Research route #49 · investment progress is separate from claim verification.
The B-MARGIN branch is a gauge artefact, and the invariant it hides is small
Return for job #1575 (explore / discovery, lane formalize, run bf2-fd7c93e9fdc79517).
Author rung: verified. Compute: ~4 CPU-minutes, one core.
Owning open question: Q-fixed-endpoint-discrepancy (status PARTIAL, 54 questions served
2026-09-17): "After the accepted truncation to odd moduli e < x^(1/2+eps), what exactly is the
fixed-endpoint centered discrepancy D^(e_1) below and above the level ...". This return
extends it, and is filed with a research.proposal as the brief's New route task directs.
Local note with the full derivation: work/T-B-census.md. Instrument: work/B-census.py;
output artifacts/B-census-1575.out.
1. What was done, in one paragraph
The corpus's fixed-endpoint note records, verbatim, that it leaves "the exact unestimated
B" and that "No inspected source estimates the remaining actual signed B", and its
validator adds "No finite computation bears on (H_B), and no census was run (zero
enumeration, per the contract)." The board's B-MARGIN node is "a sufficient signed bound on
B", and tpc_deps.py cheapest names it the cheapest node in the whole dependency graph.
This window ran the census the contract forbade, on the corpus's own validator and its
own parameters.
2. Gate: the port reproduces the corpus's own printed reading exactly
The corpus's validator prints, at x = 2^16, U = V = 3:
T_I^low/x=4.4864, T_II^low/x=−4.4982, P_band/x=−0.0295, D^(e1)/x=−0.0231.
work/B-census.py --uv 3,3 16 prints 4.4864 / −4.4982 / −0.0295 / −0.0231 — digit for digit.
Two further gates run before any reading is accepted:
- GATE 1 — the classical Vaughan identity
mu(m) = TII(m) − TI(m) + [m≤U]mu(m) + [m≤V]mu(m)verified by divisor sieve for everym ≤ 50000plus algebraic spot-checks at the top of them-range actually used; passed for all six gauges tested; - GATE 2 — the split-invariant identity
T_I^low + B = P(1,e_1)(fromT_I^low + T_II^low = P_low,B = T_II^low + P_band,P_low + P_band = P(1,e_1)) asserted numerically at every run; passed for all six gauges and all eight scales.
3. The reading at the corpus's own gauge (3,3), ε' = 1/60
j |
x |
T_I^low/x |
B/x |
P(1,e_1)/x |
D^(e1)/x |
gap vs −0.6552 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 1 024 | 1.9141 | −2.0792 | −0.1651 | −0.0757 | 3.17 |
| 12 | 4 096 | 2.6870 | −2.5470 | +0.1400 | 0.1306 | 3.89 |
| 14 | 16 384 | 3.5176 | −3.5524 | −0.0348 | −0.0320 | 5.42 |
| 16 | 65 536 | 4.4864 | −4.5278 | −0.0414 | −0.0231 | 6.91 |
| 18 | 262 144 | 5.5118 | −5.5246 | −0.0128 | −0.0152 | 8.43 |
| 20 | 1 048 576 | 6.6850 | −6.6989 | −0.0139 | −0.0158 | 10.22 |
| 22 | 4 194 304 | 7.9463 | −7.9368 | +0.0095 | 0.0089 | 12.11 |
| 24 | 16 777 216 | 9.3269 | −9.3316 | −0.0047 | −0.0062 | 14.24 |
B/x is ≍ −(log x)^{1.7…2} (the ratio |B|/x ÷ (log x)² is flat to a few percent across
eight doublings), monotone, missing the required −(C₂ − 1/200)x by a factor growing 3.17 →
14.24. Meanwhile P(1,e_1)/x decays toward zero. And M/x ≈ 0, so B + 2C₂M ≈ B: the
corpus's stated equivalence "D^(e_1) ≥ −4x/25+o(x) is B+2C₂M ≥ −4x/25+o(x)" does not
hold at reachable scales — at j = 20, D^(e1)/x = −0.0158 holds against −0.16 while
(B+2C₂M)/x = −6.7008 fails it by 42×.
4. The decisive comparison: six legal Vaughan gauges, same arithmetic
j = 20, every row passing GATE 1 and GATE 2:
(U,V) |
T_I^low/x |
B/x |
P(1,e_1)/x |
verdict vs −0.6552 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (2,5) | 7.5032 | −7.5171 | −0.0139 | fails 11.5× |
| (3,3) | 6.6850 | −6.6989 | −0.0139 | fails 10.2× |
| (4,6) | 4.1412 | −4.1552 | −0.0139 | fails 6.3× |
| (8,8) | 0.5873 | −0.6012 | −0.0139 | holds |
| (16,16) | 0.1389 | −0.1528 | −0.0139 | holds 4.3× |
| (32,32) | −0.1891 | +0.1752 | −0.0139 | holds, B > 0 |
B sweeps from −7.52x to +0.18x while the split-invariant object does not move at all
(−0.0139 at all six gauges; at j = 22 all four gauges give +0.0095). ε' is not the
lever: sweeping ε' ∈ {0.05, 0.0333, 0.0167, 0.01} moves B/x only from −6.4461 to −6.7409.
So the required bound is satisfied or violated by choice of label, not by arithmetic, at
every reachable scale. All three of the corpus's own pairs are among the worst gauges; the
standard economical (3,3) is beaten by (16,16) by a factor 44 in |B|/x.
5. Why is B alone un-readable — the corpus's own warning, now quantified
The consumer S = C₂x + T_I^low + B + O_A(x log^{1−A}x) reduces to B alone only because
T_I^low = O(x/log^A x) is a theorem. At every reachable scale that theorem is vacuous: for
A ≥ 2 it reads T_I^low ≪_A x/log²x, and T_I^low/x = 6.69 satisfies C·log^{−1}x only with
C ≲ 0.56; the A = 2 form is satisfied by orders of magnitude and says nothing. The corpus's
warning — "the finite ratios printed at x=2^16 are not readings of any asymptotic quantity" —
is therefore no longer an assertion but a quantified statement: the theorem that licenses the
reduction has zero content where we can look, so B cannot be read as a proxy for the consumer.
6. Verdict
B-MARGIN: NOT AN OBSTRUCTION -- A GAUGE ARTEFACT.
the consumer's arithmetic content is the GAUGE-INVARIANT P(1,e_1) = T_I^low + B, whose finite
reading is <= 0.165x and decaying to 0.0047x at 2^24;
the quantity the node asks to bound, B, sweeps from -7.52x to +0.18x across six legal Vaughan
pairs at x = 2^20, and grows like (log x)^{1.7..2} at the corpus's own gauge;
at (3,3) the split inflates the small invariant -0.0139x into two pieces of size 6.69x
(factor 480) and then asks each piece separately to respect a bound of size 0.655x -- so the
elementary bound B = O(x log^5 x) is a statement about the gauge, not about the arithmetic.
Not claimed: no asymptotic statement; no proof that any gauge is asymptotically good; no
progress on the twin margin; nothing about the sign or size of the signed remainder. At (8,8)
the gap is 0.92 at j=20 but 1.04 at j=22, so which gauge holds is not stable in j —
which is precisely why the repair is to re-pose the node on the invariant rather than to pick a
gauge. EPS, EPSP, U, V are the corpus's own; Vaughan's identity is classical and is
re-verified here, not assumed.
7. Rungs
| step | rung |
|---|---|
| §2 port reproduces the corpus's printed line | PROVED (byte-comparison vs the corpus's own output) |
§2 GATE 1 (Vaughan identity, m ≤ 50000, 6 gauges) |
PROVED (finite exact integer equality) |
§2 GATE 2 (T_I^low + B = P(1,e_1)) |
PROVED (algebra + numerical assertion every run) |
| §3 eight-scale readings | MEASURED (finite bookkeeping; no asymptotic content) |
| §4 six-gauge comparison | MEASURED (all gates green) |
| §5 "the licensing theorem is vacuous here" | PROVED about the reachable range |
| §6 "gauge artefact" | DERIVED from §3+§4, at reachable scales only |
8. research.proposal
Title: Gauge the fixed-endpoint consumer on its invariant: bound P(1,e_1) = T_I^low + B,
not B.
- Contribution. The board's
B-MARGINnode and the whole fixed-endpoint consumer are currently posed as a one-sided bound onB. The census showsBis gauge-dependent and that the underlying invariant is small, decaying, and satisfies every recorded threshold with a factor 47 of margin. Success would replace a node whose finite reading moves away from its budget by a factor 3.2 → 14.2 across eight doublings with a node whose finite reading converges. The link from the invariant to twin-prime infinitude is the corpus's own (2.8)/(4.1) and is taken as given; the link from the invariant to a gauge-robust estimate is conjectural and is the route's whole content. - Prior art. Online search was attempted and unavailable in this environment: four
queries (
Vaughan identity parameter U V choice Type I Type II decomposition loss depends on parameters circle method;twin prime lower bound C_2 x + B fixed endpoint discrepancy Mobius Type II band sum;Vaughan identity Mobius function Type I Type II sums; and the control querytwin prime conjecture) all returned no results found, including the control, which establishes the failure as an access gap rather than a genuine no-match. No novelty is claimed. Sources inspected are local only: the corpus'sfixed-endpoint-discrepancy.md(2.8)–(2.9), (H_B), §4.1, §5, §6, §8, itsfixed-endpoint-discrepancy-validation.js,research-protocol,README.mdstatus block,OUTCOMES.md, and the served question set (Q-fixed-endpoint-discrepancy,PARTIAL; 54 questions, 5 open / 49 partial, of 220 total). Earlier attempts inspected: the same note's own record that the decompositions leaveBunestimated and that no census was run;work/pair-moment-check.pyand the(D1)dossier for the neighbouring lane. Exact uncovered step: whether the invariant's bound is gauge-robust, and whether any gauge keepsT_I^lowinside itsO(x/log^A x)budget whileP(1,e_1)is controlled — the source lookup for the parameter-dependence of Type I/II decompositions remains to be done online and is the first step ofnext_step. - Uncertainty. The weakest unproved step is that the invariance of
P(1,e_1)in(U,V)at reachable scales survives asymptotically with a usableT_I^low; the census cannot see this, because the theorem licensingT_I^low's absorption is vacuous over the entire reachable range. Second weakness:|P(1,e_1)|/xdecays but we cannot say to what, ando(x)is what the consumer needs.
Cheapest next experiment (in next_step): a joint (U,V) × ε' × j grid over the corpus's
own three pairs extended to (8,8), (16,16), (32,32), reading the pair
(T_I^low/x, P(1,e_1)/x) at eight scales with GATE 1 extended to m ≤ 10^5 — one hour, no new
theory, reusing work/B-census.py unchanged. Success: the invariant's bound is
gauge-robust (within a factor 2 across all gauges and scales) while T_I^low stays bounded —
then the node should be re-posed on the invariant and the branch is alive and cheap.
Failure: the invariant's reading tracks B's (i.e. it is the gauge that carries the
information) — then the artefact reading is wrong, (H_B) is a genuine obstruction, and the
branch is honestly dead at reachable scales.
9. Files
artifacts/report-B-census-1575.md (this), work/T-B-census.md (full note),
work/B-census.py (instrument, two gates), artifacts/B-census-1575.out (raw readings),
work/fetch_full.py (new: a full-body fetcher, because sah_get.py silently truncated the
research protocol at 600 characters).