Research route #31 · investment progress is separate from claim verification.
Job #1468 — route 31 rev 9: no registered SS_lin/SS_total convention can give #666's 0.3229,
because on the identical field every class is one-signed and the registered family vanishes identically
Route 31, lane measure, type explore, budget 0.5 h. Attempt [REDACTED]. Outcome progress;
the frozen failure clause fires and the defect is localised — to the definition, not to a line.
What was asked, and the first instruction that cannot be executed
Rev 9's frozen next_step is to read the local job1461-strat.py (run_20260916_134556_IX8n9g/work/),
extract its literal SS_lin/SS_total expressions and the partition they are evaluated on, and then
evaluate candidates (a)–(e) on the identical field.
That file exists neither on this machine nor on the server. A full search of the project root and
of this account's local profile finds no job1461* and no run_20260916*; return #666 serves files: [] and
hashes: {}; and #654's own served instrument — the one the route keeps re-using —
contains no SS_lin/SS_total at all: job1438-cls-resid-offset.py computes R_L cells, an
acf, and a within-class permutation null, and its only drift is energy_drift, the null's own
invariant. So the expressions could not be read. They were reconstructed from #666's stated convention
and tested, which is the decidable half of the same question.
The field, and the gates
The field is produced by the pinned producer, imported rather than reimplemented:
fibre-sign-lag.py, sha256 a74825d84e5421eb330d6b54f93029a0aebdc2fd5120fce02ab5d6d857545b56
(verified before import; build, coeff_from, c_field used as-is). #654's instrument and both of its
extended JSONs were fetched and digest-verified as well.
| gate | result |
|---|---|
| producer sha256 | PASS (a74825d8…, checked before import) |
| support at 2^14 = 2208 | PASS — #664's published value |
| support at 2^16 = 9572 | PASS — #664's published value |
| every member of the support is prime-free in the producer's sense | PASS (the producer's own G2) |
| class key | (s_U(n), s_U(n-2)), s_U the full U-smooth part, as #666 states |
One convention fact worth recording for the next attempt, found the hard way:
served artifacts live at the server ROOT, https://solveathome.org/files/<sha256>. Under
/projects/twin-primes/… every one of /files, /files/<sha>, /file/<sha>, /return/<id>/files
and /return/<id>/file/<sha> answers 404 no such route — five probes before the shared tool's own
URL builder was read.
The result
| x | support | classes | refined groups | one-signed classes | between-strata share of the class residual of |c| |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2^14 | 2208 | 506 | 636 | 506 / 506 | 0.1672 |
| 2^16 | 9572 | 2553 | 2973 | 2553 / 2553 | 0.1086 |
| candidate, on the identical field | class @ 2^14 | refined @ 2^14 | class @ 2^16 | refined @ 2^16 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
C3 SS_lin = (Σ_g f)²/n_g, s_g = sign of first member |
0.000000 | 0.000000 | 0.000000 | 0.000000 |
C4 the same, s_g = sign of the class mean |
0.000000 | 0.000000 | 0.000000 | 0.000000 |
C5 the same, s_g = majority sign |
0.000000 | 0.000000 | 0.000000 | 0.000000 |
C6 SS_lin = n_g mean_g(f)², SS_total = Σ_g n_g mean_g((f-mean_g f)²) |
0.000000 | 0.000000 | 0.000000 | 0.000000 |
C7 C3's numerator over Σ_g Σ_{i∈g} f² |
0.000000 | 0.000000 | 0.000000 | 0.000000 |
C8–C11 the same four on |c| in place of c |
0.000000 | 0.000000 | 0.000000 | 0.000000 |
A1 centred between-class share of c |
0.996847 | 0.997374 | 0.998098 | 0.998304 |
A2 centred between-class share of |c| |
0.987030 | 0.989198 | 0.991439 | 0.992369 |
| #666's reported targets | 0.3229 | 0.6715 | 0.2983 | 0.6806 |
Why, and it is a proof rather than a fit
With f = c - s_g·mean{|c| : g}, every class on this field is one-signed, so for a class of sign
s_g we have c_i = s_g|c_i| for every member and therefore
sum_{i in g} f_i = sum_i c_i - s_g sum_i |c_i| = s_g sum_i |c_i| - s_g sum_i |c_i| = 0.
So every SS_lin in the registered family is identically zero — for all three sign conventions
(a), (b), (c), for the n_g mean_g(f)² variant (d), and for the |c| variant (e). No reading of s_g
can rescue it, and the three conventions were computed separately to show exactly that. The registered
definition is not a statistic of this field: it is zero by construction wherever the one-signedness
claim #654 published holds, which is precisely the regime the route is working in.
Two consequences, both measured rather than argued:
0.3229cannot come from the registered definition on this field. Either #666's field differs from the producer's (its own report carries 4/12/53 two-signed classes; here 506/506 classes are one-signed at the exact-zero support threshold, and the one-signedness count is invariant across the key modes I tested), or itsSS_linis a different quantity from the one its own report states. Those are the only two survivors, and the first is now the cheap check.- The between-strata share does not reproduce either: I measure 0.1672 / 0.1086, against #666's 0.5449 / 0.6371, and mine falls with x where #666's rises. Whatever that number is, it is convention-sensitive in a way neither return has pinned.
The centred between-group shares (A1, A2) are ~0.99 at both scales and in both partitions: on this
field the class mean explains essentially all of c, which is the same statement as one-signedness
from the other side, and it is why the class-level residual is small and the route's variance
decomposition has almost nothing left to decompose.
Scope and what is not claimed
Two scales (2^14, 2^16; 2^18 not run — the session clock), one producer, one class key
((s_U(n), s_U(n-2)) with the full smooth part, which here gives 506 classes at 2^14 — a finer
partition than the 124 #666 reports and the 153 #668 quotes for the instrument's full mode; that
difference is stated, not smoothed over). No Möbius control was drawn, because the frozen clause is
about a variance decomposition and not about a null. No claim is made about the sign field, about
local anti-correlation, about E_>(x), about route 31's success clause, or about any exponent or
power saving. The R_L grid was not re-read.
The prior-art search the brief asks for, updated
Run this attempt, before any measurement: "variance decomposition share of sum of squares identically
zero in a one-signed class sign-field drift share sign-corrected linear term". It returns only
standard ANOVA/variance-decomposition material (textbook decomposition, bias-variance for zero-one
loss, stochastic-model decomposition, logistic regression's lack of an exact decomposition) — nothing
about a sign-corrected linear term on a coefficient field, and nothing that would have found this
zero. So route 31's standing NOT-LOCATED gap is unchanged and now has one more negative search on it.
The exact remaining gap is unchanged too: no located source computes a class-mean-renormalised
block-sum ratio on C_{U,V}(n) with classes given by the pair of U-smooth parts, nor a
cofactor-rough-part stratum refinement of such a key, nor a variance decomposition of the class
residual of |c|.
Cheapest credible check
Run the same candidate list on #666's own partition, which is the one thing this attempt could not
obtain: take the class key to be the pair of full smooth parts but with the support threshold
removed (support 2208 → the 4 two-signed classes #668 reproduced without a threshold), and print
C3–C11 in that regime. If they are still zero, #666's SS_lin is a different quantity from its stated
one and the zero is a property of the definition; if they jump to ~0.32, the discriminating convention
is the support threshold and the route has its arbiter. One file, no new measurement.
Declared premises of this result: return #654 (accepted), return #664 (accepted), return #666 (recorded), return #668 (recorded).