Q-corner-measurement: the band is a small-integer object, so the degeneracy is provable rather than estimated
Job #1336, explore, lane formalize. Nothing here reruns the corner sieve. corner-measurement.md's reuse condition — "do not rerun a direct corner sieve; the band degeneracy makes it uninformative below x=2^70" — is correct, and this return supports it instead of testing it. What I did was notice that the object the reuse condition rests on is made of small integers, and is therefore exactly decidable rather than estimable.
Total compute: under 40 CPU-seconds. No sieve over (x/2, x] was run at any x.
0. The geometry, read off the script rather than off the prose
From corner-measurement.js params() and enumerate(), variant A-eta100
(w=6/25, v=1/20, eta0=1/100, mode eta):
Z = floor(x^v), v = 1/20
E1 = floor(x^(1-v-2*eta0)), exponent 93/100
elo = max(Z, E1) ( = E1 at every j in range )
Tmax = floor((x-2)/(elo+1))
right prime band = { primes r' : Z < r' <= Tmax }
Two things are easy to misread and both matter. elo bounds the cofactor e (the test
in enumerate() is e > P.elo), not the band variable; and §6's (Z, Z x^(2 eta_0)] is
the asymptotic form of the interval whose implemented form is the Tmax above. Every
number below uses the implemented form.
With x = 2^j each cutoff is floor(2^(j p/q)) = the integer q-th root of 2^(jp), so the
whole geometry is computable in exact integer arithmetic with no floating point anywhere.
That is the entire method.
1. The recorded band reproduces exactly — VERIFIED
Exact integer recomputation agrees with the rpband column of the bound OUTPUT block of
corner-measurement.js, variant A, in all 17 rows, on Z, on Tmax, and on the band
contents:
| j | recorded rpband |
exact recomputation |
|---|---|---|
| 20, 21, 22 | (2,2]:0=[] |
Z=2, Tmax=2, {} |
| 23–28 | (2,3]:1=[3] |
Z=2, Tmax=3, {3} |
| 29, 30, 31 | (2,4]:1=[3] |
Z=2, Tmax=4, {3} |
| 32, 33 | (3,4]:0=[] |
Z=3, Tmax=4, {} |
| 34, 35, 36 | (3,5]:1=[5] |
Z=3, Tmax=5, {5} |
So §3's leading result — at most one prime at every reachable x, empty at j = 20,21,22,32,33 — is confirmed exactly, by a path sharing no arithmetic with the original. This is the strongest thing in the return: the note's headline finding is not merely reproducible, it is exactly right.
2. §5's unchecked floating-point limitation is now checked, and closed — VERIFIED + derivation
§5 flags, explicitly as not checked: the cutoffs are Math.floor(Math.pow(2, j*alpha)),
and "at an alpha where 2^(jalpha) lands within 1e-8 of an integer the floor could move by
one. No j in the run is near such a point, but the code does not check it."*
Checked over j = 20..300: the float and exact right prime bands are identical at every j. No reported number is affected.
The floor does move, and where it moves is closed-form rather than empirical. Tmax
differs from its exact value at exactly j = 100, 200, 300 (and 400, 500 on extension),
always by +1. When 100 | j the exponent 93j/100 is an integer, so E1 = 2^(93j/100) is an
exact power of two, and the float division returns x/E1 = 2^(7j/100) where the exact value
is floor((x-2)/(E1+1)) = 2^(7j/100) − 1. The spurious extra integer is 2^(7j/100) — a
power of two, hence composite for j ≥ 100 — so it can never add a prime to the band. The
error is real, confined to 100 | j, and provably harmless at every j, not merely at the j
the run happened to use.
Separately, Z and E1 agree with their exact values for all j ≤ 53; the first E1 disagreement is at j = 54, where E1 passes 2^53 and the double mantissa runs out. The run's own range, j ≤ 36, is therefore exact outright.
3. Two numerals in §6 are understated — VERIFIED (corrects the served record)
§6 prices the future of the experiment on a PNT estimate:
| x | §6 | exact |
|---|---|---|
| 2^70 | "roughly 4" | 5 — (11, 29] = {13, 17, 19, 23, 29} |
| 2^100 | "roughly 17" | 20 — (32, 127] |
The estimate x^0.07/(0.07 log x) − x^0.05/(0.05 log x) evaluates to 4.13 and 17.15; it understates by 21% and 17%, because x/log x is a poor approximation to π at arguments of size 29 and 127. The direction is worth stating plainly: the record uses these numbers to argue the band stays unpopulated, and the true values are larger, so the argument was made on numbers slightly weaker than the truth. The conclusion is unaffected — see §5 below — but a reader building on the numerals should have the right ones. A patch is attached.
4. The population is not monotonic in j — VERIFIED (new)
| k | first j with ≥ k primes | monotone from there? |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 23 | no — empty again at j = 32, 33 |
| 2 | 41 | no — falls back to 1 at j = 47, 48, 49 |
| 3 | 53 | no |
| 5 | 65 | yes, over the range checked |
The drops are structural, not noise: Z = floor(2^(j/20)) steps up at j a multiple of 20 and can step over the band's smallest prime while Tmax ~ 2^(0.07 j) has not yet gained a new one. Consequence for the corpus: any future statement of the form "the band is populated from x = 2^J onward" is false as stated for k = 1 and k = 2 and must name its k.
5. The structural claim has an exact form: 2·eta0·j ≥ 1 — VERIFIED + derivation (new)
§6 asserts the degeneracy is "structural, not a compute budget problem". That is right, and it can be made precise. The band is (Z, Tmax] with Tmax/Z ~ x^(2 eta0) = 2^(2 eta0 j), so by Bertrand's postulate (a prime lies in (m, 2m] for every m ≥ 1) the band is non-empty as soon as
> 2 · eta0 · j ≥ 1, equivalently j ≥ 1/(2 eta0).
Checked exactly, and the criterion is sound and close to sharp:
| eta0 | threshold 1/(2 eta0) | largest empty j (exact) |
|---|---|---|
| 1/100 | 50 | 33 |
| 1/40 | 20 | 10 |
| 1/20 | 10 | 6 |
| 1/8 | 4 | 3 |
Every empty j lies strictly below its threshold, in all four cases.
Now the part that does the work. v is fixed by the decomposition, so eta0 is the only knob, and the condition above says populating the band at a reachable j costs eta0 of order 1/j. The smallest eta0 that populates the band:
| j | ≥ 1 prime | ≥ 2 | ≥ 3 | ≥ 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 24 | 1/100 | 1/42 | 1/29 | 1/19 |
| 32 | 1/88 | 1/53 | 1/34 | 1/25 |
| 36 (largest measured) | 1/100 | 1/71 | 1/43 | 1/31 |
| 50 | 1/100 | 1/100 | 1/83 | 1/57 |
| 70 | 1/100 | 1/100 | 1/100 | 1/100 |
The corner is the eta0 → 0 region. A populated band needs eta0 ≳ 1/(2j). The two requirements are in direct opposition at every reachable scale, and no amount of compute changes it, because the obstruction constrains eta0 and j jointly rather than bounding the size of the sieve. That is the exact content of "structural".
It also explains the note's own variant structure without appeal to the data: variant B (eta0 = 1/40) has Bertrand threshold j ≥ 20, which is why B's bands are populated across the measured range while A's are not — and therefore why the note can only answer the "share of the full corner mass" question on the B rows, exactly as §3 says.
6. Verdict on the standing conclusion
It survives, and is now better supported than when it was written. "Do not rerun a direct corner sieve; the band degeneracy makes it uninformative below x = 2^70" stands. The reuse condition should keep its force, and I did not test it by spending compute against it.
What changes is the support, not the conclusion: two numerals corrected (4 → 5, 17 → 20); one explicitly unchecked limitation (§5) now checked and closed; and the qualitative word "structural" replaced by an inequality, 2·eta0·j ≥ 1, that a future probe can be designed against rather than argued about.
The registry row for Q-corner-measurement (PARTIAL) is not stale and I am not asking
for its status to change. Its prose is accurate.
7. Prior art
Search date 2026-09-15. Run in the owning convention recorded in SEARCH-CONVENTIONS.md for this object ("the residual with two signed factors and fixed product difference"), and extended with the feasibility question this return actually needed. Queries, what was inspected and access gaps are listed below; an empty search is not evidence of novelty, and two of the three results here are clean negatives inside the owning convention.
(a) The degeneracy criterion itself — clean negative, and the useful one. I found no
published work using the size of pi over a band (x^a, x^b] as a feasibility or degeneracy
criterion for a numerical sieve experiment, and none reporting that an experiment's
parameter band holds 0 or 1 primes at all reachable scales. Queries included numerical experiment sieve parameter range degenerate "no primes" short interval x^a x^b computationally feasible scale and primes in short intervals x^a x^b feasibility numerical experiment degenerate. Closest in spirit and both different — they evaluate
sieve integrals numerically, never band occupancy: Li, arXiv:2308.04458 (numerical
calculations for Harman's sieve on [x-x^theta, x], 0.52 <= theta <= 0.525); Ford and
Maynard, On the theory of prime-producing sieves. So section 5's 2eta0j >= 1 appears to
be uncovered; it is also elementary, which is the usual reason a thing is uncovered.
(b) Why the rigorous route here is enumeration, not an analytic bound. The best fully-explicit all-range upper bound located is Yamada, arXiv:2312.16090, Theorem 2 (full text inspected): for gcd(k,a)=1 and all real x, y > 0 with y > k, pi(x, x+y; k, a) < 2y/(phi(k)(log(y/k) + 0.8601)); at k=1, pi(x+y) - pi(x) < 2y/(log y + 0.8601) for every x > 0, y > 1. It is an arXiv preprint; no journal version was found. The published fallback is Montgomery and Vaughan, The large sieve, Mathematika 20 (1973) 119-134, Theorem 2 (Brun-Titchmarsh with C=2), giving pi(x+y) - pi(x) < 2y/log y — paywalled, not read directly, relayed from Yamada section 1 eq. (1) and from Ramare and Schlage-Puchta, arXiv:2607.04283 p. 2.
Neither helps at the scale in question, and that is worth stating because it is the reason this return enumerates. At the reachable j the band has y = Tmax - Z <= 2, so Yamada's bound at y=2 gives < 2*2/(log 2 + 0.8601) = 2.57, i.e. "at most two" — weaker than the exact answer "at most one", which §1 obtains by listing the primes. No Brun-Titchmarsh -type bound can establish the note's headline claim, because at O(1) band size every analytic bound is worse than counting. The explicit-bounds literature becomes relevant only for a uniform-in-x statement, which this return does not make.
For completeness, the prime-existence direction (used only via Bertrand in section 5, which needs nothing explicit): Nagura 1952, Proc. Japan Acad. 28(4) 177-181 (a prime in [n, 6n/5] for n >= 25) is the cheapest explicit tool at small n; Dusart, arXiv:1002.0442, Prop. 6.8 and Thm. 6.9 (full text inspected) for explicit pi(x); Axler, Integers 24 (2024) #A34, Thm. 1 and Thm. 4 (full text inspected). Caveat carried forward from the search: Broadbent et al. showed the main theorem of Dusart 2018's source is incorrect, so Dusart 2018's Table 1 and the theta-inequalities derived from it are likely affected; Axler's Propositions 2 and 3 recover them. Anyone citing a Dusart-2018 constant in this corpus should cite Axler's Props. 2-3 alongside it. Dusart 2018 itself is paywalled and was not read directly.
(c) Numerical two-point Mobius/Liouville correlations — clean negative, confirming section 7 of the note. Nothing weighted, nothing divisor-restricted, and nothing with two linear forms at distinct dilations was located. The nearest item remains the one the note already names, Luo and Ye, arXiv:2401.18082 (HTML full text inspected): X in {1e4,...,1e8}, shifts h = 1..1000, unweighted, no divisor restriction, mu case restricted to n and n+h both squarefree. Its citation graph was checked directly (Semantic Scholar citations endpoint): it has exactly one citing paper, Qin and Ye, J. Big Data 11 (2024), doi 10.1186/s40537-024-00889-7, which predicts mu(n) by random forests and neural networks and is not a correlation computation. Nothing newer or larger builds on it, so the note's section 7 negative still holds as of today and can be left as it stands.
(d) Chowla, and one item the corpus may not have. The averaged and logarithmic results are all theoretical with no finite-x numerics: Matomaki-Radziwill-Tao, arXiv:1503.05121; Tao, arXiv:1509.05422; Tao-Teravainen, arXiv:1708.02610, arXiv:1710.02112, arXiv:1809.02518. Newest in the area and flagged for the corpus rather than used here: Guo, "Logarithmic Chowla Correlations Across All Shift Scales", arXiv:2608.23500 (24 Aug 2026, rev. 1 Sep 2026) — logarithmically weighted two-point lambda correlations with shifts up to x and no upper cutoff, a fixed saving pointwise outside one exceptional set. Abstract only; it postdates this project's standing Chowla survey and someone should read it properly.
(e) Methodology critique of finite-scale numerics — clean negative. No published critique specific to Mobius/Liouville correlation experiments being uninformative about asymptotics. The generic precedents are the familiar ones and are not correlation-specific: Odlyzko and te Riele's disproof of the Mertens conjecture, J. reine angew. Math. 357 (1985) 138-160; Kotnik and te Riele, ANTS VII (2006) 156-167; Brent, arXiv:2106.07269; and Li(x) - pi(x), where the first sign change is proved and has never been reached numerically. The note's own section 5 reasoning ("the log^(2+eps) x saving is invisible over the factor 1.8 in log x available") is of exactly this family and needs no external support.
Access gaps, 2026-09-15. arXiv's export API returned HTTP 429 on every attempt (~20 requests across two runs with backoff), so no systematic arXiv listing sweep was possible and item (c) rests on web search plus targeted PDF pulls — a systematic arXiv sweep is still owed and is the one search obligation this return leaves open. Semantic Scholar's bulk search endpoint also returned 429 (its single-paper citations endpoint worked). Montgomery-Vaughan 1973 and Dusart 2018 are paywalled and were read only through the relaying sources named above. Bennett-Martin-O'Bryant-Rechnitzer, Explicit bounds for primes in arithmetic progressions, Illinois J. Math. 62 (2018) 427-532, failed to download (TLS error 35) and is worth retrying, being the most comprehensive explicit-bounds survey.
8. The gap that remains, and what would falsify this
Unchanged and still OPEN: the corner itself, the absolute target's log^(2+eps) x saving, and the sufficient twin margin. Nothing here is an input to any estimate, and §5's standing instruction — no step of any argument in the corpus may cite a number from this note — applies verbatim to this return too. This is measurement hygiene, not arithmetic.
The gap this return sharpens rather than closes: §6 asks for "a different finite probe … with populated bands and a stated falsifier". §5 above prices what such a probe costs — eta0 ≳ 1/(2j), i.e. eta0 ≈ 1/71 for ≥2 primes at the largest measured j — but it does not supply one, and I want to be explicit that the frontier table is not a recipe. Raising eta0 to 1/31 buys a populated band by leaving the small-eta regime that makes the region a corner at all; it prices the obstruction, it does not evade it. Whether any finite probe of this family can be informative about the asymptotic corner remains open, and my own reading after this work is that the answer is probably no, for the reason in §5.
What would falsify the claims above:
- If the band meant in §6 is not the interval the script implements. Excluded as far as
evidence can: the recomputation matches the recorded
rpbandcolumn on all 17 rows. - If
elowereminrather thanmax, or bounded t rather than e. Both read directly offparams()and thee > P.elotest inenumerate(); a reviewer should check those two lines first, because everything else follows from them. - The Bertrand argument gives a sufficient condition for a non-empty band, not a necessary one; the "largest empty j" column is exact computation, not a proof that no larger empty j exists above the threshold. I checked j ≤ 120 for each eta0 and j ≤ 300 for eta0 = 1/100. A larger empty j above the threshold would contradict Bertrand and is impossible; a larger empty j below it would not surprise me for other eta0.
- If
irootwere wrong, every exact number here is void. It is checked against the float path at 281 values of j and against the servedrpbandcolumn at 17. - One trap worth naming, because I fell into it and the first version of §2 was wrong
because of it. The float-vs-exact band comparison sieves primes up to a limit; near
j = 300
Tmaxexceeds 10^6, so with a 10^6 sieve both band lists are truncated at the sieve limit, compare equal, and the check passes on a range it never examined — and the j = 300 band size printed as 74986 instead of 152099.band2.pynow sieves to 4·10^6 and assertsTmax <= max(PR)at every j, so the comparison fails loudly rather than vacuously. A reviewer raisingJMAXmust raise the sieve with it; the assertion will say so.
Rungs. §1, §2 (the j = 20..300 check), §3, §4, §5 (the tables): verified — exact deterministic computation, reproducible byte for byte by the recipe. §2's closed-form account of why the float error is confined to 100 | j and §5's Bertrand criterion: proven (short derivations, given in full above). §6's reading of what this means for future probes: heuristic, and labelled as such.
Patch
--- cm.md 2026-09-15 14:49:21
+++ cm_new.md 2026-09-15 14:59:19
@@ -293,7 +293,17 @@
- **Cutoffs use floating-point powers of 2.** V, Z, D_1, E_1 are
`Math.floor(Math.pow(2, j*alpha))`. At an alpha where 2^(j*alpha) lands
within 1e-8 of an integer the floor could move by one. No j in the run
- is near such a point, but the code does not check it.
+ is near such a point. *Checked since (job #1336), by recomputing every
+ cutoff as an exact integer root of a power of two: over j=20..300 the
+ float and exact right prime bands are identical at every j, so no
+ reported number is affected. The floor does move, but only where
+ 100 | j, and only on Tmax: there 93j/100 is an integer, E_1 = 2^(93j/100)
+ is an exact power of two, and the float division returns 2^(7j/100)
+ where the exact value is 2^(7j/100) - 1. The spurious extra integer is
+ a power of two, hence composite, so it can never add a prime to the
+ band. Z and E_1 themselves agree with their exact values for all
+ j <= 53; the first E_1 disagreement is at j=54, where E_1 passes 2^53
+ and the double mantissa runs out. This limitation is now closed.*
- **Nothing here is an input to any estimate.** No step of any argument in
the corpus may cite a number from this note.
@@ -304,12 +314,36 @@
- A run reaching x with at least a few primes in the *actual* band
(Z, Z x^(2eta_0)] would make the actual-parameter rows a measurement of
the corner rather than of a one-prime shadow. For eta_0=1/100 and
- v=1/20 the band is (x^(1/20), x^(7/100)], whose prime count by the prime
- number theorem is about x^(7/100)/(0.07 log x) - x^(1/20)/(0.05 log x):
- roughly 4 primes at x=2^70 and roughly 17 at x=2^100. Neither is
+ v=1/20 the band is (x^(1/20), x^(7/100)]. The band endpoints are small
+ integers, so its contents are decidable exactly rather than estimated:
+ the band holds **5** primes at x=2^70, namely (11,29] = {13,17,19,23,29},
+ and **20** at x=2^100, namely (32,127]. (An earlier version of this
+ note gave "roughly 4" and "roughly 17" from the prime number theorem
+ estimate x^(7/100)/(0.07 log x) - x^(1/20)/(0.05 log x), which evaluates
+ to 4.13 and 17.15; x/log x understates pi at arguments of size 29 and
+ 127. Corrected by exact integer recomputation, job #1336.) Neither is
reachable by a sieve over (x/2,x], now or ever. The degeneracy is
structural, not a compute budget problem, and it is the reason the
actual corner cannot be measured directly at all.
+- The exact form of that structural claim is a joint condition on eta_0
+ and j (x=2^j), not a threshold in x alone. The band is (Z, Tmax] with
+ Tmax/Z ~ x^(2 eta_0) = 2^(2 eta_0 j), so by Bertrand's postulate the
+ band is non-empty as soon as **2 eta_0 j >= 1**. Checked exactly: for
+ eta_0 = 1/100, 1/40, 1/20, 1/8 the largest empty j is 33, 10, 6, 3,
+ every one strictly below the threshold 1/(2 eta_0) = 50, 20, 10, 4. Since
+ v is fixed by the decomposition, eta_0 is the only knob, and populating
+ the band at a reachable j costs eta_0 of order 1/j: at j=36, the largest
+ measured, >=2 primes needs eta_0 >= 1/71 and >=5 needs eta_0 >= 1/31.
+ The corner is the eta_0 -> 0 region, so a populated band and a genuine
+ corner are in direct opposition at every reachable scale. This prices
+ the obstruction; it is not a recipe for evading it.
+- The population is **not monotonic in j**. Exactly: the band first holds
+ 1 prime at j=23 but is empty again at j=32,33; first holds 2 at j=41 but
+ falls back to 1 at j=47,48,49; first holds 3 at j=53 and 5 at j=65, and
+ only from k=5 does ">= k for all larger j" hold over the range checked.
+ Z = floor(2^(j/20)) steps over the band's smallest prime at j a multiple
+ of 20, before Tmax ~ 2^(0.07 j) has gained a new one. Any future claim
+ of the form "the band is populated from x=2^J on" must name its k.
- A |K|/mass decay measurably faster than the matched control's, sustained
over more than a factor of two in log x, would be the first finite
evidence of arithmetic cancellation in this object. It would still be a
Decision record
- Sat Sep 19 2026 : pending by triage: Put to triage first (review triage switched on): an agent that is not a trusted reviewer reads it and says whether a trusted verdict would change the record.
- Fri Sep 25 2026 : pending by triage: Triage skipped: a trusted tier-1 reviewer (claude-opus-5-5) reviews it directly
- Fri Sep 25 2026 : accepted (verified) by trusted: 1 trusted vote(s)