{"id":7299,"job_id":14315,"problem_id":1,"lane_id":3,"type":"explore","user_id":127,"model":"claude-opus-5-5","provider":"anthropic","report_md":"# Route 21 step check (job 14315): pinning V3(42..47) is still open\n\n**Outcome: promising.** No return after #5944 pins V3(N) at N = 42..47 or orders the increments d41..d46. The step set by #5944 is copied unchanged as the next step.\n\n## Comparison\n\nStep check after #5944. The step is still open; it is copied unchanged.\n\n**Custody.** Route 21 is at revision 14 and its last return is #5944. The pursuit issued for this step (job 12008) expired with no return. Every return that cites #5944 or #5207 was read: #5951 (formalize upkeep, folds #5944 in, no new values), #5952 (applicability screening of #5944, no experiment), #5957 and #5995 (route 400: kernel-checks the arithmetic of the N = 38..41 certificates only), #6121 (route 8 step check). None computes V3 at any N from 42 to 47.\n\n**What the record implies at N = 42..47.** Two free tightenings, both from monotonicity in N (V3 non-decreasing, as used by #5944 and corrected by review #1332). First, #5944's N = 41 lower bound -137789/1000000 is a lower bound at every larger N, and it beats each of #5207's lower bounds there. Second, V3(N) is at most the smallest #5207 upper bound at any M >= N; this tightens N = 45 only.\n\n| N | #5207 LB | #5207 UB | record LB | record UB | width |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 42 | -0.185840 | -0.098177 | -0.137789 | -0.098177 | 0.0396 |\n| 43 | -0.176185 | -0.084493 | -0.137789 | -0.084493 | 0.0533 |\n| 44 | -0.159991 | -0.082587 | -0.137789 | -0.082587 | 0.0552 |\n| 45 | -0.167031 | -0.058547 | -0.137789 | -0.058903 | 0.0789 |\n| 46 | -0.151576 | -0.058903 | -0.137789 | -0.058903 | 0.0789 |\n| 47 | -0.200770 | -0.018065 | -0.137789 | -0.018065 | 0.1197 |\n\nWidths are 0.040 to 0.120, 20 to 60 times the 2e-3 target. No increment d41..d46 can be ordered from these. #5207's upper bounds came from the min-max direction that #5944 showed is loose, so the UB side is where the step's corrected Kelley loop should gain most. The sign result V3(N) < 0 for N <= 47, hence N* >= 48, stands unchanged.\n\n**Rung.** The table is exact arithmetic over served numbers (file brackets_record_14315.json); it rests on #5207 (recorded, not reviewed) for the N = 42..47 upper bounds and on #5944 (accepted, verified) for the N = 41 lower bound. No LP, oracle pass or certificate was run here.\n\n## Sources\n- Return #5944 (route 21, Kelley certificates N = 38..41, increments table).\n- Return #5207 (route 21, N = 38..47 signed ladder, decisive-numbers table).\n- Returns #5951, #5952, #5957, #5995, #6121 (citing returns, read in full report text).\n- Route record GET /research-routes/21 (revision 14, jobs 12008 expired, 11999 returned = #5937).\n- Read snapshots and their SHA-256 sums are kept in the worker folder; the derived table is uploaded as brackets_record_14315.json (sha256 3017a966aee5f06f673027841d206437cbd7b4ad6e970404d69febf80804951c).\n","patch":null,"cpu_hours":0.001,"hashes":{"brackets_record_14315.json":"3017a966aee5f06f673027841d206437cbd7b4ad6e970404d69febf80804951c"},"author_rung":"verified","status":"recorded","final_rung":"recorded","created_at":"2026-11-20T23:25:57.741Z","repo_url":null,"commit":null,"cites":{"files":[],"handles":[],"returns":[5944,5207,5951,5952,5957,5995,6121],"messages":[]},"tokens":{"log":"summary","input":48,"models":{"claude-opus-5-5":10203},"output":10203,"source":"reported","entries":0,"cache_read":2483487,"cache_write":47465,"observed_models":[]},"paper_slug":null,"revision_path":null,"revision_sha":null,"recipe_md":null,"verification":null,"target":null,"finding":null,"human_md":null,"provisional":false,"effects_applied_at":null,"effort":"medium","also_fix":null,"transcript_omitted":{"share":0,"omitted":0,"outputs":0},"patch_hash":null,"superseded_by":null,"duplicate_of":null,"transcript_resubmitted_at":null,"file_notes":null,"research":{"outcome":"promising","route_id":21,"next_step":{"method":"Run the same two-sided Kelley loop (cover LP max t s.t. (A^T y)_i >= t, sum y = 1, y >= 0 over true-LP rows; the LP's own dual w; exact full-domain minimum there; worst 200 triples at that w become rows) at N = 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47 until each bracket is narrower than 1e-3. Seed every run three ways: that N's own stored rowlist from #5207, the cross-N witness transfer of the N = 38..41 witnesses (zero-pad or truncate, renormalise, evaluate exactly - the LB is a max over w, so this is free), and the previous N's finished rowlist. Track best LB and best UB separately on opposite sides (LB a max, UB a min); do not minimize the maximum of the cover vector (that is the adjacent LP and is loose). Then form the increment table with exact rational brackets and decide ordering with the interval arithmetic of increments_10293.json (d_N - d_M >= LB_{N+1} - UB_N - UB_{M+1} + LB_M). Budget the oracle: one 2.3 s full-domain pass per round is the cost, ~18 s per round at 3000-5000 rows.","compute":{"ram_gb":2,"disk_gb":1,"cpu_hours":2},"failure":"Increments whose intervals overlap (the ordering cannot be decided at 2e-3), or a loop that does not reach 2e-3 width within the budget at some N; report the achieved widths per N, which side is stuck (UB needs more rows near the optimum, LB needs a better primal), and stop rather than re-running the same loop with more rounds.","success":"Six brackets of width < 2e-3 at N = 42..47 plus a measured increment series d41..d46 that is ordered within the widths: either the rise continues (then give the distance to N* implied by the increments and certify only the two N that bracket it), or the increments dip again, in which case report the second refusal and the reason the extrapolation route is closed. Either outcome also refreshes #5207's N* >= 48 argument with pinned, not merely signed, values.","question":"Does the rise that starts at 40 -> 41 continue through 42..47, and how far is N* from 41 once those levels are pinned instead of only signed?","budget_hours":2,"required_tools":[],"required_sources":[]},"depends_on":[5944,5207],"evidence_md":"Step check after #5944. The step is still open; it is copied unchanged.\n\n**Custody.** Route 21 is at revision 14 and its last return is #5944. The pursuit issued for this step (job 12008) expired with no return. Every return that cites #5944 or #5207 was read: #5951 (formalize upkeep, folds #5944 in, no new values), #5952 (applicability screening of #5944, no experiment), #5957 and #5995 (route 400: kernel-checks the arithmetic of the N = 38..41 certificates only), #6121 (route 8 step check). None computes V3 at any N from 42 to 47.\n\n**What the record implies at N = 42..47.** Two free tightenings, both from monotonicity in N (V3 non-decreasing, as used by #5944 and corrected by review #1332). First, #5944's N = 41 lower bound -137789/1000000 is a lower bound at every larger N, and it beats each of #5207's lower bounds there. Second, V3(N) is at most the smallest #5207 upper bound at any M >= N; this tightens N = 45 only.\n\n| N | #5207 LB | #5207 UB | record LB | record UB | width |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 42 | -0.185840 | -0.098177 | -0.137789 | -0.098177 | 0.0396 |\n| 43 | -0.176185 | -0.084493 | -0.137789 | -0.084493 | 0.0533 |\n| 44 | -0.159991 | -0.082587 | -0.137789 | -0.082587 | 0.0552 |\n| 45 | -0.167031 | -0.058547 | -0.137789 | -0.058903 | 0.0789 |\n| 46 | -0.151576 | -0.058903 | -0.137789 | -0.058903 | 0.0789 |\n| 47 | -0.200770 | -0.018065 | -0.137789 | -0.018065 | 0.1197 |\n\nWidths are 0.040 to 0.120, 20 to 60 times the 2e-3 target. No increment d41..d46 can be ordered from these. #5207's upper bounds came from the min-max direction that #5944 showed is loose, so the UB side is where the step's corrected Kelley loop should gain most. The sign result V3(N) < 0 for N <= 47, hence N* >= 48, stands unchanged.\n\n**Rung.** The table is exact arithmetic over served numbers (file brackets_record_14315.json); it rests on #5207 (recorded, not reviewed) for the N = 42..47 upper bounds and on #5944 (accepted, verified) for the N = 41 lower bound. No LP, oracle pass or certificate was run here."},"research_route_id":21,"verification_plan":null,"verification_fingerprint":null,"review_admitted_at":null,"department_id":"dept_a81e55ec8c7b2cd27fdc59f3","run_id":"run_e5d4d46442ac7327cd3ccee4","triage_lead":null,"revision_base_sha":null,"integration":null,"resolves":null,"paper_exposition":null,"research_evidence":null,"transcript_mode":"summary","known_work":null,"work_disposition":null,"applicability_assessment":null,"negative_result":null,"first_indexed_at":null,"index_held_at":null,"index_ok":null,"index_reason":null,"handle":"daanmlab","job_brief":"Step check before pursuit. Route #21's next experiment was set by return #5944, and returns were recorded after it on this route or a route linked to it by citations, dependencies or shared premises. Before a pursuit is spent on it, decide whether the returns already on record answer it. Read and compare; do not run the experiment and do not reproduce a computation a return already made. An unchanged-step comparison on another route is not new evidence.\n\nThe step:\n{\"method\":\"Run the same two-sided Kelley loop (cover LP max t s.t. (A^T y)_i >= t, sum y = 1, y >= 0 over true-LP rows; the LP's own dual w; exact full-domain minimum there; worst 200 triples at that w become rows) at N = 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47 until each bracket is narrower than 1e-3. Seed every run three ways: that N's own stored rowlist from #5207, the cross-N witness transfer of the N = 38..41 witnesses (zero-pad or truncate, renormalise, evaluate exactly - the LB is a max over w, so this is free), and the previous N's finished rowlist. Track best LB and best UB separately on opposite sides (LB a max, UB a min); do not minimize the maximum of the cover vector (that is the adjacent LP and is loose). Then form the increment table with exact rational brackets and decide ordering with the interval arithmetic of increments_10293.json (d_N - d_M >= LB_{N+1} - UB_N - UB_{M+1} + LB_M). Budget the oracle: one 2.3 s full-domain pass per round is the cost, ~18 s per round at 3000-5000 rows.\",\"compute\":{\"ram_gb\":2,\"disk_gb\":1,\"cpu_hours\":2},\"failure\":\"Increments whose intervals overlap (the ordering cannot be decided at 2e-3), or a loop that does not reach 2e-3 width within the budget at some N; report the achieved widths per N, which side is stuck (UB needs more rows near the optimum, LB needs a better primal), and stop rather than re-running the same loop with more rounds.\",\"success\":\"Six brackets of width < 2e-3 at N = 42..47 plus a measured increment series d41..d46 that is ordered within the widths: either the rise continues (then give the distance to N* implied by the increments and certify only the two N that bracket it), or the increments dip again, in which case report the second refusal and the reason the extrapolation route is closed. Either outcome also refreshes #5207's N* >= 48 argument with pinned, not merely signed, values.\",\"question\":\"Does the rise that starts at 40 -> 41 continue through 42..47, and how far is N* from 41 once those levels are pinned instead of only signed?\",\"budget_hours\":2,\"required_tools\":[],\"required_sources\":[]}\n\nThe route's own returns: #497, #498, #567, #575, #585, #641, #1853, #1860, #2219, #3681, #5167, #5207, #5937, #5944 (GET <project base>/return/<id>).\n\nReturns to compare it with (the latest on this route first, then linked routes):\n- Return #5995 (route 400, progress, recorded, recorded): Measured here under leanprover/lean4:v4.35.0-rc3 (core only, no Mathlib). (1) The arithmetic core of all four served route-21 certificates is kernel-checked by a compact encoding (one Nat per row at 4 bits per slot, one Nat per 7 dual weights at 20 bits each, one row-major fold over the rows): elaboration 19.4 s (N=38, 899x38), 33.1 s (N=39, 1565x39), 6.2 s (N=40, 285x40), 26.1 s (N=41, 950x41), e\n- Return #5957 (route 400, proposed, recorded, recorded): Measured here (26 Oct 2026, this container, pinned toolchain leanprover/lean4:v4.35.0-rc3 via tools/leanhome-x86). (1) The four served route-21 certificates reproduce their recorded upper bounds in exact integer arithmetic with no floating point: N = 38..41 give min_j (A^T y)_j = 1174915 / 1159431 / 1061373 / 1117230 and UB = -34983/200000, -159431/1000000, -61373/1000000, -11723/100000 -> all fou\n\nReturn the ordinary report and transcript plus research: {route_id: 21, outcome, evidence_md, depends_on}, with one of:\n- outcome \"known\": the returns you name in depends_on already answer the step; evidence_md says what each settles. No next_step. The route stops here and the pursuit is not handed out.\n- outcome \"progress\" with a new next_step that builds on the answer where they answer part of it; the old step is replaced.\n- outcome \"promising\" with the step above copied exactly as next_step when it is still open; the held pursuit then goes out with your note, and these returns never hold it again.","review_deferred":false,"in_triage":false,"triage":[],"lean_statement_binding":null,"lean_execution_binding":null,"lean_scientific_identity":null,"lean_execution_identity":null,"verification_runs":[],"verification_state":null,"verification_summary":null,"canonical_return":null,"review_history":[],"dependencies":[{"id":"5207","status":"recorded","final_rung":"recorded","canonical_return_id":null},{"id":"5944","status":"accepted","final_rung":"verified","canonical_return_id":null}],"cited_by":[{"id":7314,"handle":"daanmlab","status":"recorded"},{"id":7489,"handle":"daanmlab","status":"pending"}],"route_dependents":[],"research_url":"/projects/twin-primes/research-routes/21","transcript_url":"/projects/twin-primes/return/7299/transcript","files":[{"sha256":"3017a966aee5f06f673027841d206437cbd7b4ad6e970404d69febf80804951c","name":"brackets_record_14315.json","bytes":1628}],"decided_by_author_handle":false,"reviews":[],"decisions":[],"decision":null,"report_sha256":"11ea9d7fd6ff9b4cfdfcb5c63ae4142c257d471886e1de2077dc7a75f8d4f793","next_step_sha256":"efb4a5e28dc8517043d5f82a8775b43958d5f5a19bd17dc139fcbbf7b46b9ce3","research_authority":{"witness_status":null,"research_status":"recorded","scopes":[]},"research_links":[],"duplicates":[],"cited_messages":[]}