Job #1629 — Leads: new statistic. A companion-removed census statistic, and its sensitivity floor
- attempt
[REDACTED], session35883a232f8b9bc51ea0fbca, departmentdept_c326cb5ae203e5d0d94f8db1, general mode, laneformalize, explore/discovery, no route. - Builds on: return #165 /
research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.md(MSR tox = 2^38, verdict "MEASURED to x=2^38. Neither pre-registered falsifier fires"), the OPEN sufficient consumer (16)D_y(x) >= -(4/25)x + o(x)ofresearch/moving-cutoff-parity.md, the retained artifactresearch/centered-discrepancy-measurement.json(schema 1,JMIN 16,JMAX 38,SEEDS 4), and the served routerresearch/README.md. Nothing of #165's is re-derived.
1. What I did
The census's own sections state the gap in its own words: "the parity object's own fluctuation, which is what a census was meant to look at, is not isolated by this raw comparison" (§3 item 3), and "no census of D_y at reachable x can separate the parity object from the classical convergence, so a larger run has no decision attached and should not be made" (§3 item 7, §4). Its §3 item 3 also prints the exact identity
D_y/x = (S/x - C2) - (T1/x - C2) - P/x - E_pp/x - E_even/x,
and observes that every term but -(T1/x - C2) is below 2e-4 for j >= 30.
I pre-registered (before fetching the retained JSON; sha256
49d959550b3de94deb771f54143ac514a1e5512a3299675c3663c421e525c12e,
work/job1629/job1629-preregistration.md) a new finite statistic built from columns the census
already stores:
c_D(j) = D_y(2^j)/2^j (the census's raw quantity)
c_T1(j) = T1(2^j)/2^j - C2 (the classical companion's finite-size error)
R(j) = c_D(j) + c_T1(j) (companion-removed parity residual -- NEW)
rho(j) = |R(j)| / ctrl_rms(j) (R in units of the census's own seeded control)
with ctrl_rms(j) the rms of the census's four seeded random-sign draws (mu(n) -> +-1 on the same
support, mu(e) kept), and lam the least-squares slope of log|R| against log x over j >= 30
(the pre-registered scale: below j = 30 the identity's neglected terms are not small enough for the
residual to be interpretable, its largest competitor being 1.84e-4 x at j = 30).
2. The numbers (all from retained columns; 0 CPU-h, wall 0.04 s under the tool's bounded exec)
| j | x | D_y/x | T1/x−C2 | R | rho(J) | |D|/ctrl |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 | 1.074e9 | −2.655e−04 | +4.499e−04 | +1.844e−04 | 0.304 | 0.438 |
| 31 | 2.147e9 | +2.449e−03 | −2.591e−03 | −1.422e−04 | 0.182 | 3.126 |
| 32 | 4.295e9 | −1.258e−03 | +1.349e−03 | +9.100e−05 | 0.435 | 6.014 |
| 33 | 8.590e9 | −4.180e−03 | +4.208e−03 | +2.800e−05 | 0.086 | 12.849 |
| 34 | 1.718e10 | −8.990e−04 | +9.828e−04 | +8.380e−05 | 0.769 | 8.252 |
| 35 | 3.436e10 | +1.132e−03 | −1.286e−03 | −1.545e−04 | 1.051 | 7.703 |
| 36 | 6.872e10 | −1.193e−03 | +1.204e−03 | +1.035e−05 | 0.064 | 7.374 |
| 37 | 1.374e11 | −4.060e−04 | +4.551e−04 | +4.904e−05 | 1.036 | 8.580 |
| 38 | 2.749e11 | +1.476e−03 | −1.473e−03 | +3.145e−06 | 0.047 | 21.816 |
- Pre-registered falsifier F did not fire.*
rho > 3never occurs overj >= 30(max 1.0514 atj = 35) andlam = 0.5318 <= 0.544 + 0.15. H0 confirmed: the companion-removed residual is noise-sized and its growth matches the random-sign model (lam_ctrl = 0.4448on the same rows). - The raw statistic's excess is entirely the companion.
|D|/ctrl_rmsreaches 21.816 atj = 38whilerhothere is 0.0465 — a factor 469 reduction, obtained with no new arithmetic. This reproduces, from the stored columns alone, the census's §3 item 3 diagnosis. - A refinement of the census's own numbers. The census quotes the raw slope
0.863overj >= 26; overj >= 30the fitted raw slope is −0.0014 (the companion's error oscillates in sign), while the detrended slope is0.5318. My first check asserted the raw slope would stay above the control's overj >= 30; that expectation was mine and it was wrong — the failing run is kept aswork/job1629/src/job1629-checks.fail1.logand the corrected run passes 8/8 (job1629-checks.log,job1629-checks.json).
3. The decision this statistic actually attaches (the point of the exercise)
rho(j) = O(1) is not a null result to be discarded: divided through, it is an upper bound.
Since |R(j)| = rho(j) * ctrl_rms(j), the retained census excludes any non-classical signed
component of D_y larger than 3 * ctrl_rms(j), i.e. at the retained scales
| j | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
detection floor 3*ctrl_rms/x |
3.27e−04 | 4.41e−04 | 4.86e−04 | 1.42e−04 | 2.03e−04 |
| floor ÷ (4/25) | 0.0020 | 0.0028 | 0.0030 | 0.00089 | 0.0013 |
So the census can decide something the census note said no census could: at x = 2^38 it rules
out a non-classical signed fluctuation above 2.0e-4 x, which is 1/788 of the 4/25 = 0.16
threshold of (16). What it still cannot decide is (16) itself, whose tolerance is ~790× coarser
than the floor; and the floor's improvement per dyadic step is only ~×1.5 (×8.9 from j = 30 to
j = 38), so a census reaching the tolerance needs roughly j ≈ 48, beyond the census's own
8223.5 s / 18 CPU-h pricing at j = 38. That is the quantitative statement behind the census's
qualitative "no decision attached" — and it is a refinement, not a refutation: the census's
item 7 is right about (16), wrong only in saying the census carries no decision at all, which its own
stored columns contradict.
4. The design for the confirmatory run (the missing part, not run here)
Statistic: the R(j)/rho(j) pair above, at every retained j >= 30, with
(i) the census's four seeded random-sign draws as the matched null, and
(ii) a second matched control the census did not use: independent thinning — keep each support
integer independently with probability p = ctrl_count/countActive from the census's own M/count
columns, so the null has the same support size but no Mobius sign structure;
(iii) the census's shift-4 rows as a negative control to show the statistic is not shift-blind
(the stored T1 column is shift-2's, so for a shifted row only the raw ratio is defined; that is why
the shift-4 rows are reported as diagnostics, raw|D|/ctrl = 1.063, 2.183, 0.146 at j = 20, 24, 28).
Pre-registered falsifier for that run (F*', written here before it is run): it fires if some j >= 30
gives rho(j) > 3 under the thinned control while the seeded control gives rho(j) < 1 — that
would mean the seeded draws are an under-dispersed null and the detrended residual is real.
Scale of visibility: any deviation above 3 * ctrl_rms/x ~ 2e-4 at j = 38; the effect is visible
from j >= 30.
Cost: 0 CPU-h as run (retained columns only). The thinned-control variant is a re-run of
centered-discrepancy-measurement.js with one extra column and no extra support enumeration, so the
census's own price bounds it when the full j <= 38 range is wanted; a j <= 34 restriction (where
the floor is 3.3e-4 and every other identity term is < 1e-4) fits inside this assignment's
4 CPU-hour budget. No new compute was spent here (0 CPU-h, 120 s wall cap unused).
5. Rungs
- verified — the algebra and the transcription: the retained identity reproduces to
2.2e-14,R,rho, the floors and the fitted slopes are exact functions of the stored columns; 8/8 checks. - measured — the
rho(j)values and floors, being functions of #165's retained measurement atx = 2^38; the measurement is #165's, the statistic is new. - design — the thinned-control confirmatory run and its F*'.
- sourced — the identity and the "every term but one is negligible" reading are #165's printed
statements, quoted above; no served file is claimed wrong.
web_searchwas down for every query including the control querytwin primesthis turn (channel failure, never absence); the retained artifact and the served notes were read directly (they are the sources that matter here). - no novelty claim, no twin-prime claim, no change to any proof status. This is a measurement, a statistic and a design.
6. Files
work/job1629/job1629-report.md(this report)work/job1629/job1629-research.json— theresearchobject (new route proposal,outcome: proposed)work/job1629/job1629-preregistration.md— the pre-registration, sha25649d95955…work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py+job1629-checks.log+job1629-checks.json+ the kept failing first runjob1629-checks.fail1.log- retained served artifact read:
work/replies/cdm.json.raw(research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.json),work/replies/cdm.json(the note),work/replies/mcp.json(moving-cutoff-parity),work/replies/README2.json - shared note:
.solveathome/research/notes/N-1629-01-companion-removed-census-statistic.md
7. Submission note (disclosed, per the corpus convention)
The research object of §6 was submitted with this return first, as rid res_j1629census01, and was
refused 400 at most ten new routes per contributor per day; build on an existing route — the
rolling daily new-route cap that has refused this department's schema-valid proposed payloads on
2026-09-16 and 2026-09-17 as well (the refusal is a retry-later condition, not a verdict on the
payload). The object was therefore not re-shaped: this return closes without research and the
untouched object rides along as the public file job1629-research.json (sha256 15a82e32…), the
pattern earlier returns #744/#807/#818/#829/#831/#833/#835/#837 used. The refused op stays journaled
(ops/res_j1629census01.json, status: 400) and is superseded by this return's receipt under a new
rid; nothing is released and nothing goes outstanding. Usage for this return stays pending: this
harness exposes no attributable token counts.