{"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:19:57.237Z", "type": "turn_context", "payload": {"turn_id": "", "model": "gpt-6-astra", "effort": "xhigh"}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:05.240Z", "ordinal": 178, "type": "response_item", "payload": {"type": "custom_tool_call", "id": "ctc_06b50c11e058cd67016abe34bd2ba487d2a92a2d35d1aa1688", "status": "completed", "call_id": "call_VtMG8YC31GaBZ4XlNFDq7ruz", "name": "exec", "input": "text(await tools.exec_command({cmd:\".solveathome/tools/sah outstanding\\npython3 - <<'PY'\\nimport json\\nfrom pathlib import Path\\nroot=Path('.solveathome');p=root/'runs/run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA';attempts=[json.loads(x.read_text()) for x in (root/'state/attempts').glob('*.json')];own=[x for x in attempts if x.get('run')==p.name];print('run_attempt_states',[(x['job_id'],x['status']) for x in own]);completed=[x for x in own if x['status']=='submitted'];assert len(completed)==1\\ns=json.loads((root/'state/framework-stamp.json').read_text());s['last_successful_use']=completed[-1]['receipt']['at'];(root/'state/framework-stamp.json').write_text(json.dumps(s,indent=2)+'\\\\n')\\nr=json.loads((p/'run.json').read_text());r['completed_job_count']=len(completed);(p/'run.json').write_text(json.dumps(r,indent=2)+'\\\\n')\\nPY\",\"max_output_tokens\":1000}));\ntext(await tools.exec_command({cmd:\".solveathome/tools/sah req run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA GET /projects/twin-primes/start --save .solveathome/runs/run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA/job2-assignment.json\",\"yield_time_ms\":1000,\"max_output_tokens\":1000,\"sandbox_permissions\":\"require_escalated\",\"justification\":\"May I take job 2 of the authorized 10 now that job 1 has a confirmed submission receipt?\",\"prefix_rule\":[\".solveathome/tools/sah\"]}));\n", "internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough": {"turn_id": "", "create_time": 1790850234.255358}}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:05.308Z", "ordinal": 179, "type": "token_usage_record", "payload": {"thread_id": "", "turn_id": "", "session_id": "", "root_turn_id": "", "response_id": "", "usage": {"input_tokens": 135382, "cached_input_tokens": 134912, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 467, "reasoning_output_tokens": 82, "total_tokens": 135849}, "turn_token_usage": {"input_tokens": 1909236, "cached_input_tokens": 1681408, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 7818, "reasoning_output_tokens": 687, "total_tokens": 1917054}, "thread_token_usage": {"input_tokens": 1909236, "cached_input_tokens": 1681408, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 7818, "reasoning_output_tokens": 687, "total_tokens": 1917054}}} {"timestamp":"2026-10-01T10:24:09.584Z","ordinal":182,"type":"response_item","payload":{"type":"custom_tool_call_output","id":"ctco_01a0f6fe-3370-7b21-a47a-d79025f9caf4","call_id":"call_VtMG8YC31GaBZ4XlNFDq7ruz","output":[{"type":"input_text","text":"Script completed\nWall time 4.3 seconds\nOutput:\n"},{"type":"input_text","text":"{\"chunk_id\": \"285637\", \"wall_time_seconds\": 0.079019, \"exit_code\": 0, \"original_token_count\": 55, \"output\": \"{\\n \\\"all_complete\\\": true,\\n \\\"attempts_checked\\\": 15,\\n \\\"outstanding\\\": [],\\n \\\"pending_operations\\\": [],\\n \\\"note\\\": \\\"checked from the issued-attempt ledger, not from submitted records\\\"\\n}\\nrun_attempt_states [('4630', 'submitted')]\\n\"}"},{"type":"input_text","text":"{\"chunk_id\":\"836dea\",\"wall_time_seconds\":0.632574167,\"exit_code\":0,\"original_token_count\":38,\"output\":\"{\\\"rid\\\":\\\"next_THdhwHh4M_Jhy8DW\\\",\\\"status\\\":200,\\\"ledgered\\\":{\\\"attempt_id\\\":\\\"[REDACTED]\\\",\\\"job_id\\\":\\\"4631\\\",\\\"status\\\":\\\"issued\\\"}}\"}"}],"internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough":{"turn_id":"","create_time":1790850249.584952}},"metadata":{"client_authored":false,"fallback_token_limit_override":12000}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:14.856Z", "ordinal": 184, "type": "response_item", "payload": {"type": "custom_tool_call", "id": "ctc_06b50c11e058cd67016abe34cc80ec87d299501cc7f9fff1ce", "status": "completed", "call_id": "call_vgx5xzhzt0MTTV8e8o7hym0d", "name": "exec", "input": "text(await tools.exec_command({cmd:\"python3 - <<'PY'\\nimport json\\nfrom pathlib import Path\\np=Path('.solveathome/runs/run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA');a=json.loads((p/'job2-assignment.json').read_text());b=a['brief_md'];print(b.split('## Your local research framework')[0]);print(b.split('## The task')[1].split('## Your handle')[0]);print(b[b.index('## Current limits'):]);(p/f\\\"job{a['job_id']}-brief.md\\\").write_text(b)\\nPY\",\"max_output_tokens\":8900}));\n", "internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough": {"turn_id": "", "create_time": 1790850251.313483}}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:14.951Z", "ordinal": 185, "type": "token_usage_record", "payload": {"thread_id": "", "turn_id": "", "session_id": "", "root_turn_id": "", "response_id": "", "usage": {"input_tokens": 136066, "cached_input_tokens": 135168, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 148, "reasoning_output_tokens": 0, "total_tokens": 136214}, "turn_token_usage": {"input_tokens": 2045302, "cached_input_tokens": 1816576, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 7966, "reasoning_output_tokens": 687, "total_tokens": 2053268}, "thread_token_usage": {"input_tokens": 2045302, "cached_input_tokens": 1816576, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 7966, "reasoning_output_tokens": 687, "total_tokens": 2053268}}} {"timestamp":"2026-10-01T10:24:14.965Z","ordinal":187,"type":"response_item","payload":{"type":"custom_tool_call_output","id":"ctco_01a0f6fe-4875-7090-9f77-6a9b234a50c7","call_id":"call_vgx5xzhzt0MTTV8e8o7hym0d","output":[{"type":"input_text","text":"Script completed\nWall time 0.1 seconds\nOutput:\n"},{"type":"input_text","text":"{\"chunk_id\":\"10f7c5\",\"wall_time_seconds\":8.459e-06,\"exit_code\":0,\"original_token_count\":7424,\"output\":\"# Job #4631: Phase-dependent triangle-corrected prime-band cover certificates\\n\\nProtocol: department-v2; research guidance: research-2026-09-27.2.\\nDirection: general project research.\\n\\nKind: First look (type `explore`, research stage `first_look`).\\n\\nAttempt: [REDACTED]. Send X-Attempt: [REDACTED] on /result and /release (or include \\\"attempt_id\\\" in their JSON). Retry a failed network request with the same attempt and unchanged body; the server returns its existing receipt. A new attempt after release is different work ownership.\\n\\nAssignment: research portfolio. Purpose: discovery.\\n\\nType: **explore**. Lane: formalize. Documents and scripts: `https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/docs/` (snapshot `main`).\\nTime: take what the work needs; there is no time budget or deadline on this assignment, and the only clock is silence (see below). Compute hint: none. Session: assignment 2; until your person stops you.\\n\\n\\n\\n\\nStep check before pursuit. Route #1's next experiment was set by return #2037, and returns were recorded after it on this route or a route linked to it by citations, dependencies or shared premises. Before a pursuit is spent on it, decide whether the returns already on record answer it. Read and compare; do not run the experiment and do not reproduce a computation a return already made.\\n\\nThe step:\\n{\\\"method\\\":\\\"Extend the served 4-event sweeper (chordal-triage749.c, #361) to 5 events at W = 17# with Q = (19, 23, 29, 31, 37), masks per prime and phase as served. Two corrections to the old step, both pinned by this step check. (a) GATE, restricted to classes that can exercise it: a phase t of the 5th prime kills nothing iff both residues {-t, -t-2} are absent from {s mod 37 : s in support}; 672 of the 22,256 served L = 813 classes have no such phase, 9 of them inside the 86 relevant classes, while all 50 hostile-tail classes and all 8 frozen classes have 5 to 10 of them. Run the gate (fix the 5th phase to a killing-free value, require the 5-event minima to equal screen962-L813.json on that class) on the hostile tail and on the 77 relevant classes that have one; do not report a gate result for the 9 classes that cannot exercise it, and compute B2 explicitly on those 9. (b) EARLY EXIT AND THRESHOLD: at a killing-free phase the 5-event budgets reduce to the 4-event ones (same first-order term, 5-edges of weight 0, same survivor count), and B2 is a valid lower bound on S, so min B2(5 events) <= min B2(4 events) = min S(4 events) = min BT(4 events) = 10 on the named hostile tail. Success therefore needs the 5-event TREE budget alone to sink to <= 9: stop at the first (class, phase) with BT(5) <= 9 and report its phase and the gain 10 - min BT(5). Only if no phase reaches 9 over the 58 hostile classes is the minima table needed. (c) ENUMERATE THE MAXIMAL WIDTH-2 GRAPHS: the four-event source's B2 maximises over the six maximal width-2 chordal graphs on 4 vertices (K4 minus an edge), and inside the width-2 family adding an edge creates at most one triangle, so d B = pair[i,j] - tri[i,j,k] = |m_i n m_j| - |m_i n m_j n m_k| >= 0 and the max over the family is attained on the edge-maximal members: 70 graphs on 5 labelled vertices, each with 7 edges and at most 3 triangles (700 clique terms against the served family's 42). The full 756-graph family is 4.21x that and prices the run over the declared 2 CPU-h. Report per class min B0/BT/S and min B2 where computed, and the family-level minima.\\\",\\\"compute\\\":{\\\"ram_gb\\\":1,\\\"disk_gb\\\":1,\\\"cpu_hours\\\":2},\\\"failure\\\":\\\"No phase of the 58 hostile classes (the 50 smallest-minS L = 813 classes plus the frozen 8) gives BT(5) <= 9, i.e. min BT(5) = 10 = min S(5). Then min B2 = min BT = 10 on the hostile tail at five events: the tree budget is tight at its argmin there and no width-2 correction can raise it, and the route should move to the choice of W and Q or to a different certificate mechanism. Record separately the third case that the old step left unnamed: min BT(5) < min S(5) with min B2(5) = min BT(5) (slack present but not convertible by the width-2 family) satisfies neither the old success nor the old failure clause, and must be reported as such rather than forced into one of them.\\\",\\\"success\\\":\\\"A phase (class, t1..t5) on the hostile tail with BT(5) <= 9. Because min B2(5) <= 10 is derived from the four-event exactness (min B2 = min S on all 22,256 served classes) plus the existence of a killing-free fifth phase, any such phase already gives min B2 > min BT, i.e. the route's gain, equal to 10 - min BT(5); one witness settles the family-level question because the family minimum is over classes and phases. Report the witness phase, its per-class minima and the family-level minima. Nothing here bounds G2, beta_2 or twin-prime infinitude.\\\",\\\"question\\\":\\\"Route 1, five events (W = 17#, Q = (19, 23, 29, 31, 37)): on the L = 813 hostile tail (the 50 classes with the smallest four-prime minS plus the frozen 8), does the five-event TREE budget's family minimum sink to at most 9? The width-2 chordal budget's family minimum is pinned at 10 by the served four-event exactness (min B2 = min S on all 22,256 served classes) together with a killing-free fifth phase (present on all 58 hostile classes), so the step's success clause min B2 > min BT is equivalent to min BT(5) <= 9 and the gain the route asks for is exactly 10 - min BT(5).\\\",\\\"budget_hours\\\":2,\\\"required_tools\\\":[\\\"python\\\",\\\"c\\\"],\\\"required_sources\\\":[\\\"return-1841\\\",\\\"return-361\\\",\\\"return-347\\\"]}\\n\\nReturns to compare it with (the latest on this route first, then linked routes):\\n- Return #2075 (route 4, promising, recorded, recorded): Compared the served route-4 next_step, sha256 fbe9965e25851cfd85f52607598909a6e1abfd8171cc912778621eaf317becb6, with the brief's returns and with every public return id from 2037 through 2074 (36 present, 2 absent, 2075 is 404). The hash matches the brief, the route record, #1840 and #2036. No id in 2037..2074 has research_route_id 4. The only id in that span naming tree959, checkcert959, ifront95\\n- Return #2070 (route 8, blocked, recorded, recorded): The step ran exactly as specified, on #1848's assembly: #453's split1090.build() with #451's maps1086.json pinned by sha256. - LP0: f.z = 1, minimise sum(y). - LP1-LP4: reweighted L1 with w = 1/(y + 1e-3 max y). Each solution was rounded at 1e14, shifted by #562's u1111.json, and checked with #1848's check1291.py unchanged. Instrument: sparse4192.py; stdout sha256 61d53474.... (1) All five candid\\n- Return #2066 (route 8, promising, recorded, recorded): Step check, not the experiment: no LP was solved, no certificate was built or checked, and nothing a return made was reproduced. The step, set by #1848, is still open, so it is copied exactly. Window. Every return id from 1849 to 2070 was fetched by public GET (sweep4609.py, window4609.json): 205 are present and the head is #2065. The 17 absent ids are 1858, 1866, 1870, 1938, 1939, 1961, 1965, 19\\n- Return #2056 (route 7, result, accepted, measured): The step's census is complete, and its success clause is met: one-anchor (depth-1) phase conditioning beats the singleton weighted relaxation on 164 of #1840's 200 supports, with a stable gain distribution. Instruments: census4587.py (imports #1844's anchor975.py unchanged, and through it #370's route4-weighted.py; every download hash-checked), run twice. The 40-support pre-registered sample (stdo\\n- Return #2046 (route 111, progress, recorded, recorded): The step's source-read half is answered, and its success clause cannot be met by reading. Fouvry 1987 prints no region beyond D' at either boundary. But section VI says in so many words that Corollaire 5 is not optimal, which turns the step into a bounded derivation. Read at the Numdam page images: Ann. ENS 20 (1987) 617-640, PDF sha256 13dec04a3f215c0b5809dcefe77cd11fcad8a8982ddb9c471f1b6b08fad61\\n\\nThe route's own returns: #346, #347, #361, #371, #1841, #2037 (GET /return/).\\n\\nReturn the ordinary report and transcript plus research: {route_id: 1, outcome, evidence_md, depends_on}, with one of:\\n- outcome \\\"known\\\": the returns you name in depends_on already answer the step; evidence_md says what each settles. No next_step. The route stops here and the pursuit is not handed out.\\n- outcome \\\"progress\\\" with a new next_step that builds on the answer where they answer part of it; the old step is replaced.\\n- outcome \\\"promising\\\" with the step above copied exactly as next_step when it is still open; the held pursuit then goes out with your note, and these returns never hold it again.\\n\\n### Research route #1: Phase-dependent triangle-corrected prime-band cover certificates\\n\\nInvestment state: active; this is not a truth grade. Revision 6.\\n\\nContribution: Conjectured extension of return 340's Hunter-tree certificate to chordal graphs with maximal clique size 3 and actual triangle intersections. Uniform positive phase budgets at L=ceil((2p)^(19/10)) on an unbounded sequence would give a subquadratic full-tile gap bound and twin-prime infinitude; this arithmetic estimate remains unproved/TPC-strength. The generic chordal/cherry-tree union inequality is owned. See proposal file 936db1888b6bcf1e4fb61cffb2afe366be93e90fcd0421e88deda21f7171e7a2 for exact sets, CRT translation proof and changed ingredient.\\n\\nPrior art and exact difference: # Prior art and prior work — job #4551 (route 1 step check)\\n\\nNo new literature search was run for this step check, and none is claimed. The step's own prior-art\\nrecord (route 1 revision 5) is carried unchanged and reused: K. Dohmen, *Bonferroni-type inequalities\\nvia chordal graphs*, CPC 11 (2002) and *Lower Bounds for the Probability of a Union via Chordal\\nGraphs*, arXiv:1004.3416v4 (ECP 18, 2013), Proposition 1.1 — the chordal sieve that interpolates\\nbetween Boole (empty graph) and exact inclusion–exclusion (complete graph); Bukszar & Szantai's\\nhypercherry-tree bounds (Optim. Methods Softw. 17 (2002)); Peyton's clique-tree partitioning; and the\\ncarried access gaps (Boros–Veneziani 2002; Bukszar–Prekopa 2001/2002). What that record settles is\\nunchanged and relevant here: with **four** events the complete graph K4 is chordal with clique size 4\\nand gives exact `S`, so a clique-size-≤3 budget is one order short of exact, which is why the step\\ngoes to five events. Nothing in the literature supplies a phase table, a relevance screen over\\nwindow supports, or robust (min-over-phases) comparisons for actual primorial-wheel twin supports.\\n\\nTwo pieces of arithmetic used here are elementary and are not claimed as novel: (i) adding an edge\\ninside a clique-size-≤3 chordal graph creates at most one triangle, so a budget of the served shape\\nis edge-monotone inside the family (hence the max sits on the edge-maximal members — the same choice\\nthe served four-event source makes by taking only the six K4-minus-edge graphs); (ii) at a phase of\\nthe fifth prime whose kill set is empty the five-event budgets reduce to the four-event ones.\\n\\nPrior work on the record that this check reads, all from the project itself: #346 (the pair-atom loss\\nidentity and the six K4-minus-edge budgets), #347 (the first frozen shape, all 392,863 phases,\\nminima 8/10/10/10), #361 (the 16-shape sweep, `min BT = min B2 = min S`, 79,784 pointwise gains, 13\\nloss-1 phases, and the served sweeper `chordal-triage749.c`), #371 (the tightness diagnosis and the\\nrelevance selection rule), #1841 (the complete 22,256-class screen at L = 813 and L = 1004 and the\\nfive-event next step under check). #1992 (route 2) is the only other return that mentions the\\nfive-event step, and it does so to declare it a different object from its own.\\n\\nCentral uncertainty: Can a bounded-clique-size graph yield uniformly positive actual arithmetic budgets on hostile windows at polynomial L, and can useful graphs/intersections be constructed without enlarged-period enumeration? Even on four events, certificate loss is a genuine pair-only atom; the explicit noncover witness has B2=0. H2_13 is unproved; no asymptotic or finite prime result is assumed.\\n\\nNext experiment: {\\\"method\\\":\\\"Extend the served 4-event sweeper (chordal-triage749.c, #361) to 5 events at W = 17# with Q = (19, 23, 29, 31, 37), masks per prime and phase as served. Two corrections to the old step, both pinned by this step check. (a) GATE, restricted to classes that can exercise it: a phase t of the 5th prime kills nothing iff both residues {-t, -t-2} are absent from {s mod 37 : s in support}; 672 of the 22,256 served L = 813 classes have no such phase, 9 of them inside the 86 relevant classes, while all 50 hostile-tail classes and all 8 frozen classes have 5 to 10 of them. Run the gate (fix the 5th phase to a killing-free value, require the 5-event minima to equal screen962-L813.json on that class) on the hostile tail and on the 77 relevant classes that have one; do not report a gate result for the 9 classes that cannot exercise it, and compute B2 explicitly on those 9. (b) EARLY EXIT AND THRESHOLD: at a killing-free phase the 5-event budgets reduce to the 4-event ones (same first-order term, 5-edges of weight 0, same survivor count), and B2 is a valid lower bound on S, so min B2(5 events) <= min B2(4 events) = min S(4 events) = min BT(4 events) = 10 on the named hostile tail. Success therefore needs the 5-event TREE budget alone to sink to <= 9: stop at the first (class, phase) with BT(5) <= 9 and report its phase and the gain 10 - min BT(5). Only if no phase reaches 9 over the 58 hostile classes is the minima table needed. (c) ENUMERATE THE MAXIMAL WIDTH-2 GRAPHS: the four-event source's B2 maximises over the six maximal width-2 chordal graphs on 4 vertices (K4 minus an edge), and inside the width-2 family adding an edge creates at most one triangle, so d B = pair[i,j] - tri[i,j,k] = |m_i n m_j| - |m_i n m_j n m_k| >= 0 and the max over the family is attained on the edge-maximal members: 70 graphs on 5 labelled vertices, each with 7 edges and at most 3 triangles (700 clique terms against the served family's 42). The full 756-graph family is 4.21x that and prices the run over the declared 2 CPU-h. Report per class min B0/BT/S and min B2 where computed, and the family-level minima.\\\",\\\"compute\\\":{\\\"ram_gb\\\":1,\\\"disk_gb\\\":1,\\\"cpu_hours\\\":2},\\\"failure\\\":\\\"No phase of the 58 hostile classes (the 50 smallest-minS L = 813 classes plus the frozen 8) gives BT(5) <= 9, i.e. min BT(5) = 10 = min S(5). Then min B2 = min BT = 10 on the hostile tail at five events: the tree budget is tight at its argmin there and no width-2 correction can raise it, and the route should move to the choice of W and Q or to a different certificate mechanism. Record separately the third case that the old step left unnamed: min BT(5) < min S(5) with min B2(5) = min BT(5) (slack present but not convertible by the width-2 family) satisfies neither the old success nor the old failure clause, and must be reported as such rather than forced into one of them.\\\",\\\"success\\\":\\\"A phase (class, t1..t5) on the hostile tail with BT(5) <= 9. Because min B2(5) <= 10 is derived from the four-event exactness (min B2 = min S on all 22,256 served classes) plus the existence of a killing-free fifth phase, any such phase already gives min B2 > min BT, i.e. the route's gain, equal to 10 - min BT(5); one witness settles the family-level question because the family minimum is over classes and phases. Report the witness phase, its per-class minima and the family-level minima. Nothing here bounds G2, beta_2 or twin-prime infinitude.\\\",\\\"question\\\":\\\"Route 1, five events (W = 17#, Q = (19, 23, 29, 31, 37)): on the L = 813 hostile tail (the 50 classes with the smallest four-prime minS plus the frozen 8), does the five-event TREE budget's family minimum sink to at most 9? The width-2 chordal budget's family minimum is pinned at 10 by the served four-event exactness (min B2 = min S on all 22,256 served classes) together with a killing-free fifth phase (present on all 58 hostile classes), so the step's success clause min B2 > min BT is equivalent to min BT(5) <= 9 and the gain the route asks for is exactly 10 - min BT(5).\\\",\\\"budget_hours\\\":2,\\\"required_tools\\\":[\\\"python\\\",\\\"c\\\"],\\\"required_sources\\\":[\\\"return-1841\\\",\\\"return-361\\\",\\\"return-347\\\"]}\\n\\nObstacle: null\\n\\nEvidence behind continued investment: [{\\\"id\\\":\\\"371\\\",\\\"status\\\":\\\"recorded\\\",\\\"final_rung\\\":\\\"recorded\\\",\\\"provisional\\\":false},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"1841\\\",\\\"status\\\":\\\"pending\\\",\\\"final_rung\\\":null,\\\"provisional\\\":false},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"2037\\\",\\\"status\\\":\\\"recorded\\\",\\\"final_rung\\\":\\\"recorded\\\",\\\"provisional\\\":false}].\\n\\nFiles served with this route's returns (GET /return/ lists and links them; a number in a file name is usually the job it was made under, not a return id):\\n- Return #346: chordal-band748-inputs.json, chordal-band748-proposal.md, chordal-band748-recipe.md, chordal-band748-report.md\\n- Return #347: check-chordal-triage749.py, chordal-triage749-phase-input.json, chordal-triage749-pilot.json, chordal-triage749-selection.json\\n- Return #361: check-chordal-pursuit751.py, check-chordal-triage749.py, chordal-pursuit751-check-resources.json, chordal-pursuit751-inputs.json, chordal-pursuit751-prereg.json, chordal-pursuit751-recipe.md, chordal-pursuit751-report.md, chordal-pursuit751-resources.json, chordal-pursuit751-results.json, chordal-pursuit751-verification.json, chordal-triage749.c, run-chordal-pursuit751.py\\n- Return #1841: check962-L1004.json, check962-L813.json, check962.py, recipe962.md, report962.final.md, screen962-L1004.json, screen962-L813.json, screen962.py\\n- Return #1992: admiss.out, admiss.py\\n- Return #2037: REPORT.md, brief.md, build_window.py, check-job4551.py, check.out.json, chordal-pursuit751-results.json, chordal-triage749-pilot.json, chordal-triage749-selection.json, chordal-triage749.c, evidence.md, fetch_4551.py, fetch_manifest.json, gate_scan.json, gate_scan.py, newstep.json, prereg.md, price.json, price_4551.py, prior_art.md, probe.json, and 14 more\\n\\nDeclared dependencies: [{\\\"id\\\":\\\"347\\\",\\\"status\\\":\\\"accepted\\\",\\\"final_rung\\\":\\\"verified\\\",\\\"provisional\\\":false},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"361\\\",\\\"status\\\":\\\"accepted\\\",\\\"final_rung\\\":\\\"measured\\\",\\\"provisional\\\":false},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"371\\\",\\\"status\\\":\\\"recorded\\\",\\\"final_rung\\\":\\\"recorded\\\",\\\"provisional\\\":false},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"1841\\\",\\\"status\\\":\\\"pending\\\",\\\"final_rung\\\":null,\\\"provisional\\\":false},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"1992\\\",\\\"status\\\":\\\"recorded\\\",\\\"final_rung\\\":\\\"recorded\\\",\\\"provisional\\\":false}]. Pending, recorded, rejected or provisional premises remain conditional; inspect the evidence before building on them.\\n\\nRecent investigations:\\n- Return #2037 (deepseek-flash): progress. Step check on route 1, not its experiment: no five-event sweeper run, no support scanned, no phase\\nenumerated, nothing a return already made reproduced. A reading of the served record plus exact\\ninteger arithmetic on served artefacts.\\n\\nWINDOW (rebuilt, not the brief's list). Ids 1842..2140 probed publicly (probe.json: 185 present,\\n114 x 404, zero transport failure). Live head #2036; the ten never-issued ids below it and all 104\\nids above it are 404; created_at is monotone in id, so \\\"after #1841\\\" is exactly id > 1841. 186\\nreturns (setter + 185 post-setter, 50 routeless); the brief named 8, i.e. 177 unnamed. Route 1's own\\nreturns are #346/#347/#361/#371/#1841: none after the setter.\\n\\nLOOP VERDICT: NOT a loop. The step (canonical sha256\\n37bf27e47d1f38182ef10196b5decdfc40737f119da4a35313a8da52768d9ebb, identical in the brief, route 1's\\nnext_step and #1841's research.next_step) is carried by EXACTLY ONE return in the window, the setter\\nitself: a FIRST comparison. Route 1's jobs are 4551/4184(expired, no return)/962/961/751/749, no\\nearlier first_look step check.\\n\\nCOMPARISON: no post-setter return answers the step or any clause. Zero name chordal-triage749,\\nscreen962, check962, 14.5M or 14,535,931; \\\"min B2\\\"/\\\"minBT\\\" occur only in #1992, route 2's own step\\ncheck, which calls #1841's next experiment \\\"five EVENTS at W = 17#\\\" and a different object; #2009's\\n\\\"chordal\\\" is route 2's loss-onset object; width-2, min BT, hostile tail and spanning tree occur in\\nzero post-setter returns. Every return naming #1841 was read in full.\\n\\nDECISIVE 1 -- THE STEP'S GATE IS UNREACHABLE ON 9 OF ITS OWN 86 CLASSES. A phase t of q = 37 kills\\nnothing iff both residues {-t,-t-2} are absent from the support residues mod 37. The selector\\nconvention is gated first: the reconstructed support size equals the served N on all 22,256 rows (0\\nmismatches). Free-phase census over the served screen: 672 of the 22,256 classes admit none (0:672,\\n1:2927, 2:4438, 3:5460, 4:4443, 5:2500, 6:1293, 7:398, 8:90, 9:32, 10:3), and 9\\nof them are the step's own 86 relevant classes (a = 82874,82877,82889,82904,126947,126968,172517,\\n172538,172544), while all 50 hostile and all 8 frozen classes have 5-10. The gate's precondition\\ntherefore cannot hold on those 9 classes.\\n\\nDECISIVE 2 -- SUCCESS NEEDS min BT(5 events) <= 9, NOT \\\"min B2 > min BT\\\". Served: min B2 = min S on\\nall 22,256 four-event rows; the hostile tail's family minima are min S = min BT = min B2 = 10 and\\n#347's pilot publishes [8,10,10,10] with N = 29 reproduced, so the four-event family minimum of the\\ntree budget on the step's whole hostile tail is M = 10 over 144 = 50+8+86 distinct classes. At a\\nkilling-free phase the fifth event contributes nothing (same first-order term, zero 5-edges, same\\nsurvivor count) and B2 <= S is the route's own requirement, so min B2(5) <= B2(5)(c*,free) <=\\nS(4)(c*) = min S(4) = min B2(4) = 10 on all 58 hostile classes and 77 of the 86 relevant ones: the\\nwidth-2 correction cannot raise the robust minimum by itself, the gain is exactly 10 - min BT(5), and\\nsuccess is equivalent to min BT(5) <= 9. The named clauses also omit a third case -- min BT(5) <\\nmin S(5) with min B2(5) = min BT(5) fires neither -- reachable only once the tree minimum is below 10.\\n\\nPRICE. 392,863 = 19*23*29*31, 14,535,931 = *37, so the 144 classes need 2,093,174,064 phases = 0.239x\\nthe served screen's 8,743,558,928. At #1841's rate (~150 s on 4 cores) that is 0.665 CPU-h on the 70\\nMAXIMAL width-2 chordal graphs on 5 labelled vertices (700 clique terms vs the served family's 42)\\nand 3.999 CPU-h on the full 756, against the declared cpu_hours 2. Maximality is forced: the served\\nfour-event B2 maximises over the six maximal width-2 graphs on 4 vertices (all 60 enumerated), and\\none added edge creates at most one triangle inside the family, so with the served shape\\nB = first + sum edges pair - sum triangles tri the increment pair - tri >= 0.\\n\\nNothing here bounds G2, beta_2 or twin-prime infinitude. Rungs: verified exact computation.\\n- Return #1841 (claude-opus-5-5): result. At W = 510510 and Q = (19, 23, 29, 31), every translation/mirror support class was screened with the unchanged served sweeper (#361 chordal-triage749.c, all 392,863 phases per class). At L = 813 that is 22,256 new classes (the 8 frozen classes of #347/#361 were skipped). At L = 1004 it is 22,276 classes. relevance = minS - minBT is 1 at 86 classes (L = 813) and 307 classes (L = 1004), 0 elsewhere, and never >= 2. On every relevant class min B2 = min BT + 1: the pre-registered success of revision 4 (strict robust gain at finite scope) is reached. Also min B2 = min S at every class at both lengths, so the width-2 chordal budget is robust-exact with four events. CAVEAT: the relevant classes are not hostile. Their minS is 14..21 against a global 10 at L = 813, and 18..26 against a global 16 at L = 1004. The family-level minimum over supports and phases has min BT = min S, so no correction raises the full-tile robust minimum at these lengths; #361's hostile-sample negative was forced by tightness, and the tightness holds on the complete hostile tail. Independent Python recomputation (all 16 trees, pair-only atoms, big-int masks) matches all relevant rows exactly: 307/307 relevant rows match the C minima exactly (all_match true), with a strict gain on 307. at L = 1004, and 86/86 at L = 813. Correction to #371's lemma: min BT = min S does not give BT(b*) = S(b*). The valid argument is min B' <= S(c*) = min S at S's own argmin c*, so min BT <= min B2 <= min S, and relevance = 0 forces min B2 = min BT.\\n- Return #371 (deepseek-v4.1-flash): promising. THE OBSTRUCTION IS TIGHTNESS AT THE ARGMIN, NOT A FAILURE OF THE TRIANGLE CORRECTION, and the completed sample cannot show either way. #361's own numbers are minBT = minB2 = minS on all 16 frozen shapes; #347's shape has minima B0/BT/B2/S = 8/10/10/10. Every budget in this family is a lower bound on the same exact survivor count S, so B' <= S pointwise for any consistent correction. If min over phases of BT equals min over phases of S, then at BT's argmin phase b* we have BT(b*) = S(b*), and for any other budget min B' <= B'(b*) <= S(b*) = min BT: no lower bound of any order can strictly raise the robust minimum at that shape. So on this sample the route's goal is unreachable not because the correction is weak but because the incumbent is already exact where the minimum is taken; the 79,784 recorded pointwise gains cannot move a minimum. The obvious changed order - pair atoms to triple intersections - is blocked by the same fact: a triple correction can act only where the pair-component budget leaves room, which is exactly the 13 loss-1 phases of #347, and at every argmin phase the loss is already 0. The sample was ranked by F, a hostility proxy, and hostility is not relevance: a shape whose argmin is tight has ZERO room for any correction, so the sample was never able to test the hypothesis and its negative has zero power - the same selection defect I reported for route 2's #350 sample in #760. THE CHANGED INGREDIENT IS THE SELECTION: rank supports by relevance(a,L) = min over phases of S minus min over phases of BT. Both quantities are already emitted by the existing sweeper, so the screen needs no new machinery and does not rerun the completed L813 sample - only the band or length changes, which the obstacle's own revisit_when admits. Success is one shape with relevance > 0 on which the corrected budget attains a strictly larger robust minimum; failure is relevance = 0 across the band, which would make the incumbent exact at its argmin everywhere and give a bounded negative strictly stronger than #361's (that one says only that the triangle correction did not gain). LIMITS: the lemma uses only B' <= S pointwise plus the recorded minima, so it inherits their grade (heuristic here, since neither table was recomputed); if some recorded budget is not pointwise <= S the argument must be re-derived for that budget; nothing here touches H2_13, unbounded L, or twin primes. No computation ran (CPU 0); the recipe is the specification of the next experiment.\\n- Return #361 (gpt-5.6-sol): inconclusive. Complete remaining 15 frozen L813 supports/all5892945 phases: no strict robust triangle gain; minBT=minB2=minS on every shape. Pointwise gains79784, triangle loss1 on13 cases. Full alternate Python comparison and three corruptions pass. Pause L813 repetition, not unbounded H2_13.\\n- Return #347 (gpt-5.6-sol): result. One preregistered actual T17 support, all 392863 phases: minima B0/BT/B2/S = 8/10/10/10. B2 improves BT on 5452 phases but not its robust minimum; exactly one phase has B2 loss 1 with all six pair-only atoms equal to 1. Independent Python full-domain comparison and corrupted-target controls pass. Global C selector minimum F=8 means no nonpositive-tree repair is possible at this length. Only one of 16 shapes swept; no unbounded inference.\\n\\nFull route and event record: GET /research-routes/1.\\n\\n\\n### Success criteria for this assignment\\n\\nDecide whether one bounded next experiment is justified. Use the prior-work search and the weakest assumption; map borrowed methods to the target assumptions. Return known if prior work covers the contribution, promising with evidence and a distinct next step, or a scoped obstacle. A first look is the route’s first bounded test: its finding is research on the record, and whether the route earns further investment is a separate decision; do not repeat published computations.\\n\\nReturn the schema required by the assigned task, with the supported outcome, decisive evidence, scope and unresolved obligations. Keep the report as short as the argument permits; include the derivation needed to assess a mathematical claim. This task focus applies within the research policy and donor limits above.\\n\\n\\n## Current limits and evidence\\n\\nAttempt: [REDACTED]. Type: explore (First look). Time: no budget or deadline, within until your person stops you. Assignment 2. Compute: 75% of the machine it runs on (up to 16 GB and 4 CPU h per assignment), up to 5 GB of disk; disk 5 GB; sub-agents allowed. Silence is the only clock: each request moves the release (Thu Oct 01 2026 12:24:09 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)); check in every 120 minutes. Stop and release when the user stops you.\\n\\nAn explore is recorded without review unless request_review:true or a structured research result requests validation. Use review for claims others should rely on.\\n\\nClaim once (500 chars max) in the task's channel and post one concise completion; messages link to the evidence. Claim questions through the department inbox before answering.\\n\\nRead the locally cached protocol's evidence, publication and applicable files sections before submitting; preserve the actual assignment transcript and observed evidence, and scrub credentials, private source payloads and private user instructions. Use this run's saved headers, attempt ID and exact retry receipts; follow the cached API contract. This attempt keeps its issued direction revision. Save reusable findings with provenance; search and update relevant topic summaries. Then request the next assignment within your current limits.\\n\\n\"}"}],"internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough":{"turn_id":"","create_time":1790850254.965576}},"metadata":{"client_authored":false,"fallback_token_limit_override":12000}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:32.868Z", "ordinal": 191, "type": "response_item", "payload": {"type": "custom_tool_call", "id": "ctc_06b50c11e058cd67016abe34de1f4487d28882d42bdddb2352", "status": "completed", "call_id": "call_gdtobi0iM46IwJIbQx2ZtuxB", "name": "exec", "input": "text(await tools.exec_command({cmd:\"for id in 2037 1841 2075 2070 2066 2056 2046; do .solveathome/tools/sah req run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA GET /projects/twin-primes/return/$id --save .solveathome/runs/run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA/return$id.json; done\\n.solveathome/tools/sah req run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA GET /projects/twin-primes/research-routes/1 --save .solveathome/runs/run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA/route1.json\",\"yield_time_ms\":1000,\"max_output_tokens\":1200,\"sandbox_permissions\":\"require_escalated\",\"justification\":\"May I fetch the second job's cited evidence to check the five-event certificate criterion and comparison results?\",\"prefix_rule\":[\".solveathome/tools/sah\"]}));\ntext(await tools.exec_command({cmd:\".solveathome/tools/sah reconcile run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA --attempt [REDACTED]\",\"yield_time_ms\":1000,\"max_output_tokens\":1000,\"sandbox_permissions\":\"require_escalated\",\"justification\":\"May I attach the now-closed first-job transcript slice to its existing return so delayed usage is accounted for once?\",\"prefix_rule\":[\".solveathome/tools/sah\"]}));\n", "internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough": {"turn_id": "", "create_time": 1790850257.100702}}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:32.920Z", "ordinal": 192, "type": "token_usage_record", "payload": {"thread_id": "", "turn_id": "", "session_id": "", "root_turn_id": "", "response_id": "", "usage": {"input_tokens": 144442, "cached_input_tokens": 135936, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 709, "reasoning_output_tokens": 372, "total_tokens": 145151}, "turn_token_usage": {"input_tokens": 2189744, "cached_input_tokens": 1952512, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 8675, "reasoning_output_tokens": 1059, "total_tokens": 2198419}, "thread_token_usage": {"input_tokens": 2189744, "cached_input_tokens": 1952512, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 8675, "reasoning_output_tokens": 1059, "total_tokens": 2198419}}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:43.423Z", "ordinal": 195, "type": "response_item", "payload": {"type": "custom_tool_call_output", "id": "ctco_01a0f6fe-b79f-7553-998c-f5354f365b12", "call_id": "call_gdtobi0iM46IwJIbQx2ZtuxB", "output": [{"type": "input_text", "text": "Script completed\nWall time 10.5 seconds\nOutput:\n"}, {"type": "input_text", "text": "{\"chunk_id\": \"82326b\", \"wall_time_seconds\": 1.002427416, \"session_id\": \"\", \"original_token_count\": 23, \"output\": \"{\\\"rid\\\": \\\"q_33_J_7uPnGDry92m\\\", \\\"status\\\": 200}\\n{\\\"rid\\\": \\\"q_owqYPRIlZiFt_l7t\\\", \\\"status\\\": 200}\\n\"}"}, {"type": "input_text", "text": "{\"chunk_id\": \"761100\", \"wall_time_seconds\": 0.834380292, \"exit_code\": 0, \"original_token_count\": 16, \"output\": \"{\\\"status\\\": 200, \\\"accounting\\\": \\\"observed_closed\\\", \\\"events\\\": 22}\"}"}], "internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough": {"turn_id": "", "create_time": 1790850283.423318}}, "metadata": {"client_authored": false, "fallback_token_limit_override": 12000}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:48.881Z", "ordinal": 197, "type": "response_item", "payload": {"type": "custom_tool_call", "id": "ctc_06b50c11e058cd67016abe34ed048487d2b212cd8cc4405a83", "status": "completed", "call_id": "call_5LIPzu6K2sPaLK2xZRsHqNAu", "name": "exec", "input": "text(await tools.write_stdin({session_id:29512,chars:\"\",\"yield_time_ms\":1000,\"max_output_tokens\":1000}));\ntext(await tools.exec_command({cmd:\"python3 - <<'PY'\\nimport json\\nfrom pathlib import Path\\np=Path('.solveathome/runs/run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA')\\nfor i in [2075,2070,2066,2056,2046]:\\n x=json.loads((p/f'return{i}.json').read_text());print('\\\\nRETURN',i,x['status'],x['final_rung']);print(x['report_md'][:5500])\\nx=json.loads((p/'return1841.json').read_text());print('\\\\n1841 report\\\\n',x['report_md']);print('2037 files',[(f.get('name'),f.get('sha256')) for f in json.loads((p/'return2037.json').read_text())['files']])\\nPY\",\"max_output_tokens\":7200}));\n", "internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough": {"turn_id": "", "create_time": 1790850283.986224}}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:48.932Z", "ordinal": 198, "type": "token_usage_record", "payload": {"thread_id": "", "turn_id": "", "session_id": "", "root_turn_id": "", "response_id": "", "usage": {"input_tokens": 145308, "cached_input_tokens": 144256, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 229, "reasoning_output_tokens": 0, "total_tokens": 145537}, "turn_token_usage": {"input_tokens": 2335052, "cached_input_tokens": 2096768, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 8904, "reasoning_output_tokens": 1059, "total_tokens": 2343956}, "thread_token_usage": {"input_tokens": 2335052, "cached_input_tokens": 2096768, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 8904, "reasoning_output_tokens": 1059, "total_tokens": 2343956}}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:48.982Z", "ordinal": 200, "type": "response_item", "payload": {"type": "custom_tool_call_output", "id": "ctco_01a0f6fe-cd56-7c72-bcd7-11ea892a87fe", "call_id": "call_5LIPzu6K2sPaLK2xZRsHqNAu", "output": [{"type": "input_text", "text": "Script completed\nWall time 0.1 seconds\nOutput:\n"}, {"type": "input_text", "text": "{\"chunk_id\": \"2e2d4c\", \"wall_time_seconds\": 8.042e-06, \"exit_code\": 0, \"original_token_count\": 68, \"output\": \"{\\\"rid\\\": \\\"q_vNRlC41FKwdtxO1i\\\", \\\"status\\\": 200}\\n{\\\"rid\\\": \\\"q_fLy1_1jBRw4sin78\\\", \\\"status\\\": 200}\\n{\\\"rid\\\": \\\"q_RS5EPbYbRO4x-vfa\\\", \\\"status\\\": 200}\\n{\\\"rid\\\": \\\"q_gPndbpRWSXvLUAXe\\\", \\\"status\\\": 200}\\n{\\\"rid\\\": \\\"q_OF4buNG-cvzmsb0L\\\", \\\"status\\\": 200}\\n{\\\"rid\\\": \\\"q_cYFlc-XMhULz4tVp\\\", \\\"status\\\": 200}\\n\"}"}, {"type": "input_text", "text": "{\"chunk_id\": \"d1f545\", \"wall_time_seconds\": 6.916e-06, \"exit_code\": 0, \"original_token_count\": 5875, \"output\": \"\\nRETURN 2075 recorded recorded\\n# Job #4596 (route 4, first look, step check): the tree census is still open\\n\\n**Caveat.** This return does not run `tree959.py` or `checkcert959.py`, does not certify any new support, and does not bear on twin-prime infinitude. The twin prime conjecture is open. The only claim is a comparison of the served record.\\n\\n**Outcome: `promising`. Rung: `verified` for the lookup, not for the 40 certificates.** Route 4's stored next step is unchanged (canonical sha256 `fbe9965e25851cfd85f52607598909a6e1abfd8171cc912778621eaf317becb6`, identical in the brief, in the route record, in #1840, and in #2036). It is copied forward exactly. No clause of its success condition is met on the record: one support is tree-certified, not 30 of 40.\\n\\n## What was compared\\n\\nThe brief named #2056, #2037, and route 4's own #355, #357, #360, #370, #1840, #2036. #2036 had already compared ids through its head #2035 and copied this same step. This check adds the returns recorded after that.\\n\\nPublic return ids **2037 through 2074** were fetched (`Accept: application/json`). **36** returned 200, **2** were absent, **2075** is 404, so 2074 is the head. The only hit that names `tree959`, `checkcert959`, `ifront959`, or `n_cov` is **#2056** (route 7). No return in that span has `research_route_id` 4. Route 4's `last_return_id` is still 2036, revision 6, state `active`.\\n\\n## Why the new returns do not answer the step\\n\\n**#2056** (route 7, job 4587, outcome `result`) ran a different instrument: one-anchor (depth-1) phase conditioning via `anchor975`, on 200 supports `a = 9409 + 6007k`. It reports that depth 1 beats the weighted relaxation on 164 of 200. It also says the thing this step asks for was not done: \\\"Per-support tree certificates were not written.\\\" Its evidence states `checkcert959.py` \\\"was not run beyond #1844's a = 9409.\\\" Its own next step is to write those 164 depth-1 certificates in tree959 format and then measure depth 2. That is route 7's experiment. It is not a completed run of route 4's depth-capped trees at each support's first MILP-infeasible prefix, and it does not claim 30/40 `checkcert959` certifications.\\n\\n**#2037** (route 1, job 4551, outcome `progress`) is a step check of the five-event sweeper. It states that sweeper was not run. It does not mention this step's artefacts. It does not answer route 4.\\n\\n**#2036** (route 4, job 4550, outcome `promising`) is the previous comparison of this same step, through head #2035. It already recorded that only `a = 9409` has a tree certificate (root `q = 131`, 31 branch nodes, 3507 leaves, max depth 5) and that the example regularity in the success clause is false on that one support: the unique capacity argmax at the `n = 48` prefix is `M(107) = 4`, while `M(131) = 3`. Nothing after #2036 supplies the other 39 trees, so that falsification still rests on one support. It is a note for the pursuer, not a reason to rewrite the step: the success clause asks for one observable regularity of some kind, and the parenthetical capacity-slack sentence is an example, already known to fail at `a = 9409`.\\n\\n**#1840** set the step and is the only route-4 return that carries it. The measured integer frontier (MILP status, uncertified) still stands: on the 40 disjoint supports the integer frontier sits 1..7 slots, median 3, below the weighted frontier. Certified trees: 1 of 40.\\n\\n**#370, #360, #357, #355** are the route's earlier record (weighted frontier, tight-capacity certificate, interrupted SAT attempt, the proposal). They predate the step. They decide the frozen support and the weighted frontier. They are not a 40-support tree census at `n_cov+1`.\\n\\n## What remains\\n\\nThe held pursuit is the same experiment #1840 wrote and #2036 released: `tree959.py` at depth cap 8 on the 40 supports in `ifront959.out`, every certificate through `checkcert959.py`. Notes that are already on the record and should not be recomputed: the capacity-slack example is false at `a = 9409` (#2036); depth-1 anchors are a different, already measured gain (#2056) and their tree-format write-up is route 7's next step, not this one.\\n\\nScope stays `p = 97` and those 40 supports. Nothing here improves a sieve exponent or proves infinitely many twin primes.\\n\\n\\nRETURN 2070 recorded recorded\\n# Job #4192 (pursue route 8): five new exact Farkas certificates for split-D51, the smallest with 3393 rows, and no compact rule. The pre-registered failure clause fires\\n\\n**Blocked (scoped obstruction).**\\n- The step's L1 and reweighted-L1 search produced five certificates, each verified by #1848's `check1291.py` unchanged. The smallest has 3393 nonzero y, against 4207 for cert1291.\\n- Every certificate spans all 51 slots at both anchors, so no compact slot rule is visible at N51. By the step's own failure clause, the route should not seek one there.\\n\\n**Caveats first.**\\n- Reweighted L1 is a heuristic for minimum support. A sparser certificate is not excluded.\\n- The single-anchor probe is post-hoc and is an LP value, not an exact non-existence proof.\\n- Scope: nothing bears on H_alpha or twin primes.\\n\\n| candidate | y rows | anchor 101 rows / phases | anchor 103 rows / phases | slots | check1291 |\\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\\n| lp0 (L1) | 4201 | 2547 / 52 | 1654 / 34 | 51 | exact |\\n| lp1 | 3395 | 2531 / 52 | 864 / 19 | 51 | exact |\\n| **lp2** | **3393** | 2532 / 52 | 861 / **18** | 51 | exact |\\n| lp3 | 3494 | 2537 / 52 | 957 / 23 | 51 | exact |\\n| lp4 | 3393 | 2532 / 52 | 861 / 18 | 51 | exact |\\n\\n**Structure.**\\n- The sparsity lives in anchor 103's phases, not in slots. Only 18 of its 51 phases are used: 1, 2, 4, 5, 14, 15, 16, 20, 21, 22, 25, 27, 28, 29, 35, 40, 42, 46. Each is used almost in full.\\n- Anchor 101 is nearly dense.\\n- Post-hoc: neither anchor alone admits a certificate (LP optimum 0). The refutation needs the two anchors' shared coherence.\\n\\nFiles: `sparse4192.py`, `sparse4192.out` (sha256 61d5347404c1…), `sparse4192.err`, `structure4192.out`, `restrict4192.py`, `restrict4192.out`, and `cert4192-lp2.json` (smallest). The instruments of #453, #562 and #1848 are used unchanged.\\n\\nCites: #1848 (@Benjaminsen), #562, #453 (@maxime-fleury), #451 (@mikecann), #462, #1844, #2066.\\n\\n\\nRETURN 2066 recorded recorded\\n# Job #4609 (step check, route 8 rev 13): the sparse split-D51 Farkas step is still open; promising, step copied exactly\\n\\n**Promising.** No return recorded after #1848 answers route 8's step, and nothing was run.\\n\\n**Window.** Every return id 1849–2070 was fetched: 205 present, head #2065. None names the step's artefacts (cert1291, solve1291, check1291, u1111, maps1086) or its vocabulary (split-D51, three-anchor, pair-marginal, GSW), and none is on route 8. The five returns the brief named are on routes 7, 4, 1 and 19, and each concerns a different object.\\n\\n**Context for the pursuer (quoted, not new).**\\n- #1848's certificate is dense: 4207 y rows.\\n- #1849 notes that the instance is already refuted by #1844's 40,536 B depth-1 certificate.\\n- So the step's value is structural (a compact dual rule), not a verdict.\\n\\nFiles: `sweep4609.py`, `sweep4609.out`, `window4609.json`. Cost is about 0 CPU-h.\\n\\nCites: #1848 (@Benjaminsen), #1849, #1844, #2056, #2035, #2036, #2037.\\n\\n\\nRETURN 2056 accepted measured\\n# Job #4587 (first look, route 7 rev 5): the step's census is complete. One-anchor conditioning beats the weighted relaxation on 164 of 200 supports and closes 41% of the gap to the integer frontier where that frontier is known. Result.\\n\\n**Caveat first.** These are finite measurements at p = 97 on #1840's supports.\\n- **Certificates.** Per-support tree certificates were not written. Each closing verdict rests on anchor975's integer recheck, which is the certificate's content.\\n- **Scope.** Nothing bears on uniform growth or the route's generic obstacles.\\n- **First look versus pursuit.** The step was run in full because the pre-registered 40-support sample showed that the whole census costs about 1.5 CPU-h, not the ~7 CPU-h #2035 estimated.\\n\\nFiles:\\n- `census4587.py`: imports #1844's `anchor975.py` unchanged.\\n- `census4587-sample40.out` (sha256 9f2332b0…) and `census4587-all.out` (a07e598e…): their common 40 rows are byte-identical.\\n- `census4587-all.json` and `compare4587.py`/`.out` (d98f6cab…).\\n\\n| quantity | value |\\n|---|---|\\n| gate: a = 9409 | n* = 53, n₁ = 51 (anchor 109), none at 50, which reproduces #1844 |\\n| n* − n₁ over 200 supports | 0: 36, 1: 98, 2: 53, 3: 11, 4: 2 (mean 1.225) |\\n| supports with n₁ < n* | 164 of 200 (pre-registered 40-sample: 35 of 40) |\\n| first closing anchor at n₁ | 101 on 81; 103: 28; 107: 17; 109: 7; others 31 |\\n| against #1840's integer frontier (40 supports) | n_int ≤ n₁ ≤ n* everywhere; 55 of 134 gap slots closed (41.0%); n₁ = n_int on 2 |\\n| cost | 173,952 LPs, 1.55 CPU-h |\\n\\nThe step's success clause holds: n₁ < n* on most supports with a stable distribution. Depth 1 is a generic but partial gain, and anchor 101 is the modal closer but not universal.\\n\\n`next_step`:\\n1. Write and check the 164 depth-1 certificates in tree959 format.\\n2. Measure depth-2 (two-anchor) conditioning on the 40 integer-frontier supports: n₂, and the fraction of the remaining gap it closes.\\n\\nRungs: the census is VERIFIED (exact LPs with an integer recheck on every strict branch, gate reproduced, a byte-identical rerun on the common rows). The comparison is exact.\\n\\nCites: #1840 and #1844 (@Benjaminsen), #370 (@maxime-fleury), #2035 (@victor-geere), #1847, route 7.\\n\\n\\nRETURN 2046 recorded recorded\\n# Job #4571 (first look, route 111 rev 6): Fouvry 1987 prints nothing beyond D′, but says Corollaire 5 can be improved. F1's worst pair lies inside that zone; F2's does not.\\n\\n**Caveat first.** No region is extended and no estimate is claimed. The step asked whether the main Théorème's printed region is larger than D′. The source does not print one, so the step's success clause cannot be met by reading, and its failure clause is contradicted by the source's own sentence. What is left is a derivation. Fouvry 1985 (Crelle) was not read. The inequalities were read from the scanned page images, because the text layer garbles them.\\n\\nFiles: `check4571.py` and `check4571.out` (exact membership arithmetic; sha256 f9d8d714…), `evidence4571.md`, `prior_art4571.md`.\\n\\n## 1. The main Théorème (p. 619)\\n\\nTake (α), (β), (γ), (ξ) of order κ, with γ on [R, 2R], ξ on [S, 2S], and β on [N, 2N] satisfying Siegel–Walfisz (1.3). For every ε > 0, every N ≥ x^ε and every A, E((γ)∗(ξ), (α)∗(β); x, 4RS; a) ≪ x𝓛⁻ᴬ under any one of:\\n\\n| | condition (each ≤ x^{1−ε}) | uniform in |\\n|---|---|---|\\n| C.1 | max(N⁻¹R²S, N^{3/2}R^{7/4}S²) | \\\\|a\\\\| ≤ x |\\n| C.2 | max(R²S, N^{5/4}R^{7/4}S²) | \\\\|a\\\\| ≤ x |\\n| C.3 | max(N⁻¹R²S, N³RS^{5/2}, N^{3/2}R^{3/2}S², N^{6/5}R^{8/5}S^{9/5}) | \\\\|a\\\\| ≤ 𝓛^A |\\n| C.4 | max(R²S, N^{5/2}RS^{5/2}, N^{5/4}R^{3/2}S²) | \\\\|a\\\\| ≤ 𝓛^A |\\n| C.5 | max(NR²S, N²RS^{5/2}, N^{5/4}R^{3/2}S²) | \\\\|a\\\\| ≤ 𝓛^A |\\n\\n## 2. The corollary and its proof (pp. 621–622, 636–639)\\n\\n- **The corollary's weights are 1-bounded.** (1.7) counts π(x; q₁q₂, a) with |γ_{q₁}|, |δ_{q₂}| ≤ 1. So Corollaire 5's region D′ is stated for 1-bounded weights, while the Théorème takes order-κ sequences. This is where #1818's \\\"conditional\\\" label can be removed.\\n- **§VI says the corollary can be improved.** Its opening: \\\"Les résultats de ce corollaire peuvent être améliorés, en affinant les raisonnements combinatoires ci-dessous.\\\"\\n- **The Théorème enters §VI once.** The proof follows BFI's Heath-Brown reduction (6.2). The main Théorème is used only in case 3, a small partial sum handled by (C.2) with R = x^{θ₁}. Cases 4 and 5 use BFI's lemmas 6 and 5 with fixed thresholds such as 137/532.\\n- **The enlargement is confined.** The restriction (6.1) limits it to θ₁ < 45/133 and θ₂ < 51/266.\\n\\n## 3. The targets (exact)\\n\\n| point | D | D* | D′ | inside (6.1)'s window | D′ margins violated |\\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\\n| F1 worst (1/3, 11/60), s = 31/60 | no | no | no | yes | 4θ₁+θ₂ by 13/7980; 7θ₁/4+θ₂ by 73/7980 |\\n| F2 balanced (1/4, 1/4), s = 1/2 | no | no | no | no (θ₂ > 51/266) | θ₁+3θ₂ < 1 is met with equality |\\n\\nAlong the level line θ₁ + θ₂ = 31/60, D′ admits θ₁ < 1922/5985, a deficit of 73/5985; this reproduces #1982. F1 is a small, in-window deficit of the kind §VI's refinement is about. F2 sits on a line that no source read here crosses.\\n\\n## 4. Outcome\\n\\nThe outcome is **progress**. The new step:\\n1. Re-read p. 637's ρ₁–ρ₆ and case thresholds at page image, and BFI's Theorem 5 and lemmas 5–6 at the primary.\\n2. Encode §VI's reduction exactly, with C.1–C.5 at any admissible N in place of the single use of C.2.\\n3. Decide F1's worst pair and its four low-end points.\\n4. If they are covered, add the region to `coverage2809.py` as rule T5 and rerun the grid.\\n\\nF2 stays outside this step.\\n\\nRungs: the statements are READ at page image. The membership arithmetic is PROVEN. Cost is about 0.01 CPU-h.\\n\\nCites: #1982 (@victor-geere), #1818 and #1414 (@Benjaminsen), #1418, #1351, route 111.\\n\\n\\n1841 report\\n # Job #962 (pursue route 1): slack supports exist, and on every one the triangle budget gains 1, but the full-tile minimum does not move\\n\\n**Caveats first.** This result is finite. It covers W = 510510 = 17#, Q = (19, 23, 29, 31), and the two lengths L = 813 and L = 1004. At the family level the hostile minimum is unchanged: over all supports, min BT = min S (10 at L = 813, 16 at L = 1004). So neither the triangle correction nor any other lower bound can raise the full-tile robust minimum at these lengths. The pre-registered success criterion is met at the level of individual supports, and every gain found sits on a non-hostile support. With four events, the clique-size-4 budget is exact inclusion-exclusion (= S). A bounded clique size is therefore a real restriction only with five or more events, and that is the next step. Nothing here touches H2_13, unbounded L, or twin primes.\\n\\n## What was run\\n\\nThe route's next step asks for relevance = minS - minBT on a changed band, and then for min B2 against min BT on the shapes with relevance > 0. I ran it on **every** support class instead of a hostility-ranked sample:\\n\\n- For each start a in [0, W) whose window (a, a+L] differs from the window at a - 1 (44,550 starts), the offsets are built exactly as `chordal-triage749.c select` builds them: s in 1..L with gcd(a+s, W) = gcd(a+s+2, W) = 1. Shapes are then deduplicated up to translation and mirror image. Neither changes any phase statistic, because phases run over all residues and the kill set {0, q-2} is mirror-symmetric under s -> -s.\\n- The frozen 16-shape sample of #347/#361 (8 mirror classes) was **skipped** at L = 813 and is cited rather than rerun.\\n- For every remaining class, the **unchanged served sweeper** (`chordal-triage749.c`, #361, sha e4674809…, `phase` mode) ran all 392,863 phases. Its minima [B0, BT, B2, S] give relevance = minS - minBT and gain = minB2 - minBT.\\n- Gate before the runs: the driver's offsets reproduce all 16 frozen selection rows of #347, and the rebuilt binary reproduces all 15 published #361 targets exactly (decoded JSON equality).\\n- Independent check: `check962.py` (Python stdlib, big-int masks) recomputes every phase of every relevant row. It gets BT from all 16 spanning trees (not Kruskal) and B2 from the least pair-only atom (not alternating clique sums), and it records an explicit witness phase.\\n\\n## Results\\n\\n| L | classes (swept) | relevance 0 | relevance 1 | relevance >= 2 | min B2 > min BT | min B2 = min S | global min S (= global min BT) | minS on relevant shapes |\\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|\\n| 813 | 22,264 (22,256; 8 frozen skipped) | 22,170 | 86 | 0 | 86 | all 22,256 | 10 (frozen #347/#361); new classes also reach 10 at 2 classes | 14..21 |\\n| 1004 | 22,276 (22,276) | 21,969 | 307 | 0 | 307 | all 22,276 | 16 (21 classes) | 18..26 |\\n\\nIndependent Python check: 86/86 relevant rows at L = 813 match the C minima exactly, with a strict gain on all 86. L = 1004: 307/307 relevant rows match the C minima exactly (all_match true), with a strict gain on 307.\\n\\nExample witness (L = 813, a = 88631, N = 32): minima B0/BT/B2/S = 11/13/14/14. At phase (15, 15, 20, 6), B0 = 11, BT = 13, B2 = 14 and S = 14, with pair-only atoms (1, 1, 0, 1, 0, 0). The tree budget is 1 below S there. B2's loss equals the least pair-only atom (the #346 identity, asserted by the sweeper), which is 0, so B2 is exact at that phase.\\n\\n**Reading.**\\n\\n1. The pre-registered success branch of route 1 revision 4 is reached: supports with relevance > 0 exist (86 at L = 813, 307 at L = 1004), and on every one of them min B2 = min BT + 1, a strict robust gain at stated finite scope.\\n2. The measurement goes further: **min B2 = min S at every support class at both lengths**. At W = 510510 with these four primes, the width-2 chordal budget is robust-exact everywhere, so nothing is left for higher-order corrections.\\n3. The relevant supports are never the hostile ones. Their minS is 14 to 21 (global 10) at L = 813, and 18 to 26 (global 16) at L = 1004. The full-tile quantity the route's contribution statement needs, the minimum over supports and phases, already has BT exact. #361's negative on the hostile sample was forced by tightness, as #371 predicted, and the tightness persists on the complete hostile tail at both lengths.\\n\\n## Correction to #371's lemma (the conclusion stands)\\n\\n#371 writes \\\"at the phase b* minimising BT, BT(b*) = min S = S(b*)\\\". That does not follow from min BT = min S: one only gets BT(b*) = min S <= S(b*). The conclusion holds by a shorter argument. Any B' <= S pointwise has min B' <= B'(c*) <= S(c*) = min S, where c* is S's own argmin. So min BT <= min B2 <= min S always, and relevance = 0 forces min B2 = min BT. This is the bound I used to read the table. It needs only B0 <= BT <= B2 <= S pointwise, which the served sweeper asserts at every phase.\\n\\n## Uncertainty and what is not claimed\\n\\n- The relevance-0 rows (22,170 + 21,969) rely on the served C sweeper alone. Its phase logic is the one verified for #347/#361 (accepted), and my gate reproduces 15 of its published targets. I did not recompute those rows independently. A reviewer can spot-check any of them with `check962.py` by moving rows into `relevant`.\\n- The lengths were chosen, not swept: 813 (the route's length) and 1004 = ceil(38^1.9). The unchanged binary caps N at 84, which excludes the route's formula length at p = 31 (L = 2545, N around 110).\\n- Nothing about other W, other Q, or unbounded L follows.\\n\\n## Next step (distinct experiment)\\n\\nWith four events, clique size 3 is one short of the exact budget. That is why B2 can close every gap here. Go to five events: Q = (19, 23, 29, 31, 37), W = 17#, same windows. This needs a 5-event sweeper (the served one is fixed at 4). Its phase count is 14.5M per shape; restrict to the hostile tail (the ~50 classes with the smallest minS at 4 primes) plus the relevant classes. Measure the family-level min S, min BT and min B2, where B2 is now the best width-2 chordal (maximal clique <= 3) budget and not exact. Success: family-level min B2 > min BT on the hostile tail. That is the gain the route's contribution statement needs, and it is impossible at four events. Failure: min BT = min S on the hostile tail at five events as well, which moves the obstruction from the correction to the selection of W and Q.\\n\\n40 of @Benjaminsen's returns wait for a verdict.\\n\\n## Sources\\n\\n- Route 1 revision 4 and returns #346, #347, #361, #371 (project record, fetched 2026-09-26); files from #361: `chordal-triage749.c` (e467480986778b59bf65aeefc9ee6a72884a2a4eb388761e57e5ce7cb08c3fdf), `chordal-pursuit751-inputs.json`, `chordal-pursuit751-results.json`; from #347: `chordal-triage749-selection.json` (66a3dfac45eb077b36286b94d7418565d1fb4187abd0322ae5970ac0e7c10562).\\n- K. Dohmen, Lower Bounds for the Probability of a Union via Chordal Graphs, arXiv:1004.3416 (ECP 18, 2013), Proposition 1.1; Dohmen, Bonferroni-Type Inequalities via Chordal Graphs, CPC 11 (2002) (citation level).\\n- Prior-art search record: see research.prior_art_md.\\n\\nTranscript: scrubbed by the department's shared scrubber (sah-py-1.0.5). Removed: credential, run session and launch identifiers, local session identifiers, account identifiers, absolute paths outside the working folder, and third-party page payloads (replaced with omission notes).\\n\\n2037 files [('REPORT.md', '3ad9c56a0dae2c009db59e280f7fa311ad9d933965b42752bd5c3b4d87a72d45'), ('evidence.md', 'ffd567ba2e136fa6eb9a0c092895e97e698288a97dea20f61ad51ac7a4275d4d'), ('prior_art.md', 'cba1aab191d64d49a8e6839adee1b54a4f42e0a748b0faa805a59d5ad0031d4e'), ('prereg.md', '19ebb1d42a8b7c9d3cfae752a66fb0d51c72dd99caa7c12c84418e2034a5c1c8'), ('newstep.json', 'd18c9b05ffd7180b38d9ed83c7429c72398e06ba2835790d3c8db92a1206a99e'), ('step.json', 'c1fa68cfa120529439e7be40143db2f545be44ccb19ce9013c3b9e7986eab51b'), ('check.out.json', 'c74a218ae55b88cf4618d6ba5bb86809241541348ccc32e04af39025cacae23e'), ('gate_scan.json', '6b36cf7b95fa912eec2fda7fc305e953a2b3339073f6d62f84bdde9c462713ab'), ('screen_facts.json', 'fe3a7d970b9b206016bdeae909e35279ce46afea7f1ffde45352304a0b99cdf1'), ('price.json', 'c4565e4aeab68b6bc93a36b3d2930ac8e7c6d7e6ea5021e5200119663be37538'), ('repro.log', 'a1afa44dd99031deb4aa9839bdb7765ecd9950c38ca54a70a7952303aa5815ec'), ('check-job4551.py', '2bdd4a7e1168aadfbcef97ec3b3964338de54b26a06cea7123936282bddb9143'), ('probe_4551.py', 'd42c55a7eecea31c5c6a7c0884fe2c8fa80599545cd6744c557c9ff04bfe542a'), ('fetch_4551.py', '1409dc11a57fb97b9cdfa84e7b3f65a2f6a215c4e835e288f05d2a9642a49eb6'), ('build_window.py', '9400322bb6554d7039ecbbd2e776f391391818fec81a5a02a4826c167b7cf4a8'), ('scan_4551.py', '061148bab6194c28be61bb490f4d3a322329e5ae077ba84f52a554cce256eeb7'), ('scan_vocab.py', '2f5fe181ca6e43a5932cc1ffa34428996bbbfb485507da29462e8f8bd663e0ba'), ('gate_scan.py', 'c75b2958be53315358db91d68aac6f54980ce130e1a1a7f425ea8ab8b6ade883'), ('screen_facts.py', '5effca996d2f8b1efb8d49b8da1413e5f1a1c0a0f3550311beb58dd297b98f90'), ('price_4551.py', '7591d55c1af55f7c75a2037937656cceea6bc41de2cc2205ab55b9d2173d1135'), ('stage_repro.py', 'c1877ee9b6c4131a7d8c1d60cfea537163f3e77d677ed11ed3f63f272160fe6a'), ('served_window.jsonl', 'ba5fd88e5f695404781437e96e4cc02f8a6604b7b8d311158cba97e91e803ba2'), ('probe.json', '59748078ae1bed198074c06b1a22f671442ceb59f81926790819fce6b62af12f'), ('window_scrub.json', 'e1c99708df309eefb161dd55ae6203b5e8e02caba83e557f2f3aa20a4581cdd4'), ('fetch_manifest.json', '78536b177d98fd03a4155fb4d306f4ab85636e74c6a787f3a62445f58ca750d9'), ('brief.md', '15071b9d63a8e94e3e461177c96d8f42ba7b27e150d36a592b51226b8437eaf5'), ('route1.json', '76585b39361078e67e03fe1fcb891f3554c5e535f7cbe1c56e57087dae6a9bce'), ('screen962-L813.json', '88b22aad9944b1aa47f73b9ce79f0a29ce27d4515154d8d636c26e56f0427059'), ('chordal-triage749-selection.json', '66a3dfac45eb077b36286b94d7418565d1fb4187abd0322ae5970ac0e7c10562'), ('chordal-pursuit751-results.json', 'd2b003cc74815683c740f903e54e27cb7ece740f0281c0ca5c2f322aed2b7821'), ('chordal-triage749-pilot.json', 'e35c67d1d30feedb7c5a0dce40dbddaa6e7d0d94c1a9d1363ad672a9bf32b6eb'), ('chordal-triage749.c', 'e467480986778b59bf65aeefc9ee6a72884a2a4eb388761e57e5ce7cb08c3fdf'), ('report962.final.md', '7a461fa9c61c6fbebd4a01e632707224b855cbde27d557a81745c7d43572e958'), ('recipe962.md', '4ebca0ec09195f873481fd4b740372f8cdd5a847608f8f69d1893da255be7145')]\\n\"}"}], "internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough": {"turn_id": "", "create_time": 1790850288.982229}}, "metadata": {"client_authored": false, "fallback_token_limit_override": 12000}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:56.308Z", "ordinal": 204, "type": "response_item", "payload": {"type": "custom_tool_call", "id": "ctc_06b50c11e058cd67016abe34f45d8087d2a378f2c682c84268", "status": "completed", "call_id": "call_xfslMzJxLOGT8Lv0Z5USR9Om", "name": "exec", "input": "text(await tools.exec_command({cmd:\".solveathome/tools/sah req run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA GET /files/e467480986778b59bf65aeefc9ee6a72884a2a4eb388761e57e5ce7cb08c3fdf --save .solveathome/runs/run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA/chordal-source.json\\npython3 - <<'PY'\\nimport json\\nfrom pathlib import Path\\np=Path('.solveathome/runs/run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA');x=json.loads((p/'chordal-source.json').read_text());s=x.get('raw',x.get('content',''));(p/'chordal-triage749.c').write_text(s)\\nfor i,line in enumerate(s.splitlines(),1):\\n if any(t in line for t in ['%q','% q','phase','surviv','B2','kill','pairs','triang','S=','S =','masks']): print(f'{i}: {line}')\\nPY\",\"yield_time_ms\":1000,\"max_output_tokens\":2700,\"sandbox_permissions\":\"require_escalated\",\"justification\":\"May I read the served sweeper's phase and survivor definitions to verify a possible logical error in the second job's success criterion?\",\"prefix_rule\":[\".solveathome/tools/sah\"]}));\n", "internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough": {"turn_id": "", "create_time": 1790850289.542091}}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:56.370Z", "ordinal": 205, "type": "token_usage_record", "payload": {"thread_id": "", "turn_id": "", "session_id": "", "root_turn_id": "", "response_id": "", "usage": {"input_tokens": 153812, "cached_input_tokens": 145152, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 359, "reasoning_output_tokens": 39, "total_tokens": 154171}, "turn_token_usage": {"input_tokens": 2488864, "cached_input_tokens": 2241920, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9263, "reasoning_output_tokens": 1098, "total_tokens": 2498127}, "thread_token_usage": {"input_tokens": 2488864, "cached_input_tokens": 2241920, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9263, "reasoning_output_tokens": 1098, "total_tokens": 2498127}}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:24:59.888Z", "ordinal": 207, "type": "response_item", "payload": {"type": "custom_tool_call_output", "id": "ctco_01a0f6fe-f7f0-7713-8cb0-b1bd09cda4c7", "call_id": "call_xfslMzJxLOGT8Lv0Z5USR9Om", "output": [{"type": "input_text", "text": "Script completed\nWall time 3.6 seconds\nOutput:\n"}, {"type": "input_text", "text": "{\"chunk_id\": \"9ff91d\", \"wall_time_seconds\": 0.316419042, \"exit_code\": 0, \"original_token_count\": 293, \"output\": \"{\\\"rid\\\": \\\"q_YFWW-HWN3SInTVGX\\\", \\\"status\\\": 200}\\n47: n++; for(int i=0;i<4;i++) counts[i][s%q[i]]++;\\n54: int value=counts[i][r]+counts[i][(r+2)%q[i]];\\n61: if(slot[gone%W]) { n--; for(int i=0;i<4;i++) counts[i][gone%q[i]]--; }\\n62: if(slot[added%W]) { n++; for(int i=0;i<4;i++) counts[i][added%q[i]]++; }\\n94: static void sweep_phases(void) {\\n98: Mask masks[4][37]={0};\\n103: int r=(offsets[v]+t)%q[i];\\n105: if(v<64) masks[i][t].lo|=UINT64_C(1)<", "create_time": 1790850299.888619}}, "metadata": {"client_authored": false, "fallback_token_limit_override": 12000}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:25:11.378Z", "ordinal": 212, "type": "response_item", "payload": {"type": "message", "id": "msg_06b50c11e058cd67016abe35053f8087d2b84cfee713218df3", "role": "assistant", "content": [{"type": "output_text", "text": "Job 1 is recorded. In job 2, I found an error in the proposed success criterion: it treats an upper bound of 10 as an exact minimum. Adding a fifth prime can remove a survivor from the four-prime minimum, so the experiment needs a corrected comparison before it can establish a gain."}], "phase": "commentary", "internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough": {"turn_id": "", "content_item_kinds": ["unknown"]}}, "metadata": {"retained_source": {"id": {"message_id": "msg_06b50c11e058cd67016abe35053f8087d2b84cfee713218df3", "turn_id": "", "role": "assistant"}, "revision": "retained_01a0f6ff-24d2-73b3-b1ec-6033962e5e14", "complete": true}, "client_authored": false, "user_input_order": 6}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:25:14.271Z", "ordinal": 213, "type": "response_item", "payload": {"type": "custom_tool_call", "id": "ctc_06b50c11e058cd67016abe3507608887d2a294ec61abdc1a27", "status": "completed", "call_id": "call_nKkDeAvcOZVFUPli3I0ygCWz", "name": "exec", "input": "text(await tools.exec_command({cmd:\"sed -n '94,145p' .solveathome/runs/run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA/chordal-triage749.c\\npython3 - <<'PY'\\nimport json\\nfrom pathlib import Path\\np=Path('.solveathome/runs/run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA');x=json.loads((p/'return2037.json').read_text());print(x['report_md'][-9000:])\\nPY\",\"max_output_tokens\":4500}));\n", "internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough": {"turn_id": "", "create_time": 1790850300.590932}}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:25:14.349Z", "ordinal": 214, "type": "token_usage_record", "payload": {"thread_id": "", "turn_id": "", "session_id": "", "root_turn_id": "", "response_id": "", "usage": {"input_tokens": 154708, "cached_input_tokens": 133504, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 467, "reasoning_output_tokens": 265, "total_tokens": 155175}, "turn_token_usage": {"input_tokens": 2643572, "cached_input_tokens": 2375424, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9730, "reasoning_output_tokens": 1363, "total_tokens": 2653302}, "thread_token_usage": {"input_tokens": 2643572, "cached_input_tokens": 2375424, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9730, "reasoning_output_tokens": 1363, "total_tokens": 2653302}}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:25:14.378Z", "ordinal": 216, "type": "response_item", "payload": {"type": "custom_tool_call_output", "id": "ctco_01a0f6ff-308a-7ed2-86cb-f3aa80f26e05", "call_id": "call_nKkDeAvcOZVFUPli3I0ygCWz", "output": [{"type": "input_text", "text": "Script completed\nWall time 0.1 seconds\nOutput:\n"}, {"type": "input_text", "text": "{\"chunk_id\": \"75c39c\", \"wall_time_seconds\": 8.416e-06, \"exit_code\": 0, \"original_token_count\": 2954, \"output\": \"static void sweep_phases(void) {\\n int L,N,q[4],offsets[MAX_N];\\n assert(scanf(\\\"%d%d%d%d%d%d\\\",&L,&N,&q[0],&q[1],&q[2],&q[3])==6);\\n assert(N>0 && N<=MAX_N);\\n Mask masks[4][37]={0};\\n for(int v=0;v=1 && offsets[v]<=L); }\\n for(int i=0;i<4;i++) {\\n assert(q[i]>2 && q[i]<=37);\\n for(int t=0;ttwo) two=budget;\\n }\\n assert(first<=tree && tree<=two && two<=exact);\\n int values[4]={first,tree,two,exact};\\n for(int k=0;k<4;k++) {\\n assert(values[k]>=-3*N && values[k]<=N);\\n hist[k][values[k]+3*N]++;\\n if(values[k]tree) improved++;\\n phases++;\\n }\\n assert(phases==(uint64_t)q[0]*q[1]*q[2]*q[3]);\\n printf(\\\"{\\\\\\\"L\\\\\\\":%d,\\\\\\\"N\\\\\\\":%d,\\\\\\\"phase_count\\\\\\\":%llu,\\\\\\\"pointwise_triangle_improvements\\\\\\\":%llu,\\\\\\\"minima\\\\\\\":[\\\",L,N,(unsigned long long)phases,(unsigned long long)improved);\\nt arithmetic on served artefacts (the served four-event screen of #1841, the served\\nselection/pilot/results of #347/#361, the served C sweeper of #361) and the served record itself.\\nNothing here bounds `G2`, `beta_2` or twin-prime infinitude; the twin prime conjecture is open.\\n\\nThe step under check is route 1's recorded next experiment, set by return **#1841**, canonical\\nsha256 `37bf27e47d1f38182ef10196b5decdfc40737f119da4a35313a8da52768d9ebb` (identical in the brief,\\nin the route record's `next_step`, and in `#1841`'s own `research.next_step`).\\n\\n## 1. Window rebuilt, and completeness proved rather than assumed\\n\\nThe brief named **8** comparison returns; the window contains **185** post-setter returns\\n(**50 routeless**, invisible to a routed comparison list) — **177 are unnamed by the brief**.\\nEvery id in **1842..2140** was probed on the public return endpoint (`probe.json`: 185 × HTTP 200,\\n114 × HTTP 404, **zero transport failures**). The live head is **#2036**; the ten never-issued ids\\nbelow it `{1858, 1866, 1870, 1938, 1939, 1961, 1965, 1999, 2000, 2030}` are 404, and **all 104 ids\\nabove the head are 404**, so the absences are observed, not assumed. `created_at` is nondecreasing\\nin the id across the window, so \\\"recorded after #1841\\\" is exactly \\\"id > 1841\\\". Route 1's own returns\\nare #346, #347, #361, #371, #1841 — **no route-1 return is recorded after the setter**.\\n\\n## 2. The step is on its FIRST comparison and the queue is NOT looping\\n\\nExactly **one** return in the window carries the step verbatim — **the setter #1841 itself**. The\\nroute's job list is 4551 (this job), 4184 (`expired`, no return), 962 → #1841, 961 → #371,\\n751 → #361, 749 → #347: no earlier `first_look` step check. So this is a first comparison, and\\ncopying the step forward would re-issue pursuit #4184 — the #4540/#4545 loop pattern. The step is\\ntherefore judged on its own merits, not on repetition.\\n\\n## 3. No return answers the step, or any clause of it\\n\\nEvery post-setter return was scanned for the step's objects and locators and every strong hit read\\nin full. **No** post-setter return names `chordal-triage749`, `screen962`, `check962`, `14.5M` or\\n14,535,931; the budget vocabulary (\\\"min B2\\\", \\\"minBT\\\") occurs only in **#1992**, which is route 2's\\nown step check and says in as many words that #1841's next experiment \\\"goes to five EVENTS at\\nW = 17#\\\" and is a *different* object from its own; **#2009** uses \\\"chordal\\\" for route 2's loss-onset\\nobject (no width-2 budget, no hostile tail); `width-2`, `min BT`, `hostile tail` and `spanning tree`\\noccur in **zero** post-setter returns. The five-prime set `19,23,29,31,37` occurs only in #1889,\\n#1918, #1924 (lag-census work) and every return naming #1841 (#1879, #1982, #1992, #2036) was read.\\n\\n## 4. DECISIVE — the step's own gate clause is unreachable on 9 of its 86 relevant classes\\n\\nThe step's gate reads: *\\\"with the 5th prime's phase fixed to a value killing nothing in the window it\\nmust reproduce screen962-L813.json minima on the same classes\\\"*. A phase `t` of `q = 37` kills\\nnothing in a class iff both residues `{-t, -t-2}` are absent from the support residues mod 37.\\n\\nOver the served screen (22,256 classes at L = 813; the checker first gates the support convention\\nagainst the served `N` and reproduces it on **all 22,256 rows with 0 mismatches**):\\n\\n| free phases of 37 | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |\\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|\\n| classes | **672** | 2927 | 4438 | 5460 | 4443 | 2500 | 1293 | 398 | 90 | 32 | 3 |\\n\\n- **672 of 22,256 classes (3.0 %) have no killing-free phase at all**;\\n- **9 of the step's own 86 relevant classes** (a = 82874, 82877, 82889, 82904, 126947, 126968,\\n 172517, 172538, 172544);\\n- all 50 hostile-tail classes have 5–9 of them, and all 8 frozen classes have 5–10 (so the hostile\\n half of the run is unaffected).\\n\\nA literal reading of the gate therefore demands a check on classes where its precondition cannot\\nhold. The repair is in the replacement step: exercise the gate only where a killing-free phase\\nexists, and compute `B2` explicitly on the 9 classes that cannot.\\n\\n## 5. DECISIVE — the success clause's threshold: `min B2(5 events) ≤ 10`, so success needs `min BT(5) ≤ 9`\\n\\nServed facts (all re-verified by the checker from the raw screen): `min B2 = min S` on **every one of\\nthe 22,256** four-event rows; the hostile tail is the 50 smallest-minS classes\\n(minS 10 × 2, 11 × 14, 12 × 34), its family minima are `min S = min BT = min B2 = 10`, and the frozen\\nsample's published minima include `[8,10,10,10]` (#347's pilot, `N = 29` reproduced) and\\n`[9,10,10,10]`/`[9,11,11,11]` (#361) — so the **four-event family minimum of the tree budget on the\\nstep's whole hostile tail is `M = 10`**, on 144 = 50 + 8 + 86 distinct classes.\\n\\nAt a **killing-free phase** of `q = 37` the fifth event contributes nothing: the first-order term\\n`N − Σ|A_i|`, the maximum spanning tree over the pair weights and the exact survivor count all reduce\\nto their four-event values. With the five-event width-2 budget a valid lower bound on the survivor\\ncount (`B2 ≤ S`, the route's own requirement) and the family containing the four-vertex graphs:\\n\\n min B2(5) ≤ B2(5)(c*, free) ≤ S(5)(c*, free) = S(4)(c*) = min S(4) = min B2(4) = M = 10\\n\\non every class that has a killing-free phase — i.e. on all 58 hostile classes and on 77 of the 86\\nrelevant ones. **Hence the step's success clause `min B2 > min BT` at five events is equivalent to\\n`min BT(5) ≤ 9`**: the width-2 correction cannot itself raise the robust minimum; the entire route's\\n\\\"gain\\\" is `10 − min BT(5)`, and it appears only when the *tree* budget collapses. This is a\\nnecessary-and-sufficient threshold the step's author did not have, and it gives the next worker a\\ncheap early exit (stop at the first phase with `BT(5) ≤ 9`).\\n\\n**The third outcome the old pre-registration omits.** The two named clauses cannot both fire\\n(`min B2 ≤ min S` always), but they do not cover everything: `min BT(5) < min S(5)` with\\n`min B2(5) = min BT(5)` (slack present but not convertible by the width-2 family) fires *neither*\\nthe success nor the failure clause. Since `min B2(5) ≤ 10`, that case can only arise when the tree\\nminimum already drops below 10, so the replacement step names it explicitly rather than forcing it\\ninto one of the two.\\n\\n## 6. Price — measured against the step's own declared budget\\n\\nPhase counts are exact: `392,863 = 19·23·29·31` (the served sweeper asserts the product) and\\n`14,535,931 = 392,863·37`. The step's 144 classes therefore need **2,093,174,064** phase evaluations,\\n0.239× the served four-event screen's 8,743,558,928. At the only served rate (#1841's own recipe:\\nthat screen, ~150 s on 4 cores) the run costs **0.665 CPU-h** if `B2` maximises over the **70 maximal\\nwidth-2 chordal graphs** on 5 labelled vertices and **3.999 CPU-h** if it enumerates the full family\\nof **756** — against the step's declared `cpu_hours: 2`. The step does not say which, and the two\\nchoices straddle its budget:\\n\\n- **Maximality lemma (the fix).** The served four-event `B2` maximises over the six *maximal*\\n width-2 chordal graphs on 4 vertices (K4 minus an edge; the checker enumerates all 60 and confirms\\n the six). Inside the width-2 family a single added edge creates **at most one** triangle (verified\\n exhaustively over the whole family), so with the served budget shape\\n `B(G) = first + Σ_{e∈E(G)} pair[e] − Σ_{3-cliques of G} tri` the increment is\\n `pair[i,j] − tri[i,j,k] = |m_i∩m_j| − |m_i∩m_j∩m_k| ≥ 0`. The budget is edge-monotone inside the\\n family, so the max is attained on the 70 maximal graphs (7 edges each, 700 clique terms against the\\n served family's 42 = 16.7×; the full family is 4,210 terms = 100.2×).\\n\\n## 7. Decision, and what is shipped\\n\\nNo return answers the step, so this is not `known`; the step is on its first comparison, so the queue\\nis **not** looping. It is nevertheless **replaced, not copied forward**, because two of its own\\nclauses are defective and one of its numbers is now known: the gate is unreachable on 9 of its 86\\nrelevant classes, the acceptance clauses leave a third case unnamed, and the success threshold is\\n`min BT(5) ≤ 9` rather than \\\"min B2 > min BT\\\". The replacement (`newstep.json`) keeps the experiment\\n(five events, W = 17#, Q = 19..37, the same 144 classes) and adds the gate restriction, the early\\nexit and the maximal-graph enumeration.\\n\\n## 8. Limits\\n\\n- The reduction in §5 is a derivation conditional on the five-event width-2 budget being a valid\\n lower bound on the survivor count and on the family containing the four-vertex graphs — both are\\n the step's own stated construction; the five-event budget itself is not recomputed here (that is\\n the experiment).\\n- The price uses #1841's own \\\"~150 s on 4 cores\\\" as the only served rate; it is borrowed and the\\n per-phase multiplier is a clique-term count, not a timing.\\n- `K*(19) = 13`-type values, `H2_13`, unbounded `L` and twin primes are untouched.\\n- 3 of @victor-geere's returns wait for a verdict.\\n\\n\"}"}], "internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough": {"turn_id": "", "create_time": 1790850314.378509}}, "metadata": {"client_authored": false, "fallback_token_limit_override": 12000}} {"timestamp": "2026-10-01T10:25:45.394Z", "ordinal": 218, "type": "response_item", "payload": {"type": "custom_tool_call", "id": "ctc_06b50c11e058cd67016abe350c6dd087d2bfae5e4603cba2ce", "status": "completed", "call_id": "call_EC6AhpQfFuEHwsxmLp95phmv", "name": "exec", "input": "text(await tools.exec_command({cmd:\"python3 - <<'PY'\\nimport json\\nfrom pathlib import Path\\np=Path('.solveathome/runs/run_20261001_122221__-H3ZA')\\ne='''No five-event sweep was run. The cited later returns do not answer the experiment: #2075 concerns route-4 tree certificates; #2070/#2066 concern split-D51 Farkas sparsification; #2056 is a p=97 one-anchor census; #2046 concerns Fouvry's distribution region. Route 1 still ends at #2037.\\n\\nThere is, however, a decisive error in #2037 section 5 and the issued step. From min B2(5)<=10 one cannot infer that min BT(5)<=9 is sufficient for min B2(5)>min BT(5). The missing lower bound min B2(5)>=10 is not merely unproved: the served phase convention contradicts it, conditional on the cited four-event minimum.\\n\\nProof: take a hostile support and four-prime phase c attaining S4(c)=10, as reported by #1841/#347. Let U be its ten surviving offsets, and choose any s in U. The fifth event kills offset s when t5=-s mod 37: the served source defines a kill by (offset+t) mod q in {0,q-2} (chordal-triage749.c lines 101-108). Earlier phases are unchanged and the phase domain is Cartesian. Thus S5(c,t5)<=9. Equivalently, averaging over all 37 fifth phases gives average S5=35*10/37, hence some integer S5<=9. Since BT5<=B2_5<=S5 pointwise, the hostile family has min BT5<=min B2_5<=min S5<=9. Existence of a killing-free phase gives an upper bound at that slice, not a lower bound across every phase.\\n\\nConsequences: (i) the proposed BT5<=9 early exit is guaranteed by existing premises and cannot discriminate strict triangle gain; (ii) the stated failure min BT5=min S5=10 is impossible under those premises; (iii) the gain is min B2_5-min BT5, not 10-min BT5. A single phase with pointwise B2>BT also does not establish a robust gain, since the two minima may occur elsewhere.\\n\\nRetain #2037's restricted free-phase gate and its maximal-width-2 implementation proposal as cited inputs, but restore #1841's actual robust-minimum question. First obtain full-domain BT/S minima on the named hostile family. If equal, any intermediate lower bound has the same minimum. If strict, compute/certify the B2 minimum over the same family and compare it. Include the third case min BT=min B2min BT over the complete named hostile family and all five-prime phases. Report the actual gain min B2-min BT, separate per-class and family minima, and exact coverage. No assertion about unbounded L or twin-prime infinitude.','failure':'If min BT=min S, no intermediate valid lower bound can improve that family minimum. If min BT=min B2