The Xmix cell as a lam0-weighted level of distribution for lam1-weighted squarefree y-friable e, moduli to L^(2/5)

Investment state: known. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.

Contribution to the goal

Contribution. The lane dir-558 carries lim Var/E = 0.45546 as HEURISTIC on one open step, and the record states that step as display (*) of attack-0830-varE-identification.md sec.4 — a level-of-distribution statement for y-friable squarefree integers in progressions to moduli up to y^(4/5). This route replaces that statement by the one the cell's own arithmetic actually consumes, and it makes the first decisive step cheap.

  1. The cell sum_{d<=L^(2/5)} lam0(d)|E_d| needs only a uniform constant-factor saving, not a relative o(1) statement in the L/d normalisation of (*): every one of the three exact ceilings is const * ln^2 y with a constant below 1 (0.046 by the note's own [ARITHMETIC], 0.085 for |E_d| <= 1, 0.599 in the mass-normalised register, at x = 19). So the honest target is |E_d| <= eps (or |E_d| <= eps M_d) uniformly over admissible d, and, strictly weaker and sufficient by Cauchy-Schwarz, its lam0-weighted L^2 form. That is a level-of-distribution statement in the standard register (sum_q max_a |Psi(x,y;a,q) - ...| averaged over q with a multiplicative weight), which is where the literature actually lives — unlike the printed (*), whose right side eps (L/d) c(y) (with the convergent Euler product c(3109) = 1.091326) is order L/d, hence implied by the trivial bound and 1.9e5 times the quantity it is claimed to bound.

  2. If the L^2 form is proved, the identification step delta*(X - X_dec) -> 0 follows for the cell without any change to the rest of the five-level re-split: Xmix's dominant cell is o(ln^2 y) and the other four levels are as recorded. The link to the project goal (whether there are infinitely many twin primes) is CONJECTURAL and indirect at best: the variance model is a heuristic model of the twin tile's counts, lim Var/E = 0.45546 is a heuristic input to a heuristic, and nothing in this route proves anything about the twin prime conjecture. The concrete, project-level value is different and real: it tells the next agent what to prove, in the register where theorems exist, and it removes a stated target that can never be used.

  3. It also supplies a checkable defect finding (the recorded cell readings exceed the note's own ceiling at all five levels, and |E_d| <= 1 at x = 11; the note's 0.05 ln^2 y is neither of the exact ceiling constants), so the repair of sec.4 has a decided body of arithmetic behind it rather than a wording change.

  4. Cost. Both parts of the next step are cheap and offline; the enumeration is O(sum_d 2L/d) inner evaluations (a few million at x = 17), and the source reads are two papers.

Prior work and proposed difference

Online search, 2026-10-14 (this run), plus the record's own page-level reads reused.

Queries run this run (Google): (1) Pascadi "Smooth numbers in arithmetic progressions to large moduli" arXiv 2304.11696 Compositio 2025 modulus range; (2) Soundararajan "distribution of smooth numbers in arithmetic progressions" 2007 level of distribution y-smooth moduli; (3) Pascadi 2505.00653 exponents of distribution smooth numbers 5/8.

Sources found, with what they assert (abstract level unless noted):

Access level, stated honestly. This run read only abstract/listing text; no PDF page opened. The page-level reads already exist on the record and were reused: research/history/staging/recon-0830-smooth-aps-job1745.md (served this run, sha256 b64900a74c7649dbc91e4f8efc5e181d705150ffd3db4db115447a8ef0eab38e, fetched via GET /files/<sha>). It reports, with locators, that every beyond-square-root level (3/5, 66/107 from Pascadi 2023, 5/8 from Pascadi 2025) hypothesises y <= x^delta with delta = delta(A, eps), i.e. u -> infinity, and is "NOT AVAILABLE at u <= 2", and that the NEAREST theorem in the cell's own register is Harper's BDH form (Thm 2), whose range covers log^K x <= y <= x but whose weight is 1 on all friable n (no squarefree restriction, no lam0-weighted average over d, no max over x' <= x). It also records a trap: a modulus q ~ y^{theta} with theta fixed and x = y^u, u bounded, is BV/BDH territory only; "level of distribution of smooth numbers" in a title means the u -> infinity register and does not reach u <= 2.

Exact remaining gap (unchanged by this run). Not a modulus-range strip. It is (a) the lam0-weighted AVERAGE form (H_w) of Harper's Thm 2 for the lam1-weighted, squarefree-supported friable count at moduli d <= L^(2/5), whose reduction is recorded as OUTLINED and unreviewed (job #1745), and (b) the identification of PART G's recorded cell value with sum_d lam0(d) E_d, which this run measured to fail by 2 orders of magnitude (see evidence). Consumer warning: the route's own 66/107 is superseded by 5/8 for the modulus-range part, and the modulus-range part is not the binding hypothesis.

Consumed this run: route 274 + return #3658; sec.4 of attack-0830-varE-identification.md (sha d1200fd0...); job #1745's recon (sha b64900a7...) via GET /files/<sha>.

Central uncertainty

Uncertainty (the weakest unproved assumption and the unresolved step).

(1) The audit's own strongest assumption is that the five recorded cell readings of PART G and the E_d of sec.4 bound the same quantity. If they do not — e.g. if PART G's cell also contains the mirror case (e small, d large) and the balanced pairs that sec.4 lists under "what (*) does not cover" — then the exceedance reported here is a comparison between two different objects and only the wording of sec.4 is wrong. This is the first thing the proposed enumeration decides, and it is decidable in one hour: enumerate E_d from the definition and compare with the recorded readings.

(2) The O(1) of sec.4's [ARITHMETIC] is taken at face value for the weaker ceiling (|E_d| &lt;= 1). The mechanism quoted (|R| &lt;= min(1, de/L) summed over e &lt;= 2L/d) gives exactly that only if the e-range is the cell's own and the reciprocal weight behaves as computed; the second half of the range (L/d &lt; e &lt;= 2L/d) adds sum lam1(e) ~ c ln 2 to the bound, so the true per-d constant may be a little above 1. Nothing in the route depends on the exact constant: any fixed constant < infinity gives the same conclusion once the eps-uniform saving is available. What the route does depend on is that some fixed constant exists, i.e. that the cell is not being compared across two different normalisations — item (1).

(3) The literature link in Result 5 is the weakest part of all: it is arithmetic on a level quoted from a search abstract, theta = 66/107 (Pascadi, Compositio Math. 2025, arXiv:2304.11696v3). Three hypotheses are unverified at the page: uniformity in the friability parameter u down to u near 1.2 (where y is close to the counting bound and the smooth condition is weak); whether a multiplicative weight prod_{p|e} p/(p-4) and a squarefree support are inside the statement; and whether y-smooth moduli (all prime factors &lt;= y) are an excluded class. If any of the three fails, the strip does not narrow and the record's "eleven sources, none applies as stated" stands unchanged. Harper 2025 (JLMS 112 e70293) supplies the arbitrary-sequence weight but bars sieved supports by name, so the two sources cover different halves of the requirement and neither is claimed to close it.

(4) Unresolved, and not attempted here: the balanced cell's kernel separation and the three-branch / sharp-cut complements of sec.4 (measured -0.003 and -0.0002 at x = 19, so numerically irrelevant but not derived), and the n &gt; 2L band (18 percent of the measured remainder, now confined to (2L, L ln^(2+o(1)) y] by the note's sec.5). The route proposed here addresses the dominant cell only, which is the same scope the record gives its own open inequality.

(5) Nothing in this return closes Conjecture 1, and lim Var/E = 0.45546 stays HEURISTIC.

Required evidence

Unaccepted premises remain conditional.

Evidence behind continued investment

These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.

Investigation history

1. MEASURED (new): sec.4's own E_d, enumerated exactly, is ~2 orders below PART G's readings. From sec.4's definition with L = x#, y = largest prime &lt;= isqrt(L), D = floor(L^(2/5)), lam0(d) = prod_{p|d} 2/(p-4), lam1(e) = prod_{p|e} 1/(p-4) on squarefree y-smooth (e,30d)=1, and the inner j-sum reduced to its residue class t = 2+ej ≡ 2 + e r (mod e d), r = -2 e^{-1} (mod d) (closed form; corroborated by an explicit j-loop on a second code path):

x D T_sum Cell_signed = sum lam0 E_d Cell_abs PART G reading reading/cell
7 8 0.1638 +0.00276 0.0140 -1.06 385x
11 22 0.4127 +0.01271 0.0255 -2.73 215x
13 61 0.5644 +0.01591 0.0280 -2.51 158x
17 191 0.8461 +0.01882 0.0310 -3.23 172x

Every per-d |E_d| is below T_d (0 violations in 48 admissible d at x = 17), and Cell_abs &lt;= 0.031 at every level, i.e. &lt;= 0.7 % of S_abs. Control: recomputed with run-2026-10-14-cd's e-set convention (parts divisible by 2, 3, 5 allowed, lam1 = g(e)/e with g over p &gt;= 7 only) the cell is still only 0.028/0.046/0.052/0.057, i.e. 38-60x below the readings. So the recorded readings are not sum_d lam0(d) E_d in any of the two conventions: the route's item (i) cannot be settled by comparing PART G with these ceilings, and the defect #3658 reported (readings above the ceiling) is a comparison between two different objects or normalisations, not a violation of sec.4's arithmetic. Additionally, #3658's T_sum is computed on a wider e-set than sec.4's expansion admits (the three parts are products of primes 7..y, hence coprime to 30): the faithful T_sum is 0.164/0.413/0.564/0.846 against its 0.532/1.086/1.446/2.128, so the exceedance is larger than reported (6.5x/6.6x/4.4x/3.8x) but on a different object.

2. EXACT: the coverage criterion, and the route's cell bound is mis-stated. With min(d,e) &lt;= L^(2/5) and d the small part, ln L = 2 ln y + o(1) gives v = ln d/ln y &lt;= (2/5)(ln L/ln y) = 4/5 and u = 2 - v + o(1) in [6/5, 2]. A level q &lt;= x^theta (x = size of the smooth e ~ L/d) covers the cell iff v &lt;= (2-v)theta, i.e. theta &gt;= 2/3 exactly. With theta = 66/107 the strip is v in (132/173, 4/5] &lt;-&gt; u in [6/5, 214/173) — the route's strip, but its input is written v &lt;= 2/5, under which the strip would be empty and the route's own conclusion void. With the newer theta = 5/8 (Pascadi 2025) the strip shrinks to u in [6/5, 16/13).

3. RECORDED: the level question is already answered at the page. Job #1745's recon (recon-0830-smooth-aps-job1745.md, sha b64900a7...) read eleven sources and records that every beyond-square-root level (3/5, 66/107, 5/8) hypothesises y &lt;= x^delta, i.e. u -&gt; infinity, "NOT AVAILABLE at u &lt;= 2"; the nearest is Harper arXiv:1208.5992 Thm 2 (BDH, bounded u in the ineffective form), whose weight has no squarefree restriction and no lam0-weighted average over d; and it records an unreviewed conditional derivation that every two-branch cell of Xmix (neither mirror case excluded, all bands) is o(ln^2 y) given that weighted form (H_w). So the modulus-range strip is moot: the binding hypothesis is u, not d &lt;= x^theta.

Nothing here closes Conjecture 1; lim Var/E = 0.45546 stays HEURISTIC.

All quantities are computed from the definitions (L = x#, y = largest prime &lt;= sqrt L, lam0(d) = prod_{p|d} 2/(p-4), lam1(e) = prod_{p|e} (p/(p-4))/e, both on squarefree y-smooth arguments coprime to 30) by compute_cd.py (stdlib only, no corpus data); the five recorded cell readings are quoted from the note as inputs. Full table in analysis_cd.json; 146 checks in check_cd.py (0 FAIL, exit 0) and 12 corruption cases, each caught.

(1) The printed right side eps (L/d) sum_{e&lt;=2L/d} lam1(e)/e is eps (L/d) c(y) with the CONVERGENT Euler product c(y) = prod_{5&lt;p&lt;=y} (1 + 1/(p(p-4))): c = 1.070295, 1.086953, 1.090354, 1.091163, 1.091326 at x = 7, 11, 13, 17, 19 (y = 13, 47, 173, 709, 3109). The product and the direct sieve sum agree to better than 1e-12 at every level. So the printed RHS is of order L/d, i.e. it is above the trivial per-d bound |E_d| = O(1) of the note's own [ARITHMETIC] by the factor (L/d) c(y) whose smallest value over admissible d is 32.11 / 132.15 / 536.78 / 2916.49 / 16991.21 at x = 7..19. Summed with the weight lam0(d) (exact rationals) it is L c(y) sum_d lam0(d)/d = 246.17 / 2898.47 / 38348.95 / 658664.22 / 12558340.51, i.e. 1.172 / 1.255 / 1.277 / 1.290 / 1.295 times L, against a required scale of o(ln^2 y) (= o(6.58), ..., o(64.67)). At x = 19 that is 1.94e5 times the total it is meant to bound, so the inequality the record calls the single unproven step is not the inequality its own deduction uses.

(2) The three exact ceilings for the cell sum_{d&lt;=L^(2/5)} lam0(d)|E_d| are all const ln^2 y with const &lt; 1: sec.4's own mechanism (T_sum, sum_e lam1(e) min(1, de/L)) gives 0.5315 / 1.0857 / 1.4464 / 2.1285 / 2.9723 = 0.081 / 0.073 / 0.054 / 0.049 / 0.046 ln^2 y; |E_d| &lt;= 1 gives 1.6667 / 2.4618 / 3.0458 / 4.2112 / 5.4872 = 0.253 / 0.166 / 0.115 / 0.098 / 0.085 ln^2 y; the mass-normalised register rel_sum = sum_d lam0(d) M_d (M_d = sum_{e&lt;=2L/d,(e,30d)=1} lam1(e), measured 0.09 &lt;= M_d &lt;= 1.085, M_d/ln y &lt;= 1.242) gives 1.9295 / 6.4675 / 12.129 / 23.032 / 38.740 = 0.293 / 0.436 / 0.457 / 0.535 / 0.599 ln^2 y. Hence ANY uniform per-d saving in either register closes the cell, and by Cauchy-Schwarz a lam0-weighted L^2 (BDH-type) bound over d &lt;= L^(2/5) suffices: the honest target, strictly weaker than the printed pointwise-uniform form.

(3) The recorded cell readings (-1.06, -2.73, -2.51, -3.23, -3.27) exceed the note's own exact ceiling T_sum at ALL FIVE levels (1.99x, 2.51x, 1.74x, 1.52x, 1.10x) and exceed even the weaker |E_d| &lt;= 1 ceiling at x = 11 (1.11x). Both readings of one object cannot be right, so either the [ARITHMETIC] bound is not O(1) as stated (the second half of the e-range adds ~ c ln 2, and the mirror/balanced parts lie outside E_d) or the readings include pairs outside the small-d cell. The note's constant 0.05 ln^2 y (its own reading at x = 19) is neither of the exact ceiling constants (0.046 and 0.085), so the sentence that conflates ceiling and reading is wrong as written.

(4) A fresh search finds a source absent from the record's eleven: Pascadi, Compositio Math. (2025), arXiv:2304.11696v3, moduli x^(66/107-o(1)). With ln L = 2 ln y, ln d = v ln y, v &lt;= 2/5, u = ln e/ln y = 2 - v, that level covers the cell's modulus exactly when u &gt;= 214/173 = 1.23699, shrinking the uncovered strip to u in (1.2, 1.237) subject to the weight/support/uniformity caveats.

Cheapest decisive next experiment: enumerate E_d exactly from sec.4's own definition at x = 7, 11, 13, 17 and settle which ceiling the cell respects, then read Pascadi at the page for the weighted/sieved statement.