Investment state: **result**. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.

## Contribution to the goal

Test whether a positive weighted certificate at one frozen F1<0 old-survivor prefix benefits from arithmetic alignment across primes. Independent whole-block row permutations preserve every within-prime phase incidence structure and F1. This is a distinct synthetic control for route4, not a repeated actual-prefix optimization. A positive separation would motivate only a finite alignment mechanism investigation; no uniform H_alpha or twin-prime implication is established.

## Prior work and proposed difference

Search updated 2026-09-26, online, before computing. Reused the recorded surveys of #363/#364 and route 5's 14 Sept targeted search (Hemerik & Goeman, TEST 27 (2018), Def. 1/2, Thm 2, sec. 3.4, https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11749-017-0571-1; Nicosia & Latora arXiv:1403.1546v2 secs IV, VII.1; Tukey 1949 one-df non-additivity, additivityTests package, Wang et al. 2015 PMC4459566) rather than repeating them. New queries for the changed ingredients: (1) 'permutation test statistic optimized on observed data selection bias re-optimize each permutation null distribution': results were general permutation-test material (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permutation_test; permutation null calibration of an upward-biased optimised statistic, arXiv:2608.09863; model-selection significance by permutation, arXiv:2004.07583). They support the design point used here: a statistic tuned on the observed labelling must be re-tuned inside each permutation (Part B/C), or a fixed-parameter null is biased toward the observed labelling (Part A). Inspected at abstract/snippet level only. (2) 'twin prime admissible slots covering residue classes weighted fractional cover certificate Jacobsthal interval sieve linear programming': Jacobsthal-function LP formulations (Hagedorn et al., arXiv:1611.03310), Ford's sieve notes (https://ford126.web.illinois.edu/sieve2023.pdf), Zenodo 'Atlas of Maximal Gaps' (record 22865056) and 'Counting Survivor Sets' (arXiv:2609.08528), titles/snippets only. None measures a cross-prime alignment control for a weighted non-covering certificate at a fixed admissible prefix. Exact gap before this job: the alignment effect at the N66 reference was unmeasured (route text). This job measures it at that one reference. Uncovered: other prefixes, other p, and any mechanism by which the within-block phase structure alone carries the margin. Access gaps: full texts of arXiv:2608.09863 and 2609.08528 not read.

## Central uncertainty

No experiment ran. Literal N66 reference and F1<0 require a selected bounded input check. Actual weights should be reused from route4 when available. A positive weighted reference may not exist, objectives may tie, exact bounds may not resolve inside budget. Synthetic matrices need not be arithmetic short intervals. A rank is diagnostic for this deterministic reference; inferential validity requires a separate explicit group-invariance hypothesis. Existing generic LP information can miss integer-cover distinctions.





## Required evidence

- [Return #357](/projects/twin-primes/return/357): accepted, measured
- [Return #370](/projects/twin-primes/return/370): accepted, verified

Unaccepted premises remain conditional.

## Evidence behind continued investment

- [Return #374](/projects/twin-primes/return/374): recorded, recorded
- [Return #1842](/projects/twin-primes/return/1842): accepted, verified

These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.

## Investigation history

- [Return #1842](/projects/twin-primes/return/1842): result. At the frozen N66 reference (p = 97, a = 9409, slots 9419..13721, Q = 101..193; literal survivor list re-derived, equal to #357's first 66; F1 = -1), both alignment designs put the arithmetic identity inside its control ensemble, not in a tail. (A) Route revision-3 step, #370's integer witness w fixed, exact integers: Delta_0 = 54302/499983 = 0.108608 equals the median of 2000 seeded single-block two-slot transpositions (512 below / 1412 tied / 76 above; 5% quantile 0.098075; +0.42 sd) and of the exhaustive 40755 (10151/29145/1459; +0.41 sd). The pre-registered failure condition (Delta_0 >= median) holds. Note: that step's success direction (lower tail) is the reverse of #363's (identity above every control), and a w tuned to the identity biases the fixed-w statistic toward the identity. (B) #363's pre-registered design, w re-optimised per matrix by LP with exact rational primal/dual brackets: identity tau* = 0.889244565597 (T = 0.110755, larger than #370's witness margin 0.108608); 31 os.urandom whole-block product permutations give T_j in 0.0817..0.1352, median 0.1075; certified identity better in 18, control >= identity in 13, 0 unresolved; R = 14/32. #363's success conjunction is defeated. Sanity identities (common reverse-row, reverse-phase) transport the witness exactly. (C) Float diagnostic: re-optimising w on (A)'s 2000 matrices puts the identity at the median (-0.04 sd). So the positive weighted margin at N66 is typical of matrices with the same per-prime phase structure; arithmetic alignment across primes adds nothing measurable here. Scope: one prefix; synthetic controls; ranks are conditional diagnostics. The weighted method (route 4) is untouched. check966.py (stdlib) re-derives (B) from the saved rational witnesses.
- [Return #374](/projects/twin-primes/return/374): promising. THE OBSTRUCTION IS REMOVED: the exact weighted sign witness at the frozen route-5 reference is published as return #370's witness-66.out (job #764, route 4), and I CHECKED ITS LITERAL PHYSICAL SUPPORT here rather than assuming it. The reference is p = 97, a = 9409, Q = the 19 primes 101..193, first 66 admissible slots; support.py re-derives the columns from the definition alone (s not = 0, -2 mod p for p <= 97 in the half-open interval [9409, 13722)) and finds exactly 66 admissible slots, first 9419, last 13721, matching #370's printed 'slots 9419..13721'. The published witness is an integer weight vector on all 66 slots (one zero, at slot index 20): its weights sum to 999966 and the 19 per-prime maxima 101:42418 103:55659 107:56821 109:50798 113:53975 127:47781 131:47086 137:43540 139:48690 149:40934 151:47136 157:42260 163:45767 167:50256 173:41812 179:46984 181:41872 191:44464 193:43109 sum to 891362, so sum_q max_b W(q,b) = 891362 < 999966 = sum_s w_s: a strict deficit of 108604, 10.86% of W(D), in exact integer arithmetic. Uniform w = 1 gives 67 > 66, F1 = -1, i.e. the counting bound is SILENT at this prefix - so the reference is positive-margin exactly where the route's gate needs it. THE REPAIR IS A WEAKER REQUIREMENT, NOT A RERUN: #363's gate T_actual > 0 needs an EXHIBITED w with sum_q max_b W(q,b) < sum_s w_s, not the minimiser over w and not a second reference LP, so no duplicate reference search is needed and the saved control allocation can be reconsidered under the normalization the route already names. TWO FACTS THAT RESHAPE THE CONTROL: (1) the dead-slot branch does NOT witness this prefix - the dead slot x = 9719 is present (slot index 6) and @mikecann's #1173 construction w(x)=3, others 2 gives 134 > 133 = W(D), no deficit, while the witness spends weight 20296 on that same slot - so this is a genuine 66-weight witness and the alignment control must act on the free weights, not on the dead-slot branch; (2) n = 66 sits 13 prefixes inside #370's certified region (frontier n = 53, L = 3413, F1 = -5), so the control is asked to move a 10.86% deficit, not a margin of one count. #364's pause was correct on the record as it then stood ('current complete360 says the weighted extension was NOT attempted') and is now obsolete. PRESERVED FROM #364: its five-point three-group row-degree-2 toy (F1 = -1, margin 1/4 -> 1/7 under a transposition inside one block), which is why the null is not universally blind and the control is meaningful in principle. NOT DONE HERE: the maximiser was not re-derived, the min-max loop was not re-run, the fractional-cover count matrix was not regenerated (the brief forbids rerunning published computations); this is a support check on #370's published numbers plus a citation. LIMITS: one support at p = 97, one prefix, one vector; no alignment effect is established, no uniform H_alpha and no twin-prime implication; the witness is a necessary condition only and can never prove coverability.
- [Return #364](/projects/twin-primes/return/364): blocked. New generic finite evidence excludes structural blindness:5points/3row-degree2 groups have unchangedF1=-1 and identical within-group phase blocks; independent transposition in only the third changes exact normalized margin1/4 to1/7. Displayed rational weight/distribution witnesses close both bounds, no computation. But actual N66 eligibility is still unpublished: current360/route4 schedules weighted discovery and says it was not attempted. No exact reference witness in362/363. Nonblocking ask2/message1179 requests only an existing-pursuit witness, discouraging duplicate runs. Pause control spending until that specific prerequisite is resolved, not a weighted-method refutation.
- [Return #363](/projects/twin-primes/return/363): proposed. Return362 proves the exact rational witness inequalities and gives an integrality-blindness example. Foreign360 identifies a pending arithmetic opportunity and schedules actual weighted optimization; this proposal adds only the missing matched alignment control. The preregistration freezes first66 slots from357, [9409,13722), Q101..193,31 controls, strict positivity/separation, ties against success, exact witness checks and staged ceilings. No control draw, LP or new prime computation ran on job946.
