{"type": "solveathome.transcript", "version": 1, "harness": "freebuff-cli", "model": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash", "effort": "unmeasured", "started_at": "11:06 AM", "note": "agent-written from ~/.config/manicode chat records; this app exposes no token usage"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "user", "content": "First read https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/department-protocol and follow its setup instructions in the local folder I opened. After readiness passes, use this exact joining URL: https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/start?time=1task. API credential: SOLVEATHOME_TOKEN=sah_; never publish it. Start in general mode. | Operating notes from your overseer (an automated supervisor plus a human-directed Claude thread; you cannot ask either of us questions, so take reasonable defaults and record them): | 1. Session clock. You run inside a prepaid Freebuff session that ends at 09:51 UTC (about 44 min from now). It ends WITHOUT warning and cuts your turn mid-step; anything not written to disk is lost. Re-read `fbctl/logs/session.json` (`deadline_utc`) whenever you plan a step. Do not start a step you cannot checkpoint before the deadline. 2. Checkpoint continuously. After every meaningful step write `.solveathome/runs//work/PROGRESS.md`: assignment id/attempt, what is done (with file paths and hashes), what is next (exact commands), open questions. Keep `.solveathome/state/HANDOFF.md` current. A successor agent with NO memory of this conversation must be able to finish your attempt from those two files plus the run directory. 3. Recover before you take. Before requesting work, run the outstanding-work check and read `.solveathome/state/HANDOFF.md`. If a previous agent's attempt in this folder is still open, recover it under this joining instruction (GET /run/context, POST /run/recover or X-Recover-Attempt at registration, per the protocol) and finish or release it first; do not take a second assignment on top of open work. If HANDOFF.md lists cheap pending follow-ups from predecessors (e.g. a transcript correction with commands ready in a PENDING.md), do them now and record the receipt before taking new work. 4. Close cleanly. Finish through the tested completion path, then run the outstanding-work check, then end your turn with a final line that starts with `DONE:` (all attempts accounted for) or `BLOCKED:` (with the concrete blocker and next action). The supervisor reads that line."} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "assistant", "content": "Let me start by reading the protocol and understanding the local setup.\n\nThe user says session clock ends at 09:51 UTC, ~44 min from now. Let me be efficient.\n\nLet me read the department protocol URL and the local folder's .solveathome/README.md.\n\nContext is enormous. Let me be efficient. The session deadline is 09:51:43Z; observed at 09:06:43Z, 44 min left. So now it's ~09:07Z. Roughly 44 min.\n\nKey facts from HANDOFF.md newest entry: run `run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ` job #1628 closed as return #837. That session's cap is spent (1 of 1). So a successor needs a fresh joining instruction — which we have: the user gave us a new joining URL with `?time=1task`.\n\nWait — but the user gives exactly the same URL pattern. The URL: https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/start?time=1task. And the instruction says start in general mode.\n\nSteps:\n1. Recover before take: run outstanding check and read HANDOFF.md. HANDOFF says 0 of 66 outstanding, all_complete=True (newest entry). But I need to verify with the tool.\n2. Readiness passes (re-run readiness + path fixture? The protocol says validate readiness before the joining URL. Reuse readiness evidence for unchanged tools/application; rerun checks relevant to changes. Since tool unchanged sah/12, maybe rerun acceptance quickly to be safe — it's fast).\n3. Check cheap pending follow-ups from predecessors: PENDING.md items, e.g. transcript correction. The overseer says \"If HANDOFF.md lists cheap pending follow-ups from predecessors (e.g. a transcript correction with commands ready in a PENDING.md), do them now and record the receipt before taking new work.\"\n\nHmm — but the usage/transcript corrections are pending items. But note gotcha: `POST /files` and attach routes are only available before the run has submitted its own result. For my run, before complete. So predecessor attaches could be done right after registration.\n\nBut time is tight (~44 min). Let me prioritize:\n- Pre-work gate: outstanding + HANDOFF (read newest entries — done partly).\n- Readiness: re-run (maybe ~10-30s).\n- Identity: bind to this chat dir, record.\n- run new + register with exact joining URL.\n- Print binding JSON.\n- Fetch assignment, do research work (bounded), complete, outstanding.\n\nLet me first look at the run directory of the newest run and PROGRESS.md, plus check outstanding. Also, let me check the tools directory and recent session state.\n\nActually let's move fast. Run the commands.\n\nLet me check current time and outstanding status first, plus check fbctl session.\n\nPre-work gate clean: 0 of 66 outstanding, all_complete=True. No open predecessor.\n\nNow check whether there are cheap pending follow-ups (PENDING.md) in recent runs. Let me check quickly for PENDING.md files and the newest PROGRESS.md.\n\nTime: 09:07Z. 44 min.\n\nAlso need to re-run readiness & identity, then register.\n\nLet me plan with todos and check PENDING files.\n\nI need to find the chat directory for this current turn. The previous run used `chats/2026-09-17T08-59-36.790Z`. Where are these chats? Probably in a Freebuff app data dir. Let me look at how the identity command was invoked previously — check `.solveathome/state/identity/run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ.json`.\n\nNow find this chat's directory: the newest chat in `~/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/`. But must bind to *this* chat — I need to identify which is mine. The newest one should be the current turn's chat dir (this session started ~09:07Z). Let me list.\n\nNote caution: \"never select the newest log in a shared folder\" — but the identity reader is bound to this chat dir which I must determine. The previous runs did select the newest chat dir they created. Let me check timestamps and start time. This session started around 09:06:43 (session.json observed_utc) — actually the session.json was written at 09:06:43 within THIS session (by fbctl). Hmm, actually the supervisor wrote it. So this chat started around 09:06Z or slightly earlier.\n\nLet me list chats with time.\n\nMy chat dir is `chats/2026-09-17T09-06-44.977Z` (started 09:06:44, matches session.json observed 09:06:43).\n\nNow the plan. Time 09:07Z, deadline 09:51:43Z → ~44 min.\n\nSteps with todos:\n1. Pre-work gate ✓ (0/66 outstanding, HANDOFF read).\n2. Readiness re-run (acceptance 26/26) + path fixture 5/5.\n3. `run new` + identity record + register with exact URL, model, effort.\n4. Print binding JSON.\n5. Fetch assignment.\n6. Do bounded research; write report, checks, proposal.\n7. Complete (dry-run first), outstanding.\n\nGiven only ~40 min, I should pick a task that can be done quickly but well. The cheapest pending science from HANDOFF: \"parameterise residual-coverage.md (11)-(16) and grouped-divisor-moment.md §4 in w ... locate the derivations of the printed constants 31/50 and 77/200\". That's a 0.5h read-only task. But actually the assignment will be whatever the server gives — general mode follows the project queue. So I can't choose. I'll get whatever job is issued and do it well.\n\nLet me set up todos and start readiness in parallel with drafting? Actually readiness must come before the joining URL. Let's run readiness now (acceptance + path_fixture) — that took ~seconds before.\n\nLet me run both.\n\nReadiness 26/26 at 09:07:21Z. Now path fixture 5/5. That runs a local fixture server; took maybe 10s.\n\nThen run new + identity + register.\n\nLet me check the sah.py CLI usage for `run new`, `identity`, `register` to get exact flags.\n\nBoth readiness checks pass. Now:\n- `run new --model deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash --effort unmeasured --mode general`\n- `identity --app freebuff-cli --chat --record --run `\n- `register --run `\n\nLet me check register help quickly, and how to get run id from `run new` output. Let me just do run new and see output.\n\nURL: https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/start?time=1task\n\nNote: shell quoting the URL with `?` is fine unquoted usually but quote it.\n\nLet's do it.\n\nRun created: `run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg`.\n\nNow identity first (bind to this chat), then register.\n\nidentity --app freebuff-cli --chat ~/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/2026-09-17T09-06-44.977Z --record --run run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg\n\nThen register --run (it will use saved URL).\n\nLet me do identity first and inspect the output.\n\nIdentity bound correctly to this chat, model deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash, effort unmeasured.\n\nNow register. This can immediately assign work.\n\nRegistration 200. Now print binding JSON immediately (per the transcript-binding rule) and inspect assignment.\n\nLet me read assignment.json and print json.dumps({'job_id','attempt_id','session'}).\n\nJob #1629, explore/discovery, stage discover, NO ROUTE, session 1 of 1 (so a single assignment; no more this session).\n\nNow read brief_md to know what to do.\n\nJob #1629: \"Leads: new statistic\" — design ONE finite statistic with a pre-registered falsifier, matched control, scale. Read research/README.md router, search online for existing statistics/datasets, reuse published numbers, and either run the missing part or return the design with cost.\n\nTime: 09:08Z now, deadline 09:51:43Z → ~43 min. The job budget is 2h but my session ends in ~43 min. So I must produce a compact, well-scoped design and submit.\n\nStrategy: This is exactly a \"design a statistic with a falsifier\" job. Previous runs have done similar. I should:\n1. Read `research/README.md` (served router) and relevant served notes/OUTCOMES to ground the statistic in existing censuses and reuse published numbers.\n2. Design the statistic, write a checks script (local arithmetic verification), report, and submit without `--research` (given the daily route cap is likely to refuse anyway — but the brief says include research.proposal if it amounts to a new route). Given gotchas 28/32/38: routeless `proposed` requires top-level next_step, no top-level prior_art_md, route_id omitted; and the daily cap has refused this row's payloads for three days. So the routine: try once, and if refused, submit without `--research` and attach the object as a public file.\n\nGiven time, I'll plan: attempt the research object once (cheap), then fallback.\n\nFirst, fetch the served docs I need. Let me be efficient: \n- GET /projects/twin-primes/research/README.md (router)\n- Maybe the OUTCOMES.md is 209 KB — too big to read fully. But maybe I can grep for census-related sections.\n\nActually, a smarter approach given limited time: the HANDOFF lists the standing cheapest science item — parameterise residual-coverage.md (11)-(16) and grouped-divisor-moment.md §4 in w. But that's a different job type (\"Leads: new route\" was #1626/#1628). This job is \"new statistic with a falsifier\".\n\nThe brief mentions \"retained censuses could not\" decide. So there are censuses in the repo (e.g., #165's census of D_y). The task: design one finite statistic that decides something the retained censuses could not, with a pre-registered falsifier, matched control, and scale.\n\nThere is a natural fit with the #1627 finding: the census extreme |D_y|/x = 0.039617 is 4.04x inside the 4/25 threshold, so censuses cannot discriminate (16). Hmm — but \"new statistic\" job.\n\nLet me check the served docs for the house format and existing census work. Let me first look at the department's local research notes to reuse findings, and fetch research/README.md.\n\nTime management: I'll spend ~10 min on reconnaissance, ~12 min writing artifacts, ~8 min submitting. Tight.\n\nLet me fetch the router and list local research notes.\n\n404 — need the project prefix (gotcha 13): `/projects/twin-primes/research/README.md` ought to work... Hmm, that's exactly what I used. Maybe the router is at `/projects/twin-primes/docs/research/README.md`.\n\nLet me fetch `/projects/twin-primes/docs/` index and `docs/research/README.md`.\n\nAlso I should check the notes relevant: N-1526-01-cutoff-parameterised-budget-region.md, N-1533-01-tile-resolved-margin.md, N-1604-01-twin-slot-census-owned.md, N-1606-01-split-ramp-uniform-product-threshold.md. The \"new statistic\" job — previous similar jobs? Let me check what earlier \"Leads: new statistic\" jobs produced... I don't have that list handy.\n\nLet me be pragmatic: fetch docs index, and read local notes N-1604 (twin-slot census) and N-1533 (tile-resolved margin) — these are census-related and the brief says \"retained censuses could not\" decide.\n\nActually reading many notes costs time. Let me fetch the served docs index first to know available documents.\n\nThe router is large but useful. Time check: ~09:10Z. ~41 min left.\n\nThe job: design ONE finite statistic with a pre-registered falsifier, matched control, and scale, where the retained censuses could not decide. Search online for existing statistics first, reuse published numbers.\n\nKey existing census: project's twin-slot census (N-1604-01-twin-slot-census-owned.md); #165's census of D_y (moving-cutoff). Let me read the local note N-1604 (twin-slot census owned) — this is directly \"retained censuses\".\n\nAlso check what \"house format\" is: question in comments, then code.\n\nLet me read N-1604-01 note and N-1533-01-tile-resolved-margin.md quickly (both local, cheap).\n\nActually, time. Let me read N-1604 only, plus grep OUTCOMES for \"census\". Hmm, OUTCOMES is 209 KB — grep with the raw extraction is risky (gotcha 24). Let me instead download it and use python to grep lines.\n\nPriority: produce a good, self-contained design. The design needs:\n- Decision it informs\n- Pre-registered falsifier\n- Matched control (random-sign, permutation, or independent thinning)\n- Scale where effect visible\n- Existing numbers reused/cited\n- Cost if not run\n\nI think a strong, cheap choice: a statistic on the project's own retained twin-slot census / the parity discrepancy data that discriminates the two competing readings... Hmm.\n\nLet me look at N-1604 note now.\n\nGood, this is a census-related note. Now, the \"new statistic\" job wants a statistic that decides something the retained censuses could not, with falsifier, matched control, scale.\n\nLet me think about what a genuinely good, cheap, well-scoped design would be — and importantly one grounded in existing project numbers so I can reuse published figures and verify locally with a small script.\n\nIdea candidates:\n\n(A) A \"census-discriminating\" statistic for the centered discrepancy consumer (16): `D_y >= -(4/25)x + o(x)`. #165's census gives |D_y|/x = 0.039617 — inside threshold. A new statistic: instead of a single max over the moving endpoint, use a **two-sided run/block statistic** — e.g., the maximum of partial sums of the centered discrepancy over a dyadic block decomposition with a thinning control. Hmm, but designing \"matched control\" = independent thinning, as the repo uses.\n\n(B) The split axis (route 46) — the two readings disagreement at w* = 12/125 — a statistic that could decide whether κ is pinned... that's not really a finite statistic.\n\n(C) A statistic on **retained censuses of the primorial-period twin slots** (T_y) that tests the *uniformity of slot positions within residue classes mod small moduli* — decides whether the three-slot lattice structure (mod 30 classes 11, 17, 29) exhibits the same discrepancy as the full count. Hmm.\n\nGiven the time, I think the best is something that is (i) genuinely finite and computable by me NOW within the compute budget (4 CPU-h, 16 GB, 5 GB disk — but my session only has ~35 min, so I need something that runs in seconds/minutes), and (ii) grounded in the project's served censuses.\n\nSince this is the discovery lane: design a statistic + pre-registered falsifier + matched control + scale — with the option to run the missing part if it fits. A statistic I can compute exactly in seconds gets me a \"measured\" rung and a much stronger return.\n\nConcrete proposal: **A \"gap-composition\" statistic for the centered-discrepancy consumer: the signed autocorrelation of the parity/centering residual on the mod-30 three-slot lattice.**\n\nHmm, careful. Let me look at what data the project actually retains. Key served docs likely: `moving-cutoff-parity.md` (with the census of D_y from #165), `research/verify-ladder-big.js`, and OUTCOMES.md. Also `centered-discrepancy`. \n\nAlternatively I could design a statistic whose control is **independent thinning** and which is exactly computable from the twin-slot lattice mod primorials — i.e., a \"twin-slot gap statistic\" T_gap.\n\nHonestly, a defensible and self-contained design that reuses published numbers:\n\n**Statistic S_N = normalized fluctuation of the twin-slot count in a half-period window** — compare the actual twin-slot census restricted to a dyadic window [0, y#/2) against the uniform expectation T_y/2, with the same statistic computed under independent thinning (control) and a random-sign control. Decision: does the primorial-period twin-slot distribution carry a *bias* at half-period scale (which a single global count cannot see, because the global count is forced to prod(p-2))? Falsifier: if the half-period imbalance statistic is within the null band from the control at N = 31#,37#, the \"half-period bias\" hypothesis is dead.\n\nThis is genuinely something \"retained censuses could not\" decide (the censuses only record the total count and the max gap), it is exactly computable (enumerate residues mod 200 billion? No — y# = 200,560,490,130 for 31#; enumerating a full period is infeasible... but |slots| = T31 = 6.2e9, too big too. However, we can compute exactly by CRT/recursive structure: the slot set mod y# is a lifted product; counting slots in [0, y#/2) can be computed exactly by the standard recursive / CRT argument since y#/2 is not a multiple of p-structure... Actually y# is even? y# for y=29 is 29#= 6469693230, which is 2*3*5*...*29, even. Split at y#/2: by symmetry r -> ? For each prime p >= 3, r mod p# ... Hmm, the symmetry r -> -r maps slot r (gcd(r,y#)=1, gcd(r+2,y#)=1) to -r with gcd(-r)=1 and gcd(-r+2)=gcd(r-2) — not a slot necessarily. So no clean symmetry; counting in half-period requires actual computation. But that's exactly the point: it can be computed with a modular sieve in ~T_y/... hmm 200 billion is too much, but a smarter approach: slots mod 31# are determined by the CRT lift from 29#: each slot mod 29# lifts to (p-2)=29 slots mod 31# (0 <= k < 31 with r + k*29# ≡ -2 mod 31). So we can generate all 6.2e9 slots explicitly? That's too many for memory but on-the-fly counting is ~6e9 ops in Python — way too slow. In C, maybe 30s-60s... we don't have time to write, compile, debug.\n\nSo better: pick a small primorial (up to 23# = 223092870 or 19# = 9699690) and compute the statistic exactly; then pre-register the extrapolation to 29#/31#. Actually the \"retained censuses\" the job refers to are probably the project's own censuses (like #165's D_y census or the T_y enumeration).\n\nHmm wait. Let me re-read the brief: \"Design one finite statistic a run could actually decide something about, where the retained censuses could not: the decision it informs, a pre-registered falsifier written before any run, a matched control (random-sign, permutation or independent thinning, as the repo uses), and the scale at which the effect would be visible if present.\"\n\nSo: design a statistic, define decision, falsifier, control, scale. And \"run the missing part... if it fits compute\". This is a design-first job. The deliverable is primarily the design; running is optional.\n\nGiven ~35 min of session, I should:\n1. Ground the design in the served docs (brief look at moving-cutoff-parity.md §4-5 and the census #165 numbers, which I already have from HANDOFF: |D_y|/x = 0.039617 at j=17, threshold 4/25).\n2. Design statistic: a *shape* statistic that the max-census cannot see.\n\nActually here's a strong, concrete, defensible design tied to an open consumer already in the record:\n\n**The gap: the census records only the extreme max (and maybe a few points) of D_y over j. The consumer (16) needs a *signed average* (`(1/25)x` type lower bound) — i.e. the censuses cannot decide sign/average behavior, only magnitude extremes.** #1627's note quantified: census extreme 0.039617 vs threshold 4/25=0.16, 4.04x inside → cannot discriminate.\n\nSo new statistic: **a block-averaged signed centered discrepancy** — `A_J = (1/J) sum_j D_{y_j}/x` over a dyadic grid of endpoints, with an explicit null distribution from a matched control (independent thinning of the slot set / random-sign permutation of the residuals) and a pre-registered falsifier: the sign structure of the consumer requires the *lower* tail; the census's max is on |D|. \n\nHmm. I want to be careful not to over-engineer in 35 min. Let me do a quick scan of the served `moving-cutoff-parity.md` for (13)-(16) and the census description, so my design is properly cited. Let me fetch it and grep the relevant sections.\n\nAlso the brief says to search online first for existing statistics/datasets/computed ranges. web_search may be down (gotcha 41) — send a control query too.\n\nLet me parallelize: fetch moving-cutoff-parity.md + do a web_search control query.\n\nTime budget: it's ~09:11Z. I'll aim to start writing artifacts by 09:25Z, submit by ~09:45Z.\n\nLet me do it.\n\nweb_search is down (control query \"twin primes\" returned nothing) — record as channel failure, not absence.\n\nNow read the census paragraph around lines 355-390 of moving-cutoff-parity.md.\n\nNow I have solid grounding:\n- (16): D_y(x) >= -(4/25)x + o(x) on an unbounded set of dyadic x; sufficient consumer.\n- Census: `centered-discrepancy-measurement.md` — finite census of D_y to x=2^38; shows D_y is the finite-size error of classical term T_1, order x/log^2 x, beneath which the discrepancy's own fluctuation is invisible; measures no asymptotic trend.\n- #165's census extreme |D_y|/x = 0.039617 at j=17 (from HANDOFF note N-1627-01).\n\nThe gap is precisely stated in the served doc: \"A census of D_y without a specified falsifier... would repeat the unresolved step.\" And \"at every reachable x the value of D_y is the finite-size error of the classical term T_1 in (6), of order x/log^2 x, beneath which the discrepancy's own fluctuation is invisible; it measures no asymptotic trend\".\n\nSo the \"new statistic\" should be one that **cancels the classical T_1 trend** and thereby makes the fluctuation visible — i.e., a *detrended, sign-aware* statistic on the census data. That is exactly the discovery this job asks for: \"one finite statistic a run could actually decide something about, where the retained censuses could not\".\n\nDesign:\n\n**Statistic: the detrended, self-normalized centered discrepancy ratio with a signed tail asymmetry, computed at the census's own reachable scales.**\n\nPrecisely:\n- Let c(x) := D_y(x)/x (the census's retained quantity), and let x_j = 2^j be the census's dyadic grid. The census shows c(x_j) ≈ -2C_2·(stuff)/... hmm. T_1 is of order x/log^2 x, so D_y ≈ error of order x/log^2 x → c(x_j) ~ const/log^2 x_j.\n\nWait, actually re-read: \"at every reachable x the value of D_y is the finite-size error of the classical term T_1 in (6), of order x/log^2 x, beneath which the discrepancy's own fluctuation is invisible\". Hmm, that suggests D_y(x) itself is dominated by the T_1 truncation error, O(x/log^2 x)? That is bigger than the 4/25 x threshold though. Hmm, \"beneath which the discrepancy's own fluctuation is invisible\" — the classical error x/log^2 x dominates and hides the target fluctuation. So the census measures the classical error, not the target.\n\nSo a new statistic must **remove the classical main term exactly**: define the *residual after removing the explicit finite-size classical term T_1* — i.e., a normalized statistic\n\nR(x) := (D_y(x) - T_1trunc(x)) / (x/log^2 x)... \n\nHmm, but D_y = S - stuff. Actually the classic decomposition (17): D_y = B_L + 2C_2 M + O(x/log^A x). And T_1 = C_2 x (the classical count?). Hmm.\n\nRather than guess the exact algebra from memory, the cleanest design that is *verifiable now* without reading the whole corpus:\n\n**Use the census's own structure: the retained quantities are (x_j, D_y(x_j)). The statistic: the second-difference/trend-removed sequence with a matched control.**\n\nConcretely, define the \"log-slope statistic\" \n Λ := (sum over consecutive triples of a fixed linear-in-1/log^2 x model fit) — hmm too fancy.\n\nAlternative sharper idea, well within what I can compute and pre-register:\n\n**Statistic S = the signed dyadic-detrended residual:**\n Let m(x) = a + b/log^2 x, the classical finite-size model (two free parameters). Fit (a,b) by least squares over the census points at the *lower* half of the dyadic range (pre-registered training set), then compute\n S := (1/J_test) * sum_{j in test} sign-normalized residual (D_{y_j} - x_j*m(x_j)) / (x_j/log^2 x_j).\nDecision: does the target fluctuation appear as a *systematic signed* residual of order ≥ 4/25 in normalized units — i.e., rungs on the census with |c| ≥ 0.16 after detrending.\nFalsifier (pre-registered): the detrended normalized residual has mean ≤ 0.01 (say) in magnitude with the control band; then the retained census cannot support (16) at any reachable scale and the 4/25 threshold remains undecidable below x* where x/log^2 x < 4x/25 → log^2 x > 25/4 → log x > 2.5 → x > e^2.5 ≈ 12.2. Hmm, that's tiny, so that computation is wrong — the classical error isn't x/log^2 x in the same normalization.\n\nI'm spending too long. Let me step back and pick something I can *actually execute and verify* in the remaining ~28 minutes, with real numbers from the served docs.\n\nBetter plan: read `centered-discrepancy-measurement.md` (the census doc) — it's probably smallish, gives the actual retained numbers (the census of D_y to 2^38). Then the statistic becomes concrete: the census table gives (x, D_y) pairs; I can compute the detrended statistic from the actual retained values and report. And it directly addresses \"where the retained censuses could not\".\n\nThat's the right move: fetch that doc, look at the table and its stated limitations.\n\nTime: 09:13Z. Fetch now.\n\nExcellent — this is exactly the material. The census note says: the retained censuses could NOT see the parity object, because D_y/x ≈ -(T1/x − C2), dominated by classical term T1's convergence. The parity object's own fluctuation \"is not isolated by this raw comparison\".\n\nSo the NEW STATISTIC: a **detrended, term-matched statistic** that removes the classical companion T1 exactly using the census's own identity columns: \n\nD_y/x = (S/x − C2) − (T1/x − C2) − P/x − E_pp/x − E_even/x.\n\nThe census notes that all but one term are negligible, so D_y/x ≈ −(T1/x − C2). The new statistic: \n\n**T(x) := D_y(x)/x + (T1(x)/x − C2)** — the residual after removing the classical companion. This is the parity object's own fluctuation, isolated. It's exactly computable from the same factor lists (T1 is computed by the same script), it's finite at every reachable x, and the retained censuses could not see it because they only retained D_y and raw controls.\n\nThen: does T(x) reveal structure beyond the random-sign model? Pre-registered falsifier: if the residual r(x) := D_y/x + (T1/x − C2) is within the control's band (control rms) at all j>=26 and its ratio |r|/(control rms) < some threshold, then no new statistic needed — the parity object remains invisible. And the decision it informs: whether the raw census's |D_y|/(control rms) = 6–22 \"excess\" is entirely the classical term (→ the census's apparent structure reading is an artifact) or whether a genuine excess survives detrending (→ lane A has a measurable handle, and (16) becomes numerically testable at scale).\n\nEven better: the statistic has a *pre-registered directional* prediction. Note |D_y|/(control rms) ratio 6.014…21.816 and slope of log|D_y| 0.863 vs control 0.544. If the whole excess is the classical term, then after removing (T1/x − C2), the residual should be comparable to the control (ratio ~O(1)) and the slope should drop to the control slope 0.544. Falsifier F*: if the detrended residual ratio stays > 3 with slope bounded away from the control slope for j>=30, the classical term does NOT explain the retained excess → there is an unmodelled signed structure → the census's conclusion (\"dominated by classical term\") is wrong and must be audited; conversely if the ratio falls to ~1, the census's diagnosis is confirmed with an explicit number and the raw excess measure is retired.\n\nThat's a genuine, finite statistic, with a matched control (the four seeded random-sign draws already in the census; plus an independent-thinning variant), a scale (j >= 30 where every other term is < 2e-4), and a decision. And it is runnable at zero new compute if the census script's retained output columns exist — the census already computes T1, S, P, E_pp, E_even! So the missing part is: **recompute the residual r(x) from retained columns** — no re-run needed if the OUTPUT block carries columns. If it doesn't, the cost is a rerun of the served script (8223.5 s on 8 workers ≈ 1.03 h on 8 cores ≈ 8.2 CPU-h... wait, 8223.5 s total with 8 workers = 8*8223.5/3600 = 18.3 CPU-h — exceeds the 4 CPU-h budget!). But the statistic only needs rows j=30..38? The full run 8223s. Hmm, we could restrict to j <= 34 or fewer j. Actually the census's cost is the large-x support (3.9e9 integers at j=38). The design should state cost: rerun to j=34 (support ~2^34/... ) — estimate.\n\nActually — important: the \"decision\" here is decidable *now* from the retained OUTPUT block if it includes T1/x per j. Let me read the OUTPUT block of the served doc (rest of the file) to see the retained columns. If T1/x columns are retained, I can compute the residual statistic immediately — a real \"measured\" contribution, reusing published numbers, and the census-derived statistics can be computed exactly from printed values! That would make this return much stronger: new statistic *plus* its immediate evaluation on retained data.\n\nLet me read the rest of the doc (lines beyond 7000 chars).\n\nKey: the retained artifact is `centered-discrepancy-measurement.json`. The doc says \"Retained artifact: centered-discrepancy-measurement.json\" — this likely has all the columns (T1/x, S/x, D_y/x, controls). So I can compute a detrended statistic from the retained JSON with zero new compute!\n\nThat's the win: \"where the retained censuses could not\" — but also reusing retained data. But careful: the brief says design a statistic that decides something the retained censuses could not. So the statistic must be new (the census retained only D_y and raw comparisons; the new statistic is the detrended residual and its ratio-to-control with a slope comparison).\n\nSo plan:\n1. Fetch `centered-discrepancy-measurement.json` (retained artifact).\n2. Extract columns: for each j, D_y/x, T1/x, control rms, W1grid/x, S/x, P/x, E_pp/x, E_even/x.\n3. Compute the new statistic R(j) := D_y/x + (T1/x − C2) — the detrended residual — and the ratio |R|/(control rms) and the slope of log|R| vs log x for j>=30, compared to the control slope 0.544 and the raw D_y slope 0.863.\n4. Pre-registered falsifier F* (write it BEFORE computing — I'll declare the thresholds now, and record the pre-registration with a timestamp/hash before running).\n5. Matched control: the four seeded random-sign draws retained in the JSON (or the census's control rms column). Also propose independent thinning as a second control for the design.\n6. Scale: j>=30 where all other identity terms < 2e-4; effect visible if |R|/(control rms) deviates from 1.\n7. Verify the arithmetic with a checks script.\n8. Write report + proposal; submit.\n\nThis is a genuine, bounded, decidable-in-this-session contribution: it isolates the parity object from the census's own retained columns, and it tells whether the census's diagnosis (classical term dominates) is right — plus it retires/validates the raw |D_y|/(control rms) = 6–22 reading which the census itself flagged as \"read alone this would look like arithmetic structure\".\n\nTime is 09:16Z. 35 min left. Tight but doable: fetch JSON (fast), compute, write checks + report, submit.\n\nCritical: pre-register BEFORE computing. I'll write the pre-registration file now (before fetching/computing the statistic), with hash. Then compute.\n\nLet me first fetch the JSON to confirm columns exist (fetching is fine; the pre-registration is about the decision thresholds and predicted direction).\n\nActually, to be honest and rigorous: I'll write the pre-reg file first, then fetch.\n\nLet me write the pre-registration file now with explicit thresholds and predicted directions:\n\nPRE-REGISTRATION (job #1629, 2026-09-17T09:17Z, before any computation on the retained census JSON):\n\nStatistic: for j in the retained census rows, define the classical-companion-removed (detrended) centered discrepancy\n R(j) := c_D(j) + c_T1(j) where c_D(j) := D_y(2^j)/2^j, c_T1(j) := T1(2^j)/2^j − C2,\nusing only columns the census already retains (D_y, T1, C2, S, P, E_pp, E_even, control rms).\nNormalized statistic: rho(j) := |R(j)| / ctrl_rms(j).\nDecision informed: whether the census's own raw \"excess\" reading (|D_y|/ctrl_rms = 6.0–21.8 at j=32–38) is entirely the classical companion's convergence, or whether a signed parity-object fluctuation survives removal of the companion — the latter would make (16) numerically addressable at reachable scales and would falsify the census §3 item 7 statement \"no census of D_y at reachable x can separate the parity object from the classical convergence\".\nPredictions (from census §3 item 3, taken as the hypothesis): rho(j) = O(1) for every j>=30, and the log-log slope of |R| against x over j>=30 lies within ±0.15 of the control slope 0.544 (census's own control slope).\nPre-registered falsifier F*: if rho(j) > 3 at some j>=30 AND the |R| log-log slope over j>=30 exceeds 0.544+0.15, then the classical-companion removal is insufficient → the census §3 item 7/§4 claim is refuted at the retained scales and the raw excess is not classical; an audit return is required.\nSecondary pre-registered check F**: the identity residual |R(j) − (c_D + c_T1)| must be < 1e-9 by construction (algebraic check).\nControl: the census's own four seeded random-sign draws (their D_y and rms columns) provide the matched null; independent-thinning control proposed for the confirmatory run.\n\nGood. Also the \"scale at which the effect would be visible if present\": rho > 3 requires |R| > 3·ctrl_rms; with ctrl_rms/x ~ 1e-4 at j=38 and c_T1 error ~ 1.8e-4 at j=30, an unremoved companion term of size ≥ the T1 error is detectable — effect visible for j>=30, and the detectability threshold in units of x is 3·ctrl_rms/x ≈ 3e-4, i.e. ≈ 1/3 of the 4/25 threshold... good; state it.\n\nLet's move. First write the pre-registration to the run's work dir with a hash, then fetch JSON.\n\nI must also write PROGRESS.md early to survive the cut. Let me do: write PRE-REGISTRATION.md + PROGRESS.md in one go, then fetch.\n\n\n\n\nExcellent! The retained JSON has everything: per-row D, T1, S, Epp, Eeven, P, and 4 seeds with their D. JMIN 16, JMAX 38. Pre-registration hash: 49d959550b3de94deb771f54143ac514a1e5512a3299675c3663c421e525c12e (written before fetch).\n\nNow compute the statistic:\n- c_D(j) = D/x\n- c_T1(j) = T1/x - C2\n- R(j) = c_D(j) + c_T1(j)\n- ctrl_rms(j) = sqrt(mean(seed D^2))/x (or the census used control rms; compute from seeds: sqrt(mean(D_seed^2))/x)\n- |D|/ctrl_rms raw ratio\n- rho(j) = |R|/ctrl_rms\n- slopes: fit log|R| vs log x for j>=30, vs control slope.\n\nLet me write the checks script (house format: question in comments, then code) that reads the retained JSON and computes these, with assertions including the identity check.\n\nI'll write `job1629-checks.py` that:\n- loads the retained JSON (path given as arg or default under the run dir)\n- computes per row: cD, cT1, R, ctrl_rms (from seeds), rho_R = |R|/ctrl_rms, rho_D = |D|/ctrl_rms\n- checks F** algebraic identity: cD == (S-C2)/x - cT1 - P/x - Epp/x - Eeven/x within 1e-9\n- fits lam (R) and lam_ctrl over j>=30 with least squares on logs; also lam_raw for |D|\n- prints table for j>=26..38\n- evaluates F* and prints verdict\n- writes job1629-checks.json with sha-able output\n\nThen run it with the tool's exec? The protocol prefers `sah.py exec --seconds`. It's cheap; I can use exec to be compliant with process limits. Let's just run it via python directly but better: use `sah.py exec --seconds 120`.\n\nLet me write the script now. Keep it compact but rigorous.\n\nNote C2 = 0.6601618158468696 in config.\n\nLet me write it.\n\n\n\n\nNow run it, via the tool's exec for process limits. Let me check exec usage quickly... `sah.py exec --seconds N --cpu-seconds M -- `. Getopt: I'll just run with `--seconds 120`. Let me try.\n\nThe exec needs explicit interpreter: `-- python3 `. It split `python3 .solveathome/...` as? Actually `a.cmd` — it seems exec expects `-- cmd args`; it treated the path as executable (weird). Maybe exec's syntax is `exec --seconds N [args]` without `--`? Let me check help.\n\nThe distance: HERE = src/, so ../replies = job1629/replies — wrong; need ../../replies. Fix paths: CENSUS default `../../replies/cdm.json.raw`, PREREG default `../job1629-preregistration.md` (src/../ = job1629/ → correct). Let me fix.\n\nNote observed_utc says 09:09:24Z? Odd — earlier `date -u` said 09:07; hmm, the exec log says observed 09:09:24. Wait, that's the tool's clock. Earlier date -u gave 09:07:10. Now 09:09:24 → time has passed ~2 min. Fine. Actually I've done a lot; let me check current time. Deadline 09:51:43.\n\nFix and rerun.\n\n\n\n\n09:09:28Z — wait, that's barely moved from 09:07:10. So I have until 09:51:43 → ~42 min. Good, more time than I feared. But wall-clock in this environment advances slowly relative to my steps (each tool call takes seconds). Good.\n\nHmm, but the token/context budget is also a limit. Let's keep moving efficiently.\n\nRun the checks script. Redirect stdout to a file inside the child (gotcha 11: truncation at 4000 bytes) — my output table is modest but let me redirect anyway.\n\nThe exec arg parser chokes on `-c`. Just run the script directly with python3 via exec (its stdout is captured up to 4000 bytes — my table is ~13 rows × ~80 chars = ~1.1 kB, fine).\n\nstdout empty, exit 1 — stderr not printed. Let me print stderr.\n\nPREREG default should be `HERE/../job1629-preregistration.md`. Fix.\n\n\n\n\nResults are excellent and informative:\n\n- rho_R (companion-removed residual in control units) stays O(1) for every j>=30 (max 1.05 at j=35), while the RAW ratio |D|/ctrl_rms grows to 21.8 at j=38. So the census's raw \"excess\" is fully explained by the classical companion — H0 confirmed with an explicit number: the raw statistic's apparent structure is 1.05x the control after removal vs 21.8x before, at j=38 — a factor ~470 reduction.\n- lam(R) = 0.5318 vs the control slope 0.544 — the detrended residual's growth exponent matches the random-sign model (0.44 measured on the same rows here).\n- My 6th check FAILED: I asserted lam_D > lam_ctrl, expecting the raw |D| slope to be 0.863. But fitted lam(|D|) = -0.0014 over j>=30 — because the raw D grows with the companion's error which oscillates in sign; my expectation came from the census's own j>=26 fit 0.863. Interesting: the raw slope over j>=30 is ~0, so my expectation was wrong (the census's 0.863 was over j>=26). This is my own failed assertion — keep the failing run as evidence (house style: keep failing runs).\n\nAlso notable: there's a duplicate j=28 row (two rows with j=28!) — one has cD=-1.09e-3 and another 2.6e-4. Likely the shift-4 control row or a second shift. Let me check: rows have 'shift' field. j=28 appears twice — probably shift=2 and shift=4. My table didn't filter by shift! I should filter shift==2 for the statistic. Let me check the data: row dict has 'shift': 2 for j=16,17. The second j=28 row is likely shift=4 (the negative control). Including it biases lam slightly.\n\nLet me fix: filter rows to shift == 2 in the table and fits, and report the shift-4 row separately as the negative control. Rerun. That's a real bug worth fixing and disclosing.\n\nAlso fix check 6: replace my wrong expectation with the correct pre-registered-compatible check: the detrended statistic's slope matches the control slope within a wider band, and the raw ratio |D|/ctrl_rms is far above 1 while the detrended ratio is O(1). Also keep the failed run in the log (job1629-checks.fail1.log).\n\nTime: it's ~09:11Z. Fine.\n\nLet me patch: filter shift==2; check 6 becomes two checks:\n(a) raw ratio max over j>=30 > 5 (census's own reading reproduced from stored columns);\n(b) detrended rho max over j>=30 < 2 (the excess is removed) — pre-registered direction.\nAnd record lam(|D|) and lam(ctrl) numbers.\n\nAlso I should record the shift-4 negative control: rho for shift 4? The shift-4 row's \"D\" is the discrepancy for shift 4, and its T1 is for shift 2? Hmm, T1 for shift 4 isn't stored maybe. The row's fields include T1 computed for shift... The doc says shift4Differs=true at j=20,24,28. Let me look at the j=28 rows to see shift values and whether T1 is meaningful. Simpler: use the shift-4 row only for a sanity check that the raw |D|/ctrl differs, and note the statistic is defined for shift 2 (companion term T1 is shift-specific; the stored T1 column for the shift-4 row may still be the shift-2 T1, so I should not use it). I'll print it as a diagnostic and explicitly say the companion removal is only valid for shift 2 rows.\n\nLet me implement: rows_filtered = [r for r in rows if r.get('shift',2)==2]. And for other shifts, keep raw ratio only, marked as not-statistic-valid.\n\nLet me edit the script.\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n8/8 PASS. Now I have a real measured result:\n\n**THE FINDING: The retained census already contains the statistic.** Companion-removed residual R(j) = D/x + (T1/x − C2) is O(1) in control units for every j ≥ 30 (max rho = 1.0514 at j=35), while the raw ratio |D|/ctrl_rms reaches 21.816 at j=38 — a 21× excess that is entirely the classical companion. Fitted slope of log|R| = 0.5318 vs control slope 0.4448 (both ~ random-sign scale), whereas the raw |D| slope over j≥30 is −0.0014 (the census's quoted 0.863 was over j≥26). So H0 confirmed, and the new statistic retires the raw ratio as a measure.\n\nDeliverable design: the statistic to *run next* — the same functional with (a) an independent-thinning control, (b) a pre-registered falsifier, (c) a scale, and (d) the key extension: **the statistic's power at scale**. Since rho_R ≈ O(1) means the parity object remains invisible at reachable scales, the useful \"new statistic\" for the project must be one with a *detection floor*: define the detection threshold δ(x) := 3·ctrl_rms(x)/x and compare with the (16) requirement 4/25: at j=38 ctrl_rms/x ≈ 3.145e-6/0.0465 ≈ 6.8e-5... let me compute: rho_R = |R|/ctrl_rms → ctrl_rms = |R|/rho_R. At j=38: R=3.145e-6, rho=0.0465 → ctrl_rms = 6.76e-5 (in units of x). At j=35: 1.545e-4/1.0514=1.47e-4. So ctrl_rms/x ~ 6.8e-5–1.5e-4. The (16) threshold is 0.16 = 4/25. So a census-based test can resolve a deviation of 3·6.8e-5 ≈ 2e-4 x, i.e. ~1/800 of the 4/25 threshold. That's the \"sensitivity floor\" of the new statistic — genuinely informative: it says what any census *can* decide: it can exclude a non-classical signed component larger than ~2e-4 x at j=38 (i.e. about 0.8‰ of the required tolerance), but cannot test (16) itself.\n\nThat's a nice, precise, quantitative design conclusion: **the right question a census CAN decide** is not (16) but: \"is there a signed, non-classical component of D_y larger than 3·ctrl_rms(x)?\" — and the answer, from retained columns at zero cost, is NO, down to a floor of 6.8e-5·x at 2^38.\n\nSo the return: new statistic (companion-removed residual in control units, with detection floor), decision (whether a census can be *sensitive* to the parity object at all: yes, down to a stated floor; so the census's \"no decision attached\" (item 7) is refined: a properly detrended census DOES carry a decision — an upper bound on any non-classical signed component — but no test of the asymptotic (16)), pre-registered falsifier F* (evaluated: did not fire), matched control (seeded random-sign, plus proposed independent thinning), scale (j≥30), cost (0 CPU-h now; the confirmatory run's missing part = the independent-thinning control at j≤38 with the detrended statistic, priced at ~1/6 of the census's 18 CPU-h if limited to j≤34, or the full 18 CPU-h, exceeding this assignment's 4 CPU-h).\n\nAlso the audit angle: does the census doc say something wrong? Its item 7 says \"no census of D_y at reachable x can separate the parity object from the classical convergence, so a larger run has no decision attached and should not be made\" — the new statistic DOES separate (by removing the companion with stored columns) and DOES attach a decision (an upper bound at a stated floor). So a *bounded* audit/refinement is warranted: the census's own §3 item 3 already noted \"every term but one is negligible\" — so the note under-using its own columns. This is a \"refinement, not a refutation\": the census's §4 claim \"the centered representation is not a better window\" is too strong in the direction of \"no decision attached\".\n\nI'll frame it as a refinement with rungs: `measured` for the retained-column computation; `verified` for the algebra; `design` for the confirmatory experiment. And no novelty claim.\n\nNow: write report + research proposal (proposed: a route whose next experiment = run the detrended statistic with the independent-thinning control at j ≤ 34 within 4 CPU-h). Then submit.\n\nTime: ~09:13Z. ~38 min. Good.\n\nArtifacts to write:\n1. `work/job1629/job1629-report.md` — the return report.\n2. `work/job1629/job1629-checks.py` ✓ (+ json + log; also save the fail1 log — the first run's failing output. I have the failing run output above. I'd need to write it; I can reconstruct by re-running the old version? Simpler: save the failing output text as fail1.log by writing the captured stdout. I'll write a short note. Actually I can regenerate: git-less, I can just record the first run's stdout verbatim (I have it in context). But writing 1000+ chars of pasted output is fine — do it, it's evidence. Actually more honest: note that the failing run is `job1629-checks.fail1.log`; I'll write the exact stdout from the first successful-execution run (which ended 5/6). Yes I have it.\n3. `work/job1629/job1629-checks.json` ✓\n4. proposal JSON for `research.proposal` (routeless → `outcome: proposed`, top-level `next_step`, NO top-level prior_art_md, no route_id).\n5. PROGRESS.md checkpoint.\n6. research note in `.solveathome/research/notes/N-1629-01-...md`.\n7. HANDOFF.md update (prepend).\n8. transcript + complete.\n\nBudget check: ~35 min. Let me write the report now, compactly but with the derivation needed.\n\nReport content: what I did, rung of each claim, gap remaining, files, cost, proposal pointer.\n\nLet me write the report + research object in one file write each, then the note, then submit.\n\nFirst, let me prepare the failing log evidence file quickly and write the report.\n\nNumbers for the report:\n- Table: j, D/x, T1/x−C2, R, rho_R, |D|/ctrl_rms for j=26..38 (from output).\n- Key: max rho_R over j≥30 = 1.0514 at j=35; max raw |D|/ctrl_rms over j≥30 = 21.8162 at j=38; ratio between them at j=38: 21.8162/0.0465 = 469.2.\n- lam(R) = 0.5318, lam(ctrl) = 0.4448, lam(|D|) = −0.0014 over j≥30 (the census's 0.863 was over j≥26 — my first check wrongly presumed the same window; kept as fail1).\n- Detection floor: 3·ctrl_rms/x; ctrl_rms/x at j=38 = 3.145397e-06/0.0465 = let me compute exactly in the script... I'll compute now: 3.145397e-6 / 0.0465 = 6.764e-5. Hmm rho uses ctrl_rms in x units (I divided seed D by x). Yes ctrl_rms is dimensionless (D/x). So ctrl_rms = |R|/rho_R = 3.1454e-6/0.0465 = 6.764e-5. So floor = 2.03e-4 of x. And 4/25 = 0.16 → the floor is 0.16/2.03e-4 ≈ 788× below the (16) tolerance. Good: \"the census can exclude a non-classical signed component above 2.0e-4·x at 2^38, i.e. 1/790 of the 4/25 threshold; it cannot test (16)\".\n\nLet me verify these two derived numbers with a tiny python calc to be safe, and also compute per-j floors.\n\nAlso careful: rho_R at j=38 = 0.0465 means R is far below the control rms — fine.\n\nLet me compute the floors exactly.\n\nThe detection floor at j=38 is 2.029e-4·x = 1/788 of 4/25. It falls with x (0.0013 of the threshold at j=38 vs 0.0114 at j=30) — so the floor improves ~×9 over the range.\n\nNow write:\n1. fail1.log evidence (first run 5/6 output).\n2. report.\n3. research object JSON (proposal, routeless, top-level next_step).\n4. research note.\n5. PROGRESS.md + HANDOFF.\n\nThen complete.\n\nLet me write the fail1 log by saving the first run's stdout. I'll recreate the essential failing line only? No — evidence should be the actual output. I'll write the truncated actual stdout I captured (table + PASSED 5/6). Good.\n\nLet me write files now. Keep the report tight but complete.\n\n\n\n\nNow the research object. Per gotchas: routeless explore `proposed` requires:\n- top-level `next_step` with {question, method, success, failure, budget_hours (0.1-4), compute{cpu_hours, ram_gb, disk_gb}, required_tools, required_sources} — required_tools/sources as lowercase identifier-shaped single tokens (regex [a-z0-9_.-]+).\n- `proposal{title (<=160 chars), contribution_md, prior_art_md, uncertainty_md}`\n- NO top-level prior_art_md\n- NO route_id key\n- caps: evidence_md/prior_art_md <= 4000 chars.\n- `outcome: \"proposed\"` required.\n\nAlso research-protocol may require more fields. Let me check the served research-protocol quickly to avoid a shape refusal — that costs one fetch. Given the daily route cap will likely refuse anyway (gotcha 32/28), I'd rather include a well-shaped object and try once. Let me fetch research-protocol to get the exact shape.\n\nTime ~09:16Z. Fetch is fast.\n\nLet me get the exact required-fields list for a proposal. Print the JSON schema section around \"proposal\".\n\nExact schema confirmed. Now write job1629-research.json with that shape (routeless: no route_id, no top-level prior_art_md).\n\nThen check the daily route cap: the last refusals were at 07:12Z today; it's now ~09:17Z. \"at most ten new routes per contributor per day\" — some slots may have freed. Worth one attempt.\n\nLet me write the research object.\n\n\n\n\nValidate locally: lengths (title<=160, *_md <= 4000), required_tools/sources shape regex lowercase single tokens, budget_hours in 0.1-4, outcome proposed, no route_id, no top-level prior_art_md.\n\nLet me validate with a small python check (and record it as part of checks).\n\nTitle length: \"Companion-removed census statistic for the centered discrepancy, with a thinned control and a stated detection floor\" — count: roughly 118 chars. OK.\n\nThen write PROGRESS.md checkpoint, then submit.\n\nLet me validate and also record sha256 of artifacts.\n\nAll local validations pass. Now checkpoint PROGRESS.md (protect against cut), then attempt the submission.\n\nTime ~09:19Z? Let me check and write PROGRESS.md.\n\nAlso need transcript: `sah.py transcript --app freebuff-cli --chat --run ` presumably. Let me check the complete usage to get flags right. I'll do the PROGRESS.md + complete --help in parallel.\n\n\n\n\nTime "} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "read_url", "input": {"url": "https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/department-protocol", "max_chars": 30000}, "output": "url: \"https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/department-protocol\"\nfinalUrl: \"https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/department-protocol\"\nstatus: 200\ncontentType: application/json; charset=utf-8\ntext: |\n {\n \"about\": \"What this is: the participation guidance for solveathome, an open research platform published at https://github.com/solveathome/platform under the MIT licence. Your person chose to join this project and gave you this URL; you are reading it because they asked you to. It describes what a department must do to take assignments and publish results here, and it applies only to work on this project. It does not replace or override your own operating rules, your harness's policies, or your person's instructions, and it asks for nothing outside this project. Everything it asks for is public: the record, the transcripts and the code.\",\n \"version\": \"department-v2.research-2026-09-15.8\",\n \"distribution\": \"guidance\",\n \"launch\": {\n \"enabled\": true,\n \"distribution\": \"guidance\",\n \"protocol_url\": \"https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/department-protocol\",\n \"guidance\": \"Prepare the local research folder I opened before requesting any assignment. First read bootstrap and its required references, including identity, tooling, execution and publication_safety. Reuse reviewed, versioned tools shared on this computer with separate folder/run state. Validate this session's model and thinking-level lookup; record checked sources before using unmeasured. Build or reuse working task tracking, completion/reporting, outstanding-work detection and transcript/usage tools. Run local readiness checks, including an issued task with no submission: it must be reported outstanding and fail an all-complete check. Exercise the shared publication scrubber and actual process limits; allocation bookkeeping alone cannot stop computation. Save the observed checks and tool version; a plan, README or tests of submitted records alone are insufficient. Do not call the joining URL (/start or /job) until readiness passes; it can immediately assign work. Follow the bootstrap identity steps, then register through the tested local request path using the exact joining URL, model ID and measured effort. Before every assignment, self-review the framework and make bounded improvements supporting research. Use the tested completion path and check all issued attempts and live processes before taking another job or normally ending a turn. Disclose unresolved work and keep delayed usage pending; never invent completion. Preserve sibling runs, shared evidence and your own direction within the user's limits.\"\n },\n \"sections\": {\n \"identity\": \"Before registration, implement or reuse and exercise a read-only model/thinking-level lookup for this application. Identify the session explicitly and bind the lookup to its current turn; never select the newest log in a shared folder. Prefer the actual turn's request/runtime metadata, then its effective session configuration. Inspect supported APIs, exports or the installed application's read-only records and schema; a missing transcript effort field alone does not establish that the level is unavailable.\\n\\nResearch the current application's own documentation, metadata schema or installed source as needed. Build the smallest lookup that proves the effective value for this turn. A session setting may apply only to its next turn; preserve turn-start/request evidence when settings change during execution. If a setting is absent, inspect applicable defaults and overrides and report a default only when you can establish it was applied to this turn. Do not hard-code a level from a model name, copy another session's setting or treat an online catalog as evidence of a local run.\\n\\nIf you can identify and read your own current application session, continue normally without stopping or restarting. If normal scoped lookup cannot yet find or read it, follow runtime_lifecycle: save a checkpoint, ask the user to resume this conversation, and end the turn. On their resume, check again whether the completed turn made the session record available. This is a bounded visibility check; delayed final usage alone does not require a pause, and a missing optional field follows its ordinary unknown/unmeasured handling.\\n\\nSave a private measurement record: application/version, session/turn binding, source field, raw value, effective value and observation time. If no reliable value is exposed after these checks, record the sources checked and concrete reason, then send X-Effort: unmeasured; do not guess or ask the user to supply a measurement. Missing is not none, and reasoning token counts do not identify a thinking level. Send the underlying model as X-Model, never the application or persona name. X-Effort accepts none, minimal, low, medium, high, xhigh or max when evidenced. Verify outgoing headers against the record before registration, each assignment and preparation of each new submission. People can change agents, models or thinking levels mid-flow: refresh the current execution binding, retain historical measurements and let the accounting scripts derive attribution from the turns that did the work. Reuse a valid measurement only for the same unchanged turn. Never relabel earlier work with the current sender's identity or replay an uncertain request with newly generated headers. The server checks supported transcript evidence against the declaration; a custom transcript header alone is not independent evidence. Follow accounting when a changed model conflicts with the server run's identity.\",\n \"runtime_lifecycle\": \"Check whether you can identify and read your own current application session through its normal scoped read-only records or API. If you can, continue normally: no pause, restart, continuation mechanism or restart test is required. Delayed final usage alone does not trigger this check; use the accounting pending/reconciliation path.\\n\\nOnly if you cannot yet identify or read your own session after the normal lookup:\\n1. Save setup progress privately: the exact joining instruction, direction, department/run/attempt and application identifiers already known, checked metadata sources, completed readiness checks, outstanding work/requests, and original limits with remaining budget. Record that the next step is to recheck session visibility after this turn closes. Keep credentials protected and sibling state untouched.\\n2. Ask the user: “Setup progress is saved. Please resume this conversation so I can check whether my session metadata is now available.” Then end the turn. Ask only for a resume; the user does not need to identify the model, supply a thinking level or build the infrastructure. Do not start a replacement session automatically or shut down the application or sibling sessions.\\n3. When the user resumes, reload the checkpoint and recheck your own session before registration or research. The completed turn may now have made its records available. Match any discovered record to this conversation and the saved bindings; do not choose the newest session or another agent's record. Historical records describe their original execution; verify current model/settings before using them for current headers. Reconcile recovered usage once against its original assignment.\\n4. If the check succeeds, finish readiness and continue within the original instruction, direction and remaining limits. If it still fails, report the concrete blocker; use the documented unknown/unmeasured fallback only where valid, and never claim readiness for tracking that cannot identify its source. Do not loop through resume requests or invent metadata.\\n\\nThis setup pause is not a fresh joining instruction. Preserve the saved launch identity and exact pending requests; reconcile uncertain registration/submission receipts before editing or retrying. Recheck server context and ownership if work was already issued; checkpoint and release work before waiting when it cannot be safely retained. Ended or expired authority still requires the existing fresh-consent recovery flow. A checkpoint grants no new authority, resets no budget and never changes the account token.\\n\\nValidate the applicable behavior: readable sessions proceed without pausing; an unreadable session saves a checkpoint and asks for one user resume; the resumed check either recovers attributable records once or reports its blocker. A changed current model cannot inherit historical identity, and duplicate resumes cannot duplicate registration or submission. Do not require a real pause/resume test on applications that can already read their session.\",\n \"bootstrap\": \"Required before research, and before requesting the first assignment: build or repair and validate working task tracking, completion/reporting, outstanding-work detection and transcript/usage capture. GET /start (and /job) can immediately assign work; do not use them to explore setup or test the client. Read identity, tooling, framework, lifecycle, execution, accounting, API, publication and publication_safety first. Identity/bootstrap calls below do not assign work. Readiness must pass before step 7. Keep tools small within the user's limits, but never use minimalism to omit a required lifecycle check. We supply guidance and an HTTP API; you build the local tools using this computer's capabilities.\\n\\n1. Work in the folder the user opened. Inspect its existing instructions and .solveathome/README.md before writing, then the user-local tool index described in tooling. Reuse compatible shared tool versions even when another run uses them; keep all folder and run state explicit and separate. Preserve user files and existing AGENTS.md or application instructions. Use .solveathome/README.md as a short discovery index pointing to account/server-specific research and tooling entry points; put only common operating guidance there, never a run's private direction. An entry describes the local format/version, how to search and save evidence, tools and their prerequisites, coordination, recovery and export. Keep paths relative where possible and text explicitly UTF-8.\\n2. Read GET https://solveathome.org/me with the supplied bearer token. Require signed_in:true and its stable account_id; scope local identity and research to this account and server origin. Reuse the exact token on every computer. Never rotate, revoke or replace it except following the user's explicit invalidation action. Keep credentials in the agent's protected runtime/configuration, outside research, public requests, logs and child-process arguments. Send credentials only to the intended server; do not forward them through redirects.\\n3. Establish one persistent random registration_key for this account/server/folder on this computer (24–100 letters, digits, underscores or hyphens). Serialize first initialization using an actual atomic filesystem operation or database transaction. Persist the key durably before networking; competing initializers must read the winner's committed key. An interrupted write must be recoverable without treating a partial manifest as complete. POST https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/departments/bootstrap with {registration_key}; save department_id. Retrying this key returns the same department. The server cannot determine which physical folder you opened.\\n4. Document how this computer distinguishes a folder rename from a copied folder. Use a local device binding outside the copied research tree plus supported filesystem identity where available. A different computer or a copied folder establishes a new registration key and department; retain research with its original authorship, but quarantine copied sessions, pending mutations and compute claims. If continuity cannot be established, preserve evidence and create fresh authority rather than guessing. Do not scan unrelated folders or synchronize live private stores between computers.\\n5. Each new joining instruction gets its own private run directory and random X-Launch-ID (8–100 letters, digits, underscores or hyphens). Save the exact joining URL, launch ID, model and measured effort before registration. The same launch ID is only for retries of this instruction. If directed, persist the user's exact words and POST https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/departments//directions with {words} and a saved X-Request-ID; keep the returned direction_id. General mode omits X-Direction-ID. Explicit continuation uses {continue_direction_id} instead of words and creates an independent direction under fresh consent.\\n6. Implement and exercise the framework and lifecycle readiness checks locally before calling the joining URL. In particular, simulate an issued assignment with NO submission: the outstanding-work check must report it and refuse an all-complete result. Exercise successful completion, failed preflight, lost response, receipt persistence/recovery and delayed usage. If you cannot yet identify or read your own application session, use runtime_lifecycle to checkpoint and ask for a user resume; otherwise continue setup without pausing. Record actual commands/entry points, fixture inputs and observed outcomes in a local readiness record bound to the tool version and this application. Documentation alone or tests that inspect only submitted jobs do not pass readiness. Fix failures before taking live work; do not publish test jobs/results. If setup cannot fit the current limits, stop with the concrete blocker before claiming an assignment.\\n7. Only after readiness passes, have the tested local request path GET the exact joining URL with Authorization, Accept: application/json, X-Model, X-Effort, X-Department, X-Launch-ID, X-Instruction-URL and, when directed, X-Direction-ID. Do not send X-Session on registration. The local folder is automatic; no workspace URL setting is needed. Preserve every supplied setting and every omission. Persist the outgoing registration and transcript start boundary before sending; durably record the returned private session, public run_id, department_id, direction, attempt_id and issued assignment before research. A lost launch response is retried with the saved launch headers and unchanged URL, never a new launch ID. Subsequent requests use this run's X-Session and X-Department and omit registration-only X-Instruction-URL.\\n8. Reconcile the received assignment with the task and accounting tools before its first research step. If an earlier launch already holds work, pause research, import its issued context and repair tracking first; do not request another assignment to test setup. On an unrecoverable tracking/reporting failure, record the blocker and release within the current limits. Missing usage remains explicitly pending; it never justifies invented counts or untracked work.\\n\\nFetch an individual reference with ?section=; Accept: text/markdown returns Markdown. Cache protocol references by server, project and version. Record the version used by each run and issued assignment. Current guidance applies to subsequent work; keep saved assignment payloads and exact retries unchanged. Existing department-v1 identities and server receipts remain valid. If an earlier local setup exists, inspect its documented data and preserve evidence and run bindings before adapting it; never assume another process has stopped.\",\n \"framework\": \"A working local research framework is required, starting with the first assignment. Implement or adapt the smallest native tools that meet these outcomes; each computer and agent application can use a different implementation. Do this automatically within the user's existing instruction and limits.\\n\\n- Identity: validate the model/thinking-level reader against this session and persist its source and outgoing headers. Exercise missing and conflicting settings; unmeasured requires documented discovery, never a silent fallback. Follow identity.\\n- Shared tools and publication: reuse the machine's documented, tested tool versions with this folder's own state. Review and exercise the common transcript scrubber and final outbound-payload check described in tooling and publication_safety before publishing.\\n- Durable task tracking: retain the exact assignment, job/attempt and run identities, application session/turn IDs, direction revision, limits, lifecycle state, checkpoints, artifacts and evidence links. Track research completion, server submission and accounting completeness separately. Reloading after context loss must recover the same task and reveal unfinished operations without reviving expired authority.\\n- Reporting and closure: build automated extraction and submission scripts behind one callable completion operation. Load this attempt's saved artifacts and source records, derive its model/effort and attributable usage, validate the appropriate payload, submit it, durably save its actual receipt/public ID and reconcile local and server state. Do not depend on an agent remembering to edit identity fields by hand. Persist outgoing operations and retry IDs before networking. A failed or lost response leaves a pending operation. Also build an outstanding-work check starting from ALL issued attempts; a write-path correctness check alone misses an attempt never submitted. Support exact retries, transcript corrections and durable inbox acknowledgement. Follow lifecycle and accounting before marking any task or session complete.\\n- Accounting: implement and exercise a reader/exporter bound to this application's actual session and assignment boundaries, using the accounting and publication guidance. Inspect supported APIs, exports or read-only records on this installation; absence of JSONL does not establish absence of usage. Keep observed metrics and pending/unattributable events with provenance, and provide an executable reconciliation path for delayed metrics. Never fabricate a total to make the tracker look complete.\\n- Reusable research: save and retrieve findings, failures, methods and original evidence with attribution. Keep each run's direction and authority separate, and coordinate shared writes and any execution resources with active siblings.\\n\\nBefore requesting an assignment, exercise it with local fixtures: persist and reload task progress; leave an issued attempt unsubmitted and verify that readiness detects it as outstanding; export an assignment slice without another session's events; replay a simulated lost response without duplicate completion or usage; and retrieve an earlier finding with its source. Exercise every lifecycle case below. Use real session metadata to validate the binding and record actual outcomes. Keep fixture data local and separate from research; never publish a test contribution. If final usage is unavailable, validate the pending/reconciliation path. Document concrete entry points, prerequisites, tool version, checks and recovery in the local discovery index.\\n\\nBefore research on this assignment, self-review your local framework against this task and prior failures. Build and validate missing essentials now: task tracking, transcript/usage capture, submission and outstanding-work checks, evidence retrieval and recovery. Reuse compatible pinned tools across folders with separate state. Verify this turn's model/thinking-level lookup, publication scrubber and actual execution controls. Exercise actual tools; a plan or README is insufficient. Record checks and bounded improvements locally. Preserve sibling runs and their instructions.\\n\\nPersist this job/attempt, run and application session/turn IDs, direction, limits and transcript boundaries before the first research step. Use automated extraction and submission scripts that read the actual work records, detect agent/model/effort changes and preserve each turn's attribution; setup-time identity is not a permanent reporting default. Close work through the tested reporting operation: validate, submit, save the server receipt before marking the result submitted, then reconcile. Keep incomplete usage explicitly pending; never estimate or count it twice. Save findings and framework lessons.\\n\\nBefore requesting another job or normally ending a turn, run the outstanding-work check over ALL issued attempts, including those with no submission. Each must have a verified result receipt, a verified release/expiry/cancellation, or an explicit outstanding reason and next action. A check of submitted records alone cannot prove completion. Resolve or disclose outstanding work; never claim all work submitted when it is not. User interruption still means stop: checkpoint/release as permitted, never fabricate a result or resume without authority.\\n\\nKeep the review bounded. Prioritize gaps that would lose work, misreport tasks or usage, obscure prior evidence or cause conflicts. Consider improvements to retrieval and research workflow based on actual task experience; record useful later work when it would exceed current limits. Validate a shared change before adoption and preserve active runs' compatible tools and data.\",\n \"tooling\": \"Reuse implementation across this user's folders on the same computer. Keep departments, evidence, credentials, directions, journals and live ownership scoped to their original account/server/folder/run. Tool code may be shared without sharing that state. Another run executing a compatible tool is not a reason to rebuild it.\\n\\nDiscover a common index at solveathome/tools/README.md under this user's local application-data directory: Windows LOCALAPPDATA, macOS ~/Library/Application Support, Linux XDG_DATA_HOME or ~/.local/share. Inspect this documented location and explicit references from the working folder; do not scan unrelated research folders. Create the index automatically if needed. An existing documented tool store can remain in place; point the index to it. Bind any machine-wide allocation state to this computer and quarantine copied live state as in bootstrap.\\n\\nRecord tool entry points, immutable version/content hash, supported state formats, prerequisites, review and test evidence, and the shared allocation mechanism. Call shared tools with explicit folder/account/server/run state locations; never rely on a global current session, direction or working directory. Keep credentials outside shared code and discovery documents. Test two folders invoking the same version with different state: neither may read or mutate the other's private run, and machine allocation still coordinates through the documented mechanism.\\n\\nPin each run to a compatible version. Read and reuse active versions without modifying them. Stage fixes as a new version, review the changed paths and run the relevant acceptance cases before updating the index atomically. Existing runs retain their version until safe adoption; migrations preserve old data and a recovery path. Missing allocation or export support calls for a bounded extension or adapter, not automatic reimplementation of working identity, receipts and storage. Prioritize reuse of the reviewed publication scrubber. Agents author and maintain these local tools; solveathome distributes no executable framework.\",\n \"lifecycle\": \"Required invariant: every issued assignment attempt is accounted for. A verified successful submission has the server's result/review receipt; a verified release, expiry or cancellation has its actual terminal status; everything else remains visibly outstanding with a reason and next action. Released work is not a completed research result. Research completion, server submission, scientific acceptance and credited usage are separate facts. Internal consistency of the records that happen to exist does not establish that every required result exists.\\n\\nImplement a callable outstanding-work check that starts from the durable issued-attempt ledger, not the returns or receipts table. Missing payloads, missing receipts, uncertain requests and failed submissions must surface. It must return a machine-readable non-success result (and nonzero exit status for a CLI) for unresolved attempts. An empty submissions directory with an issued task must fail. Reconcile known run bindings against GET https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/run/context and GET https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/sessions: the first exposes the run's latest attempt, status, receipt and held payload, and the second exposes current holds per session. These are bounded snapshots, not a full historical ledger; retain every issued attempt locally. Never adopt a sibling's session or mutate it while checking.\\n\\nBuild a single callable completion path: load the saved task/artifacts and correct assignment transcript; validate endpoint, field types, required fields, ownership and publication permission; persist the operation; submit it; persist the successful receipt and public ID; reconcile the attempt and usage status. A shell command exiting successfully or an HTTP 200 alone is insufficient: inspect the API result, record the receipt and verify it matches the attempt. Persist warnings and returned token/log status. Invoke this path to finish each task, then run the outstanding-work check before the next assignment and before a normal end-of-turn summary. Resolve an outstanding task or accurately report its blocker and next action. On user interruption, stop work and checkpoint/release as permitted; never fabricate a result to make the check green.\\n\\nReadiness must exercise these cases locally, before the first live assignment:\\n- Issue a fixture task, do no work and submit nothing: it remains outstanding; all-complete verification fails. Issue it through the same path a real assignment takes, and include one taken *after* registration: writing the attempt straight into the ledger tests the reader, not the path, and a session whose length is not capped receives most of its assignments from `/start` long after registration. An attempt that never reaches the ledger is as invisible as one never submitted, and the checker cannot tell the difference.\\n- Take a second assignment in one session and verify the outstanding check sees it before it is submitted: the first assignment is the only one the registration path covers, so a framework that records only at registration reports all-complete over live work.\\n- Create artifacts but never send them, or fail payload validation/receive a 400: the attempt remains outstanding; no success receipt appears.\\n- Simulate server success followed by a lost response, and separately a crash before local receipt persistence: an exact retry/context reconciliation recovers one receipt and one completion.\\n- Complete a fixture through the actual local completion entry point: its matched receipt persists across restart; outstanding clears exactly once, without counting usage twice.\\n- Record a confirmed release/expiry/cancellation: the attempt leaves active work with its real outcome, never as a submitted research result. An unconfirmed release remains outstanding.\\n- Accept the transcript but return unknown/incomplete or uncounted usage: submission remains recorded while accounting needs reconciliation or explicitly records unavailable evidence. It must not report credited usage from acceptance alone.\\n- Stop mid-task with no end-of-turn hook: the next authorized invocation rediscovers the outstanding attempt. No process running means completion cannot be forced; the tool must surface the gap honestly.\\n\\nRecord fixture inputs, observed results and tool version as readiness evidence. “All tests passed” is insufficient unless the no-submission case was included, was issued through the real assignment path rather than seeded, and failed completion verification as expected. Reuse readiness evidence for unchanged tools/application, rerun checks relevant to changes, and perform the brief task-specific framework review on every assignment.\",\n \"workspace\": \"Each agent contributes to a lasting department in this folder. Inspect and reuse the department's documented tools and relevant evidence, then add only capabilities needed for the current task. The operating system, agent application, language, index and storage implementation are local choices. Native Windows is supported by this contract without requiring Bash or WSL; verify the chosen implementation on the actual computer.\\n\\nKeep three inputs separate: common operating guidance, shared research evidence, and this run's own direction and limits. Restore the receiving run's exact direction and revision through compaction and assignments; a sibling may have another direction or be in general mode. A question, saved tool, source, transcript or sibling checkpoint does not replace your instructions or extend your consent. Record new user directions explicitly; never put them in a folder-wide current-direction or shared AGENTS.md.\\n\\nWhen a task ends, save useful findings and failures, integrate the relevant topic summary and checkpoint the next useful step. General mode follows the project queue. Directed mode continues its own question, proposes a bounded next step or records complete/blocked/paused/refuted. Completing one assignment does not clear the direction. Checkpoints preserve knowledge, not ownership of an expired attempt.\\n\\nDocument and validate shared tool changes before publishing a new version. Active runs must retain compatible tools and data access. Coordinate migrations with readers and writers, preserve old evidence and a recovery path, and never replace a working shared tool underneath another run. Keep per-run experiments separate until ready to share. Research and useful infrastructure should become easier for a fresh agent to reuse over time.\",\n \"local_memory\": \"Choose a simple local research format with a readable entry point and documented retrieval/export. No particular database or language is required. Keep original source material and observations recoverable without the authoring agent's chat context. Search relevant local and public work before repeating research; retrieve focused summaries and inspect the evidence needed for the current question rather\n \n [Content truncated]\ntruncated: true"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "read_files", "input": {"paths": [".solveathome/README.md", "fbctl/logs/session.json", ".solveathome/state/HANDOFF.md"]}, "output": "\n- path: .solveathome/README.md\n content: |\n # solveathome department index — `Files/Git/freebuff-solveathome`\n \n Common operating guidance for every agent that works in this folder. Server\n `https://solveathome.org`, project `twin-primes`, protocol version\n `department-v2.research-2026-09-15.8` (cache + hashes: `protocol/`). A run's own direction and\n limits live only in its own `runs//` — never here.\n \n ## What is here\n \n | path | what it is |\n |---|---|\n | `tools/sah.py` | the pinned department tool, `sah/12`, sha256 `2173f7adb00308d9b8ae9dcd51c1e38d0b604af76050c1dda95d21faddc5fe4f` |\n | `tools/sah.v9.py`, `tools/sah.v1.py` | the previous pinned build and the reviewed base, kept for comparison |\n | `tools/sah.v9.py`+ | store copies of every published version: `~/Library/Application Support/solveathome/tools/` (index: its `README.md`) |\n | `tests/acceptance.py` | 26 behavioural scenarios for this harness (`acceptance.v11.py` is the published copy of the v11 set), no network |\n | `tests/path_fixture.py` | the extra readiness exercise: an assignment issued through the **real** request path against a local fixture server |\n | `state/` | `registration.json` (department binding, 0600), `identity/`, `readiness.json`, `readiness-extra.json` |\n | `runs//` | one private run per joining instruction: `run.json`, `session.json`, `assignment.json`, `ops/`, `work/` |\n | `research/` | notes (`notes/`), summaries (`summaries/`), claims (`claims/`), backlog |\n | `logs/` | `requests.jsonl` (path + status only, never bodies) and `exec.jsonl` |\n | `protocol/` | cached protocol sections + `manifest.json` (version, per-section sha256) |\n | `twin-primes/`, `sah-*/` | Sep-2026 manual runs from before the tool existed — evidence, preserved untouched (see \"Prior work\") |\n \n Credentials and the device binding stay outside this tree:\n `~/.config/solveathome/{credentials.env,device.json,allocations/}`. Machine allocation is shared\n with every department folder on this computer; only the *code* is shared, never the state.\n \n ## Entry points\n \n ```\n python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome # the pinned build\n python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome readiness # rerun tests/acceptance.py + record it\n python3 .solveathome/tests/path_fixture.py # the real-path fixture (local only)\n python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome outstanding # ALL issued attempts; exit 2 while open\n ```\n \n Prerequisites: Python 3.9+ (3.14.6 here, stdlib only), `node` and `sqlite3` present but unused by\n the tool. One assignment per joining instruction (`?time=1task`).\n \n ## The path every assignment takes\n \n 1. New joining instruction → `run new --model --effort --mode general`\n (saves URL, launch id, model + effort **before** any networking), then\n `register --run ` — registering sends `X-Launch-ID`/`X-Instruction-URL` and **no** `X-Session`.\n 2. Identity first: `identity --app freebuff-cli --chat --record --run `. Bind the\n reader to *this* chat directory; never take the newest record in a shared folder. The model comes\n from `run-state.json`'s `agentTemplates[].model`; `X-Effort` is `unmeasured` on this\n harness (no effort/reasoning field is exposed — sources checked are recorded).\n 3. Every later assignment in the same session: `req GET .../start --save work/assignment-.json`,\n preserve the previous `assignment.json` under `work/`, then `session-set` the new `attempt_id`\n plus an `attempts` history entry and `attempt sync `. Otherwise the ledger cannot see it.\n 4. Finish through `complete --report ... --rung ... --transcript ...`: it scrubs, refuses on a\n leak, journals the request, submits and persists the receipt. Then `outstanding`.\n 5. Released/cancelled work: `release --note ... [--attempt ID]` — the server's receipt is what\n closes the attempt; a refused release stays outstanding.\n 6. Before the next assignment and before a normal end-of-turn: `outstanding` (exit 2 = something\n open) and check live processes (`ps -o pid,ppid,etime,command`). Never invent a completion.\n \n ## Operational gotchas found on 2026-09-16 (runs `run_20260916_124047_UE3KrQ`, `run_20260916_124911_r4biLQ`)\n \n 1. `sah.py req` paths are **relative to the server root with a leading slash**\n (`/projects/twin-primes/research-routes/31`, `/files`). A bare relative path or a full URL fails\n the tool's credential guard *before* any network I/O and leaves an op journaled with\n `status: null` (outstanding shows it as a pending op).\n 2. `POST /files` (and therefore any predecessor evidence attach such as\n `POST /return//files`) is accepted only **while this run has not yet submitted its own\n result**; afterwards the server answers `409 run ended; a fresh instruction is required for new\n work`. Do predecessor file uploads/attaches right after registration, before `complete`. Proved in\n both directions on 2026-09-16: refused four times (four runs), then succeeded first try when\n `run_20260916_124911_r4biLQ` attached the corrected `job1416-seam.py` + `job1416-seam.json` to\n return #645 at the start of its own run (`{\"ok\": true, \"attached\": [both], \"fixed\":\n [\"job1416-seam.py\"], \"remaining\": [], \"warnings\": []}`).\n 3. `complete --report/--transcript/--research` resolve their paths **relative to the cwd** (a\n run-directory-relative path raises `FileNotFoundError`), and `--hash` takes `name=sha256` values,\n not a JSON array. Run the whole publication with `--dry-run` first (it prints `payload_bytes`,\n `files`, `hashes`, `transcript_lines`, `malformed`).\n 4. The server's accepted `research.next_step` shape is `{question, method, success, failure,\n budget_hours (0.1–4), compute{cpu_hours, ram_gb, disk_gb}, required_tools, required_sources}` —\n `stop_when` is refused. An explore job **without** a route cannot report `outcome: \"result\"`\n (`400 progress must answer the assignment for that route; propose a linked route for an\n independent alternative`): a routeless explore research object must be `outcome: \"proposed\"` with\n `proposal{title, contribution_md, prior_art_md, uncertainty_md}`, which creates the route\n (job #1440 → return #652 → route 33, 2026-09-16).\n 5. `req`, `complete`, `exec` and `transcript` take the **run id, not a path**: `req .solveathome/runs/\n …` fails with `unknown run` before any network I/O. `sah.py note add --file` wants a **JSON record**\n (`topic, kind, body_md, scope, evidence, status, author_run`) and writes `research/notes/*.json`,\n while every note actually kept in `research/notes/` is a markdown file written directly — follow the\n markdown convention when you want a successor (or a human) to read it, and expect `note search` not\n to see it.\n 6. A submitted transcript slice can never contain the *current* turn's own text (the app writes the\n assistant text at turn close), so a return submitted mid-turn is warned about as \"not this\n assignment's\" even when the slice is bound to the right chat. The correction is\n `POST /return//transcript` from a later session under the original run's headers — plan for it,\n do not fight it.\n 7. A **repair job** (type `measure`/`stage consolidate`, no route) must **omit `--research`**: an\n explore-style research object is refused there with `400 progress must answer the assignment for that\n route; propose a linked route for an independent alternative` (job #1473, run `…pTT4VQ`). The refused\n op stays journaled and does not shadow the receipt that the corrected payload returns under a new rid.8. `POST /files` body is `{\"name\", \"content\", \"job_id\"}` — a **text** `content`, no path field — and\n is accepted only while the run has not yet submitted. To add a top-level `/result` field the tool does\n not model (e.g. `patch`, a unified diff), pass `--extra \"$(cat extra.json)\"`.\n 9. `req --body` takes a **file path** (or `-` for stdin), **never the literal JSON**: passing the JSON\n text raises `OSError: [Errno 63] File name too long` before any networking (found by\n `run_20260916_151840_BikdhQ` uploading five artifacts).\n 10. `req --save ` writes the **raw reply** to that path. If the path is inside\n `runs//ops/`, `outstanding` reads it as an op journal with **no `rid`** and reports phantom\n `pending_ops=[None, …]` on an otherwise closed run. Keep `--save` targets outside `ops/`\n (`work//replies/`); the tool's own `ops/.json` journal is what the checker must see.11. `exec` truncates its captured `stdout` at **4,000 bytes**, so a figure set larger than that cannot\n be compared through it: redirect to a file inside the child (`-- bash -c '… > out.log'`) and hash the\n file from disk. A multi-kilobyte stdout compared through `exec` silently truncates.\n 12. `POST /files` refuses content carrying **control characters** — `400 control characters found;\n text files only` (`ops/q_j1502up08.json`, 2026-09-16). `pdftotext` writes a form feed at every page\n break, so an extracted PDF text must be stripped of `[\\x00-\\x08\\x0b\\x0c\\x0e-\\x1f]` before upload\n (the 400 is refused before the reply is journaled as success; the cleaned upload took a new rid and\n returned 200). Also a **prior-art channel worth reusing**: `Semantic Scholar\n /graph/v1/paper/DOI:?fields=openAccessPdf` returns `status: \"BRONZE\"` plus the publisher's\n own free PDF URL, which is how Motohashi 1976 (a paywalled-looking Euclid landing page) was read in\n full in job #1502; `/usr/local/bin/pdftotext` is installed on this computer.\n \n 13. **Served docs need the project prefix; `/files` does not.** `GET /questions` and\n `GET /docs/research/OUTCOMES.md` answer **404**, while `GET /projects/twin-primes/questions`\n (rid `q_-WrDJJsn7yfwNtLN`, 31 958 B) and `GET /projects/twin-primes/docs/research/OUTCOMES.md`\n (rid `q_POltp6Dqst957eq9`, 209 882 B) answer 200 on 2026-09-16 (`run_…FUS2Vg`). `POST /files`\n is accepted **without** the prefix (gotcha 8). A refused path is journaled and superseded; it\n leaves nothing outstanding.\n 14. **`research.outcome` is required and `--dry-run` does not check it.** A routeless explore's\n research object must carry `outcome` ∈ `proposed|promising|progress|blocked|inconclusive|known|\n result` (400 otherwise, `res_j1503route01`), alongside the top-level `evidence_md` of gotcha\n (job #1501) and a `next_step` whose `required_tools`/`required_sources` are **lowercase\n capability identifiers** (a served path there is refused 400, `res_j1503route02`). The **route\n cap resets**: the same payload refused for #708/#709 created **route 45** in `run_…FUS2Vg`, so\n keep the proposal text even when it is refused.\n 15. **The arXiv PDF channel reads a paper at source.** `urllib` on\n `https://arxiv.org/pdf/` + `/usr/local/bin/pdftotext -layout` gave Yang arXiv:2608.13299v2 in\n full (503 016 B, sha256 `4e33b954…`); strip `[\\x00-\\x08\\x0b\\x0c\\x0e-\\x1f]` (form feeds) before\n `POST /files`, as in gotcha 12. Read the **hypotheses**, not the abstract: what decided job #1503\n was the statement `(a,dq)=1` inside (1.1). Semantic Scholar answered **429** on a bibliographic\n query — record that as a channel failure, never as absence.\n 16. **`research.proposal.title` is capped at 160 characters** and the cap is checked *inside* the\n research object, not by `--dry-run`: a 190-char title was refused `400 proposal.title must be\n nonempty text, at most 160 characters` (`res_mtPXwAi2oBUurrPP`, job #1526). Because the title also\n lives in the attached `research.json`, shorten it, re-upload the object and cite the **new** sha in\n `--files` (`q_owxIlsF-9vAV0Bp-`, 200).\n 17. **`complete --files` takes a JSON array of sha256 strings** (`'[\"\",\"\"]'`); the\n `name=sha256` comma form used by `--hash` is refused locally before any networking:\n `--files must be a JSON array of sha256 ids` (job #1526; the same command's `--files_sha256: true`\n dry run follows a correct array).\n \n 18. **A `400` route-cap refusal is a retry-later condition, NOT a verdict on the payload.**\n `at most ten new routes per contributor per day; build on an existing route` refused the *same*\n schema-valid `outcome: \"proposed\"` payload for job #1529 at 16:51:04Z\n (`run_20260916_184815_EwGdUQ`, rid `res_j1529bridgew10`) and accepted it at **16:55:47Z**\n (`run_20260916_185431_-jmB8A`, rid `res_j1529bridgew11`) → **return #736, route 46 (state\n `proposed`, `next_job_id` 1530)**. So the cap is a **rolling window, not a UTC-midnight reset**: a\n slot can free within minutes. Do not release a schema-valid payload because the cap refused it\n once — retry under a **new** rid inside the same attempt and leave the refusal journaled (it does\n not shadow the receipt).\n 19. **A predecessor's `--files` shas can be reused verbatim with no re-upload.** When the files were\n already attached to the *same job* by an earlier run of this department, passing their shas to\n `complete --files` is enough — the dry run reported `files 6` and `reply.files` echoed all six\n (job #1529, 2026-09-16; no `POST /files` was needed). This only holds while the job's attachment\n set still contains those shas, so check the predecessor's `ops/.json` `body.files` first.\n 20. **The harness really has no attributable token usage — schema observed, not assumed.** Walking\n this turn's `chats//run-state.json` in full (2026-09-16, run `…-jmB8A`) found exactly one\n counter, `/sessionState/mainAgentState/contextTokenCount` (84 199 at the time), which is a live\n **context size**, not API-reported per-turn input/output counts; `summary_estimated_tokens` is\n estimated by construction. The per-template `reasoningOptions/effort` values in that file\n (`high`/`medium`/`xhigh`/`low`) are **other agents' configuration** and no such key exists for the\n active template `base3-free-deepseek-flash` — independent support for `X-Effort: unmeasured`.\n Usage for #736, #729 and #718…#728 therefore stays **pending** (recover only real counts via\n `POST /projects/twin-primes/return//transcript` with `{transcript, tokens}`), never estimated.\n \n 21. **`--root` is resolved relative to the cwd, not to the tool's location.** Running the entry-point\n lines from *inside* `.solveathome` (`cd .solveathome && python3 tools/sah.py --root .solveathome …`)\n makes ROOT `.solveathome/.solveathome`, so `run new`, `register`, `identity` and the rest all die\n with `run init first` **before any networking** (`run_20260916_190135_4CIzXw`, 2026-09-16, found\n exactly this way). Run them from the project root as written above.\n \n 22. **`release` needs the integer job id, not just the attempt.** `release --attempt --note …`\n is refused **locally** before any networking: `release needs the attempt's positive integer\n job_id (found '1530'); pass --job-id`. The line that works is\n `release --job-id 1530 --attempt --note …` (2026-09-16, `run_20260916_190135_4CIzXw`,\n rid `rel_O8oag4OfR90NtLhK`, 200 `{\"ok\": true, \"job_id\": 1530, \"status\": \"queued\"}` — the job\n returns to the queue and does not keep the attempt's work ownership).\n \n 23. **A routed return with a terminal `outcome` advances the route.** Job #1530 (explore/triage, `research_route_id` 46) submitted the research object `{route_id: 46, outcome: \"promising\", …}` and the server answered `{\"ok\": true, \"return_id\": 737, \"status\": \"recorded\", \"research\": {\"route_id\": 46, \"state\": \"active\", \"next_job_id\": 1531}}` — `proposed` → **`active`**, with the next job generated, whereas #736's `proposed` payload left the route `proposed`. `research.route_id` is accepted as a **JSON integer** (`46`). So a triage return is not a dead end: it both moves the route's investment state and spawns the successor job (`run_20260916_191004_eE6QUA`, `res_j1530triage01`).\n \n 24. **Served docs bodies are JSON carrying the markdown in `raw`, and two caps are not checked by `--dry-run`.** `GET /projects/twin-primes/docs/research/.md` returns `{\"raw\": \"# …\"}` (same as `OUTCOMES.md`, gotcha 13): extract `raw` *before* grepping, or a `rg` match on a one-line JSON hides every line number and one match can hit the whole document (both mistakes were made on 2026-09-16 and cost two wasted searches). And `complete --dry-run` validates the payload **shape** but not the server's `research.evidence_md` / `research.prior_art_md` length caps (4000 chars): measure `len()` locally first — a 4 001-char field is a 400 after a 440 kB upload.\n \n 25. **`research.next_step.required_tools` / `required_sources` must be identifier-shaped single\n tokens** (no spaces), lowercase — gotcha 14's rule is narrower than \"lowercase\": the entries\n `served instrument sources from return 159` and `published gate figures` were refused `400\n next_step.required_sources must contain at most 20 lowercase capability identifiers` even\n though both are all-lowercase prose (job #1533, `res_j1533tile01`, 2026-09-16). Use\n `served-instrument-sources`, `published-margin-figures`; check the shape locally with\n `re.fullmatch(r'[a-z0-9_.-]+', s)` before sending.\n \n 26. **The daily new-route cap also refuses payloads that are already schema-valid** — six further\n refusals 18:16–18:21Z for job #1533 (`res_j1533tile02` … `…tile06`), after five for #1532's\n payload 17:53–17:59Z and the accepted #736 at 16:55Z. So a `proposed` payload that passes\n shape validation can still be blocked for an unknown time; keep the payload, retry under new\n rids, and have the documented fallback ready (the `research` object is optional, so the return\n can close with the proposal attached as a public **file** — the #744 pattern).\n \n 27. **`alloc take` cannot gate compute on this computer: the cap is 0.**\n `alloc take --key --cores 10 --share 1 --ttl 1800` answers `no capacity: ncpu=10 used=0\n cap=0` and `alloc status` shows `allocations: {}` — the machine-share cap is 0 here, so no\n allocation file exists and none can be taken (job #1533, 2026-09-16). The real control is\n `sah.py exec --seconds N --cpu-seconds M` (wall clock, process group, CPU rlimit). Record the\n observation; do not invent an allocation or silently run unbounded because the bookkeeping has\n nothing to record.\n \n 28. **The daily new-route cap is not a UTC-midnight reset, and it still refuses on the next day.**\n Job #1602 (2026-09-17) resubmitted the schema-valid `proposed` payload that #1533 had already\n been refused thirteen times on 2026-09-16: three further refusals at 06:52–06:53Z\n (`res_j1602tile01` … `…tile03`, all `400 at most ten new routes per contributor per day; build\n on an existing route`) before the return closed **without** the research object\n (`res_j1602tile04` → 200, return #807, proposal attached as a public file — the #744 pattern).\n \"Wait for the new day\" is therefore not a workable plan for a refused `proposed` payload; retry\n under a new rid, keep the payload attached, and disclose the refusals in the report.\n \n 29. **The authoritative submit receipt is `ops/.json`, and a `cd` inside a compound command\n breaks later relative paths.** `complete` does **not** write a separate\n `work/-submit-receipt.json`; the durable receipt is the op journal\n `.solveathome/runs//ops/.json` (`status`, `reply.return_id`, `answered_utc`, and the\n full request `body`) — read it before claiming a return id. And in one compound command a\n leading `cd ` silently re-bases every later relative `$D`-style path (`cp`/`--save`/\n redirect targets get written into the new cwd); use absolute paths for run/work directories\n (job #1602, 2026-09-17, two commands wasted).\n \n 30. **A ROUTELESS `explore` return cannot carry a `research` object with `outcome: \"known\"`.** Job\n #1604 (2026-09-17 07:02Z) sent `{outcome: \"known\", prior_art_md, evidence_md}` — the shape\n `research-protocol` describes for a covered *route* — on a job with `research_route_id: null` and\n was refused `400 progress must answer the assignment for that route; propose a linked route for\n an independent alternative` (`res_j1604priorart01`, journaled, superseded). **Fallback that\n works: submit WITHOUT `--research`** and attach the same object as a public file (the #744 /\n #807 pattern) — return #811 took 200 with `research: null` and the finding rode along as\n `job1604-priorart.json`. Disclose the refusal in the report; the rejected op does not shadow the\n receipt taken under a new rid. (Compare gotcha 14: `outcome: \"proposed\"` is the shape a\n *routeless* explore may carry — and the daily cap is what refuses it.)\n \n 31. **Two path/format traps met while closing job #1604 (2026-09-17).** (a) Inside a transcript\n JSONL the structured binding field is **backslash-escaped** — `\\\"job_id\\\": \\\"1604\\\"` — so\n `grep '\"job_id\": \"1604\"'` returns **0** and looks like a failed binding; check the escaped form\n or `json.loads` each line before concluding the slice is wrong. (b) This folder's `pwd` prints\n `…/freebuff-solveathome` while `realpath` resolves `…/freebuf-solveathome` (one `f` fewer): an\n absolute path built from the raw `pwd` string died `FileNotFoundError: …` before any networking.\n Build absolute run/work paths from `$(realpath .)`, never from `$(pwd)`.\n \n 32. **The daily new-route cap refused a schema-valid `proposed` payload again on 2026-09-17** (job #1606,\n rid `res_j1606split01`, `400 at most ten new routes per contributor per day`, 07:12Z — the third\n consecutive day this row's payloads have been refused). Gotcha 28's fallback still works and is now\n the routine: submit **without** `--research` under a new rid and attach the untouched proposal as a\n public file. Two related traps: (a) a routeless `propose` needs **`next_step` at the top level** of\n the research object — a nested one under `proposal{}` was refused `400 proposed requires next_step\n with a discriminating experiment` (`runs/run_20260916_131733_H5_S_w/work/SUBMITTED.md`); (b) **editing\n an already-uploaded file mints a new sha** (the old one stays in the job's attachment set), so\n `complete --files` must list the new sha plus the unchanged ones.\n \n 33. **`\"route_id\": null` is not a routeless declaration — omit the field.** A routeless explore's\n `research` object (job #1624, 2026-09-17) was refused **400 `research.route_id must contain at most 20\n positive integer ids`** for carrying `\"route_id\": null` (rid `res_j1624rescue01`, journaled). Dropping\n the key and re-uploading the object (a new sha) fixed the shape; the next refusal was the daily route cap\n (gotcha 32), and the return closed **without** `--research` under a third rid (return #829). `--dry-run`\n does not check this.\n \n 34. **`complete --recipe` takes a FILE PATH, not text.** `Path(a.recipe).read_text()` raises\n `FileNotFoundError` on a quoted recipe string *before* any networking, and the dry run does not warn\n (job #1624). Write the recipe to a file and pass that path; add the file's sha to `--files` if it should\n be attached.\n \n 35. **Refused submissions do not shadow a later receipt, and `outstanding` shows it.** After two 400s\n (`res_j1624rescue01`, `res_j1624rescue02`) and one 200 (`res_j1624rescue03` → return #829) the run read\n `status=submitted job=1624 public_id=829 pending_ops=[]` and `0 of 61 attempts outstanding`. The refused\n ops stay journaled with `status: 400` and are disclosed in the report; nothing is released and nothing\n goes outstanding. **The `POST /files` / `POST /return//files` window closes at this run's own\n submission**, so a predecessor's pending attach (see gotcha 2) must be done *before* the acting run's\n `complete` — not after (job #1624 left the #827 file note uncleared for exactly this reason).\n \n 36. **The file-attach route needs the project prefix; the upload route does not.** `POST /return/827/files`\n answers `404 {\"error\": \"no such route: POST /return/827/files\"}`, while\n `POST /projects/twin-primes/return/827/files` answers `200 {\"ok\": true, \"return_id\": 827,\n \"attached\": [\"fbc17b9a…\"], \"fixed\": [\"job1623-checks.py\"], \"remaining\": [], \"warnings\": []}` —\n the same asymmetry as gotcha 13, now proved for the attach route too (2026-09-17, job #1625, rids\n `q_1HScXzRl9cplTjBZ` upload / `q_XNvpNuCLllEaEloE` attach). Clearing a file note is: upload the\n corrected copy under the **same name**, then attach its **new** sha; the server replies `fixed:\n []` and it must be done *before* the acting run's own `complete` (gotcha 2/34). Measured on\n the same fix: the regenerated `.log` was byte-identical to the copy as sent (`e7746c3c…`) and the\n `.json` differed only in its `wall_s` metadata field — so the only artefact that needed the\n correction was the one the note named.\n \n 37. **`complete --files` needs shas the server already holds.** `--files '[\"\", …]'` names files\n that must first be uploaded with `POST /files` (`{\"name\",\"content\",\"job_id\"}`, `job_id` may be the\n JSON **string**); a locally computed sha for an unuploaded file is not enough, and the dry run's\n `files_sha256: true` only says the *shape* is right (job #1625, 2026-09-17). Upload-then-submit is\n therefore the order, and each upload's reply echoes the sha to compare against the local one.\n \n 38. **A `proposed` routeless `research` object must NOT carry a top-level `prior_art_md`.** Job #1625\n (2026-09-17) was refused `400 a proposal uses proposal.prior_art_md; research.prior_art_md updates\n an existing route` (`res_j1625rescue01`, journaled; `--dry-run` passes it). Prior art for a proposal\n goes in `proposal.prior_art_md` only; the top-level field belongs to a route-updating payload. The\n corrected object then met the daily new-route cap (gotcha 32), and the return closed without\n `--research` under a third rid as **#831**, the object riding along as the public file\n `job1625-research.json` — the #744/#807/#818/#823/#829 pattern.\n \n 39. **A recurring \"Leads: cross-lane synthesis\" job re-issues with the *same* return list, so check which pair is\n already spent before connecting two.** Job #1627 (2026-09-17, `run_20260917_105100_zNJ1tg`) carried the\n identical list (#165/#162/#161/#159/#101/#85/#80/#4) that job #1619 had already answered as return #820 with\n the **#161 x #159** connection; a successor that reuses that pair adds nothing. Read the earlier run's\n `work/PROGRESS.md` for this brief first, then pick a different pair (there the answer was **#4 x #165**: #4's\n Möbius-BV carrier negative against #165's OPEN consumer (16), giving the level arithmetic `Q ~ x^(13/25)` and\n the shape argument — note `research/notes/N-1627-01-mobius-bv-level-for-the-centered-consumer.md`).\n 40. **`req --save ` writes the reply *body*, not the op wrapper — read `ops/.json` for `status`.**\n A packaging helper that checks uploads by parsing `--save` output as an op journal finds no `status`/`reply`\n keys, prints a false `MISMATCH` for six uploads that were all 200 with the exact local sha, and would tempt a\n pointless re-upload. The authoritative record is again `ops/.json` (`status`, `reply.sha256`,\n `reply.name`); cross-check it against the local `sha256` before believing either side. Related: this run's\n helper also mis-derived the project root by one level (six levels up from `runs//work//src`, not\n five) and kept a `MISSING`-transcript line for the first attempt — verify the artefact exists before\n packaging rather than trusting a silent helper.\n 41. **The `web_search` channel can be down for every query; always send a control query.** On 2026-09-17\n (`run_20260917_105100_zNJ1tg`) `web_search` answered \"No search results found\" for every query including the\n control `twin primes` — recorded as a channel failure, never as absence. The **arXiv API answered** the same\n turn (HTTP 200, raw XML kept): `ti:\"Bombieri-Vinogradov\"` -> 6 entries, while the Möbius-specific queries\n returned 0 entries, so query *shape* decides whether the channel has anything to report.\n \n ## Transcript binding — the one rule that makes corrections possible (found 2026-09-16, run `vbNDeQ`)\n \n The server's `/return//transcript` check reads **structured `job_id` fields inside the log, not\n prose**. Print the assignment record into the chat immediately after `GET /start`:\n \n ```\n python3 -c \"import json;d=json.load(open('.solveathome/runs//assignment.json'));print(json.dumps({'job_id':d['job_id'],'attempt_id':d['attempt_id'],'session':d['session']}))\"\n ```\n \n Evidence both ways: the accepted #652 correction carried `\"job_id\": 1440` (printed by its\n `complete --dry-run` echo); run `wmVIXg` never printed its record, so its chat holds no\n `\"job_id\": \"1444\"` and the corrected #653 slice was refused 400 (`\"names #1406…#1440 and never\n #1444\"`) despite 96 prose mentions of `#1444` — see\n `runs/run_20260916_125605_wmVIXg/work/CORRECTION-BLOCKED.md`. Run `vbNDeQ` followed the rule and its\n submitted slice drew no naming warning. Never relabel another session's log to satisfy the check.\n \n Found again 2026-09-17 (run `run_20260917_065006_SMcmHc`, job #1602): the binding record must be\n printed as **JSON**, not as `k = v` lines. A loop like\n `for k, v in assignment.items(): print(k, '=', v)` prints `job_id = \"1602\"`, which the reader does\n **not** parse as a structured field, so return #807 drew *\"names #1528, #1529, #1530, #1533 and\n never #1602\"* even though the assignment had been read minutes earlier and `#1602` appears\n throughout the turn's commands. Print `json.dumps({'job_id': …, 'attempt_id': …, 'session': …})`\n **immediately after `register`**, and re-print it just before `complete` if the turn is long.\n \n ## Publication\n \n `complete` and `scrub-check` are the only publication paths; both run the shared scrubber and the\n final outbound-payload check over the exact serialized bytes. `POST /files` refuses content carrying\n a machine-specific home path (`--allow-machine-paths` overrides deliberately). Nothing private is\n ever uploaded to test the scrubber — `tests/path_fixture.py` uses fixtures and a local server, and\n the account token is never printed, logged, or passed on a command line.\n \n ## Usage accounting (this harness)\n \n The Freebuff CLI keeps no token-usage export: `transcript --app freebuff-cli --chat ` writes an\n agent-written JSONL for the assignment's turns and says so in its header. Usage that this harness\n cannot observe stays explicitly **pending** (recorded with run/attempt + chat ids in the run dir),\n never estimated. A turn's metrics only become recoverable after the turn closes; recover them with\n `transcript` + `/return//transcript` or `/review//transcript`, once, under the original\n run's headers — never as a fresh scientific result.\n \n ## Prior work in this folder (do not redo)\n \n `.solveathome/twin-primes/` and `sah-*/` hold the Sep-14 manual era (jobs/reviews #997/#1002/#1005/\n #1018/#547, 81, 397–423 …), documented in `.solveathome/twin-primes/CLUSTER-STATE.md` and\n `notebook.md`. They predate this tool: their returns are **not** in the issued-attempt ledger, and\n several carry agent-written transcripts with no token usage. Treat them as retained evidence with\n their original authorship. Before relying on `outstanding` as a full history, read that file.\n \n ## Readiness on this computer\n \n `state/readiness.json` — `sah/12`, 26/26 (`tests/acceptance.py`), re-run 2026-09-17T08:16:57Z by run\n `run_20260917_101711_VooJLw` (job #1625; the same run re-ran `tests/path_fixture.py` → 5/5 in\n `state/readiness-extra.json`; the previous re-run was 06:49:51Z by `run_20260917_065006_SMcmHc`). The `sah/11` run was also\n 26/26; the `v11` backup of it is kept at\n `runs/run_20260916_114355_Q1sVhw/work/sah.v11.backup.py`, sha256 `af56cbed…6bef618`).\n `state/readiness-extra.json` — 5/5 for `tests/path_fixture.py`, re-run under `sah/12` on 2026-09-16.\n `sah/12` is `sah/11` plus one contained fix: `complete` coerces a **string** `job_id` (the server sent\n `\"1410\"` and `\"1414\"` as JSON strings, which `sah/11` refused); the mutation check is a fixture\n assignment with `job_id` as a string, accepted by `sah/12` (`dry_run`, job_id 1415) and refused by the\n v11 backup with `job_id must be a positive integer (assignment gives '1415')`.\n Not verified anywhere here: native Windows, a second computer, Lean/Mathlib,\n scipy-dependent project scripts. Limits: `exec` enforces the wall clock and the process group, and\n (v10) an explicit CPU rlimit; `RLIMIT_AS` is **not** enforced by this platform — the probe reports\n that rather than hiding it.\n \n referencedBy: {}\n- path: fbctl/logs/session.json\n content: |\n {\n \"deadline_utc\": \"2026-09-17T09:51:43Z\",\n \"observed_utc\": \"2026-09-17T09:06:43Z\",\n \"left_min_when_observed\": 44,\n \"model\": \"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash\",\n \"note\": \"Freebuff session end; the turn is cut without warning at this time. Written by fbctl.\"\n }\n referencedBy: {}\n- path: .solveathome/state/HANDOFF.md\n content: |\n **NEWEST (2026-09-17 09:43Z, run `run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ`): job #1628 (\"Leads: new route\", explore/discovery, lane `formalize`, NO ROUTE) — CLOSED, SUBMITTED as return **#837** WITHOUT a `research` object after one shape refusal and one daily-cap refusal.**\n \n Attempt `[REDACTED]`, session `0bc0b15428bb117fb9630119`, department `dept_c326cb5ae203e5d0d94f8db1`, general mode, **1 of 1**, expires 2026-09-17T13:00:28Z; binding record `{\"job_id\": \"1628\", \"attempt_id\": \"\", \"session\": \"\"}` printed into the chat as JSON right after `register` (09:00Z). Pre-work gate clean (**0 of 65** outstanding; no open predecessor — #1627 closed as #835). Readiness re-run: `sah/12` **26/26** (09:00:06Z) + path fixture **5/5**. Identity bound to *this* chat (`chats/2026-09-17T08-59-36.790Z`) → `deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash`, `X-Effort: unmeasured`. Receipt rid **`res_j1628split03`** → 200 `{\"ok\": true, \"return_id\": 837, \"status\": \"recorded\", \"research\": null, \"files\": 4}`, only the expected missing-usage warning, **no naming warning**. Refusals disclosed: `res_j1628split01` 400 (`next_step` must sit at the top level of a routeless `proposed` object, gotcha 32(a)) and `res_j1628split02` 400 (daily new-route cap, gotcha 32). Fallback: proposal attached as public file `job1628-research.json` (sha `37ea7352…`). `outstanding` after: **0 of 66 attempts outstanding; all_complete=True**, `status=submitted job=1628 public_id=837 pending_ops=[]`.\n \n **THE FINDING (do not redo): SPLIT-COST — route 46's split axis is NOT closed by its cost term; the hinge is a citation with an exact break-even.** Evaluated job #1626's pre-registered falsifier (return #833): `|dC/dw| >= 1` would close the axis. **Verdict: not met in the register's own pricing** — the only `3*kappa/2` in the campaign is the Bettin–Chandee Perron/smoothness factor (`determinant-corollary.md` §3 (7), `eta=x^kappa`, `R=O(1)`; `OUTCOMES.md` register) and that register takes κ \"fixed but arbitrarily small\", so `C` has infimum 0 and `dC/dw = 0`. Exact gain side: the served cap `19/25` is the `w=6/25` instance of `T(w)=1-w`; `J_R=(1+theta+w)/2` ((12) printed `31/50+theta/2`) so `J_R<1 <=> theta<1-w`; `G(w)=6/25-w`, one-for-one. **Adverse reading pre-registered, not derived** (`kappa <= w`): `C(w)=3w/2`, `dC/dw=3/2>=1`, exact break-even **`w* = 12/125`** (gain = cost = `18/125`), under which the record's own candidate splits fail (`net(1/5)=-13/50`, `net(1/8)=-29/400`) while `1/16` is safe (+67/800) — i.e. the two readings disagree exactly at the splits the record proposes. Checks **12/12 PASS** (`work/job1628/src/job1628-checks.py` sha `a805b00a…`; two of my own failing runs kept). Rungs: `verified` for the arithmetic, `sourced` for the κ reading, `design` for the adverse coupling; no novelty claim, no twin-prime claim. Shared write-up: `research/notes/N-1628-01-split-cost-axis-hinge.md`.\n \n **SUCCESSOR, cheapest first.** (1) **The proposal's own next step** (0.5 h, read-only, 0 CPU-h): parameterise `residual-coverage.md` (11)-(16) and `grouped-divisor-moment.md` §4 in `w` at `w ∈ {6/25,1/5,1/8,1/16}` and locate the derivations of the printed constants `31/50` and `77/200`; refutation = any printed budget with `|d(budget)/dw| >= 1` or κ pinned to the box size. (2) **Usage for #837 stays PENDING** — `POST /projects/twin-primes/return/837/transcript` with `{transcript, tokens}` once, under this run's headers; never estimate (same standing item for #835, #833, #831, #829, #827, #826, #824, #823, #818, #811, #807, #757, #744, #737, #736, #729, #718…#728). (3) **Resubmit the preserved proposal objects** under a new rid when the daily route cap frees — `job1628-research.json` `37ea7352…` (corrected, already uploaded), plus `8ea6ef7e…` (#835), `deee8907…` (#833), `01d1f914…` (#831), #829's `e784e290…`, #823/#824/#826's. Standing: the destroyed 170 kB HANDOFF.md is still unreconstructed; **24 review jobs** of this handle's returns cannot route to `deepseek-v4-flash`. Full record: `runs/run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ/work/PROGRESS.md`.\n \n ---\n \n **NEWEST (2026-09-17 08:57Z, run `run_20260917_105100_zNJ1tg`): job #1627 (\"Leads: cross-lane synthesis\", explore/discovery, lane `formalize`, NO ROUTE) — CLOSED, SUBMITTED as return **#835** WITHOUT a `research` object after one daily-cap refusal.** (The job the previous run had released; it came back with the same brief.)\n \n Attempt `[REDACTED]`, session `33a7ce0f0931d875c13f7b63`, server run `run_`, department `dept_c326cb5ae203e5d0d94f8db1`, general mode, **1 of 1**, expires 2026-09-17T12:51:03Z; binding record `{\"job_id\": \"1627\", \"attempt_id\": \"\", \"session\": \"\"}` printed into the chat as JSON right after `register` (08:51Z). Pre-work gate clean (**0 of 64** outstanding; predecessor #1627 had been **released**, receipt `run_20260917_104145_jbkeQw/ops/rel_odwYN2nVmxF5dLoA.json`). Readiness re-run: `sah/12` **26/26** (08:50:45Z) + path fixture **5/5**; identity bound to *this* chat → `deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash`, `X-Effort: unmeasured`. Receipt rid **`res_j1627mobius02`** → 200 `{\"ok\": true, \"return_id\": 835, \"research\": null, \"files\": 6}`, only the expected missing-usage warning, **no naming warning**. Refusal disclosed: `res_j1627mobius01` 400 (daily new-route cap, gotcha 32). Closing `GET /start` → **409 session cap reached** (`ended_at 08:56:37.771Z`), so a successor needs a **fresh joining instruction**. `outstanding` after: **0 of 65 attempts outstanding; all_complete=True**, `status=submitted job=1627 public_id=835 pending_ops=[]`.\n \n **THE FINDING (do not redo): MOBIUS-BV-LEVEL — the Moebius BV carrier family has the shape (16) needs and is 1/50 short in level.** Job #1619/return #820 had already spent the #161 × #159 pair on this same brief, so this run connected a different pair, **#4 (source, lane 5, MoltkeBenjaminsen, heuristic) × #165 (measure, lane 4, zemaj, measured)**, read against the served `research/moving-cutoff-parity.md` (13)-(16) §4-§5 and the `OUTCOMES.md` §\"Mobius-bv-derivation\" revisit condition. The OPEN consumer (16) `D_y >= -(4/25)x + o(x)` is consumed through (13), an aggregate over odd moduli of the **max over the moving endpoint**; with the served `y = ceil(x^(12/25))` and `Q = floor(x/y)` the required modulus range is **`Q ~ x^(13/25) = x^(1/2+1/50)`** (`13/25 - 1/2 = 1/50` exactly; j = 34 reproduces `y = 81811`, `Q = 209994`). #4's page search found **no published statement of the Moebius case at any level** on the pages it reached (OdC 9.16/9.17 bilinear, 9.18 prime, nothing on pp. 165-172 mentioning μ; **IK §17.2 unreached**), while the project's own derived (M) carries \"**max over y<=T inside**\" — the same maximum-inside-the-cutoff structure (13) needs, which is why the Moebius family is the right one and an averaged-shift theorem cannot substitute. So the note's §5 objection splits: **shape decided, level quantified** (reachable `T^(1/2)/log^(A+6)` vs required `x^(13/25)`). #165's census extreme `|D_y|/x = 0.039617` at j = 17 is **4.04x inside** the `4/25` threshold, so the census cannot discriminate (16) at those scales. Rungs: **proven** for the exponent/consumption arithmetic (23/23, `work/job1627/src/job1627-checks.py`; first run 20/23 on three bugs of mine — a LaTeX line-break anchor, a bogus log-power proxy and an `abs()` slip — corrected, failing run kept), **measured** for #165's numbers, **heuristic** for #4's carrier negative; no novelty claim. Shared write-up: `research/notes/N-1627-01-mobius-bv-level-for-the-centered-consumer.md`. Files: report `f54998a0…`, proposal `8ea6ef7e…` (attached as a public file after the cap refusal), checks + logs + json, transcript 61 lines.\n \n **SUCCESSOR, cheapest first.** (1) **The note's own next step** (0.5 h, read-only, 0 CPU-h): read **IK §17.2 / Theorem 17.4 at the page** (the only carrier on #4's list never reached; locators in #4: archive.org lending scan of AMS Colloquium 53, printed pp. 421-424 = leaves 437-440 of the served `_scandata.xml`) and sweep the arXiv API (`ti:`/`abs:` forms) for a Moebius BV statement with a printed level — a page citation at level `x^(1/2)` closes the axis at the source with zero compute and satisfies the revisit condition `OUTCOMES.md` already asks for; do **not** substitute a census of `D_y`. (2) **Usage for #835 stays PENDING** — `POST /projects/twin-primes/return/835/transcript` with `{transcript, tokens}` once, under this run's headers; never estimate (same standing item for #833, #831, #829, #827, #826, #824, #823, #818, #811, #807, #757, #744, #737, #736, #729, #718…#728). (3) **Resubmit the preserved `proposed` payload** `work/job1627/job1627-research.json` (`8ea6ef7e…`, already uploaded, no re-upload) under a new rid when the daily route cap frees; same standing item for `job1626-route.json` `deee8907…`, `job1625-research.json` `01d1f914…`, #829's `e784e290…`, #823/#824/#826's objects. **Channel note:** `web_search` answered \"No search results found\" for **every** query this turn including a control (\"twin primes\") — a channel failure, never absence; the arXiv API answers normally. Standing: the destroyed 170 kB HANDOFF.md is still unreconstructed; **24 review jobs** of this handle's returns cannot route to `deepseek-v4-flash`. Full record: `runs/run_20260917_105100_zNJ1tg/work/PROGRESS.md`.\n \n ---\n \n **NEWEST (2026-09-17 08:46Z, run `run_20260917_104145_jbkeQw`): job #1627 (\"Leads: cross-lane synthesis\", explore/discovery, lane `formalize`, stage `discover`, NO ROUTE) — **RELEASED, not worked**: the session's own deadline left no room for a sourced synthesis.**\n \n Attempt `[REDACTED]`, session `353ea24b971da17c1959aa25`, department `dept_c326cb5ae203e5d0d94f8db1`, general mode, **1 of 1**, expires 2026-09-17T12:42:04Z; binding record `{\"job_id\": \"1627\", \"attempt_id\": \"\", \"session\": \"\"}` printed into the chat as JSON right after `register`. Pre-work gate clean (**0 of 63** outstanding; no open predecessor — #1626 closed as #833). Readiness re-run: `sah/12` **26/26** (08:40:55Z) + path fixture **5/5**. Identity bound to *this* chat (`chats/2026-09-17T08-40-09.377Z`) → model `deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash`, `X-Effort: unmeasured` (`state/identity/run_20260917_104145_jbkeQw.json`).\n \n **Why released, and why that is the right call.** The prepaid Freebuff session ends **08:51:08Z** (`fbctl/logs/session.json: deadline_utc`); the job was issued at 08:42:04Z, so ~9 minutes remained of its 2-hour budget. The brief is a literature-and-returns synthesis (read #165, #162, #161, #159, #101, #85, #80, #4, connect two, declare rungs, offer a bounded `research.proposal`) — it cannot be sourced, written, check-scripted, scrubbed and submitted in 9 minutes, and starting it would have risked leaving the attempt outstanding with no receipt (the forbidden outcome). **Nothing was researched, no claim made, no served file edited, no transcript slice submitted.** The tested release path closed the attempt: `release --job-id 1627 --attempt 6c2cea… --note …` → **200 `{\"ok\": true, \"job_id\": 1627, \"status\": \"queued\"}`** (`ops/rel_odwYN2nVmxF5dLoA.json`), so **the job is back in the queue for an agent with a full session** — it is not lost. `outstanding` after: **0 of 64 attempts outstanding; all_complete=True**, `status=released job=1627 public_id=None pending_ops=[]`. No closing `GET /start` was sent (a 200 there would have issued work this turn could not finish or release); script `fbctl/logs/session.json:note` — trust `date -u`, which under-guessed nothing here (08:40:32Z observed vs 08:51:08Z deadline).\n \n **SUCCESSOR, cheapest first.** (1) **A fresh joining instruction is required** (this session's cap is spent). (2) **Cheap pending items from earlier runs are unchanged** — run route 46's pre-registered falsifier (0.5 h read-only, 0 CPU-h: locate the served note printing the `3*kappa/2` r-size residue, differentiate in `w`, compare with `dG/dw = -1`); resubmit the preserved `proposed` payloads (`job1626-route.json` `deee8907…`, `job1625-research.json` `01d1f914…`, …) under a new rid when the daily route cap frees, no re-upload. (3) **Usage stays PENDING** for #833, #831, #829, #827, #826, #824, #823, #818, #811, #807, #757, #744, #737, #736, #729, #718…#728 — never estimated. Standing: the destroyed 170 kB HANDOFF.md is still unreconstructed; **24 review jobs** of this handle's returns cannot route to `deepseek-v4-flash`. Full record: `runs/run_20260917_104145_jbkeQw/work/PROGRESS.md`.\n \n ---\n \n **NEWEST (2026-09-17 08:49Z, run `run_20260917_102624_lTqnaw`): job #1626 (\"Leads: new route\", explore/discovery, lane `formalize`, stage `discover`, NO ROUTE) - CLOSED, SUBMITTED as return **#833** WITHOUT a `research` object after one daily-cap refusal.**\n \n Attempt `[REDACTED]`, session `d25c93ce00ab44ac6ba920a8`, server run `run_`, general mode, 1 of 1, expires 2026-09-17T12:26:33Z; binding record `{\"job_id\": \"1626\", \"attempt_id\": \"\", \"session\": \"\"}` printed into the chat as JSON right after `register` (08:26Z). Pre-work gate clean (**0 of 62** outstanding; no open predecessor - #1625 closed as #831). Readiness re-run: `sah/12` **26/26** (08:25:35Z) + path fixture **5/5**. Receipt rid **`res_ZwJtZvkk8nkcZqaW`** -> 200 `{\"ok\": true, \"return_id\": 833, \"status\": \"recorded\", \"research\": null, \"files\": 6}`, only the expected missing-usage warning, **no naming warning**. Receipt = `runs/run_20260917_102624_lTqnaw/ops/res_ZwJtZvkk8nkcZqaW.json`. Refusal disclosed: `res_vQvPe_MWts8lPMqT` 400 (daily new-route cap, gotcha 32). Fallback: proposal attached as the public file `job1626-route.json` (sha `deee8907c692e5be`). `outstanding` after: **0 of 63 attempts outstanding; all_complete=True**, `status=submitted job=1626 public_id=833 pending_ops=[]`. This was the session's only assignment, so a successor needs a **fresh joining instruction**.\n \n **THE FINDING (do not redo): SPLIT-COST - route 46's product axis is bought exactly one-for-one, and its cost side is unread.** Job #1606/return #818 showed the served uniform product threshold is `T(w) = 1 - w` and left the cost side open (its caveat 3). This run closes the accounting with exact rationals (6/6 PASS, `src/job1626-checks.py`, one assertion failed first run on my own `17/175` slip - the gain is `23/200`, so `G/T = 23/175`; failing run kept): **`G(w) := T(w) - T(6/25) = 6/25 - w`, so `dG/dw = -1`** - each unit of split reduction buys one unit of theta-range, and the newly controlled set is a theta-strip of width exactly `6/25 - w`. `G(21/100) = 3/100`; `G(1/5) = 1/25` (`G/T = 1/20`); `G(1/8) = 23/200` (`G/T = 23/175`); `G(1/10) = 7/50` (`G/T = 7/45`). The domain corner `(1-w, y)` stays outside the right region at every point (cap = corner, not the old left region). **Pre-registered falsifier, NOT evaluated:** if the route's own cost term `C(w)` (the `3*kappa/2` r-size residue) has `|dC/dw| >= 1`, the one-for-one gain is fully consumed and the split axis closes with **zero compute** and no consumption proof; cheapest check = one read (0.5 h, read-only, 0 CPU-h). Outcomes: `C` w-independent -> axis open (then `R_IJ` at `w = 1/5`); `0 < |dC/dw| < 1` -> report `w*` with `G(w*) = Delta C(w*)`; `|dC/dw| >= 1` -> closed at the source. Rung: **verified** for the arithmetic rows, **design** for the falsifier; no cost term was read, no served file edited, no twin-prime claim.\n \n **SUCCESSOR, cheapest first.** (1) **Run the falsifier** (0.5 h read-only, 0 CPU-h): locate the served note printing the `3*kappa/2` r-size residue, differentiate in `w`, compare with `dG/dw = -1`. (2) **Usage for #833 stays PENDING** - `POST /projects/twin-primes/return/833/transcript` with `{transcript, tokens}` once, under this run's headers; never estimate (same standing item for #831, #829, #827, #826, #824, #823, #818, #811, #807, #757, #744, #737, #736, #729, #718...#728). (3) **Resubmit the preserved `proposed` payloads** under a new rid when the daily cap frees: `job1626-route.json` (`deee8907`) plus #807/#1602, #818/#1606, #823/#1620, #824/#1621, #826/#1622, #829/#1624, #831/#1625 - all already uploaded, no re-upload. Standing: the destroyed 170 kB HANDOFF.md is still unrec\n \n [FILE_TOO_LARGE]: The combined read_files output exceeded the 20,000 estimated-token limit. This file was truncated after 7,286 estimated tokens. Read it separately or use code_search for the relevant section.\n referencedBy: {}"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "date -u; cd \"$(realpath .)\"; pwd; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome outstanding 2>&1 | tail -20", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 30}, "output": "Thu Sep 17 09:06:59 UTC 2026\n~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome\nclosed run_20260916_190135_4CIzXw status=released job=1530 public_id=None pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260916_191004_eE6QUA status=submitted job=1530 public_id=737 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260916_194518_tf0vew status=submitted job=1532 public_id=744 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260916_201015_Hh5eKg status=submitted job=1533 public_id=757 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_065006_SMcmHc status=submitted job=1602 public_id=807 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_085855_jlbczA status=submitted job=1604 public_id=811 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_090839_ZqccwQ status=submitted job=1606 public_id=818 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_092036_lmD4fA status=submitted job=1619 public_id=820 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_092822_FAxUsg status=submitted job=1620 public_id=823 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_093557_BnL_gA status=submitted job=1621 public_id=824 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_095041_CtvXDw status=submitted job=1622 public_id=826 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_095812_rQz9hg status=submitted job=1623 public_id=827 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_100923_FMS_yQ status=submitted job=1624 public_id=829 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_101711_VooJLw status=submitted job=1625 public_id=831 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_102624_lTqnaw status=submitted job=1626 public_id=833 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_104145_jbkeQw status=released job=1627 public_id=None pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_105100_zNJ1tg status=submitted job=1627 public_id=835 pending_ops=[]\nclosed run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ status=submitted job=1628 public_id=837 pending_ops=[]\n\n0 of 66 attempts outstanding; all_complete=True\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; ls -la .solveathome/runs/ | tail -8; echo ---; ls .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ/ .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ/work/ 2>/dev/null; echo ---; ls .solveathome/state/", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 30}, "output": "drwx------@ 7 ~ staff 224 Sep 17 09:50 run_20260917_095041_CtvXDw\ndrwx------@ 7 ~ staff 224 Sep 17 09:58 run_20260917_095812_rQz9hg\ndrwx------@ 7 ~ staff 224 Sep 17 10:09 run_20260917_100923_FMS_yQ\ndrwx------@ 7 ~ staff 224 Sep 17 10:18 run_20260917_101711_VooJLw\ndrwx------@ 7 ~ staff 224 Sep 17 10:26 run_20260917_102624_lTqnaw\ndrwx------@ 7 ~ staff 224 Sep 17 10:42 run_20260917_104145_jbkeQw\ndrwx------@ 7 ~ staff 224 Sep 17 10:53 run_20260917_105100_zNJ1tg\ndrwx------@ 7 ~ staff 224 Sep 17 11:02 run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ\n---\n.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ/:\nassignment.json\nops\nrun.json\nsession.json\nwork\n\n.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ/work/:\nPROGRESS.md\njob1628\n---\nHANDOFF.md\nHANDOFF.md.bak-083331\nattempts.json\ncurrent_run\nhandoff-entry-run_20260916_191004_eE6QUA.md\nhandoff-entry-run_20260917_065006_SMcmHc.md\nhandoff-entry-run_20260917_090839_ZqccwQ.md\nidentity\nreadiness-extra.json\nreadiness.json\nregistration.json\nsession\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; find .solveathome/runs -name \"PENDING*\" -newermt \"2026-09-16\" 2>/dev/null | tail; echo \"--- newest progress\"; tail -40 .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ/work/PROGRESS.md", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 30}, "output": ".solveathome/runs/run_20260916_130950_vbNDeQ/work/PENDING.md\n.solveathome/runs/run_20260916_124911_r4biLQ/work/PENDING.md\n.solveathome/runs/run_20260916_111913_U5Xr-Q/work/job1406/PENDING.md\n.solveathome/runs/run_20260916_125605_wmVIXg/work/PENDING.md\n--- newest progress\n at exactly the splits the record proposes → the hinge is a two-line citation, not a computation.\n- Checks: **12/12 PASS**, `work/job1628/src/job1628-checks.py` sha256\n `a805b00a93525c2ce3f8e854274763519e31d02637c215c02c24f2957e14ad58`, log sha256 `6fb91815…af60f1e2`,\n exit 0. Two of my own failing runs kept: `job1628-checks.fail1.log` (wrong gain base `T(6/25)-w`),\n `fail2.log` (sign slip in an assertion).\n- Rungs: arithmetic `verified`; the κ reading `sourced`; the adverse coupling `design`; no novelty claim,\n no twin-prime claim.\n\n## Files\n- report `work/job1628/job1628-report.md` (sha `7d40d9bb…`)\n- proposal object `work/job1628/job1628-research.json` (sha `37ea7352…`, corrected: top-level `next_step`)\n- checks `work/job1628/src/job1628-checks.py` (+ `.log`, `.fail1.log`, `.fail2.log`; upload bodies `work/job1628/upload/`)\n- transcript `work/job1628/job1628-transcript.jsonl` (47 lines), chat\n `chats/2026-09-17T08-59-36.790Z`\n\n## Done before taking work (gate + readiness)\n1. `outstanding` → **0 of 65** outstanding, all_complete=True; no open predecessor (#1627 closed as #835).\n2. `state/HANDOFF.md` read; cheapest listed item was exactly this cost-side falsifier → done here.\n3. `sah.py readiness` re-run **26/26** at 09:00:06Z; `tests/path_fixture.py` **5/5**.\n4. Identity bound to **this** chat (`chats/2026-09-17T08-59-36.790Z`) → `deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash`,\n `X-Effort: unmeasured` (sources recorded) → `state/identity/run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ.json`.\n5. `run new` saved the exact URL + launch id before networking; `register` 200 took the job.\n\n## What is next (exact commands, from the project root)\n- **Session cap spent (1 of 1)** → a successor needs a **fresh joining instruction**.\n- **Usage for #837 stays PENDING** — `POST /projects/twin-primes/return/837/transcript` with\n `{transcript, tokens}` once, under this run's headers; never estimate (same standing item for\n #835, #833, #831, #829, #827, #826, #824, #823, #818, #811, #807, #757, #744, #737, #736, #729, #718…#728).\n- **Resubmit the corrected proposal** `work/job1628/job1628-research.json` (`37ea7352…`, already uploaded,\n no re-upload) under a new rid when the daily route cap frees; same standing item for `job1627-…jsjs.json`\n `8ea6ef7e…`, `job1626-route.json` `deee8907…`, `job1625-research.json` `01d1f914…`, #829's `e784e290…`,\n #823/#824/#826's objects.\n- **Cheapest pending science (from the proposal)**: the same 0.5 h read-only read, now with an exact\n decision boundary (`w* = 12/125`) — parameterise `residual-coverage.md` (11)-(16) in `w` and locate the\n derivations of `31/50` and `77/200`.\n\n## Open questions\n- Is the register's \"r-size split … the split region equals the current region\" about `r <= V` or about the\n `U=V=x^w` support split? Both can be true only if they are different objects — unresolved here.\n- Is κ pinned to the box size anywhere in the Perron derivation of (7)? Unprinted in every source checked.\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; cat .solveathome/state/current_run 2>/dev/null; echo; cat .solveathome/state/readiness.json 2>/dev/null | head -c 600; echo; echo \"--- chat dirs\"; ls -1t ~/.config/../Library/Application\\ Support/ 2>/dev/null | head -0; ls -1t \"$HOME/Library/Application Support/\" 2>/dev/null | head -20", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 30}, "output": "run_20260916_190135_4CIzXw\n\n{\n \"tool_version\": \"sah/12\",\n \"tool_sha256\": \"2173f7adb00308d9b8ae9dcd51c1e38d0b604af76050c1dda95d21faddc5fe4f\",\n \"v1_sha256\": \"35b09015e2cbf1fdf4ee5f2d9b257d1a6c5018f52feec2329dace77f4f8fc9b5\",\n \"command\": \"/opt/homebrew/opt/python@3.14/bin/python3.14 ~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/tests/acceptance.py\",\n \"exit_code\": 0,\n \"passed\": 26,\n \"total\": 26,\n \"checks\": [\n {\n \"name\": \"one committed registration key under 8 concurrent initializers\",\n \"ok\": true\n },\n {\n \"name\": \"interrupted/competing write leaves committed data readable\",\n \n--- chat dirs\nVimcal\ndiscord\nGitHub Desktop\nCodex\nCrashReporter\ncom.apple.sharedfilelist\niTerm2\nElement\nicdd\nBetterDisplay\ncom.apple.spotlight\nCloudDocs\nSteam\ncom.openai.codex\nsolveathome\nSignal\ncom.apple.akd\nmaestral\ndefault.store-shm\nCallHistoryDB\nhead: illegal line count -- 0\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; cat .solveathome/state/identity/run_20260917_110022_fmG4fQ.json; echo ---; ls -1t \"$HOME/Library/Application Support/solveathome\" 2>/dev/null | head", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 30}, "output": "{\n \"app\": \"freebuff-cli\",\n \"harness\": \"freebuff-cli\",\n \"chat\": \"~/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/2026-09-17T08-59-36.790Z\",\n \"agent\": \"base3-free-deepseek-flash\",\n \"model\": \"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash\",\n \"model_source\": \"run-state.json agentTemplates['base3-free-deepseek-flash'].model\",\n \"effort\": \"unmeasured\",\n \"effort_source\": \"no effort/reasoningOptions field exposed by this app version (~/.config/manicode/settings.json 0.0.174, runConfig, agentTemplates, chat records all checked)\",\n \"model_evidence_counts\": {\n \"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash\": 17\n },\n \"runConfig\": {\n \"agent\": \"base3-free-deepseek-flash\",\n \"promptLength\": 2167,\n \"contentBlockCount\": 0,\n \"previousMessageCount\": 0,\n \"agentDefinitionCount\": 96,\n \"costMode\": \"free\",\n \"maxAgentSteps\": 200\n },\n \"checked\": [\n {\n \"source\": \"~/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/2026-09-17T08-59-36.790Z/log.jsonl\",\n \"field\": \"data.runConfig (agent) and model fields\"\n },\n {\n \"source\": \"~/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/2026-09-17T08-59-36.790Z/run-state.json\",\n \"field\": \"sessionState.fileContext.agentTemplates['base3-free-deepseek-flash']\"\n },\n {\n \"source\": \"~/.config/manicode/settings.json\",\n \"field\": \"freebuffModel / effort keys\"\n }\n ],\n \"observed_utc\": \"2026-09-17T09:00:25Z\"\n}\n---\ntools\nresearch\nstate\nlogs\nruns\nprivate\ndevice\nallocation\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "ls -1dt \"$HOME/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/\"* | head -5; echo ---; date -u; echo ---; ls -1t \"$HOME/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/\" | head -3", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 30}, "output": "~/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/2026-09-17T09-06-44.977Z\n~/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/2026-09-17T08-59-36.790Z\n~/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/2026-09-17T08-49-57.223Z\n~/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/2026-09-17T08-40-09.377Z\n~/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/2026-09-17T08-33-31.206Z\n---\nThu Sep 17 09:07:10 UTC 2026\n---\n2026-09-17T09-06-44.977Z\n2026-09-17T08-59-36.790Z\n2026-09-17T08-49-57.223Z\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "write_todos", "input": {"todos": [{"task": "Pre-work gate: outstanding check + read HANDOFF.md (done: 0/66 outstanding, all_complete=True)", "completed": true}, {"task": "Re-run readiness (acceptance 26/26) + path fixture 5/5", "completed": false}, {"task": "run new (exact URL, model, effort, general mode) + identity bound to this chat", "completed": false}, {"task": "register via tested path; print binding JSON; save assignment", "completed": false}, {"task": "Research the issued assignment; write report + checks + artifacts; PROGRESS.md checkpoints", "completed": false}, {"task": "complete (dry-run -> submit -> receipt); outstanding check; DONE/BLOCKED line", "completed": false}]}, "output": "message: Todos written"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome readiness 2>&1 | tail -6", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 180}, "output": " \"tool_sha256\": \"2173f7adb00308d9b8ae9dcd51c1e38d0b604af76050c1dda95d21faddc5fe4f\",\n \"passed\": 26,\n \"total\": 26,\n \"exit_code\": 0,\n \"observed_utc\": \"2026-09-17T09:07:21Z\"\n}\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 .solveathome/tests/path_fixture.py 2>&1 | tail -8", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 180}, "output": "PASS a second assignment taken inside the live session is in the ledger and open BEFORE any submission\n req exit=None current=att_fixture02 job=772; outstanding exit=2 both attempts listed=True\nPASS completion persists the server receipt; an exact retry re-reads it without a second POST\n complete exit=None; retry exit=None; POSTs before/after retry=1/1; the second attempt is closed, the first stays open (outstanding exit=2)\nPASS a confirmed release records its real outcome and clears the ledger exactly once\n release exit=None op=rel_SRyBbVTyxw_iA3rh attempt=att_fixture01 status=200; outstanding exit=0 all_complete=True\n\n5/5 passed; recorded in ~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/state/readiness-extra.json\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome run new --help 2>&1 | head -30; echo ===; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome identity --help 2>&1 | head -20", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 60}, "output": "usage: sah.py run [-h] [--name NAME] --model MODEL --effort EFFORT\n [--model-source MODEL_SOURCE]\n [--effort-source EFFORT_SOURCE] [--caps CAPS] [--mode MODE]\n [--protocol-version PROTOCOL_VERSION]\n {new} url\n\npositional arguments:\n {new}\n url\n\noptions:\n -h, --help show this help message and exit\n --name NAME\n --model MODEL\n --effort EFFORT\n --model-source MODEL_SOURCE\n --effort-source EFFORT_SOURCE\n --caps CAPS\n --mode MODE\n --protocol-version PROTOCOL_VERSION\n===\nusage: sah.py identity [-h] [--app {claude-code,freebuff-cli}]\n [--session-log SESSION_LOG] [--chat CHAT]\n [--settings SETTINGS] [--record] [--run RUN]\n\noptions:\n -h, --help show this help message and exit\n --app {claude-code,freebuff-cli}\n --session-log SESSION_LOG\n --chat CHAT\n --settings SETTINGS\n --record\n --run RUN\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome run new 'https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/start?time=1task' --model deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash --effort unmeasured --mode general 2>&1 | tail -20; echo \"=== register help\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome register --help 2>&1 | head -20", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 60}, "output": "{\"run\": \"run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg\", \"dir\": \"~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg\"}\n=== register help\nusage: sah.py register [-h] [--run RUN] [--model MODEL] [--effort EFFORT]\n [--model-source MODEL_SOURCE]\n [--effort-source EFFORT_SOURCE] [--caps CAPS]\n [--mode MODE] [--protocol-version PROTOCOL_VERSION]\n [url]\n\npositional arguments:\n url\n\noptions:\n -h, --help show this help message and exit\n --run RUN\n --model MODEL\n --effort EFFORT\n --model-source MODEL_SOURCE\n --effort-source EFFORT_SOURCE\n --caps CAPS\n --mode MODE\n --protocol-version PROTOCOL_VERSION\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; CHAT=\"$HOME/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/2026-09-17T09-06-44.977Z\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome identity --app freebuff-cli --chat \"$CHAT\" --record --run run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg 2>&1 | tail -30", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 60}, "output": " \"effort_source\": \"no effort/reasoningOptions field exposed by this app version (~/.config/manicode/settings.json 0.0.174, runConfig, agentTemplates, chat records all checked)\",\n \"model_evidence_counts\": {\n \"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash\": 17\n },\n \"runConfig\": {\n \"agent\": \"base3-free-deepseek-flash\",\n \"promptLength\": 2167,\n \"contentBlockCount\": 0,\n \"previousMessageCount\": 0,\n \"agentDefinitionCount\": 96,\n \"costMode\": \"free\",\n \"maxAgentSteps\": 200\n },\n \"checked\": [\n {\n \"source\": \"~/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/2026-09-17T09-06-44.977Z/log.jsonl\",\n \"field\": \"data.runConfig (agent) and model fields\"\n },\n {\n \"source\": \"~/.config/manicode/projects/freebuf-solveathome/chats/2026-09-17T09-06-44.977Z/run-state.json\",\n \"field\": \"sessionState.fileContext.agentTemplates['base3-free-deepseek-flash']\"\n },\n {\n \"source\": \"~/.config/manicode/settings.json\",\n \"field\": \"freebuffModel / effort keys\"\n }\n ],\n \"observed_utc\": \"2026-09-17T09:07:32Z\",\n \"recorded_at\": \"~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/state/identity/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg.json\"\n}\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome register --run run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg 2>&1 | tail -40", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 90}, "output": "{\"run\": \"run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg\", \"status\": 200, \"reply_keys\": [\"department_id\", \"run_id\", \"direction\", \"protocol_version\", \"job_id\", \"attempt_id\", \"guidance_version\", \"type\", \"purpose\", \"research_stage\", \"research_route_id\", \"session\", \"session_jobs\", \"session_max_jobs\", \"inbox\", \"assignment_reason\", \"contact_id\", \"brief_md\"]}\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 -c \"\nimport json\nd=json.load(open('.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/assignment.json'))\nprint(json.dumps({'job_id':d.get('job_id'),'attempt_id':d.get('attempt_id'),'session':d.get('session')}))\nprint('type',d.get('type'),'purpose',d.get('purpose'),'stage',d.get('research_stage'),'route',d.get('research_route_id'))\nprint('session_jobs',d.get('session_jobs'),'of',d.get('session_max_jobs'))\nprint('reason',d.get('assignment_reason'))\nprint('inbox',json.dumps(d.get('inbox'))[:500])\nprint('KEYS',list(d.keys()))\n\"", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 60}, "output": "{\"job_id\": \"1629\", \"attempt_id\": \"\", \"session\": \"\"}\ntype explore purpose discovery stage discover route None\nsession_jobs 1 of 1\nreason {'policy': 'research portfolio', 'tier': 3, 'guidance_version': 'research-2026-09-15.8', 'discovery_share': 0.2, 'discovery_allocation': {'total': 0, 'discovery': 0}, 'eligible_backlog': {'reviews': 0, 'research': 0}, 'prefer_research': False, 'research_allocation': {'discover': 0.3, 'pursue': 0.4, 'rescue': 0.15, 'consolidate': 0.15}, 'research_hours': {'total': 676.3116666666667, 'abandoned': 48.06333333333333, 'discover': 490, 'pursue': 105.35, 'rescue': 13.5, 'consolidate': 67.46166666666667}, 'research_bucket': 'discover', 'skill_matches': 0, 'purpose': 'discovery'}\ninbox {\"asks_for_you\": [], \"open_asks\": [], \"answers\": [], \"replies\": [], \"replies_other\": [], \"challenges\": [], \"max_message_id\": 0}\nKEYS ['department_id', 'run_id', 'direction', 'protocol_version', 'job_id', 'attempt_id', 'guidance_version', 'type', 'purpose', 'research_stage', 'research_route_id', 'session', 'session_jobs', 'session_max_jobs', 'inbox', 'assignment_reason', 'contact_id', 'brief_md']\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 -c \"\nimport json;d=json.load(open('.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/assignment.json'));print(d['brief_md'])\n\" 2>&1 | head -120", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 60}, "output": "# Job #1629: Leads: new statistic\n\nProtocol: department-v2; research guidance: research-2026-09-15.8.\nDirection: general project research.\n\nAttempt: . Send X-Attempt: on /result and /release (or include \"attempt_id\" in their JSON). Retry a failed network request with the same attempt and unchanged body; the server returns its existing receipt. A new attempt after release is different work ownership.\n\nAssignment: research portfolio. Purpose: discovery.\n\nType: **explore**. Lane: formalize. Documents and scripts: `https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/docs/` (snapshot `main`).\nBudget: 2 h of your time (the job's budget and your person's cap agree). Compute hint: none. Expires: Thu Sep 17 2026 13:07:35 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time). Session: assignment 1 of 1 your person allowed.\n\n## Your local research framework\n\nBefore research on this assignment, self-review your local framework against this task and prior failures. Build and validate missing essentials now: task tracking, transcript/usage capture, submission and outstanding-work checks, evidence retrieval and recovery. Reuse compatible pinned tools across folders with separate state. Verify this turn's model/thinking-level lookup, publication scrubber and actual execution controls. Exercise actual tools; a plan or README is insufficient. Record checks and bounded improvements locally. Preserve sibling runs and their instructions.\n\nPersist this job/attempt, run and application session/turn IDs, direction, limits and transcript boundaries before the first research step. Use automated extraction and submission scripts that read the actual work records, detect agent/model/effort changes and preserve each turn's attribution; setup-time identity is not a permanent reporting default. Close work through the tested reporting operation: validate, submit, save the server receipt before marking the result submitted, then reconcile. Keep incomplete usage explicitly pending; never estimate or count it twice. Save findings and framework lessons.\n\nBefore requesting another job or normally ending a turn, run the outstanding-work check over ALL issued attempts, including those with no submission. Each must have a verified result receipt, a verified release/expiry/cancellation, or an explicit outstanding reason and next action. A check of submitted records alone cannot prove completion. Resolve or disclose outstanding work; never claim all work submitted when it is not. User interruption still means stop: checkpoint/release as permitted, never fabricate a result or resume without authority.\n\nRequired setup: `https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/department-protocol?section=framework`; completion and outstanding-work checks: `https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/department-protocol?section=lifecycle`; transcript/usage: `https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/department-protocol?section=accounting`; submission format: `https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/department-protocol?section=publication`.\n\nFramework references also cover identity, tooling, execution and publication_safety. If you cannot read your own session, follow runtime_lifecycle: checkpoint and ask the user to resume. Otherwise continue without pausing.\n\n## The task\n\nThis assignment uses the project's reserved discovery capacity for your tier, even while other jobs are queued. Find something new: a route, connection, counterexample, or testable hypothesis. Record what you tried and learned, including negative findings.\n\n**New statistic with a falsifier.** Design one finite statistic a run could actually decide something about, where the retained censuses could not: the decision it informs, a pre-registered falsifier written before any run, a matched control (random-sign, permutation or independent thinning, as the repo uses), and the scale at which the effect would be visible if present. Search online for existing statistics, datasets and computed ranges first. Reuse and cite any numbers already published. Only if the experiment answers an uncovered question and fits the compute your person offered, run the missing part in the house format (question in comments, then code) and report; otherwise return the design with the cost, so a session with the compute can run it.\n\nRead `research/README.md` (the router) first if this is your first assignment here; cite every message, return, file and person you build on.\n\n**Return** as this job (type explore): a report with what you did, the rung of each claim, and the gap that remains, plus any files. If your work amounts to a new route, include `research.proposal` and its cheapest next experiment in this return (GET https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/research-protocol); if it finds a served document wrong, an `audit` return with the revised file. Then call `GET https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/start` once. Do not poll.\n\n### Success criteria for this assignment\n\nFind an uncovered contribution to the project goal. Use the prior-work search to compare promising approaches, choose one and identify its weakest assumption and cheapest discriminating next step. A good outcome can be a sourced known match or a precisely scoped gap; novelty is not a required conclusion. Propose a route only when its difference and next experiment are concrete.\n\nReturn the schema required by the assigned task, with the supported outcome, decisive evidence, scope and unresolved obligations. Keep the report as short as the argument permits; include the derivation needed to assess a mathematical claim. This task focus applies within the research policy and donor limits above.\n\n## Reviews waiting for your person's other agents\n\n24 review job(s) of this handle's own returns are queued and cannot go to deepseek-v4-flash: a model never reviews its own kind. They wait for an agent on another model at tier 3 or above (claude-fable-5-1, gpt-6, gpt-6-astra, gpt-6-astra-pro, claude-opus-5, claude-sonnet-5, deepseek-v4.1-flash, gemini-3.8-flash, gpt-5.6-sol, qwen3.8). Until one reviews them, this handle's returns stack unreviewed; tell your person when you report.\n\n## Current limits and evidence\n\nAttempt: . Type: explore. Time: 2 hours, within one assignment. Assignment 1 of 1. Compute: 75% of the machine it runs on (up to 16 GB and 4 CPU h per assignment), up to 5 GB of disk; disk 5 GB; sub-agents allowed, sharing the same budget. Expires Thu Sep 17 2026 13:07:35 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time). Check the server during long local steps, at least every 120 minutes. Stop and release when the user stops you.\n\nAn explore is recorded without review unless request_review:true or a structured research result requests validation. Use review for claims others should rely on.\n\nClaim once in the task's channel; this is the session's last assignment, so the session ends at the result and the return itself is the completion note (a done message after the result is refused); messages link to the evidence. Claim questions through the department inbox before answering.\n\nRead the locally cached protocol's evidence, publication and applicable files sections before submitting; preserve the actual assignment transcript and observed evidence, and scrub credentials, private source payloads and private user instructions. Use this run's saved headers, attempt ID and exact retry receipts; follow the cached API contract. This attempt keeps its issued direction revision. Save reusable findings with provenance; search and update relevant topic summaries. Then request the next assignment within your current limits.\n\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; ls .solveathome/research/notes/ | tail -20; echo \"--- summaries\"; ls .solveathome/research/summaries/ 2>/dev/null | tail", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 30}, "output": "N-1472-01-triage-route39-repriced.md\nN-1481-01-transport-margin-c-over-q.md\nN-1485-01-ladder-convention.md\nN-1491-01-shadow-band-average-prior-art.md\nN-1492-01-q43-start-tile-spread.md\nN-1494-01-route44-jacobsthal-conventions.md\nN-1499-01-class-stratified-statistic.md\nN-1502-01-motohashi1976-mechanism-read.md\nN-1503-01-well-factorable-convolution-transfer.md\nN-1504-01-yang-theta-gt-0-and-residue.md\nN-1524-01-scour-cutoff-and-crystallization-exception.md\nN-1526-01-cutoff-parameterised-budget-region.md\nN-1529-01-bridge-w-route46.md\nN-1530-01-split-w-full-constraint-set.md\nN-1533-01-tile-resolved-margin.md\nN-1604-01-twin-slot-census-owned.md\nN-1606-01-split-ramp-uniform-product-threshold.md\nN-1625-01-return15-negative-closes-sentences.md\nN-1627-01-mobius-bv-level-for-the-centered-consumer.md\nN-1628-01-split-cost-axis-hinge.md\n--- summaries\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; D=$(python3 -c \"import json;print(json.load(open('.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/run.json'))['run'])\" 2>/dev/null); echo $D; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome req run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg GET /projects/twin-primes/research/README.md --save .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/replies/README.json 2>&1 | tail -5; python3 -c \"\nimport json;d=json.load(open('.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/replies/README.json'));print(d.get('raw','')[:4000])\"", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 60}, "output": "run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg\n{\"rid\": \"q_pC_dd22edwx74Z0k\", \"status\": 404}\n\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; R=run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg; W=\".solveathome/runs/$R/work\"; mkdir -p \"$W/replies\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome req $R GET /projects/twin-primes/docs/research/README.md --save \"$W/replies/README2.json\" >/dev/null 2>&1; python3 -c \"\nimport json;d=json.load(open('$W/replies/README2.json'));print(d.get('raw','NO RAW')[:5000])\"", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 60}, "output": "# The research directory: what answers what, and in what order\n\n\n\n**Scope.** This file is the **router**, and that is all it is. It holds no\nmathematics and no summary of the programme's state. Its one job is to get a\nreader to the right file for the question they have, at the lowest token cost,\nwithout reading the wrong file first. State lives in [../README.md](../README.md)\n§Status and [G2-STATE.md](G2-STATE.md) §0; the target lives in\n[ZONE-POSTULATE.md](ZONE-POSTULATE.md); what to try next lives in\n[../TODO.md](../TODO.md).\n\nPrimes as moiré patterns: stack the periodic multiples of the primes you know,\nand the holes of the interference pattern — repeating with period P_n# =\n2·3·…·p_n — are where all further primes must live. This directory is the lab\nnotebook: each numbered script states a claim in comments, computes it, and\ncarries its actual output and reading at the bottom. Experiments are\nindexed in [SCRIPTS.md](SCRIPTS.md). Check each producer's invocation,\nretained inputs, cost and correction banners before running it; some\nsource logs and over-budget reproductions remain outstanding.\n\n## Start here, and every entry document points at the same path\n\n1. [../README.md](../README.md) **§Status** — the central object, the proven\n bound, the gap, and the unchanged upper bound on G₂.\n2. [G2-STATE.md](G2-STATE.md) **§0** — what is hard here, before any derivation.\n3. **This table**, and then read for your question rather than in file order.\n\n**Do not open [GLOSSARY.md](GLOSSARY.md) first.** It is a lookup document, read\none entry at a time. **Do not open anything in `history/`** unless you need the\nhistory of a specific claim.\n\n## Which file answers which question\n\n| the question | read, in this order |\n|---|---|\n| what to give the core handler so agents can continue | [RESEARCH-EXECUTION.md](RESEARCH-EXECUTION.md); reviewed closeout, candidate next obligations, ownership, checkpoints and acceptance |\n| how an incoming research agent should start without loading the entire corpus | [AGENT-START.md](AGENT-START.md), then [RESEARCH-HANDOFF.md](RESEARCH-HANDOFF.md) sections 1–3 and the assigned lane |\n| whether the shifted-Mobius source keeps its moving cutoff and what explicit error tolerance suffices | [moving-cutoff-parity.md](moving-cutoff-parity.md), [validator](moving-cutoff-validation.js); source counterexample, dyadic repair, exact centered discrepancy and OPEN arithmetic estimate |\n| whether joint prime-partner/complement completion supplies a new estimate | [joint-correction-source-audit.md](joint-correction-source-audit.md), [validator](joint-correction-validation.js); prior-art matches, short Vaughan reconstruction, selected-branch control and remaining arithmetic |\n| what the whole supported coefficient contributes to the harmonic and sieve budgets | [supported-coefficient-dickman.md](supported-coefficient-dickman.md), [validator](supported-coefficient-dickman-validation.js); novelty check, classical Dickman collapse, insufficient separate-sign lower bound and OPEN joint correction |\n| whether the proposed positive companion pays the negative family | [paired-factor-budget.md](paired-factor-budget.md), [validator](paired-factor-budget-validation.js); aggregate Pan--Ding input and complete two-family budget |\n| whether paying only negative mass can close the current consumer, and what switching supplies | [switching-negative-mass.md](switching-negative-mass.md), [validator](switching-negative-mass-validation.js); actual negative-mass lower bound, prime exclusion, matched classical inputs and required net comparison |\n| what nearby sieve literature already supplies and which factor configurations remain | [smooth-sieve-literature.md](smooth-sieve-literature.md), [validator](smooth-sieve-literature-validation.js); source matches, profile constant, paid shifted small-prime tail and remaining signed factor estimate |\n| whether all absolute global contributions can be paid at scale x | [global-smooth-majorant.md](global-smooth-majorant.md); a C3 admissible profile, three-prime majorant and corrected Henriot upper theorem give full absolute O(x); the signed constant remains open |\n| what causes negative products of the full global coefficients, and what the first bound attempt established | [global-factor-signs.md](global-factor-signs.md); complete small-prime subset formula, paid prime-power exceptions, failed pair majorant, and the full signed cofactor target with prime filters |\n| whether the wider corpus supports changing the global decomposition before extending the corner | [global-cutoff-averaging.md](global-\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "read_files", "input": {"paths": [".solveathome/research/notes/N-1604-01-twin-slot-census-owned.md"]}, "output": "\n- path: .solveathome/research/notes/N-1604-01-twin-slot-census-owned.md\n content: |\n # N-1604-01 — the twin-slot census of a primorial period is OWNED (OEIS A059861 + Brown 2023)\n \n - **id / version:** `N-1604-01`, v1 (2026-09-17)\n - **topic / question:** prior art for the central object of return **#162** (job **#33**, @zemaj),\n *\"the T29, T31, T37 twin-slot censuses reproduced on a second machine with the served\n `research/verify-ladder-big.js`\"* — is the object covered by published work?\n - **author run / task:** `run_20260917_085855_jlbczA`, job **#1604** (explore/discovery, lane\n `infinitude`, general mode), public return **#811**, attempt `[REDACTED]`.\n - **status:** locally **measured** (exact integers) and **sourced**; prior-art verdict **owned /\n known**; not submitted as a route (the daily new-route cap is exhausted; #1604 had no route).\n \n ## Body (the finding)\n \n The object, restated exactly: each reported census `T_y` — `T29 = 214,708,725`,\n `T31 = 6,226,553,025`, `T37 = 217,929,355,875` at widths `29# = 6,469,693,230`,\n `31# = 200,560,490,130`, `37# = 7,420,738,134,810` — is the cardinality of the **twin slots of one\n complete primorial period**:\n \n T_y = |{ r : 0 <= r < y#, gcd(r, y#) = 1 and gcd(r + 2, y#) = 1 }| = prod_{3 <= p <= y} (p - 2),\n \n i.e. **OEIS A059861** at `n = 10, 11, 12` (`a(n) = prod_{i=2..n} (p_i - 2)`).\n \n **Owners.** (1) **OEIS A059861** carries the defining statement verbatim as a formula comment —\n *Greg Tener, 2021-10-22*: `a(n) = |{r | 0 <= r < primorial(n) and gcd(r, primorial(n)) = 1 and\n gcd(r + 2, primorial(n)) = 1}|` — together with all three integers on its data line, the recursion\n `a(n) = a(n-1)*(A000040(n) - 2)` (Smeets, 2019) and the comment *\"Arises in Hardy-Littlewood k-tuple\n conjecture. Also a(n) is the exact number of d=2 and also d=4 differences in dRRS[modulus=n-th\n primorial]; see A049296\"*; its printed references include Hardy & Littlewood, *Acta Math.* **44**\n (1923) 1–70. (2) The T29 value is **in print in a paper**: **Steven Brown**, *Distance between\n consecutive elements of the multiplicative group of integers modulo n*, **arXiv:2311.06873 (2023),\n Table 1 \"Values of K(D, p#)\"**, row `D = 2`, column `p = 29` = `214708725`, computed by\n \"reference calculation\" and cross-checked against formula 15 p. 13.\n \n **Exact difference from the closest printed results.** The printed owners give the exact count for\n *every* `n` (definition, gcd formula, recursion), so the three integers are fully covered as values;\n Brown's table shows `D = 2` through `p = 29`, and A059861's data/recursion cover `p = 31, 37`. What\n return #162 adds is a **measurement** (a second-machine rerun of a served script, checked against\n integers embedded in that script's fingerprint), and the return itself states that the classical\n \"Copying Theorem\" it exercises \"is not made more proven by the run\". The project's name **\"Copying\n Theorem\"** is local vocabulary for the standard CRT lifting of one admissible slot into `p - 2`\n slots (equivalently the recursion above); the literature does not use that name. Not found in any\n source, and not claimed by #162: the mod-30 three-slot lattice scan, its embed-hash gate, the\n 37#-width single-core run — implementation and verification, not statements.\n \n **Ready-to-file IMPORT-MAP row** (belongs in an **`audit`** return; the map has no `A059861` /\n `A049296` / `214708725` row):\n \n | object | owning vocabulary | printed owner (locators) | coverage / difference |\n |---|---|---|---|\n | twin-slot census of one complete primorial period, `T_y = prod_{3<=p<=y}(p-2)`; return #162 / job #33 | \"dRRS at primorials\"; \"the number of d=2 differences of the reduced residue system mod p_n#\"; Hardy–Littlewood k-tuple candidate count | OEIS **A059861** (definition; Tener's gcd formula 2021-10-22; data n = 10,11,12; cf. A049296, A002110, A005867); **Brown arXiv:2311.06873** Table 1 p. 25, D = 2, p = 29 | exact for every n; the served mod-30 scan and embed gate are not printed statements; \"Copying Theorem\" is local |\n \n ## Scope and assumptions\n \n Scope: the **count** object only (not the served script, not the project's \"Copying Theorem\" name,\n not any claim about twin primes or `G₂`). The reading assumes return #162's widths are the primorials\n `y#`, which the served script's banner states (`P = 30 * 7 * 11 * ... * upto`) and the local check\n confirms.\n \n ## Evidence and source locators\n \n - Local, exact integers, `runs/run_20260917_085855_jlbczA/work/job1604/src/job1604-checks.py` (run\n under the tool's bounded `exec --seconds 300`, wall 1.21 s) → `job1604-checks.json` sha256\n `f6009c8f48dc56a4f3eb1d33c8f0055388c5f1b8ca2b3cd54f164b0d3a0af84d`, **6/6 PASS**: widths are the\n primorials; `prod(p-2)` reproduces all three embedded integers; the gcd definition reproduces\n A059861 by brute force for `n = 3..8` (`P <= 9,699,690`); the copying recursion holds; the mod-210\n reduced residue system has exactly `a(4) = 15` gaps of size 2 and 15 of size 4; the census splits\n exactly over the mod-30 classes 11, 17, 29 (`T_y/3` each).\n - Channels (raw replies + sha256 in `job1604-search.json`, sha256\n `19c7ff71e78786573f163d262c63e2af0b1f0d1ba8e84a1b9433a2780f605de0`; saved under\n `work/job1604/replies/`): OEIS `q=214708725` 200 (3 hits, A059861 owning = 214708725, Tener\n formula present); OEIS `q=217929355875` 200 (1 hit, A059861); `https://oeis.org/A059861` 200;\n A049296 200; OpenAlex full-text `\"twin prime\" \"primorial\"` 200, 237 works, no match; OpenAlex DOI\n `10.48550/arxiv.2311.06873` 200, exactly 1 work (Brown); arXiv API twin+primorial 200 (3 entries,\n no match) and dRRS 200 (1 entry, no match); **Semantic Scholar 429** (channel failure — never\n evidence of absence); Crossref bibliographic queries returned 2,323,457 / 5,338,763 results (too\n broad: channel limitation, not absence).\n - Read at source: Brown arXiv:2311.06873 PDF 348,302 B sha256\n `3e5142af6c4fd4379aa4f86b2a615691bcf78587d25dd9bc59101b64476c38eb`, `pdftotext -layout`; excerpt\n kept as `job1604-brown-table-1.txt` sha256\n `4e7c364dace13348823f8baf60cb0c401cca00d06adee54cdf251fbd1bbc816c`.\n - **Not probed** (never \"absent\"): Hardy–Littlewood 1923 at source (its locator came from OEIS's\n citation; the equation number for `prod_{p<=y}(1-2/p) ~ 2 C_2 / log^2 y` is **not** pinned here),\n Finch, *Mathematical Constants* (2003) 84–94, Guy, *UPINT* §A8/A1, message #121, return #25,\n Bateman–Horn 1962.\n \n ## Uncertainty\n \n - The claim \"owned\" rests on two printed owners for the *values* and on OEIS for the *defining\n statement*; if a reviewer needs the asymptotic form pinned to an equation number, that is the open\n item above. No uncertainty about the three integers themselves: they are reproduced here in closed\n form and by brute force at smaller `n`.\n - Brown's Table 1 was extracted from the arXiv PDF; only `p = 29` appears in the extracted columns\n for `D = 2` (the table's later columns are not in the extraction) — the `p = 31, 37` values rest on\n OEIS A059861's data line and recursion.\n \n ## Consumers\n \n Return **#811** (job #1604) — report `work/job1604/job1604-report.md` and attached\n `job1604-priorart.json`; `research/IMPORT-MAP.md` (row above, to be filed as an `audit` return);\n return **#162** / job **#33** (@zemaj) as the object; the corpus's `SEARCH-CONVENTIONS.md` row for\n \"max gap between twin-admissible slots mod `x#`\" is the *neighbouring* convention (the max-gap /\n Jacobsthal question), not this count object.\n \n referencedBy: {}"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; R=run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg; W=\".solveathome/runs/$R/work\"; mkdir -p \"$W/replies\" \"$W/src\" \"$W/job1629\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome req $R GET /projects/twin-primes/docs/research/moving-cutoff-parity.md --save \"$W/replies/mcp.json\" >/dev/null 2>&1; python3 - <<'EOF'\nimport json,re\np='.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/replies/mcp.json'\nd=json.load(open(p)); raw=d.get('raw','')\nprint('LEN',len(raw))\nlines=raw.split('\\n')\nfor i,l in enumerate(lines):\n if re.search(r'census|censuses|D_y|0\\.039617|4/25|max over', l):\n print(i, l[:220])\nEOF", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 90}, "output": "LEN 19014\n8 verdict: CHECKED prior art: Murty--Vatwani already supplies the conditional squarefree/parity mechanism and fixed-residue reduction. Its printed p. 654 swap omits n+h>ey; an exact finite counterexample verifies failure o\n235 \\boxed{\\mathcal D_y(x)=\n250 T_2=\\mathcal D_y+\n277 \\boxed{S(x)=C_2x-2C_2M(x)+\\mathcal D_y(x)\n283 the shifted-Mobius distribution hypothesis supplies D_y=o(x).\n291 |\\mathcal D_y|\\le\n310 S(x)\\ge C_2(1-A_2)x+\\mathcal D_y(x)+O_A(x/\\log^A x).\n331 \\mathcal D_y(x)\\ge-\\frac4{25}x+o(x) \\tag{16}\n350 \\mathcal D_y=B_L+2C_2M+O_A(x/\\log^A x). \\tag{17}\n356 the required bound on D_y is still missing. Neither ordinary BV\n365 (16). A finite census of D_y to x=2^38\n368 and shows that at every reachable x the value of D_y is the finite-size\n377 against (13)--(16) is appropriate. A census of D_y without a specified\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "web_search", "input": {"query": "twin primes", "depth": "standard"}, "output": "No search results found for \"twin primes\""} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 - <<'EOF'\nimport json\nd=json.load(open('.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/replies/mcp.json'))\nlines=d['raw'].split('\\n')\nprint('\\n'.join(lines[300:400]))\nEOF", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 60}, "output": "Indeed log(e/t) is negative and decreasing, and the sum of its\ntwo endpoint magnitudes and total variation on [a_e,x] is\nexactly 2log(x/e). Its jump at the excluded boundary has not been\nsilently discarded. Equation (13) shows how the paper's uniform-prefix\ninput pays for the correct domain. The two endpoints in the dyadic\nDelta cost only a fixed factor relative to cumulative discrepancies.\n\nSince M<=V, (6) and (12) imply\n\n\\[\n S(x)\\ge C_2(1-A_2)x+\\mathcal D_y(x)+O_A(x/\\log^A x).\n \\tag{14}\n\\]\n\nThe signs of the error in this lower bound are unspecified; equivalently\nreplace its O term by minus its absolute bound. Rational finite Euler\nproducts through 1000, with elementary infinite-tail bounds, certify\n\n\\[\n \\frac{33}{200}1000)1/(p-1)^2<=1/999. For A2 it lies between\n1-1/1000 and 1 by telescoping sum_(m>1000)1/(m(m-1)). Multiplying\nthese rational enclosures proves the certified inequalities in the\nvalidator; no decimal Euler-product guess is used.\n\nOne sufficient **OPEN** estimate is therefore\n\n\\[\n \\mathcal D_y(x)\\ge-\\frac4{25}x+o(x) \\tag{16}\n\\]\n\non an unbounded set of dyadic x. It would give\nS(x)>=x/200+o(x), and hence S(x)>=x/400 on sufficiently large\nwitnessing scales. Removing the proper-prime-power contribution\nthen gives infinitely many twins, with a positive scale-x weighted\nmargin. Alternatively, the first weighted absolute sum in (13)\nbeing <=2x/25 on those scales suffices. The allowance is finite;\nfull arbitrary-logarithmic equidistribution is a stronger sufficient\ninput. No reverse logical non-implication is asserted.\n\n## 5. What this changes, and what remains open\n\nCompared with the existing left Vaughan remainder B_L, equations\n(12) and [joint-correction-source-audit.md](joint-correction-source-audit.md)\n(12) give\n\n\\[\n \\mathcal D_y=B_L+2C_2M+O_A(x/\\log^A x). \\tag{17}\n\\]\n\nThus this is a different explicitly centered sufficient consumer,\nnot a second independent estimate of the twin count. The density\nbound for M is unconditional and provides the tolerance (15);\nthe required bound on D_y is still missing. Neither ordinary BV\nfor Lambda nor the one-odd-exponent squarefree theorem controls\nDelta_e: its sequence is Lambda(n-2)mu(n), at the fixed shift two.\nAn average over shifts also cannot select that fixed shift.\nThe missing input is not merely an extension by 1/50 beyond the\nordinary BV exponent: ordinary BV concerns a different sequence.\n\nThe bounded attempt establishes the endpoint correction, the complete\ndyadic relation and its conditional tolerance. It fails to establish\n(16). A finite census of D_y to x=2^38\n([centered-discrepancy-measurement.md](centered-discrepancy-measurement.md))\nrefutes neither (16) nor the absolute form behind (13) at those scales,\nand shows that at every reachable x the value of D_y is the finite-size\nerror of the classical term T_1 in (6), of order x/log^2 x, beneath which\nthe discrepancy's own fluctuation is invisible; it measures no asymptotic\ntrend and no improvement to B_L. The contribution is source validation\nand a precise arithmetic interface, with literature novelty unestablished.\n\nThe next useful attempt must supply actual information about (9),\nretaining both its density subtraction and the moving lower endpoint.\nA bounded comparison of a candidate structured progression estimate\nagainst (13)--(16) is appropriate. A census of D_y without a specified\nfalsifier, another generic rewriting, or an automatic import of\nuntwisted BV would repeat the unresolved step. The 2019 source gap\nis now filled at the stated reading scope; do not reassign its retrieval.\n\n## 6. Validation and custody\n\n[moving-cutoff-validation.js](moving-cutoff-validation.js) uses exact\nrational polynomials in formal prime logarithms. It checks (2) under\nboth Lambda conventions and the author-preprint swap before (6.23).\nIt checks (5), the odd/even split, and (10)\nby independently ordered sums on 40 finite (x,y) fixtures, with\nx in {32,48,64,96,128,192,256}. Controls detect deletion of the moving\nboundary, replacement of phi(e) by e, loss of the density projection,\neven-modulus terms and proper prime powers. It also certifies (15)\nusing rational arithmetic and proved tail inequalities.\nThese are finite controls for the formulas; the written BV and\nconvolution arguments carry the asymptotic claims. They do not prove\n(16). The source observation was checked during this pass before\nbeing promoted into the records; no promising deduction was deferred\nmerely to await another research prompt.\n\nSource artifacts read on 2026-09-06:\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; R=run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg; W=\".solveathome/runs/$R/work\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome req $R GET /projects/twin-primes/docs/research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.md --save \"$W/replies/cdm.json\" >/dev/null 2>&1; python3 - <<'EOF'\nimport json\nd=json.load(open('.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/replies/cdm.json'))\nraw=d.get('raw','NO RAW')\nprint('LEN',len(raw))\nprint(raw[:7000])\nEOF", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 90}, "output": "LEN 9496\n# The centered discrepancy D_y at finite x: what a census can and cannot see\n\n\n\n**No estimate for D_y is obtained and the sufficient input (16) of\n[moving-cutoff-parity.md](moving-cutoff-parity.md) remains OPEN.** This note\nrecords a finite computation with two pre-registered falsifiers, what it\nrefuted (nothing), and the one thing it did establish: that at reachable x\nthe object is dominated by the finite-size error of its classical companion\nterm, so a larger census could not see the parity object either.\n\n## 1. Prior data and the decision this run informed\n\nNo published or tabulated values of D_y, of Lambda(n-2)mu(n) in progressions,\nor of the neighbouring shifted-prime and two-point Chowla sums exist above\nx=10^4 in the owning convention; the search record is\n[history/reviews-0907/01](history/reviews-0907/01-shifted-prime-data-search.md)\nand the convention row is in [SEARCH-CONVENTIONS.md](SEARCH-CONVENTIONS.md).\n\nThe decision: whether lane A of [RESEARCH-EXECUTION.md](RESEARCH-EXECUTION.md)\nshould aim at an absolute, Bombieri--Vinogradov-type theorem for the sequence\nf(n)=Lambda(n-2)mu(n), which would supply (16) through (13), or must exploit\nsign cancellation across the moduli; and, cheaper, whether (16) is numerically\nfalse at accessible scales, which would end the centered route.\n\n## 2. The objects, exactly as computed\n\n[centered-discrepancy-measurement.js](centered-discrepancy-measurement.js)\ntakes x=2^j, J=(x/2,x], y=ceil(x^(12/25)), Q=floor(x/y), standard Lambda with\nprime powers, f(n)=Lambda(n-2)mu(n), M=sum_J f, and evaluates\nD_y(x) of (9) as the finite atomic Stieltjes sum\n\nD_y = sum_{e<=Q odd sqfree} mu(e) [ sum_{n>ey, e|n} f(n) log(e/n)\n - (1/phi(e)) sum_{n>max(x/2,ey)} f(n) log(e/n) ],\n\nwith the endpoint a_e excluded; the first bracket summed over all e is acc1,\nthe second is the density term P. It also evaluates T1, T2, E_pp, E_even of\n(4)--(5) and (10) from the same factor lists, S(x)=sum_J Lambda(n)Lambda(n-2),\nand the absolute sum W1=sum_e log(x/e) max_t |Delta_e(t)| of (13) with the\nmax over a 64-point grid in t (a lower bound for W1; at j in {16,18,20} the\nexact max gives grid/exact 0.9747, 0.9718, 0.9661).\n\nPre-registered before the first full run: F1, D_y/x < -4/25 at any j>=26\nrefutes (16) at that scale; F2, W1grid/x > 2/25 at every j>=26 and\nnon-decreasing makes the absolute form implausible; F3, the residual r(x) of\n(12) must fall with j; F4, comparison with four random-sign draws (mu(n)\nreplaced by +-1 on the same support, mu(e) kept). Controls: S=T1+T2+E_pp and\nT2=acc1+E_even exactly; a naive per-modulus implementation directly from (9)\nat j in {16,18,20}; draws' mean within 4 se of zero; shift 4 differs from\nshift 2. An adversarial code review before the bound run\n([history/reviews-0907/02](history/reviews-0907/02-centered-discrepancy-script-review.md))\nfound the E_even column double-subtracting P and a vacuous F2 on short runs;\nboth fixed, no headline number affected. The constant A2 in the thresholds\nline was corrected from a wrong value before the bound run, for the reason\nrecorded in [shifted-prime-mobius-sums.md](shifted-prime-mobius-sums.md) §2.\n\n## 3. Readings\n\nEvery figure is from the OUTPUT block. j indexes x=2^j; 3948794345 support\nintegers at j=38; 8223.5 s total on 8 workers.\n\n1. **F1 does not fire.** For j>=26 the extreme values of D_y/x are -0.004283\n (j=27), -0.004180 (j=33) and +0.002449 (j=31); at j=38 it is 0.001476. The\n threshold is -0.16. The centered route is not refuted at these scales.\n This is \"not refuted\", never \"supported\": (16) is an asymptotic statement.\n2. **F2 does not fire, and the absolute form is noise-sized.** W1grid/x falls\n monotonically from 0.322294 (j=26) to 0.077347 (j=38), crossing 2/25 at\n the last row; the grid undercount is about 3 percent, so the true W1/x at\n j=38 is at the threshold. Real W1 is within 8 percent of the control at\n every j>=26 (0.077347 against 0.080797 at j=38) and the slopes of log W1\n against log x over j>=26 are 0.827 real against 0.825 control. The\n absolute sum is the size a random-sign model gives, roughly\n x^(1/2) Q^(1/2) times logarithms, and shrinks relative to x for that\n reason alone. Consistent with the absolute form being true; no bearing on\n proving it.\n3. **Real D_y is far above the control, and the identity says why.** The\n ratio |D_y|/(control rms) is 6.014, 12.849, 8.252, 7.703, 7.374, 8.580,\n 21.816 at j=32..38, and the slope of log|D_y| over j>=26 is 0.863 against\n the control's 0.544. Read alone this would look like arithmetic\n structure. The raw comparison is dominated by a classical term on these\n measured scales. The exact identities\n S=T1+T2+E_pp and T2=acc1+E_even, with D_y=acc1-P, give\n\n D_y/x = (S/x - C2) - (T1/x - C2) - P/x - E_pp/x - E_even/x,\n\n and the columns show every term but one is negligible: S/x-C2 is at most\n 1.8e-4 in magnitude for j>=30 (1.80e-4 at j=32, 9e-6 at j=38), P/x is below 9e-5 (it is\n (P+2C2M)/x, below 5e-7, minus 2C2M/x with M/x below 7e-5), E_pp/x is\n below 3e-5, E_even/x below 2e-9. So D_y/x\n equals -(T1/x - C2) to within 2e-4 at every j>=30 (the largest deviation\n is 1.84e-4 at j=30; it is below 1e-4 at j=32, 33, 34, 36, 37, 38): at j=38,\n 0.001476 against -(-0.001473); at j=33, -0.004180 against -(0.004208);\n at j=35, 0.001132 against -(-0.001286). T1 is the classical term of (6),\n Bombieri--Vinogradov plus the Mobius mean, whose error is O_A(x/log^A x)\n for every fixed A; its measured size is comparable to x/log^2 x with\n oscillating sign on this range (1/log^2(2^38)=1.4e-3). The control has no such term: its D_y is a\n genuine random-sign sum of size about 1e-4 x at j=38. The real D_y's\n excess over the control is therefore the slow convergence of a proved\n classical asymptotic, and the parity object's own fluctuation, which is\n what a census was meant to look at, is not isolated by this raw c\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 - <<'EOF'\nimport json\nd=json.load(open('.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/replies/cdm.json'))\nraw=d['raw']\nprint(raw[6600:])\nEOF", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 60}, "output": "g^2 x with\n oscillating sign on this range (1/log^2(2^38)=1.4e-3). The control has no such term: its D_y is a\n genuine random-sign sum of size about 1e-4 x at j=38. The real D_y's\n excess over the control is therefore the slow convergence of a proved\n classical asymptotic, and the parity object's own fluctuation, which is\n what a census was meant to look at, is not isolated by this raw comparison.\n This is a finite diagnostic, not a theorem about every reachable scale.\n4. **F3.** |r(x)| falls from 0.017153 (j=20) through 0.010170 (j=24),\n 0.003895 (j=29) to 0.001471 (j=38) with oscillating sign; it is the\n T1 error by item 3. The derivation is not flagged. The rate is not\n resolved (a power of 1/log x between 2 and 3 fits the range; not fitted).\n5. **The centering removes almost nothing at finite x.** P/x is at most\n 1.5e-4 in magnitude for j>=26 and D_y/x agrees with acc1/x to 4e-6 at\n j=38, because M is at random-sign size (real M/x against control rms:\n -3.28e-6 against 6.44e-6 at j=38). The trivial bound M<=A2 x/2 that sets\n the -4/25 tolerance is loose by four orders here, as\n [shifted-prime-mobius-sums.md](shifted-prime-mobius-sums.md) records; a\n derivation still cannot use that.\n6. **Controls.** exactAlgebra=true (both identities hold to at most 1.3e-5\n absolute at j=38 on sums of size 1e11); naiveMatches=true (relative\n differences 9e-15, 7.5e-15, 6.1e-15 at j=16,18,20); ctrlMeanWithin4se=true;\n shift4Differs=true at j=20,24,28. M at j=24 is -18508.63 here and\n -18508.6301 in the other script's block.\n7. **Not measured, and not measurable this way:** any estimate for D_y; the\n rate of (12)'s error; anything about the parity object beneath the T1\n error. By item 3, no census of D_y at reachable x can separate the\n parity object from the classical convergence, so a larger run has no\n decision attached and should not be made.\n\n## 4. What this changes\n\nNothing in the proof status. For lane A: an absolute BV-type theorem for\nf(n) is consistent with the data and would suffice through (13); the\ndifficulty is entirely in proving it for this sequence, not in whether it\nholds. For finite testing: the centered representation is not a better\nwindow on the parity object than the residual it re-expresses; at every\nreachable scale it shows the classical term's error. This is a bounded\nnegative about the method of measurement, recorded so it is not repeated.\n\n## 5. Cost and custody\n\n8223.5 s wall on 8 workers (j=38 single-threaded for the last two hours),\nabout 2.3 GB per worker at j=38. Two earlier launches were killed within 20\nminutes for the review fixes and the constant. Retained artifact:\n[centered-discrepancy-measurement.json](centered-discrepancy-measurement.json).\nThe naive per-modulus implementation is the independent check of (9); the\nshifted-prime script's M column is the cross-codebase check.\n\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "write_file", "input": {"path": ".solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/job1629-preregistration.md", "instructions": "Pre-register the new statistic, its decision, falsifier, control and scale before any computation on the retained census JSON.", "content": "# Job #1629 — PRE-REGISTRATION (written BEFORE any computation on the retained census)\n\n- attempt ``, session ``, department\n `dept_c326cb5ae203e5d0d94f8db1`, general mode, job **#1629**, explore/discovery, lane `formalize`,\n NO ROUTE. Written 2026-09-17 ~09:17Z, before fetching or reading\n `research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.json`.\n- Object of study: return #165 / job #? census note\n `research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.md` (verdict `MEASURED to x=2^38`) and the OPEN\n sufficient consumer **(16)** `D_y(x) >= -(4/25) x + o(x)` of `research/moving-cutoff-parity.md`.\n\n## 1. The gap being addressed (quoted, not paraphrased)\n\nCensus note §3 item 3: \"The real D_y's excess over the control is therefore the slow convergence of a\nproved classical asymptotic, and **the parity object's own fluctuation, which is what a census was\nmeant to look at, is not isolated by this raw comparison**.\"\nCensus note §3 item 7: \"**no census of D_y at reachable x can separate the parity object from the\nclassical convergence**, so a larger run has no decision attached and should not be made.\"\nCensus note §3 item 3 also records, from the *same retained columns*, the exact identity\n\n D_y/x = (S/x - C2) - (T1/x - C2) - P/x - E_pp/x - E_even/x,\n\nin which every term but `-(T1/x - C2)` is below 2e-4 in magnitude for j >= 30.\n\n## 2. The new statistic (definitions fixed now)\n\nUsing only columns the census already retains (`D_y`, `T1`, `C2`, `S`, `P`, `E_pp`, `E_even`, and the\nmatched random-sign control's `D_y`/rms per j), define at every retained dyadic `x = 2^j`:\n\n c_D(j) := D_y(2^j) / 2^j\n c_T1(j) := T1(2^j) / 2^j - C2 (the classical companion's finite-size error)\n R(j) := c_D(j) + c_T1(j) (companion-removed, \"detrended\" parity residual)\n rho(j) := |R(j)| / ctrl_rms(j) (R in units of the census's own matched control)\n lam := -slope of log|R(j)| against log(2^j), fitted by least squares over j >= 30\n lam_ctrl := the same slope for the control's own D_y (census reports 0.544 over j >= 26)\n lam_raw := 0.863 over j >= 26 (census's reported slope of log|D_y|, which is what the raw\n statistic sees)\n\n## 3. Decision this statistic informs\n\nWhether the census's own raw \"excess\" reading (|D_y|/ctrl_rms = 6.014, 12.849, 8.252, 7.703, 7.374,\n8.580, 21.816 at j = 32..38, which \"read alone would look like arithmetic structure\") is **entirely**\nthe classical companion's convergence, or whether a signed parity-object fluctuation survives removal\nof the companion. In the second case the census's §3 item 7 / §4 \"bounded negative about the method of\nmeasurement\" is refuted at the retained scales, (16) becomes numerically addressable there, and the\nretained census already contains a usable handle.\n\n## 4. Hypothesis under test (taken from the census, not from me)\n\nH0: the companion-removed residual is noise-sized, i.e. `rho(j) = O(1)` for every retained j >= 30,\nand `lam` is within 0.15 of `lam_ctrl = 0.544`. Under H0 the census's diagnosis is confirmed and the\nraw |D_y|/ctrl_rms ratio is retired as a measure of arithmetic structure.\n\n## 5. PRE-REGISTERED FALSIFIER (F*)\n\nF*: if for some retained j >= 30, `rho(j) > 3`, **and** the fitted `lam > 0.544 + 0.15`, then H0 is\n**falsified**: the companion removal is insufficient, the retained excess is not (only) classical, and\nthis job must return an **audit** of `centered-discrepancy-measurement.md` §3 item 3/7 rather than a\ndesign. Any other outcome (including `rho > 3` at an isolated j with `lam` inside the band, or the\nresidual falling below the control) **confirms H0** and the return is the design below.\n\nSecondary, algebraic, pre-registered: F**: `|R(j) - (c_D(j) + c_T1(j))| < 1e-12` for every row, and\nthe recomputed identity residual `|c_D - ((S-C2)/x - c_T1 - P/x - E_pp/x - E_even/x)| < 1e-9` — this\nis a transcription check on the retained JSON, not a new claim.\n\n## 6. Matched control\n\nThe census's own **four seeded random-sign draws** (`mu(n) -> +-1` on the same support, `mu(e)` kept)\nsupply the matched null: the same functional, the same support, the same sieve. The design below adds\nan **independent-thinning** control (keep each slot independently with the density the census's own\ncount implies) as the confirmatory run's null, and a **shift-4** negative control (already in the\ncensus) to show the statistic is not shift-blind.\n\n## 7. Scale at which the effect would be visible\n\nCompanion removal leaves a residual of size `ctrl_rms` under H0. At j = 38 the census's control rms is\nabout `1e-4 x`, and the largest competing term of the identity is `1.84e-4 x` at j = 30. So a\nnon-classical signed fluctuation is visible from **j >= 30** onwards at any size above\n`3 * ctrl_rms / x ~ 3e-4`, i.e. about 1/500 of the `4/25 = 0.16` threshold of (16). Below j = 30 the\nidentity's neglected terms are not small enough for the residual to be interpretable.\n\n## 8. Cost if the retained columns suffice; cost if they do not\n\nRetained-column evaluation: **0 CPU-hours**, seconds, stdlib Python, no new arithmetic. If the\nretained JSON lacks the `T1` or control columns, the missing part is exactly one column re-derivation\non the census's own fixture (j <= 38), which the census priced at 8223.5 s wall on 8 workers\n(~18 CPU-h) and which **exceeds** this assignment's 4 CPU-hour budget — in that case this return is the\ndesign plus the explicit cost, and no run is made.\n"}, "output": "file: .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/job1629-preregistration.md\nmessage: Created file successfully."} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; R=run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg; W=\".solveathome/runs/$R/work\"; sha256sum \"$W/job1629/job1629-preregistration.md\" 2>/dev/null || shasum -a 256 \"$W/job1629/job1629-preregistration.md\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome req $R GET /projects/twin-primes/docs/research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.json --save \"$W/replies/cdm.json.raw\" >/dev/null 2>&1; ls -la \"$W/replies/\"; python3 -c \"\nimport json\nd=json.load(open('$W/replies/cdm.json.raw'))\nprint(type(d), list(d.keys())[:20] if isinstance(d,dict) else len(d))\nprint(str(d)[:1500])\n\"", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 90}, "output": "49d959550b3de94deb771f54143ac514a1e5512a3299675c3663c421e525c12e .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/job1629-preregistration.md\ntotal 224\ndrwxr-xr-x@ 7 ~ staff 224 Sep 17 11:08 .\ndrwxr-xr-x@ 5 ~ staff 160 Sep 17 11:08 ..\n-rw-------@ 1 ~ staff 232 Sep 17 11:07 README.json\n-rw-------@ 1 ~ staff 38583 Sep 17 11:07 README2.json\n-rw-------@ 1 ~ staff 9665 Sep 17 11:08 cdm.json\n-rw-------@ 1 ~ staff 34716 Sep 17 11:08 cdm.json.raw\n-rw-------@ 1 ~ staff 19677 Sep 17 11:08 mcp.json\n ['schema', 'scope', 'config', 'rows', 'naives', 'totalSeconds']\n{'schema': 1, 'scope': 'Finite measurement of the centered prime-Mobius discrepancy D_y and its absolute form; no asymptotic estimate.', 'config': {'JMIN': 16, 'JMAX': 38, 'SEGLG': 22, 'GRID': 64, 'SEEDS': 4, 'SEED': 219529438, 'C2': 0.6601618158468696, 'THETA_Y': 0.48, 'NAIVE_J': [16, 18, 20]}, 'rows': [{'j': 16, 'shift': 2, 'x': 65536, 'y': 206, 'Q': 318, 'nOddSqfE': 130, 'countActive': 3045, 'countSupport': 2294, 'S': 41516.84933102578, 'T1': 43398.2673997368, 'T2': -2210.876455164044, 'Epp': 329.4583864530284, 'Eeven': -3.276775537953889, 'absF': 24659.518621271636, 'M': 948.4118983552479, 'acc1': -2207.5996796260893, 'P': -1116.6386832419828, 'D': -1090.9609963841065, 'W1': 56606.9476997062, 'Wend': 37063.231158628165, 'Wmax': 461.53157769054314, 'seeds': [{'M': -135.98375856253006, 'D': 3495.367117032666, 'W1': 53541.30427111414, 'Wend': 33870.81202808356}, {'M': -44.76249834997756, 'D': -646.483812825262, 'W1': 52987.286642705345, 'Wend': 34271.85262635628}, {'M': -75.49362134959712, 'D': 1266.33965402288, 'W1': 60353.64014486858, 'Wend': 41505.87982677508}, {'M': -123.1957540812255, 'D': -236.6755013828871, 'W1': 58156.86771955089, 'Wend': 38407.56666661077}], 'seconds': 0.033}, {'j': 17, 'shift': 2, 'x': 131072, 'y': 287, 'Q': 456, 'nOddSqfE': 186, 'countActive': 5734, 'countSupport': 4283, 'S': 87982.41778641171, 'T1': 91429.07984205897, 'T2': -3775.7860542110416, 'Epp': 329.12399856379926, 'Eeven': 0, 'absF': 49025.56877452718, 'M': -1131.16943755612, 'acc1': -3775\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "write_file", "input": {"path": ".solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py", "instructions": "Write the job1629 checks script implementing the pre-registered statistic and falsifier on the retained census JSON.", "content": "#!/usr/bin/env python3\n# Job #1629 (explore/discovery, lane formalize, no route) -- NEW STATISTIC checks.\n#\n# QUESTION (house format): using ONLY the columns the retained census\n# `research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.json` already stores, does the\n# companion-removed parity residual\n# R(j) = D_y(2^j)/2^j + (T1(2^j)/2^j - C2)\n# stay noise-sized against the census's own four seeded random-sign draws (H0 of\n# work/job1629/job1629-preregistration.md, sha256 49d95955...), or does the\n# pre-registered falsifier F* fire (rho(j) > 3 at some j >= 30 AND fitted\n# slope of log|R| over j >= 30 > 0.544 + 0.15)?\n#\n# Inputs : retained census JSON (read-only), pre-registration file (hashed).\n# Output : job1629-checks.json + a plain table on stdout. No network, no new\n# arithmetic beyond the stored columns; 0 CPU-hours by design.\nimport json, math, hashlib, sys, os, statistics\n\nHERE = os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__))\nCENSUS = sys.argv[1] if len(sys.argv) > 1 else os.path.join(\n HERE, \"..\", \"replies\", \"cdm.json.raw\")\nPREREG = os.path.join(HERE, \"..\", \"job1629\", \"job1629-preregistration.md\")\nOUT = os.path.join(HERE, \"job1629-checks.json\")\nSLOPE_BAND = 0.15 # pre-registered: |lam - 0.544| must not exceed this\nRHO_T = 3.0 # pre-registered: rho threshold for F*\nCTRL_SLOPE = 0.544 # census §3 item 3, control slope over j >= 26\nRAW_SLOPE = 0.863 # census §3 item 3, log|D_y| slope over j >= 26\nJMIN_STAT = 30 # pre-registered: statistic evaluated for j >= 30\n\ndef slope(xs, ys):\n \"\"\"least-squares slope of ys against xs\"\"\"\n mx, my = sum(xs) / len(xs), sum(ys) / len(ys)\n num = sum((a - mx) * (b - my) for a, b in zip(xs, ys))\n den = sum((a - mx) ** 2 for a in xs)\n return num / den\n\ndef main():\n d = json.load(open(CENSUS))\n C2 = d[\"config\"][\"C2\"]\n rows = sorted(d[\"rows\"], key=lambda r: r[\"j\"])\n checks, table = [], []\n for r in rows:\n x = r[\"x\"]\n cD = r[\"D\"] / x # census's raw quantity\n cT1 = r[\"T1\"] / x - C2 # classical companion's finite-size error\n Rc = cD + cT1 # NEW statistic (companion-removed)\n seedD = [s[\"D\"] for s in r[\"seeds\"]]\n ctrl_rms = math.sqrt(sum(v * v for v in seedD) / len(seedD)) / x\n rho_R = abs(Rc) / ctrl_rms if ctrl_rms else float(\"nan\")\n rho_D = abs(cD) / ctrl_rms if ctrl_rms else float(\"nan\")\n # F**: transcription/algebra check of the retained identity columns\n ident = (r[\"S\"] - C2 * x) / x - cT1 - r[\"P\"] / x - r[\"Epp\"] / x - r[\"Eeven\"] / x\n table.append(dict(j=r[\"j\"], x=x, cD=cD, cT1=cT1, rho_R=rho_R, rho_D=rho_D,\n R=Rc, ctrl_rms=ctrl_rms, ident_res=abs(cD - ident)))\n checks.append(dict(name=\"F**: retained identity D/x == (S-C2)/x - cT1 - P/x - Epp/x - Eeven/x\",\n ok=all(t[\"ident_res\"] < 1e-9 for t in table),\n worst=(\"%.3e\" % max(t[\"ident_res\"] for t in table))))\n checks.append(dict(name=\"pre-registration file present and hashed\",\n ok=os.path.exists(PREREG),\n sha256=hashlib.sha256(open(PREREG, \"rb\").read()).hexdigest()[:16]))\n hi = [t for t in table if t[\"j\"] >= JMIN_STAT]\n xs = [t[\"j\"] * math.log(2.0) for t in hi]\n lam = -slope(xs, [math.log(abs(t[\"R\"])) for t in hi]) # log|R| vs log x\n lam_D = -slope(xs, [math.log(abs(t[\"cD\"])) for t in hi]) # raw statistic, same rows\n lam_ctrl = -slope(xs, [math.log(t[\"ctrl_rms\"]) for t in hi])\n worst_rho = max(hi, key=lambda t: t[\"rho_R\"])\n fires_rho = worst_rho[\"rho_R\"] > RHO_T\n fires_slope = lam > CTRL_SLOPE + SLOPE_BAND\n checks.append(dict(name=\"F* part 1: max rho_R over j>=30 > 3.0\", ok=not fires_rho,\n value=round(worst_rho[\"rho_R\"], 4), at_j=worst_rho[\"j\"]))\n checks.append(dict(name=\"F* part 2: fitted lam <= 0.544 + 0.15\", ok=not fires_slope,\n value=round(lam, 4), bound=CTRL_SLOPE + SLOPE_BAND))\n checks.append(dict(name=\"H0 confirmed (census §3 item 3/7 stands at retained scales)\",\n ok=not (fires_rho and fires_slope)))\n checks.append(dict(name=\"raw statistic is much larger than the detrended one (the §3 item 3\"\n \" '2e-4 the other way' effect is reproduced by the stored columns)\",\n ok=lam_D > lam_ctrl, lam_raw=round(lam_D, 4), lam_detrended=round(lam, 4)))\n\n print(\"j x D/x T1/x-C2 R=D/x+(T1/x-C2) rho_R |D|/ctrl\")\n for t in table:\n if t[\"j\"] >= 26:\n print(\"%-6d %-13.6g %-13.6e %-14.6e %-16.6e %-8.4f %-8.4f\"\n % (t[\"j\"], t[\"x\"], t[\"cD\"], t[\"cT1\"], t[\"R\"], t[\"rho_R\"], t[\"rho_D\"]))\n print()\n print(\"fitted over j>=%d: lam(R)=%.4f lam(|D|)=%.4f lam(ctrl)=%.4f (band %.2f..%.2f)\"\n % (JMIN_STAT, lam, lam_D, lam_ctrl, CTRL_SLOPE - SLOPE_BAND, CTRL_SLOPE + SLOPE_BAND))\n print(\"F* fires:\", bool(fires_rho and fires_slope), \" rho trigger:\", fires_rho, \" slope trigger:\", fires_slope)\n for c in checks:\n print((\"PASS \" if c[\"ok\"] else \"FAIL \"), c[\"name\"], {k: v for k, v in c.items() if k not in (\"name\", \"ok\")})\n json.dump(dict(checks=checks, table=table, JMIN_STAT=JMIN_STAT,\n lam=lam, lam_D=lam_D, lam_ctrl=lam_ctrl, F_star=bool(fires_rho and fires_slope),\n census_note=\"research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.md\",\n prereg_sha256=hashlib.sha256(open(PREREG, \"rb\").read()).hexdigest()),\n open(OUT, \"w\"), indent=1)\n print(\"wrote\", OUT)\n print(\"PASSED %d/%d\" % (sum(1 for c in checks if c[\"ok\"]), len(checks)))\n\nif __name__ == \"__main__\":\n main()\n"}, "output": "file: .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py\nmessage: Created file successfully."} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome exec --seconds 120 --cpu-seconds 60 -- python3 .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py 2>&1 | tail -40", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 180}, "output": "Traceback (most recent call last):\n File \"~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/tools/sah.py\", line 1261, in \n main()\n ~~~~^^\n File \"~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/tools/sah.py\", line 1258, in main\n a.f(a)\n ~~~^^^\n File \"~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/tools/sah.py\", line 1117, in cmd_exec\n p = subprocess.Popen(a.cmd, stdin=subprocess.DEVNULL, stdout=subprocess.PIPE, stderr=subprocess.PIPE,\n start_new_session=(os.name != \"nt\"), text=True, errors=\"replace\", preexec_fn=preexec)\n File \"/opt/homebrew/Cellar/python@3.14/3.14.6/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.14/lib/python3.14/subprocess.py\", line 1039, in __init__\n self._execute_child(args, executable, preexec_fn, close_fds,\n ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^\n pass_fds, cwd, env,\n ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^\n ...<5 lines>...\n gid, gids, uid, umask,\n ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^\n start_new_session, process_group)\n ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^\n File \"/opt/homebrew/Cellar/python@3.14/3.14.6/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.14/lib/python3.14/subprocess.py\", line 1990, in _execute_child\n raise child_exception_type(errno_num, err_msg, err_filename)\nPermissionError: [Errno 13] Permission denied: '.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py'\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome exec --help 2>&1 | head -20", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 30}, "output": "usage: sah.py exec [-h] [--seconds SECONDS] [--cpu-seconds CPU_SECONDS]\n [--mem-mb MEM_MB] [--max-output MAX_OUTPUT]\n run [cmd ...]\n\npositional arguments:\n run\n cmd\n\noptions:\n -h, --help show this help message and exit\n --seconds SECONDS\n --cpu-seconds CPU_SECONDS\n --mem-mb MEM_MB\n --max-output MAX_OUTPUT\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome exec --seconds 120 --cpu-seconds 60 run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg python3 .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py 2>&1 | tail -40", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 180}, "output": "{\n \"run\": \"run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg\",\n \"cmd\": [\n \"python3\",\n \".solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py\"\n ],\n \"seconds_limit\": 120,\n \"wall_s\": 0.06,\n \"limits\": {\n \"wall_seconds\": 120,\n \"cpu_seconds\": 60,\n \"mem_mb\": null,\n \"mechanism\": \"start_new_session + killpg(SIGKILL) on the wall clock; setrlimit(RLIMIT_CPU[,RLIMIT_AS]) in the child\"\n },\n \"exit_code\": 1,\n \"timed_out\": false,\n \"process_group_gone\": true,\n \"stdout\": \"\",\n \"stderr\": \"Traceback (most recent call last):\\n File \\\"~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py\\\", line 98, in \\n main()\\n ~~~~^^\\n File \\\"~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py\\\", line 37, in main\\n d = json.load(open(CENSUS))\\n ~~~~^^^^^^^^\\nFileNotFoundError: [Errno 2] No such file or directory: '~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/../replies/cdm.json.raw'\\n\",\n \"observed_utc\": \"2026-09-17T09:09:24Z\"\n}\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "str_replace", "input": {"path": ".solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py", "replacements": [{"oldString": " HERE, \"..\", \"replies\", \"cdm.json.raw\")", "newString": " HERE, \"..\", \"..\", \"replies\", \"cdm.json.raw\")", "allowMultiple": false}]}, "output": "file: .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py\nmessage: String replace applied successfully."} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; date -u", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 30}, "output": "Thu Sep 17 09:09:28 UTC 2026\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; R=run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg; D=\".solveathome/runs/$R/work/job1629\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome exec --seconds 120 --cpu-seconds 60 $R bash -c \"python3 $D/src/job1629-checks.py > $D/src/job1629-checks.log 2>&1; echo exit=\\$?\" 2>&1 | tail -6; echo \"=== log\"; cat \"$D/src/job1629-checks.log\"", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 180}, "output": "usage: sah.py [-h] [--root ROOT]\n {init,run,identity,register,req,retry,session-set,attempt,outstanding,complete,scrub-check,release,exec,readiness,note,claim,summary,alloc,transcript} ...\nsah.py: error: unrecognized arguments: -c python3 .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py > .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.log 2>&1; echo exit=$?\n=== log\ncat: .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.log: No such file or directory\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; R=run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg; D=\".solveathome/runs/$R/work/job1629\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome exec --seconds 120 --cpu-seconds 60 $R python3 \"$D/src/job1629-checks.py\" 2>&1 | python3 -c \"import sys,json;d=json.load(sys.stdin);print(d['stdout']);print('EXIT',d['exit_code'],'wall',d['wall_s'])\"", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 180}, "output": "\nEXIT 1 wall 0.05\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; R=run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg; D=\".solveathome/runs/$R/work/job1629\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome exec --seconds 120 --cpu-seconds 60 $R python3 \"$D/src/job1629-checks.py\" 2>&1 | python3 -c \"import sys,json;d=json.load(sys.stdin);print('ERR',d['stderr'][-1500:])\"", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 180}, "output": "ERR Traceback (most recent call last):\n File \"~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py\", line 98, in \n main()\n ~~~~^^\n File \"~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py\", line 59, in main\n sha256=hashlib.sha256(open(PREREG, \"rb\").read()).hexdigest()[:16]))\n ~~~~^^^^^^^^^^^^^^\nFileNotFoundError: [Errno 2] No such file or directory: '~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/../job1629/job1629-preregistration.md'\n\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "str_replace", "input": {"path": ".solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py", "replacements": [{"oldString": "PREREG = os.path.join(HERE, \"..\", \"job1629\", \"job1629-preregistration.md\")", "newString": "PREREG = os.path.join(HERE, \"..\", \"job1629-preregistration.md\")", "allowMultiple": false}]}, "output": "file: .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py\nmessage: String replace applied successfully."} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; R=run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg; D=\".solveathome/runs/$R/work/job1629\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome exec --seconds 120 --cpu-seconds 60 $R python3 \"$D/src/job1629-checks.py\" 2>&1 | python3 -c \"\nimport sys,json;d=json.load(sys.stdin);print(d['stdout']);e=d['stderr'][-800:]\nprint('EXIT',d['exit_code'],'wall',d['wall_s']);print('ERR',e) if e else None\"", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 180}, "output": "j x D/x T1/x-C2 R=D/x+(T1/x-C2) rho_R |D|/ctrl\n26 6.71089e+07 -3.430309e-03 2.409250e-03 -1.021059e-03 0.3160 1.0615 \n27 1.34218e+08 -4.283329e-03 4.598059e-03 3.147306e-04 0.1191 1.6207 \n28 2.68435e+08 -1.090265e-03 -2.633280e-04 -1.353593e-03 2.5619 2.0635 \n28 2.68435e+08 2.616705e-04 -3.038840e-04 -4.221346e-05 0.0235 0.1457 \n29 5.36871e+08 -3.991625e-03 3.848163e-03 -1.434625e-04 0.1737 4.8329 \n30 1.07374e+09 -2.654658e-04 4.498668e-04 1.844010e-04 0.3043 0.4381 \n31 2.14748e+09 2.449027e-03 -2.591211e-03 -1.421845e-04 0.1815 3.1260 \n32 4.29497e+09 -1.257631e-03 1.348634e-03 9.100332e-05 0.4352 6.0142 \n33 8.58993e+09 -4.180146e-03 4.208142e-03 2.799658e-05 0.0861 12.8488 \n34 1.71799e+10 -8.990122e-04 9.828073e-04 8.379518e-05 0.7692 8.2520 \n35 3.43597e+10 1.131866e-03 -1.286361e-03 -1.544944e-04 1.0514 7.7031 \n36 6.87195e+10 -1.193293e-03 1.203647e-03 1.035446e-05 0.0640 7.3739 \n37 1.37439e+11 -4.060346e-04 4.550764e-04 4.904172e-05 1.0363 8.5803 \n38 2.74878e+11 1.475654e-03 -1.472508e-03 3.145397e-06 0.0465 21.8162 \n\nfitted over j>=30: lam(R)=0.5318 lam(|D|)=-0.0014 lam(ctrl)=0.4448 (band 0.39..0.69)\nF* fires: False rho trigger: False slope trigger: False\nPASS F**: retained identity D/x == (S-C2)/x - cT1 - P/x - Epp/x - Eeven/x {'worst': '2.153e-14'}\nPASS pre-registration file present and hashed {'sha256': '49d959550b3de94d'}\nPASS F* part 1: max rho_R over j>=30 > 3.0 {'value': 1.0514, 'at_j': 35}\nPASS F* part 2: fitted lam <= 0.544 + 0.15 {'value': 0.5318, 'bound': 0.6940000000000001}\nPASS H0 confirmed (census §3 item 3/7 stands at retained scales) {}\nFAIL raw statistic is much larger than the detrended one (the §3 item 3 '2e-4 the other way' effect is reproduced by the stored columns) {'lam_raw': -0.0014, 'lam_detrended': 0.5318}\nwrote ~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.json\nPASSED 5/6\n\nEXIT 0 wall 0.04\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "str_replace", "input": {"path": ".solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py", "replacements": [{"oldString": " rows = sorted(d[\"rows\"], key=lambda r: r[\"j\"])\n checks, table = [], []\n for r in rows:", "newString": " rows = sorted(d[\"rows\"], key=lambda r: r[\"j\"])\n checks, table, other = [], [], []\n for r in rows:\n if r.get(\"shift\", 2) != 2:\n # The companion removal is defined for the assigned shift 2 only; the stored T1 column\n # of a shifted row is not that row's companion. Keep it as a diagnostic, not a statistic.\n sd = [s[\"D\"] for s in r[\"seeds\"]]\n cr = math.sqrt(sum(v * v for v in sd) / len(sd)) / r[\"x\"]\n other.append(dict(j=r[\"j\"], shift=r.get(\"shift\"), raw_ratio=abs(r[\"D\"] / r[\"x\"]) / cr))\n continue", "allowMultiple": false}, {"oldString": " checks.append(dict(name=\"raw statistic is much larger than the detrended one (the §3 item 3\"\n \" '2e-4 the other way' effect is reproduced by the stored columns)\",\n ok=lam_D > lam_ctrl, lam_raw=round(lam_D, 4), lam_detrended=round(lam, 4)))", "newString": " # Pre-registered direction: the RAW ratio is the census's own excess reading; the DETRENDED ratio\n # must be O(1). (First run asserted lam_D > lam_ctrl instead; that expectation was wrong over\n # j >= 30 and the failing run is kept as job1629-checks.fail1.log.)\n checks.append(dict(name=\"raw |D|/ctrl_rms reproduces the census's excess reading (max > 5 over j>=30)\",\n ok=max(t[\"rho_D\"] for t in hi) > 5,\n value=round(max(t[\"rho_D\"] for t in hi), 3)))\n checks.append(dict(name=\"companion-removed rho_R is O(1) (max < 2 over j>=30)\",\n ok=max(t[\"rho_R\"] for t in hi) < 2,\n value=round(max(t[\"rho_R\"] for t in hi), 3)))\n checks.append(dict(name=\"detrended slope matches the control slope within 0.25 (random-sign model)\",\n ok=abs(lam - lam_ctrl) < 0.25,\n lam_detrended=round(lam, 4), lam_ctrl=round(lam_ctrl, 4)))", "allowMultiple": false}]}, "output": "file: .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py\nmessage: String replace applied successfully."} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "str_replace", "input": {"path": ".solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py", "replacements": [{"oldString": " print(\"F* fires:\", bool(fires_rho and fires_slope), \" rho trigger:\", fires_rho, \" slope trigger:\", fires_slope)", "newString": " print(\"F* fires:\", bool(fires_rho and fires_slope), \" rho trigger:\", fires_rho, \" slope trigger:\", fires_slope)\n for o in other:\n print(\"non-shift-2 diagnostic row: j=%s shift=%s raw|D|/ctrl=%.4f (companion removal not valid here)\"\n % (o[\"j\"], o[\"shift\"], o[\"raw_ratio\"]))", "allowMultiple": false}, {"oldString": " json.dump(dict(checks=checks, table=table, JMIN_STAT=JMIN_STAT,", "newString": " json.dump(dict(checks=checks, table=table, other_shift_rows=other, JMIN_STAT=JMIN_STAT,", "allowMultiple": false}]}, "output": "file: .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py\nmessage: String replace applied successfully."} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; R=run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg; D=\".solveathome/runs/$R/work/job1629\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome exec --seconds 120 --cpu-seconds 60 $R python3 \"$D/src/job1629-checks.py\" 2>&1 | python3 -c \"\nimport sys,json;d=json.load(sys.stdin);print(d['stdout']);e=d['stderr'][-600:]\nprint('EXIT',d['exit_code'],'wall',d['wall_s']);print('ERR',e) if e else None\"", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 180}, "output": "j x D/x T1/x-C2 R=D/x+(T1/x-C2) rho_R |D|/ctrl\n26 6.71089e+07 -3.430309e-03 2.409250e-03 -1.021059e-03 0.3160 1.0615 \n27 1.34218e+08 -4.283329e-03 4.598059e-03 3.147306e-04 0.1191 1.6207 \n28 2.68435e+08 -1.090265e-03 -2.633280e-04 -1.353593e-03 2.5619 2.0635 \n29 5.36871e+08 -3.991625e-03 3.848163e-03 -1.434625e-04 0.1737 4.8329 \n30 1.07374e+09 -2.654658e-04 4.498668e-04 1.844010e-04 0.3043 0.4381 \n31 2.14748e+09 2.449027e-03 -2.591211e-03 -1.421845e-04 0.1815 3.1260 \n32 4.29497e+09 -1.257631e-03 1.348634e-03 9.100332e-05 0.4352 6.0142 \n33 8.58993e+09 -4.180146e-03 4.208142e-03 2.799658e-05 0.0861 12.8488 \n34 1.71799e+10 -8.990122e-04 9.828073e-04 8.379518e-05 0.7692 8.2520 \n35 3.43597e+10 1.131866e-03 -1.286361e-03 -1.544944e-04 1.0514 7.7031 \n36 6.87195e+10 -1.193293e-03 1.203647e-03 1.035446e-05 0.0640 7.3739 \n37 1.37439e+11 -4.060346e-04 4.550764e-04 4.904172e-05 1.0363 8.5803 \n38 2.74878e+11 1.475654e-03 -1.472508e-03 3.145397e-06 0.0465 21.8162 \n\nfitted over j>=30: lam(R)=0.5318 lam(|D|)=-0.0014 lam(ctrl)=0.4448 (band 0.39..0.69)\nF* fires: False rho trigger: False slope trigger: False\nnon-shift-2 diagnostic row: j=20 shift=4 raw|D|/ctrl=1.0630 (companion removal not valid here)\nnon-shift-2 diagnostic row: j=24 shift=4 raw|D|/ctrl=2.1826 (companion removal not valid here)\nnon-shift-2 diagnostic row: j=28 shift=4 raw|D|/ctrl=0.1457 (companion removal not valid here)\nPASS F**: retained identity D/x == (S-C2)/x - cT1 - P/x - Epp/x - Eeven/x {'worst': '2.153e-14'}\nPASS pre-registration file present and hashed {'sha256': '49d959550b3de94d'}\nPASS F* part 1: max rho_R over j>=30 > 3.0 {'value': 1.0514, 'at_j': 35}\nPASS F* part 2: fitted lam <= 0.544 + 0.15 {'value': 0.5318, 'bound': 0.6940000000000001}\nPASS H0 confirmed (census §3 item 3/7 stands at retained scales) {}\nPASS raw |D|/ctrl_rms reproduces the census's excess reading (max > 5 over j>=30) {'value': 21.816}\nPASS companion-removed rho_R is O(1) (max < 2 over j>=30) {'value': 1.051}\nPASS detrended slope matches the control slope within 0.25 (random-sign model) {'lam_detrended': 0.5318, 'lam_ctrl': 0.4448}\nwrote ~/Files/Git/freebuf-solveathome/.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.json\nPASSED 8/8\n\nEXIT 0 wall 0.04\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 - <<'EOF'\nimport json\nd=json.load(open('.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.json'))\nfor t in d['table']:\n if t['j']>=30:\n print(t['j'], 'ctrl_rms=%.3e'%t['ctrl_rms'], 'floor3x=%.3e'%(3*t['ctrl_rms']),\n 'floor/(4/25)=%.4g'%(3*t['ctrl_rms']/(4/25)), 'rho_R=%.4f'%t['rho_R'], 'rho_D=%.3f'%t['rho_D'])\nw=[t for t in d['table'] if t['j']==38][0]\nprint('ratio raw/detrended at j=38', w['rho_D']/w['rho_R'])\nEOF", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 60}, "output": "30 ctrl_rms=6.060e-04 floor3x=1.818e-03 floor/(4/25)=0.01136 rho_R=0.3043 rho_D=0.438\n31 ctrl_rms=7.834e-04 floor3x=2.350e-03 floor/(4/25)=0.01469 rho_R=0.1815 rho_D=3.126\n32 ctrl_rms=2.091e-04 floor3x=6.273e-04 floor/(4/25)=0.003921 rho_R=0.4352 rho_D=6.014\n33 ctrl_rms=3.253e-04 floor3x=9.760e-04 floor/(4/25)=0.0061 rho_R=0.0861 rho_D=12.849\n34 ctrl_rms=1.089e-04 floor3x=3.268e-04 floor/(4/25)=0.002043 rho_R=0.7692 rho_D=8.252\n35 ctrl_rms=1.469e-04 floor3x=4.408e-04 floor/(4/25)=0.002755 rho_R=1.0514 rho_D=7.703\n36 ctrl_rms=1.618e-04 floor3x=4.855e-04 floor/(4/25)=0.003034 rho_R=0.0640 rho_D=7.374\n37 ctrl_rms=4.732e-05 floor3x=1.420e-04 floor/(4/25)=0.0008873 rho_R=1.0363 rho_D=8.580\n38 ctrl_rms=6.764e-05 floor3x=2.029e-04 floor/(4/25)=0.001268 rho_R=0.0465 rho_D=21.816\nratio raw/detrended at j=38 469.1470164356754\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "write_file", "input": {"path": ".solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.fail1.log", "instructions": "Keep my own failing first run of the checks script as evidence.", "content": "# FAILING FIRST RUN of job1629-checks.py (kept deliberately, house style).\n# Cause: my check 6 asserted lam(|D|) > lam(ctrl) over j >= 30, i.e. I presumed the census's quoted\n# raw slope 0.863 (which the census fits over j >= 26) would also hold over j >= 30. It does not:\n# over j >= 30 the raw |D|/x slope is -0.0014, because D/x tracks the classical companion, whose\n# finite-size error oscillates in sign. The expectation was mine, not the census's, and it was wrong.\n# The check was replaced by the pre-registered directional pair (raw ratio >> 1, detrended ratio O(1))\n# plus the control-slope match; the second run passed 8/8. Nothing downstream depended on check 6.\n\nj x D/x T1/x-C2 R=D/x+(T1/x-C2) rho_R |D|/ctrl\n26 6.71089e+07 -3.430309e-03 2.409250e-03 -1.021059e-03 0.3160 1.0615\n27 1.34218e+08 -4.283329e-03 4.598059e-03 3.147306e-04 0.1191 1.6207\n28 2.68435e+08 -1.090265e-03 -2.633280e-04 -1.353593e-03 2.5619 2.0635\n28 2.68435e+08 2.616705e-04 -3.038840e-04 -4.221346e-05 0.0235 0.1457\n29 5.36871e+08 -3.991625e-03 3.848163e-03 -1.434625e-04 0.1737 4.8329\n30 1.07374e+09 -2.654658e-04 4.498668e-04 1.844010e-04 0.3043 0.4381\n31 2.14748e+09 2.449027e-03 -2.591211e-03 -1.421845e-04 0.1815 3.1260\n32 4.29497e+09 -1.257631e-03 1.348634e-03 9.100332e-05 0.4352 6.0142\n33 8.58993e+09 -4.180146e-03 4.208142e-03 2.799658e-05 0.0861 12.8488\n34 1.71799e+10 -8.990122e-04 9.828073e-04 8.379518e-05 0.7692 8.2520\n35 3.43597e+10 1.131866e-03 -1.286361e-03 -1.544944e-04 1.0514 7.7031\n36 6.87195e+10 -1.193293e-03 1.203647e-03 1.035446e-05 0.0640 7.3739\n37 1.37439e+11 -4.060346e-04 4.550764e-04 4.904172e-05 1.0363 8.5803\n38 2.74878e+11 1.475654e-03 -1.472508e-03 3.145397e-06 0.0465 21.8162\n\nfitted over j>=30: lam(R)=0.5318 lam(|D|)=-0.0014 lam(ctrl)=0.4448 (band 0.39..0.69)\nF* fires: False rho trigger: False slope trigger: False\nPASS F**: retained identity D/x == (S-C2)/x - cT1 - P/x - Epp/x - Eeven/x {'worst': '2.153e-14'}\nPASS pre-registration file present and hashed {'sha256': '49d959550b3de94d'}\nPASS F* part 1: max rho_R over j>=30 > 3.0 {'value': 1.0514, 'at_j': 35}\nPASS F* part 2: fitted lam <= 0.544 + 0.15 {'value': 0.5318, 'bound': 0.6940000000000001}\nPASS H0 confirmed (census §3 item 3/7 stands at retained scales) {}\nFAIL raw statistic is much larger than the detrended one ... {'lam_raw': -0.0014, 'lam_detrended': 0.5318}\nPASSED 5/6\n"}, "output": "file: .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.fail1.log\nmessage: Created file successfully."} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "write_file", "input": {"path": ".solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/job1629-report.md", "instructions": "Write the job1629 return report with the new statistic, its evaluation, rungs and design.", "content": "# Job #1629 — Leads: new statistic. A companion-removed census statistic, and its sensitivity floor\n\n- attempt ``, session ``, department\n `dept_c326cb5ae203e5d0d94f8db1`, general mode, lane `formalize`, **explore/discovery**, no route.\n- Builds on: **return #165 / `research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.md`** (MSR to `x = 2^38`,\n verdict *\"MEASURED to x=2^38. Neither pre-registered falsifier fires\"*), the OPEN sufficient\n consumer **(16)** `D_y(x) >= -(4/25)x + o(x)` of `research/moving-cutoff-parity.md`, the retained\n artifact `research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.json` (schema 1, `JMIN 16`, `JMAX 38`,\n `SEEDS 4`), and the served router `research/README.md`. Nothing of #165's is re-derived.\n\n## 1. What I did\n\nThe census's own sections state the gap in its own words: *\"the parity object's own fluctuation,\nwhich is what a census was meant to look at, is not isolated by this raw comparison\"* (§3 item 3),\nand *\"no census of D_y at reachable x can separate the parity object from the classical convergence,\nso a larger run has no decision attached and should not be made\"* (§3 item 7, §4). Its §3 item 3\nalso prints the exact identity\n\n D_y/x = (S/x - C2) - (T1/x - C2) - P/x - E_pp/x - E_even/x,\n\nand observes that every term but `-(T1/x - C2)` is below `2e-4` for `j >= 30`.\n\nI pre-registered (**before** fetching the retained JSON; sha256\n`49d959550b3de94deb771f54143ac514a1e5512a3299675c3663c421e525c12e`,\n`work/job1629/job1629-preregistration.md`) a **new finite statistic** built from columns the census\nalready stores:\n\n c_D(j) = D_y(2^j)/2^j (the census's raw quantity)\n c_T1(j) = T1(2^j)/2^j - C2 (the classical companion's finite-size error)\n R(j) = c_D(j) + c_T1(j) (companion-removed parity residual -- NEW)\n rho(j) = |R(j)| / ctrl_rms(j) (R in units of the census's own seeded control)\n\nwith `ctrl_rms(j)` the rms of the census's four seeded random-sign draws (`mu(n) -> +-1` on the same\nsupport, `mu(e)` kept), and `lam` the least-squares slope of `log|R|` against `log x` over `j >= 30`\n(the pre-registered scale: below `j = 30` the identity's neglected terms are not small enough for the\nresidual to be interpretable, its largest competitor being `1.84e-4 x` at `j = 30`).\n\n## 2. The numbers (all from retained columns; `0 CPU-h`, wall 0.04 s under the tool's bounded `exec`)\n\n| j | x | D_y/x | T1/x−C2 | R | rho(J) | \\|D\\|/ctrl |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 30 | 1.074e9 | −2.655e−04 | +4.499e−04 | +1.844e−04 | 0.304 | 0.438 |\n| 31 | 2.147e9 | +2.449e−03 | −2.591e−03 | −1.422e−04 | 0.182 | 3.126 |\n| 32 | 4.295e9 | −1.258e−03 | +1.349e−03 | +9.100e−05 | 0.435 | 6.014 |\n| 33 | 8.590e9 | −4.180e−03 | +4.208e−03 | +2.800e−05 | 0.086 | 12.849 |\n| 34 | 1.718e10 | −8.990e−04 | +9.828e−04 | +8.380e−05 | 0.769 | 8.252 |\n| 35 | 3.436e10 | +1.132e−03 | −1.286e−03 | −1.545e−04 | **1.051** | 7.703 |\n| 36 | 6.872e10 | −1.193e−03 | +1.204e−03 | +1.035e−05 | 0.064 | 7.374 |\n| 37 | 1.374e11 | −4.060e−04 | +4.551e−04 | +4.904e−05 | 1.036 | 8.580 |\n| 38 | 2.749e11 | +1.476e−03 | −1.473e−03 | +3.145e−06 | **0.047** | **21.816** |\n\n- **Pre-registered falsifier F* did not fire.** `rho > 3` never occurs over `j >= 30` (max **1.0514**\n at `j = 35`) and `lam = 0.5318 <= 0.544 + 0.15`. **H0 confirmed**: the companion-removed residual\n is noise-sized and its growth matches the random-sign model (`lam_ctrl = 0.4448` on the same rows).\n- **The raw statistic's excess is entirely the companion.** `|D|/ctrl_rms` reaches **21.816** at\n `j = 38` while `rho` there is **0.0465** — a factor **469** reduction, obtained with no new\n arithmetic. This reproduces, from the stored columns alone, the census's §3 item 3 diagnosis.\n- **A refinement of the census's own numbers.** The census quotes the raw slope `0.863` over\n `j >= 26`; over `j >= 30` the fitted raw slope is **−0.0014** (the companion's error oscillates in\n sign), while the *detrended* slope is `0.5318`. My first check asserted the raw slope would stay\n above the control's over `j >= 30`; that expectation was mine and it was wrong — the failing run is\n kept as `work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.fail1.log` and the corrected run passes **8/8**\n (`job1629-checks.log`, `job1629-checks.json`).\n\n## 3. The decision this statistic actually attaches (the point of the exercise)\n\n`rho(j) = O(1)` is not a null result to be discarded: divided through, it is an **upper bound**.\nSince `|R(j)| = rho(j) * ctrl_rms(j)`, the retained census **excludes** any non-classical signed\ncomponent of `D_y` larger than `3 * ctrl_rms(j)`, i.e. at the retained scales\n\n| j | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| detection floor `3*ctrl_rms/x` | 3.27e−04 | 4.41e−04 | 4.86e−04 | 1.42e−04 | **2.03e−04** |\n| floor ÷ (4/25) | 0.0020 | 0.0028 | 0.0030 | 0.00089 | **0.0013** |\n\nSo the census **can** decide something the census note said no census could: at `x = 2^38` it rules\nout a non-classical signed fluctuation above `2.0e-4 x`, which is **1/788 of the `4/25 = 0.16`\nthreshold of (16)**. What it still cannot decide is (16) itself, whose tolerance is ~790× coarser\nthan the floor; and the floor's improvement per dyadic step is only ~×1.5 (×8.9 from `j = 30` to\n`j = 38`), so a census reaching the tolerance needs roughly `j ≈ 48`, beyond the census's own\n`8223.5 s / 18 CPU-h` pricing at `j = 38`. That is the quantitative statement behind the census's\nqualitative \"no decision attached\" — and it is a **refinement, not a refutation**: the census's\nitem 7 is right about (16), wrong only in saying the census carries no decision at all, which its own\nstored columns contradict.\n\n## 4. The design for the confirmatory run (the missing part, not run here)\n\nStatistic: the `R(j)`/`rho(j)` pair above, at every retained `j >= 30`, with\n(i) the census's four seeded random-sign draws as the matched null, and\n(ii) a **second matched control the census did not use: independent thinning** — keep each support\ninteger independently with probability `p = ctrl_count/countActive` from the census's own `M`/count\ncolumns, so the null has the same support size but no Mobius sign structure;\n(iii) the census's shift-4 rows as a **negative control** to show the statistic is not shift-blind\n(the stored `T1` column is shift-2's, so for a shifted row only the raw ratio is defined; that is why\nthe shift-4 rows are reported as diagnostics, `raw|D|/ctrl = 1.063, 2.183, 0.146` at `j = 20, 24, 28`).\nPre-registered falsifier for that run (F*', written here before it is run): it fires if some `j >= 30`\ngives `rho(j) > 3` under the *thinned* control while the seeded control gives `rho(j) < 1` — that\nwould mean the seeded draws are an under-dispersed null and the detrended residual is real.\nScale of visibility: any deviation above `3 * ctrl_rms/x ~ 2e-4` at `j = 38`; the effect is visible\nfrom `j >= 30`.\nCost: **0 CPU-h as run** (retained columns only). The thinned-control variant is a re-run of\n`centered-discrepancy-measurement.js` with one extra column and no extra support enumeration, so the\ncensus's own price bounds it when the full `j <= 38` range is wanted; a `j <= 34` restriction (where\nthe floor is `3.3e-4` and every other identity term is `< 1e-4`) fits inside this assignment's\n4 CPU-hour budget. **No new compute was spent here** (0 CPU-h, 120 s wall cap unused).\n\n## 5. Rungs\n\n- **verified** — the algebra and the transcription: the retained identity reproduces to `2.2e-14`,\n `R`, `rho`, the floors and the fitted slopes are exact functions of the stored columns; 8/8 checks.\n- **measured** — the `rho(j)` values and floors, being functions of #165's retained measurement at\n `x = 2^38`; the measurement is #165's, the statistic is new.\n- **design** — the thinned-control confirmatory run and its F*'.\n- **sourced** — the identity and the \"every term but one is negligible\" reading are #165's printed\n statements, quoted above; no served file is claimed wrong. `web_search` was down for every query\n including the control query `twin primes` this turn (channel failure, never absence); the retained\n artifact and the served notes were read directly (they are the sources that matter here).\n- **no novelty claim**, no twin-prime claim, no change to any proof status. This is a measurement,\n a statistic and a design.\n\n## 6. Files\n\n- `work/job1629/job1629-report.md` (this report)\n- `work/job1629/job1629-research.json` — the `research` object (new route proposal, `outcome: proposed`)\n- `work/job1629/job1629-preregistration.md` — the pre-registration, sha256 `49d95955…`\n- `work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py` + `job1629-checks.log` + `job1629-checks.json` + the kept\n failing first run `job1629-checks.fail1.log`\n- retained served artifact read: `work/replies/cdm.json.raw` (`research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.json`),\n `work/replies/cdm.json` (the note), `work/replies/mcp.json` (moving-cutoff-parity), `work/replies/README2.json`\n- shared note: `.solveathome/research/notes/N-1629-01-companion-removed-census-statistic.md`\n"}, "output": "file: .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/job1629-report.md\nmessage: Created file successfully."} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; R=run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg; W=\".solveathome/runs/$R/work\"; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome req $R GET /projects/twin-primes/research-protocol --save \"$W/replies/research-protocol.json\" >/dev/null 2>&1; python3 - <<'EOF'\nimport json,re\nd=json.load(open('.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/replies/research-protocol.json'))\nraw=d.get('raw') or json.dumps(d)\nprint(len(raw))\n# print required-field-ish sections\nfor m in re.finditer(r'(?m)^.*(next_step|required|proposal\\.|evidence_md|contribution_md|uncertainty_md|capped|at most).*$', raw):\n print(m.group(0)[:200])\nEOF", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 90}, "output": "28299\nIf published work already covers an assigned route's proposed contribution, report `outcome: \"known\"` with `prior_art_md` and `evidence_md`, without `next_step` or `obstacle`. This records the match, \nAn optional `research` object on a return proposes a route or reports progress on its assigned route. Generated route assignments require it. Proposals get a short triage assignment, available to any \nNegative reports distinguish unresolved work, failed attempts, refuted statements and scoped obstructions. Every obstacle states its exact scope, evidence and a condition for reconsideration. A failed\n \"_lengths\": \"title 160 characters; evidence_md, prior_art_md, contribution_md, uncertainty_md, method 4000; question, budget notes 1000; success, failure, obstacle fields 2000. A field over its ca\n \"contribution_md\": \"How success would contribute to the project goal; label conjectural links.\",\n \"uncertainty_md\": \"The weakest unproved assumption or unresolved step.\"\n \"evidence_md\": \"Why this experiment is worth a bounded investment.\",\n \"next_step\": {\n \"required_tools\": [],\n \"required_sources\": []\nOn a route assignment, replace `proposal` with `route_id`, keep `evidence_md`, and report `outcome`: `promising`, `progress`, `blocked`, `inconclusive`, `known`, or `result`. Promising/progress requir\n \"availability\": {\"status\": \"complete\", \"details\": \"All required files are in the manifest.\", \"required_sources\": [], \"network\": false},\n{\"blocker\": {\"kind\": \"capability\", \"required_tools\": [\"python3\"], \"required_sources\": []}}\nPut this optional object inside `check_receipt`. Use `capability` only when another worker with the named tools or source access can run the unchanged package; at least one tool or source identifier i\nA reviewer using an execution receipt supplies `verification_receipt_id` and `verification_sufficiency_md`, describing why the method supports the selected rung and which assumptions remain. The latte\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; python3 - <<'EOF'\nimport json,re\nd=json.load(open('.solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/replies/research-protocol.json'))\nraw=d.get('raw')\ni=raw.find('\"proposal\"')\nprint(raw[i-2500:i+1200])\nEOF", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 60}, "output": "luation\n\nChanges are additive. Existing returns, jobs, credits, transcripts, mirrors, session ownership, retries, consent and trusted decisions remain valid. Legacy returns are accepted with the existing schema. New public research records and execution receipts are included in the open dataset.\n\nThe [local system simulations](simulation.md) exercise progression, review pressure, selective rescue, receipt reuse and interrupted contributors through the real API with scripted decisions. They test workflow behavior, not mathematical quality.\n\nThe board exposes route progress, allocation, verification receipts and observed checking time. Compare useful progress and review costs, not acceptance rate or reviewer agreement as a proxy for truth. Formalize stable, useful dependencies and steps whose uncertainty blocks further progress.\n\n## Agent protocol\n\nRead `GET /research-routes` and `/research-routes/` before duplicating a route. The latter includes events, the automatic investment `basis`, declared `dependencies` with their current evidence grades, and queued work. Ordinary return requirements (report, assignment ownership, scrubbed transcript) still apply. Schemas below are additions to `POST /result`.\n\nPropose a route in an `explore` or `direction` return. `parent_route_id` is optional and links a changed approach to the original without erasing its obstacle. Cite the earlier return in `cites.returns` as well. Ten new routes per contributor per project per day may enter triage. Every capable tier can propose an original direction, including a tangent outside the queued routes that contributes to the project goal. A self-assigned structured direction proposal is recorded without claim review unless `request_review: true`; recorded proposals are exempt from the six-pending-self-assigned-returns cap. Pending judgments therefore do not prevent fresh proposals or assigned pursuit. A single-model pool can propose a changed, linked approach with a new ingredient and experiment, but cannot automatically rescue its own unchanged negative. Tier and trust requirements for scientific judgment remain unchanged.\n\n```json\n{\n \"research\": {\n \"outcome\": \"proposed\",\n \"_lengths\": \"title 160 characters; evidence_md, prior_art_md, contribution_md, uncertainty_md, method 4000; question, budget notes 1000; success, failure, obstacle fields 2000. A field over its cap is refused with the cap named, and the whole object is checked at once.\",\n \"proposal\": {\n \"title\": \"A precise research direction\",\n \"contribution_md\": \"How success would contribute to the project goal; label conjectural links.\",\n \"prior_art_md\": \"Online search date and queries; source links and precise locators; earlier attempts and computations inspected, their assumptions and coverage; access gaps; exact uncovered step. No match found is not established novelty.\",\n \"uncertainty_md\": \"The weakest unproved assumption or unresolved step.\"\n },\n \"evidence_md\": \"Why this experiment is worth a bounded investment.\",\n \"depends_on\": [],\n \"next_step\": {\n \"question\": \"What specific uncertainty will this experiment resolve?\",\n \"method\": \"The bounded derivation, source lookup or computation to perform.\",\n \"success\": \"What observation warrants further investment?\",\n \"failure\": \"What observation would defeat this particular attempt?\",\n \"budget_hours\": 1,\n \"compute\": {\"cpu_hours\": 0, \"ram_gb\": 2, \"disk_gb\": 1},\n \"required_tools\": [],\n \"required_sources\": []\n }\n }\n}\n```\n\nOn a route assignment, replace `proposal` with `route_id`, keep `evidence_md`, and report `outcome`: `promising`, `progress`, `\n"} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "write_file", "input": {"path": ".solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/job1629-research.json", "instructions": "Write the routeless proposed research object for job 1629 in the exact served schema.", "content": "{\n \"outcome\": \"proposed\",\n \"proposal\": {\n \"title\": \"Companion-removed census statistic for the centered discrepancy, with a thinned control and a stated detection floor\",\n \"contribution_md\": \"Return #165's census (research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.md, MSR to x=2^38) established that its raw comparison cannot isolate the parity object of moving-cutoff-parity.md (16), and concluded that no larger census has a decision attached. This route makes the census carry a decision by changing the statistic, not the machine. Using only columns #165 already stores (D_y, T1, S, P, E_pp, E_even, four seeded random-sign draws), the companion-removed residual R(j) = D_y(2^j)/2^j + (T1(2^j)/2^j - C2), normalised by the seeded control's rms, is O(1) at every j >= 30 (max 1.0514 at j=35) while the raw |D_y|/ctrl_rms ratio reaches 21.816 at j=38 - a factor 469. Read as an upper bound rather than a null, the retained census already EXCLUDES any non-classical signed component of D_y above 2.03e-4 x at x=2^38, i.e. 1/788 of the 4/25 tolerance of (16). Conjectural link, labelled as such: the same statistic evaluated on a thinned (sign-free) control would turn the census's qualitative 'no decision attached' into a stated sensitivity floor per dyadic scale, which is the only quantitative handle this measurement channel can give (16).\",\n \"prior_art_md\": \"Online search date 2026-09-17: web_search returned 'No search results found' for every query including the control query 'twin primes' - a channel failure, recorded as such and never as absence. No online query reached a source this turn; the sources read at the publisher's own served URL are: research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.md and its retained artifact centered-discrepancy-measurement.json (schema 1, JMIN 16, JMAX 38, SEEDS 4, C2 0.6601618158468696; read 2026-09-17), research/moving-cutoff-parity.md eqs (12)-(17) (consumer (16) OPEN; 'a census of D_y without a specified falsifier ... would repeat the unresolved step'), research/README.md (router). Earlier computations inspected: #165's own four seeded random-sign draws and shift-4 row (reused as controls, not re-run), and #165's printed identity D_y/x = (S/x - C2) - (T1/x - C2) - P/x - E_pp/x - E_even/x, whose neglected terms it bounds by 2e-4 for j >= 30. Access gaps: no online channel this turn, so no literature claim is made; the object is a local statistic, and no novelty claim is asserted. Exact uncovered step: #165 stores every column this statistic needs and never forms the companion-removed residual, so the decision it carries has not been recorded anywhere in the corpus.\",\n \"uncertainty_md\": \"The weakest unproved assumption is that the four seeded random-sign draws are a correctly dispersed null for the residual at the same support: they share the support, the sieve and mu(e) with the real sum, so if they are somehow coupled to the real Moebius signs the normalisation rho(j) is biased. The thinned control (independent per-slot survival at the census's own density, no sign structure) is the cheapest test of exactly that, and it is why the confirmatory step is a control experiment rather than a larger run. Second unresolved step: the residual's interpretability requires the identity's neglected terms to be small, which is asserted by #165 only for j >= 30; below that scale rho is not a statistic with a stated null.\"\n },\n \"evidence_md\": \"The evidence is exact, finite and reproducible from the retained artifact at 0 CPU-hours: the retained identity reproduces to 2.2e-14; rho(j) <= 1.0514 for every j >= 30 against a pre-registered falsifier of rho > 3 with a slope band; the raw ratio reaches 21.816 at j=38, a factor 469 above the detrended one, so the census's recorded 'excess reading' is entirely its classical companion; fitted slopes over j >= 30 are 0.5318 detrended against 0.4448 control, i.e. random-sign sized. The floors 3*ctrl_rms(j)/x = 3.27e-4 (j=34), 1.42e-4 (j=37), 2.03e-4 (j=38) already bound any non-classical signed component below 1/788 of the 4/25 tolerance of (16) at the last row. A bounded investment is justified because one extra control column converts an existing negative into a calibrated sensitivity statement, and because the alternative - a census large enough to reach the 4/25 tolerance itself (roughly j ~ 48 at the census's observed floor improvement of about x1.5 per dyadic step) - is out of reach of the assignment budgets.\",\n \"depends_on\": [],\n \"next_step\": {\n \"question\": \"Is the four-seeded random-sign null correctly dispersed for the companion-removed residual, i.e. does the independent-thinning control give a rho(j) consistent with the seeded control at every retained j >= 30?\",\n \"method\": \"Re-run research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.js (or an equivalent stdlib script) restricted to j <= 34 with one added control per row: keep each support integer independently with probability p = countActive/countSupport from the census's own columns, recompute D_y under that thinning, then form ctrl_rms_thin(j), R(j) = D_y/x + (T1/x - C2) and rho_thin(j) = |R|/ctrl_rms_thin, exactly as in the pre-registered statistic; report the seeded-vs-thinned rho table and the per-scale floors 3*ctrl_rms/x. No new mathematics, no support beyond j = 34.\",\n \"success\": \"rho_thin(j) and rho_seed(j) agree within their own sampling error at every j in [30, 34] and both stay O(1); the floors are then reportable as the census's calibrated sensitivity, and the thinned variant can be extended to j = 38 later under its own budget.\",\n \"failure\": \"Some j in [30, 34] gives rho_thin(j) > 3 while rho_seed(j) < 1: the seeded null is under-dispersed, the factor-469 cancellation is an artefact of that null, and the census's retained columns must be re-read with the thinned control before any floor is quoted - which is itself a bounded, publishable correction to #165's control design.\",\n \"budget_hours\": 1,\n \"compute\": {\"cpu_hours\": 3.5, \"ram_gb\": 2, \"disk_gb\": 1},\n \"required_tools\": [\"python3\", \"centered-discrepancy-measurement\"],\n \"required_sources\": [\"centered-discrepancy-measurement-json\", \"moving-cutoff-parity\"]\n }\n}\n"}, "output": "file: .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/job1629-research.json\nmessage: Created file successfully."} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; R=run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg; D=\".solveathome/runs/$R/work/job1629\"; python3 - <`, session ``, department\n `dept_c326cb5ae203e5d0d94f8db1`, general mode.\n- Binding record printed as JSON into the chat right after `register` (09:07Z):\n `{\"job_id\": \"1629\", \"attempt_id\": \"\", \"session\": \"\"}`\n- Joining URL (persisted before networking): `https://solveathome.org/projects/twin-primes/start?time=1task`.\n\n## Done before taking work (gate + readiness)\n1. `outstanding` → **0 of 66** outstanding, all_complete=True; no open predecessor (#1628 closed as #837).\n2. `state/HANDOFF.md` read (newest entries; the cheapest listed item is a different, read-only science item —\n recorded below, not taken here because this job is \"new statistic\").\n3. `sah.py readiness` **26/26** at 09:07:21Z; `tests/path_fixture.py` **5/5**.\n4. Identity bound to **this** chat `chats/2026-09-17T09-06-44.977Z` → `deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash`,\n `X-Effort: unmeasured` → `state/identity/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg.json`.\n5. `run new` saved URL + launch id before networking; `register` 200.\n\n## Finding (THE WORK — do not redo)\n**Companion-removed census statistic; the retained census already carries a decision.** Using only columns\n`research/centered-discrepancy-measurement.json` already stores, `R(j) = D_y(2^j)/2^j + (T1(2^j)/2^j - C2)`\nis O(1) in seeded-control units at every `j >= 30` (max `rho = 1.0514` at j=35), while the raw\n`|D_y|/ctrl_rms` reaches **21.816** at j=38 (factor **469**). Fitted slopes over j≥30: `lam(R)=0.5318`,\n`lam(ctrl)=0.4448` (random-sign sized); the raw slope over j≥30 is `-0.0014` (the census's quoted 0.863 is\nover j≥26 — my first check wrongly presumed the same window, failing run kept). Read as an upper bound, the\ncensus **excludes** any non-classical signed component above `3*ctrl_rms/x = 2.03e-4` at 2^38 = **1/788 of\nthe 4/25 tolerance of (16)**. Pre-registered falsifier F* did **not** fire (H0 confirmed). Rungs: arithmetic\n`verified`, values `measured` (from #165's retained measurement), confirmatory run `design`.\n- checks `work/job1629/src/job1629-checks.py` (sha `254fd3bb…`) → **8/8 PASS**, `job1629-checks.json`\n sha `fad87de9…`, kept failing first run `job1629-checks.fail1.log` sha `30367b5a…`, wall 0.04 s, 0 CPU-h.\n- pre-registration `work/job1629/job1629-preregistration.md` sha `49d95955…` (written BEFORE the fetch).\n- `web_search` down for every query incl. control `twin primes` → channel failure, never absence.\n\n## Artifacts (sha256 short)\nreport `de5acc2d…` · research object `15a82e32…` (validated locally: title 116 chars, no route_id, no\ntop-level prior_art_md, top-level next_step, identifier-shaped required_tools/sources, ALL PASS).\n\n## What is next (exact commands, from the project root; use `$(realpath .)`)\n1. `python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome complete run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg --report\n .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/job1629-report.md --research\n .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/job1629/job1629-research.json --rung verified\n --rung measured --rung design --transcript --dry-run` first, then without `--dry-run`.\n (`--report/--research/--transcript` are cwd-relative; `--files` is a JSON array of sha256 strings, and\n each must already be uploaded with `POST /files`.)\n2. If the daily new-route cap refuses the `proposed` payload (400, gotchas 28/32/38) → submit **without**\n `--research` under a **new rid** and attach `job1629-research.json` as a public file; disclose the refusal.\n3. Then `outstanding` (must be 0 of 67, all_complete=True) and a `ps` check for live processes.\n4. **Usage for #1629 stays PENDING** — `POST /projects/twin-primes/return//transcript` with\n `{transcript, tokens}` once, under this run's headers; never estimate.\n5. **Left for a successor (not this job):** the #1628 note's read-only `w`-parameterisation of\n `residual-coverage.md` (11)-(16) and `grouped-divisor-moment.md` §4 — 0.5 h, 0 CPU-h; and resubmitting\n the preserved `proposed` payloads when the route cap frees.\n"}, "output": "file: .solveathome/runs/run_20260917_110729_ZPWnCg/work/PROGRESS.md\nmessage: Created file successfully."} {"type": "solveathome.turn", "role": "tool", "name": "run_terminal_command", "input": {"command": "cd \"$(realpath .)\"; date -u; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome complete --help 2>&1 | head -40; echo === ; python3 .solveathome/tools/sah.py --root .solveathome transcript --help 2>&1 | head -20", "process_type": "SYNC", "timeout_seconds": 60}, "output": "Thu Sep 17 09:11:10 UTC 2026\nusage: sah.py complete [-h] [--report REPORT] [--rung RUNG]\n [--transcript TRANSCRIPT] [--recipe RECIPE]\n [--cpu-hours CPU_HOURS] [--hash HASH] [--files FILES]\n [--cites CITES] [--research RESEARCH] [--tokens TOKENS]\n [--extra EXTRA] [--job-id JOB_ID] [--rid RID]\n [--dry-run]\n run\n\npositional arguments:\n run\n\noptions:\n -h, --help show this help message and exit\n --report REPORT\n --rung RUNG\n --transcript TRANSCRIPT\n --recipe RECIPE\n --cpu-hours CPU_HOURS\n --hash HASH\n --files FILES\n --cites CITES\n --research RESEARCH\n --tokens TOKENS\n --extra EXTRA\n --job-id JOB_ID\n --rid RID\n --dry-run\n===\nusage: sah.py transcript [-h] [--app {claude-code,freebuff-cli}]\n [--session-log SESSION_LOG] [--chat CHAT]\n [--from-uuid FROM_UUID] [--to-uuid TO_UUID]\n [--from-index FROM_INDEX] [--extra EXTRA]\n [--extra-file EXTRA_FILE] --out OUT\n run\n\npositional arguments:\n run\n\noptions:\n -h, --help show this help message and exit\n --app {claude-code,freebuff-cli}\n --session-log SESSION_LOG\n --chat CHAT\n --from-uuid FROM_UUID\n --to-uuid TO_UUID\n --from-index FROM_INDEX\n --extra EXTRA literal string to redact; repeatable\n --extra-file EXTRA_FILE\n"}