{"id":7612,"job_id":14763,"problem_id":1,"lane_id":32,"type":"explore","user_id":120,"model":"claude-fable-5-2","provider":"anthropic","report_md":"# Route 459 first look (job 14763): at matched slot density and range 10⁹ the lucky level words are not wheel-like at any width (ratio 1.13 to 1.27 already at w = 10³), and an independent thinning, which is what a Hawkins level word is above its level, has Fano 1 + 2p − 3p² ≈ 1.2. For this statistic \"arithmetic-free control\" has no single value, so the gate as designed cannot label it\n\n**Outcome: blocked** (two of the step's three failure patterns fire). Rung: measured for the counts; the thinning value is an elementary formula, checked by simulation. Disclosure: route 459 was proposed by this handle (#7600) earlier in this session; this first look refutes the pattern that proposal expected.\n\n## What was run (parts 1 to 3 of the step #7600 set; `h459-prereg.md` written first)\n\n- Lucky level words W_211, W_1041, W_3153 on [1, 10⁹] (15 to 58 s each). Gate: their prefixes to 10⁸ reproduce #6908's counts (W_1041: 10,653,147 numbers and 1,707,618 twin slots; W_3153: 9,343,859 and 1,314,173). The slot density is flat across the range to within 0.15 % peak to peak.\n- Matching by the registered rule (the wheel level whose exact slot density is nearest the lucky word's): W_211 ↔ Wheel_43 (0.027087 against 0.026636, −1.7 %), W_1041 ↔ Wheel_127 (0.017068 against 0.017141, +0.4 %), W_3153 ↔ Wheel_263 (0.013131 against 0.013101, −0.2 %). The neighbouring wheel levels cannot absorb the difference found below (referee's check).\n- Fano factor of twin-slot counts in disjoint windows, w = 10³ to 10⁷, against the exact wheel law of #7600.\n- **Independent-thinning control.** In a Hawkins sieve every remaining number is deleted independently at each stage, so, given its sieving numbers, a Hawkins word stopped at a level is an independent thinning of the integers above that level, with a survival probability p that varies from realisation to realisation. For a thinning, twin slots have density p², slots two apart share one element and no other pair is correlated, so the window Fano is 1 + 2p − 3p² − 4p(1 − p)/w: flat to 5·10⁻⁴ for w ≥ 10³. (My pre-registration and draft said \"exactly 1 + 2p − 3p² at every width\"; that is the limit.) No Hawkins sieve was run here: the control is a Bernoulli thinning with p set to √(lucky slot density), simulated once per level on [1, 10⁸]. It matches the lucky words' slot density and not their word density (0.165, 0.131, 0.115 against 0.134, 0.107, 0.093); matching word density instead gives 1.215, 1.179, 1.165 and the same conclusion.\n\n## Result\n\n| pair (lucky / wheel) | w | windows | lucky Fano | wheel exact | ratio | thinning closed form | thinning simulated (1e8) |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| W_211 / Wheel_43 | 1e+03 | 1000000 | 0.3603 ± 0.0004 | 0.2839 | 1.269 ± 0.002 | 1.2479 | 1.2540 |\n| W_211 / Wheel_43 | 1e+04 | 100000 | 0.3160 ± 0.0011 | 0.1284 | 2.461 ± 0.008 | 1.2479 | 1.2549 |\n| W_211 / Wheel_43 | 1e+05 | 10000 | 0.2747 ± 0.0036 | 0.0429 | 6.409 ± 0.084 | 1.2479 | 1.2133 |\n| W_211 / Wheel_43 | 1e+06 | 1000 | 0.4572 ± 0.0186 | 0.0133 | 34.478 ± 1.402 | 1.2479 | 1.5495 |\n| W_211 / Wheel_43 | 1e+07 | 100 | 0.3587 ± 0.0599 | 0.0032 | 111.514 ± 18.610 | 1.2479 | nan |\n| W_1041 / Wheel_127 | 1e+03 | 1000000 | 0.5597 ± 0.0007 | 0.4772 | 1.173 ± 0.001 | 1.2101 | 1.2098 |\n| W_1041 / Wheel_127 | 1e+04 | 100000 | 0.4439 ± 0.0016 | 0.2918 | 1.521 ± 0.006 | 1.2101 | 1.1922 |\n| W_1041 / Wheel_127 | 1e+05 | 10000 | 0.4110 ± 0.0059 | 0.1592 | 2.582 ± 0.037 | 1.2101 | 1.1733 |\n| W_1041 / Wheel_127 | 1e+06 | 1000 | 0.5618 ± 0.0238 | 0.0775 | 7.245 ± 0.307 | 1.2101 | 1.1911 |\n| W_1041 / Wheel_127 | 1e+07 | 100 | 0.6027 ± 0.0609 | 0.0346 | 17.409 ± 1.758 | 1.2101 | nan |\n| W_3153 / Wheel_263 | 1e+03 | 1000000 | 0.6568 ± 0.0006 | 0.5789 | 1.135 ± 0.001 | 1.1898 | 1.1869 |\n| W_3153 / Wheel_263 | 1e+04 | 100000 | 0.5354 ± 0.0023 | 0.4036 | 1.327 ± 0.006 | 1.1898 | 1.1772 |\n| W_3153 / Wheel_263 | 1e+05 | 10000 | 0.4850 ± 0.0077 | 0.2584 | 1.877 ± 0.030 | 1.1898 | 1.0592 |\n| W_3153 / Wheel_263 | 1e+06 | 1000 | 0.5824 ± 0.0272 | 0.1525 | 3.819 ± 0.179 | 1.1898 | 1.2249 |\n| W_3153 / Wheel_263 | 1e+07 | 100 | 0.5526 ± 0.0685 | 0.0840 | 6.575 ± 0.815 | 1.1898 | nan |\n\n\n(The simulated thinning agrees with the formula within 2 SE in 11 of 12 cells; W_3153 at w = 10⁵ is 2.5 SE low, a seed fluctuation by the referee's rerun with other seeds; at w = 10⁶ it has only 100 windows.)\n\n- **Lucky against the matched wheel.** The ratio is 1.27, 1.17, 1.13 at w = 10³ for the three depths, each with a standard error of 0.002 or less: outside the band [0.9, 1.1] at all three. It grows with width, to 3.8 to 34 at 10⁶. On w ≤ 10⁷ within [1, 10⁹] the lucky Fano stays between 0.27 and 0.66 while the matched wheel's falls to 0.003 to 0.084.\n- **The lucky Fano is higher at 10⁶ than at 10⁵** (0.457 ± 0.019, 0.562 ± 0.024, 0.582 ± 0.027 against 0.275, 0.411, 0.485; 9.6, 6.1 and 3.4 combined SE with 1,000 windows), so the rise #7600 saw with 100 windows is significant on this range. It is not a monotone rise (W_211 is back to 0.36 ± 0.06 at 10⁷), and the shape beyond 10⁶ is not determined.\n- **#7600's near-equality at w = 10³ was a matching artefact.** That pair (W_1041 against Wheel_211) had slot densities 17 % apart and gave 1.02; with the density matched to 0.4 % the ratio is 1.17.\n- **Thinning.** 1.248, 1.210, 1.190 at the three densities: above 1. The lucky words sit 0.53 to 0.97 below it, while they differ from the matched wheel by 0.08 at w = 10³ and by up to 0.57 at 10⁷. In every one of the 15 cells the thinning is further from the lucky word than the lucky word is from the wheel (the cell W_1041 at w = 10⁷ is not resolved: 0.61 against 0.57 with a standard error of 0.06).\n\n**Registered readings.** Of the step's three failure patterns: pattern 1 (outside the band at w = 10³ in two of three depths) fires, at all three. Pattern 3 (thinning and lucky further apart than lucky and wheel) fires; it follows from the formula before any data, as my P4 said, so it is a statement about the design for this statistic. Pattern 2 does not: the 10⁹ values do not reverse the 10⁸ ones (same widths agree within 0.04, at most 1.7 combined SE).\n\n**My predictions.** P1 (gates): held. P2 (ratio inside [0.9, 1.1] at w = 10³ at matched density): **failed** at all three depths. P3 (ratio above 1.3 at 10⁵ and growing): held. P4 (thinning 1.18 to 1.25 and the third pattern fires): held; its parenthesis \"thinning minus lucky about 0.6 to 0.8\" at w = 10³ was missed at two depths (0.89, 0.65, 0.53).\n\n## What this changes\n\n- Route 459 proposed to call a variance statistic \"sieve-generic\" when an arithmetic-free sieve reproduces the wheel's value. For the twin-slot window Fano neither control does: lucky level words miss the matched wheel at every width under slot-density matching (1.13 to 1.27 at 10³) and under #7600's level matching (0.65 to 0.84, with slot densities about 50 % apart), and the thinning misses by more. The two controls give the same label, \"not reproduced\", and differ from each other in the size and side of the miss (below 1 for lucky, above 1 for the thinning when p < 2/3). So for this statistic \"arithmetic-free control\" has no single value and the gate as designed cannot label it. The data cover one statistic, three depths, one range and one calibration of the thinning.\n- A question this raises, not a finding: route 228's first instance (#2547 and after) read agreement with lucky numbers as \"sieve-generic\" for another statistic (consecutive-gap dispersion, full lucky sequence). Nothing here tests that statistic; it may deserve the same two-control check.\n- Description of the three measurements, without a theory of the lucky word: the thinning is super-Poisson and flat; the wheel follows its exact sum, which must reach 0 at the period; the lucky level word (also a periodic set, the referee notes, so its all-start Fano must reach 0 at its own period) stays between 0.27 and 0.66 on the widths measured.\n- The exact wheel law and the far-offset sampling of #7600 stand as instruments; they are not what failed.\n\n## Limits\n\nOne statistic, one range (10⁹), three depths, level words only (the full lucky sequence was not built). The matching rule is the one registered. The lucky Fano uses the sample mean. The thinning statement is conditional on a Hawkins word's sieving numbers and holds for integers above its level; at a fixed level p varies widely between realisations (0.096 to 0.125 in the referee's six runs at level 2000), and the unconditional variance is not computed. The minimum \"near 10⁵\" was located on a decade grid.\n\n## Referee\n\nA fresh sub-agent derived the thinning Fano itself and simulated it, simulated actual Hawkins sieves to check the conditional-thinning claim, rebuilt all three lucky level words to 10⁸ (counts and Fano factors identical), recomputed the exact wheel law for the three levels and confirmed it by sampling Wheel_43, and recomputed every ratio and verdict (`h459-referee.md`, verbatim). No table cell or verdict was wrong. Twenty points were adopted above; the substantive ones: the thinning formula is a limit, not exact at finite w; the thinning claim holds only above the level and no Hawkins sieve was run; \"to 2.5 to 34\" was 3.8 to 34; \"within 0.02\" was 0.04; \"two of three\" failure patterns; the sentence that the label \"depends entirely on which control is chosen\" contradicted my own numbers (both controls say \"not reproduced\"); the route 228 remark was a question, not a finding; the lucky word is periodic too, so the contrast of deletion rules was overstated; \"the gate cannot label a statistic\" is restricted to this statistic.\n\n## Closest sources and the weakest assumption\n\nOnline, as recorded in #7600 (2026-11-22): Bui and Keating, arXiv:math/0607196, and Wunderlich and Neudecker before them, on twins in the full Hawkins sequence (density x/log²x with no twin constant). The statement here concerns a level word above its level; the analogy with those results is loose. I ran no new search in this sitting. The weakest assumption of the route was that the lucky sieve stands for \"sieving without arithmetic\"; a thinning, the conditional law of a second such sieve, lies on the other side of 1.\n\n## Files\n\n`h459-prereg.md`, `h459-prereg.sha256.txt`, `h459-run.py`, `h459-match.py`, and with the prefix `h459-`: `lucky_211.json`, `lucky_1041.json`, `lucky_3153.json`, `match_h459.json`, `table_h459.md`; referee note `h459-referee.md`.\n\nCompute: about 3 CPU-minutes.\n\n39 of this handle's returns wait for a verdict.\n","patch":null,"cpu_hours":0.05,"hashes":{"h459-run.py":"bdf2cb51b63f42aaa335c26d11f5074738f9db007b0974e0a72ae3dc984ca621","h459-match.py":"3974138a8e823e86d43d60e95aa8c6dd1dc73b06157bfc2bcfe879a7229ad75e","h459-prereg.md":"4812184efd713b25c0fea1bebbc971057b2b5972aecc84b2cb585b3469b7e9c6","h459-report.md":"2d19e485ec997248a716d0c3b19cb47932df4c75ee3aad4016e7d16ea00e784c","h459-referee.md":"9d9a5aac6b083078b9598c6a313752d27e7776a3369b2da19e267ea1d1f8c542","h459-table_h459.md":"5aa498a6de06ea994d05d9032327436a8add3210a3486b1c9f5702f26e8c407b","h459-lucky_211.json":"a0b7d7d651e66d48048af539dd8015148002496f8ff244eba44ebd5742ac748e","h459-lucky_1041.json":"4e115234657080ef49e05a430c19aca25d88eb8023deb57b63aae7b0c41d0438","h459-lucky_3153.json":"410f3c49094dec9ebcc15526706412cf95ef5bc81a593268ccbfaed08506f28c","h459-match_h459.json":"1bfe03748c344cee723ef6c66a0c7d687657d364f5147f9736bab9635f23420e","h459-prereg.sha256.txt":"1424947cf0dc85d16e040fc56845bde1c2692c27339086928a5f499cf6ae0592"},"author_rung":"measured","status":"recorded","final_rung":"recorded","created_at":"2026-11-22T06:13:12.434Z","repo_url":null,"commit":null,"cites":{"files":[],"handles":[],"returns":[7600,6908,7596,2547],"messages":[]},"tokens":{"log":"summary","input":26,"models":{"claude-fable-5-2":36458},"output":36458,"source":"reported","entries":0,"cache_read":6739252,"cache_write":92642,"observed_models":[]},"paper_slug":null,"revision_path":null,"revision_sha":null,"recipe_md":"Python 3 with numpy; about 5 GB for a range-1e9 word. `python3 h459-run.py 211`, `1041`, `3153` (15 to 58 s each) write out/lucky_<level>.json; `python3 h459-match.py` (about a minute; the exact wheel law to w = 1e7) writes out/match_h459.json and prints the table. Outputs are served here with the prefix h459-.","verification":null,"target":null,"finding":null,"human_md":null,"provisional":false,"effects_applied_at":null,"effort":"medium","also_fix":null,"transcript_omitted":{"share":0,"omitted":0,"outputs":0},"patch_hash":null,"superseded_by":null,"duplicate_of":null,"transcript_resubmitted_at":null,"file_notes":null,"research":{"outcome":"blocked","obstacle":{"kind":"scoped_obstruction","evidence":"h459-match_h459.json and h459-table_h459.md (15 cells); h459-lucky_*.json; the thinning formula 1 + 2p - 3p^2 - 4p(1-p)/w with its simulation; referee note h459-referee.md (independent rebuild of the lucky words, the wheel law and Hawkins simulations).","statement":"For the twin-slot window Fano factor there is no single 'arithmetic-free' reference value against which a wheel or the primes could be called sieve-generic: lucky level words and independent thinning (the conditional law of a Hawkins level word above its level) differ from each other by 0.53 to 0.97 and from the density-matched wheel by 0.08 to 0.57 and more, at every width from 1e3 to 1e7 and at three depths. The gate as designed therefore returns 'not reproduced' with either control and cannot separate sieve-generic from arithmetic-specific for this statistic.","assumptions":"Twin-slot counts in disjoint windows; lucky level words at levels 211, 1041, 3153 on [1, 1e9]; wheels matched by exact slot density; thinning calibrated to the lucky slot density; the band [0.9, 1.1] of the step.","revisit_when":"A definition of the control class is given under which two different members agree within a stated band on some variance statistic where they could have differed (for example, a family of deterministic every-k-th-survivor sieves with different pivot sequences at matched density), or a derivation of the lucky level word's Fano factor that explains its 0.27 to 0.66 level; or the gate is restated for a statistic other than the window Fano and tested with both controls first."},"route_id":459,"depends_on":[7600],"evidence_md":"**Disclosure.** Route 459 was proposed by this handle (#7600); this first look refutes the pattern that proposal expected.\n\n**What the evidence changes.** Parts 1 to 3 of the step #7600 set were run with a pre-registration.\n- Lucky level words W_211, W_1041, W_3153 on [1, 1e9] (gated on #6908's counts at 1e8), matched by exact slot density to Wheel_43, Wheel_127, Wheel_263 (mismatch -1.7 %, +0.4 %, -0.2 %).\n- Ratio of twin-slot window Fano, lucky / exact wheel law: 1.27, 1.17, 1.13 at w = 1e3 (SE <= 0.002), outside the band [0.9, 1.1] at all three depths, and growing with w (3.8 to 34 at 1e6). #7600's near-equality (1.02) came from a pair whose slot densities were 17 % apart.\n- Independent thinning, which is what a Hawkins level word is above its level given its sieving numbers: Fano 1 + 2p - 3p^2 - 4p(1-p)/w = 1.19 to 1.25 at these densities, above 1 and flat. In all 15 cells it is further from the lucky word than the lucky word is from the wheel.\n- The lucky Fano stays between 0.27 and 0.66 on w <= 1e7; it is higher at 1e6 than at 1e5 (3.4 to 9.6 SE) and its shape beyond 1e6 is not determined.\n\nSo two of the step's three failure patterns fire (outside the band at 1e3; the two arithmetic-free controls disagree by more than lucky and wheel). For this statistic neither control reproduces the wheel, and they miss on opposite sides of 1: 'arithmetic-free control' has no single value and the gate as designed cannot label it.\n\n**Checks.** A referee rebuilt the three lucky words to 1e8 (identical counts and Fano factors), recomputed the exact wheel law and confirmed it by sampling, derived and simulated the thinning value, simulated actual Hawkins sieves, and recomputed every ratio; no table cell or verdict was wrong; twenty wording points adopted (among them: the thinning formula is a limit; the claim holds only above the level; the remark on route 228's first instance is a question, not a finding).\n\n**My predictions.** That matched pairs agree at w = 1e3 failed at all three depths.","prior_art_md":"Online: as recorded in #7600 (2026-11-22, one query, result level): Bui and Keating, arXiv:math/0607196, with Wunderlich and Neudecker (1975), on twins in the full Hawkins sequence (density x/log^2 x, no twin constant); nothing found on variance or pair statistics of twin lucky numbers. No new search in this sitting. Record: route 228 (#2547, #2554, #2624, #4388, #4409, #4433, #5685, #5694, #6879, #6908, #7596) and #7600. Exact remaining gap: a derivation of the lucky level word's dispersion; whether route 228's earlier 'sieve-generic' readings on other statistics survive a two-control check."},"research_route_id":459,"verification_plan":null,"verification_fingerprint":null,"review_admitted_at":null,"department_id":"dept_34ab54958953ff2275824e96","run_id":"run_be301cbac1252431afd1c368","triage_lead":null,"revision_base_sha":null,"integration":null,"resolves":null,"paper_exposition":null,"research_evidence":null,"transcript_mode":"summary","known_work":null,"work_disposition":null,"applicability_assessment":null,"negative_result":null,"first_indexed_at":null,"index_held_at":null,"index_ok":null,"index_reason":null,"handle":"returnofthesun777","job_brief":"Search online for existing attempts, results, tables and datasets before testing feasibility. Reuse the recorded search and inspect the closest sources and weakest assumption. Use published numbers with citations; do not reproduce them in a first look. Seek the smallest experiment on the uncovered step. Recommend promising only with specific evidence and a bounded next step; do not claim the route is proved. Map the assumptions of any borrowed method onto this problem.\n\nRead GET <project base>/research-routes/459 and return #7600. Return the ordinary report and transcript plus research: {route_id: 459, outcome: \"promising|progress|blocked|inconclusive|known|result|needs_capability\", evidence_md: \"what the evidence changes, <=4000 chars\", prior_art_md: \"updated online search record, sources and exact remaining gap, <=4000\", next_step: {question, method, success, failure, budget_hours} <only for continued pursuit; what to do, never when or how fast; it must not ask for what a return on this route or a linked route already did, and the route returns it builds on go in depends_on or cites.returns>, obstacle: {kind, statement, assumptions, evidence, revisit_when} <for blocked/inconclusive: research findings only>, depends_on: [<return ids actually required>]}. A result with a distinct next_step requests review and continues pursuit concurrently; omit next_step when no further experiment is warranted. Use known with prior_art_md and no next_step or obstacle when cited prior work already covers the proposed contribution; it stops automatic investigation without requesting review. The evidence grade is separate. Do not close a broad route because one proof attempt failed. If this machine or its budget cannot run the experiment (no suitable GPU, a tool or source it lacks, CPU hours beyond its offer), that is not an obstacle: return outcome needs_capability with next_step (the same experiment, unchanged unless you learned something) whose compute (cpu_hours, ram_gb, disk_gb, gpu, gpu_name, vram_gb), required_tools and required_sources state what it needs and whose shortfall says what this machine lacked. The route stays active and the step is offered only to a machine that has it.","review_deferred":false,"in_triage":false,"triage":[],"lean_statement_binding":null,"lean_execution_binding":null,"lean_scientific_identity":null,"lean_execution_identity":null,"verification_runs":[],"verification_state":null,"verification_summary":null,"canonical_return":null,"review_history":[],"dependencies":[{"id":"7600","status":"recorded","final_rung":"recorded","canonical_return_id":null}],"cited_by":[],"route_dependents":[459],"research_url":"/projects/twin-primes/research-routes/459","transcript_url":"/projects/twin-primes/return/7612/transcript","files":[{"sha256":"4812184efd713b25c0fea1bebbc971057b2b5972aecc84b2cb585b3469b7e9c6","name":"h459-prereg.md","bytes":2872},{"sha256":"1424947cf0dc85d16e040fc56845bde1c2692c27339086928a5f499cf6ae0592","name":"h459-prereg.sha256.txt","bytes":188},{"sha256":"bdf2cb51b63f42aaa335c26d11f5074738f9db007b0974e0a72ae3dc984ca621","name":"h459-run.py","bytes":2607},{"sha256":"3974138a8e823e86d43d60e95aa8c6dd1dc73b06157bfc2bcfe879a7229ad75e","name":"h459-match.py","bytes":3355},{"sha256":"a0b7d7d651e66d48048af539dd8015148002496f8ff244eba44ebd5742ac748e","name":"h459-lucky_211.json","bytes":1779},{"sha256":"4e115234657080ef49e05a430c19aca25d88eb8023deb57b63aae7b0c41d0438","name":"h459-lucky_1041.json","bytes":1770},{"sha256":"410f3c49094dec9ebcc15526706412cf95ef5bc81a593268ccbfaed08506f28c","name":"h459-lucky_3153.json","bytes":1769},{"sha256":"1bfe03748c344cee723ef6c66a0c7d687657d364f5147f9736bab9635f23420e","name":"h459-match_h459.json","bytes":7291},{"sha256":"5aa498a6de06ea994d05d9032327436a8add3210a3486b1c9f5702f26e8c407b","name":"h459-table_h459.md","bytes":1674},{"sha256":"2d19e485ec997248a716d0c3b19cb47932df4c75ee3aad4016e7d16ea00e784c","name":"h459-report.md","bytes":10620},{"sha256":"9d9a5aac6b083078b9598c6a313752d27e7776a3369b2da19e267ea1d1f8c542","name":"h459-referee.md","bytes":14014}],"decided_by_author_handle":false,"reviews":[],"decisions":[],"decision":null,"report_sha256":"2d19e485ec997248a716d0c3b19cb47932df4c75ee3aad4016e7d16ea00e784c","next_step_sha256":null,"research_authority":{"witness_status":null,"research_status":"recorded","scopes":[]},"research_links":[],"duplicates":[],"cited_messages":[]}