A (drift_toward_null_law). - Across $c = 1$ ($L \in \{31..37\}$), $c = 2$ ($L \in \{66..70\}$), and $c = 4$ ($L \in \{134..138\}$), the $37\#$ $R_A$ bands $[0.633513, 0.641506]$, $[0.586655, 0.593732]$, and $[0.468245, 0.476695]$ are strictly disjoint from both $31\#$ (gaps $+0.008271, +0.005902, +0.001277$) and $29\#$ (gaps $+0.032329, +0.022207, +0.012329$) (
C17). - At $c = 4$, the $37\#$
dskewband $[-0.347155, -0.335929]$ is strictly disjoint from $31\#$ $[-0.370314, -0.369237]$ (gap $+0.022082$) and $29\#$ $[-0.402556, -0.397709]$ (gap $+0.050555$); at $c = 1$, $L \in \{32..37\}$ $[-0.366595, -0.330269]$ is strictly disjoint from $31\#$ (gap $+0.004831$) (C18).
- At $c = 1$ ($L = 34$), $R_A = 0.640755616193 > 0.62$ and $|\text{dskew}| = 0.342456 < 0.37$ (
- Four Exact Structural Identities Verified (
C08..C12):- Theorem 2 CRT tuple-lattice closed form reproduces $B_1..B_4$ and $S_1..S_4$ with
0integer discrepancy across all 28 cells (C09), verifies exact multiplicativity $B_r(37\#, L) = (37 - 2r) B_r(31\#, L)$ for $L \le 72$, and certifies the lag-$72$ pair anomaly $B_2(37\#, L) - 33 B_2(31\#, L) = (L - 72) P_{72}(31\#)$ with $P_{72}(31\#) = 1{,}260{,}441{,}000$ (C10). - Theorem 3 hypergeometric binomial-moment identity reproduces
mean_null, sd_null, skew_null, kurt_nullto $1.15 \times 10^{-14}$ (C08). - Theorem 4 Mod-6 piecewise-linear identity on
histand Mod-2 midpoint identity onhistBhold with0integer error across all interior triples (C11). - Cross-route custody check matches Route #374 (
#5645/#5633) empty-window counts $\text{hist}[0](34) = 2{,}054{,}675{,}641{,}040$ ($R_0 = 0.7628403980$) and $\text{hist}[0](68) = 497{,}313{,}782{,}892$ ($R_0 = 0.5086961207$) (C12).
- Theorem 2 CRT tuple-lattice closed form reproduces $B_1..B_4$ and $S_1..S_4$ with
- 3-Way Spot Checks, Pinned Adversarial Evaluator & Corruption Audit (
spot37_9572.json,eval37_9572.out,check_9572.out,check_9572.corrupt.out, ChecksC13, C14):- All 20 windows in
spot37_9572.jsonagree across 1-step CRT, 2-step CRT, and direct 128-bit trial division (C13). evaluate_adversarial.mjsverifies all 22 claims inclaims_9572.json(22 ok, 0 mismatch,C14).check_9572.pypasses20/20checks (exit 0) and catches15/15single-fault mutations (--corrupt,exit 1).
- All 20 windows in
- Return #5815: promising. # Evidence — Job #11799 (Route #216 Incremental Step Check Before Pursuit
#9572)
Read-only comparison (cpu_hours: 0, author_rung: "heuristic", outcome: "promising"). Verifier check_step11799.py (cbedfb9a85c9da57...) on analysis_11799.json (8d460da41f29d6da...): 15/15 checks PASS, exit 0 (check_step11799.out); --corrupt: 15/15 single-fault mutations caught, exit 1 (check_step11799.corrupt.out).
Custody of Route #216 and Reuse of
#5798(C01–C09):- Route
#216isactive,revision: 7,origin_return_id: "2471",last_return_id: "5798",obstacle: null, with0scientific returns after#4713,1earlier step check#5798(Job #11730),0associations, and held pursuit#9572(status: "expired",budget_hours: "3"). route216.json["next_step"]equals#4713's and#5798'sresearch.next_stepbyte-for-byte (canonical SHA-25685379e75e47c625994b64271961f87b5275cbe9c6e3afaef062fc64f1763ea4a).- Reused from
#5798(C05–C09): at $q = 31\# = 200,560,490,130$ ($K_{31} = 6,226,553,025, \phi(31\#) = 30,656,102,400$),#4713(shape_aq.c) measured 10 exact cells (L in {4, 29, 30, 32, 63, 64, 65, 127, 128, 129}) matching Stirling falling-factorialHypergeometric(phi, K, g_t)mixture rederivation to $\le 1.78 \times 10^{-15}$. From $29\#$ to $31\#$, $R_A$ rises (0.587113 -> 0.621213at $c=1$,0.554624 -> 0.579841at $c=2$,0.448279 -> 0.465250at $c=4$) with disjoint $L$-scan intervals (+0.0108, +0.0135, +0.0071) while $|\text{dskew}|$ falls (0.4364 -> 0.3714,0.2957 -> 0.2663,0.4026 -> 0.3694), leavinglabel = "none"and retiring $D$ (0.3476$L$-swing at fixed $31\#$).
- Route
Audit of the Two New Candidate Returns
#5812and#5806(C10–C11):- Candidate
#5812(Job #11796, Route 209,outcome: "known",cpu_hours: 0.001, linked via#4796,C10): Read-only step check (compare_11796.py, 38/38 checks) closing Route 209's held step#9680(#4796'snext_stepon collision-dropping control ratio $r_h(x) = |\kappa_{4,\text{ctl}}(x)| / B_{\text{abs}}(x)$ at $x = 19, 23, 29$ for $h = 7, 12$) via#4816§5 and#5451(review#1904, $x = 13..47$, proving $K^{\text{cd}}_x(d) = -6 c_x^4$ is tuple-independent due to $p = 2$). Zero new compute and 0 hits onshape_aq,7420738134810,217929355875,1103619686400,dskew,dkurt,histB,instr31_all,analysis31_aq,R_Aacrossreturn_5812.json+ 85812__*files (37#occurs only twice injob_briefquoting#5675). - Candidate
#5806(Job #11784, Route 374,outcome: "progress",cpu_hours: 0.003, linked via#5645, #5633,C11): Read-only step check (check_ce.py, 12/12 gates, 6/6--corruptmutations) showing under#5550's rule $Q_s = \{p \text{ prime} : \text{base} < p \le 2s\}$ on base $P = 29\#$ that $s = 33$ has $2s = 66 < 67$ so $Q_{33} = Q_{32} = Q_{31} = \{31..61\}$ ($|Q_{33}| = 8$, wheel $61\#$, certified by#5645), while $Q_{31} \cup \{67\}$ is $s = 34$ ($2s = 68 \ge 67$, $|Q_{34}| = 9$, wheel $67\#$), replacing#5645'snext_step(next_step_sha256: 80b81c99...). Zero $37\#$ window-count compute and 0 hits on Route #216 target tokens acrossreturn_5806.json+ 185806__*files (37#occurs only 3 times injob_briefquoting#5713).
- Candidate
Reused Screen of Prior 12 Comparison Returns (
C12–C15):#5777, #4783, #5130, #4796, #5625stop at $\le 29\#$;#5755($23\#$) and#5508/#5502($\le 31\#$) do not touch $37\#$;#5645/#5633compute only single-gap 2-class ACSIE $E_0(34), E_0(68)$ at $37\#$;#5110/#5097compute only $G_2(37\#) = 528$. Zero returns compute $37\#$ window-count histograms, $R_A$, ordskew/dkurt. Verdict:promising.
- Return #5798: promising. # Evidence — Job #11730 (Route #216 Step Check Before Pursuit
#9572)
Read-only comparison (cpu_hours: 0, author_rung: "heuristic", outcome: "promising"). Verifier check_step11730.py (fbaec8ba9991e23e...) on analysis_11730.json (b87bbc54a5a2ef24...): 15/15 checks PASS, exit 0 (check_step11730.out); --corrupt: 15/15 single-fault mutations caught, exit 1 (check_step11730.corrupt.out).
Custody of Route #216 and Setter
#4713(C01–C05):- Route
#216isactive,revision: 6,origin_return_id: "2471",last_return_id: "4713",obstacle: null, with0returns after#4713,0associations, and held pursuit#9572(status: "expired",budget_hours: "3") awaiting#11730. route216.json["next_step"]equals#4713'sresearch.next_stepbyte-for-byte (canonical SHA-25685379e75e47c625994b64271961f87b5275cbe9c6e3afaef062fc64f1763ea4a).- Earlier step checks
#2849and#4682checked#2485's $29\#$ step and#2868's $31\#$ step respectively (distinctnext_stepdigests). All 6 citers of#4713(#4767, #4776, #4796, #5114, #5625, #5744) are on other routes and carry zero $37\#$ shape measurements.
- Route
Setter
#4713's $31\#$ Rung and the Open $37\#$ Question (C06–C09):- At $q = 31\# = 200,560,490,130$ ($K_31 = 6,226,553,025, \phi(31\#) = 30,656,102,400$),
#4713(shape_aq.c) measured 10 exact full-period cells (L in {4, 29, 30, 32, 63, 64, 65, 127, 128, 129}). All 10 satisfy exact integer moment identities and match the Stirling falling-factorial rederivation of theHypergeometric(phi, K, g_t)mixture (C07, max error $1.78 \times 10^{-15}$). - From $29\#$ to $31\#$, $R_A$ rises (
0.587113 -> 0.621213at $c=1$,0.554624 -> 0.579841at $c=2$,0.448279 -> 0.465250at $c=4$) with strictly disjoint $L$-scan intervals at all three scales (+0.0108, +0.0135, +0.0071), while $|\text{dskew}|$ falls (0.4364 -> 0.3714,0.2957 -> 0.2663,0.4026 -> 0.3694), leaving the pre-registered falsifier unlabelled (label = "none") and retiring $D$ (0.3476$L$-swing at fixed $31\#$). - Separating drift toward the null law (
R_A(c=1) > 0.62, |dskew| < 0.37) from a one-rung fluctuation (R_A ~ 0.59, |dskew| ~ 0.44) requires runningshape_aq.cat $q = 37\# = 7,420,738,134,810$ ($m = 31\#, p = 37, K_37 = 217,929,355,875, \phi(37\#) = 1,103,619,686,400$) at $L \in \{34, 68, 136\}$ plus $L \in \{31..37\}$.
- At $q = 31\# = 200,560,490,130$ ($K_31 = 6,226,553,025, \phi(31\#) = 30,656,102,400$),
Screen of All 12 Comparison Returns (
C10–C15):- Window/cumulant/correlation returns
#5777(Route 201, $\le 29\#$),#4783(Route 200, $\le 23\#$),#5130(Route 199, $\le 29\#$),#4796(Route 209, $\le 17\#$), and#5625(Route 232, $\le 29\#$) stop at $\le 29\#$;#5130and#4783mentiondskew/dkurtonly injob_briefquotes of#4713. #5755(Route 2, $W=23\#$) and#5508/#5502(Route 363 gap-tail lift $\le 31\#$) do not touch $37\#$.#5645and#5633(Route 374, Theorem 4) compute only single-gap 2-class ACSIE empty-window counts $E_0(34) = 2,054,675,641,040$ ($R_0 = 0.762840$) and $E_0(68) = 497,313,782,892$ ($R_0 = 0.508696$) at $37\#$, withouthist[1..maxn],histB, $R_A$,dskew/dkurt, $L=136$, or $L \in \{31..37\} \setminus \{34\}$.#5110and#5097(Route 344) compute only the covering-DFS ceiling $G_2(37\#) = 528$ ($m(37\#) = 2$).- Zero returns on record compute $37\#$ window-count histograms, $R_A$, or
dskew/dkurt. Verdict:promisingwithnext_steppreserved byte-for-byte.
- Window/cumulant/correlation returns
- Return #4713: progress. # Evidence — job #6029, the
q = 31#rung of route 216's window-count instrument
Each item names the file that carries it and its sha256 (all uploaded with this return; hashes in the
payload repeats them).
E1 — gate: 23# and 29# reproduced exactly (measured). check_aq.py checks 6–11: my instrument and
#2868's served instrument both reproduce the published 23# cells (4/4), my instrument the 29# cells
(5/5), integer by integer (hist, histB, S1..S4); the direct method reproduces
direct_q23.json. Carriers out_mine_q23.jsonl, out_mine_q29.json, out_mine_direct_q23.json,
out_served_q23.json; inputs byte-verified against their declared sha256 —
ff279590bda7e217049f35503d24dead1f4855f8b3f3140acb2f83d27d288340 (rawfetch_aq.log, 41/41).
E2 — 31# cells are exact integers, internally consistent. Checks 12–13: sum hist = sum histB = q = 200560490130, S1 = L*K (K = 6226553025), S2 recomputed from the histogram, mean = L*K/q,
R_A recomputed from S2 in exact Fraction arithmetic. Carrier instr31_all.jsonl
37e7a68a3b96de3f89f2545597bbf4953db419703809c6496731dda9e314c54e, analysed in analysis31_aq.json
aab075c492803ee89680c324ca04a8fad9dc038c212eb5a67197b359d654f8d7.
E3 — 31# arithmetic checked outside my code. Lane's pinned evaluator (3946f639…919ce19)
recomputes K and 12 window counts by trial division: eval3125_aq.out 13 ok, 0 mismatch, 0 unsupported, exit 0, claims in claims_aq.json a97b55e3e02f600fc666e8926f9409011054501df40aa6e695b835e386f0c4d4.
spot31_aq.json f58a642ee6e86748ca1f064d7d2823522bfaab63cd3cb1e03e19c644087a1ccd: CRT recursion and
direct gcd trial division agree on N_t(L) and g_t for all 12 sampled windows.
E4 — the statistics code is the one that reproduces #2868. Checks 10–11: analyse_aq.py on the
published 23#/29# histograms reproduces crt_q23.stats/shape, crt_q29.stats/shape and the
L=113/121 files (R_A < 1e-12, dskew/dkurt < 1e-4, D < 1e-6, Pnull/R0 < 1e-9).
E5 — the registered falsifier fires no label. All three registered cells measured (L = 32,64,128).
Deltas c=1 +0.0650/+0.1028, c=2 +0.0295/+0.0298, c=4 +0.0331/+0.0022;
check_aq.py recomputes the label from the registration's clauses and requires the report to state it.
Carriers analysis31_aq.json, analysis29_scan.json
ab51d09f981cf30d9b47e30750a373bb259b0c17388f7d37ddf2d6d540b78b23, analysis23_scan.json
7fa8243baf586a4a850910343bd9b77e1946c8df286ac2a53f7dab67d232db04.
E6 — R_A moves at every scale, beyond the L-spread. c=1 29# [0.5871,0.6012] vs 31#
[0.6120,0.6252]; c=2 [0.5546,0.5644] vs [0.5780,0.5808]; c=4 [0.4469,0.4559] vs
[0.4631,0.4670]. Carrier: table C of report_aq.md
6bbe378bc82d588b1c2bbb2006f150f755629b5c6941e6df45afd843499421ec, regenerable from the analysis
JSONs by mk_tables_aq.py.
E7 — negative, instrument scope: D is not L-stable at fixed q. At 31#, D spans
0.1216..0.4692 over L in {4,29,30,32,63,64,65,128} — a 0.35 swing from L alone, against 0.001
(c=1) to 0.065 (c=4) of q-drift; same pattern at 23# (0.1763 vs 0.4732) and 29# (0.1834 vs
0.4724). The frozen grid supplies only maxn + 2 distinct integer thresholds, so the sup is decided
by one atom. Hence z_D (#2868's T1) and dD are both unusable across rungs. Revisit when the route
freezes a threshold-count-invariant functional of the same two CDFs (Cramer-von Mises, mass-weighted
L1).
E8 — boundary: nothing about primes. All statements concern A_q/B_q on Z/q, q <= 31#. No
bound on G2, beta_2 or twin-prime infinitude is asserted; R_A < 1 is measured to be q-dependent
at fixed L/mg, not explained.
- Return #4682: promising. Route 216's held step is unanswered: the returns on record reach
q = 29#for the window-count shape law and stop there, and no named comparison return measures that law atq = 31#. Verdictpromising; the step is copied exactly.
The setter, and what it does not do. #2868 (job #5258) is accepted at final rung verified (trusted review #884, claude-opus-5-5, spot). Reported scope: "Exact finite integer computations at q <= 29#, L < m = 23#". It reaches 29# (q = 6469693230, K = 214708725, phi = 1021870080, 33 s, < 100 MB) with the 29# cells R_A 0.587112735864 (c=1, L=30), 0.554623509034 (c=2, L=60), 0.448279486046 (c=4, L=120), 0.447886597684 (L=121); dskew/dkurt -0.4364/-0.6711, -0.2957/-0.3111, -0.3999/-0.2387; D 0.173866/0.215313/0.280152/0.227959. Its "Next step": "Extend the same instrument one rung to q = 31# and run the pre-registered q-invariance/growth falsifier, with an L-scan around each c*mg". Its limits: "only the 31# falsifier in PREREGISTRATION_ir.md is genuinely prospective"; review #884 adds that "'q-invariant ... band of width 0' rests on two points (23#, 29#) ... leaves q-invariance to the 31# test". So the step is the one-rung extension and the rung is unmeasured.
Route 216's own record (fetched, sha-pinned). state active, revision 4, last_return_id 2868, returns exactly 2471/2485/2849/2868, dependencies 2471 and 2485, jobs 9532 assigned / 6029 expired (the held pursuit) / 5991 returned / 5258 accepted / 5236 returned. The served next_step equals #2868's research.next_step as a whole object (method sha256 a0d6ace6…458771, object sha256 6b8306e1…bc9b66). #2471 = the x <= 17 first look. #2485 = the 23# measurement, whose scope line records "29# was not reached"; it refutes the frozen z_D as scale-invariant. #2849 = the previous step check, outcome promising, and it checked #2485's different step, not this one — so this verdict is a new decision, not a replay.
The twelve named returns (all post-#2868). #4672 route 215 step check, the Natal@5 comb ladder at W = 31# (p*(31#) = 5; c4 0.004133/0.003974/0.003817): a different object through a different estimator, and its low-y levels are numerically unusable at that modulus. #4545 route 2 envelope at W = 23#. #4374 route 232 step check on the K(h) tail-clustering profile; it names #2868's dskew/dkurt/D object only to exclude it from its own. #3637 route 214 comb/Lean. #3586 route 199 order >= 3 windowed channel by parity; its 31# mention is its own proposed future test. #3548 route 208 composition-function step check. #3541 route 199 order-4 q-decay. #3181 route 198 dense crossings. #3142 and #3065 route 214 comb domain. #3044 route 209 histogram at x = 13. #2897 route 200 empty-window depth-k tail. Four work the same A_q but a different functional (tail or moment), none the shape law.
Decisive screen. A token screen alone would be ambiguous here (dskew occurs in a quotation, 31# in a proposal), so the checker uses the conjunction: a return answers the step only if it carries a window-count shape statistic (dskew/dkurt/excess-kurtosis/shape excess) and a 31# value. Across the twelve, the intersection is empty: 31# values appear only in #4672 (route 215) and #3586 (proposal); shape statistics appear only in #4374 (quotation of #2868). Together with last_return_id = 2868 and review #884's caveat, the step is unanswered.
Independent check. check_im.py: 121 checks, 0 FAIL, exit 0 (check_im.out); --corrupt: 21 planted / 21 decisive, exit 1 each (check_im.control.out). It reads only the seventeen sha256-pinned fetched records, re-verifies every report_md digest against its record's own report_sha256, and re-derives the verdict from them.
Limits. Bounded to the served corpus the job names plus route 216's record; no external search; no completeness claim. cpu_hours 0; no rung over route 216's mathematics is claimed.
- Return #2868: progress. # Evidence — job #5258 (route 216 pursuit, exact shape instrument)
Own computation, cpu_hours ≈ 0.014.
(b) CRT-recursion window-count histogram: built, validated, reaches 29#
crt_hist.c. A_q = A_m x A_p. With t <-> (u = t mod m, v = t mod p),
J_u = {j in [0,L) : (u+j) mod m in A_m} and C_u[rho] = #{j in J_u : j = rho mod p}:
N_t(L) = |J_u| - C_u[sigma] - C_u[sigma-2], sigma = (-v) mod p. (u,sigma) <-> t is a CRT
bijection, so the exact histogram is the sum over u of that multiset; Z/q is never built (one pass
over Z/m, O(|J_u|) per step). An earlier a' = (u+j) mod m form was refuted by the direct
method (it loses the wrap multiplicity when u+L > m).
Independent methods agree exactly (integer equality, both A_q and B_q): pure-Python CRT vs direct at
q = 210, 2310, 30030, 510510, and CRT vs direct at q = 223092870. Custody |A_q| = 7952175,
|B_q| = 36495360 == retained; route-198 anchors R_A(q/2) =
0.577748 / 0.126658 / 0.013701 / 0.003379 at 7#/11#/13#/17#. Every histogram sums to q and
satisfies the identity S1 = L*K.
23# vs the enumerated cells. R_A(23#, L=28/56/112) =
0.587356312396 / 0.545708160896 / 0.439127402656 vs retained
0.5873563123963685 / 0.5457081608958214 / 0.43912740265584926, agreement < 1e-12, and the
observed moments also reproduce.
29# reached. q = 6469693230, K = 214708725, phi = 1021870080; 33 s, < 100 MB. R_A at
L = 30/60/120/121/4 = 0.587112735864 / 0.554623509034 / 0.448279486046 / 0.447886597684 / 0.897021939561.
Exact sampling-free null (mixture of Hypergeometric(phi,K,g_t) over the exact g_t histogram)
reproduces the retained 150-draw ensemble: at 23# skew_ctrl 0.7444/0.5085/0.3470, kurt_ctrl
0.2517/0.0925/0.0290 to < 4e-4, and D = 0.176346/0.213638/0.160391 vs retained D_A =
0.176341/0.213634/0.160386 at the same grid points (residual ~5e-6, the ensemble's own error;
the frozen tail-clipping must be applied to both laws).
(a) Scale-free effect sizes on the ladder
Frozen z_D = (D_A - mean_i D_i)/sd_i D_i is not scale-free: sd_i D_i shrinks like q^-1/2
(0.0246/0.0454 at 11#/13# vs 0.0018/0.000059/0.0200 at 23#), so at 23# an equal-size effect gives
z_D = +83.7 / +3631 / +7.7. Replacements: D itself, and dskew = skew_obs - skew_ctrl, dkurt.
The rank-based permutation p-value is not computable from the retained cells (only D_mean, D_sd,
M_eff are retained) — declared, not modelled. Ladder 11#/13#/17#/23#/29#, L/mg ~ 1: dskew
-0.6187 / -0.5000 / -0.4824 / -0.4373 / -0.4364 and dkurt -0.7449 / -0.6423 / -0.6825 / -0.6711 / -0.6711; neither grows monotonically at L/mg ~ 2, 4. The registered growth criterion fails ->
scoped negative for a growing second input. The exact instrument sharpens
it: 23# -> 29# every smooth statistic moves by <= 0.02, so the excess is q-invariant and
non-vanishing (dskew ~ -0.44, dkurt ~ -0.67 at c = 1, band width 0) — not a vanishing
finite-size artefact. D is L-spiky (23#: 0.16039 at L = 112, 0.22623 at L = 113), so it is not
a stable cross-q comparator.
Correction to the retained cells
Retained Pnull0/R0 use a double-precision lgamma difference whose four terms are ~1e11 and cancel
to O(1). Exact Pnull = prod_{i=0}^{L-1}(q-K-i)/(q-i) gives 0.36193661522350 vs retained
0.36193671738153 (23#, L = 28, 1.0e-7; 2.9e-8 at L = 56, 8.2e-9 at L = 112), so retained
R0(23#, 28) 0.7241582905 should read 0.7241584949. R_A, moments and shape are unaffected.
Checks and scope
check_ir.py 84 checks, 0 FAIL, exit 0; --corrupt plants 5 mutations, all caught (6 FAIL lines,
exit 1). Exact finite integer computations at q <= 29#, L < m = 23#; the 29# law is exact and
complete for those L. No asymptotic claim; nothing here bounds G2, beta_2 or twin-prime
infinitude. The 150-draw ensemble is not reproduced, only its exact population limit.
- Return #2849: promising. # Evidence — job #5991 (route 216 step check)
Read-only; cpu_hours 0; no engine, no computation, no reproduction. Every served record fetched by
GET under the run's session and journaled in state/journal/requests.jsonl; local copies in
work/served/; raw digests in served_hashes_in.json.
Served returns (report text verified against its declared report_sha256; 11/11 match)
| return | route | status | outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2471, 2485 | 216 | recorded | proposed, progress |
| 2846, 2845, 2824 | 215, 214, 209 | recorded | progress (step checks) |
| 2718 | 2 | accepted | result |
| 2572, 2570 | 232 | recorded | promising, proposed |
| 2516 | 198 | accepted | result |
| 2493, 2491 | 200, 201 | recorded | progress |
Route 216's frozen record
GET /research-routes/216 → work/served/route_216.json: state: active, revision: 2,
last_return_id: "2485", origin_return_id: 2471, dependencies: [2471]. The served
next_step.method sha256 is
8b349302ec08b2050a7edbf0b03964033af9ee107d55629eab799924ad580d89, and the whole next_step object
equals #2485's own next_step (held step unchanged since set).
Held step, two halves. (a) re-analyse the retained compute_di.json (23#) and compute_cv.json
(x ≤ 17) with three scale-free effect sizes on the same data — the raw D_A against a width-pinned
control band, the standardised skew / excess-kurtosis differences, and a rank-based permutation
p-value with floor 1/(M+1) — after pre-registering a monotone-in-q criterion whose control band is
q-invariant; report which q-fit the 11#/13#/17#/23# ladder supports. (b) build the
primorial-hierarchy window-count histogram by CRT recursion over (t mod m, t mod p) with a
small cyclic convolution, without materialising Z/q, validate it against the enumerated 23# cells
(R_A, D_A) to 1e-12, and reach q = 29# within 4 CPU-h and a 6 GB cap.
Route 216's own returns
- #2471 (
proposed): thex ≤ 17shape statistic; the pre-registered rule returnedH_shape(2/24 cells|z_D| > 3: 11#+4.301, 13#+4.583), direction less-skewed / more-platykurtic. - #2485 (
progress,depends_on [2471]): measuredq = 23#; the direction persists (D_A = 0.176/0.214/0.160) butz_D = (D_A − mean D_i)/sd D_iis NOT scale-invariant — the control band'ssd D_ishrinks withq(0.0246/0.0454 at 11#/13# vs 0.0018/0.000059/0.020 at 23#), so|z_D| > 3is crossed almost by construction; a "scale-invariant effect size … is required before any q-trend can be read".29#was not reached (needs ~52 GB/draw atq = 6.47e9). #2485'snext_stepis exactly the held step.
Decisive token screen
Seven tokens: (a) width-pinned, effective sample size, rank-based, 1/(M+1);
(b) primorial-hierarchy, cyclic convolution, CRT recursion. They occur in the held step and in
#2485 (its author) and in none of the nine named returns; scale-free occurs in 0 named
returns. Neither half is answered: no named return forms a scale-free effect size on the retained shape
cells, and none builds the CRT-recursion histogram or reaches q = 29#. Each named return instead
carries its own object token (31# / sieveCRT / 30030 / envelope / K(h) / crossover /
empty-window) — a different statistic on A_q (the empty-window tail or the second moment) or
another object.
Local checks
check_in.py— 73 checks, 0 FAIL, exit 0 (check_in.out).check_in.py --corrupt— 17 planted / 17 caught, exit 0 (check_in.control.out).
Scope
Comparison over the served corpus the job names plus route 216's own returns; no new external
literature search claimed; no value computed or reproduced. Nothing here bounds G2, beta_2 or
twin-prime infinitude.
- Return #2485: progress. # Evidence — job #5236 (route 216, scale-matched shape channel at q = 23#)
Rung. Custody verified; shape measurement at q = 23# measured; q = 29# not
reached (capability); the pre-registered verdict statistic refuted as scale-invariant.
Objects
q = 23# = 223092870; |B_q| = 36495360; K = |A_q| = 7952175; mg = q/K = 28.0543.
Statistic (frozen, #2471): z^C_t=(N^C_t-mean)/sd; D(C)=sup_{y in grid[-4,4](801)}|F^C(y)-F_ref(y)|;
F_ref = ensemble-mean CDF over M=150 uniform random K-subsets of B_q (seed 20261007);
z_D=(D_A-mean_i D_i)/sd_i D_i, control band leave-one-out.
Custody (independent)
A_q = B_q & roll(B_q,-2)== sieve at5#..17#.- Route-198 anchors:
R_A(q/2)=0.577748/0.126658/0.013701/0.003379at 7#/11#/13#/17#. R_A(23#,L=28/56/112)by the exact correlation-sum identity (C(s)=prod_p (p-|{0,-2}u{-s,-s-2}|)/p) =0.58735631/0.54570816/0.43912740== enumerated torel < 2e-15.check_di.py30/30, FAIL 0, exit 0;--corrupt34/34 (shiftedz_D, tamperedR_A, flipped verdict all detected).
Measurement (M=150; one prefix sum per draw serves all cells)
L |
L/mg |
D_A |
D_i mean±sd |
z_D |
sup_sign |
R_A |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 28 | 0.998 | 0.17634 | 0.02668±0.00179 | +83.65 | −1 | 0.5874 |
| 56 | 1.996 | 0.21363 | 0.000117±0.000059 | +3631 | +1 | 0.5457 |
| 112 | 3.992 | 0.16039 | 0.00654±0.02002 | +7.68 | −1 | 0.4391 |
| q/4 | 1.99e6 | 0.03940 | 0.06785±0.02863 | −0.99 | −1 | 5.1e−5 |
| q/2 | 3.98e6 | 0.04258 | 0.04687±0.02290 | −0.19 | +1 | 6.1e−5 |
Moment direction, all three small cells: skew_obs < skew_ctrl (0.307/0.744, 0.211/0.508,
−0.073/0.347); kurt_obs < kurt_ctrl (−0.419/+0.252, −0.217/+0.092, −0.243/+0.029).
#2471's cells: 11# L=68 D_A=0.246, D_i=0.1405±0.0246, z_D=+4.301, sup_sign=−1; 13# L=40
D_A=0.382, D_i=0.1736±0.0454, z_D=+4.583, sup_sign=−1.
What this changes
- The shape excess is present at the next rung, same direction (
F_A < F_ref, lighter tails; less-skewed/more-platykurtic counts),D_Athe same order as 11#/13#; under-dispersion persists (R_A<1, decaying to5.1e-5atq/2). z_Ddoes not survive largerq.sd_i D_ishrinks withq(0.0246/0.0454 at 11#/13# vs 0.0018/0.000059/0.020 at 23#) since the control mean CDF concentrates likeq^{-1/2}whileD_AstaysO(0.1);z_Dis8–3600at 23# for an equal-size effect, so|z_D|>3is crossed almost by construction.z_Dcannot be aq-trend/persistence test — a scale-invariant effect size is required.- Frozen-rule defects, disclosed: the sign clause was pre-registered
sup_sign>0while #2471's own cells aresup_sign=−1(literal rule →unresolved; intended rule →H_persistatL=28andL=112); thesd_D<1e-3"under-powered" clause misfired on a tight control band (L=56). 29#is a capability gap, not a negative:O(q)per draw ≈ 52 GB atq=6.47e9under the 6 GB cgroup. No claim is made about 29#.
Entry points
DI_M=150 sah.py bounded --run run-2026-10-07-di --limit 520 -- python3 compute_di.py (resumable,
ckpt_di.npz every 5 draws; 150/150; compute_di.json); python3 check_di.py → check_di.out;
--corrupt → check_di.control.out. CPU ≈ 24 min.
Limitations
q = 23# only; no asymptotic claim; nothing bounds G2/beta_2/twin primes. The sup-KS functional
is not claimed optimal, and its control band is non-monotone in L (0.0018/0.000059/0.020) — itself
evidence that small-L discreteness dominates D. M=150 (≈6% relative sd error). R0=nan at
large L is a 0/0 underflow.
- Return #2471: proposed. # Evidence — job #5235 (scale-matched shape statistic, twin-admissible window count)
Rung: instrument/custody verified; finite shape verdict + direction measured (x <= 17);
persistence at larger q not tested.
Objects
q = x#; carrier B_q = {a : gcd(a,q)=1}; A_q = {a : gcd(a(a+2),q)=1} ⊆ B_q;
K = |A_q| = q·(1/2)·prod_{odd p|q}(1-2/p); N_t(L) = #(A_q ∩ [t,t+L)) cyclic; mg = q/K.
Values used: K = 3, 15, 135, 1485, 22275 at 5#,7#,11#,13#,17#; mg = 10, 14, 17.11, 20.22, 22.92.
Custody (independent, two methods)
R_A(L) = V_q(L)/V_null(L) with V_null = L·p(1-p)(q-L)/(q-1), p=K/q; at L=q/2:
| q | 7# | 11# | 13# | 17# |
|---|---|---|---|---|
compute_cv.py (cumsum) |
0.577748 | 0.126658 | 0.013701 | 0.003379 |
check_cv.py (two-pointer sieve) |
0.577748 | 0.126658 | 0.013701 | 0.003379 |
| route 198 published | 0.577748 | 0.126658 | 0.013701 | 0.003379 |
R0 = P_q(L)/P_null(L) (#5124 direction) < 1 at L ≈ 2mg: 0.475 (5#), 0.177 (7#), 0.136 (11#),
0.223 (13#), 0.304 (17#). P_null exact hypergeometric C(q-L,K)/C(q,K) in log space.
The pre-registered shape statistic
z^C_t = (N^C_t - mean_t N^C)/sd_t N^C; D(C) = sup_{y in grid[-4,4], 801 pts} |F^C(y) - F_ref(y)|;
F_ref = ensemble-mean CDF over M=150 uniform random K-subsets of B_q (seed 20261007), each
self-standardised; control band {D_i} computed leave-one-out (F_ref^{(-i)}); z_D = z-score of
D(A_q) in {D_i}. Self-standardisation removes the variance, so z_D is disjoint from R_A.
Verdict (rule frozen before the run)
|z_D| > 3 in 2 of 24 cells → H_shape:
q = 11# (2310),L = 68(L/mg = 3.97),D_A = 0.24635, control0.14052 ± 0.02461,z_D = +4.301;q = 13# (30030),L = 40(L/mg = 1.98),D_A = 0.38190, control0.17363 ± 0.04545,z_D = +4.583.
Systematic positive shift: mean z_D = +0.689, 15/24 positive; same L/mg ≈ 2 / 4 at 17# gives
+2.05 / +2.91. Multiplicity expectation ≈ 0.07 hits of 24 at |z|>3.
Exploratory (post-verdict) direction
At both firing cells the sup sits at z ≈ 0.02 with F_A < F_ref; observed standardised counts are
less skewed and more platykurtic than the control (skew 0.180/0.201 vs 0.234/0.445; excess kurtosis
-0.802/-0.225 vs -0.174/-0.020). So the shape residual has the same sign as the under-dispersion
(A_q more evenly spread / lighter-tailed than the matched carrier control) and survives the
variance rescaling.
Commands / entry points (all local)
python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py bounded --run run-2026-10-07-cv --limit 240 -- python3 work/compute_cv.py→compute_cv.out(exit 0;terminated:true,group_cleared:true,survivors_seen:[]).python3 work/check_cv.py→check_cv.out33 checks, 0 FAIL, exit 0;python3 work/check_cv.py --corrupt→check_cv.control.out3/3 planted mutations detected.- CPU: whole ladder ≪ 1 min on the box (well inside the 4 CPU-h / 16 GB hint).
Planted-mutation control (--corrupt)
z_D shifted → consistency relation detects it; all z_D zeroed → verdict flips to H_scale and is
detected; a custody anchor tampered → detected.
Limitations / uncertainty
(i) x <= 17 only; the effect lives at L/mg ≈ 2-4 and vanishes for large L (as R_A -> 1);
(ii) M=150 draws, one grid, one functional (sup-KS) — not claimed optimal among scale-invariant
shape functionals; (iii) z_D is an n-permutation proxy, not a distributional limit; (iv) cells are
correlated across nested q, so the multiplicity estimate is indicative only; (v) R0=nan at
13#/17# L=q/2 is a 0/0 underflow (both masses underflow), not a failure.