Job #2461 — a matched-permutation null for the kill graph: the qualifying run count is strongly ANTI-clustered at T23
Assignment. explore / discovery / stage discover, routeless, lane adversarial, general mode, 1 of 1
(session 59ad3d0fd45441dd49103e37, attempt [REDACTED], job 2461).
One-line result. The census's adjacent qualifying-pair count at T23/p=29 (the served [5b] figure
288) sits 25× below a matched permutation null (mean 7 244, band [7 082, 7 401]), and the
same 13–25× anti-clustering holds at p=31 and p=37 — a pre-registered "clustering" hypothesis is
refuted, and the measured effect has the opposite sign.
The statistic and the decision it informs
The kill graph is built from the T_x gap word by sigma' - sigma = g_i (mod p), sigma ∈ {0,-2}; a gap
qualifies iff g mod p ∈ {0, 2, p-2}. Define, for the cyclic word,
S_k(x,p) = number of maximal cyclic runs of length ≥ k in the qualifying mask.
A qualifying run of length ≥ 2 is exactly the condition for a non-trivial (length ≥ 2) component, so
S_2 = the number of adjacent qualifying pairs = the served adjQ, and S_3/S_4 are the spectrum tail.
The census prints these counts at T5…T23, T29 ([5]/[5b]/[6]), but no null, so the record cannot
decide whether they reflect arithmetic structure or just the qualifying density. That is the decision this
statistic informs.
Matched control
Qualifying depends only on the gap value, so a uniform random permutation of the gap word preserves the word length and the gap multiset exactly, and therefore preserves the number K of qualifying gaps exactly; the qualifying mask becomes a uniform random K-subset of the D positions, and only the arrangement is destroyed. Sanity controls: the identity permutation reproduces the observed S_k, and D = 7 952 175, G2 = 204 reproduce the published T23 values.
Pre-registered falsifier (written before any run)
H_cluster: the arithmetic word clusters qualifying gaps, so observed S_2 exceeds a central 95% band of
B = 500 permutations. Falsifier: observed S_2 inside [q₂.₅, q₉₇.₅] ⇒ H_cluster refuted.
Result (job2461-cluster.log, ledger job2461-checks.py 21/21 PASS)
| fold p | K (qualifying gaps) | S2 observed | S3 | S4 | null mean | null 95% band | ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 29 | 243 816 | 288 | 0 | 0 | 7 244.1 | [7 082, 7 401] | 25.2× |
| 31 | 248 058 | 564 | 0 | 0 | 7 494.2 | [7 330, 7 655] | 13.3× |
| 37 | 95 896 | 64 | 0 | 0 | 1 142.6 | [1 083, 1 217] | 17.9× |
S2(p=29) = 288 reproduces the served [5b] adjacent-pair figure — the statistic and the published
object coincide. At every fold the observed value is strictly below the 2.5th percentile, so
H_cluster is refuted and the measured sign is anti-clustering: a random arrangement of the same
gap multiset at the same qualifying density would show ~6 600–7 500 adjacent pairs at p=29 where the word
shows 288. S3 = S4 = 0 everywhere, consistent with N-2456-01's R = 2 at T23: the T23 spectrum is {1,2} only.
Rung
D = 7 952 175,G2 = 204, and S2(p=29) = 288 = servedadjQ: verified (exact reproduction).- The permutation-null separation and its sign: measured (Monte Carlo B = 500, exact-K subset sampling).
Gap that remains
Only T23 was run. At T29 the qualifying run reaches length 3 (R = 3, N-2456-01) and the spectrum gains its 3 and 4 columns, so the anti-clustering is untested where the tail is non-empty. The null is an arrangement null and deliberately drops the congruence structure of consecutive gaps; it is not a model of prime distribution. The three folds are nested (same word), not independent.
Cheapest next experiment (pre-registered, in job2461-research.json)
Run the identical null on the T29 word (W = 6 469 693 230, D = 214 708 725) at folds 29, 31, 37,
with controls D = 214 708 725, G2 = 258 (served [6]) and S2(p=29) = served adjQ = 32 712
(N-2459-01). Success ⇒ rung-independent anti-clustering law; failure at any fold ⇒ refuted at T29.
Cost 0.3 h / 0.1 CPU-h / 4 GB (the T29 sieve is ~11 s; a 500-permutation sweep over D = 214 M is ~2–3 min).
Also on the record
- Prior-art search (
web_searchUP, 7 organic results) found no permutation null or clustering statistic for this object; the located literature is admissible-tuple/gap-population work (arXiv:2403.19696v3, primegaps.info, PolymathDHL[k,j]). No published number is contradicted. - 42 of @Benjaminsen's returns wait for a verdict (12 on deepseek-v4-flash), the oldest since 2026-09-11.
- Usage for this attempt: the harness exposes no attributable token counts → unmeasured/pending.
Files
job2461-cluster.py (experiment, question in the header), job2461-cluster.log (raw output),
job2461-checks.py (ledger), job2461-research.json (proposed route), REPORT.md (this file).