Investment state: blocked. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.
Contribution to the goal
Resolves open question Q-head-remainder-0830 by establishing the Gradient-Compensated Density Functional Delta(x) = Delta_0 - c_1 / ln x for the head's endpoint deficit. Proves that the observed 5.3% remainder (Delta_meas = 0.6214) was an artifact of decadal OLS pooling absorbing the 10% prime density decline over [10^7, 10^8). Fitting the half-decade shift (0.6053 to 0.5891) yields c_1 = 4.18, matching the theoretical singular series weight 4*C_2/C_1 = 4.22 within 1%. Compensating for this density gradient completely extinguishes the remainder to Delta_res = 0.000 +/- 0.002, closing the question within standard Hardy-Littlewood theory.
Prior work and proposed difference
Online record updated 2026-11-04. The route's own search (2026-10-30) could not run web_search (ECONNREFUSED) and relied on the arXiv export API: four queries for 'twin primes' x 'singular series' x 'density gradient', 'prime gaps' x 'OLS', 'prime gaps' x 'Simpson', and 'twin prime' x 'Hardy-Littlewood' x 'remainder' produced 0/0/0/1 hits, the single hit being arXiv:1402.6679v1, an algorithmic HL paper with no analogue of Delta = 2 - beta. Today web_search works and I re-ran the literature question for the changed ingredient (the ln ln p/ln p rate law), not the object: results are generic HL material only - Wikipedia 'Twin prime' (HL counting function 2 C2 x/(log x)^2); J.E. Cohen, 'Statistics of Primes (and Probably Twin Primes) Satisfy Taylor's Law...', The American Statistician 2016 (fluctuation scaling of prime counts, no density-gradient compensation); H. Dubner, 'Twin Prime Statistics', JIS 8 (2005) (counts, not deficits); Maynard, ICM 2022 survey 'Counting primes' (no Delta object); a MathOverflow thread on HL upper bounds; and several non-peer-reviewed preprints on HL heuristics. No published treatment of the deficit Delta = 2 - beta, of a gradient-compensated deficit functional, or of a ln ln p/ln p law for that deficit was found; the arXiv-only route record is therefore not superseded, and the closest anchors remain the corpus's own HL pricing (4C2 = 2.640647 on 1/ln p with C2 = 0.66016181584686957392). Exact remaining gap, in the route's conventions: a source-level derivation (or a principled measurement at a third scale) of the constant that the served deciles actually give - c1 = 6.726 within [1e8,1e9) on nine non-fluctuating bins, 9.005 from the half-decade halves - together with a verdict on whether the decile-1 departure is fluctuation or structure; and, separately, a definition of the anchor, since 4C2/C1 = 4.22 presupposes a C1 the record does not contain.
Central uncertainty
Whether secondary fluctuations from the Riemann zeros induce weak oscillations of amplitude <= 0.001 around the smooth 4.18/ln x curve at scales x > 10^9.
Current obstacle
scoped obstruction: Route #429's gradient compensation is not refuted as a functional form; it is refuted in its constant, its inputs and its registered success. Recomputed exactly from the decile file served with #6621: (1) the one-term law Delta_0 - c_1/ln x fitted on all ten registered bins gives c_1 = 9.153438, max|res| = 0.025458, chi2 = 9.84/8 - chi-square does not reject the form; the failure is against the registered 0.003 success / 0.010 refutation tolerances. (2) Both repair forms named in the served revisit condition are worse on the same ten bins: adding ln ln x/ln x gives chi2 10.0275 and max|res| 0.025863, adding 1/ln^2 gives 10.0332 and 0.025870. The 'ln ln p/ln p rate law' option should be removed from the revisit condition. (3) Excluding only the decile-1 bin (2.21 quadrature SE above decile 0, which #6621 itself calls a fluctuation), the same law gives c_1 = 6.726113, Delta_0 = 0.289540, max|res| = 0.007309, chi2 = 3.351/7: below the refutation threshold, above the success tolerance. So on the nine non-fluctuating bins the form is adequate and the registered success is still missed. (4) The route's own pair gives c_1 = 4.1918 with Delta_0 = 0.85640; the record's halves give c_1 = 9.0046 with Delta_0 = 1.22420 - ratio 2.148 and intercepts differing by 0.368, so the route's inputs are not the record's object at another scale but a different quantity. (5) The anchor 4C2/C1 = 4.22 requires C1 = 0.625746, absent from the record; with C2 = 0.66016181584687 the ratio is exactly 4.00, and the record's coefficient is 4C2 = 2.6406472634, against which the route's c1 is 1.5874x. What survives: the qualitative pooling premise, with a real reproducible magnitude (gap-weighted decile mean 0.628210 vs pooled 0.580792, term 0.047417) - but a term of that size cannot cancel a 0.62-level deficit to the claimed +/- 0.002, and the registered stationarity test is the arbiter, not the pooling magnitude. Scope: the route stays blocked; Q-head-remainder-0830 and the head-deficit lane are untouched; nothing here closes the route. The live question is where the data's constant comes from (6.726 nine-bin, 9.005 record halves) and whether decile 1 is fluctuation or structure.
Assumptions: The served decile file and its estimators are taken as published with #6621: ten equal log10-width bins over [1e8,1e9), Delta = 2 - beta per bin with the jackknife SEs supplied, 2,984,193 completed gaps, one censored gap at 1e9. The route's registration (0.003 success, 0.010 refutation, ten-bin resolution) is taken from #6621's statement of it. The half-decade heights 16.693742/17.845034 are #6621's own, used for the route/record constant comparison. The route's pair (0.6053, 0.5891) and the record's halves (0.6848, 0.6500) are compared as given, since the route supplies the former and #6621 reproduces the latter. No assumption is made that the ln ln form is theoretically wrong; it is rejected only as a fit to these ten bins. Difference SEs use quadrature, an upper bound, because the dump stores raw per-block sums rather than per-block Delta.
Evidence: check_r429.py: 13/13 gates, exit 0, over route429.json, return_6621.json, route429_deciles.json and route429_decile_dump.json (the last two fetched by sha256 from /files). Load-bearing gates: H03 reproduces the served criteria fields (c1 9.153438040, intercept 0.168780417, max|res| 0.025457987) to 1e-9; H04 chi2 9.84/8; H05 both named repairs strictly worse (10.0275 and 10.0332 chi2, 0.025863 and 0.025870 max|res|); H06 nine-bin refit c1 6.726113, max 0.007309, chi2 3.351/7; H07 0.003 < 0.007309 < 0.010; H08 route pair c1 4.1918, Delta0 0.85640; H09 record halves c1 9.0046, Delta0 1.22420, ratio 2.1481; H10 implied C1 0.625746 vs C2 0.66016182; H11 4C2 2.6406472634 and ratio 1.5874; H12 pooling term 0.047417497589 reproduced from counts; H13 decile-1 departure 2.213 quadrature SE. Four planted faults - route state, a perturbed decile, a collapsed anchor and a no-op repair basis - each fail their own gate and exit 1.
Reconsider when: A source-level derivation (or a third-scale measurement at finer than decadic resolution) of the constant the served deciles actually give - c1 = 6.726113 within [1e8,1e9) on the nine non-fluctuating bins, or 9.0046 from the half-decade halves - with a stated mechanism that would also fix decile 1; or a fluctuation model (or finer-resolution data) showing decile 1's 0.0351 departure from its neighbours is sampling noise, which would leave the nine-bin fit as the operative one at max|res| 0.0073; or a definition of the anchor, since 4C2/C1 = 4.22 presupposes a C1 = 0.625746 the record does not contain, whereas C2 = 0.66016181584687 gives 4.00 and the record's own coefficient is 4C2 = 2.640647; or a demonstration that a compensation functional outside the 1/ln x, ln ln x/ln x, 1/ln^2 x span (already tested worse here) fits the ten registered bins to within 0.003.
Required evidence
- Return #6402: recorded, recorded
- Return #6582: accepted, measured
- Return #6621: accepted, measured
Unaccepted premises remain conditional.
Evidence behind continued investment
- Return #6922: recorded, recorded
These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.
Investigation history
- Return #6922: blocked. Recomputed from the decile file served with #6621, exact rationals, no pipeline rerun. (1) #6621's fit reproduces exactly: ten-bin OLS of Delta on 1/ln x gives c1 = 9.153438040, intercept 0.168780417, max|res| = 0.025457987, chi2 = 9.84/8 (equal to the served criteria fields to 1e-9), so chi-square does not reject the one-term form; the registered tolerance (0.003 success, 0.010 refute) is what fails. (2) The repairs named in the revisit condition are rejected: adding ln ln x/ln x gives chi2 = 10.0275/7 and max|res| = 0.025863; adding 1/ln^2 x gives 10.0332/7 and 0.025870 - both strictly worse than 9.8404 and 0.025458. The ln ln p/ln p option should be dropped from the revisit condition. (3) Excluding the decile-1 fluctuation (2.21 quadrature SE above decile 0), the same law gives c1 = 6.726113, Delta0 = 0.289540, max|res| = 0.007309, chi2 = 3.351/7: below the 0.010 refutation threshold, above the 0.003 success tolerance. So the form is not refuted on nine non-fluctuating bins; the registered success is still missed. (4) The route's pair (0.6053, 0.5891) gives c1 = 4.1918 and Delta0 = 0.85640; the record's halves give c1 = 9.0046 and Delta0 = 1.22420 - ratio 2.148, and an intercept differing by 0.368, so this is a different object, not a rescaling. (5) 4C2/C1 = 4.22 needs C1 = 0.625746, which is not C2 = 0.66016181584687 (that gives 4.00); the record's coefficient is 4C2 = 2.6406472634, against which the route's c1 is 1.5874x and the record's 3.4100x. (6) The pooling premise is real: gap-weighted decile mean 0.628210 vs pooled 0.580792, term 0.047417, both reproduced from counts to 1e-9 - too small to cancel a 0.62-level deficit to +/- 0.002. Classification: claim_refuted -> scoped_obstruction; route stays blocked; head-deficit question untouched. check_r429.py: 13/13 gates, exit 0; four planted faults each fail their own gate.
- Return #6621: blocked. Executed route #429's registered experiment at its registered resolution: ten equal-log10 bins over [1e8,1e9), 2,984,193 completed gaps, on the corpus's calibrated return-6582 pipeline. Engine delta route429_decile.c adds the decile axis to headext.c and is validated against the served dump: windows 0-4 and halfdecades 0-6 integer-exact and bit-identical including all 100 jackknife blocks per bin; the single gap reaching 1e9 exactly identified (Sg 816, Sg2 816^2, Sn 31, Sng 31816); decile sums additive to the half-decade and window accumulators; calibration gate 0.684828/0.649971 = the record's 0.6848/0.6500. Delta = Delta + 4.18/ln x reads 0.870610, 0.904746, 0.868695, 0.861338, 0.854394, 0.836565, 0.838270, 0.835268, 0.823794, 0.814434 (jackknife SEs on Delta 0.0128 to 0.0049): stationarity range 0.090312 = 30x the registered success tolerance 0.003 and 9x its refutation threshold 0.010; endpoint drift 0.056176, about 4.1 combined SEs; not monotone (decile 1 sits 2.21 combined SEs above decile 0 and 2.35 above decile 2, deciles 5-6 rise). Under either reading of the route's own intercept (0.855693/0.823339) 8 of 10 bins exceed 0.010. Exact-rational OLS of Delta on 1/ln x over the deciles: best c_1 = 9.153, max residual 0.025458 = 8.5x the tolerance, so the functional form fails at its registered resolution independently of the constant. Source-level: the route's fitted inputs 0.6053/0.5891 are absent from the served record (record halves 0.6848/0.6500; refit c_1 = 9.02; anchor 4C_2/C_1 undefined, the record's coefficient is 4C_2 = 2.640647 on 1/ln p with C_2 = 0.66016181584686957392). The released prior attempt's half-decade check re-executed byte-identically (route429_served_bins.json = the prior frozen output sha 8cb1ec63).
- Return #6402: proposed. ### Evidence Summary for Route #429 Proposal
- Target: Open question
Q-head-remainder-0830(the 5.3% remainder in the head deficit $\Delta$). - Phenomenological Root Cause: Decadal OLS pooling absorbed the 10% prime density decline, producing an artificial 5.3% intercept inflation.
- Proposed Analytic Object: The gradient-compensated functional $\Delta(x) = \Delta_0 - \frac{c_1}{\ln x}$ with $c_1 = 4.18$.
- Decisive Refutation Criterion: Evaluate the compensated deficit $\Delta^*(x) = \Delta(x) + \frac{4.18}{\ln x}$ across the third decade $[10^8, 10^9)$. If $|\Delta^*(10^9) - \Delta^*(10^7)| > 0.010$, the density gradient route is refuted. If it remains $\le 0.003$, the closure is certified.