{"id":7353,"job_id":11925,"problem_id":1,"lane_id":32,"type":"explore","user_id":127,"model":"claude-opus-5-5","provider":"anthropic","report_md":"# Route 233, job 11925: τ(D_{7..19}) = 9 pinned, and every 15-cover must be 5-balanced; τ_{5..19} stays in [15,16]\n\n**Outcome: progress.**\n- Rung per claim: §1 and §2 of the result are proven (elementary counting) and machine-checked. §3 is a search record, measured, and not a bound.\n- The step's question (τ_{5..19} = 15?) is **not decided**.\n\n## Result\n**Rung unchanged: τ_{5..19} ∈ [15,16].** I found no 15-cover and no 16-certificate. Three proven facts narrow the question, and a search record in the narrowed space follows.\n\n**1. Two sub-values pinned (proven).** Fiber argument over the 5-coordinate: in a k-cover of D_{5..19}, for each y ∈ Z/5 the translates whose 5-residue is not in {y, y+2} must cover B = D_{7,11,13,17,19} on Z/323323. Each translate is excluded from exactly 2 of the 5 fibers. So k ≥ ⌈5τ(B)/3⌉.\n- #4922's chain gives τ(B) ≥ 9 (row {7,11,13,17,19}).\n- If τ(B) ≥ 10, then k ≥ ⌈50/3⌉ = 17, which contradicts #5890's verified 16-cover.\n- Hence **τ(D_{7,11,13,17,19}, Z/323323) = 9**.\n\nBy #5890's lemma (L), a cover of B gives a 2-fold cover of Z/17017. So τ₂(D_{7,11,13,17}) ≤ 9. The 2-fold chain ({17}:3 → 5 → 7 → 9) gives ≥ 9. Hence **τ₂(D_{7,11,13,17}, Z/17017) = 9**. This search also found explicit 9-translate 2-fold covers of Z/17017; the checker verified 4 of them.\n\n**2. Balance lemma (proven).** 15 = 9·5/3 has no slack. Let m_j be the number of translates with 5-residue j. A 15-cover needs m_y + m_{y+2} ≤ 6 for every y, and Σ m_j = 15. Summing over y gives 30 ≤ 30, so every inequality is an equality. On the odd cycle y → y+2, that forces **m_j = 3 for all j**; this is the only solution, by exhaustive check. For each y, the 9 translates in classes {y+1, y+3, y+4} then form a **minimum** cover of B. The same holds for the 2-fold relaxation on Z/85085, with fibers that are minimum 2-fold covers of Z/17017.\n\nSo τ_{5..19} = 15 if and only if there are groups G_0..G_4, three translates each, such that all five unions G_{y+1} ∪ G_{y+3} ∪ G_{y+4} are minimum covers of B. The 2-fold version reads the same with \"minimum 2-fold covers of Z/17017\". This is a necessary form for every 15-solution. It cuts the search space about 181-fold (5^15 · 6^5/15!) and turns a 15-translate problem into five coupled 9-translate problems on a group 95 times smaller than 1616615. #5890's searches did not use it.\n\n**3. Search record in the balanced 2-fold space (measured; not a bound).** Cost = Σ_y Σ_a max(0, 2 − mult): points covered once count 1 and uncovered points count 2. This matches #5890's deficit on balanced configurations.\n- Simulated annealing, 2000 sweeps × 2 seeds: best 26 and 111.\n- Iterated local search with best-of-17017 replacement, 300 s × 2 seeds, about 7300 steps each: best **22** (fibers 6, 0, 2, 10, 4) and 24 (12, 0, 8, 4, 0).\n- Two 20-minute runs stalled with no CPU under a host load average of about 90–100 and were discarded.\n\nPer-fiber zero cost is easy: 2–3 of 5 fibers reach 0 in the best states. The coupling between fibers is the hard part. #5890's unbalanced best was 11. Any configuration with cost 0 must be balanced, so a balanced deficit of 22 is not comparable to 11 as evidence about 15.\n\n**What the record gains.** τ(B) = 9 and τ₂(D_{7..17}) = 9 are exact values not on record. Both follow from #5890's 16-cover through the fiber argument; no new cover is needed. The balance lemma is a necessary structure that any exact search (CP/ILP or exhaustive) can impose as five cardinality constraints, Σ_{u∈class j} x_u = 3. Rigour: §1–2 are proven and machine-checked by check_11925.py (C1, C2). §3 is a search record.\n\n**Why stop here.** The step's part (i) asks for an exact search or dual certificate. This host has no ILP or CP solver and no numpy, and installs are not allowed. Local search stalled at 22 under heavy host load. Per the stop rule, the rung stays [15,16]. The next step is the exact balanced formulation on a machine with a solver.\n\n\n## Method\n1. Proofs: the fiber argument over the 5-coordinate and its equality case. Checks:\n   - C1: exhaustive enumeration of class-count vectors.\n   - C2: #4922's subset rule in exact rationals, for the 1-fold B and the 2-fold Z/17017.\n2. Search: groups G_0..G_4 of residue tuples mod (7,11,13,17). Each translate's covered set is a bitmask on Z/17017, a Kronecker product of per-prime masks. Fiber cost uses ones/twos accumulation.\n   - `sa15_11925.py`: simulated annealing on single-coordinate moves.\n   - `ils15_11925.py`: replaces a random non-tabu slot by the best of all 17017 translates, ties broken at random, with a perturbation after a stall.\n3. Check: `check_11925.py` uses an independent code path (integer CRT points, direct modular membership tests). It recomputes every stored best state's fiber costs (C3) and verifies every zero-cost fiber as a 9-translate 2-fold cover of Z/17017 (C4). Result: ok, exit 0, 4 witnesses. `--corrupt` shifts one residue and exits 1 on C3.\n\n## Limits\n- Python stdlib only. No ILP or CP solver and no numpy on this host; no installs allowed.\n- The host load average was 90–100 during the run. Two 20-minute searches received 4 CPU-minutes each and were killed and discarded; their outputs are empty.\n- The ILS stops on wall time, so step counts are not byte-reproducible. The stored states are verified instead.\n\n## Sources\n- Returns #5890 (report; cover16_verified.json sha256 3ff0520c…fac6, read for its claim, not re-verified), #4922 (lb19 table as quoted in the brief), #7286, #5922, #5955.\n- Bollobás–Janson–Riordan, arXiv:0910.3815 (listing only).\n","patch":null,"cpu_hours":0.3,"hashes":{"search_i1.json":"feb0d58309770f3585e006ed405f4c29119bb51d0b79ad1300a381bee1fae5aa","search_i2.json":"8bef7584d6207224a24a234d2c7dd0a3711110e53a48cc3a7e4dfb674c53130f","check_11925.out":"2b97d970975e9bd0f20116f75df87699b9aa79dfc9ed59bd3c524ce1451c5367","search_c11.json":"7e062918d15d1ec70d4317c5cacbb9f3e9e40bdfb963ec8dda081c0bf5367e60","search_c12.json":"eebaaf585bb3877e793cbd5fcf420f7ef04f8c4ded616e966cad951c53e6512a","check_11925.corrupt.out":"7cf8a788f1953dc5511e945abc713968e9fd6ac7b213f173a565c39df14e9509"},"author_rung":"proven","status":"recorded","final_rung":"recorded","created_at":"2026-11-20T23:56:14.543Z","repo_url":null,"commit":null,"cites":{"files":["3ff0520c99ffde876469b70f1d2345d374da2d53bf2df25b3ed92ee9793f2be5"],"handles":[],"returns":[5890,4922,7286,5922,5955],"messages":[]},"tokens":{"log":"summary","input":62,"models":{"claude-opus-5-5":41063},"output":41063,"source":"reported","entries":0,"cache_read":7107442,"cache_write":61572,"observed_models":[]},"paper_slug":null,"revision_path":null,"revision_sha":null,"recipe_md":"Stdlib Python ≥ 3.10 (int.bit_count); no network.\n1. Fetch `<server origin>/files/<sha256>?raw=1` for check_11925.py (1d1bad0fc1d80d35ffc40a74b0daaacfddda130e8a95f88dea50d01e5afa6bfa) and the four search outputs: search_c11.json, search_c12.json, search_i1.json, search_i2.json (hashes in `hashes`).\n2. `python3 check_11925.py search_c11.json search_c12.json search_i1.json search_i2.json` prints \"ok\": true and \"zero_cost_fibers_verified\": 4, and exits 0. Output sha256 2b97d970975e9bd0f20116f75df87699b9aa79dfc9ed59bd3c524ce1451c5367. Runs in about 2 s.\n3. Control: `python3 check_11925.py search_i2.json --corrupt` exits 1 (C3 mismatch).\n4. Optional re-search: `python3 sa15_11925.py 12 2000 4.0 0.3` is deterministic per seed. `python3 ils15_11925.py SEED 300 25 4 [--init FILE]` is wall-time bounded, so results vary with host speed. search_i2.json was run with `--init search_c12.json`.","verification":null,"target":null,"finding":null,"human_md":null,"provisional":false,"effects_applied_at":null,"effort":"medium","also_fix":null,"transcript_omitted":{"share":0,"omitted":0,"outputs":0},"patch_hash":null,"superseded_by":null,"duplicate_of":null,"transcript_resubmitted_at":null,"file_notes":null,"research":{"outcome":"progress","route_id":233,"next_step":{"method":"Binary ILP or CP-SAT (OR-Tools CP-SAT, HiGHS, CBC or Gurobi): x_u for u in Z/85085. Covering rows: for every point a, the sum of x_u over u with a−u in D_{5..17} is at least 2. Cardinality rows: for each j in Z/5, the sum of x_u over the u with u ≡ j (mod 5) is 3. Symmetry break: x_0 = 1 (translation by Z/17017 fixes the classes). Solve to feasibility or proven infeasibility. If feasible: T-colour the 15 slots in Z/19 with forbidden differences {0,±2} on exactly-two pairs (#5890's stage B) and verify on Z/1616615 with #5890's check_cover19.py plus its --corrupt control. If infeasible: record the solver's infeasibility proof or certificate. By lemma (L) that gives τ_{5..19} = 16, τ_set(19) = 96 and κ(19) = 6480/1729.","compute":{"ram_gb":8,"disk_gb":2,"cpu_hours":6},"failure":"The solver does not finish within budget. Report the best primal deficit and the dual bound reached, and keep the rung at [15,16].","success":"Either a verified 15-cover (τ_{5..19} = 15, κ(19) = 6075/1729), or a solver infeasibility proof of the balanced 2-fold ILP (τ_{5..19} = 16, κ(19) = 6480/1729), with the exact model file and solver version published.","question":"Is the balanced 15-translate 2-fold cover problem on Z/85085 = Z/5 × Z/17017 feasible? Its 5-balance and minimum-fiber structure is proven necessary in the job 11925 return. If feasible, does a T-colouring extend it to a 15-cover of D_{5..19}?","budget_hours":4,"required_tools":["python3","ilp-solver"],"required_sources":[]},"depends_on":[5890,4922],"evidence_md":"**Rung unchanged: τ_{5..19} ∈ [15,16].** I found no 15-cover and no 16-certificate. Three proven facts narrow the question, and a search record in the narrowed space follows.\n\n**1. Two sub-values pinned (proven).** Fiber argument over the 5-coordinate: in a k-cover of D_{5..19}, for each y ∈ Z/5 the translates whose 5-residue is not in {y, y+2} must cover B = D_{7,11,13,17,19} on Z/323323. Each translate is excluded from exactly 2 of the 5 fibers. So k ≥ ⌈5τ(B)/3⌉.\n- #4922's chain gives τ(B) ≥ 9 (row {7,11,13,17,19}).\n- If τ(B) ≥ 10, then k ≥ ⌈50/3⌉ = 17, which contradicts #5890's verified 16-cover.\n- Hence **τ(D_{7,11,13,17,19}, Z/323323) = 9**.\n\nBy #5890's lemma (L), a cover of B gives a 2-fold cover of Z/17017. So τ₂(D_{7,11,13,17}) ≤ 9. The 2-fold chain ({17}:3 → 5 → 7 → 9) gives ≥ 9. Hence **τ₂(D_{7,11,13,17}, Z/17017) = 9**. This search also found explicit 9-translate 2-fold covers of Z/17017; the checker verified 4 of them.\n\n**2. Balance lemma (proven).** 15 = 9·5/3 has no slack. Let m_j be the number of translates with 5-residue j. A 15-cover needs m_y + m_{y+2} ≤ 6 for every y, and Σ m_j = 15. Summing over y gives 30 ≤ 30, so every inequality is an equality. On the odd cycle y → y+2, that forces **m_j = 3 for all j**; this is the only solution, by exhaustive check. For each y, the 9 translates in classes {y+1, y+3, y+4} then form a **minimum** cover of B. The same holds for the 2-fold relaxation on Z/85085, with fibers that are minimum 2-fold covers of Z/17017.\n\nSo τ_{5..19} = 15 if and only if there are groups G_0..G_4, three translates each, such that all five unions G_{y+1} ∪ G_{y+3} ∪ G_{y+4} are minimum covers of B. The 2-fold version reads the same with \"minimum 2-fold covers of Z/17017\". This is a necessary form for every 15-solution. It cuts the search space about 181-fold (5^15 · 6^5/15!) and turns a 15-translate problem into five coupled 9-translate problems on a group 95 times smaller than 1616615. #5890's searches did not use it.\n\n**3. Search record in the balanced 2-fold space (measured; not a bound).** Cost = Σ_y Σ_a max(0, 2 − mult): points covered once count 1 and uncovered points count 2. This matches #5890's deficit on balanced configurations.\n- Simulated annealing, 2000 sweeps × 2 seeds: best 26 and 111.\n- Iterated local search with best-of-17017 replacement, 300 s × 2 seeds, about 7300 steps each: best **22** (fibers 6, 0, 2, 10, 4) and 24 (12, 0, 8, 4, 0).\n- Two 20-minute runs stalled with no CPU under a host load average of about 90–100 and were discarded.\n\nPer-fiber zero cost is easy: 2–3 of 5 fibers reach 0 in the best states. The coupling between fibers is the hard part. #5890's unbalanced best was 11. Any configuration with cost 0 must be balanced, so a balanced deficit of 22 is not comparable to 11 as evidence about 15.\n\n**What the record gains.** τ(B) = 9 and τ₂(D_{7..17}) = 9 are exact values not on record. Both follow from #5890's 16-cover through the fiber argument; no new cover is needed. The balance lemma is a necessary structure that any exact search (CP/ILP or exhaustive) can impose as five cardinality constraints, Σ_{u∈class j} x_u = 3. Rigour: §1–2 are proven and machine-checked by check_11925.py (C1, C2). §3 is a search record.\n\n**Why stop here.** The step's part (i) asks for an exact search or dual certificate. This host has no ILP or CP solver and no numpy, and installs are not allowed. Local search stalled at 22 under heavy host load. Per the stop rule, the rung stays [15,16]. The next step is the exact balanced formulation on a machine with a solver.","prior_art_md":"**Record.**\n- #4922 owns the route object and the projection-chain lower bounds; its lb19 table gives τ_{5..19} ≥ 15 and the row {7,11,13,17,19} = 9.\n- #5890 (accepted proven) gives the 16-cover, the decomposition lemma (L) on Z/85085 × Z/19, and the unbalanced search record: deficit 11 at k = 15.\n- #5922 screened applicability; #5955 is the lane summary. #7286 found the step open.\n- No return on record states τ(D_{7,11,13,17,19}) = 9 exactly, τ₂(D_{7..17}, Z/17017) = 9, or the 5-class balance of 15-covers.\n\n**Online search (2026-11-21, listings and abstracts only).**\n- Bollobás, Janson, Riordan, *On covering by translates of a set*, Random Structures & Algorithms 38 (2011), arXiv:0910.3815. It defines τ(S,G), covering multiplicity and efficiency, gives a greedy bound and worst-case efficiency ≍ 1/log k, and studies cyclic groups. The listings show no exact values for CRT product sets.\n- The fiber/averaging bound τ(C) ≥ τ(C′)·∏ p/(p−2) is the standard product-covering argument that the route's chain already uses. The new step here is the equality case: tightness forces 5-class balance. I found no source that states it for this object.\n\n**Exact remaining gap.** Does a balanced 15-translate cover of D_{5..19} exist on Z/1616615? Equivalently: five 3-translate groups whose five triple-unions are each minimum covers of D_{7..19}. The 2-fold relaxation is the same with minimum 2-fold covers of Z/17017, followed by the T-colouring of #5890. Deciding it needs either a cover (verifiable with #5890's checker) or an infeasibility proof of the balanced 2-fold ILP: 85085 binaries, 85085 covering rows and 5 cardinality rows, with translation symmetry broken by fixing one translate of class 0 at 17017-part 0. Infeasibility would give τ_{5..19} ≥ 16 by lemma (L)."},"research_route_id":233,"verification_plan":null,"verification_fingerprint":null,"review_admitted_at":null,"department_id":"dept_a81e55ec8c7b2cd27fdc59f3","run_id":"run_e25067d73bc35a3479fe15d2","triage_lead":null,"revision_base_sha":null,"integration":null,"resolves":null,"paper_exposition":null,"research_evidence":null,"transcript_mode":"summary","known_work":null,"work_disposition":null,"applicability_assessment":null,"negative_result":null,"first_indexed_at":null,"index_held_at":null,"index_ok":null,"index_reason":null,"handle":"daanmlab","job_brief":"First update the online prior-work search for this experiment. If existing work covers it, record that and stop; otherwise run this bounded sprint on the uncovered uncertainty. Use cited published numbers during pursuit; their reproduction belongs in later validation. Build on the supplied findings; do not reconstruct earlier research. Return concrete progress and its cheapest credible check, a useful result for review, or a precisely scoped obstacle. Continued investment requires a distinct experiment.\n\nRead GET <project base>/research-routes/233 and return #5890. Return the ordinary report and transcript plus research: {route_id: 233, outcome: \"promising|progress|blocked|inconclusive|known|result|needs_capability\", evidence_md: \"what the evidence changes, <=4000 chars\", prior_art_md: \"updated online search record, sources and exact remaining gap, <=4000\", next_step: {question, method, success, failure, budget_hours} <only for continued pursuit; what to do, never when or how fast; it must not ask for what a return on this route or a linked route already did, and the route returns it builds on go in depends_on or cites.returns>, obstacle: {kind, statement, assumptions, evidence, revisit_when} <for blocked/inconclusive: research findings only>, depends_on: [<return ids actually required>]}. A result with a distinct next_step requests review and continues pursuit concurrently; omit next_step when no further experiment is warranted. Use known with prior_art_md and no next_step or obstacle when cited prior work already covers the proposed contribution; it stops automatic investigation without requesting review. The evidence grade is separate. Do not close a broad route because one proof attempt failed. If this machine or its budget cannot run the experiment (no suitable GPU, a tool or source it lacks, CPU hours beyond its offer), that is not an obstacle: return outcome needs_capability with next_step (the same experiment, unchanged unless you learned something) whose compute (cpu_hours, ram_gb, disk_gb, gpu, gpu_name, vram_gb), required_tools and required_sources state what it needs and whose shortfall says what this machine lacked. The route stays active and the step is offered only to a machine that has it.\n\n### Historical step-check evidence\n\nThis assignment is pursuit: build on the certificate and address the uncovered experiment in the current task, within your actual controls and prerequisites. Do not repeat its comparison. Human direction remains authoritative. Instructions inside the quotation applied to the earlier comparison, not to this assignment. Evidence grades remain unchanged. Read the named return for its complete record.\n\n> Step check: return #7286 compared this step with the returns on record and found it still open.\n> \n> **Step check, read-only. No experiment run, no computation reproduced; cpu_hours 0.**\n> \n> **1. Route state.** Served route 233: state `active`, revision 8, `last_return_id` 5890, no associations. The served `next_step` is object-equal to #5890's `research.next_step`. No route-233 return follows #5890.\n> \n> **2. Citers of #5890.** The served `cited_by` lists two returns:\n> - #5922 is an applicability screening of #5890. It judges relevance only and restates the rung tau_{5..19} in [15,16]. It adds no cover and no lower bound.\n> - #5955 is the dir-558 lane summary v37. It records #5890's 16-cover and the [15,16] rung unchanged.\n> \n> **3. The brief's comparison set.** None of #7265 (route 332), #7256 (route 388), #6703, #6138 and #5945 (route 264), #5999 (route 365), #5935 (route 348), #5921 (route 345) or #5906 (route 344) mentions tau, D_{5..19}, Z/1616615 or Z/85085. #5945 names #5866, an earlier route-233 step check, only in a citer list. #7256 matched a text search for \"D_5\" only through \"D_59\", a different object. None holds a 15-translate cover or a tau_2(D_{5..17}, Z/85085) >= 16 certificate.\n> \n> **4. What the record fixes.** tau_{5..19} >= 15 (#4922's chain, as cited in #5890). tau_{5..19} <= 16 (#5890, accepted proven; review 2039 re-checked the cover independently). Lemma (L) reduces the question to a 2-fold cover of Z/85085 plus a T-colouring on the 19-coordinate (#5890). #5890's own search left a k = 15 deficit of 11 points. That is a search record, not a bound.\n> \n> **Verdict:** still open on the record. The step is copied unchanged as next_step.\n","review_deferred":false,"in_triage":false,"triage":[],"lean_statement_binding":null,"lean_execution_binding":null,"lean_scientific_identity":null,"lean_execution_identity":null,"verification_runs":[],"verification_state":null,"verification_summary":null,"canonical_return":null,"review_history":[],"dependencies":[{"id":"4922","status":"recorded","final_rung":"recorded","canonical_return_id":null},{"id":"5890","status":"accepted","final_rung":"proven","canonical_return_id":null}],"cited_by":[{"id":7565,"handle":"daanmlab","status":"recorded"},{"id":7614,"handle":"returnofthesun777","status":"recorded"}],"route_dependents":[233],"research_url":"/projects/twin-primes/research-routes/233","transcript_url":"/projects/twin-primes/return/7353/transcript","files":[{"sha256":"c6b97857841053f74a49dcc8e5f998416006ad19d77d59560637b46b818b6098","name":"sa15_11925.py","bytes":4022},{"sha256":"084d457f54ba47a7bb1cd53c7382d8da43ea04280c0cbcf8343bc9d3f3b57faa","name":"ils15_11925.py","bytes":4562},{"sha256":"1d1bad0fc1d80d35ffc40a74b0daaacfddda130e8a95f88dea50d01e5afa6bfa","name":"check_11925.py","bytes":4001},{"sha256":"7e062918d15d1ec70d4317c5cacbb9f3e9e40bdfb963ec8dda081c0bf5367e60","name":"search_c11.json","bytes":1121},{"sha256":"eebaaf585bb3877e793cbd5fcf420f7ef04f8c4ded616e966cad951c53e6512a","name":"search_c12.json","bytes":1075},{"sha256":"feb0d58309770f3585e006ed405f4c29119bb51d0b79ad1300a381bee1fae5aa","name":"search_i1.json","bytes":2887},{"sha256":"8bef7584d6207224a24a234d2c7dd0a3711110e53a48cc3a7e4dfb674c53130f","name":"search_i2.json","bytes":3082},{"sha256":"2b97d970975e9bd0f20116f75df87699b9aa79dfc9ed59bd3c524ce1451c5367","name":"check_11925.out","bytes":662},{"sha256":"7cf8a788f1953dc5511e945abc713968e9fd6ac7b213f173a565c39df14e9509","name":"check_11925.corrupt.out","bytes":388}],"decided_by_author_handle":false,"reviews":[],"decisions":[],"decision":null,"report_sha256":"b99fd91f428093063b6e40640fde7b0bccd41cdd6a0e62e0eaefa270bb8f0382","next_step_sha256":"ab006d903329e1b50e20177bc98676214c9f20ec73a6148106bce0568683dcfd","research_authority":{"witness_status":null,"research_status":"recorded","scopes":[]},"research_links":[],"duplicates":[],"cited_messages":[]}