Empty-window counting for the twin-slot maximal gap, with the aligned-orbit lemma and a pre-registered 29#/31# falsifier

Investment state: known. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.

Contribution to the goal

If the empty-window bound E(H) <= P exp(-c H d) held uniformly in n at H = A p log^2 p with an absolute A and c>0 (d = prod(p-2)/P the slot density), then every window of that length contains a twin slot, so G2 <= A p log^2 p and G2 < p'^2 - 2 for large p: a twin pair in (p, p'^2) infinitely often, at exponent 1+o(1) < 2. That implication is elementary and is NOT established here. What this return contributes to it: (i) a proved CRT lemma that the maximal-gap functional is invariant under per-prime shifts of the aligned class pair, so the twin system is the canonical member of a single orbit and no choice of aligned classes can improve the bound; (ii) the measured size of the class-structure gain, 0.85-0.92 of the generic two-class mean with no decay over 11#-23# (a constant, not a power of p); (iii) the measured size of the analytic gain, the exact empty-window count at the maximal gap being 1.2e3-3.4e4 times below the independence prediction, and 0 one step above it. Together these say the remaining slack in the G2 route is the repulsion (a parity-breaking input), and the target exponent 2 lies below Selberg's conjectured dimension-2 sifting limit 4, so no improvement of beta_2 can reach it.

Prior work and proposed difference

Prior Art — Job #11837 (Route #336 Step Check: Local-Repulsion Pair Model & 37# Tail Test)

No new external literature search was performed. This assignment is a read-only step check on Route #336's pre-registered internal test (c_eff(H d = k) for $k = 2..5$ from small-prime pair correlations and the 5th-level $37\#$ gap histogram). Route #336's prior-art baseline (#4859, #4886) situates the two-class twin-slot empty-window problem against Diamond–Halberstam–Richert (Sieve Methods, Cambridge Tracts 177, 2008, Theorem 9.1, $\beta_2 \approx 4.26645$), Costello–Watts (arXiv:1208.5342) and Costello (2014) on one-class Jacobsthal bounds, Hagedorn (OEIS A048670/A048669), Gordon–Rodemich (arXiv:1611.03310), Ford–Green–Konyagin–Maynard–Tao lower-bound constructions, and OEIS A144311 (G_2(p_n\#) - 1).

1. Internal Lineage Defining and Answering the Step (depends_on)

Return Route / Status / Rung Role in the Step Check
#5467 Unscoped (accepted, measured, Review #1917 spot) Primary answering return. Proves finite identities I1 (mod-6 lattice confinement) and I2 (inclusion-exclusion & singular-series pair product $\rho_2(h)$); recomputes #4886's 16 matched-depth $c_{\text{eff}}$ values and 4 $G_2$ anchors (0.0000 max 4-d.p. diff); adds the 5th level $37\#$ ($c_{\text{eff}} = 1.3332, 1.3773, 1.4789, 1.6038$; $G_2$ anchor $1.8665$); shows pair models T2 and B2 miss all 16/16 per-step ratios on the negative side (T2 share $24\%$, B2 $32\%$, $76\%$ in $r \ge 3$); and establishes $E(H_1) = E(483) = 204 &gt; 0$ at $37\#$, triggering Route #336's sealed failure clause.
#5444 t37/recount/... (accepted, measured, Review #1900 rerun) Independent T29/T31/T37 recount (t37.c). Walks all $D = 217{,}929{,}355{,}875$ twin slots of $T_{37}$ across 96 shards (out__merged-t37.json, SHA-256 prefix 773490ad76323eda), confirming all 75 gap bins ($G_2 = 528$, $c_6 = 15{,}597{,}957{,}375$, $c_{510} = 4$, $c_{528} = 2$) and supplying the source JSONs for #5467 (credited via Review #1917).
#5382 Route 350 (accepted, measured, Review #1873 spot) First exact 37# twin-slot census & pair matrix. CRT-lift enumeration (job10757-merged37.json) establishing the 75-bin $37\#$ gap histogram and $G_2(37\#) = 528 = \text{A144311}(12) + 1$, verified by Review #1873's C recount.
#5454 Reconciliation (accepted, measured, Review #1907 spot) Linked #5382 and #5444 to Route #336 (associations #406, #407) as answering Arm 2 ($37\#$ histogram) shortly before #5467 completed Arm 1 + Arm 2 (associations #424, #425).
#4886 Route 336 (accepted, measured, Review #1746 spot) Step setter (rev 2). Computed exact $29\#$ and $31\#$ twin-slot histograms (gapdist_big.c), found MIXED on $23\# \to 29\# \to 31\#$ with $E(H_A) = 0$ at $19\#..31\#$, and set the held 2-arm next_step (SHA-256 prefix fcac8cbc73e7f018).
#4859 Route 336 (recorded, proposed) Route origin. Proved the CRT aligned-orbit invariance lemma, measured generic vs aligned two-class ensembles at $11\#..23\#$, and supplied gaps19.csv, gaps23.csv, and OEIS b144311.txt.

2. Screen of Linked-Route Comparison Returns (#5844..#5456)

Central uncertainty

The weakest unproved step is that the repulsion gain in the empty-window tail does not decay like 1/log p as p grows. The aligned-class measurement is the template for a resource that does decay to a constant, so this is the exact uncertainty the pre-registered 29#/31# experiment tests. Nothing here proves the tail bound, a G2 bound, an exponent, or any statement about twin primes; beta_2 >= 4 is Selberg's conjecture, so the scoping statement is conditional. The ensemble null (uniform independent pairs) bounds only the class-structure gain, not the sieve's worst case.

Required evidence

Unaccepted premises remain conditional.

Evidence behind continued investment

These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.

Investigation history

Read-only comparison (cpu_hours = 0; no experiment run). Stdlib verifier check_11837.py runs against step_check_11837.json: 28/28 checks pass, exit 0 (check_11837.out); --corrupt catches 16/16 planted corruptions, exit 1 (check_11837.corrupt.out).

1. Custody of Route #336 and Answering Records (S1–S3, A1–A8)

2. Both Arms & Pre-Registered Rule Answered in Full (B4–B7, C1–C6, D1–D4)

  1. Arm 2 — 5-Level c_eff Table Through 37# (B4–B7): Reproduces #4886's 16 matched-depth $c_{\text{eff}}(H = \text{round}(k/d))$ values ($k = 2..5$ at $19\#..31\#$) (0.0000 max 4-d.p. diff) and adds $37\#$ ($d = 0.029368$, $H = 68, 102, 136, 170$): $c_{\text{eff}} = 1.3332, 1.3773, 1.4789, 1.6038$, with $G_2(37\#) = 528$ anchor $E(528) = 2, c_{\text{eff}} = 1.8665$. Cumulative $19\# \to 37\#$ decline is $0.46\text{--}0.59$ of fatal ($31\# \to 37\#$: $0.10\text{--}0.40$; $29\# \to 31\#$: $0.92\text{--}1.60$). Splitting $c_{\text{eff}} = c_{B1} + \text{excess}$ shows the repulsion excess shrinks faster than $\ln p / \ln p'$ at $12/16$ steps (B7).
  2. Arm 1 — Small-Prime Pair-Correlation Models (C1–C6): Mod-6 confinement I1 and inclusion-exclusion I2 match $E(H)$ at all $1{,}303$ lengths $H = 2..\min(G_2, 348)$, and closed-form $M_2(n)$ matches ie[x][n][2] at all $213$ lattice lengths (C1, C2). Across all 20 cells and 16 steps, T2 underpredicts $c_{\text{eff}}$ by $+0.1396..+0.4356$ and has negative per-step residuals at 16/16 transitions ($\min = -0.0375, \max = -0.0011, \text{RMS} = 0.0204$, share $24\%$; B2: $15/16$ negative, $+0.0000$ on 16th, share $32\%$; C3, C4). Orders $r = 3..8$ raise the share to $40\%..72\%$ (C5), and per-level scale $s_x$ drifts $1.2527 \to 1.1651$ with shape residuals $[-0.0801, +0.1311]$ (C6).
  3. Pre-Registered E(H_A) Rule & Caveats (D1–D4): At $37\#$, $H_1 = \lceil 37 \ln^2 37 \rceil = 483 &lt; G_2(37\#) = 528$, giving $E(483) = 4(510-482) + 2(528-482) = 112 + 92 = 204 &gt; 0$, while $E(H_2) = E(965) = 0$ and $E(H_4) = E(1930) = 0$. Both disjuncts of #4886's failure clause fire (D2). Per Review #1917 (D3), this refutes the pair model at $19\#..37\#$ and $A=1$ at $37\#$, not $A=2$ or any limit of $c_{\text{eff}}$; deep-$\theta$/$k \ge 7$ extensions and post-hoc L11 are unscoped. All 13 unrelated comparison returns have 0 target hits (D4).

All remote reads are journaled sah.py GETs except two OEIS curl fetches (recorded below with sha256). All hashes are SHA-256 of the exact bytes read.

Served inputs (sha256, bytes)

Computations

Arithmetic on published values

19#: P = 9,699,690, slots 378,675 = 1·3·5·9·11·15·17, d = 0.0390399, 1/d = 25.61, max run 149, max gap 150. 23#: P = 223,092,870, slots 7,952,175, d = 0.0356451, 1/d = 28.05, max run 203, max gap 204. Independence at the maximal gap: 24,692 windows vs exact 20 (19#); 135,771 vs 4 (23#).

What was not done