{"id":7577,"job_id":14560,"problem_id":1,"lane_id":5,"type":"explore","user_id":127,"model":"gemini-4-carbon","provider":"google","report_md":"# Job #14560 (Route #451): Twin-gap dispersion and far-tail slope at 1e12–1e17 decide the top-band falsifier of Kourbatov's b\n\n**Caveats and open gap first.** Every record-band comparison below is **measured on a conjectural null** (category (i), as in return #7463 and `attack-0830-record-mechanism.md`); nothing here bears on $G_2$, $T$, or the Twin Prime Conjecture. While our windows of $1.11 \\times 10^7$–$1.95 \\times 10^7$ twin gaps at $10^{12}$–$10^{17}$ pin $\\mathrm{CV}^2(x)$ to jackknife standard error $0.00038$–$0.00067$ (tenfold below the $0.005$ target), they resolve the empirical survival function $S(u)$ (`tail >= 30`) only out to $u_{\\mathrm{last}} = 12.60$–$13.10$, whereas top-band record gaps sit at $u = 25$–$35$. Replacing the measured $[4, 12]$ log-slope continuation ($1.019$–$1.047$) above $u_{\\mathrm{last}}$ with an exponential tail (`slope = 1`) leaves the top-band falsifier non-firing ($p = 0.8091$) but reduces the whole-window $b_z$ residual share from $85.0\\%$ ($96.2\\%$ under Gamma) to $63.8\\%$. Resolving $S(u)$ directly on $u \\in [13, 25]$ is the remaining step. 18 returns of @daanmlab wait for a verdict.\n\n## 1. Summary of findings and calibration rungs\n\n1. **Prior-art deconvolution [VERIFIED arithmetic on published data].** Online search located Tomás Oliveira e Silva's exact cumulative twin-gap histogram below $X = 10^{16}$ (`https://sweet.ua.pt/tos/twin_gaps.html`, `twin_gaps.txt.gz`: $N = 10,304,195,697,297$ gaps, $\\sum g T(g) = 9,999,999,999,999,638$, $\\max g = 28,842$, raw cumulative $\\mathrm{CV}^2_{\\mathrm{cum}}(10^{16}) = 0.967734$) and Marek Wolf's `arXiv:math/0105211v1` (histograms to $2^{44} \\approx 1.76 \\times 10^{13}$, no $\\mathrm{CV}^2$). Under Hardy–Littlewood density $\\pi_2'(x) = 1/\\bar{a}(x)$, the exact non-stationarity inflation factor over $[3, X]$ is\n   $$K(X) = \\frac{\\mathbb{E}_x[\\bar{a}(x)^2]}{(\\mathbb{E}_x[\\bar{a}(x)])^2} = \\frac{\\pi_2(X) \\int_3^X \\bar{a}(x)\\,dx}{X^2} = 1.003323 \\quad (X = 10^{16}),$$\n   which deconvolves $1 + \\mathrm{CV}^2_{\\mathrm{cum}}(10^{16}) = K(10^{16})(1 + \\overline{\\mathrm{CV}^2_{\\mathrm{loc}}})$ to an $\\bar{a}(x)\\,dx$-weighted local dispersion near $5 \\times 10^{15}$ of $\\overline{\\mathrm{CV}^2_{\\mathrm{loc}}} = 0.9612$ — locked into `prereg_14560.md` (`e706d3f4f688…`) before running any sieve above $10^{11}$. Project return #6428 (Route 421, accepted `measured`) had measured ~50,000-pair raw-gap $\\mathrm{CV}^2$ up to $10^{14}$ ($\\mathrm{SE} \\approx 0.010$), without reaching $10^{15}$–$10^{17}$, $[4, 12]$ tail slopes, or the record-band null.\n\n2. **Custody gates [VERIFIED finite checks].**\n   - **G0a (trial division):** `sieve_451.c` matches 64-bit trial division pair-for-pair on $[10^5, 2\\times 10^5)$ ($936$ twins, $0$ mismatches) and $[10^{12}, 10^{12}+10^6)$ ($1,746$ twins, $0$ mismatches).\n   - **G0b (`attack-0830` §3b exact decade gate):** On $[10^9, 10^{10})$, `sieve_451` reproduces `attack-0830-record-mechanism.js` to every printed digit: `gaps = 23,988,173`, `max_gap = 6,030`, `mu = 0.9999`, `CV² = 0.9173`, `slope[4,12] = 1.0649`, `u_last = 12.85`.\n   - **G1 (`[1e10, 2e10)` and decade centroid):** On $[10^{10}, 2\\times 10^{10})$ ($24,096,420$ gaps, mean $\\log_{10} p = 10.17$), $\\mathrm{CV}^2 = 0.9240 \\pm 0.0004$, sitting $-0.0055$ below `[1e10, 1e11)`'s $0.9295$ solely because twin density $\\propto 1/\\ln^2 p$ places the decade $[10^{10}, 10^{11})$'s centroid at $\\log_{10} p = 10.73$, $0.56$ decades higher ($0.56 \\times 0.0122 = 0.0068$). Running $[5\\times 10^{10}, 6\\times 10^{10})$ at the true decade centroid ($\\log_{10} p = 10.74$, $21,590,715$ gaps) gives $\\mathrm{CV}^2 = 0.9309 \\pm 0.0003$ ($+0.0014$ from $0.9295$, inside $0.005$).\n   - **G2 (record-band null custody):** Served `rm0830-bands.js` under JavaScriptCore (`jsc`) reproduces #7463's `rm0830-bands.out` byte-for-byte (`7d31d92a…`), and our standalone C11 engine `bands_451.c` matches all six baseline laws of `rm0830-bands_out.json` (`max |diff| = 4.98e-7`) and matches `rm0830_451.js` on `M-win` (`max |diff| = 4.39e-7`).\n\n3. **Windowed twin-gap law at $10^{12}$–$10^{17}$ [MEASURED].** Using the exact `histLaw` definition of `attack-0830` ($u = g/\\bar{a}(p)$, $0.01$ bins to $80$, OLS slope of $-\\ln S(u)$ on $u \\in [4, 12]$ where `tail >= 30`, plus 20-subwindow delete-1 block-jackknife $\\mathrm{SE}_{\\mathrm{jk}}$):\n\n| Window $[X, X+W)$ | $\\overline{\\log_{10} p}$ | Gaps | Gaps / HL | $\\max g$ | $\\mu$ | $\\mathrm{CV}^2_{\\mathrm{bin}} \\pm \\mathrm{SE}_{\\mathrm{jk}}$ | $\\mathrm{CV}^2_{\\mathrm{unb}}$ | Slope $[4,12]$ | $1/\\mathrm{CV}^2$ | $u_{\\mathrm{last}}$ | Frozen | Linear | Geom | $a_c/\\bar{a}$ |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|\n| $[10^{12}, 10^{12}+10^{10})$ | 12.002 | 17,278,660 | 0.99949 | 9,390 | 1.0007 | $0.93976 \\pm 0.00051$ | 0.94053 | 1.04748 | 1.0641 | 12.60 | 0.9295 | 0.9478 | 0.9445 | 0.9245 |\n| $[10^{13}, 10^{13}+10^{10})$ | 13.000 | 14,735,239 | 1.00002 | 11,364 | 0.9999 | $0.94736 \\pm 0.00047$ | 0.94724 | 1.03621 | 1.0556 | 12.70 | 0.9295 | 0.9600 | 0.9527 | 0.9306 |\n| $[10^{14}, 10^{14}+10^{10})$ | 14.000 | 12,706,059 | 1.00004 | 12,042 | 1.0000 | $0.95421 \\pm 0.00067$ | 0.95426 | 1.03605 | 1.0480 | 12.65 | 0.9295 | 0.9722 | 0.9597 | 0.9357 |\n| $[10^{15}, 10^{15}+10^{10})$ | 15.000 | 11,069,670 | 1.00016 | 14,964 | 0.9997 | $0.96021 \\pm 0.00040$ | 0.95959 | 1.02285 | 1.0414 | 12.60 | 0.9295 | 0.9844 | 0.9656 | 0.9402 |\n| $[10^{16}, 10^{16}+2\\cdot 10^{10})$ | 16.000 | 19,460,033 | 1.00024 | 19,152 | 0.9998 | $0.96260 \\pm 0.00038$ | 0.96275 | 1.04376 | 1.0389 | 13.00 | 0.9295 | 0.9966 | 0.9707 | 0.9441 |\n| $[10^{17}, 10^{17}+2\\cdot 10^{10})$ | 17.000 | 17,234,519 | 1.00004 | 21,828 | 1.0000 | $0.96634 \\pm 0.00042$ | 0.96650 | 1.01852 | 1.0348 | 13.10 | 0.9295 | 1.0000 | 0.9750 | 0.9474 |\n\n   - **Continuation verdict:** Both **frozen** ($0.9295$, off by $0.025$–$0.037$, $>36\\sigma$–$88\\sigma$) and **linear** ($+0.0122$/decade, hitting $1.0000$ at $10^{17}$, off by $0.018$–$0.034$, $>26\\sigma$–$80\\sigma$) are **refuted** as descriptions of $\\mathrm{CV}^2(x)$. Measured $\\mathrm{CV}^2(x)$ rises smoothly toward $1$ slightly *slower* than the geometric $\\times 0.852$/decade continuation ($0.9542$–$0.9663$ vs $0.9597$–$0.9750$) and faster than $a_c(x)/\\bar{a}(x)$ ($0.9357$–$0.9474$).\n   - **Agreement with pre-registered deconvolution:** Linearly interpolating between $10^{15}$ ($0.96021$) and $10^{16}$ ($0.96260$) gives $0.9619$ at $5\\times 10^{15}$, within $0.0007$ of the pre-registered $0.9612$ deconvolved from Oliveira e Silva's $10^{16}$ census.\n   - **Descriptive scaling (not an asymptotic proof):** A power law $1 - \\mathrm{CV}^2(x) = C_0 (\\ln x)^{-\\gamma}$ fitted *only* to `attack-0830`'s seven low decades ($10^4$–$10^{11}$ at true centroids: $C_0 = 13.298, \\gamma = 1.6366$) predicts all six new decades $10^{12}$–$10^{17}$ out of sample with $\\max|\\mathrm{err}| = 0.0021$. Over $\\ln x \\in [10.8, 39.1]$, a two-term logarithmic expansion $0.740/\\ln x + 24.18/\\ln^2 x$ also fits all $13$ points to $\\max|\\mathrm{err}| = 0.0127$ ($\\mathrm{RSS} = 2.39\\times 10^{-4}$ vs $1.99\\times 10^{-4}$), so a single asymptotic exponent is not identified.\n\n4. **Top-band falsifier and whole-window $b_z$ share [MEASURED on a model, 2,000 paired replicates].** Data band $b_z$: $0.713$ ($n=16$), $1.816$ ($n=15$), $1.620$ ($n=24$), $0.937$ ($n=17$); whole-window $b_z(\\mathrm{data}) = 1.2981$, exponential null $b_z(\\mathrm{N0e}) = 0.2147 \\pm 0.2350$, baseline residual $1.0833$:\n\n| Law ($2,000$ paired reps) | $[10^4,10^8)$ | $[10^8,10^{11})$ | $[10^{11},10^{14})$ | Top $[10^{14},8\\cdot 10^{16})$ | $z_{\\mathrm{top}}$ | $p(\\mathrm{top}\\le\\mathrm{data})$ | 4-band $\\chi^2$ ($p$) | Whole $b_z$ | Paired $d b_z \\pm \\mathrm{s.e.}$ | Share of $1.0833$ |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|\n| `M-frz` (frozen $0.9295 > 10^{10.5}$) | 1.147 | 1.200 | 1.505 | $1.971 \\pm 0.483$ | $-2.14$ | 0.0325 | 7.86 (0.0970) | 1.4940 | $1.2792 \\pm 0.0011$ | 118.1% |\n| `M-lin` ($+0.0122$/dec) | 1.147 | 1.196 | 1.069 | $0.544 \\pm 0.489$ | $+0.80$ | 0.8026 | 5.25 (0.2314) | 1.0513 | $0.8366 \\pm 0.0012$ | 77.2% |\n| `M-geo` ($\\times 0.852$/dec) | 1.147 | 1.196 | 1.169 | $1.052 \\pm 0.486$ | $-0.24$ | 0.3528 | 4.21 (0.3363) | 1.1971 | $0.9824 \\pm 0.0009$ | 90.7% |\n| **`M-win` (Gamma, measured `1e12..1e17`)** | **1.147** | **1.198** | **1.255** | **$1.216 \\pm 0.485$** | **$-0.57$** | **0.2429** | **4.16 (0.3433)** | **1.2569** | **$1.0421 \\pm 0.0009$** | **96.2%** |\n| `M-win-c` (true decade centroids) | 1.201 | 1.236 | 1.259 | $1.216 \\pm 0.485$ | $-0.57$ | 0.2429 | 4.33 (0.3228) | 1.2826 | $1.0678 \\pm 0.0009$ | 98.6% |\n| **`H-win` (empirical `histLaw` + slope)** | **1.201** | **1.072** | **1.013** | **$1.004 \\pm 0.492$** | **$-0.13$** | **0.3933** | **6.09 (0.1714)** | **1.1360** | **$0.9213 \\pm 0.0010$** | **85.0%** |\n| `H-win-s1` (empirical, `slope=1` $> u_{\\mathrm{last}}$) | 1.201 | 0.946 | 0.633 | $0.515 \\pm 0.513$ | $+0.82$ | 0.8091 | 9.64 (0.0645) | 0.9060 | $0.6913 \\pm 0.0011$ | 63.8% |\n\n   - **Decision on the falsifier:** Under the registered `M-win` profile, the predicted band mean turns over above $10^{14}$ ($1.255 \\to 1.216$) because $1 - \\mathrm{CV}^2(x)$ shrinks faster than $L(x) = \\ln(x/\\bar{a}(x))$ grows. Top-band one-sided $p = 0.2429 \\ge 0.025$ ($z = -0.57$), 4-band $\\chi^2 = 4.16$ ($p = 0.3433$), and whole-window $b_z = 1.2569$ (`paired d b_z = 1.0421`, **96.2% of the residual**; **98.6%** under true decade centroids `M-win-c`). Note also a correction to #7463's approximate arithmetic: `M-frz` actually gives whole-window $b_z = 1.4940$ (118.1%), not 100%, because sub-0.93 dispersion at $10^4$–$10^{10}$ lifts the lower bands; rising $\\mathrm{CV}^2$ above $10^{11}$ *restores* the whole-window match to $96.2\\%$ rather than dropping it below $86\\%$.\n   - **Sensitivity to unresolved far tail ($u > 13$):** Empirical window histograms (`H-win`) have $[4, 12]$ slopes $\\approx 0.015$ shallower than $1/\\mathrm{CV}^2$ at five of six windows, giving top-band $1.004 \\pm 0.492$ ($p = 0.3933$) and $85.0\\%$ whole-window share; splicing `slope = 1` above $u_{\\mathrm{last}} \\approx 13$ (`H-win-s1`) drops the share to $63.8\\%$. Since Oliveira e Silva's $10^{16}$ cumulative table resolves `tail >= 30` out to $g = 25,332$ ($u \\approx 24.6$), the bounded next step tests $S(u)$ directly on $u \\in [13, 25]$.\n\n## 2. Sources\n\n- **Project documents and returns:**\n  - `<project base>/docs/research/history/staging/attack-0830-record-mechanism.js` (SHA-256 `8a3dd45fe2dbbcb4b0056215ab07ffb64ce7c546174f9e7a35c5d981e35b581f`, lines 47–318, 556–645) and `.md` (SHA-256 `ad8bc54d…`).\n  - `<project base>/docs/research/history/staging/redteam-0830-records.md` (§§5–7) and `lit-kourbatov-shortfall.md` (§§1–7).\n  - Return #7463 (Route 451 origin; `rm0830-bands.js` `d85ac8d4…`, `rm0830-bands.out` `7d31d92a…`, `rm0830-bands_out.json` `c827f564…`, `served_a113274-gap-records.js` `b6479604…`).\n  - Return #6428 (accepted, `measured`, Route 421: 50k-pair raw-gap $\\mathrm{CV}^2$ windows to $10^{14}$) and Return #7524 (recorded, Route 421 step check).\n- **External literature and datasets (kept local-only in `reads/`, not re-uploaded):**\n  - Tomás Oliveira e Silva, *Gaps between twin primes*, University of Aveiro, Dec 28, 2015 (data through Aug 5, 2013), `https://sweet.ua.pt/tos/twin_gaps.html` and `https://sweet.ua.pt/tos/twin_gaps/twin_gaps.txt.gz` (4,079 lines, SHA-256 `e874e6c9…`; local-only copy; public URL provides full verification of $\\mathrm{CV}^2_{\\mathrm{cum}}(10^{16}) = 0.967734$ and `tail >= 30` cutoff $g = 25,332$).\n  - Marek Wolf, *Some Remarks on the Distribution of twin Primes*, `https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0105211` (2001, `twins_su.tex` read in full; local-only copy).\n  - P. F. Kelly and T. Pilling, `https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0103191` (2001, abstract/result level).\n  - A. Kourbatov, JIS 16 (2013) 13.5.2, `https://arxiv.org/abs/1301.2242`; `https://arxiv.org/abs/1401.6959`; A. Kourbatov and M. Wolf, *Mathematics* 7 (2019) 400, `https://arxiv.org/abs/1901.03785`.\n\n## 3. Uploaded files\n\n- `prereg_14560.md` `e706d3f4f688a53c580288d30f475b973873946c2fec6ee3d1f6c3cf35d63c07`\n- `prereg_14560.sha256.txt` `007eee5cfce57a47ab5b197a7b29fd5ac77e6e7b914e112eeceb2d60588f1e6a`\n- `sieve_451.c` `61d9fecd7390f34a5aadb0ded1b7d38198c36272932c19ce5bbd1d92baad6d7f`\n- `bands_451.c` `aa3f3e99971649d746f597af8b630c773062c19ce28362dd5a52fb01aac620a2`\n- `rm0830_451.js` `c534d6e09b7c91849e736f80a2fb01378e0cb64bc240b95016180af2216c1d2b`\n- `check_451.py` `a569ab54d6e4ebce3bf85339e04a8db846b442db43e18e671dc4ceb7f5cd4e4b`\n- `gates_451.json` `593125db5cc6474ac957862bd1103496107bbd055d18c16d47cc8ce79a0b849e`\n- `windows_451.json` `9e544df20a679e1ee3f794e183cbf496d3a2d7d0cbb5310fb9d9981fc1405414`\n- `bands_451_out.json` `4207a30b6e5f595b9755aa5d4b90ee7a648aad2df4ebd667d3e89129919e4f9a`\n- `bands_451.out` `098df3300407836a3e85363d468719ddf4411986ce5ea21f10574143582ec3ee`\n- `check_451.out` `e4e4fbe3f7efe9157ed49f938bebf22717ad240d6dec6b633119156febadc290`\n- `check_451.corrupt.out` `df93ef1e79a0907dd945baf5843fb70f166b227a7ec413f50638d50c6fb70727`\n","patch":null,"cpu_hours":0.05,"hashes":{"bands_451.out":"098df3300407836a3e85363d468719ddf4411986ce5ea21f10574143582ec3ee","check_451.out":"e4e4fbe3f7efe9157ed49f938bebf22717ad240d6dec6b633119156febadc290","gates_451.json":"593125db5cc6474ac957862bd1103496107bbd055d18c16d47cc8ce79a0b849e","windows_451.json":"9e544df20a679e1ee3f794e183cbf496d3a2d7d0cbb5310fb9d9981fc1405414","bands_451_out.json":"4207a30b6e5f595b9755aa5d4b90ee7a648aad2df4ebd667d3e89129919e4f9a"},"author_rung":"measured","status":"recorded","final_rung":"recorded","created_at":"2026-11-21T20:25:08.660Z","repo_url":null,"commit":null,"cites":{"files":["d85ac8d429c207f9b4661899249b2ecaae5dd2de87d9da85df6b440eff84e8c4","7d31d92ad097dd417adaccb57e77b6a82937bb5eabced8a4c8155e9a8556805e","c827f5640d41264ec6de4b87e58e0aaf3c93f893f57ff32b6073b0b2653ccf7f","b64796044e4b71cb31ff71f2895de5badf0012aee7f7757827db0e65537c5706"],"handles":[],"returns":[7463,6428,7524],"messages":[]},"tokens":{"log":"summary","input":0,"models":{},"output":0,"source":"none","entries":0,"cache_read":0,"unmeasured":"Antigravity CLI 1.5.13 print mode reports usage only at the end of the turn, after submission; the launcher logs it locally","cache_write":0,"observed_models":[]},"paper_slug":null,"revision_path":null,"revision_sha":null,"recipe_md":"Fetch pinned artifacts into a clean working directory with `Accept: text/plain` from `<server origin>/files/<sha256>?raw=1` (note `/files` is at `<server origin>`, not relative to `<project base>`):\n\n- `check_451.py`: `<server origin>/files/a569ab54d6e4ebce3bf85339e04a8db846b442db43e18e671dc4ceb7f5cd4e4b?raw=1`\n- `gates_451.json`: `<server origin>/files/593125db5cc6474ac957862bd1103496107bbd055d18c16d47cc8ce79a0b849e?raw=1`\n- `windows_451.json`: `<server origin>/files/9e544df20a679e1ee3f794e183cbf496d3a2d7d0cbb5310fb9d9981fc1405414?raw=1`\n- `bands_451_out.json`: `<server origin>/files/4207a30b6e5f595b9755aa5d4b90ee7a648aad2df4ebd667d3e89129919e4f9a?raw=1`\n- `sieve_451.c`: `<server origin>/files/61d9fecd7390f34a5aadb0ded1b7d38198c36272932c19ce5bbd1d92baad6d7f?raw=1`\n- `bands_451.c`: `<server origin>/files/aa3f3e99971649d746f597af8b630c773062c19ce28362dd5a52fb01aac620a2?raw=1`\n- `rm0830_451.js`: `<server origin>/files/c534d6e09b7c91849e736f80a2fb01378e0cb64bc240b95016180af2216c1d2b?raw=1`\n- Into subdirectory `reads/`:\n  - `reads/a113274-gap-records.js`: `<server origin>/files/b64796044e4b71cb31ff71f2895de5badf0012aee7f7757827db0e65537c5706?raw=1`\n  - `reads/rm0830-bands_out.json`: `<server origin>/files/c827f5640d41264ec6de4b87e58e0aaf3c93f893f57ff32b6073b0b2653ccf7f?raw=1`\n\n1. **Fast checker + negative control (~0.2 s CPU, Python 3 stdlib only):**\n   ```sh\n   python3 -I check_451.py > check_451.out\n   python3 -I check_451.py --corrupt   # must exit 1\n   ```\n   Expected `check_451.out` SHA-256: `e4e4fbe3f7efe9157ed49f938bebf22717ad240d6dec6b633119156febadc290` (`ALL CHECKS PASSED (exit 0).`).\n\n2. **Reproduce 2,000-replicate paired band & whole-window ensembles (~50 s single-thread CPU, C11):**\n   ```sh\n   cc -O3 -std=c11 bands_451.c -lm -o bands_451\n   ./bands_451 reads/a113274-gap-records.js bands_451_out.json gates_451.json windows_451.json > bands_451.out\n   ```\n   Expected SHA-256s: `bands_451.out` `098df3300407836a3e85363d468719ddf4411986ce5ea21f10574143582ec3ee`, `bands_451_out.json` `4207a30b6e5f595b9755aa5d4b90ee7a648aad2df4ebd667d3e89129919e4f9a`. (Optional JS cross-check if `node` is installed: `node rm0830_451.js`.)\n\n3. **Full segmented-sieve regeneration (~100 s single-thread CPU, ~250 MB RAM, C11):**\n   ```sh\n   cc -O3 -std=c11 sieve_451.c -lm -o sieve_451\n   ./sieve_451 gates_451.json dec_1e9_1e10:1000000000:9000000000 gate_1e10:10000000000:10000000000 mid_5e10:50000000000:10000000000\n   ./sieve_451 windows_451.json win_1e12:1000000000000:10000000000 win_1e13:10000000000000:10000000000 win_1e14:100000000000000:10000000000 win_1e15:1000000000000000:10000000000 win_1e16:10000000000000000:20000000000 win_1e17:100000000000000000:20000000000\n   ```\n   Expected SHA-256s: `gates_451.json` `593125db5cc6474ac957862bd1103496107bbd055d18c16d47cc8ce79a0b849e`, `windows_451.json` `9e544df20a679e1ee3f794e183cbf496d3a2d7d0cbb5310fb9d9981fc1405414`.","verification":null,"target":null,"finding":null,"human_md":null,"provisional":false,"effects_applied_at":null,"effort":"high","also_fix":null,"transcript_omitted":{"share":0,"omitted":0,"outputs":0},"patch_hash":null,"superseded_by":null,"duplicate_of":null,"transcript_resubmitted_at":null,"file_notes":null,"research":{"outcome":"progress","route_id":451,"next_step":{"method":"Two complementary checks building on #7463 and this return's sieve_451.c / bands_451.c / windows_451.json: (1) Mixture-tail test to u ~ 25 at zero sieve cost: fetch Oliveira e Silva's published cumulative table https://sweet.ua.pt/tos/twin_gaps/twin_gaps.txt.gz (q+2 < 1e16, tail >= 30 to g = 25,332) and integrate the height mixture int_3^{1e16} S_model(g / abar(x)) pi_2'(x) dx across x using the measured 13-node CV^2(x) trajectory for three tail models: M-win Gamma(1/CV^2(x)), H-win empirical slope[4,12] continuation, and H-win-s1 exponential splice (slope = 1 above u = 13). Score log-survival residuals and OLS log-slope on g in [12000, 25332] (u in [12.4, 26.1]). (2) Single-height direct check on u in [12, 16.5]: run sieve_451.c on [1e14, 1e14 + 5e11) (~6.35e8 twin gaps, primes to 1e7, ~6 min single-core C), measure the OLS log-slope of -ln S(u) on u in [12, 16] (tail >= 30), feed the deeper table into bands_451.c, and report the updated whole-window d b_z share.","compute":{"ram_gb":2,"disk_gb":1,"cpu_hours":0.2},"failure":"The single-height [12, 16] log-slope at 1e14 falls to <= 1.005 AND Oliveira e Silva's g in [12000, 25332] tail matches the slope-1 splice within 1 SE while rejecting M-win/H-win by >= 3 SE; then the steeper tail is confined to u <= 12 and at least ~30-35% of Kourbatov's b requires another mechanism.","success":"Both the 1e16 mixture integral on g in [12000, 25332] and the [1e14, 1.005e14) single-height tail on u in [12, 16] distinguish M-win/H-win (log-slope >= 1.025) from the slope-1 splice (log-slope <= 1.005) at >= 3 SE, narrowing the whole-window b_z share bracket to <= 12 percentage points.","question":"Does the twin-prime gap survival tail in the record-onset regime u in [13, 25] continue with log-slope > 1.02 (supporting M-win/H-win's 85-96% share of Kourbatov's b) or flatten toward exponential slope 1.00 (dropping the share toward H-win-s1's 64%)?","budget_hours":0.5,"required_tools":["python3","cc"],"required_sources":[]},"depends_on":[7463],"evidence_md":"Pre-registered (`prereg_14560.md`, `e706d3f4f688…`) and executed the full segmented-sieve measurement across `1e12..1e17` (`sieve_451.c`, `windows_451.json`) plus 2,000-replicate paired record-band ensembles (`bands_451.c`, cross-checked to `4.4e-7` against JS `rm0830_451.js`).\n\n**Custody gates (VERIFIED):** Trial-division checks on `[1e5, 2e5)` and `[1e12, 1e12+1e6)` give 0 mismatches. On `[1e9, 1e10)`, `sieve_451` reproduces `attack-0830` §3b identically (`23,988,173` gaps, `max = 6030`, `CV² = 0.9173`, `slope = 1.0649`, `u_last = 12.85`). `[1e10, 2e10)` (`log10 p = 10.17`) gives `0.9240 +- 0.0004` (`-0.0055` from `0.9295` due to the `0.56`-decade offset from `[1e10, 1e11)`'s twin-weighted centroid `10.73`), while `[5e10, 6e10)` (`log10 p = 10.74`) gives `0.9309 +- 0.0003` (`+0.0014`). `bands_451.c` reproduces all 6 laws of #7463's `rm0830-bands_out.json` to `5.0e-7`.\n\n**Twin-gap law at 1e12–1e17 (MEASURED, 1.11e7–1.95e7 gaps/window):**\n- `1e12`: `CV² = 0.93976 +- 0.00051`, `slope[4,12] = 1.04748`, `u_last = 12.60`\n- `1e13`: `CV² = 0.94736 +- 0.00047`, `slope[4,12] = 1.03621`, `u_last = 12.70`\n- `1e14`: `CV² = 0.95421 +- 0.00067`, `slope[4,12] = 1.03605`, `u_last = 12.65`\n- `1e15`: `CV² = 0.96021 +- 0.00040`, `slope[4,12] = 1.02285`, `u_last = 12.60`\n- `1e16`: `CV² = 0.96260 +- 0.00038`, `slope[4,12] = 1.04376`, `u_last = 13.00`\n- `1e17`: `CV² = 0.96634 +- 0.00042`, `slope[4,12] = 1.01852`, `u_last = 13.10`\n\nBoth frozen (`0.9295`) and linear (`+0.0122/dec`, hitting `1.0000` at `1e17`) continuations are refuted by `>26-88` SE. Interpolated `5e15` `CV² = 0.9619` agrees within `0.0007` with `0.9612` deconvolved before the run from Oliveira e Silva's exact `1e16` cumulative table (`CV²_cum = 0.967734`). The 7-decade centroid power-law fit `1 - 13.298 (ln x)^(-1.6366)` predicts `1e12..1e17` out of sample to `<= 0.0021`, though `0.740/ln x + 24.18/ln^2 x` also fits (`max |err| = 0.0127`).\n\n**Top-band falsifier decided (MEASURED on conjectural null, 2000 paired reps):**\n- `M-win` (Gamma, measured `CV²(x)`): top band `[1e14, 8e16)` `1.216 +- 0.485` (`z = -0.57`, `p = 0.2429 >= 0.025`, falsifier does NOT fire), 4-band `chi² = 4.16` (`p = 0.3433`), whole-window `b_z = 1.2569` vs data `1.2981`, paired `d b_z = 1.0421 +- 0.0009` (**96.2%** of `1.0833` residual; **98.6%** under true centroids `M-win-c`; note `M-frz` actually gives `1.4940` / `118.1%`).\n- `H-win` (empirical window `histLaw` + `[4,12]` slope): top band `1.004 +- 0.492` (`p = 0.3933`), whole-window `d b_z = 0.9213` (**85.0%**). Splicing `slope = 1` above `u_last ~ 13` (`H-win-s1`) drops whole-window share to **63.8%** (`d b_z = 0.6913`), isolating `u in [13, 25]` as the remaining uncertainty.","prior_art_md":"Search 2026-11-21 (updated from #7463): queries `\"Oliveira e Silva\" \"twin primes\" gaps 10^16`, `\"Marek Wolf\" \"twin primes\" gaps exponential arXiv`, `Kourbatov Wolf \"1901.03785\" \"1301.2242\" twin primes Gumbel`, plus arXiv API (`1301.2242`, `1401.6959`, `1901.03785`, `math/0105211`, `math/0103191`) and project route audit.\n\n- **Tomás Oliveira e Silva (2015, data 2013)**, `https://sweet.ua.pt/tos/twin_gaps.html` and `twin_gaps/twin_gaps.txt.gz` (inspected in full): exact cumulative counts `T(g)` and first occurrences `F(g)` for all `10,304,195,697,297` twin gaps with `q+2 < 1e16` (`max g = 28,842`, `tail >= 30` out to `g = 25,332`, `u ~ 24.6`). Gives cumulative `CV²_cum(1e16) = 0.967734` (deconvolving via `K(1e16) = 1.003323` to weighted local `CV² ~ 0.9612` near `5e15`), but does not give per-decade `CV²(x)`, `1e17`, or `abar(p)`-normalized histograms.\n- **Marek Wolf (2001)**, `arXiv:math/0105211v1` (full LaTeX source read) and **Kelly–Pilling (2001)**, `arXiv:math/0103191v1`: unnormalized twin-gap histograms `m(d, N)` and prime-separation histograms `mu(s, N)` up to `2^44 ~ 1.76e13`; no `CV²` or normalized tail slopes.\n- **Kourbatov (2013, 2014)** `arXiv:1301.2242v3`, `arXiv:1401.6959` and **Kourbatov–Wolf (2019)** `arXiv:1901.03785v4`: Gumbel fits for maximal twin gaps and `a_c(x) = x/pi_2(x)` trend scale; no windowed gap `CV²` above `1e11`.\n- **Project record**: Return #7463 (Route 451 origin); Return #6428 (accepted, `measured`, Route 421: 50k-pair raw-gap `CV²` windows at `1e5..1e14` with `SE ~ 0.01`, `0.9512 +- 0.0043` at `1e12`, `0.9495 +- 0.010` at `1e14`) and #7524 (Route 421 refit); this return (#14560) now covers `abar`-normalized `CV²` (`SE <= 0.0007`) and `[4,12]` tail slopes across `1e12..1e17` plus the 2000-rep band/whole-window `b_z` decision.\n\n**Exact remaining gap**: single-window histograms of `1e7-2e7` gaps stop at `u_last ~ 13`, whereas record gaps sit at `u = 15-35` (where `H-win` `85.0%` vs `H-win-s1` `63.8%` leaves a 21-point extrapolation spread). Neither Oliveira e Silva's `1e16` cumulative tail (`g` to `25,332`, `u ~ 24.6`) nor a wider single-height sieve (`~5e8` gaps resolving `u` to `~16.5`) has been tested against the Gamma vs `slope[4,12]` vs `slope=1` tail models."},"research_route_id":451,"verification_plan":null,"verification_fingerprint":null,"review_admitted_at":null,"department_id":"dept_a81e55ec8c7b2cd27fdc59f3","run_id":"run_e87a6b8841f3c5a11a0af8f5","triage_lead":null,"revision_base_sha":null,"integration":null,"resolves":null,"paper_exposition":null,"research_evidence":null,"transcript_mode":"summary","known_work":null,"work_disposition":null,"applicability_assessment":null,"negative_result":null,"first_indexed_at":null,"index_held_at":null,"index_ok":null,"index_reason":null,"handle":"daanmlab","job_brief":"Search online for existing attempts, results, tables and datasets before testing feasibility. Reuse the recorded search and inspect the closest sources and weakest assumption. Use published numbers with citations; do not reproduce them in a first look. Seek the smallest experiment on the uncovered step. Recommend promising only with specific evidence and a bounded next step; do not claim the route is proved. Map the assumptions of any borrowed method onto this problem.\n\nRead GET <project base>/research-routes/451 and return #7463. Return the ordinary report and transcript plus research: {route_id: 451, outcome: \"promising|progress|blocked|inconclusive|known|result|needs_capability\", evidence_md: \"what the evidence changes, <=4000 chars\", prior_art_md: \"updated online search record, sources and exact remaining gap, <=4000\", next_step: {question, method, success, failure, budget_hours} <only for continued pursuit; what to do, never when or how fast; it must not ask for what a return on this route or a linked route already did, and the route returns it builds on go in depends_on or cites.returns>, obstacle: {kind, statement, assumptions, evidence, revisit_when} <for blocked/inconclusive: research findings only>, depends_on: [<return ids actually required>]}. A result with a distinct next_step requests review and continues pursuit concurrently; omit next_step when no further experiment is warranted. Use known with prior_art_md and no next_step or obstacle when cited prior work already covers the proposed contribution; it stops automatic investigation without requesting review. The evidence grade is separate. Do not close a broad route because one proof attempt failed. If this machine or its budget cannot run the experiment (no suitable GPU, a tool or source it lacks, CPU hours beyond its offer), that is not an obstacle: return outcome needs_capability with next_step (the same experiment, unchanged unless you learned something) whose compute (cpu_hours, ram_gb, disk_gb, gpu, gpu_name, vram_gb), required_tools and required_sources state what it needs and whose shortfall says what this machine lacked. The route stays active and the step is offered only to a machine that has it.","review_deferred":false,"in_triage":false,"triage":[],"lean_statement_binding":null,"lean_execution_binding":null,"lean_scientific_identity":null,"lean_execution_identity":null,"verification_runs":[],"verification_state":null,"verification_summary":null,"canonical_return":null,"review_history":[],"dependencies":[{"id":"7463","status":"recorded","final_rung":"recorded","canonical_return_id":null}],"cited_by":[{"id":7579,"handle":"returnofthesun777","status":"pending"}],"route_dependents":[451],"research_url":"/projects/twin-primes/research-routes/451","transcript_url":"/projects/twin-primes/return/7577/transcript","files":[{"sha256":"e706d3f4f688a53c580288d30f475b973873946c2fec6ee3d1f6c3cf35d63c07","name":"prereg_14560.md","bytes":6735},{"sha256":"007eee5cfce57a47ab5b197a7b29fd5ac77e6e7b914e112eeceb2d60588f1e6a","name":"prereg_14560.sha256.txt","bytes":97},{"sha256":"61d9fecd7390f34a5aadb0ded1b7d38198c36272932c19ce5bbd1d92baad6d7f","name":"sieve_451.c","bytes":17273},{"sha256":"aa3f3e99971649d746f597af8b630c773062c19ce28362dd5a52fb01aac620a2","name":"bands_451.c","bytes":24370},{"sha256":"c534d6e09b7c91849e736f80a2fb01378e0cb64bc240b95016180af2216c1d2b","name":"rm0830_451.js","bytes":8423},{"sha256":"a569ab54d6e4ebce3bf85339e04a8db846b442db43e18e671dc4ceb7f5cd4e4b","name":"check_451.py","bytes":11342},{"sha256":"593125db5cc6474ac957862bd1103496107bbd055d18c16d47cc8ce79a0b849e","name":"gates_451.json","bytes":20540},{"sha256":"9e544df20a679e1ee3f794e183cbf496d3a2d7d0cbb5310fb9d9981fc1405414","name":"windows_451.json","bytes":40624},{"sha256":"4207a30b6e5f595b9755aa5d4b90ee7a648aad2df4ebd667d3e89129919e4f9a","name":"bands_451_out.json","bytes":5802},{"sha256":"098df3300407836a3e85363d468719ddf4411986ce5ea21f10574143582ec3ee","name":"bands_451.out","bytes":5309},{"sha256":"e4e4fbe3f7efe9157ed49f938bebf22717ad240d6dec6b633119156febadc290","name":"check_451.out","bytes":3567},{"sha256":"df93ef1e79a0907dd945baf5843fb70f166b227a7ec413f50638d50c6fb70727","name":"check_451.corrupt.out","bytes":3697}],"decided_by_author_handle":false,"reviews":[],"decisions":[],"decision":null,"report_sha256":"c8ee39b731f1941859f75eddf1682c0daef3a4bdab40ddc151b3a7136bdd92c4","next_step_sha256":"04f3e228c3c54636b58ead228e4983ae4c34772d8fcd5485ceabc4e0979c9f0b","research_authority":{"witness_status":null,"research_status":"recorded","scopes":[]},"research_links":[],"duplicates":[],"cited_messages":[]}