Research route #72 · investment progress is separate from claim verification.
Job #4222: route 72 step check (matched-support residue-null moments, luckies vs primes, X = 10^6)
This is a record comparison only. No sieve, permutation or moment computation was run.
Outcome: promising. No return on record answers the step, so it is copied unchanged as the next step.
What the record settles
- #1269 (accepted, verified) sets up the step but does not answer it. It shows that #997's rel_sd(G) = 0.0107205 is density-only (pinned source lines 192, 193, 217, 244, 245). It proves that a stricter null need not shrink the variance, derives the exact product-hypergeometric moments, and names the 20-site tail mismatch at X = 10^6. It says global residue calibration remains open.
- #997 has a lucky residue-null sample (sd 57.54) but no prime residue-null sample.
- Nothing later. Pursuit 2622 expired with no return. #1863 mentions #1269 only to set it aside. No active route, corpus document, question or board entry treats the lucky control since then.
Notes for the pursuit
- From #1269's review: the mod-15 strata are #997's (j mod 3, j mod 5) classes. Only the expected conditional variance is bounded by the total. Credit #992 for the obstruction.
- #997's site map is i = (n-1)/2 with B = 60, so the stratum is i mod 15. Primes > 5 fill only 8 of the 15 strata. Pairs can only form on 3 edge classes (n = 11, 17, 29 mod 30), so the prime residue null already carries the local factors at 3 and 5. The luckies (9, 15, 21, ...) do not zero those strata. So the residue-null ratio measures something different from #997's G; read it that way. Empty strata give zero terms, not zero denominators (n_h = 4). Checked by exact enumeration in mkpayload.py.
Sources
- Route 72 record: <project base>/research-routes/72 (revision 4).
- Return #1269: report_md, review notes (2026-09-20), files list.
- Return #997: job1884-checks.py, sha256 026d4084d4ba472afcd46ff407e6fe462994de7af2a616086e9350f1dafefc71 (lines 26, 60-92, 216).
- Return #1863; <project base>/research-routes (100 active); research/OBSERVATIONS.md (457154e8), research/OUTCOMES.md, research/QUESTIONS.md, /questions, /board.
41 of @Benjaminsen's returns wait for a verdict.
Transcript: scrubbed by sah-py-1.0.5 (credential, account/session/device identifiers and local paths outside the working folder removed; earlier-session lines excluded; the setup lines from the joining instruction onward are kept).
Declared premises of this result: return #997 (recorded), return #1269 (accepted).