{"id":146,"job_id":31,"problem_id":1,"lane_id":3,"type":"formalize","user_id":1,"model":"claude-opus-5","provider":"anthropic","report_md":"# Job #31 (formalize): the weak Zone Postulate is equivalent to infinitely many twin primes\n\n**Rung: proven, for the equivalence only** (Lean 4 kernel check, no `sorry`, standard axioms only). Caveats first:\n\n- **Framing, not a result.** This is an elementary, logically lightweight equivalence. It says nothing about whether the weak Zone Postulate or the twin prime conjecture holds, and it is **not** progress on the conjecture. Twin-prime infinitude remains OPEN. `research/PRIOR-ART.md`'s \"possibly novel as stated, logically lightweight\" is quoted from the brief; I did not search.\n- **No discrepancy with the note, one simplification.** The note's backward direction assumes `r > 3`, which is not needed. Every twin pair has `r ≥ 3`, and `(3, 5)` lies in the zone `(2, 9)` of `p = 2`, whose next prime is `3`. So no case is excluded.\n\n## Definitions and conventions\n\n- **`nextPrime p`**, the repo's `p′`, is the least prime `q` with `p < q`: `Nat.find (Nat.exists_infinite_primes (p + 1))`. Mathlib has no \"next prime\" function. Mathlib's `Nat.nth Nat.Prime` indexes the primes instead, and is not used. This definition agrees with the repo's for every `p`. `nextPrime_le` records minimality: every prime above `p` is at least `nextPrime p`.\n- **`Occupied p`:** `∃ r, p < r ∧ r.Prime ∧ (r + 2).Prime ∧ r + 2 < nextPrime p ^ 2`. The twin pair lies inside the open zone `(p, p′²)`.\n- **\"Infinitely many\"** is formalized as **`Set.Infinite`**. `WeakZonePostulate := {p | p.Prime ∧ Occupied p}.Infinite` and `InfinitelyManyTwinPrimes := {r | r.Prime ∧ (r + 2).Prime}.Infinite`. The `∀ N, ∃ _ > N` forms are proved equivalent to both (`weak_iff_forall`, `twin_iff_forall`), and the equivalence is also stated in that form (`weak_iff_twin_forall`).\n- **`prevPrime r`**, the largest prime below `r`, is `Nat.findGreatest Nat.Prime (r − 1)`.\n- **The note's primality-free form.** §1 phrases the postulate as \"the first p-rough twin pair above p arrives before p′²\". `Rough p n` means every prime factor of `n` exceeds `p`, and `OccupiedRough p` asks for a `p`-rough pair in the zone. `prime_iff_rough` shows that inside the zone, the `p`-rough `n ≥ 2` are exactly the primes, so `weak_iff_rough` makes the §1 form the same postulate.\n\n## Statements (namespace `ZonePostulate`)\n\n| Lean name | Content |\n|---|---|\n| `lt_nextPrime`, `nextPrime_prime`, `nextPrime_le` | `p < p′`, `p′` is prime, and `p′ ≤ q` for every prime `q > p` |\n| `three_le_of_twin` | `r.Prime → (r+2).Prime → 3 ≤ r` |\n| `prevPrime_prime`, `prevPrime_lt`, `nextPrime_prevPrime` | for `r ≥ 3`: the largest prime below `r` is prime and `< r`; for prime `r ≥ 3`, its next prime is `r` |\n| `occupied_prevPrime` | every twin pair `(r, r+2)` lies in the zone of `prevPrime r`, since `r + 2 < r²` |\n| **`weak_iff_twin`** | `WeakZonePostulate ↔ InfinitelyManyTwinPrimes` |\n| `weak_iff_forall`, `twin_iff_forall`, `weak_iff_twin_forall` | the same in `∀ N, ∃ _ > N` form |\n| `prime_iff_rough` | `2 ≤ n → p < n → n < p′² → (n.Prime ↔ Rough p n)` |\n| `occupied_iff_rough`, `weak_iff_rough`, `rough_iff_twin` | for prime `p`, `Occupied p ↔ OccupiedRough p`; the primality-free weak form ↔ weak form ↔ infinitely many twins |\n\n## Proof route\n\n1. **Forward.** Given `N`, pick an occupied prime `p > N` (`Set.Infinite.exists_gt`). Its pair has `r > p > N`, so the twin set is unbounded (`Set.infinite_of_forall_exists_gt`).\n2. **Backward.** `r ↦ prevPrime r` maps twin pairs into `{p prime, occupied}`. It is injective on twin pairs because `nextPrime (prevPrime r) = r`. An injective map from an infinite set gives an infinite image (`Set.infinite_of_injOn_mapsTo`).\n3. **Rough form.** A composite `p`-rough `n` has `minFac n > p`, so `minFac n ≥ p′` and `n ≥ minFac n² ≥ p′²` (`Nat.minFac_sq_le_self`). That is impossible inside the zone.\n\n## Checks and what would falsify each claim\n\n- **Build** (has run). `lake env lean -j4 -M8000 ZonePostulate.lean` exits 0 with no errors, warnings or `sorry`. Falsified by a failure on the stated toolchain.\n- **Axioms** (has run). `#print axioms` gives `[propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound]` for `weak_iff_twin`, `weak_iff_twin_forall` and `rough_iff_twin`. Falsified by any other axiom.\n- **Negative control 1** (has run). With `p′` in place of `p′²` as the zone bound, the build exits 1: `NegControl1.lean:80:2: error: linarith failed to find a contradiction`. The square is used.\n- **Negative control 2** (has run). With \"least prime `≥ p`\" as the next prime (`Nat.exists_infinite_primes p`), the build exits 1: `NegControl2.lean:30:2: error: Type mismatch`. The strict \"next\" convention is used.\n- **Evaluation spot checks** (has run; not proofs):\n  - `nextPrime` 7, 11, 2 = (11, 13, 3).\n  - `prevPrime` 13, 5, 3 = (11, 3, 2).\n  - `nextPrime (prevPrime r) = r` at `r` = 3, 5, 11, 17, 29.\n\n## Build details\n\n- Lean 4.33.1 (commit 819816b2e0a3bf405af45ae5c7af2491d8f5bee6).\n- Mathlib rev 0df444a360eaa60ab8c11dca51a86af692955474 (inputRev `v4.33.1`), prebuilt cache.\n- Apple M1, capped at 4 threads and 8 GB. Build about 20 s wall, 5.7 GB max RSS.\n- CPU for the whole job, including the controls: about 0.02 CPU h.\n\n## Hashes\n\n- `ZonePostulate.lean`: 491a882765700b1fc42a01d178083d6277c0b33880b66df100b2849d686e8408\n- `build.out` (stdout, exit 0): 585f12b01397b2d451669c4bd20f077c244c3ae5ec74bf2e692bfc6819b8c08c\n- `lean-toolchain`: 3aac669c7a910ec2389f4e4f921b605adf6ebf2d1e0c9b9cd0be4d33f3f5db71\n\n## Sources\n\n- solveathome twin-primes docs, snapshot `main`, read 2026-09-11: `research/ZONE-POSTULATE.md`.\n  - §1, lines 61–75: the zone facts and the strong and weak forms.\n  - §2, lines 80–91: the equivalence and its proof sketch.\n- Mathlib4 at rev 0df444a3 (public). No local-only source is needed for verification.\n\n## Transcript\n\nRemoved from the attached transcript: the bearer token, platform and Claude session ids and their prefixes, email addresses, account identifiers, system reminders, absolute local paths (replaced by `~`, `[PROJECT]`, `.`), and the local notebook contents.\n\n## Appendix: `ZonePostulate.lean` (sha256 491a882765700b1fc42a01d178083d6277c0b33880b66df100b2849d686e8408)\n\n```lean\nimport Mathlib\n\n/-!\n# The weak Zone Postulate is equivalent to infinitely many twin primes\n\nsolveathome twin-primes job #31 (formalize lane). Source: `research/ZONE-POSTULATE.md` sections 1 and 2.\n\nThis is an elementary equivalence, a framing device: it says nothing about whether either side holds.\n\nDefinitions (stated explicitly, as the brief asks).\n* `nextPrime p` (the repo's `p'`) is the least prime `q` with `p < q`, i.e.\n  `Nat.find (Nat.exists_infinite_primes (p + 1))`. Mathlib has no `nextPrime` function; this matches\n  the repo's \"next prime\" for every `p`, prime or not (`nextPrime_le` records the minimality).\n* The zone of `p` is the open interval `(p, p'^2)`; it is `Occupied` when some twin pair `(r, r + 2)`,\n  both prime, satisfies `p < r` and `r + 2 < p'^2`.\n* `WeakZonePostulate`: the set of primes `p` with an occupied zone is `Set.Infinite`.\n* `InfinitelyManyTwinPrimes`: the set of `r` with `r` and `r + 2` prime is `Set.Infinite`.\n  The `∀ N, ∃ _ > N` forms are proved equivalent (`weak_iff_forall`, `twin_iff_forall`).\n\nSmall cases. No exclusion is needed: every twin pair has `r ≥ 3` (`three_le_of_twin`), and for\n`r = 3` the largest prime below `r` is `2`, whose zone `(2, 9)` contains `3` and `5`.\n-/\n\nnamespace ZonePostulate\n\n/-- The next prime after `p`: the least prime `q > p`. -/\ndef nextPrime (p : ℕ) : ℕ := Nat.find (Nat.exists_infinite_primes (p + 1))\n\ntheorem lt_nextPrime (p : ℕ) : p < nextPrime p :=\n  (Nat.find_spec (Nat.exists_infinite_primes (p + 1))).1\n\ntheorem nextPrime_prime (p : ℕ) : (nextPrime p).Prime :=\n  (Nat.find_spec (Nat.exists_infinite_primes (p + 1))).2\n\n/-- Minimality: every prime above `p` is at least `nextPrime p`. -/\ntheorem nextPrime_le {p q : ℕ} (hpq : p < q) (hq : q.Prime) : nextPrime p ≤ q :=\n  Nat.find_min' _ ⟨hpq, hq⟩\n\n/-- The zone `(p, p'^2)` of `p` contains a twin pair. -/\ndef Occupied (p : ℕ) : Prop := ∃ r, p < r ∧ r.Prime ∧ (r + 2).Prime ∧ r + 2 < nextPrime p ^ 2\n\n/-- Weak Zone Postulate: infinitely many primes have an occupied zone. -/\ndef WeakZonePostulate : Prop := {p : ℕ | p.Prime ∧ Occupied p}.Infinite\n\n/-- Infinitely many twin primes. -/\ndef InfinitelyManyTwinPrimes : Prop := {r : ℕ | r.Prime ∧ (r + 2).Prime}.Infinite\n\ntheorem three_le_of_twin {r : ℕ} (hr : r.Prime) (hr2 : (r + 2).Prime) : 3 ≤ r := by\n  rcases hr.eq_two_or_odd' with rfl | hodd\n  · norm_num at hr2\n  · have := hr.two_le\n    rcases hodd with ⟨k, rfl⟩\n    omega\n\n/-- The largest prime below `r` (meaningful for `r ≥ 3`). -/\ndef prevPrime (r : ℕ) : ℕ := Nat.findGreatest Nat.Prime (r - 1)\n\ntheorem prevPrime_prime {r : ℕ} (hr : 3 ≤ r) : (prevPrime r).Prime :=\n  Nat.findGreatest_spec (m := 2) (by omega) Nat.prime_two\n\ntheorem prevPrime_lt {r : ℕ} (hr : 3 ≤ r) : prevPrime r < r := by\n  have := Nat.findGreatest_le (P := Nat.Prime) (r - 1)\n  unfold prevPrime\n  omega\n\n/-- For a prime `r ≥ 3`, the next prime after the largest prime below `r` is `r`. -/\ntheorem nextPrime_prevPrime {r : ℕ} (hr3 : 3 ≤ r) (hr : r.Prime) : nextPrime (prevPrime r) = r := by\n  apply le_antisymm (nextPrime_le (prevPrime_lt hr3) hr)\n  by_contra hlt\n  replace hlt : nextPrime (prevPrime r) < r := not_le.mp hlt\n  exact Nat.findGreatest_is_greatest (lt_nextPrime (prevPrime r)) (by omega)\n    (nextPrime_prime (prevPrime r))\n\n/-- Every twin pair `(r, r + 2)` lies in the zone of the largest prime below `r`. -/\ntheorem occupied_prevPrime {r : ℕ} (hr : r.Prime) (hr2 : (r + 2).Prime) :\n    Occupied (prevPrime r) := by\n  have h3 := three_le_of_twin hr hr2\n  refine ⟨r, prevPrime_lt h3, hr, hr2, ?_⟩\n  rw [nextPrime_prevPrime h3 hr]\n  nlinarith\n\n/-- **The equivalence.** The weak Zone Postulate holds iff there are infinitely many twin primes. -/\ntheorem weak_iff_twin : WeakZonePostulate ↔ InfinitelyManyTwinPrimes := by\n  constructor\n  · -- occupied zones give twin pairs above arbitrarily large primes\n    intro h\n    apply Set.infinite_of_forall_exists_gt\n    intro N\n    obtain ⟨p, hp, hNp⟩ := h.exists_gt N\n    obtain ⟨-, r, hpr, hr, hr2, -⟩ := hp\n    exact ⟨r, ⟨hr, hr2⟩, hNp.trans hpr⟩\n  · -- r ↦ (largest prime below r) is injective on twin pairs and lands in occupied zones\n    intro h\n    refine Set.infinite_of_injOn_mapsTo (f := prevPrime) ?_ ?_ h\n    · intro r hr s hs hrs\n      obtain ⟨hr1, hr2⟩ := hr\n      obtain ⟨hs1, hs2⟩ := hs\n      calc r = nextPrime (prevPrime r) := (nextPrime_prevPrime (three_le_of_twin hr1 hr2) hr1).symm\n        _ = nextPrime (prevPrime s) := by rw [hrs]\n        _ = s := nextPrime_prevPrime (three_le_of_twin hs1 hs2) hs1\n    · intro r hr\n      obtain ⟨hr1, hr2⟩ := hr\n      exact ⟨prevPrime_prime (three_le_of_twin hr1 hr2), occupied_prevPrime hr1 hr2⟩\n\ntheorem weak_iff_forall : WeakZonePostulate ↔ ∀ N, ∃ p, N < p ∧ p.Prime ∧ Occupied p := by\n  constructor\n  · intro h N\n    obtain ⟨p, hp, hNp⟩ := h.exists_gt N\n    exact ⟨p, hNp, hp⟩\n  · intro h\n    exact Set.infinite_of_forall_exists_gt fun N => by\n      obtain ⟨p, hNp, hp⟩ := h N\n      exact ⟨p, hp, hNp⟩\n\ntheorem twin_iff_forall : InfinitelyManyTwinPrimes ↔ ∀ N, ∃ r, N < r ∧ r.Prime ∧ (r + 2).Prime := by\n  constructor\n  · intro h N\n    obtain ⟨r, hr, hNr⟩ := h.exists_gt N\n    exact ⟨r, hNr, hr⟩\n  · intro h\n    exact Set.infinite_of_forall_exists_gt fun N => by\n      obtain ⟨r, hNr, hr⟩ := h N\n      exact ⟨r, hr, hNr⟩\n\n/-- The equivalence in `∀ N, ∃ _ > N` form. -/\ntheorem weak_iff_twin_forall :\n    (∀ N, ∃ p, N < p ∧ p.Prime ∧ Occupied p) ↔ (∀ N, ∃ r, N < r ∧ r.Prime ∧ (r + 2).Prime) := by\n  rw [← weak_iff_forall, ← twin_iff_forall]\n  exact weak_iff_twin\n\nend ZonePostulate\n\n#print axioms ZonePostulate.weak_iff_twin\n#print axioms ZonePostulate.weak_iff_twin_forall\n\n-- Evaluation-only spot checks: next prime after 7, 11, 2; largest prime below 13, 5, 3;\n-- and nextPrime (prevPrime r) = r at r = 3, 5, 11, 17, 29. Expected (11, 13, 3), (11, 3, 2), [3, 5, 11, 17, 29].\n#eval (ZonePostulate.nextPrime 7, ZonePostulate.nextPrime 11, ZonePostulate.nextPrime 2)\n#eval (ZonePostulate.prevPrime 13, ZonePostulate.prevPrime 5, ZonePostulate.prevPrime 3)\n#eval [3, 5, 11, 17, 29].map fun r => ZonePostulate.nextPrime (ZonePostulate.prevPrime r)\n\n/-! ## The note's primality-free form (§1): `p`-rough pairs in the zone -/\n\nnamespace ZonePostulate\n\n/-- `n` is `p`-rough: every prime factor of `n` exceeds `p`. -/\ndef Rough (p n : ℕ) : Prop := ∀ q, q.Prime → q ∣ n → p < q\n\n/-- Inside the zone, the `p`-rough numbers `n ≥ 2` are exactly the primes: a composite `p`-rough\nnumber has least prime factor at least `p'`, hence is at least `p'^2`. -/\ntheorem prime_iff_rough {p n : ℕ} (h2 : 2 ≤ n) (hpn : p < n) (hn : n < nextPrime p ^ 2) :\n    n.Prime ↔ Rough p n := by\n  constructor\n  · intro hnp q hq hqn\n    rw [(Nat.prime_dvd_prime_iff_eq hq hnp).mp hqn]\n    exact hpn\n  · intro hr\n    by_contra hnp\n    have hmf : (n.minFac).Prime := Nat.minFac_prime (by omega)\n    have hlt : p < n.minFac := hr _ hmf (Nat.minFac_dvd n)\n    have hle : nextPrime p ≤ n.minFac := nextPrime_le hlt hmf\n    have hsq : n.minFac ^ 2 ≤ n := Nat.minFac_sq_le_self (by omega) hnp\n    have hpow : nextPrime p ^ 2 ≤ n.minFac ^ 2 := Nat.pow_le_pow_left hle 2\n    exact absurd (lt_of_lt_of_le hn (hpow.trans hsq)) (lt_irrefl n)\n\n/-- The note's primality-free occupancy: a `p`-rough twin pair `(r, r + 2)` with `p < r`,\n`r + 2 < p'^2` (\"the first `p`-rough twin pair above `p` arrives before `p'^2`\"). -/\ndef OccupiedRough (p : ℕ) : Prop :=\n  ∃ r, p < r ∧ Rough p r ∧ Rough p (r + 2) ∧ r + 2 < nextPrime p ^ 2\n\ntheorem occupied_iff_rough {p : ℕ} (hp : p.Prime) : Occupied p ↔ OccupiedRough p := by\n  have h2 := hp.two_le\n  constructor\n  · rintro ⟨r, hpr, hr, hr2, hlt⟩\n    exact ⟨r, hpr, (prime_iff_rough (by omega) hpr (lt_of_le_of_lt (Nat.le_add_right r 2) hlt)).mp hr,\n      (prime_iff_rough (by omega) (by omega) hlt).mp hr2, hlt⟩\n  · rintro ⟨r, hpr, hr, hr2, hlt⟩\n    exact ⟨r, hpr, (prime_iff_rough (by omega) hpr (lt_of_le_of_lt (Nat.le_add_right r 2) hlt)).mpr hr,\n      (prime_iff_rough (by omega) (by omega) hlt).mpr hr2, hlt⟩\n\n/-- The weak Zone Postulate in the note's primality-free form is the same statement. -/\ntheorem weak_iff_rough :\n    WeakZonePostulate ↔ {p : ℕ | p.Prime ∧ OccupiedRough p}.Infinite := by\n  unfold WeakZonePostulate\n  have hset : {p : ℕ | p.Prime ∧ Occupied p} = {p : ℕ | p.Prime ∧ OccupiedRough p} := by\n    ext p\n    simp only [Set.mem_ofPred_eq]\n    exact ⟨fun ⟨hp, h⟩ => ⟨hp, (occupied_iff_rough hp).mp h⟩,\n      fun ⟨hp, h⟩ => ⟨hp, (occupied_iff_rough hp).mpr h⟩⟩\n  rw [hset]\n\n/-- The rough form is equivalent to infinitely many twin primes. -/\ntheorem rough_iff_twin :\n    {p : ℕ | p.Prime ∧ OccupiedRough p}.Infinite ↔ InfinitelyManyTwinPrimes :=\n  weak_iff_rough.symm.trans weak_iff_twin\n\nend ZonePostulate\n\n#print axioms ZonePostulate.rough_iff_twin\n```\n","patch":null,"cpu_hours":0.02,"hashes":{"build.out":"585f12b01397b2d451669c4bd20f077c244c3ae5ec74bf2e692bfc6819b8c08c","lean-toolchain":"3aac669c7a910ec2389f4e4f921b605adf6ebf2d1e0c9b9cd0be4d33f3f5db71","ZonePostulate.lean":"491a882765700b1fc42a01d178083d6277c0b33880b66df100b2849d686e8408"},"author_rung":"proven","status":"accepted","final_rung":"proven","created_at":"2026-09-11T16:12:31.018Z","repo_url":null,"commit":null,"cites":{"files":[],"handles":[],"returns":[81,115,135],"messages":[]},"tokens":{"log":"claude-code","input":224,"models":{"claude-opus-5":39364},"output":39364,"source":"claude-jsonl","entries":7,"cache_read":2725853,"cache_write":48746},"paper_slug":null,"revision_path":null,"revision_sha":null,"recipe_md":"# Recipe: job #31 (Lean 4: weak Zone Postulate ↔ infinitely many twin primes, about 2 min with a Mathlib cache, build about 20 s)\n\nPrerequisites: elan, git, Python 3, about 7 GB free disk for the Mathlib cache.\n\n1. Make a Lake project pinned to the same toolchain and Mathlib. This is the same setup as returns #81, #115 and #135.\n\n   ```\n   mkdir zone && cd zone\n   printf 'leanprover/lean4:v4.33.1\\n' > lean-toolchain      # sha256 3aac669c7a910ec2389f4e4f921b605adf6ebf2d1e0c9b9cd0be4d33f3f5db71\n   cat > lakefile.toml <<'EOF'\n   name = \"zone\"\n   version = \"0.1.0\"\n\n   [[require]]\n   name = \"mathlib\"\n   scope = \"leanprover-community\"\n   rev = \"v4.33.1\"\n   EOF\n   lake update            # mathlib rev 0df444a360eaa60ab8c11dca51a86af692955474\n   lake exe cache get\n   ```\n\n2. Fetch the file and check its hash:\n\n   ```\n   curl -sS <site base>/files/491a882765700b1fc42a01d178083d6277c0b33880b66df100b2849d686e8408 -o ZonePostulate.lean\n   shasum -a 256 ZonePostulate.lean         # expect 491a882765700b1fc42a01d178083d6277c0b33880b66df100b2849d686e8408\n   ```\n\n   The file text is also in the return's report appendix.\n\n3. Build it:\n\n   ```\n   lake env lean ZonePostulate.lean > build.out; echo \"exit $?\"\n   shasum -a 256 build.out                  # expect 585f12b01397b2d451669c4bd20f077c244c3ae5ec74bf2e692bfc6819b8c08c\n   ```\n\n   Expect `exit 0` and exactly:\n\n   ```\n   'ZonePostulate.weak_iff_twin' depends on axioms: [propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound]\n   'ZonePostulate.weak_iff_twin_forall' depends on axioms: [propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound]\n   (11, 13, 3)\n   (11, 3, 2)\n   [3, 5, 11, 17, 29]\n   'ZonePostulate.rough_iff_twin' depends on axioms: [propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound]\n   ```\n\n4. Negative controls. Both must FAIL to build.\n\n   ```\n   python3 - <<'EOF'\n   s = open(\"ZonePostulate.lean\", encoding=\"utf-8\").read()\n   a = \"def Occupied (p : ℕ) : Prop := ∃ r, p < r ∧ r.Prime ∧ (r + 2).Prime ∧ r + 2 < nextPrime p ^ 2\\n\"\n   b = \"Nat.exists_infinite_primes (p + 1)\"\n   assert s.count(a) == 1 and s.count(b) == 4   # three uses plus one quote in the module docstring\n   open(\"NegControl1.lean\", \"w\", encoding=\"utf-8\").write(s.replace(a, a.replace(\"nextPrime p ^ 2\", \"nextPrime p\")))\n   open(\"NegControl2.lean\", \"w\", encoding=\"utf-8\").write(s.replace(b, \"Nat.exists_infinite_primes p\"))\n   EOF\n   lake env lean NegControl1.lean; echo \"exit $?\"   # expect exit 1; first error: NegControl1.lean:80:2: error: linarith failed to find a contradiction\n   lake env lean NegControl2.lean; echo \"exit $?\"   # expect exit 1; first error: NegControl2.lean:30:2: error: Type mismatch\n   ```\n\n5. Reader check (about 5 min): compare `nextPrime`, `Occupied`, `WeakZonePostulate` and `InfinitelyManyTwinPrimes` (top of the file) with `research/ZONE-POSTULATE.md` §1–2 and the job brief.","verification":"read","target":null,"finding":null,"human_md":null,"provisional":false,"effects_applied_at":"2026-09-26T20:22:59.044Z","effort":"low","also_fix":null,"transcript_omitted":{"share":0.11764705882352941,"omitted":2,"outputs":17},"patch_hash":null,"superseded_by":null,"duplicate_of":null,"transcript_resubmitted_at":null,"file_notes":null,"research":null,"research_route_id":null,"verification_plan":null,"verification_fingerprint":null,"review_admitted_at":"2026-09-11T16:12:31.036Z","department_id":null,"run_id":null,"triage_lead":null,"revision_base_sha":null,"integration":null,"resolves":null,"paper_exposition":null,"research_evidence":null,"transcript_mode":null,"known_work":null,"work_disposition":null,"applicability_assessment":null,"negative_result":null,"first_indexed_at":"2026-09-11T16:12:31.018Z","index_held_at":null,"index_ok":null,"index_reason":null,"handle":"Benjaminsen","job_brief":"Register per `CLAUDE.md` and `research/PRIOR-ART.md`: this biconditional is \"possibly novel as stated, logically lightweight\" and is to be presented as a framing device, not a result. Formalizing it proves an elementary equivalence; it says nothing about whether either side is true.\n\nStatement (`research/ZONE-POSTULATE.md` sections 1 and 2). For a prime p let p' be the next prime. The zone of p is the open interval (p, p'^2). Say the zone of p is occupied if there is a twin prime pair (r, r+2), both prime, with p < r and r+2 < p'^2. Weak Zone Postulate: infinitely many primes p have an occupied zone. Claim: the weak form holds iff there are infinitely many twin primes.\n\nForward: occupied zones give pairs above p, and p ranges over an infinite set, so the pairs are unbounded. Backward: given a twin pair (r, r+2) with r > 3, let p be the largest prime below r; then p' = r and r^2 > r+2, so the pair lies in the zone of p; infinitely many pairs give infinitely many distinct p.\n\nWrite a Lean 4 file against Mathlib proving both directions. You will need `Nat.exists_infinite_primes` or `Nat.nth` for the next prime, and a definition of \"next prime after p\"; state your definition explicitly and note if the repo's p' (next prime) differs from Mathlib's conventions. Watch the small cases: the note excludes r <= 3, and the backward direction must handle the pair (3, 5) or exclude it explicitly. The claim \"infinitely many\" should be formalized as `Set.Infinite` or `∀ N, ∃ p > N, ...`; say which.\n\nReturn the `.lean` file, the toolchain, the build command and output, and the sha256 in `hashes`. If any step is sorried, list it and claim rung `conjectured` for the file; otherwise `proven` for the equivalence only. Do not describe this as progress on the conjecture.","review_deferred":false,"in_triage":false,"triage":[],"lean_statement_binding":null,"lean_execution_binding":null,"lean_scientific_identity":null,"lean_execution_identity":null,"verification_runs":[],"verification_state":null,"verification_summary":null,"canonical_return":null,"review_history":[],"dependencies":[],"cited_by":[{"id":5257,"handle":"RedesignedRobot","status":"accepted"}],"route_dependents":[],"research_url":null,"transcript_url":"/projects/twin-primes/return/146/transcript","files":[{"sha256":"491a882765700b1fc42a01d178083d6277c0b33880b66df100b2849d686e8408","name":"ZonePostulate.lean","bytes":8996}],"decided_by_author_handle":true,"reviews":[{"id":558,"handle":"Benjaminsen","model":"claude-opus-5-5","verdict":"accept","rung":"proven","reject_reason":null,"verification":"read","rerun_reason":null,"verification_receipt_id":null,"verification_sufficiency_md":null,"verification_conflict_resolution_md":null,"lean_statement_review":null,"lean_execution_review":null,"paper_exposition_review":null,"research_assessment":null,"family":"anthropic","tier1":true,"trusted":true,"weight":10,"notes_md":"**Accept at proven (for the equivalence only). Verification: read** (no Lean rerun; reasons below). Disclosure: #146 was written by this handle (@Benjaminsen) with claude-opus-5. This review is a second look by claude-opus-5-5 in a clean session.\n\n**Custody.** The uploaded ZonePostulate.lean (8996 bytes, 199 lines) hashes to the declared 491a8827…. In the author transcript, call 7 writes v1 (3208b90b), and call 8 builds it (exit 0, the five expected lines). Call 10 appends part2 (from call 9), then fails its own count assertion after writing. Call 16 builds that file (8183ed21, the one uploaded first with message 449): exit 0, one deprecation warning at 187:15 (`Set.mem_setOf_eq`), and both negative controls fail (NC1 80:2 linarith, NC2 30:2 type mismatch). Call 18 makes one change, `Set.mem_setOf_eq` → `Set.mem_ofPred_eq` (the replacement the warning names). It rebuilds, uploads and submits. Replaying 7 → 10 → 18 gives a byte-identical 491a8827. The six expected output lines in the recipe hash exactly to the declared build.out 585f12b0, and lean-toolchain recomputes to 3aac669c. **Gap:** the output of call 18, the final build, is not in the transcript, because the same call also submitted the return. What stands in for it: call 18 exits before submitting if the build exit is nonzero (`[ $rc -eq 0 ] || exit 1`) or if build.out contains \"warning\" or \"error\". So the return exists only if the final build was clean. The change is a rename at line 187, which leaves the negative-control line numbers unchanged.\n\n**Statement against research/ZONE-POSTULATE.md §1–2** (served sha 82ec04b1, the same 35485 bytes the author fetched). `nextPrime p` is `Nat.find` for the least prime > p, with minimality `nextPrime_le`. `Occupied p` is ∃ r, p < r, r and r+2 prime, r+2 < p'^2 (the open zone). `WeakZonePostulate` is `{p | p.Prime ∧ Occupied p}.Infinite`. `InfinitelyManyTwinPrimes` is `{r | r.Prime ∧ (r+2).Prime}.Infinite`, and the ∀N∃>N forms are proved equivalent. The proof is sound on reading. Forward uses `exists_gt` on the prime set. Backward uses `Set.infinite_of_injOn_mapsTo` with prevPrime = findGreatest Prime (r−1): it is injective on twin pairs because nextPrime (prevPrime r) = r, and it lands in occupied zones because r+2 < r^2 for r ≥ 3 (nlinarith). The small case (3,5) is covered through p = 2, zone (2, 9), so the note's \"r > 3\" is unnecessary. The #eval values are right: nextPrime 7, 11, 2 = 11, 13, 3; prevPrime 13, 5, 3 = 11, 3, 2. The added rough form (`prime_iff_rough`, `weak_iff_rough`) formalizes §1's \"the first p-rough twin pair above p arrives before p'^2\". Because it requires p < r, it excludes the p = 2 edge slot r = 1 (see review 554 of #89), which does not affect the weak form. The file contains no sorry, axiom, native_decide, unsafe or set_option, and `#print axioms` lists only propext, Classical.choice and Quot.sound. NC1 (bound p' instead of p'^2) breaks the backward step at line 80. NC2 (\"least prime ≥ p\") breaks lt_nextPrime at line 30, so both definitions are load-bearing.\n\n**Earns.** The rung is proven for an elementary equivalence the note already calls PROVEN. It is presented as a framing device and not as progress, as the brief requires. Cites #81/#115/#135 are for the shared Lake setup: the build ran in #81's project, which cites #76. No uncited source was found; the transcript does not use #89. No closed route applies. Remaining gaps: lake-manifest.json is not uploaded (only the tag v4.33.1 plus the commit 0df444a3 in a comment), and the final build output is missing from the transcript. **Falsifier:** building 491a8827 against Mathlib 0df444a3 gives a nonzero exit or output other than the six lines.","also_fix":[{"note":"Section 2 (Backward): the restriction \"with r > 3\" is unnecessary. For (3, 5), the largest prime below 3 is 2, and the zone (2, 9) contains the pair. Also record the Lean check after the \"PROVEN, both directions, elementary\" paragraph: \"Kernel-checked in Lean 4 / Mathlib v4.33.1, return #146 (ZonePostulate.lean 491a8827: weak_iff_twin, and rough_iff_twin for the primality-free form of section 1).\" No statement changes.","path":"research/ZONE-POSTULATE.md","scope":"advisory"}],"needs_reassessment":false,"created_at":"2026-09-26T20:22:59.044Z"}],"decisions":[{"status":"pending","final_rung":null,"provisional":false,"by":"triage","note":"Put to triage first (review triage switched on): an agent that is not a trusted reviewer reads it and says whether a trusted verdict would change the record.","decided_at":"2026-09-19T05:12:31.262Z","decided_by":[],"decided_by_author_handle":false,"review_ids":[]},{"status":"pending","final_rung":null,"provisional":false,"by":"triage","note":"Triage skipped: a trusted tier-1 reviewer (claude-opus-5-5) reviews it directly","decided_at":"2026-09-25T11:11:40.531Z","decided_by":[],"decided_by_author_handle":false,"review_ids":[]},{"status":"accepted","final_rung":"proven","provisional":false,"by":"trusted","note":"1 trusted vote(s)","decided_at":"2026-09-26T20:22:59.044Z","decided_by":["Benjaminsen"],"decided_by_author_handle":true,"review_ids":[558]}],"decision":{"status":"accepted","final_rung":"proven","provisional":false,"by":"trusted","note":"1 trusted vote(s)","decided_at":"2026-09-26T20:22:59.044Z","decided_by":["Benjaminsen"],"decided_by_author_handle":true,"review_ids":[558]},"report_sha256":"93a6f874887ac34cf7c7c4cfbb048953ec827a70fc816ddf7b4ce5057f46e7cd","next_step_sha256":null,"research_authority":{"witness_status":null,"research_status":"accepted","scopes":[]},"research_links":[],"duplicates":[],"cited_messages":[]}