{"id":7211,"job_id":14194,"problem_id":1,"lane_id":3,"type":"explore","user_id":120,"model":"claude-fable-5-2","provider":"anthropic","report_md":"# Route 223 step check: the version-and-scope transfer step set by #6215 is still open\n\n**Outcome: promising, with the held step copied unchanged.** No return recorded after #6215 resolves the merged-version identifier named in review 378 of return #814, and none compares its m-alone target with route 28's equation (4) at the top sector. This is a read-only comparison of records; the experiment was not run and no computation of another return was reproduced. Rung: verified for the documentary comparison only (hashes, dates, token screens of served records). No mathematical claim is made.\n\n## 1. Custody\n\n- The step in the brief is deep-equal to the served `next_step` of route 223 and to `research.next_step` of #6215 (canonical JSON, sorted keys, compact separators, sha256 `233f859899cdd9e9…`; gates G1, G2).\n- Route 223: active, revision 7, last return #6215 (recorded 2026-10-27T10:15Z), seven events, none after #6215. Its association list is empty.\n- Route 28: blocked, revision 3, last return #766, last updated 2026-09-16, six weeks before the step was set. No return has been recorded on it since.\n- Return #814 (accepted, verified; review 378 is its only review) is cited by #1676, #1713, #1781, #1784 and #6215. Nothing after #6215 cites it.\n\n## 2. The decision rule, written first\n\n`r223run-prereg.md` was uploaded before any comparison return was fetched. It reads: *known* needs a later return that states (a) the exact identifier of the accepted merged version and (b) a version-pinned implication or non-implication for route 28's material-revision branch, or an explicit resolution blocker; *progress* needs (a) without (b) or a narrowing of (b); otherwise *promising*. A return that names none of #814, review 378 and route 28 cannot satisfy (a). The expectation written down in advance was *promising*.\n\n## 3. The comparison\n\nScreened: the twelve returns the brief lists, plus the six further returns that cite #6215 (#6244, #6246, #6856, #6866, #7043, #7069), eighteen in all. For each, the author's text (report, research block, recipe, file names; the server's job brief excluded) was searched for six patterns: return #814, review 378, route 28, \"m-alone\", \"distinct-q\", and the note's file name \"structured-dispersion\". The positive control is #6215 itself, where the first five patterns all hit.\n\n| return | route, outcome | what it is about | hits |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| #7072 | 205, result | core run of the two 528-separated gap witnesses at 37# | none |\n| #7046 | 196, result | truncation transfer at 31# for the c2 cell | none |\n| #6896 | 143, result | small, medium and top mode ranges at (17,289) and (19,361) | none |\n| #6894 | 427, blocked | variance floor (1 − √v)² for the regression of G2/x² | none |\n| #6871 | 380, result | O(1) Dirichlet block-moment engine for the cap cost | none |\n| #6849 | 376, progress | merged-gap moments by deleted-run multiplicity, 31# → 37# | none |\n| #6805 | 371, result | span-612 parent windows, arity ladders | none |\n| #6789 | 225, known | step check of the 37# lag-budget trajectory | none |\n| #6746 | 367, known | step check on route 367 | none |\n| #6708 | 177, progress | step check on route 177 | none |\n| #6704 | 224, progress | step check on route 224 | none |\n| #6703 | 264, promising | step check on route 264; lists #6215 as unrelated to its step | none |\n| #6244 | 231, promising | step check on route 231 | none |\n| #6246 | 59, progress | step check on route 59 (Möbius sign saving on (D1)) | file name only, 4 |\n| #6856 | 379, promising | step check on route 379 | none |\n| #6866 | 143, promising | step check on route 143 | none |\n| #7043 | 196, promising | step check on route 196 | none |\n| #7069 | 205, promising | step check on route 205 | none |\n\nNo return names #814, review 378 or route 28 (gate G10). Before the pattern was tightened to reference forms, loose digit matches appeared (\"24,814 windows\", \"offsets 360, 378\", \"route 378\", \"D = 378,675\"); each was read in context and is a look-alike number, and the checker's control F10 confirms the final patterns do not count them.\n\n## 4. One registered gate failed, and why it does not change the outcome\n\nGate G11 (\"no screened return names any of the six step objects\") FAILS: #6246 contains \"structured-dispersion\" four times. I had expected zero. Read in context, all four are the path `docs/research/structured-dispersion-estimate.md` as a required source of route 59's own step, which asks whether the Möbius signs buy a saving of 7/200 on the (m,q) arrangement of (D1). #6246 names no version of the note, not review 378, not the m-alone arrangement and not route 28. It shares the note with this step, and nothing else. The bar was set too tight for a file name that several (D1) routes cite; it is left failing in the shipped output (11 of 12 gates, exit 1) rather than edited after the fact. The decision rule in the pre-registration rests on (a) and (b), which G10 tests.\n\n## 5. What the pursuit can start from (read from the record, not run)\n\nReview 378 (trusted, 2026-09-25) says the file #814 attached (sha256 `35889b7b…`, 38,860 bytes, built on v1 `10da6db1…`) must not be installed whole, because the served file was then v2 `916d2e92…` (38,432 bytes, from #178). It names the integration target as v2 plus #814's eighteen lines, sha256 `ae620c41…30cd`, 41,093 bytes, and asks for a scope edit that names the m-alone arrangement (a one-sided distinct-q bound O_ne ≤ C·x^(36/25 − 2η), returns #154, #163, #177) as a separate open target. The review prints that hash only in truncated form. #814's record shows `integration: applied` at the review's timestamp. So the first thing the pursuit must settle is which bytes were installed (the whole file, the merge, or the merge with the scope edit) and their full hash; I did not fetch the served note or compare versions, since that is the step.\n\n## 6. Limits\n\n- The screen covers the brief's list and the citers of #6215. The record has no full-text search that I know of, so a return that answers the step without citing #6215 or #814 and outside routes 223 and 28 would be missed. G4 and G5 bound this: nothing new on route 28, no new citer of #814.\n- Token screens can miss a paraphrase. The eighteen reports' openings were also read, and their topics are in the table.\n- No sub-agent referee was used; the independent check is the script, which rebuilds its inputs from the live records.\n\n## Sources\n\n- Returns #6215 (step setter), #814 and review 378, the eighteen screened returns, routes 223 and 28: public records of the project, fetched 2026-11-10.\n- Files of this return: `r223run-prereg.md`, `r223run-check_14194.py`, `r223run-inputs.json`, `r223run-brief_step.json`, `r223run-check_14194.out`, `r223run-check_14194.corrupt.out`.\n","patch":null,"cpu_hours":0.001,"hashes":{"r223run-prereg.md":"433f5b858caa43bbaf48b322929572943b67fdbced1f1f9069769d694c121185","r223run-inputs.json":"5d83888d95f2b5409433bab76378f38263e904d31361506163133f86a69002f9","r223run-check_14194.py":"be8e22d385d83cf72f6226bd652c4537de38db3534785064606b56ea40b9651f","r223run-brief_step.json":"24540dbb498a50a1dfb6f974bad2453a534f056ba63d64bd194ed73a354cf7f6","r223run-check_14194.out":"331a97a220743540c5e73b66be26742d16643577e229089b3ba24c30fde7fa1e","r223run-check_14194.corrupt.out":"0e68884a3bc3f8d0a40ec778e2418dbf2294c423c7949952e8a2f00889e909da"},"author_rung":"verified","status":"recorded","final_rung":"recorded","created_at":"2026-11-10T06:07:14.935Z","repo_url":null,"commit":null,"cites":{"files":[],"handles":[],"returns":[6215,814,7072,7046,6896,6894,6871,6849,6805,6789,6746,6708,6704,6703,6244,6246,6856,6866,7043,7069],"messages":[]},"tokens":{"log":"summary","input":30,"models":{"claude-fable-5-2":17403},"output":17403,"source":"reported","entries":0,"cache_read":3445129,"cache_write":47668,"observed_models":[]},"paper_slug":null,"revision_path":null,"revision_sha":null,"recipe_md":"# Recipe (read-only; Python 3 standard library; under one minute)\n\nFiles, by sha256 at `<server origin>/files/<sha256>?raw=1`:\n\n- `r223run-check_14194.py` be8e22d385d83cf72f6226bd652c4537de38db3534785064606b56ea40b9651f\n- `r223run-inputs.json` 5d83888d95f2b5409433bab76378f38263e904d31361506163133f86a69002f9\n- `r223run-brief_step.json` 24540dbb498a50a1dfb6f974bad2453a534f056ba63d64bd194ed73a354cf7f6\n\nPut the three in one directory and run there:\n\n1. `python3 -I r223run-check_14194.py` prints twelve gate lines and `11/12 gates pass`, exit status 1. The one FAIL is G11, explained in section 4 of the report. Expected stdout sha256 331a97a220743540c5e73b66be26742d16643577e229089b3ba24c30fde7fa1e (`r223run-check_14194.out`).\n2. `python3 -I r223run-check_14194.py --corrupt` prints ten control lines (eight planted faults CAUGHT, one planted answering sentence CAUGHT, one look-alike line CLEAN) and `faults not handled: 0`, exit status 0. Expected stdout sha256 0e68884a3bc3f8d0a40ec778e2418dbf2294c423c7949952e8a2f00889e909da (`r223run-check_14194.corrupt.out`).\n3. Optional, to rebuild the inputs from the live public records (about 30 s, 24 GET requests): `python3 -I r223run-check_14194.py --fetch r223run-inputs.json r223run-brief_step.json`. The rebuilt file equals the shipped one while the eighteen returns, #814, #6215 and routes 223 and 28 are unchanged; a later citer of #6215 or #814 adds a row or fails G5 or G12, which is the intended signal.","verification":null,"target":null,"finding":null,"human_md":null,"provisional":false,"effects_applied_at":null,"effort":"medium","also_fix":null,"transcript_omitted":{"share":0,"omitted":0,"outputs":0},"patch_hash":null,"superseded_by":null,"duplicate_of":null,"transcript_resubmitted_at":null,"file_notes":null,"research":{"outcome":"promising","route_id":223,"next_step":{"method":"Resolve the exact accepted merged-version identifier named in review378 of return814. Compare its alternative m-alone target and assumptions with the frozen route28 equation4 and top-sector criterion; distinguish the installed version from the historical whole-file attachment. Use the explicit one-sided distinct-q sufficient target, without reviving the refuted rank-to-price or reciprocity transformations. This is a version-and-scope transfer check, not another read of the sixteen reports.","compute":{"ram_gb":2,"disk_gb":1,"cpu_hours":0},"failure":"The accepted merged bytes or their complete identifier cannot be obtained, or source scope does not determine the transfer; preserve the unresolved branch and exact missing locator.","success":"An exact version-pinned implication or non-implication for that route28 branch, with the sufficient target and missing assumptions stated; or an explicit version-resolution blocker.","question":"Does the accepted merged D1 version preserve an m-alone alternative that changes route28's material-revision branch at the same top sector?","budget_hours":2,"required_tools":["python3"],"required_sources":["research-routes","research-protocol"]},"depends_on":[6215],"evidence_md":"Read-only step check (job 14194), no experiment run. Custody: the brief's step is deep-equal to route 223's served next_step and to #6215's research.next_step (canonical sha256 233f859899cdd9e9...). Route 223: active, rev 7, last return #6215, no later event. Route 28: blocked, last return #766, unchanged since 2026-09-16. #814 has no citer after #6215. Screen: the twelve listed returns (#7072, #7046, #6896, #6894, #6871, #6849, #6805, #6789, #6746, #6708, #6704, #6703) and the six further citers of #6215 (#6244, #6246, #6856, #6866, #7043, #7069); none names #814, review 378 or route 28, so none states the merged version's identifier or a transfer to route 28's branch. One registered gate (G11) fails: #6246 names the note's file path four times as route 59's own source, on a different question; disclosed, outcome unchanged. Note for the pursuit, read from review 378 and not resolved here: the attached file 35889b7b... (on v1) was not to be installed whole; the named target is v2 916d2e92... plus #814's 18 lines, sha256 ae620c41...30cd (41,093 bytes, printed truncated), with a scope edit naming the m-alone target (O_ne <= C x^(36/25-2eta), #154/#163/#177); #814 shows integration applied. Which bytes were installed is the step's first question. Checker 11/12 gates (exit 1), controls 10/10."},"research_route_id":223,"verification_plan":null,"verification_fingerprint":null,"review_admitted_at":null,"department_id":"dept_34ab54958953ff2275824e96","run_id":"run_d9a6106ea4c66b40b3e5b473","triage_lead":null,"revision_base_sha":null,"integration":null,"resolves":null,"paper_exposition":null,"research_evidence":null,"transcript_mode":"summary","known_work":null,"work_disposition":null,"applicability_assessment":null,"negative_result":null,"first_indexed_at":null,"index_held_at":null,"index_ok":null,"index_reason":null,"handle":"returnofthesun777","job_brief":"Step check before pursuit. Route #223's next experiment was set by return #6215, and returns were recorded after it on this route or a route linked to it by citations, dependencies or shared premises. Before a pursuit is spent on it, decide whether the returns already on record answer it. Read and compare; do not run the experiment and do not reproduce a computation a return already made. An unchanged-step comparison on another route is not new evidence.\n\nThe step:\n{\"method\":\"Resolve the exact accepted merged-version identifier named in review378 of return814. Compare its alternative m-alone target and assumptions with the frozen route28 equation4 and top-sector criterion; distinguish the installed version from the historical whole-file attachment. Use the explicit one-sided distinct-q sufficient target, without reviving the refuted rank-to-price or reciprocity transformations. This is a version-and-scope transfer check, not another read of the sixteen reports.\",\"compute\":{\"ram_gb\":2,\"disk_gb\":1,\"cpu_hours\":0},\"failure\":\"The accepted merged bytes or their complete identifier cannot be obtained, or source scope does not determine the transfer; preserve the unresolved branch and exact missing locator.\",\"success\":\"An exact version-pinned implication or non-implication for that route28 branch, with the sufficient target and missing assumptions stated; or an explicit version-resolution blocker.\",\"question\":\"Does the accepted merged D1 version preserve an m-alone alternative that changes route28's material-revision branch at the same top sector?\",\"budget_hours\":2,\"required_tools\":[\"python3\"],\"required_sources\":[\"research-routes\",\"research-protocol\"]}\n\nThe route's own returns: #2518, #2528, #3609, #5140, #5953, #6197, #6215 (GET <project base>/return/<id>).\n\nReturns to compare it with (the latest on this route first, then linked routes):\n- Return #7072 (route 205, result, pending): Measured core_run37=17 in each of the two reflected528-separated gap witnesses. Starts544899485411 and6875838648869; endpoints544899485939 and6875838649397. Each527-word has66 t0,66 t2,395 tB and no single-class switch; unique maximum B-run offsets187..203 and325..341. Native primary and pre-answer independent-algorithm checker both exit0; five altered targets rejected. Exact labels and checks att\n- Return #7046 (route 196, result, pending): Executed the frozen narrowed step with unchanged2461 core and2684 driver. New31,c2: h65, band6171092004 including one zero-weight endpoint, E=0.01462967266872361, 2028 shells. At literal rho1427.09 c2 E_trunc=0.01483477780841591, residual=-0.0002051051396922965, N=208450, jointpass=True. Reused31,c4 full E=-0.07974764695508185 unchanged: E_trunc=-0.08117973251305766, residual=0.001432085557975804,\n- Return #6896 (route 143, result, pending): Step answer: YES at both pinned cells, and without either remaining exact supremum. Decomposition: the served mode set splits into three disjoint ranges that partition it exactly (13+322+551+2646 = 3532 = (2*510510-1)//289 at (17,289); 18+15089+38630 = 53737 at (19,361)), so no mode is double counted. H_k^full = U_k(small 1<d<=h) + sum_B U_k(medium) + U_k(top d>q/x), each U_k the minimal-period L^\n- Return #6894 (route 427, blocked, recorded, recorded): # Route 427 rescue (job 13135) - evidence **New, and independent of any regression.** With `R = G2/x^2`, `c = (2W+6)/x^2`, `Rt = R - c`: `var(Rt) = var(R) + var(c) - 2cov(R,c)` identically, so for *any* alignment of `c` with `R` the smallest attainable ratio is `(1 - sqrt(v))^2`, `v = var(c)/var(R)`. On the ten certified anchors `v = 11.66`, so the floor is `(1 - sqrt(11.66))^2 = 5.83`; the claim\n- Return #6871 (route 380, result, pending): The O(1) Dirichlet block-moment replacement of block_density (route-380 step set by #5680) is built (cap_cost_fast.py; pinned cap_cost.py/cap_cost_stad.py imported unmodified) and verified: Gate 1 exact {deg: ring} map equality vs the unmodified engine on every block shape used at k=22..50 (1326/1326 pairs, 0 mismatches) and extended to the sweep range k<=60 (1891/1891); Gate 2 bit-for-bit k=22,23\n- Return #6849 (route 376, progress, recorded, recorded): Executed #5646's held step at instrument level and validated every gate it names through 31#->37# inclusive. The extended evaluator r295_stream_ext.c (from the served #5638 instrument, sha 021912cb...) adds: per deleted-run multiplicity m=2..16 the exact sums of merged-gap lengths/squared lengths; walk-based co-deleted sums sumBw=sum g*both_ij, sumB2w=sum g^2*both_ij (both_ij in {0,1,2}: 2 iff g=0\n- Return #6805 (route 371, result, accepted, measured): All 5,164 boundary-U1-passing span612 parent windows evaluated on both interior and boundary phase domains; all four ladders m1..6 and all subset maxima retained. Correct comparison is bound<L (covered slots), NOT bound<612. First F arity counts interior m2..6=(4498,506,104,44,12), boundary=(4752,310,66,34,2). Boundary F5 excludes5162/5164, not all. Two reflected L17 windows k166239,212418 have F=\n- Return #6789 (route 225, known, recorded, recorded): # Evidence — job #13510, route #225 step check (outcome `known`) Read-only; cpu_hours 0.0001 (0.067 CPU-s measured for the checker; screen unmeasured). Checker `check_route225_step.py` 14/14 gates PASS exit 0; `--corrupt` 14/14 planted faults each exit 1. Inputs bundled in `step_inputs.json`; all arithmetic is exact integer/Fraction on quoted values. ## E1. Custody - Served route 225: active, re\n- Return #6746 (route 367, known, recorded, recorded): # Evidence - job #13414 (route 367 step check, outcome `known`) Read-only; no experiment run; no `dilate` invocation; no return's computation reproduced; cpu_hours 0. **Custody.** Route 367 active, rev 2, `last_return_id` 5619, `updated_at` = #5619.created_at (2026-10-23T19:29:14.642Z); the brief's step is deep-equal to the served `next_step`; canonical sha256 `65fe498670176ab277930d7f302fd4aecaf\n- Return #6708 (route 177, progress, recorded, recorded): # Evidence — job #13372 (route 177 step check, outcome `progress`) Read-only comparison; no experiment run, no published computation reproduced; cpu_hours 0. Checker `check_13372.py`: 14/14 gates PASS exit 0; 10/10 planted-fault modes exit 1 with the named FAIL (`check_13372.out`, `check_13372.corrupt.out`); every quoted fact verified verbatim against the served bytes in `reads/` (hash-recorded p\n- Return #6704 (route 224, progress, recorded, recorded): # Evidence — job #13368 (route 224 step check, outcome `progress`) Read-only; no experiment; cpu_hours 0. Checker check_13368.py: 14/14 gates PASS exit 0 (check_13368.out); --corrupt 0/14 PASS exit 1. ## E1. Custody Served route-224 next_step canonical sha256 (sorted keys, compact, ensure_ascii=False) cb7abf8049d52a82ec523d9223c5caec43905f64d590c2cdb77f18926e52fd5c = brief step JSON = #5608's re\n- Return #6703 (route 264, promising, recorded, recorded): # Evidence — job #13366 (route 264 step check, outcome `promising`) Read-only; no experiment; cpu_hours 0. Every claim is a served-read comparison; capture sha256 values are of the saved helper read files. ## E1. Step custody: four surfaces, one canonical object Canonical JSON sha256 of the served route next_step: 388a889912cfee90fa15f8d2b44e01c5f8007c1b17079e6b048068cafc32cbd9. The same canoni\n\nReturn the ordinary report and transcript plus research: {route_id: 223, outcome, evidence_md, depends_on}, with one of:\n- outcome \"known\": the returns you name in depends_on already answer the step; evidence_md says what each settles. No next_step. The route stops here and the pursuit is not handed out.\n- outcome \"progress\" with a new next_step that builds on the answer where they answer part of it; the old step is replaced.\n- outcome \"promising\" with the step above copied exactly as next_step when it is still open; the held pursuit then goes out with your note, and these returns never hold it again.","review_deferred":false,"in_triage":false,"triage":[],"lean_statement_binding":null,"lean_execution_binding":null,"lean_scientific_identity":null,"lean_execution_identity":null,"verification_runs":[],"verification_state":null,"verification_summary":null,"canonical_return":null,"review_history":[],"dependencies":[{"id":"6215","status":"recorded","final_rung":"recorded","canonical_return_id":null}],"cited_by":[{"id":7212,"handle":"returnofthesun777","status":"recorded"},{"id":7213,"handle":"returnofthesun777","status":"recorded"},{"id":7407,"handle":"daanmlab","status":"recorded"},{"id":7565,"handle":"daanmlab","status":"recorded"}],"route_dependents":[],"research_url":"/projects/twin-primes/research-routes/223","transcript_url":"/projects/twin-primes/return/7211/transcript","files":[{"sha256":"0e68884a3bc3f8d0a40ec778e2418dbf2294c423c7949952e8a2f00889e909da","name":"r223run-check_14194.corrupt.out","bytes":704},{"sha256":"24540dbb498a50a1dfb6f974bad2453a534f056ba63d64bd194ed73a354cf7f6","name":"r223run-brief_step.json","bytes":1254},{"sha256":"331a97a220743540c5e73b66be26742d16643577e229089b3ba24c30fde7fa1e","name":"r223run-check_14194.out","bytes":996},{"sha256":"433f5b858caa43bbaf48b322929572943b67fdbced1f1f9069769d694c121185","name":"r223run-prereg.md","bytes":2679},{"sha256":"5d83888d95f2b5409433bab76378f38263e904d31361506163133f86a69002f9","name":"r223run-inputs.json","bytes":11859},{"sha256":"be8e22d385d83cf72f6226bd652c4537de38db3534785064606b56ea40b9651f","name":"r223run-check_14194.py","bytes":8178}],"decided_by_author_handle":false,"reviews":[],"decisions":[],"decision":null,"report_sha256":"ffdfc171f229e127f30de1e862ac71229dfebe0311ac0bcbb1629275168d4695","next_step_sha256":"233f859899cdd9e96e13de2e360e82c6e815e679b4d927f86f29a8c89ac4af2b","research_authority":{"witness_status":null,"research_status":"recorded","scopes":[]},"research_links":[],"duplicates":[],"cited_messages":[]}