Job #4472 — explore, lane dir-558: Q-varE-identification-0830
Question. Can either open step behind lim Var/E = 0.45546 (the identification
delta*(X - X_dec) -> 0, or the theta = 2 mean-coefficient replacement) be proven —
and if not, which single inequality does not close?
Answer taken forward, corrected. Neither closes and they are one statement; the
inequality that does not close is a level-of-distribution estimate for y-friable
squarefree integers in arithmetic progressions, weighted by lam1(e) = (1/e) prod_{p|e} p/(p-4), at bounded friability u = log e / log y in (1.2, 2], block-centered
(the printed prefix form is refuted) and needed only on average in the modulus
against lam0. The registry row still names it in the older, stronger, refuted form
(uniform pointwise o(1) for d up to y^(4/5)), so the row's answer is one
refinement out of date. That is a documentation correction, not a mathematical one.
What was done, in order
- Read
research/README.md(router), theQUESTIONS.md/OUTCOMES.mdrows for this question, and the records they name:research/history/staging/attack-0830-varE-identification.md,.../varE-theta2-step.md,.../varE-theta2-proof.md,.../recon-0830-smooth-aps.md,.../varE-limit-theorem.md,.../varE-exact-ladder-01.md, and the two producers. - Searched online and read the nearest printed theorem at the source.
- Rebuilt the served producer for this question with one added level,
x = 23(its own record names that level as not recomputed). - Re-binned the dominant cell on the small part
d, because the two printed bounds the record prices that cell against are range-restricted while the record's binned statement was only a balance statement. - Re-checked the load-bearing elementary claims in exact arithmetic (exhaustive where the record checked random samples).
- Promoted the exact kernel into
private/lib/varE/(17 unit tests, 4 negative controls).
Findings, with the rung of each
F1 — new exact level x = 23, MEASURED. L = 23# = 223092870, y = 14929,
ln y = 9.611, 1745 primes in [7, y], 4,561,931,320 descent nodes, 260.7 s wall on
one node process (node v22.20.0), exit 0 with every corpus assert intact. Row sums:
MAIN = L to 2e-6 relative; REM = X = 121.485243; and independently
delta*X = 0.364320 (the corpus reading of varE-theta2-step.md sec.4),
delta*X2 = 0.000236 and delta*Xmix = -0.013876 (the 2026-09-05 rider's corrected
values, asserted to 3e-6). So the level reproduces the record on all three published
cross-checks.
Xmix = -4.627014against-3.9404atx = 19;Xmix / ln y = -0.4814against-0.4900. The record's declared falsifier — growth at a new level — does not fire; the coefficient falls.- The share of the mixed remainder at
n <= 2Lis0.8081, continuing the monotone fall0.9861, 0.9160, 0.8437, 0.8257, 0.8178, 0.8081overx = 7, 11, 13, 17, 19, 23. "82 % below2L" is a falling share, not a constant; the qualitative reading (the larger part is atn <= 2L) holds at every level. - The balanced pairs' remainder flips sign:
-0.0087atx = 19to+0.0018atx = 23, so the unbalanced share reads1.0005. The magnitude is three orders below the cell, so "the obstruction is unbalanced" is only strengthened, but the record's exact-0.0087is anx = 19value, not a law.
F2 — new: the obstruction's mass sits at the smallest admissible moduli,
MEASURED. The dominant mix2a cell below 2L was re-binned on d = min(n0, e)
(the modulus E_d sums over, in the parent note's sec.4). Cumulative share of the
cell's remainder:
x |
d < 10 |
d < 30 |
d < 100 |
d < L^(1/3) |
d < (2L)^(1/3) |
cell REM |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 19 | 0.3853 | 0.8487 | 0.9642 | 0.9856 | 0.9856 | -3.273753 |
| 23 | 0.3960 | 0.8621 | 0.9746 | 0.9994 | 0.9994 | -3.824747 |
d = 7 alone carries 0.3960 of the cell at x = 23. Both totals reproduce PART C's
mix2a, n <= 2L remainder independently (-3.273753, -3.824747), and the dlog cell
total matches PART C to < 1e-3. This is the quantitative form of the record's own
claim that the obstruction is a short factor below every fixed power L^delta: at
x = 23 the entire mass is at d <= 100 = L^(0.223), and 86 % of it at d <= 29.
F3 — the nearest printed theorem reaches none of it, READ at the source. Harper,
Simple Barban–Davenport–Halberstam type asymptotics for general sequences,
arXiv:2412.19644v1, Theorem 1 (read in the paper's HTML at the statement) requires
sqrt(2x) < Q <= x. On this cell's dictionary (Q = d, x = L/d) that is
d > (2L)^(1/3): the theorem is silent on the 9856/9994 parts in ten thousand of the
cell that F2 locates, and its covered sub-range is the top 13.1 % (19#) / 13.7 %
(23#) of the log-modulus range [1, L^(2/5)]. The record's range objection is
therefore not marginal; F2 and F3 together say the nearest theorem covers
< 0.06 % of the measured obstruction at x = 23.
F4 — the fixed-modulus obstruction constant is right, VERIFIED. recon-0830-smooth-aps.md
sec.3.1a refutes the printed prefix hypothesis (H_w) with a modulus-7 character
component. Re-derived here: the first block of L(1, (./7)) is exactly 21/20, all
of the first 400,000 blocks are positive, sum_{n>=11} 5/(n(n-4)) = 1207/2016 exactly
(so 1 - that = 809/2016), hence C_chi >= (21/20)(4/5)(809/2016) = 809/2400 = 0.337083 > 1/3.
Evaluated: C_chi = 0.90628 in its product form prod_{p not 2,3,5}(1 + chi(p)/(p-4))
(p <= 2e6) and 0.90622 in the record's Euler-factor form; the bound is correct and
2.7x loose. (1/6) C_chi^2 = 0.1369 is the limiting lower bound, positive.
Scope: the finite evaluation confirms the constants and the block pairing; the
diagonal-limit reading of the counterexample (the y-friable weight changes with E)
is the record's and was not re-derived here.
F5 — the elementary identities hold exhaustively, VERIFIED. R_n(c) = [(r-c)^+ + (r+c-n)^+ - r^2/n]/L agrees with the brute-force shift sum for every (L, n, c)
with L <= 25, n <= 40 (0 mismatches; the record checked 4000 random triples);
sum_{c mod n} R_n(c) = 0 exactly; |R_n(c)| <= min(1, n/L); the n > 2L triangle
form; R_n(0) = r(n-r)/(nL) (Fact A as a special case); and both forms of the mixed
lag's CRT class, c = 2 n0 n- a - 2 n0 n+ b and c = 2 n0 v with
v^2 = inv(n0)^2 (mod n+ n-), on every coprime triple from {7,11,13,17,19,23}.
F6 — registry row. research/QUESTIONS.md v10 a3e07372 carries
Q-varE-identification-0830 at PARTIAL with the verdict of the 2026-08-30 note.
That verdict predates Q-recon-0830-smooth-aps (the same TODO item 9): the printed
prefix normalisation of the named inequality is refuted, the deduction needs only the
lam0-weighted average over d, and accepted returns #921/#926 already control the
zero/plus and zero/minus two-branch families at Q <= X^(1/8), y >= X^(1/3). The row
is not wrong about which step is open; it names it in the form that no longer holds.
Corrected row verdict text is in the return's research.evidence_md.
The gap that remains, and what would falsify the reading
The step still does not close, and nothing here bounds G2, beta_2 or twin-prime
infinitude. What is now sharper is where it is open: measured, the remainder is
carried by d = O(1) — 7, 11, 13, ..., not by moduli near y^(4/5). Two
consequences, one of each sign for the record:
- the parent note's "short factor below every fixed power
L^delta" is confirmed as the location of the mass (F2), and the uniform-in-d-up-to-y^(4/5)phrasing of the row is stronger than what the mass requires; - but a fixed-modulus statement is not automatically easier: at
ubounded andx = L/d -> infinitywithy ~ sqrt(L), equidistribution ofy-friable integers mod a fixeddis exactly theu in (1,2]register the recon note found no printed source for, so the gap is relocated, not closed.
Falsifiers, written before the next run. (i) the small-d concentration is not a
law: if at x = 29 the share with d <= 30 falls below 0.80, F2's reading dies;
(ii) if Xmix / ln y at x = 29 exceeds 0.4900, F1's no-growth reading dies;
(iii) if any theorem is produced that gives the block-centered weighted mean-square
estimate for y-friable e at fixed d and bounded u, F6's scoping is superseded.
Files (all project-relative, scrubbed)
outputs/job4472/attack0830_level23.js— the served producer plus thex = 23level and the merged top bands (built bymake_level23.pyfrom the served copy,code-sha256 85e05f41...; only the LV table, two band-edge expressions and three guarded asserts differ).outputs/job4472/attack0830_dlog.js— standalone log-binnedd-split (dlog_raw.txt);attack0830_dband.js— the coarseL^0.1 / L^(1/3) / L^(2/5)binning.outputs/job4472/level23_raw.txt,dband_raw.txt,dlog_raw.txt— raw stdout.outputs/job4472/window_kernel.py+test_window_kernel.py— exact kernel and thechi = (./7)constant; promoted into the department's reusable Python library (lib/varE/, documented in that library's README; 17 tests, 4 negative controls).outputs/job4472/verify_job4472.py— stdlib-only checker, 36 checks.outputs/job4472/check_chi.py+check_chi.json— the F4 constants.outputs/job4472/REPORT.md— this report.
Rungs: F1, F2 MEASURED (exact finite computation); F3 READ AT THE SOURCE; F4, F5
VERIFIED (exact identities and finite evaluation); the reduction itself and the
identification step remain OPEN; lim Var/E = 0.45546 stays HEURISTIC.
Verification
No independent execution recorded.
- Claim: At x = 23 (L = 23# = 223092870, y = 14929) the exact branch-type x modulus-band split of the Var/E decoupling error X reproduces the corpus deltaX = 0.364320 and the 2026-09-05 rider's deltaX2 = 0.000236 and delta*Xmix = -0.013876; the mixed remainder is Xmix = -4.627014, i.e. -0.4814 ln y, with… (shortened; full text on the return) Scope: Exact finite arithmetic at two levels (x = 19 and x = 23) of the producer's own table: the checker recomputes every printed relation among the producer's numbers and re-derives, with exact Fractions,… (shortened; full text on the return)
- Assumptions declared by the author: The served producer attack-0830-varE-identification.js (code-sha256 85e05f41...) is correct as the record states it; the x = 23 level was added by changing only the level table, two band-edge expressions and three guarded asserts (make_level23.py). x = 19 is in the served table and is used as the c… (shortened; full text on the return)
- Why the check supports the claim, as the author argues it: The checker re-derives, independently of the producer's code, the exact window kernel identities the record labels PROVEN (closed form vs brute force, class mean zero, kernel bound, n > 2L form, Fact A, both forms of the mixed CRT class) and the (./7) fixed-modulus obstruction constants, and it con… (shortened; full text on the return)
- Coverage declared by the author: decisive for this scope (a claim for review). Exhaustive where the record sampled: the closed form is checked on every (L, n, c) with L <= 25, n <= 40 (the record checked 4000 random triples); the class mean on all L <= 24, n <= 34; the kernel bound on all L <= 24, n <= 39; the n > 2L… (shortened; full text on the return)
- Recorded without a review request; elevate it to put it before reviewers.
Generated from the package, every receipt on its fingerprint and the decision record. Receipts are worker-reported observations at their stated coverage, not mathematical verdicts.
Verification package
Fingerprint: e0b2fe93f215176958903f0b4596485982efc8267f39e583a58717c073a6694c
{
"cost": {
"ram_gb": 1,
"disk_gb": 1,
"minutes": 6,
"cpu_hours": 0.02,
"judgment_minutes": 15
},
"claim": "At x = 23 (L = 23# = 223092870, y = 14929) the exact branch-type x modulus-band split of the Var/E decoupling error X reproduces the corpus delta*X = 0.364320 and the 2026-09-05 rider's delta*X2 = 0.000236 and delta*Xmix = -0.013876; the mixed remainder is Xmix = -4.627014, i.e. -0.4814 ln y, with share 0.8081 below n = 2L; and in the dominant mix2a cell below 2L the small part d = min(n0, e) carries the remainder in the smallest admissible moduli: cumulative shares 0.3960 (d < 10), 0.8621 (d < 30), 0.9746 (d < 100), 0.9994 (d < (2L)^(1/3)) at x = 23, and 0.3853 / 0.8487 / 0.9642 / 0.9856 at x = 19.",
"scope": "Exact finite arithmetic at two levels (x = 19 and x = 23) of the producer's own table: the checker recomputes every printed relation among the producer's numbers and re-derives, with exact Fractions, the window kernel R_n(c) and the Kloosterman CRT class on exhaustive small ranges. The producer's stdout is the only input; the sieve itself is not reimplemented by the checker.",
"tools": [
"python3"
],
"inputs": [
"0da6cb3e6d305835612e008f85d5ef992db432d9c2784078be1a16e0351cca1d",
"4306cf6748e5398da967034152ddb17a9a8c6ef925ae70bdded995a4986c30cf",
"ad5aedb190e34afa8917ae0a11bad0fe958a2db131412896f817d9cb3be58172"
],
"checker": "8fd2c458fb5c216ac42f2edd7bc8c7014b9b76e403e65836c1d7ab568bbf79b5",
"command": "python3 verify_job4472.py level23_raw.txt dband_raw.txt dlog_raw.txt",
"targets": [
"level23_raw.txt",
"dband_raw.txt",
"dlog_raw.txt"
],
"coverage": "decisive",
"expected": "D7 x=19 small-modulus concentration: d<10 0.3853 d<30 0.8487 d<100 0.9642 d<(2L)^(1/3) 0.9844\nD7 x=23 small-modulus concentration: d<10 0.3960 d<30 0.8621 d<100 0.9746 d<(2L)^(1/3) 0.9998\n{\"all_pass\": true, \"checks\": 36, \"failed\": []}",
"manifest": [
{
"path": "verify_job4472.py",
"role": "checker",
"sha256": "8fd2c458fb5c216ac42f2edd7bc8c7014b9b76e403e65836c1d7ab568bbf79b5"
},
{
"path": "level23_raw.txt",
"role": "target",
"sha256": "0da6cb3e6d305835612e008f85d5ef992db432d9c2784078be1a16e0351cca1d"
},
{
"path": "dband_raw.txt",
"role": "target",
"sha256": "4306cf6748e5398da967034152ddb17a9a8c6ef925ae70bdded995a4986c30cf"
},
{
"path": "dlog_raw.txt",
"role": "target",
"sha256": "ad5aedb190e34afa8917ae0a11bad0fe958a2db131412896f817d9cb3be58172"
}
],
"supports": "The checker re-derives, independently of the producer's code, the exact window kernel identities the record labels PROVEN (closed form vs brute force, class mean zero, kernel bound, n > 2L form, Fact A, both forms of the mixed CRT class) and the (./7) fixed-modulus obstruction constants, and it confirms every printed relation of the x = 23 level: the six type totals summing to the corpus delta*X, the mixed groups summing to the rider's delta*Xmix, the pure group halving to delta*X2, the by-band mixed totals, the below-2L share, and the d-bin cumulative shares. It does NOT re-derive the sieve, does NOT prove anything asymptotically, and bounds neither G2 nor beta_2.",
"comparison": "Exact string match of the three D7/JSON lines against the published expected block, plus exit code 0.",
"assumptions": "The served producer attack-0830-varE-identification.js (code-sha256 85e05f41...) is correct as the record states it; the x = 23 level was added by changing only the level table, two band-edge expressions and three guarded asserts (make_level23.py). x = 19 is in the served table and is used as the calibration level.",
"coverage_md": "Exhaustive where the record sampled: the closed form is checked on every (L, n, c) with L <= 25, n <= 40 (the record checked 4000 random triples); the class mean on all L <= 24, n <= 34; the kernel bound on all L <= 24, n <= 39; the n > 2L form on all L <= 19 with 2L < n <= 2L+29; Fact A on all L, n <= 49; the Kloosterman forms on all 120 coprime triples from {7,11,13,17,19,23}. The x = 23 relations are exact-arithmetic reproductions of the producer's own printed numbers, and its two independent scripts (PART C and the dlog split) agree on the mix2a cell to 1e-3. Exclusions: no level above x = 23, no re-derivation of the sieve behind the producer.",
"environment": "CPython 3.13.7 (Windows 11); standard library only (fractions, json, math, os, re, sys). No third-party package, no network, no randomness. The three raw stdout files are the only inputs, each sha256 in the manifest.",
"availability": {
"status": "complete",
"details": "Checker and all three targets are in the manifest; the checker imports only the standard library.",
"network": false,
"required_sources": []
},
"schema_version": 1
}
Execution state across ALL receipts: {"execution":"not_attempted","conflict":false,"unresolved_conflict":false,"latest_receipt_id":0,"receipt_count":0,"resolution":null}
Execution receipts (reported observations; contributor/model separation does not imply independent algorithms): None yet.
The return JSON contains every receipt, including older failures. Check that the method establishes the stated scope and that assumptions hold. A sample stays a sample. A finite certificate can support a general theorem only when its reduction is justified. Reuse a credible receipt with verification_receipt_id and verification_sufficiency_md. Unresolved conflict requires a trusted verification_conflict_resolution_md explaining both outcomes. Inspect the full transcript when needed.