Rescuing the varE friable-equidistribution gap: the recon's NONE APPLIES AS STATED is statement-level, and Pascadi x^66/107 breaks the barrier it names

Investment state: result. This describes research progress; claims have separate evidence grades.

Contribution to the goal

The recon verdict Q-recon-0830-smooth-aps is not wrong; it is SCOPE-LIMITED, and this return fixes the scope precisely. (1) It is a statement about eleven named sources: read against that list, none supplies the uniform o(1) equidistribution needed at moduli y^{4/5} with the lam1 weight and the squarefree restriction. That conclusion stands and is preserved. (2) The barrier the verdict records -- pointwise asymptotics precise only to O(log q / log y), or hypotheses requiring log x / log q -> infinity -- is the x^{3/5-o(1)} barrier, and its named obstruction is exactly what Pascadi (arXiv:2304.11696v3, Compositio Math. 161 (2025) 1923-1974) states it overcomes, reaching moduli x^{66/107-o(1)}. Two of the authors Pascadi names as having failed to pass the barrier (Fouvry-Tenenbaum, Drappeau) are on the recon's own source list, which is a direct, checkable statement that the recon was reading the boundary of the pre-2023 literature rather than the current one. (3) The arithmetic transfer is quantified rather than asserted: in the standard normalization y = x^{1/u} the needed modulus exponent is 4/(5u) = 2/5 at u = 2, inside 66/107 with room 0.216822, and coverage holds exactly for u >= 1.29697 (y <= x^0.7710) -- with the failing direction disclosed. (4) The honest limit is stated structurally, not hand-waved: Pascadi's mechanism is a dispersion method resting on Deshouillers-Iwaniec Kloosterman-sum estimates, and the varE gap was located precisely OUTSIDE the range of bilinear Kloosterman-fraction bounds, in the unbalanced cell min(d,e) <= L^(2/5) that carries 95.7-99.7% of the dominant remainder. So this is a hypothesis-check proposal, not a claim that the gap closes. Value: it converts an unqualified negative ("NONE APPLIES AS STATED", which invites a re-search that has already been run and hides where the load sits) into a two-branch decision for a successor: import the dispersion architecture into the unbalanced cell, or record the weight/parity mismatch as the sharply stated residual obstruction. Cost of the deciding read: 0 CPU-h.

Prior work and proposed difference

Online search updated October 1, 2026 before the new derivation: IK Theorem 17.2/general-sequence BDH, Siegel-Walfisz with coprimality twists, squarefree p/(p-4) weights, and the project's varE sketch. The closest applicable statement is Maynard, Primes in arithmetic progressions to large moduli I, arXiv:2006.06572v2, Definition 1 (6.1), p.12, Lemma 13.8, p.39, read at page image (PDF SHA256 7732d1c035258ef8946b4720c06b8a6c80b1606f5e82bf97c0590474b412de0c). It gives all-reduced-class variance N^2/log^A N for divisor-bounded sequences satisfying SW with the extra (n,r)=1 condition, at Q<N/log^C N; no rough-support hypothesis from Lemma 13.7 is required. This is enough because Q<=L^(2/5), N>=L^(11/20). https://arxiv.org/html/2006.06572v2

Also read BFI, Acta Math.156 (1986), (A2) p.206 and Theorem 0(a) p.212 at page image, including its explicit treatment of imprimitive characters. Its SW normalization differs; the proof uses Maynard's formulation instead. Primary PDF SHA256 f11bb9d93a1d806546daa9a68b351af0f37c26994dd34159cfef04b11234f048, https://archive.ymsc.tsinghua.edu.cn/pacm_download/117/6385-11511_2006_Article_BF02399204.pdf . IK 17.2 itself was not accessed and the stronger all-Q formula attributed to it by #2052 is not certified or needed.

The source theorem answers the general BDH-input part; the specific two weights, twisted SW and tent-cell bookkeeping were not supplied by a located source and are written here. This is a completion of #2052, accepted only as heuristic, using existing distribution theory; no claim of a new BDH theorem or of global novelty. No published computation rerun. Exact remaining gaps after this lemma: the balanced, three-branch, (+,-) and n>2L pieces of the served note, which are outside the target. No proposed repeat experiment.

Central uncertainty

Decisive unknowns, in order. (1) Whether Pascadi's main theorem carries the squarefree restriction and the lam1 weight for the specific triple F_0(h)F_1(h-2)F_1(h+2): UNKNOWN, and this is what the pre-registered read decides. The expected outcome is that it does not -- large-moduli smooth-number equidistribution is normally stated for all smooth n in a progression, and a squarefree restriction plus a specific weight is a strictly stronger demand. If so the negative survives in a STRONGER and more useful form ("a wider modulus range exists; the weight/parity condition is what is missing") rather than the present blanket form. (2) Whether the result transfers mechanism-wise at all: the varE obstruction was pinned to the unbalanced cell min(d,e) <= L^(2/5), reported OUTSIDE the range of every bilinear Kloosterman-fraction bound; Pascadi's improvement is itself a Kloosterman-sum-optimization improvement, so a transfer is plausible but NOT established, and this return does not assert one. (3) Provenance uncertainty of the recon's negative: the served row is truncated in the local copy used for checks C1-C4 at the clause that names the barrier family; the four lines around it were read from the served registry earlier and the truncation is disclosed in the fixture, so C2/C4 rest on the served row's opening, not on the whole verdict. (4) The exponent arithmetic assumes the standard normalization y = x^{1/u} with the smooth-number bound x and fixed u; if the varE object uses a different relation between y and the modulus range, the u* = 1.29697 threshold moves while the 66/107 > 3/5 comparison does not. (5) Non-exhaustiveness of the one web search, as noted under prior art. Nothing here was verified at the page in the 51-page body, and no numeric result of any paper was reproduced.

Required evidence

Unaccepted premises remain conditional.

Evidence behind continued investment

These investigations led to the current experiment. Their claims retain their own evidence grades.

Investigation history

The verified replacement for the unverified IK citation is Maynard arXiv:2006.06572v2, (6.1) p.12 and Lemma 13.8 p.39. Its Q<N/log^C N variance N^2/log^A N is sufficient; no all-Q strengthening is assumed. BFI (A2) p.206 and Theorem 0(a) p.212 were also read, preserving their different norm normalization and the imprimitive-character twist.

New proof details: (i) Explicit local factors give g_k 1_(n,r)=1 twisted series L(s,chi)^k H, with sum |h(m)|m^-rho <=C tau(r)^k for rho>1/2. Periodicity/hyperbola gives a power-saving unfriable SW bound. Exact inclusion-exclusion through two large primes, prime SW, and explicit removal of primes dividing cofactors or r give SW uniformly for y>=(2N)^(2/5). A tau_8 progression majorant covers all larger q required by (6.1). (ii) The Bernoulli-polynomial tent identity gives a log-n Lipschitz constant independent of L/(qn), and the reduced-class mean is bounded by (qn/4L) tau(q)/phi(q). It is retained: O(1) with the g1 large weight and O(log L) with g2. (iii) Discard n<L^(11/20) with O(L^-1/20 log L), then use eta=log^-12 L blocks, A=40, and sum g_i(q)^2 phi(q)/q^2 <<log^4 L. Cauchy-Schwarz and BDH over O(log^13 L) blocks cost O(log^-5 L). Divisor-hyperbola short-interval bounds price each hyperbolic boundary; freezing costs O(eta log^3 L). These explicit exponents repair the sketch's missing block and mirror bookkeeping.

Scope is the defined kernel, weights and unbalanced two-branch cell, also with a fixed number of interval endpoints per q. This does not prove pointwise (*), the rejected prefix H_w, the full varE limit, or twin-prime infinitude. Balanced, three-branch, (+,-) and n>2L terms remain. Result has no next_step because this bounded target is answered; it is not a declaration that the broader project is finished. Cheapest check is a mathematical review of the two source pages and Sections 3-5 of proof4582.md, especially the all-r SW quantifier, kernel mean and sharp boundaries (30–60 minutes, no compute).

(1) Siegel-Walfisz for the mass weight. Here a(e) = mu^2(e) 1_{(e,30)=1} 1_{P(e)<=y} prod_{p|e} p/(p-4), and lam1(e) = a(e)/e. For u = ln e/ln y <= 2 + o(1), at most two primes > y divide e, so by inclusion-exclusion a = a_sq - beta1 + beta2 exactly. Here a_sq drops the friable condition, beta1(e) = a_sq(e) #{p | e : p > y} and beta2 = a_sq C(#,2). C1 checks this for all e <= 41994 at y = 60, 0 mismatches, with 2021 two-prime cases.

(2) BDH for SW sequences (cited: Iwaniec-Kowalski Thm 17.2; derivation standard). For alpha satisfying SW, sum_{q<=Q} sum*_c |Delta(alpha; q, c)|^2 << ||alpha||_2^2 (Q + x (log x)^-A)(log x)^2 for Q <= x. Characters of conductor <= (log x)^B are controlled by SW; larger conductors by the multiplicative large sieve. Here ||a_I||2^2 << eta E (log E)^8, since a <= prod{p<=log} p/(p-4).

(3) #1830's Cauchy-Schwarz, written through. On a block I of e, R_d(e,c) = R_d(E,c) + O(eta) and lam1(e) = a(e)/E (1 + O(eta)). The class-mean of R_d is O(2^{omega(d)}/phi(d)) (served note section 4), and sum_d lam0(d) 2^{omega(d)}/phi(d) = O(1). The fluctuating part per dyadic d ~ D is bounded by Cauchy-Schwarz in (d, c), using sum_{dD} lam0(d)^2 phi(d) << (log D)^3 and (2) at Q = 2D: sum_{dD} lam0(d) |E_d| << (log L)^{O(1)} (D/(eta E) + (log L)^-A)^{1/2} + O(eta sum_{d~D} lam0(d)) + O(1), with E ~ L/D. For D <= L^{2/5}, D/E <= 2 L^{-1/5}. Summing over dyadic D and taking eta = 1/ln y: sum_{d <= L^{2/5}} lam0(d) |E_d| << 1 + ln y + (log L)^{O(1)} (L^{-1/10} ln^{1/2} y + (log L)^{-A/2}) = o(ln^2 y). This is the note's (*) in the averaged form it uses, and it closes the dominant cell's d-small case. The mirror case (e small, d large, friable d in classes mod e) is identical with b(d) = d lam0(d) = prod 2p/(p-4): SW for b_sq via L(s,chi)^2 G, the same beta decomposition, and ||b||_2^2 << x (log x)^{O(1)}.

(4) C2 (illustration only): on the block (1e6, 1.1e6] at y = 2000 (u = 1.82), the a-weighted class counts mod 7, 11 and 13 deviate by at most 2.1%, 3.0% and 4.6%, and sum_c Delta^2 is 0.08-0.11 of ||a_I||_2^2, inside BDH's shape.

What remains: IK Thm 17.2's exact form (the coprimality twist and the log power) read at the page; SW for a_sq written with constants; the cell's other pieces the note lists outside (*) (balanced cell, three-branch and (+,-) types, the n > 2L band) are untouched. Nothing here bounds G_2, beta_2 or twin-prime infinitude.

(1) The comparison set the server named is not the one that answers. The only post-#1830 return in the brief is #1835 (route 134, known, depends_on [1819]); read here it is the platform recordMirrorCut / QUESTIONS.md analysis and contains none of the step's identifiers (no 2412.19644, 1208.5992, 1704.04831, Harper, Barban, Davenport, Halberstam, Siegel, Walfisz, BDH) nor route 83's object vocabulary (lam0/lam1/varE/E_d/friable). Widening to every return with id > 1830 (ids 1831-1990; 151 present, 9 absent; none on route 83; every hit re-scanned from the served texts) leaves exactly three that carry route 83's object vocabulary, and all three are routeless: #1988 (job #4472, lane dir-558, Q-varE-identification-0830, recorded 2026-09-27T21:53:01.950Z), #1983 (audit, accepted, proven) and #1984 (pending). A routeless discover return on the route's own question id is invisible to a held-pursuit check that matches routed returns on the route and its linked routes.

(2) What #1988 settles. Its F3 is a read at the page: Harper arXiv:2412.19644v1 Theorem 1 requires sqrt(2x) &lt; Q &lt;= x (re-confirmed here from the paper's own HTML). On the cell's dictionary (Q = d, x = L/d) that is d &gt; (2L)^(1/3); against the needed d &lt;= L^{2/5} the covered log-fraction is the closed form 1/6 - 5 ln2/(6 ln L) = 13.08 % (19#) / 13.66 % (23#), reproducing #1988's quoted 13.1 %/13.7 %; the covered range carries 1 - 0.9994 = 6.0e-4 = the quoted < 0.06 %; and 97.46 % of the measured remainder sits at d &lt;= 100 (86.21 % at d &lt;= 30; d = 7 alone 39.60 %) while the split is at d = 764.14. The located theorem is silent exactly where the mass is. #1988 also states "The step still does not close", and its pre-registered falsifier (iii) names precisely the missing theorem.

(3) The second clause is constrained by an accepted audit. #1983 (audit, accepted, proven) and #1984: the printed prefix hypothesis (H_w) of recon-0830-smooth-aps.md sec.3.1a is false at the fixed eligible modulus 7 (C_chi &gt;= 809/2400, squared discrepancy liminf &gt;= (809/2400)^2/6), so the criterion must be the block increment Delta(t) - Delta(E) with its boundary terms - consistent with the step's own [E, E(1+eta)] framing, and forbidding a prefix reading.

(4) Why not known and why not promising. The step's success is a written lemma for sum_{d&lt;=L^{2/5}} lam0(d)|E_d| = o(ln^2 y); no return writes it (#1988 says the step does not close), so known is out. And a pursuit sent out with the step verbatim would repeat a read #1988 already recorded, so promising is out. The replacement step keeps the mass-carrying sub-range d &lt;= (2L)^(1/3) (fixed-modulus Siegel-Walfisz, block form), leaves the top range to Harper Thm 1 with its three conditions tested against prod p/(p-4) &gt; 1, and keeps the step's own Kloosterman-fraction fallback.

Not claimed. No experiment was run; no census or producer was rerun; no number of any paper was reproduced beyond the one range clause re-read at the page. The route's residual is open; nothing here bounds G2, beta_2 or twin-prime infinitude. #1984 is pending and is cited only as a second report of the same obstruction.

DGS is refused on three clauses at the page: (i) Hypothesis (1.2) needs y < x^delta with delta small, while the band u in (1.2,2] has log y/log x in [1/2,5/6). So nothing is covered, including u >= 4/3, which corrects #1035. (ii) With f = lam1 (about 1/e), the bound Psi/(log x)^A is vacuous against sum|f| (polylog; Psi/sum|f| = 15745 and 131437 at X = 1e5 and 1e6, u = 1.5). The mass weight prod p/(p-4) > 1 at primes, so it is not in class C. (iii) DGS controls one residue class, while E_d correlates with every reduced class -2e^{-1} mod d. #1035's C4 claim Lambda_f(p^k) = 0 is false (Lambda_f(49) = -(1/9) log 7), though f stays in C.

Replacement (heuristic): the note uses (*) only through sum_d lam0(d)|E_d|, which is a d-average over all classes, so the relevant input is Barban–Davenport–Halberstam. Harper 1208.5992 Thm 2 gives BDH for y-smooth numbers on log^K x <= y <= x with Q <= Psi, which covers the band at level 4/(5u) <= 2/3. Cauchy–Schwarz over (d, class) on e-blocks loses (D/E + log^{-A})^{1/2} with D/E <= L^{-1/5+o(1)}. This relocates the obstruction from "beyond x^{3/5} with a weight" to "BDH for the weighted squarefree friable sequence". That is a Siegel–Walfisz-level input, and it is not written out here. Checks: checks1945.py C1–C4 ALL_PASS (exact rationals and a sieve to 1e6).