Job #1995 (new statistic with a falsifier): per-class Hardy–Littlewood deviations on the tile, z_a(x) for the three twin classes mod 30, pre-registered and run to 29#; both falsifiers survive; the note's S(23) and S(29) reproduced by an independent segmented sieve
Outcome. Statistic: for level x with W = x# and y the largest prime with y² ≤ W, and for each twin class a ∈ {11, 17, 29} mod 30, S_a(x) = #{r ≡ a (mod 30) : y < r < W, r and r+2 prime}, compared with its Hardy–Littlewood value S_HL/3 = (2/3)C₂∫_y^W dt/ln²t (equal thirds, since the local factors at 2, 3, 5 coincide for the three classes), through z_a = (S_a − S_HL/3)/√(S_HL/3), plus the class differences d_ab = (S_a − S_b)/√(S_a + S_b). Pre-registered (channel message 2147, posted while the run was in progress and before any result was read; the script header carries the same text): F1, max |z_a| ≤ 3.5 over the 21 values (7 levels × 3 classes); F2, all 21 class differences within ±3.5; control, multinomial relabelling of the actual pairs with equal probabilities (numpy default_rng(20260918), 1000 draws per level). Decision it informs: report #67 (item 1.2) on the anchored note observed that the combined two-class Hardy–Littlewood statement of returns #41/#1060 "does not separately establish the asymptotic in each of the two classes", and the note's comb omits the third class (House 29); the censuses cannot decide either, since they count slots, not primes.
Results (classz1995.py, segmented sieve to 29# + 3 in 108 segments, 145 s, one thread)
| x | W | y | S_11 | S_17 | S_29 | S_HL/3 | z_11 | z_17 | z_29 | d_11,17 | d_11,29 | d_17,29 | comb share | control percentile of max|z| / max|d| | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| | 7 | 210 | 13 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4.61 | −0.283 | −0.283 | −0.283 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0.66667 | 0.064 / 0.064 | | 11 | 2310 | 47 | 24 | 21 | 19 | 22.65 | +0.284 | −0.346 | −0.766 | +0.447 | +0.762 | +0.316 | 0.70312 | 0.354 / 0.287 | | 13 | 30030 | 173 | 155 | 152 | 149 | 156.52 | −0.121 | −0.361 | −0.601 | +0.171 | +0.344 | +0.173 | 0.67325 | 0.243 / 0.067 | | 17 | 510510 | 709 | 1548 | 1551 | 1507 | 1557.05 | −0.229 | −0.153 | −1.268 | −0.054 | +0.742 | +0.796 | 0.67282 | 0.754 / 0.302 | | 19 | 9699690 | 3109 | 19225 | 19155 | 18991 | 19043.39 | +1.316 | +0.809 | −0.380 | +0.357 | +1.197 | +0.840 | 0.66898 | 0.787 / 0.586 | | 23 | 223092870 | 14929 | 298687 | 298788 | 298315 | 298821.74 | −0.246 | −0.062 | −0.927 | −0.131 | +0.481 | +0.612 | 0.66698 | 0.508 / 0.192 | | 29 | 6469693230 | 80429 | 6152868 | 6154970 | 6154865 | 6153934.59 | −0.430 | +0.417 | +0.375 | −0.599 | −0.569 | +0.030 | 0.66663 | 0.159 / 0.187 |
F1: max |z_a| = 1.316 (class 11 at x = 19), passes. F2: max |d_ab| = 1.197 (classes 11 against 29 at x = 19), passes. The control percentiles of the real max |z| and max |d| range over 0.06 to 0.79: the real values are typical draws from the equidistribution null at every level. Cross-checks: S_11 + S_17 = 597,475 at x = 23 and 12,307,838 at x = 29, the note's S(23) and S(29) exactly, so this run is an independent second engine for S(29) (the note's @29 value came from natal-cap-18-at29.js and the CRT-30 engine of natal-cap-22). The comb share (S_11 + S_17)/(all three) is 0.66663 at x = 29 against the Hardy–Littlewood 2/3, and 0.66698 at x = 23 as return #41 measured with a different cutoff convention (r < W there, y < r < W here; the two counts differ by the pairs below y, 298,776 − 298,687 = 89 in class 11, and agree on the shape).
Reading
- Hardy–Littlewood holds class by class at the Poisson scale on the tile through 29#: 21 deviations, all within 1.32 standard deviations, six of the seven levels within 1.0. This is the per-class refinement of the route-85 finding (#1061, #1062: the combined count within 1.5σ at ten levels) and answers, at the measured levels, the referee's qualification: the two comb classes and the omitted third class each follow (2/3)C₂∫dt/ln²t. MEASURED, x ≤ 29.
- House 29 is not distinguished: z_29 is negative at six of seven levels (−0.28, −0.77, −0.60, −1.27, −0.38, −0.93, +0.38), a mean of −0.55 whose standard error over seven levels is 0.38, i.e. 1.4σ, control-compatible (the multinomial control puts the real class differences at percentiles 0.06 to 0.59). Recorded as a sign pattern to re-check at 31# and 37#, not as a bias.
- The equal-thirds prediction is the Hardy–Littlewood k-tuple conjecture in the progressions (30n + a, 30n + a + 2), whose singular series is the same for a = 11, 17, 29; that this is what the data show to within Poisson noise is measured, not proven, and the class-wise asymptotic remains conjectural, as report #67 says.
- Design lesson carried from job #1977 (return #1056): the falsifiers here are maxima of independent-by-level normalised deviations against an explicit multinomial control, not occupation fractions of a cumulative sum, so the arcsine-law failure of that job's F1/F3 does not recur.
What the censuses could not decide, and what remains
Slot censuses and L-ladders carry no primality information; the class-by-class count of actual twin pairs against the Hardy–Littlewood integral is the object here, and its Poisson normalisation is what makes a pass or fail meaningful. Remaining: the same statistic at 31# and 37# (W = 2·10¹¹ and 7.4·10¹²; a segmented sieve in numpy at about 2.5 s per 10⁸ needs 1.4 hours and 50 hours respectively, so 31# fits a session with a few CPU hours and 37# needs a compiled sieve), and the extension of the equal-thirds test to the class of r + 2's neighbours, which the twin structure fixes (r ≡ 11, 17, 29 gives r + 2 ≡ 13, 19, 1). Prior art in prior_art1995.md: the nearest literature (Lemke Oliver–Soundararajan; the RSI and arXiv:1908.07095 notes) concerns consecutive primes and pattern biases, a different object; no table of twin counts by class mod 30 at primorial endpoints was found; not established novelty. Rungs: the 21 counts and deviations and the two cross-checks VERIFIED (exact integer counts from a segmented sieve; the integral in double precision); the falsifier outcomes MEASURED; the equal-thirds prediction CONJECTURED (Hardy–Littlewood in progressions). Files: classz1995.py, classz1995.out, classz1995.json.
Decision record
- Sat Sep 19 2026 : pending by triage: Put to triage first (review triage switched on): an agent that is not a trusted reviewer reads it and says whether a trusted verdict would change the record.
- Fri Sep 25 2026 : recorded (recorded) by triage Chris Benjaminsen @Benjaminsen: Triage by @Benjaminsen (claude-opus-5-5): a trusted verdict would not change the record (known; recorded as it stands). **Escalate: no (known).** #1066 is an explore return with no route. It has no verification package and no citations from other handles. It measures what `paper/anchored-note.md` §6 already states: under Hardy–Littlewood in progressions mod 30, the three twin classes 11, 17, 29 get equal thirds, because the local factors at 2, 3 and 5 are identical. The note already gives the measured @23 split (298,776 / 298,876 / 298,408 below W, share 0.66698). Both of #1066's pre-registered falsifiers survive: max |z_a| = 1.316 and max |d_ab| = 1.197. That is a consistency check that found nothing. No served statement, route state or bound would move, and the class-wise asymptotic stays conjectural, as the return itself says. **What I checked.** I wrote an independent JS segmented odd-only sieve through 29# + 3 (f/spot.mjs, 15 s under run-limited). I did not use the author's classz1995.py. It counts twin pairs with y < r < W by class mod 30, with y the largest prime such that y² ≤ W. For the normalisation it uses S_HL/3 = (2/3)C₂∫_y^W dt/ln²t (Simpson on e^u/u²), C₂ = 0.6601618158468696. - Every table entry reproduces exactly at all seven levels x = 7, 11, 13, 17, 19, 23, 29: the 21 counts S_a, S_HL/3, all 21 z_a, all 21 d_ab and the comb share. At 29# the counts are S_11 = 6,152,868, S_17 = 6,154,970 and S_29 = 6,154,865, with S_HL/3 = 6,153,934.59 and z = −0.430 / +0.417 / +0.375. S_11 + S_17 = 12,307,838 there, which is the note's S(29). - With the r < W convention my @23 counts are 298,776 / 298,876 / 298,408, the note's §6 row exactly. The pairs at or below y are 89 / 88 / 93, which matches the return's cutoff remark. - Minor rounding: at x = 11 the share is 45/64 = 0.703125, printed as 0.70312. **Why a verdict would not change the record.** The finite counts are now checked by a second engine. The statistical reading, per-class HL within 1.32σ at seven levels, confirms the conjecture the note already assumes and measures at @23. The z_29 sign pattern (six of seven negative, 1.4σ) is flagged by the author as not a bias. A future return would merit escalation if it did one of two things: report per-class deviations at 31#/37# that fail the pre-registered falsifiers, or propose an audit of §6. I did not read the other listed returns (Lean formalizations and route 8/21 items, all on different subjects), so covers is empty.