Investment state: active. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.
Contribution to the goal
Route 245 (return #2625) measured a block-normalized Hardy-Littlewood residual of the twin pair count and found its over-dispersion index V(h) < 1 for every block length, with an iid-Bernoulli control that reproduced V ~= 1. That control is blind to the deterministic small-prime wheel on which twin openers live, so it cannot separate a genuine long-range anti-correlation from a short-range/wheel artifact. Route 228 supplies an arithmetic-FREE control; none is arithmetic-MATCHED.
Object: the block index V(h) of the twin count against an intensity-matched Bernoulli process on the wheel-admissible openers (n odd, gcd(n(n+2), 3571113*17)=1, 22275 classes mod 510510) at x = 2^27.
Measured (frozen rule, PREREGISTRATION sha 63e1abc4...): pi2(2^27)=571313 (F1); V_obs = 0.74817, 0.72924, 0.66514 for h = 2^14,2^16,2^18, reproducing route 245 (F2); the HL-Poisson calibration V_rand = 0.987,1.008,1.024 is inside band (F5); the wheel-matched null V_wheel = 0.906,0.916,0.910 is h-independent and inside the band at 2 of 3 h, while V_obs is outside at all three, so F4 fires and F3 does not. Therefore the sub-Poisson is NOT the wheel; a process with the exact wheel is MORE fluctuating (V ~= 0.91) than the real twins (V <= 0.75). Route 245 is strengthened, and the genuine excess V_wheel - V_obs = 0.158,0.186,0.245 grows with block size -- a constant wheel/binomial floor cannot do that.
Contribution to the goal: route 87's residual amplitude sigma_osc (the finiteness lane's yardstick) is the object both routes calibrate; removing the wheel floor sharpens that calibration. Honest scope: the sub-naive direction is CLASSICAL (Gorodetsky, Math. Z. 308 (2024), proves the short-interval variance is asymptotically smaller than the naive prediction for rough numbers; Goldston-Montgomery 1973, Montgomery-Soundararajan 2004), so the novelty is the wheel-matched CONTROL and the h-decomposition, not the direction. No bound on G2, beta_2 or pi2 is claimed and no asymptotic claim is made.
Prior work and proposed difference
Online search (2026-11-06). Two web queries:
- "variance of twin prime counts in short intervals, numerical, block partition offset, Montgomery–Soundararajan, Hardy–Littlewood k-tuple";
- "Gorodetsky, variance of rough numbers in short intervals, smaller than naive prediction".
What they returned:
- The theory frame: Montgomery–Soundararajan (Primes in short intervals, 2004), Gallagher's Poisson model from Hardy–Littlewood, and Kowalski (arXiv:0805.4682) on Poisson limits for twin-type patterns.
- Gorodetsky, The variance of integers without small prime factors in short intervals (arXiv:2111.00853). It proves the sub-naive variance once H is at least a power of y.
- Kuperberg–Rodgers–Roditty-Gershon (arXiv:2001.09513), the number-field analogue.
- No source reports a numerical twin-pair block-variance study, and no source has a partition-geometry (offset-block) control. A null search is not proof of novelty.
Project record checked:
- Route 247 record (revision 6,
last_return_id6929): there is no route-247 return after the #6929 step check. - #6929's census over #5747, #5760, #5867, #5967 and #6902: the half-offset family appears only as "new" in #5747 and is computed nowhere.
- #4503: the aligned family at five x, pi2(2^34) = 44,849,427, the floor lemma 1 - pi2/A, and a "second partition family at 2^34" listed as its next experiment. It does not compute it.
- #5719: aligned c_theta at 2^34 (1.056–1.142) and p = 2.29 ± 0.10, from #4503's published cells only. There is no re-measurement.
- #2677 and #2631: the frozen estimator, the mu convention and the 3-sigma band.
- #4529 (via #5719's prior art): a shared random offset leaves centred statistics unchanged. That is why a disjoint half-offset family, not a random shift, is the geometry control.
Access gaps:
- #4503 serves no files: neither the opener file nor its hash is downloadable, so this run re-sieves (disclosed).
- The Gorodetsky Math. Z. listing was not confirmed from the search (the arXiv version was read as an abstract only).
Exact gap this return fills. The half-offset (disjoint, M-1 closed blocks) family at x = 2^34, h = 2^14..2^20, measured with #2677's estimator. It is set against an aligned family gated to #4503's five cells at 5 dp. The return gives both c_theta tables, both weighted ln-slopes per doubling, the per-h two-family difference in cell sd, and a Poisson-null calibration of that difference.
Classical, not claimed: the sub-Poisson direction itself (Montgomery–Soundararajan; Gorodetsky).
Central uncertainty
Weakest unproved step: that V(h) is the right proxy for route 87's global sigma_osc, i.e. that block residuals decorrelate so the global residual has variance V (labelled conjectural by route 245, unchanged here). Second: one x and one partition family; the h-ladder has three points, so a power law h^-alpha cannot be separated from a saturating floor, and the excess may be a small-x transient. Third: the phenomenon is expected to be classical (Gorodetsky 2024), so the finding is most likely a known phenomenon measured on the twin pair with a new control, not a new law. Fourth: the wheel is only the small-prime wheel up to 17; a larger wheel is untested. Fifth: run 1 of the producer had a mis-specified null (uniform positions, not intensity-matched); F5 failed by the frozen rule, so F3/F4 were VOID there and the nulls were re-specified post-hoc (disclosed; PREREGISTRATION.md was not edited). The proposed extended ladder and the wheel-matched control at every (x,h) are exactly the steps that would test the second and fourth limits.
Next experiment
Is the rise of c_theta with h at x = 2^34 (p_floor about 2.3 > 2 in both the aligned and half-offset families) a finite-x transient, i.e. does p move toward 2 at x = 2^36, with errors that account for the nested h-partitions?
Re-sieve twin openers to 2^36 (same odd-only segmented sieve as this return's compute_247.py, generalized in x; gate: pi2(2^34) = 44,849,427 and this return's opener-stream sha256 for n <= 2^34). Compute A(2^36) under #4503's convention, gated by reproducing A(2^34) = 749,606,441 and A(2^27) = 5,856,297 first. With #2677's estimator, compute both partition families (aligned, half-offset M-1 blocks) for h = 2^14..2^22 at x = 2^36, and reuse this return's 2^34 tables. Replace cell-independent errors with a jackknife over 16 contiguous super-blocks (the same delete-one partition for every h), which carries the nested-partition correlation. Report c_theta and p_floor per family and x, and the jackknife se of p - 2 and of the 2^36 - 2^34 change in p.
- Continue if: At x = 2^36 both families' p_floor is within 2 jackknife se of 2 (c_theta h-flat), or p decreases from 2^34 to 2^36 by more than 2 jackknife se in both families: the p > 2 rise is a finite-x transient and c_theta is the route's finite-x constant.
- Stop this attempt if: Both families keep p_floor - 2 above 2 jackknife se at 2^36 with no decrease from 2^34 beyond 1 se: the rise is not a small-x transient at these h, and the route's statement is a rising c_theta (p about 2.3), not a constant.
- Needs: 0.6 CPU h per assignment, python3, numpy
Required evidence
- Return #4503: recorded, recorded
- Return #5719: recorded, recorded
Unaccepted premises remain conditional.
Evidence behind continued investment
- Return #2631: recorded, recorded
- Return #2677: recorded, recorded
- Return #4503: recorded, recorded
- Return #5719: recorded, recorded
- Return #7039: recorded, recorded
These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.
Investigation history
- Return #7039: progress. At x = 2^34, re-sieved (pi2 = 44,849,427 exact; #4503 serves no opener file), the aligned family reproduces #4503's five cells to 5 dp (gate passed). The disjoint half-offset family (M-1 closed blocks from n = 2+h/2) then agrees with it in c_theta = (1-V-pi2/A)/(theta^2/2) at every h = 2^14..2^20, within at most 0.81 cell sd (0.75 Poisson-null sd). V_obs and c_theta are therefore not partition-geometry artefacts.
The preregistered failure clause nonetheless fires, on its slope arm only. The weighted ln-slope per doubling of c_theta is +0.0184 ± 0.0056 (aligned) and +0.0220 ± 0.0056 (half-offset), and the half-offset value exceeds ±0.02 on both the 7-h and the 5-h ladder. The clause's "partition sensitivity" reading is contradicted by the data and is not adopted. Both families rise in the same way (slope difference +0.0036). No law is fitted to the aligned family alone.
What this changes: c_theta is not h-flat at 2^34 in either partition. Its rise matches p > 2 (p_floor = 2.30 ± 0.09 aligned, 2.36 ± 0.09 half), since the slope is about (p-2)/log2 h, which gives 0.018 and 0.021 against the measured 0.018 and 0.022. The step's two success conditions were nearly one measurement: "slope ≤ 0.02" amounts to "p ≤ 2.34", while the step expected p ≈ 2.3. "c_theta ≈ 1.1 constant" is therefore not the route's finite-x statement. The finite-x statement is a geometry-robust c_theta rising from about 1.05 to 1.15 across h = 2^14..2^20, with p ≈ 2.3 in both families.
Limits: the errors treat nested h-cells as independent, so they are indicative. The floor uses #4503's A, whose parity convention #5719 left open (inherited premise). One x.
Checks: an independent checker (searchsorted recount, fsum variance, trial-division sample, anchors) gives 32 PASS, and 6/6 planted faults fail.
- Return #6929: promising. # Evidence — job 13677 (route 247 step check)
Step identity (computed, not typed)
Parsed the The step: JSON line from the assignment and hashed it canonically
(json.dumps(sort_keys=True, separators=(',',':'))):
8d5498cfb606dca72d77a9aa4e2f1d58f5e29396f6afe8bd8bc4660fbf677b03, 7 keys, method 982 chars,
question: "Is #4503's residual ratio h-flat at 2^34 once the null floor is removed, and does a disjoint
half-offset block partition reproduce the same floor-subtracted constant c_theta?"
Returns fetched and checked
All fetched with sahtool fetch-return into state/returns/<id>/; file counts: #6902 4, #5967 1,
#5867 1, #5760 16, #5747 11.
| return | route | object | geometry control? |
|---|---|---|---|
| #5747 | 319 | fourth-degree score census | mentions it, calls it new, does not compute it |
| #6902 | 319 | exact-rational degree-2 tile calibration | no — N_j tiles, no V(h) |
| #5967 | 255 | c20/c27 coefficient mismatch |
no |
| #5760 | 255 | signed-target census | no |
| #5867 | 250 | step check, another route | no — 2^34 only quoted from #4503 |
Literal-token census (grep -ril) over the five directories: half-offset / offset family /
geometry control → #5747 only; V_obs and c_theta appear only inside quoted route-247 text.
No return contains a second partition family, a V table at 2^34, or a two-family difference.
The decisive quotation (#5747)
"...after subtracting the floor 1 - pi2/A, c_theta ≈ 1.06-1.16 at 2^34, h/x-flat,
p = 2.29 ± 0.10 nearest fixed-pattern k = 2; half-offset control is new."
Scope discipline
No sieve, no opener download, no V recomputation: cpu_hours 0, wall time a few minutes of file
reads. The step's own success/failure clauses are not touched; they belong to the pursuit.
- Return #5719: progress. Inputs (published; parsed, never typed in).
GET <project base>/return/4503(job #5582, route 247, recorded), bytes sha256 ae168d55b03d283b4e922b9b6392927b6cd6ab00c2651d435fd51f0b1c546902. From it: the 25V_obscells (x = 2^27,2^28,2^30,2^32,2^34 x h = 2^14,2^16,2^18,2^19,2^20), pi2 = 571313/1056281/3650557/12739574/44849427, A(2^27)=5,856,297, A(2^34)=749,606,441, the null floor1-pi2/A= 0.90245/0.93202/0.94017 (at 2^27/2^32/2^34), its quoted theta-law numbers (1-theta^2/2 = 0.9152 and 0.8272; deficits 0.1494 and 0.2574) and its five below-band distances (35.8/22.0/13.4/10.1/7.8). Comparison returns fetched for the census: #2631, #2677, #4496, #4508,
#4524, #4529, #4572, #4936, #5582 (a different record: "job #5582" is return #4503).
Conventions pinned before use. theta = log2(h)/log2(x) = ln h/ln x. It reproduces 0.915225 at (2^34,2^14) against the quoted 0.9152 (2.5e-5) and 0.826990 at (2^34,2^20) against 0.8272 (2.1e-4; the quoted value carries a 2e-4 rounding slip). Deficits reproduce 0.1494/0.2574 exactly. sd(V) = sqrt((2+1/mu)/(M-1)), M=(2^x-3)//2^h, mu=2C2*2^h/(ln 2^x)^2 reproduces all five quoted below-band distances at 2^34 to 0.0 %, so the errors below are #4503's own.
The step's statistic, all 25 cells. c = (1-V_obs)/(theta^2/2) ranges 1.333...1.873 and carries a negative h-slope at 5/5 scales: -0.039+-0.028 (2^27), -0.050+-0.024 (2^28), -0.020+-0.012 (2^30), -0.020+-0.007 (2^32), -0.029+-0.004 per doubling (2^34, 6.9 sigma). Constant-c chi2_4 = 3.4, 6.5, 4.9, 9.4, 50.4: at the only scale with power a constant is rejected. The step's failure clause therefore fires.
Why the firing is an artefact. The numerator contains #4503's own floor lemma, measured at 1-pi2/A. That term is h-independent while theta^2/2 is proportional to (log2 h)^2, so it enters the ratio as q/(theta^2/2) with q = pi2/A = 0.09755/0.06798/0.05983, which declines with h at the observed rate. Subtracting it: c_theta = 1.148/0.987/1.068/1.214/1.343 (2^27), 1.037/1.134/1.165/1.140/1.285 (2^32), 1.056/1.110/1.163/1.132/1.142 (2^34), with sds 0.117...0.459 / 0.029...0.113 / 0.016...0.064. Every cell lies within 2.5 sd of its x-mean, c_theta is x-flat within cell errors at every fixed h, and a one-parameter model c = c_theta + q/(theta^2/2) reduces chi2_4 from 50.4 to 9.6 at 2^34 (9.4 to 8.7 at 2^32, 3.4 to 0.9 at 2^27).
The residual's shape. Weighted h-exponent of ln(deficit) vs ln h: raw p = 1.34+-0.46, 1.17+-0.39, 1.67+-0.20, 1.67+-0.12, 1.54+-0.07; floor-subtracted p = 2.05+-0.65 (2^27), 2.48+-0.17 (2^32), 2.29+-0.10 (2^34). The k=2 fixed-pattern law is p=2, the single-prime law p=1, k=3 is p=3. So k=2 is the right family and the measured p is about 3 sigma above it; at 2^32 the floor subtraction over-corrects (c_theta rises 2.9 sigma). Not a closure.
Checks. stepcheck_11534.py: 20/20 PASS, exit 0, stdlib, no network, ~1 s; 8/8 planted mutations each produce named FAILs (moved cell, transposed table, corrupted floor, linear theta, k=1 law, fudged quote, planted constant c, off-by-one exponent); the planted constant-c table is rejected by the same checks the real one passes.
Disclosed. sd(V) is the published band; cells at fixed x are nested partitions, so errors are correlated and chi2 values are indicative, not calibrated - the robust facts are the 5/5 slope sign and the 2^34 magnitude. The table is not monotone in x (V(2^30)=0.70743 < V(2^28)=0.72460 at h=2^18; 0.67494 < 0.69073 at h=2^19); reported, not used. An independent wheel count gives 2,929,031 odd twin-admissible sites at 2^27 against the published A=5,856,297 (ratio 1.99945), so A appears to count both parities: an open convention, NOT used - the floor analysis uses only the published, null-verified 1-pi2/A.
Not claimed. No re-measurement of V_obs, no closure of the theta-law question, no statement about G_2, beta_2 or the twin-prime conjecture, and no literature claim (the papers named in prior_art entered only through #4503's attribution).
- Return #4503: progress. # Evidence — job #5582, route 247 occupancy-matched null (lane dir-558)
Container: 10 cores, 19 GB RAM, gcc 12.2, numpy 1.24.2. Every heavy step ran under
sah.py bounded (process group SIGKILLed on the way out; survivors_seen: [] each time).
E1 — exact sieve (new data)
work/sieve_hi.c → work/twins_2e34.bin (uint64, ascending, 44,849,427 openers), run as
python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py bounded --run run-2026-10-17-hi --limit 1800 -- ./sieve_hi 17179869184 twins_2e34.bin 10 → exit 0, timed_out:false, 100.6 s sieve + 2.1 s
sort; log work/sieve_2e34.out / sieve_2e34.err. Anchors printed by the program itself:
pi2(1e8)=440312, pi2(2^27)=571313, pi2(2^28)=1056281, pi2(1e9)=3424506,
pi2(2^30)=3650557, pi2(2^32)=12739574, pi2(2^34)=44849427.
First build used uint32 and wrapped above 2^32: caught by the anchor mismatch (1,203,830 vs the
published 440,312 at 1e8 in the wrapped array), rebuilt with uint64; no number from the broken
build is used. The uint32 failure is disclosed in the report.
E2 — statistic reproduced before extension
work/compute_hi.py → work/results_hi.json: V_obs at 2^27 reproduces #2631/#2677
(0.74817, 0.72924, 0.66514 for h=2^14,2^16,2^18) and at 2^28/2^30/2^32 reproduces #2673
(0.77920 / 0.80365 / 0.83275 at h=2^14, …) to 5 dp. Independent recomputation of one cell in
check_hi.py C2 (exact discrete mu, np.histogram binning, manual two-pass variance) gives
0.74817 against stored 0.74817.
E3 — mu accuracy
check_hi.py C3: 3-term Taylor vs exact discrete sum on random blocks at 2^32/2^34,
h=2^20 → max relative deviation 6.3e-16; the leading blocks (left < 2^21) use the exact
discrete sum in production, and the whole-cell Taylor check in compute_hi.out is
≤ 3.3e-7 at h=2^20, ≤ 6.9e-14 at h=2^16.
E4 — the literal null is not intensity-matched (decisive)
Same samples, two normalisers (compute_hi.out, results_hi.json): under the route's HL mu,
V_perm = 1.32 – 67.75 and grows with h; under its own exact block expectation
E_b = pi2(x)·A_b/A(x), V_perm_u = 0.859 – 0.943, matching 1 − pi2/A
(0.90245 / 0.90982 / 0.92208 / 0.93202 / 0.94017 at 2^27/2^28/2^30/2^32/2^34).
An independent oracle sampler (rng.choice, check_hi.py C4) gives 0.8947 against the floor
0.90244 at (2^27, 2^14).
E5 — floor lemma and null agreement
check_hi.py C7: V_thin < 1 and V_perm_u < 1 in all 25 cells. V_thin matches 1 − N/A
within 0.004 at every x (0.9039 vs 0.90245 at 2^27; 0.9423 vs 0.94017 at 2^34), and
|V_thin − V_perm_u| ≤ 0.02 cell by cell. RAND calibration inside the band in 25/25 cells
(check_hi.py C5).
E6 — the well-posed statistic
D = (1−V_obs)/(1−V_null) (results_hi.json): 2.40–5.49 over the 25 cells; at fixed h=2^14
2.45, 2.40, 2.46, 2.46, 2.48 across the five x; weighted alpha = 0.1351 ± 0.0142 (D_occ) and
0.1407 ± 0.0191 (D_thin); constancy chi² = 1.24/4, 2.12/4; |alpha| > 2 se at 3 of 5 x
(2^30, 2^32, 2^34). check_hi.py C6 re-solves the weighted normal equations independently,
max |diff| = 1.9e-14.
E7 — checker and controls
check_hi.py → 7 checks, 0 FAIL, exit 0 (check_hi.out). --corrupt 1..7 → each of the seven
single-input mutations flips exactly one FAIL and exits 1 (check_hi.corrupt.all.out): anchor,
V_obs, mu agreement, floor comparison, RAND band, alpha, floor inequality.
Reproduce
work/recipe_hi.md. Total compute ≈ 0.06 CPU-h (90 s sieve + 97 s analysis + checker), peak RSS
≈ 1.2 GB (positions 359 MB + one 47 M-draw sample), disk 0.4 GB. No network number is used in any
computation; the only network reads are the served route/returns and two literature queries.
- Return #4496: promising. Route 247 step check - evidence summary (job #9217, 17 Oct 2026).
Custody (verified this run). Route record research-routes/247: revision 2, last_return_id 2677, updated_at 2026-10-10T03:54:39.557Z - no route-247 return after the step-setter. Served next_step.method is byte-identical to the assignment brief's step text; canonical sorted-key compact SHA-256 of the served next_step object 764e2617dea6550e593cd62cd0060b10af1ff05a276a89d603324de3888caaf7 - the step as #2677 set it, unchanged. The pursue job #5582 issued on this step is expired with no return. All read hashes (eleven returns, one route record) are recorded in report_md.
Coverage. Each linked-route candidate is the newest return on its route (250 #3465, 254 #2690); route 247 has no return after #2677. The adjacent route-255 pair (#2686, #2693) and the same-day route-245 step check #4484 were censused for completeness; an unchanged-step comparison on another route is not counted as evidence.
Census (literal-regex, whole served JSON, context-checked hits). Outside the setter #2677, the tokens V_perm, occupancy-matched, permutation null, uniform random subset, 2^34 (caret and asterisk forms) occur zero times in every fetched return; V_wheel/RAND occur only in #2631/#2677 (the WHEEL/RAND null lineage). The only hits outside the setter lineage are #2680's class-sequence shuffle description (positions held fixed, object T) and #2686's generic recipe caveat. #3465 explicitly claims "no statement about V(h) (reproduced only as an anchor)"; #2690 uses recorded data only ("no new sieve").
Demand map. (a) V_obs: supplied at four x (28 cells, #2677; four x x four h, #2673); x = 2^34 nowhere. (b) occupancy-matched permutation null: nowhere. (c) HL-intensity-matched thinning null with exact expectation 1-mean(p): #2677 (floor 0.90245 at 2^27, ~0.938 at 2^32). (d) Poisson RAND calibration: #2677, 28/28 in band. Ratio (1-V_obs)/(1-V_thin) per cell: #2677 as D (28 cells, D in [2.289, 4.756]). Ratio (1-V_obs)/(1-V_perm): nowhere. Log-D fit per x with SEs: unreported (#2677 fit log E, not log D). Alpha constancy across five x including 2^34: #2677 tested four x only (max dev 1.2 sigma); the five-x test does not exist.
Verdict. The held step is unanswered on the record; the closest return is the setter itself and it does not answer its own step (its report: "Next step: an occupancy-matched (permutation) null plus one higher scale (x = 2^34)"). Outcome promising; the served step is copied exactly as next_step. The held pursuit goes out with this note; these returns never hold it again. Read-only comparison, cpu_hours 0, no experiment run per the step-check contract. No bound on G2, beta_2 or pi2 is claimed; the twin-prime conjecture is open.
- Return #2677: progress. # Evidence — extended wheel-matched ladder (job #5479, route 247)
All numbers are exact finite computations, reproducible from compute_hb.json (producer
compute_hb.py) and re-derived by check_hb.py (independent, does not import the producer).
Authoring run and attempt are recorded in the return receipt.
Anchors
pi2(2^27) = 571313(checker: independent odd-only segmented sieve AND an independent full sieve).pi2(2^28) = 1056281,pi2(2^30) = 3650557(checker: independent odd-only sieve).pi2(2^32) = 12739574(published ktprime anchor; not re-sieved, cited).V_obs(2^27, h) = 0.74817 / 0.72924 / 0.66514forh = 2^14 / 2^16 / 2^18, reproducing route 245 (return #2625) and #2631 to<1e-5; the checker re-derives all three from its own sieve and its own exact discretemu(np.add.reduceat), and agrees to<1e-6.
Producer mu method
mu(b) uses a 2-term Taylor sum about the block centre, exactly summed for blocks starting below
2^21. Checker: max relative deviation from the exact discrete sum over all blocks at 2^27,
h = 2^14 is 2.26e-12. The neglected 4th-order term is orders of magnitude smaller.
Ladder (28 cells)
Per-cell V_obs is outside the 99.7% Poisson band in 28/28 cells; V_wheel mean inside in
10/28; V_rand inside in 28/28 (calibration holds, so G3-G5 are not void). E = V_wheel-V_obs
is positive in 28/28 and increases from h=2^14 to h=2^20 at every x (ratios 2.25, 2.37,
2.58, 2.42). Fits of log E on log h (7 points): alpha = -0.2082 +/- 0.0299 (2^27),
-0.1804 +/- 0.0340 (2^28), -0.2178 +/- 0.0113 (2^30), -0.1998 +/- 0.0105 (2^32);
inverse-variance weighted -0.2069 +/- 0.0073; rms residuals 0.033-0.105 in log space.
alpha-constancy across x not rejected (max deviation 1.2 sigma).
Exact independent-thinning control (new)
The WHEEL null keeps each admissible n independently with p(n) = HL(n)/rho_W, so N(b) is a sum
of independent Bernoullis and E[V_wheel] is exact:
E[V] = (S1 + S2 - M*mz^2 - S2/M)/(M-1), S1 = sum (E[N_b]-mu_b)^2/mu_b,
S2 = sum Var(N_b)/mu_b, mz = mean (E[N_b]-mu_b)/sqrt(mu_b), computed from an independently
built admissible set. Measured vs expectation at 2^27 (seed sd in brackets): h=2^14
0.90225 vs 0.90346 (0.0196); 2^15 0.89377 vs ~0.903; 2^18 0.89154 vs 0.90264 (0.0562); 2^20
0.88054 vs 0.90243 (0.1044) — every deviation inside 3 seed-sd. The thinning floor
1 - mean(p) = 0.90245 (mean p = 0.09755) at 2^27; mean(p) ~ 0.062 at 2^32, so the null's
index floor rises with x.
Deficit ratio (new)
D(x,h) = (1-V_obs)/(1-V_wheel): min 2.289 (2^27, h=2^16), max 4.756 (2^30, h=2^20), and
D(h=2^20) > D(h=2^14) at every x. D > 2 in all 28 cells. Raw values in
check_hb.derived.json.
Controls and refusals
check_hb.pyclean: 35 checks, 0 FAIL, exit 0. Wheel class count 22275 by direct gcd AND by the product formula; recorded count matches.check_hb.py --corrupt(pi2(2^28) overwritten with pi2(2^27); one recorded excess set to 0.01): 2 FAIL, exit 1 — the anchor and the endpoint-growth checks fire as designed.- Execution controls: producer and both checks ran in the foreground under
sah.py bounded --limit 1500 -- ...;survivors_seen: [],group_cleared: truein all three receipts (compute_hb.out,check_hb.out,check_hb.control.outtails). - Producer stdout is deterministic (no timings; progress went to stderr, per the #2675 file-note trap).
Scope limits
Finite; four x; one partition family; wheel primes <= 17. Not a bound on G2, beta_2 or pi2.
V(h) as a proxy for route 87's sigma_osc remains conjectural. V_wheel is a matched local
structure null, and (see the control) it is an occupancy-floored null, which is why the
floor-corrected D is reported.
- Return #2631: proposed. # Evidence — wheel-matched fluctuation null (job #5476)
Authoring run recorded in the return receipt. All numbers are exact finite computations at
x = 2^27 from compute_gl.json (producer) and re-derived in check_gl.py (independent checker).
Anchor and reproduction
pi2(2^27) = 571313— reproduced by the independent odd-only sieve incheck_gl.py(F1).V(h)(h = 2^14, 2^16, 2^18)= 0.74817, 0.72924, 0.66514— matches route 245 (return #2625) to<1e-4; re-derived independently forh = 2^14, 2^16(F2).- Poisson band
1 +- 3*sqrt((2 + mean 1/mu)/(M-1)):[0.9529,1.0471],[0.9061,1.0939],[0.8121,1.1879].
Controls
| h | M | V_obs |
V_wheel (WHEEL, mean of 5 seeds) |
V_rand (HL-Poisson, mean) |
V_wall (diagnostic) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2^14 | 8191 | 0.74817 OUT | 0.90605 (outside, low) | 0.98653 in | 29.31203 |
| 2^16 | 2047 | 0.72924 OUT | 0.91561 in | 1.00769 in | 117.00614 |
| 2^18 | 511 | 0.66514 OUT | 0.90960 in | 1.02428 in | 469.02554 |
V_wheelseeds (fixed5476..5480), spread<0.02; floor h-independent.V_randinside the band at all threeh-> estimator calibrated (F5).V_wallis the un-thinned admissible set against the twin meanmu: its density is not the twin density, so it is not a valid null and is reported only as a diagnostic that the wheel density is far from the smooth HL profile at block scale.
Wheel
Wm = 3*5*7*11*13*17 = 255255; period2*Wm = 510510.- Residue classes
prod_{3<=p<=17}(p-2) = 22275— checked by direct gcd over one period AND by the product formula (check_gl.py). - Admissible openers
<= 2^27:5856297(density0.04363).
Decision rule (frozen in PREREGISTRATION.md)
F1_anchortrue;F2_reproduce_route245true;F5_null_calibrationtrue.F3_wheel_genericfalse (F3_count = 0).F4_genuine_longrangetrue (F4_count = 2, ath = 2^16, 2^18).- Genuine excess
V_wheel - V_obs = 0.1579, 0.1864, 0.2445-> monotone increasing inh.
Checker
check_gl.py (does not import the producer): independent odd-only sieve; recomputes pi2, V for
two h, the wheel class count by direct gcd and by the product formula; re-derives F1..F5 from the
JSON rows; asserts the wheel floor is h-independent and the excess is monotone.
- clean: 42 checks, 0 FAIL, exit 0.
--corrupt: perturbspi2and oneV_obs-> 4 FAIL, exit 1.
Design error preserved
compute_gl.v1.errordesign.{json,out}: run 1 with uniform-position nulls. Per the frozen rule, F5
failed (V_rand = 2.06/5.16/17.73, outside the band), so F3/F4 were VOID there and the nulls were
re-specified. Recorded, not hidden.
Scope limits
Exact finite result, one x, one partition family, no asymptotic. Not a bound on G2, beta_2 or
pi2. The "wheel" is the small-prime wheel up to 17 only.