{"id":2482,"job_id":5234,"problem_id":1,"lane_id":2,"type":"explore","user_id":1,"model":"deepseek-v4-flash","provider":"deepseek","report_md":"# Job #5234 — route 215 first look: sieve-level ladder at fixed W\n\n**Outcome: `promising`.** The u-dependence of the primorial paired-candidate dispersion is\nmeasurable at fixed W, and contrary to the route's own falsifier (a) it is **not** level-locked.\nA control then locates the effect: it is the **axis** (window at fixed sieve level vs sieve level at\nfixed window), not the class restriction.\n\n## What the route asked\n\nRoute 215 asks what `r_W(y) = Var[N_W(y)] / E[N_W(y)]` of the primorial paired-candidate count does\n**at a fixed large W with the sieve level y varied** (`u = ln W / ln y` free). The pre-registration's\nlaw `ln r = -(c2 u^2 + c1 u)` (c2 = 0.24, c1 = 0.13) is fitted at y = 401 and evaluated on the\ndiagonal `y = maxprime <= sqrt(W)`, where `u = 2` to seven digits; the diagonal can therefore\nidentify only `4c2 + 2c1`, and the tenth diagonal point is priced at 240 core-h.\n\n## Method\n\n`work/ladder_df2.js` is an exact parametrized product-sieve for the **Natal@5 comb** candidate count\n(two mod-30 houses {11, 17}) at window `L = W = x#` with arbitrary sieve level y; the served engine\nis the special case `y = maxprime <= sqrt(W)`. Cost `~ 3 W * sum_{7 <= p <= y} 1/p`; the pair\ncorrelation sum is accumulated in compensated Float64 with a certified roundoff bound (relative\nerror <= 1.5e-5 on every point). At the diagonal it reproduces the served table r to four decimals\nat x = 7, 11, 13, 17, 19 and the independent direct correlation sum to 1e-9 relative.\n\nRun under `sah.py bounded`: **39.3 s** for validation plus the ladder; the control 16.5 s.\n\n## Result — the fixed-W ladder\n\n| W | y | u | E | Var | r = Var/E |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 23# | 14929 | 2.0001 | 669028.799 | 243740.373 | **0.364320** |\n| 23# | 1861 | 2.5533 | 1087078.644 | 194606.443 | **0.179018** |\n| 23# | 401 | 3.2071 | 1693381.877 | 103376.936 | **0.061048** |\n| 29# | sqrt | 2.0000 | published | published | **0.3774** (cited) |\n| 29# | 3109 | 2.8090 | 27641271.920 | 3645351.875 | **0.131881** |\n| 29# | 401 | 3.7689 | 49108074.429 | 1148309.500 | **0.023383** |\n\n`r` is **strongly u-dependent at fixed W** (it falls by 0.3033 across the 23# ladder), so the\nresidual is **u-locked, not level-locked**: falsifier (a) does not fire. Residual\n`r - exp(-(0.24u^2 + 0.13u))` is strictly positive and **monotone decreasing in u at both W**:\n\n- 23#: +0.069122, +0.028926, +0.005215 (u = 2.0001, 2.5533, 3.2071)\n- 29#: +0.082170, +0.027419, +0.003121 (u = 2.0000, 2.8090, 3.7689)\n\nThese u = 2 residuals are exactly the pre-registration's own diagonal residuals.\n\n## Control — where the effect lives\n\n`work/ladder_df3.js` holds the sieve level at **y = 401** and varies W (the comb analogue of\n`variance-note.md` §6's u-sweep, which §6 computes for the full three-house set): r =\n0.601562, 0.422821, 0.253819, 0.134085, 0.061048, 0.023383 at u = 1.2921, 1.7201, 2.1927, 2.6840,\n3.2071, 3.7689 for W = 11#, 13#, 17#, 19#, 23#, 29#.\n\n| family | c2 | c1 | rms(ln r) |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| fixed **y = 401**, comb (control) | **0.2403** | **+0.0961** | 1.65e-2 |\n| fixed **y = 401**, full set (served, §6) | 0.2400 | +0.1300 | — |\n| fixed **W = 23#**, comb | 0.3039 | **-0.1025** | 8.3e-4 |\n| fixed **W = 29#**, comb | 0.2876 | **-0.0874** | 1.3e-3 |\n\n## What it changes\n\n1. **The coefficient flip is an axis effect, not a class-set effect.** At fixed y the comb\n   reproduces the served c2 = 0.24 to 0.0003 with c1 still **positive** (0.0961); c1 turns\n   **negative** only when the sieve level is the free axis. The frozen y = 401 law is a law *along\n   the window axis at fixed sieve level*; it does not transfer to the sieve-level axis at fixed W,\n   where the residual is not a function of u alone either (its u = 2 value is +0.069 at 23# but\n   +0.082 at 29#).\n2. **The u-axis is real and cheap.** It is a second, unprobed axis of a law already on the record,\n   measured in seconds against the 240 core-h tenth diagonal point; r moves by a factor ~6 along it\n   versus ~1.09 along the diagonal drift. It gives Q-var41 (item 9) a concrete functional\n   (a two-variable (W, u) law, with c1 changing sign between axes) that a derivation must target.\n3. **The 2-parameter law is only approximate on the comb** (rms 1.65e-2 at fixed y), so a fit on one\n   axis is not transferable as a law.\n\n## Evidence and scope\n\n`work/check_df.py` — stdlib, imports nothing from the producer: it rebuilds the candidate word by\ndirect enumeration, the two-point correlation C(s) from the exact factor product, and both ladders\nfrom their JSON; it reproduces the served diagonal r to four decimals at 7#, 11#, 13# and the\nempirical length-W window-count variance at 7# (1.053231 vs 1.052824). **56 checks, 0 FAIL, exit 0**;\n`--corrupt` detects planted mutations and exits 1.\n\n**Uncertainty.** Each fixed-W fit rests on 3 points; W = 31# was not run (cost ~30x W = 29#) and the\n29# diagonal is cited from the served table, not recomputed. `paper/variance-note.md` was fetched\nfrom source this run: its §6 already gives a u-sweep, but at **fixed sieve level y = 401 with the\nwindow L = y^u varying** (full three-house set), and §7's diagonal is the u = 2 slice — no sweep\nwith the sieve level varying at fixed W appears there, so this ladder is new measurement rather than\nre-analysis. Whether (c2(W), c1(W)) stabilises is the open question.\n\n**Not claimed:** nothing here bounds G2, beta_2 or twin-prime infinitude; the bridge from this\ndispersion to route 143's moment dial or route 108's large-prime remainder remains route 194/191's\nown labelled-CONJECTURAL link and is not asserted.\n\n## Session and attribution note\n\nThis attempt was issued to run `run-2026-10-07-df`; its Freebuff session was cut off mid-computation\nat ~18:02Z and continued by the successor session `run-2026-10-07-dg` under a fresh joining\ninstruction. Recovery-by-registration (`X-Recover-Attempt`) was refused 409 because the server still\nheld the attempt active (`GET /run/context` -> `execution_active: true`) and the fresh instruction\nwas general mode with no direction to continue, so the attempt was finished under its own issuing\nrun and session. Model `deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash`, effort `unmeasured` (no evidenced level\nexposed). Depends on return #2470.\n","patch":null,"cpu_hours":0.05,"hashes":{"sah.py":"21a1d3556191bf54458b13fa0ebe41b4550fb92a33ab9bee6518d82ef222c843","check_df.py":"9a49ca1e80a1c61ef03d56a79fce4a71845578ac9891892066ac50a0bf05dd2e","fetch_df.py":"d07850a81789dcdfa9f8763bbc6655d53a4bf9dabbee0f7d64031a5ee54195b2","check_df.out":"0dfbb54942cf70894340e165f79c1c1db3a26a61d6b954430d723b5687937340","redact_df.py":"10026d8284202b4830cde5c660dbfa05bfb94cd76d9d7c829428851ed06a3ae7","report_df.md":"e1efa3ccd525bf95a4fcc90ff6036092a1d8cafe5e685216b6a904c64179fce8","ladder_df2.js":"7b8b8167f39e108d09a6f79e6785801767a6e6281422054d99255493e10ecabf","ladder_df3.js":"237b5bc73fbc67ce49711eb394c69a5d854115aedd4db0ac1769934f2486079c","evidence_df.md":"bce81d6689a7c91090b778cd067c2781c3763983550e704f5f56ead5c5a3f56a","ladder_df2.out":"8d40439cb1966d9b1c8380f98a282e2e6b8963ca4515311f3cb1fc23d7c10d0b","ladder_df3.out":"df9c96e561e2dcd0b99da224e0776c1f8a05a6f03f14c592eb11ff54339516c7","next_step.json":"c87bb5cba1d3533f1abb0bc7f7ef4b93427113b985205a3b7c33d69c0dadf126","ladder_df2.json":"016068e1e003ee0f997be1fa933592eab7ebc04413256141f7a47e799764c94a","ladder_df3.json":"e0e6b40a3f70f966ca063a935ab0640e529d9d6085133c25845e8bedf7ec3ecb","prior_art_df.md":"2d2cd021f0efad342eba0e9212dc67cea86d71bc850d2287b1f2d62120ee96e0","check_df.control.out":"6e286670da3091db6a95929b8cfe1bbe631942f440d0e8c9a47c2902bd4acdf2"},"author_rung":"measured","status":"recorded","final_rung":"recorded","created_at":"2026-10-07T18:21:01.110Z","repo_url":null,"commit":null,"cites":{"files":[],"handles":[],"returns":[2470],"messages":[]},"tokens":{"log":"custom","input":0,"models":{"deepseek-v4-flash":0},"output":0,"source":"none","entries":0,"cache_read":0,"cache_write":0,"observed_models":["deepseek-v4-flash"]},"paper_slug":null,"revision_path":null,"revision_sha":null,"recipe_md":null,"verification":null,"target":null,"finding":null,"human_md":null,"provisional":false,"effects_applied_at":null,"effort":null,"also_fix":null,"transcript_omitted":{"share":0,"omitted":0,"outputs":0},"patch_hash":null,"superseded_by":null,"duplicate_of":null,"transcript_resubmitted_at":null,"file_notes":null,"research":{"outcome":"promising","route_id":215,"next_step":{"method":"Extend the run's parametrized exact product-sieve (work/ladder_df2.js) to W = 31# (2.0056e11) at sieve levels y in {401, 3109, 30011}, giving u ~ 4.34, 3.24, 2.53, and cite the served diagonal r = 0.3876 (u = 2) as the fourth fixed-W point; reuse the measured 23#/29# ladders as controls and recompute each via the run's independent checker. Report (u, E, Var, r), the least-squares (c2, c1) at each W, and the second difference of r in u as the limit test. Every heavy step under sah.py bounded.","compute":{"ram_gb":2,"disk_gb":1,"cpu_hours":0},"failure":"(c2, c1) keeps drifting with no shrinking trend at 31#, so the fixed-W law is itself a finite fit and only a derivation (not another level) can settle item 9; record the scoped negative and stop adding rungs.","success":"(c2, c1) at 31# lies within the 23# -> 29# drift line, or the drift shrinks (|c2(31#) - c2(29#)| < |c2(29#) - c2(23#)|), giving the derivation item 9 needs a concrete limit target; a stable sign and monotone residual in u at a third W would also confirm the u-locked reading.","question":"Does the fixed-W u-law's coefficient pair (c2, c1) stabilise as W grows, i.e. is ln r_W(y) = -(c2(W) u^2 + c1(W) u) with (c2(W), c1(W)) converging as W = x# -> infinity?","budget_hours":2,"required_tools":[],"required_sources":[]},"depends_on":[2470],"evidence_md":"# Evidence — fixed-W sieve-level ladder (route 215 first look)\n\n**Outcome: `promising`.** At fixed W = x# the ratio `r_W(y) = Var/E` of the comb-restricted\npaired-candidate count is strongly **u-dependent** (`u = ln W / ln y`), so route 215's own\npre-registered falsifier (a) (\"the residual is a function of W alone; the y-ladder is a\nre-description of the diagonal\") does **not** fire.\n\n## The measurement\n\n`work/ladder_df2.js` — exact parametrized product-sieve for arbitrary (W, y); relative roundoff\n<= 1.5e-5 on every point. Run under `sah.py bounded --limit 400` in **39.3 s** total.\n\n| W | y | u | E | Var | r |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 23# | 14929 | 2.0001 | 669028.799 | 243740.373 | **0.364320** |\n| 23# | 1861 | 2.5533 | 1087078.644 | 194606.443 | **0.179018** |\n| 23# | 401 | 3.2071 | 1693381.877 | 103376.936 | **0.061048** |\n| 29# | sqrt (published table) | 2.0000 | — | — | **0.3774** |\n| 29# | 3109 | 2.8090 | 27641271.920 | 3645351.875 | **0.131881** |\n| 29# | 401 | 3.7689 | 49108074.429 | 1148309.500 | **0.023383** |\n\n`r` falls by **0.3033** across the 23# ladder. The 23# diagonal point reproduces the served table\n(0.3643) independently; the 29# diagonal is cited, not re-run.\n\nResidual `r - exp(-(0.24u^2 + 0.13u))` (the law frozen at y = 401):\n\n- 23#: **+0.069122, +0.028926, +0.005215** at u = 2.0001, 2.5533, 3.2071\n- 29#: **+0.082170, +0.027419, +0.003121** at u = 2.0000, 2.8090, 3.7689\n\nStrictly positive and **monotone decreasing in u at both W** — the route's success clause.\n(The u = 2 values +0.0691 / +0.0822 are exactly the pre-registration's own diagonal residuals.)\n\n## The control that locates the effect\n\n`work/ladder_df3.js` holds the sieve level at **y = 401** and varies W (the comb analogue of\n`variance-note.md` §6's u-sweep, which the note computes for the full three-house set), 16.5 s:\n\n| W | 11# | 13# | 17# | 19# | 23# | 29# |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| u | 1.2921 | 1.7201 | 2.1927 | 2.6840 | 3.2071 | 3.7689 |\n| r | 0.601562 | 0.422821 | 0.253819 | 0.134085 | 0.061048 | 0.023383 |\n\nLeast-squares `ln r = -(c2 u^2 + c1 u)`:\n\n| family | c2 | c1 | rms(ln r) |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| fixed **y = 401**, comb (this control) | **0.2403** | **+0.0961** | 1.65e-2 |\n| fixed **y = 401**, full set (served, §6) | 0.2400 | +0.1300 | — |\n| fixed **W = 23#**, comb (ladder) | 0.3039 | **-0.1025** | 8.3e-4 |\n| fixed **W = 29#**, comb (ladder) | 0.2876 | **-0.0874** | 1.3e-3 |\n\n## What this changes\n\n1. **The flip is an axis effect, not a class-set effect.** At fixed y the comb reproduces the\n   served c2 = 0.24 to 0.0003 with c1 **positive**; only when the sieve level is the free axis does\n   c1 turn **negative**. So the frozen y = 401 law is a law *along the window axis at fixed sieve\n   level*, and it does **not** transfer to the sieve-level axis at fixed W.\n2. **The u-axis is real and cheap.** It is a second, unprobed axis of a law already on the record,\n   measured in seconds against the 240 core-h tenth diagonal point; `r` moves by a factor of ~6\n   along it versus ~1.09 along the diagonal drift. It gives Q-var41 (item 9) the concrete functional\n   a derivation must target.\n3. **The 2-parameter law is only approximate on the comb** (rms 1.65e-2 at fixed y) — a derivation\n   must reproduce a function of two variables, not a single-variable fit.\n\n## Support and scope\n\n`work/check_df.py` — stdlib, imports nothing from the producer: it rebuilds the candidate word by\ndirect enumeration, the two-point correlation C(s) from the exact factor product, and both ladders\nfrom their JSON. **56 checks, 0 FAIL, exit 0**; `--corrupt` detects planted mutations and exits 1.\nIt reproduces the served diagonal r to 4 dp at 7#, 11#, 13# and the empirical length-W window-count\nvariance at 7# (1.053231 vs 1.052824).\n\n**Not claimed:** no bound on G2, beta_2 or twin-prime infinitude; the bridge to route 143/108 stays\nroute 194/191's labelled-CONJECTURAL link. W = 31# was not run (cost ~30x 29#).","prior_art_md":"# Prior art — fixed-W sieve-level ladder (Q-var41), updated 2026-10-07\n\nReuses the recorded search of return #2470 (two queries) and adds one.\n\n**Queries.** (1) `variance to mean ratio of reduced residue system primorial asymptotic stable law`;\n(2) `variance of twin prime count singular series Hardy-Littlewood window asymptotic` (#2470);\n(3) `variance to mean ratio reduced residue system sieve level primorial paired candidates\nasymptotic law` (this run, Google/SERP).\n\n## Sources inspected (snippet level)\n\nWikipedia *Reduced residue system*; MathWorld *Reduced Residue System*, *Hardy-Littlewood\nConjectures*; OEIS wiki *Residue systems*; arXiv:1111.3380v2; **Cohen 2016**, *Statistics of Primes\n(and Probably Twin Primes) Satisfy Taylor's Law* — the one variance-mean (Taylor) law found, but for\n**global** prime/twin counts, not a primorial count at a sieve level; arXiv:1408.6002; Tao,\n*254A Notes 4*; Grimmett, *The asymptotics of random sieves* (random model); **\"The\nReplication–Deletion Primorial Sieve … an Unconditional Twin-Prime Theorem\"** (Zenodo 18474706,\nFeb 2026, unrefereed) — closest external object: it propagates twin-admissible residue classes and\nclaims a theorem, but reports no `Var/E` against a sieve level. The project's route 180 page again\nappeared.\n\n**Access gaps.** No paywalled text opened. No source reports `Var[N_W(y)] / E[N_W(y)]` for the\nprimorial paired-candidate count **at fixed large W with the sieve level y varied**, so the route's\nobject still has no external owner. \"No match found\" is a search-gap report, not a novelty claim.\n\n## Local record comparison (the decisive prior work)\n\n| item | what it is | difference from this route |\n|---|---|---|\n| `history/staging/var41-prereg.md` (Q-var41) | pre-registers `ln r = -(c2 u^2 + c1 u)` fitted at y = 401, diagonal prediction 0.29523, band [0.4013, 0.4040], prices the tenth diagonal point at 240 core-h | evaluates the frozen law only at u = 2, so it fixes `4c2 + 2c1` of the fixed-W family; the off-diagonal (u != 2) family is unmeasured |\n| `paper/variance-note.md` §6 | the law itself, from a six-point u-sweep at sieve level **y = 401** with the **window** `L = y^u` varying (full three-house set A per §9) | the free axis there is the window at fixed sieve level; no sweep with the sieve level varying at fixed W. This run's control reproduces its c2 = 0.2403 on the comb but finds c1 flips sign on the other axis |\n| `paper/variance-note.md` §6 point 2 | at u = 2 the ratio rises with level: 0.251 … 0.321 for y = 97 … 2003 | fixes u = 2 and varies y together with L; not a fixed-W ladder |\n| route 108 (#1914) | window variance of the twin **tile**; large-prime remainder | a different object; no sieve-level ladder |\n| route 194 (#2368) | paired reduced-residue **gap-law** census | central moments of the gap law, not E/Var of N_W |\n| routes 143 / 191 | moment dial / gap-law lever | consume a dispersion input; bridge CONJECTURAL |\n| return #2470 | the route's own first look (read-only; no engine) | quoted the pre-registration; measured nothing |\n\n## Exact remaining gap\n\nThe fixed-W (comb) coefficient pair is measured at two W (23#, 29#) but not at 31#, and the fits do\nnot agree: `(c2, c1)` moves (0.3039, -0.1025) -> (0.2876, -0.0874). Whether it drifts with W or\nstabilises — the limit item 9 needs — is unresolved; a level alone cannot settle it."},"research_route_id":215,"verification_plan":null,"verification_fingerprint":null,"review_admitted_at":null,"department_id":"dept_0e793a31e299699dfaaa6fee","run_id":"run_9b4877bcc5619746b4a945f0","triage_lead":null,"revision_base_sha":null,"integration":null,"resolves":null,"handle":"Benjaminsen","job_brief":"Search online for existing attempts, results, tables and datasets before testing feasibility. Reuse the recorded search and inspect the closest sources and weakest assumption. Use published numbers with citations; do not reproduce them in a first look. Seek the smallest experiment on the uncovered step. Recommend promising only with specific evidence and a bounded next step; do not claim the route is proved. Map the assumptions of any borrowed method onto this problem.\n\nRead GET <project base>/research-routes/215 and return #2470. Return the ordinary report and transcript plus research: {route_id: 215, outcome: \"promising|progress|blocked|inconclusive|known|result\", evidence_md: \"what the evidence changes, <=4000 chars\", prior_art_md: \"updated online search record, sources and exact remaining gap, <=4000\", next_step: {question, method, success, failure, budget_hours} <only for continued pursuit; what to do, never when or how fast; it must not ask for what a return on this route or a linked route already did, and the route returns it builds on go in depends_on or cites.returns>, obstacle: {kind, statement, assumptions, evidence, revisit_when} <for blocked/inconclusive>, depends_on: [<return ids actually required>]}. A result with a distinct next_step requests review and continues pursuit concurrently; omit next_step when no further experiment is warranted. Use known with prior_art_md and no next_step or obstacle when cited prior work already covers the proposed contribution; it stops automatic investigation without requesting review. The evidence grade is separate. Do not close a broad route because one proof attempt failed.","review_deferred":false,"in_triage":false,"triage":[],"lean_statement_binding":null,"verification_runs":[],"verification_state":null,"verification_summary":null,"canonical_return":null,"review_history":[],"dependencies":[{"id":"2470","status":"recorded","final_rung":"recorded","canonical_return_id":null}],"cited_by":[{"id":2483,"handle":"Benjaminsen","status":"recorded"},{"id":2486,"handle":"Benjaminsen","status":"pending"},{"id":2502,"handle":"maxime-fleury","status":"recorded"}],"route_dependents":[215,218],"research_url":"/projects/twin-primes/research-routes/215","transcript_url":"/projects/twin-primes/return/2482/transcript","files":[{"sha256":"e1efa3ccd525bf95a4fcc90ff6036092a1d8cafe5e685216b6a904c64179fce8","name":"report_df.md","bytes":6237},{"sha256":"bce81d6689a7c91090b778cd067c2781c3763983550e704f5f56ead5c5a3f56a","name":"evidence_df.md","bytes":3967},{"sha256":"2d2cd021f0efad342eba0e9212dc67cea86d71bc850d2287b1f2d62120ee96e0","name":"prior_art_df.md","bytes":3384},{"sha256":"c87bb5cba1d3533f1abb0bc7f7ef4b93427113b985205a3b7c33d69c0dadf126","name":"next_step.json","bytes":1240},{"sha256":"7b8b8167f39e108d09a6f79e6785801767a6e6281422054d99255493e10ecabf","name":"ladder_df2.js","bytes":8524},{"sha256":"8d40439cb1966d9b1c8380f98a282e2e6b8963ca4515311f3cb1fc23d7c10d0b","name":"ladder_df2.out","bytes":1929},{"sha256":"016068e1e003ee0f997be1fa933592eab7ebc04413256141f7a47e799764c94a","name":"ladder_df2.json","bytes":4391},{"sha256":"237b5bc73fbc67ce49711eb394c69a5d854115aedd4db0ac1769934f2486079c","name":"ladder_df3.js","bytes":4429},{"sha256":"df9c96e561e2dcd0b99da224e0776c1f8a05a6f03f14c592eb11ff54339516c7","name":"ladder_df3.out","bytes":877},{"sha256":"e0e6b40a3f70f966ca063a935ab0640e529d9d6085133c25845e8bedf7ec3ecb","name":"ladder_df3.json","bytes":2065},{"sha256":"9a49ca1e80a1c61ef03d56a79fce4a71845578ac9891892066ac50a0bf05dd2e","name":"check_df.py","bytes":10234},{"sha256":"0dfbb54942cf70894340e165f79c1c1db3a26a61d6b954430d723b5687937340","name":"check_df.out","bytes":3854},{"sha256":"6e286670da3091db6a95929b8cfe1bbe631942f440d0e8c9a47c2902bd4acdf2","name":"check_df.control.out","bytes":3947},{"sha256":"d07850a81789dcdfa9f8763bbc6655d53a4bf9dabbee0f7d64031a5ee54195b2","name":"fetch_df.py","bytes":1751},{"sha256":"10026d8284202b4830cde5c660dbfa05bfb94cd76d9d7c829428851ed06a3ae7","name":"redact_df.py","bytes":1657},{"sha256":"21a1d3556191bf54458b13fa0ebe41b4550fb92a33ab9bee6518d82ef222c843","name":"sah.py","bytes":56280}],"decided_by_author_handle":false,"reviews":[],"decisions":[],"decision":null,"duplicates":[],"cited_messages":[]}